國外聲樂老師如何評價

Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili.com/7295246
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on KZbin: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia.com/rozette
Chapters:
00:00 第一組：黃琦珊、丁當
07:38 第二組：譚維維、魏雪漫、金池
17:15 第三組：謝娜、美依禮芽、龔琳娜
26:14 聲樂小課堂
26:41下集預告
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #美依礼芽 #黄绮珊 #谢娜 #龚琳娜 #魏雪漫 #金池 #乘风2023 #魏雪漫 #天赐的声音

[@lancrase3295]

黃媽跟叮噹的合唱連老師都捨不得暫停了

[@adriannelcy710]

好棒！！ 老師的表情變化真好理解，好聽就笑，不好聽會臉僵！！好可愛！！好真實！！第三組老師一聽到老龔的聲音就笑得好甜！！好可愛！！ 最後修得多是因為有幸運觀眾吧！！三聲部和聲第二組是選擇不做，第三組是做不到。 最後老師的示範好好聽！！

[@arieldai9087]

第一组是只有两人哈哈

[@gimini8985]

真的超明显哈哈哈哈，听到谢娜脸都僵了哈哈哈

[@aileeanniya8486]

最后一首老师的表情不断转变，真实体现好听是一阵一阵的😂

[@danielxie4173]

毕竟这首歌被称为“她她塌”🤣 最后一个塌来自谢娜

[@wisdombenlee]

黄妈和叮当那首真的是这些年听过的最好的女声合唱

[@aya071996]

每次看老師唱歌時，我都會很驚訝，唱得真棒，謝謝老師後面帶來個人唱歌部份。

[@Michelle-dm4pe]

啊～～～🎉🎉🎉 看到預告，超驚喜超期待的， 沒想到真的製作成影片了

[@_xiiaoyang7716]

丁当和黄妈的版本 真的很 nb

[@edwardhuang3146]

要是沒有謝娜，換成A-LIN，這首歌根本不用任何修音

[@jimlin3044]

這集太狠了，全是唱將裡面夾雜一個觀眾😂

[@jesseling]

只有謝唱的時候她沒笑耶

[@jimlin3044]

@@jesseling 不予置評😂

[@rosebank777]

22:16那边… 老师的表情已经足够说明穿白裙子的那位不聪明，想黑红的表现😂

[@cpcp5557]

闰土夫人，修音都这么差

[@JTJ553]

咋都是繁体字😂 确实高音高 只能当观众了 在云中遨游

[@yuezhao2990]

总觉得老师有点放不开点评… 不知道是不是受之前的影响。 您唱的那么好， 没什么不敢说的！！ 老师自信点！！！ 你会有越来越的粉丝！❤

[@user-bx3wm8ln9c]

說實話被歌手粉絲狂罵，要是我也會不敢直言

[@yumaiwahara448]

完全被老師發現謝娜在幹嘛

[@zervos6069]

第三組修音修最多是因為有白色裙子的那個在

[@hollow-man]

😂😂😂

[@Lucky-kf1ln]

修的全是她的音😂😂

[@viv.c6101]

u r professional, absolutely

[@hollow-man]

好厉害的耳朵👂，谢娜一听就比了下去😂😂

[@heidao777]

謝娜太明顯了

[@arieldai9087]

我们普通人都能听出差别啦

[@shuwenyang5728]

有資本主撐腰 大家忍受吧

[@RepublicofChinataiwan]

期待老師以後會做譚維維個人演唱～她太多經典現場了（燈塔、烏蘭巴托的夜、給你一點顏色、假行僧⋯）

[@jackysu0117]

譚維維絕對值得做多集解析❤

[@c1h2e3r4r5y60]

譚維維在金曲獎的表演和alin一起的，超級超級頂

[@mweieros]

我也是希望老师能选一些谭维维的独唱，绝对的唱将之一。好巧不巧，这些合唱都衬托别人，之前讨论过一次独唱还是一首奇怪的歌。 除了刚刚推荐的X好像还有一首秦腔演唱的歌

[@RepublicofChinataiwan]

@@mweieros 哪首奇怪的歌？

[@tifahan936]

最喜欢第一组

[@user-mc7qw8pf4r]

每次看老师点评，就让我有股想找老师学声乐的冲动😅

[@haydenpak6355]

wow,What a good understanding

[@dang_love_chen]

發現影片上方突然上了字幕😢😢😢 YT要做自己保持初衷需要有很好的心理素質，我希望這麼優秀的老師可以不要被打倒，我從老師身上學到很多正確的觀念👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

[@ga614869]

希望老師能聽聽看聲生不息的高山低谷~完美的三重唱❤️

[@wakkaka]

听听林奕匡的系列歌曲

[@XmZH123]

+1 這首歌只要一開始聼我就會無限loop很多次

[@diloluenwong]

the 1st group is stunning

[@yuezhao2990]

第三段太好看了 老师的表情点评的很到位 哈哈哈

[@hollyloo1183]

我也是来看谢娜乱入😂

[@Thomas-freedom]

老师有火眼金睛

[@user-jr8qh9uq8c]

丁噹現場很強，去看他的音樂劇邊跳邊唱也超穩

[@user-lp9qq5kh3w]

想聽老師解說黃媽 黃綺珊的生活總該迎著光亮或是 是媽媽是女兒❤

[@Una0620]

第三組不修音的話，那個白裙子的會從頭到尾都搭不在一起，這鍋不能讓龔老師背啊😅

[@user-fi3lz9rf4h]

你不说老师也明白的，比较之前也看过龚琳娜和美依礼芽的合唱还有solo😂😂

[@user-nu2sj4ho7s]

把白裙子的换成alin就完美了

[@jkco82]

真的 越聽越氣

[@heedbernadotte3140]

白裙子真的就是毀滅這首歌的元兇 換成A-Lin多好

[@shuwenyang5728]

資本主說什麼就是什麼

[@lo7085]

想看更多黄绮珊的reaction!!!

[@stevel2435]

我喜歡黃琦珊和金池的聲音。

[@Coocoocrab]

Coach Rozette we really appreciate your honest and professional comments. I would love to see your reaction on Tan Weiwei’s “Night of Ulaanbaatar” from The Singer. Thank you we love you!

[@fernandohenriquez2389]

OMG, impressed you did the Chengfeng version

[@fernandohenriquez2389]

Also, loving the Xie Na comments, so accurate

[@godzzz1]

敲碗譚維維在歌手和杭蓋表演的烏蘭巴托的夜

[@jcjoz]

再加 給你一點顏色

[@queensharp]

老師總在某些段落突然失去笑容😂

[@fetarw5758]

好聽是一陣陣的 😆

[@user-wx9cn2lk7x]

谢娜段落失去笑容😂😂😂😂 她不是歌手 情有可原啦

[@dang_love_chen]

我個人覺得跟影片突然上方上了字幕有關係😢😢😢 YT要做自己保持初衷需要有很好的心理素質，我希望這麼優秀的老師可以不要被打倒，我從老師身上學到很多正確的觀念👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

[@kevinyue4957]

是那个塌嘛？

[@ckckckckisme3631]

这留言真让我忍不住，也要忍住的看老师表情

[@Zi-qiChew]

你們影片的翻譯好強好可愛啊，讚讚！加薪加雞腿

[@seaweed9999]

In the third performance, the woman in white dress is not a professional singer. She's a TV show host. Rozette is good to notice that she's less experienced.

[@SeobinFans]

老师最后的合音好好听啊

[@user-bj5hf7hi2u]

三聲部和聲，趕快安排周深、劉彬豪、王晰的山楂樹❤

[@johnshih9224]

我就是来看看谢娜的乱入

[@xian6934]

修音师：那天听说有老龚和小美两位老师，开心的在网上看度假机票。后来听说白裙乱入，开始网上看加班需要的咖啡，哎 还是度假便宜实惠啊

[@yanmingkan4395]

但据内部人说，其实修音这个东西基本是一套模版打完的，其实不存在太大工作量变化🤣这也是为啥会觉得有反向修音

[@xian6934]

@@yanmingkan4395 可以纯靠模板就用软件好了啦 虽然我是记得对于业内人士确实是类似于一种公式一样 我只是想吐槽一下白裙哈哈哈哈

[@yanmingkan4395]

@@xian6934 理解，我也只是这么一说哈哈，之前有b站up主讲过这个问题。因为其实很多时候电视节目没有专门的修音师，可能是混音的工作人员来做这件事，工作量又大，然后就是按节目要求一次设好的，不会像录音棚那种逐个音来扣

[@hunterhugh7311]

Hi Teacher u r such professional!

[@lins1923]

她她塌唱到塌的时候老师的表情好搞笑

[@user-vu9my6vy1r]

可能之前評論鄧紫棋聲音被小炎上的關係 , 老師這次第三組講的好保守 , 但表情還是說明了一切 , 每次輪到白衣服(謝娜) WTF 完全寫在臉上XDDDDD

[@kenttee-px3yo]

希望老师可以听听 谭维维的 乌兰巴托的夜❤

[@user-um5rx3yc8w]

老师评价很中肯😂，确定乱入白衣女子一枚😅

[@venrooy850]

老师果然厉害，一下子就把两个大问题给看穿了，1，芒果台习惯无羞耻地对音乐作品进行修音是逃不过专业音乐人的耳朵的。2，白衣女的音乐修养非常差，歌声单调且根本不知道什么是和声，所以和声部分只能由另两位来完成。

[@prauunprauun91]

You are right, the 2nd song is older than the first one. This song was written by the 2 ladies at the left and right of the 2nd song. And the three ladies in the 2nd song are the original singers the song was intended for. The 2nd song was definitely live, with no autotune, since it's part of the concert. I'm not sure about the 1st and the 3rd ones though, since they are parts of 2 Chinese musical entertainment shows, which you should know, is often autotuned. For the 3rd song, the lady is white is a show host. She is not quite a singer. That's why her singing is often simpler. It's a song for the ladies. The original recording of this song with the ladies from the 2nd song have more 3 parts harmonies. So if you want to get that, go listen to that one. You should learn about the background of the song. It's touching, emotional and meaningful for the ladies.

[@fjal_dalK]

Wonderful observation. I love your reviews, of these chinese singers, starting with Zhou Shen (erm perhaps not so much on the first one, but I still commend your frankness and honesty). But also would like to appreciate your frankness, again, and sharp observation of this chain of comparisons across the various groups. The lady in white in the last performance is indeed more inexperienced than any of the other singers because she is not actually a singer by profession, unlike the others. So this may account for the fact that her singing is abit simpler, without as much flowers or flair in her techniques, because she is more an actress/variety shows host. But I think she still did a pretty decent job (albeit with some assistance from the production team). :) Oh just a fun fact as well, the lady in white is the wife of Jason Zhang, whom you reviewed quite recently.

[@user-id9nw3nl4l]

老师只有听谢娜唱的时候，没有任何感觉，哈哈哈

[@user-kr5rm7ez5x]

希望老師可以去聽一下 B站剪接的四人版她她她 (第一組+第三組 但沒有XN) 真的非常動人好聽 🥹

[@haowang1477]

第一组，的确让人听的更投入

[@weisyntan3764]

Speaking of 3 part harmony, can Rozette please review The Sound of Silence from Super Vocal? In addition, it would be a dream of mine if Rozette could also review my favorite singer, Jolin, maybe her 2015 MAMA performance? Thank you for the amazing videos! ❤

[@kimielee1597]

第三組的小美、龔老師如果要唱好聽的三部合聲，感覺只能靠A-Lin在才有辦法達成了😂謝娜在根本不可能啊….糟蹋這首歌😢怪只怪有人硬要出頭

[@mm-zn1hb]

想看老師聽A-lin唱歌😢 如果A-lin在老師就可能聽到三部和聲了，好可惜…

[@kimielee1597]

@@mm-zn1hb 真的☹️☹️

[@jesseling]

真的 +1

[@cristli7619]

+1。谢娜太毁歌曲了😢

[@wingshingchan9688]

真的+2

[@rinen3847]

她她塌真的太搞笑了 老師這圓場看是打不回來了

[@user-kg8lu4qy5b]

老师就是专业，修音也听得出来

[@user-tq7ox1ib6j]

老師心地善良，第三組有人五音不全所以無法唱出三部，只像二人合唱，老師說唱的很簡單？哈哈……

[@K3J3]

希望Rozette老师将来有机会穿着漂亮的裙子登上中国华丽的舞台！也期待能看到老师点评《声入人心》里的一些优秀的和音歌曲:)

[@yanwang4164]

+1 推荐“The sound of silence"

[@K3J3]

嗯嗯，还推荐“月弯弯”和“山楂树”

[@hawjiang5349]

高产，喜欢

[@kellylian8236]

The last show, girl in white is a TV host in China, she cannot sing well, that's why u cant really find her doing duet or 3 part unison. But her husband is China famous singer, u reviewed his video before and love him so much. Before this performance, her husband help her a bit by choosing simpler verse for her to sing in this song, those difficult parts he said leave it to the 2 professional singers. 😂

[@yuanchen10]

热切的希望听到您点评巅峰期的张学友现场的表演（分手总要在雨天、寂寞的男人……），女歌手中我最期望听听您点评张惠妹的一些好的表演。这两位都是歌曲情感表达很充分，又很细腻的歌手，歌曲表现力很有特色。

[@ivychiu6208]

一切盡在不言中😂

[@AlisAnhTran]

Hope you can make lots of video about 谭维维，she sings very well, especially 给你一点颜色, 轮回，城市船夫，秋意浓。。。

[@skyloft1111]

I actually like 龔琳娜's voice the best out of all of them in this video... 美依禮芽 is good too but I think she's much better when singing Japanese songs... Not expecting too much from 谢娜 since she is not a singer... 😅😅

[@kenong28]

黃琦珊 &丁当 are definitely better, when both singer have big voice and now hold back and sings it's very beautiful. 譚維維 魏雪漫 金池 are more relax performance because it's a concert not a competition. and this video was really old. 龔琳娜 美依禮芽 谢娜 (white dress gal) roxette you're so right, she's just a famous TV host, she's not a professional singer, BUT her husband, which u have done reaction to, Jason Zhang Jie is her husband.

[@a0920442360]

老師聽謝娜時的表情是不是不太一樣⋯⋯

[@lainbing]

是的；每次聽到白衣，老師一邊的嘴角會往下拉，彷彿看到可怕的畫面@@

[@zhaosisters]

看到最后还是感觉给乐评老师挖坑😂

[@keshen297]

Rozette的耳朵确实够狠，谢娜肯定是这三个表演里毫无疑问的最弱.........嘿嘿

[@beblessed1030]

first 1 really lovely

[@nanlee7528]

一到谢娜，老师先撇嘴，然后依据缺乏经验直中要害~🤣

[@user-sc9ln4ty1f]

可以多听一些黄妈的歌吗？

[@MYJOLIN]

真心期待做一系列譚維維的解析！❤️ 她真的是我見過的中國女歌手中最強的！

[@lutinameo]

最强不至于 是你说是不错的歌手之一

[@sugar4184]

老是可以听听张雨生的歌 有惊喜😊😊😊

[@scott9622]

可以给老师推荐一下黄绮珊的歌。我发誓绝对会爱上她

[@nono-pp6no]

真是有技术的评价。夸赞歌手的裙子穿的好看，巧妙地回避了歌手唱的如何。

[@athomenotavailable]

想听她反应许茹芸，张碧晨张靓颖，孙燕姿

[@hpe3203]

老师可不可以也把深深和Gai的玫瑰少年放在一起？😊😊😊

[@orange.studio7]

22:16 哈哈哈 老师表情说明一切又好像没说什么😂😂 你细品

[@loveloveQy]

聽完老師點評乘風組，就好想聽原音喔😂😂

[@MrZhang-cd6xv]

謝娜一下就被聽出不是專業的😂

[@juan-joanneyu399]

能不能做韩国歌手sohyang的bridge over troubled water? 很喜欢这首歌

[@ruigangchen2896]

谭维维的舞台！！！多更新点吧😢

[@Kaoo678]

21:24 專業就是專業

[@user-mu6tx1um4n]

老師看到謝娜的部份，臉就僵掉了，好像在說，她是誰？她在幹嘛？為什麼在這裡？😂

[@thomasvr4]

可以請Rozette老師評價一下齊豫老師的曲目嗎? 想看聲樂老師評美聲歌手激起更多火花

[@user-nl2wu1ch7z]

好期待

[@user-nl2wu1ch7z]

好期待姐弟喔

[@mrna1508]

竟然开始评论浪姐啦！老师评论一下龚琳娜老师和美依礼芽的那首《花海》吧！

[@cllee7506]

老师听得出谢娜是来打酱油的。

[@mweieros]

that’s really awesome, you even point out the girl in white dress was less experienced, that’s absolutely yes, she is not a singer

[@shuwenyang5728]

來告訴你資本戰勝一切的

[@JokersSmaile]

第三段的歌名叫「她她塌」

[@qicao7030]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/g6LFe2x9r994fZY kzbin.info/www/bejne/rX_VgpyVmd-Bgtk 周深 光亮 MV （Zhou Shen Bright MV） kzbin.info/www/bejne/hWakoHdsaMikb5o 周深 光亮 现场手机拍摄 （Zhou Shen Guangliang On-site mobile phone shooting） kzbin.info/www/bejne/p6TInnSgZZiWmLc kzbin.info/www/bejne/g2evpomAnrisg9U 全开麦 没有耳返 Full open mic, no ear return

[@chrislakatos5309]

Any chance reacting to Stephanie Sun’s 孙燕姿线上音乐会”series ,such as 我怀念的..etc

[@younwui4977]

第二个完全是live，多给老师看看金池吧，我想看看

[@user-ge9vd9cf7n]

老師可以講評一下林志炫《知否知否》嗎!!!!!

[@user-dq4yz5rm7l]

算不算推薦黃媽成功

[@GeminiYellow]

🤣🤣🤣謝娜被完美公開處刑啊，真的不應該浪費這個製造好作品的合作機會。

[@user-nw6ni4wm4j]

真不知道她来这个节目干嘛😂

[@GeminiYellow]

@@user-nw6ni4wm4j 也許是因為快樂大本營沒了，要找下一份工作了吧。

[@shuwenyang5728]

是資本主的親閨女呀 大家在想什麼

[@user-eg6gx3yo2i]

哈哈，谢娜没混过第三段就被揪出来啦😊

[@q-rex351]

感觉老师不理解白衣服的为什么会在一起唱。“虽然听起来很糟糕，但和那两位一起唱，总有什么道理？”

[@keiichilee]

老師說的太直白了，白裙子的女生換掉吧！

[@hollow-man]

应该换她的老公来唱是吧😂😂😂

[@sokminkoh3405]

老师也可以听听lala徐佳莹的歌❤

[@user-zp2ue6eq3m]

谢娜，这脸皮可以😂

[@DSSD-fw7pn]

When goes to Xiena's verson?

[@DSSD-fw7pn]

the girl in the white dress...lol