國外聲樂老師對比《山海》舞台｜Vocal Coach Reacts to「Mountain & Sea」

Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili...
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on KZbin: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia....
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #谭维维 #王心凌 #草东没有派对 #华晨宇 #黎真吾 #sitartan

[@x457457]

目前草東第一，還沒聽過超越的版本

[@citibank5008]

還是草東樂團原版唱的最好，花花的聽了2～3次，剛聽到很驚艷但是很容易膩，草東對這首山海的詮釋我覺得很難被超越，kk版本能夠再看到凡凡打鼓。

[@미니미규리의댄스]

在歌手花絮里有 2018年 这首歌 大陆音乐软件里才几百个评论吧 ， 花花确实把这首歌带到大众前面了。 喜欢模进那段，他前两天刚出来的新歌 就用了当年的模进

[@citibank5008]

@@미니미규리의댄스 他的翻唱讓更多人讀過這首作品山海，但是呢我實際聽了那麽多人的版本，我還是覺得不需要花里胡哨跟多強的唱功，從旋律跟句子之間的層層堆疊跟推進，因為這首作品詮釋的是對於社會的無奈及憤怒，聞初不知曲中意，再聽已是曲中人，每個人喜歡的版本都不太一樣，也能理解，華晨宇真的是一個很有實力的歌手。

[@roylin9264]

沒有實力吧，都靠後期修音跟後台關係出來的，基本都在鬼吼鬼叫

[@winterleung1411]

@@미니미규리의댄스反正最討厭的就是華晨宇的版本，該有的東西不見了，卻多了一堆多餘的調味料，讓歌曲完全走味

[@grace010ful]

要不要让橘子老师 听一听 费玉清，蔡琴， 凤飞飞。 我觉得会很有趣！

[@JoanKSX]

白安的老师 review 了吗？

[@sandarwin6766]

看看老师讲评张学友， 可想而知她会怎么说他们。。

[@Joey818Lin]

聽江蕙的才會更有趣

[@falcon9710]

like that when she asked ppl around musical quiz, it made the video feel different than previous one in a positive way ;3

[@chloehsu3294]

草東！！！！！The first one is a Taiwanese band. 好開心老師review他們的歌😍

[@cavenloo4634]

几时才要出一集张惠妹的歌史？很多人都会很期待❤

[@karenwtho9137]

I believe the official English title of this song by Caodong is "Wayfarer" not "Mountain and Sea" which is just a direct translation of 山海. The original sounded darker and grittier. Hua Hua's sounded more like an 80's rock song If Rozette sees Hua Hua's recent concert looks, she'd be flabbergasted 🤗🤗

[@蔡奇睿-t8t]

Actually, the English name for this song is ‘ wayfarer’ rather than ‘ mountain and sea’. There’s official English translation for this song which can be found at the mv for the original version of this song. [lyrics] (Verse 1) I look at myself, at the young and innocent face. He belongs to my past, from which I’ve vanished without a trace. He waits for me, for my answer, A reason why I am now here. (Chorus) He knows, he knows, I have no answer. So he turns and walks towards the mountains. He knows, he knows, I have no answer. So he turns and walks towards the oceans. (Verse 2) I hear his voice from the past, when there was still a future. He longs for something better. But what he sees is not himself in the mirror. (Chorus) He knows, he knows, I have no answer. So he turns and walks towards the mountains. He knows, he knows, I have no answer. So he turns and walks towards the oceans.

[@JoanKSX]

山海 ， 应该是 Wayfarer。 For the first time I heard was the Sitar Tan and Cyndi Wang unison duet version, but when I google 山海， turns out it's 'Wayfarer' by No Party for Cao Dong. The climax/chorus parts make me have all the goosebumps and heart flutters for no reason even more than the Sitar Tan and Cyndi Wang version which is crazy.

[@kalikali2846]

B站那邊留言直接炸掉了,一整排華家軍出征,都不忍看留言了😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@yufungchan]

那邊真的一群瘋.子華粉，網暴橘老師，人身攻擊周深像地精，攻擊路人，痴9線...😅

[@karenwtho9137]

Because they inadvertently gave anti-Hua members ammunition to validate attacks on him - ugly singing, ghost howling, needing full production support, self-glorification when the guy of this channel said "they called him the king of Chinese music", so on and so forth. Rozette correctly pointed out that everyone is his/her fans king or queen. After he won Singer 2020, the fans of other singers joined the black accounts in attacking him. Have you notice that when they feature him, many posters have no qualms leaving unpleasant comments about him? That's why his fans are a wee bit sensitive after enduring this for 10 years. When the guy in this channel praised Hua in one video, some posters lambasted him for giving Hua attention. Such viciousness doesn't happen with other singers they feature. But I'm glad they did this comparison video. Cheers!

[@karenwtho9137]

@@yufungchan You should know by now why they attack Zhou Shen. Because Zhou Shen's fans attacked Hua for Singer 2020. It was never Zhou Shen's fault and neither was Hua at fault. I believe Hua's younger fans are now playing tit for tat because Hua was attacked personally so they're giving the same back. The media outlets are also fuelling the "rivalry".

[@yufungchan]

@@karenwtho9137 別洗了，這不是網暴的藉口，2020華晨宇被黑粉黑，華粉絲就要報復攻擊周深，有沒有考慮過沒有罵過華晨宇的周深粉絲感受？

[@미니미규리의댄스]

@@yufungchan 哈哈哈 地精也太逗了

[@JeanLi1982]

不知道有沒有機會讓老師看看張韶涵的影片呢？非常好奇老師聽她演唱會有什麼感想

[@coco-dg2lm]

Like the last one😅❤❤

[@mariax3006]

Wow, No Party for Cao Dong! Loooove this band!

[@李淑玲-x5l]

謝謝老師喜歡草東😊

[@garashi1999]

Thank you for very useful tip at the end!

[@wilsonchung9394]

Please compare different versions of Fake Monk.

[@ngocanhphan9099]

yessss please

[@manx6472]

好声音直接停播的原因是转椅子黑幕被揭发

[@白民淨]

Of monster and men也是男女主唱樂團

[@cheche8565]

最喜歡花花❤❤

[@lila1957]

My favorite version : Hua Chenyu

[@shalala818]

I hope Rozette can stay true to her honest opinion and not be influenced by external factors such as fan feedback, money, etc. The day that she begins to compliment Hua would be proof.

[@karenwtho9137]

Rozette already complimented Hua aeons ago, hun.

[@shalala818]

@@karenwtho9137 I wouldn’t call that a compliment. She’s just being less blunt. She is still way more critical than complimentary of Hua.

[@karenwtho9137]

@@shalala818 She was objectively complimenting him in her second viewing of Hua. She wasn't being less blunt back then when she said positive things. She went on to be objectively critical of him in Exaggerated, then she admitted that she is averse to "screams" in singing that a lot of rock singers do. It's OK to be critical objectively. There is nothing wrong in liking Hua Hua and conversely disliking his work. However, there is something inherently disturbing when some people start to hate or despise Hua just because they don't like his style, taking the hate to the level like it's a personal grudge.

[@shalala818]

@@karenwtho9137 With all the hate on Rozette by Hua’s fans, I don’t think they agree with you on the compliment part. Hey if you’re satisfied then good for you.

[@karenwtho9137]

@@shalala818 I understand some fans position when it comes to Rozette. Because when she initially viewed him, she went in blind without understanding the context. Hence, she made remarks, critical ones that gave the anti-Hua voices the ammunition to validate their hateful position. These anti-Hua are fans of singers who had lost out in singing competitions to Hua, lost out in entertainment industry, lost in other ways not because Hua took from them but because he just did his own thing and gained fans and recognition. They've been attacking him for ten years and his loyal fans are a tad sensitive after so many years of such nonsensical treatment. That's why when Jay praised Hua for his artistry, the comments were attacking Jay for saying good things about Hua. These anti-Hua fans hold personal grudges because their idols lost in some way to Hua.

[@chRQL309]

Cyndi BB 演唱會要開了，歡迎購票入場台北小巨蛋😊

[@angelazapata6722]

Hua Chenyu 🌹🌹

[@미니미규리의댄스]

I pick huahua's version

[@cczhangzhao3044]

因為不喜歡所以記不住😂

[@apple5304]

想推薦橘子老師聽周深跟張韶涵的一路生花☺️

[@apple5304]

伊森汗流浹背哈哈哈哈

[@yp312]

聽完草東 後面改編聽得我完全聽不下去 超痛苦 除了炫技外完全沒靈魂

[@qqweasdq]

草東❤❤❤

[@徐嘉桂]

This is a song that touched me the most. And this might be the most authentic song you have ever hear from Hua Chenyu. Song name:< We> Chinese lyrics:kzbin.info/www/bejne/r2eWo4aifc2fiacsi=01sALuDsCANBRYPV English lyrics: kzbin.info/www/bejne/gpu8kp2VZbt_d7ssi=rfKCi9CT0G4qh8Cj

[@Lccan1990]

No party for cao dong is the best, no contest!

[@米哆-k7r]

为什么没有伴乐，因为版权吗

[@derekleung8269]

pls rate 华华nunchuck cover in Singer

[@Kanqipink]

她们是华黑.不要叫反应花了.不配

[@鬰林]

@@Kanqipink 这老师认可过他的唱功的，只是不对她的口味。 只是无奈有很多人想要选择只听到自己想听的部分-

[@karenwtho9137]

@@Kanqipink No, they are not smearing Hua Hua. They are actually being quite objective.

[@dwmobusa]

@@Kanqipink 对于花粉来说，不把他夸上天的都是黑

[@yhe821]

并没有，我就不那么认为，反而很欣赏老师的真诚。​@@dwmobusa

[@鬰林]

那时我有一个在澳洲居住的菲律宾网友和我一起追这季，她冲着KZ和Jessie J去，出来成了“火星人”。 而且对我说了一下这段话： “KZ在菲律宾夺冠时争议蛮大的。因为这里很多大嗓门的机能怪，例如Charice, Morisette, Regine之类的，然后大多红的歌曲也都是大芭乐歌曲。那时KZ在选秀夺冠，人气很两极化，突然蹦出一个风格迥异的女中音，很多人接受不了。难怪她能在节目中和华晨宇成好朋友。” KZ在自家人气两极化，以外国踢馆者的身份到了中国，得到全网的认可和喜爱，并也成为了许多人的意难平。 华晨宇当年被许多外国观众视为“能与Jessie J一战的少年”，KZbin最高点击率的歌手2018歌曲也是他的《平凡之路》，但他在华人地区却被黑出了汁。 这个现象太有意思了。 而且在这里搜“KZ Huachenyu kilig“的话还能找到嗑他们俩cp的影片- 这种饭制的跨国“嗑糖”影片，观看量最高还破了30万- 当然观看量不能代表一切，论唱功2018季最强的一定是Jessie J，腾格尔。 总决赛老实说我觉得华晨宇应该排第三的，直播没那么稳。（汪峰更好笑） 但是华晨宇最近碰上的破事真的有点多- “法师”，在艺术这行是褒义词。 如果他语言能力不那么烂，会说英文，出国发展，说不定会有更好的结果。 他刚出道本来就是走Muse, Radiohead那挂的，芭乐脑绝对听不懂的东西- 快男时期，刚出道的时期，就看他一直唱英文歌，但发音真的太烂了，好像他自己也有自知之明，后来极少唱英文歌了。 提到Radiohead一定一堆人说“Creep“，但这首歌是这个乐团最讨厌的歌曲。 好比提到Beyond的代表作一定会有人说到《真的爱你》，但这是他们最不喜欢的一首。 张雨生最红的《大海》也是为了糊口写出来的，他的灵魂注入的《卡拉OK，台北，我》，当年销售惨淡。。。 这就是”大众“。

[@dwmobusa]

如果做水煮鱼，对鱼的新鲜程度的要求并不需要像做清蒸鱼那样高。水煮鱼和清蒸鱼，两个都可以是好菜，可是如果一个食评人单单说了一句这道水煮鱼的鱼肉没有那道清蒸鱼的鱼肉新鲜，会不会有人群起攻之说他diss水煮鱼？其实他的评论也无可厚非，只要他在综合品评了菜的火候，用料，调味等等其他因素之后仍然能认可菜的综合品质就可以了。 华的歌有点像水煮鱼，他加的调料很多，不可否认该加什么调料，该怎么加，他都一定认真计划过的。Rosette因为自己专业方向的原因，把他的唱法（鱼肉）单独拿出来稍加评论，也是可以理解的吧。粉丝们爱他给鱼肉加的料就可以了啊。

[@鬰林]

@@dwmobusa 但是老师这次的评论好像比较偏向觉得这道水煮鱼的做法浪费了这条鱼- 她这次反而是觉得鱼还不错，但是调味料太多，反而还希望能用清蒸鱼的方式料理这条鱼。

[@dwmobusa]

@@鬰林 那就是对鱼肉也高度肯定了，挺好呀，花粉为啥还不高兴？

[@鬰林]

@@dwmobusa 你是说我吗？ 严格说我不算“花粉”，我的理由我已经给了，他最近碰到的破事太多了。 我平时爱听的东西比较硬核，Dir En Grey, Avantasia这种的。肯这么搞的华语歌手太少了，所以看华晨宇在华人地区的待遇，觉得可怜。所以我的原评论也没有在说老师怎么怎么样。 至于其他我看过，也吵过的火星人，他们眼里除非评语是“完美”就是黑子的人，这个我就。。。不谈了吧。 饭圈文化。懂的都懂。 我在这里，在哔哩哔哩，都和火星人吵过，也都和华晨宇的黑粉吵过。两边真的都半斤八两-

[@dwmobusa]

@@鬰林 当然不是说你啦，这个频道的视频一路看下来，你的ID我都看熟了啦，以前做过什么评论都知道。不过B站的这期视频又被花粉冲啦，我寻思这期也没说他啥坏话呀。 其实我觉得橘子本来可能对水煮鱼这系列的菜就不太感冒，她喜欢清蒸系列的，不过她主要做的事情也就是专门挑鱼肉出来做分析，清蒸比较容易分析啦。

[@RB-zk2vo]

我是喜歡華晨宇版本，夠爽夠炸，以前最愛唱他版本

[@huahuasmother]

Tnx for your reacts, please react to ship of Theseus and Warm house from huachenyu.

[@WencyDon]

希望老师能看一下黄子弘凡。

[@suqinliew8331]

❤

[@Amd71256]

Its a good time to see Hua Chenyu in concert. Heavily discounted tickets were available for his Beijing and Hong Kong shows. Tickets were even available on the official ticketing apps until the actual performance day. He is known to boast about his stage set ups. So go and get a ticket to see the stage at least!

[@karenwtho9137]

Hahaha you sounded a bit jealous that his 2-day concert in Bird's Nest concluded successfully. Oh, didn't you know that he got the bragging rights to his stage design from MUSE Design Awards for 2021, 2023 and 2024? He boasted at his own concerts and to his fans as a compliment to the designing team. What's wrong with that? Oh, perhaps the idols you spent money on didn't spend money on you eh. That's why you're disgruntled with someone who spends money on his fans hahaha.

[@Amd71256]

@@karenwtho9137 Yes, it's clear he needs a selling point. Unfortunately, his tickets still don't sell out even when he has spent all the money on impressive sets! His only claim to fame by his fans seems to be 'playing at the Bird's Nest' like no one else has ever played there lol

[@karenwtho9137]

@@Amd71256 Wow!! Your jealousy is too obvious and strong! Keep it up, for it's warping your thought process 😁😁 His only claim to fame was "playing at the Bird's Nest"? Darling, that was done 6 years ago in 2018, then again in 2023 and again this year. He held a 2-day concert IN THE BIRD'S NEST, how else do you expect his fans to shout about it? Ooooh.... I heard that Zhou Shen is also going to hold a 2-day concert for the first time in the Bird's Nest!!! Ahhhh....make sure his fans don't mention the name of the huge stadium ya lest you'll accuse them of claiming fame hahahaha..... Holding a concert in the Bird's Nest is considered a milestone in one's career because it is a huge stadium. Make sure you don't mention the stadium's name when your idol eventually holds one there ya.

[@Amd71256]

@@karenwtho9137 Yes, a milestone playing in such a huge stadium and he still has to heavily discount tickets to fill these big stadiums. It's great coming from a rich family, you can buy all the support you want 😂

[@karenwtho9137]

@@Amd71256 Oh, you're so hung up on discounted tickets. As a consumer, which would you rather have: a good discount or paying jacked up prices? About coming from a rich family, now I can say you intensely jealous of Hua's success hahaha... Yep, he comes from a rich family. What has that got to do with his PROFESSION? Wasn't he signed with Tianyu that gave him quite a full schedule for many years? You clearly are so sour and jealous that Hua is successful and has many admirers including those from the music industry while your idol is still way behind 🤣🤣 A fair price or good discount is better than being exploited as a consumer but apparently you prefer the latter. You must be very proud that you're paying premium price for a concert that didn't spend much money for your audio visual pleasure.

[@regularperson4106]

Hua Chenyu= my favorite artist!

[@kannkahann]

張惠妹 也有唱ㄚ

[@ariestinyworld]

想让老师听一听 艾薇 表演的歌曲

[@GOGO-op8ib]

老師我推荐尾崎豊 街路樹LIVE

[@jhgc5092]

期待

[@fredrin-z1d]

please react to ARTHUR NERY guesting in EAT BULAGA TV SHOW, thank youu.

[@JoeChanTV]

She must meant ABBA

[@chiamsunghoong5709]

大推coco的bad romance👍👍👍 真的大推大推

[@許喬筑-j9z]

草東耶

[@dyuk1987]

react to some Yuuri's first take songs?

[@tiethief9129]

想念COCO

[@MowRongLee]

老師還沒點評過李宗盛嗎？敲碗🎉🎉🎉

[@angelinalim9413]

可以让老师听听薛之谦的歌嘛，蛮好奇老师会怎么点评的

[@123111qazwsx]

橘老師學中文毫不費力😂

[@Plantofautumm]

Please do more Faye Wong

[@bangbanghands]

有林宥嘉嗎

[@fredrin-z1d]

please react to ARTHUR NERY singing ISA LANG in casino ph ❤.

[@rhowo2465]

側田 come on!

[@ColinZ-pu4mw]

周华健，刀剑如梦，难念的经

[@karenwtho9137]

Hua Chenyu just concluded his 2-day concert at Beijing Bird's Nest Stadium (7th and 8th September). You might want to check out his new songs "Ship of Theseus", "Weird Psychology", "Warm House" and "Never Cross Path", composed for his 6th album, yet to be released. Cheers.

[@wuallen495]

哈哈哈哈哈，哥们太快了

[@Blizzard3492]

Yeah no we don't care about your cult

[@karenwtho9137]

@@Blizzard3492 If you consider my proposition a cult, then all of you that follow and recommended some singers are similarly in a cult too hun 🤷‍♀Use some grey matter before you think you're so clever.

[@karenwtho9137]

@@wuallen495 What's too fast? You mean the composition? I think "Ship of Theseus" took a few years; he got the tune in his Haikou concert in the year 2021. Hua Hua isn't looking for speed 😅😅

[@Blizzard3492]

@@karenwtho9137 Thanks for the compliment and maybe don’t comment in a language that you’re not good at if you’re trying to sound intellectual lmao

[@lou-lu2644]

I really like this song. Please compare Women de Ai 我们的爱 (F.I.R,, JJ Lin, Dimash, Huang Xiaoyun, Lion (Jam Hsiao)...etc)

[@Thomas-freedom]

希望老师可以评，李安逝去的爱

[@jhgc5092]

感觉桔老师一直对华晨宇不太感冒😅 但华晨宇的改编和作曲还是很厉害的

[@미니미규리의댄스]

旁边两个故意引导她不喜欢，在2021年 这个播主故意翻唱 花花版山海 改歌词 恶意嘲讽 他跟张碧晨两个30岁的人生孩子的事情。 人性真的恶意 。 背后的蛛丝马迹可以看出他们捧一个矮个子歌手，不知道是不是抹黑中国男人形象

[@RB-zk2vo]

28:23 老師說他喜歡這位歌手，只是不喜歡後製太多

[@breath-so4gl]

但是老師已經看過華晨宇”非常、非常多次”了還是一點印象都沒有、不認得他欸…😅

[@karenwtho9137]

@@breath-so4gl It's OK that Rozette didn't recognise him after so many viewing. She didn't say she has no impression of him so, don't get too excited. If Rozette saw Hua's more recent videos, I'd bet she won't recognise him still hahaha.

[@jhgc5092]

@@breath-so4gl 是的 我感觉她对华晨宇没感觉

[@ling-is2is]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rWO0eKSEidaDlas 想聽老師評 田馥甄

[@CK-gd3lb]

The Mamas & The Papas? ABBA?

[@kamanchoi1887]

邱軍的版本是最爽的

[@YiJhen-i8w]

草東🎉🎉🎉

[@gentingberhad1]

Zhou shen. kzbin.info/www/bejne/poekmIqJprJ-sNEsi=wui3mgdG6U4cVyJQ

[@JoanKSX]

Oh. Maybe Jenn would like to listen to Khalifah? It's a Malaysian rock band and I really love that funny but educational inspiring song which bring out the meaningful message behind the lyrics, 'Hang Pi Mana'. 'Hang Pi Mana' is a Malay language song.

[@阿湯-w4z]

希望多看看花花的點評

[@多肉好麻吉]

記得之前老師有評過不少花花,很.............恐怖.

[@鬰林]

@@多肉好麻吉 风格不合她口味啦，《我管你》《易燃易爆炸》唱功她是夸过的 她说过有点让她联想到Radiohead那挂的歌手

[@多肉好麻吉]

@@鬰林 老師就算評過誰，她也不太會記得。 所以老師評的是當首的表演。 所以這次老師說喜歡，是因為這次的表現。 所以老師是真的很公正的。 之前評華唱得五音不全，也是事實，之前真的唱得很恐怖。 老師好就說好，不好她也是客氣的想很久，要用什麼婉轉的說法。 所以支持老師

[@鬰林]

@@多肉好麻吉 华晨宇确实是一个高光时刻很高低光时刻超低的人-

[@skylercao2723]

b站上不知道在吵什么 来着清净下

[@athomenotavailable]

康斯坦丁的变化球，告五人， 谁杀死石家庄人，等等

[@athomenotavailable]

刘恋和薛凯琪的梦中人

[@athomenotavailable]

还有 许巍 的《曾经的你》， 我最喜欢的旋律和歌词Top10 之一。 kzbin.info/www/bejne/b2rbhn6Gfa2glcU

[@dannyqao]

加拿大老师一如既往对华晨宇、邓紫棋等华语唱作巨擘有诸多不满。

[@chaeyl5504]

22:17 終於！那英害死coco!!!!!

[@reikei9783]

之前r的现在放，有种期盼和现实大落差 之前老师都和谭维维套娃🪆了，现在又不认识了，😂

[@breath-so4gl]

老師每次都很認真點評華晨宇，無論喜歡或不喜歡的部份。但我驚訝的是，她已經看過華晨宇”非常、非常多次”了還是一點印象都沒有、不認得他欸…無論喜歡或不喜歡的部份都沒有一點印象喔！真妙😅

[@JoanKSX]

应该还没到心坎吧。 至于华晨宇有什么著名的歌，我也不太记得，不过我只记得他翻唱别人的歌真的大部分会耳目一新， 唱功真的不错， 仅此而已。 甚至原曲是 《 国王与乞丐 》 那首， 我也是因为先听作曲者 Faizal Tahir (马来西亚著名作曲作词实力派歌手) 马来语填词版的 《 Terima Kasih 》 才认识本应该是原曲的 《 国王与乞丐 》 （谢谢华晨宇的歌迷留言）， 我自己听了好多遍还是不太喜欢华晨宇的， 我真的太喜欢 Faizal Tahir 和 Aizat Amdan 版的 《 Terima Kasih 》 了， 旋律和歌词一样好有诗境和被附上很有意义的歌词， 当然他们的歌声也很好，满满的诚恳与祝福。

[@ArvinHwang]

華晨宇如果改掉他那裝神弄鬼的風格就好了，😂聽不習慣，假藝術家的感覺，不像草東給你最直覺的藝術和靈魂

[@karenwtho9137]

Great for you?? Change for you?? Whatever for? You are already hearing ghost when he is singing a normal rock song so, that speaks volume of your attitude towards him.

[@李东宇-g3l]

这些歌对于我来说没有共鸣，所以现在这个节目都很少看了，感觉这些歌旋律不太好听，不是我喜欢的类型。

[@user-rw5dt4eg1g]

終於出這首了 山海我只服黎真吾

[@洪秉豪-v5r]

花78...看神 經病

[@jasonj3952]

华晨宇可以在氛围上和原唱打个平手很不错了， 其他的唱的还行，但音乐的感觉还不到位。

[@wuallen495]

华晨宇进步太大了

[@Kssuydkajahd]

並沒有 前陣子的舞台才被老師批評爆（比較沒修音的那次）這版估計修音 他音準一直以來都有問題 聽演唱會側錄的都有

[@karenwtho9137]

Yes, he has made improvement throughout his 11 years. I've listened a few of his concerts from fan cams and his pitch is great, not perfect because he is human and he was walking up and down the big stage. To say that he hasn't improved is just needing to deny him anything positive.

[@wuallen495]

​@@Kssuydkajahd 我刚去完他北京演唱会，太嗨了，音准现在已经是一线歌手水平吧，完全不是问题，主要是他的作品都很有深度啊，然后舞美还好看，我直接入坑了。

[@wuallen495]

我觉得吧，华晨宇是偏创作型的歌手，因为他唱法不是那种很多高难度转音的，老师又是声乐老师，所以老师并没有那么喜欢吧，不过华晨宇的歌确实都很好听，除了几个翻车现场。。@@Kssuydkajahd

[@wuallen495]

老师之前那个reaction我有看，那应该是刚出道不久的时候吧，也算正常，这个影片应该是18年？也算古早了，所以我才说他进步太大了，因为我刚听完他的现场。@@Kssuydkajahd

[@hifimusic441]

为什么youtube上所有的洋人做的歌曲反应视频包含音乐专业的和普通乐迷都一边倒的称赞华晨宇，除了这位女洋人😂

[@JoanKSX]

应该就华晨宇表面太花式了吧， 声音表达没有到心坎那种吧？

[@yufungchan]

？就一定要喜歡你家哥哥？她不太喜歡，你們就網暴是吧，華晨宇粉絲有夠沒品

[@karenwtho9137]

Rozette did praise Hua Hua already. We should appreciate that she gives her honest and objective review rather than appeasement. But she didn't know that Hua has legions of anti-Hua that'll use her constructive criticism as ammunition to validate their attack on Hua.

[@sissidai6325]

有吗？没有看到呢！欣赏不来花花，但不会黑他，因为有人喜欢他，不会随便伤害他人。

[@mayl.866]

因為他的後製太多。記得有一次他在評論花花，還說麥克風怪怪的，有興趣可以再去查查。

[@MLL09]

華改是最好無庸置疑，因為加了大量制作，我也是最喜他歌手版的，但現場的話真的有差

[@kinglibra2539]

Please react to Katrina Velarde's Whitney Houston medley, I guarantee you'll cry after you watch it🙏.

[@lokyeeIvanWong]

想聽老師點評艾薇🙇‍♀️ kzbin.info/www/bejne/en7Ge4Vsl81_prMsi=Bj55xswyctOLXPBw

[@myzhao9566]

前面几个好好的人唱歌，为啥后面要配上一条狗呢？23分狗叫警告…避雷

[@PhuongNguyen-rr5mk]

Hua Chenyu 🥰🥰🥰