'My mother was beheaded in front of me': a survivor recalls India's violent partition

Zareena Parveen was 12 years old when British colonial India was carved up along religious lines. Two independent states were created: Hindu-majority India, and the Muslim-majority Dominion of Pakistan, which was made up of West Pakistan and East Pakistan (now Bangladesh).
Subscribe to Guardian News on KZbin ► bit.ly/guardianwiressub
As millions rushed to cross the new borders, violence erupted between Hindu, Muslim and Sikh populations that had coexisted for thousands of years. In the months that followed, an estimated 1 million people were killed, up 15 million were displaced and between 75,000 and 100,000 women were abducted and raped.
With the 75th anniversary of India's partition approaching, Parveen recalls seeing family members killed in front of her, the Sikh officer who pulled her from the rubble of her house, and her tortuous journey to Lahore.
‘A Sikh soldier pulled me out of the rubble’: survivors recall India’s violent partition - and reflect on its legacy ► www.theguardian.com/world/202...
The Guardian publishes independent journalism, made possible by supporters. Contribute to The Guardian today ► bit.ly/3uhA7zg
Sign up to the Guardian's free new daily newsletter, First Edition ► theguardian.com/first-edition
Website ► www.theguardian.com
Facebook ► / theguardian
Twitter ► / guardian
Instagram ► / guardian
The Guardian on KZbin:
The Guardian ► bit.ly/guardiannewssubs
Guardian Australia ► bit.ly/guardianaussubs
Guardian Football ► bit.ly/gdnfootballsubs
Guardian Sport ► bit.ly/gdnsportsubs
Guardian Live ► bit.ly/guardianlivesubs
#India #Pakistan #IndiaPartition #Partition

[@user-qz3to7gd5l]

Guardian only shown one side of the story. My grandfather was kicked out of East Pakistan where he has lost his brothers and mother but no one will talk about it.

[@Muslim_GirI]

Fun fact:1947 britishers divided india 2023: They are making videos on it to earn money/yet so called respect and sympathy. Ironic!

[@mohammedarzam3658]

Correct

[@vaibhavkhandve4526]

Yes my sister your absolutely right

[@blacklight5919]

Its bitter fact not fun fact

[@raj2487]

Why blame British? People voted for creation of Pakistan. Ladke lenge Pakistan was a very popular slogan .

[@shivaachariya4526]

Or to educate people who knows.

[@aulw22ashtin12]

Partition of Indian subcontinent was one of the darkest chapters of the history. People on both sides were involved in killing and looting.

[@thinkgood7412]

Colonial history*

[@ssimba2785]

aulw22Aashtin You have hit the nail over the head. and As if she and her family were the only people who suffered, Millions of both side suffered..

[@jaidattadethe]

@@No2Integration Brother reason behind the partition was is**** and aurangzeb ideology was also inspired from is****. so both were darkest chapters of Indian history.

[@KishanSingh-mw1dk]

Dharm pyar felata hai 1947 me sab dharmo k pyar ki goonj aaj tak aa rahi h... 😢😢

[@KishanSingh-mw1dk]

@@immers2410 ant remains better than human beings..

[@Reasoningofficial_Dheeraj123.]

amma shayad aap ye bhool gyi hai ki shuruaat muslimo ne ki thi hinduo ko markar

[@nikifrasier3026]

The British literally sliced this world apart, now we live with the mess

[@nihalreddy1451]

When they r reporting other country fact check is important.but British media is terrible at it and also it should know that they playing games with upcoming super power

[@ty-re9or]

Bhai aacha hua partition ho gya ,damage to hona he tha ,aaj kitna aacha hai ,tumay nhi pta kitna kharab hota agar partition na hota to

[@youtubeuserandchef471]

Actually Indian and Pakistani leaders agreed on the partition And many are grateful

[@chefandmusician9170]

@M Y T H I C A L N O V A he's praising the partition, saying it was obvious, and had to happen India and Pakistan are better separate

[@chefandmusician9170]

@@nihalreddy1451 India isn't upcoming super power Maybe just huge in population and scam calls It's religious extremism won't allow it to be Most intelligent Indian people live in 🇭🇲🇦🇪🇬🇧🇺🇸🇨🇦etc

[@nareshsingh3394]

The British was directly responsible for 6 of the worst famine when they occupied lndia. Over 19 million lndian citizens died of hunger over the 200 years ,the worst was the Bengal famine caused by Churchill.He instructed that all the food produced by lndian farmers must be forcefully removed and given to the British soldiers and allied forces, leaving lndians with no food at all for months,many died of starvation. When Churchill was told of this in a letter,he replied " so why hasn't Ghandi died yet" .Do readers know that the British government never revealed their illegal occupation and stealing of all lndia wealth to its citizens. Their history books have absolutely no trace of lndian occupation. Churchill was actually worse then Hitler,a criminal for mass murder

[@shadowguard3578]

@@josm1481 calling someone a liar doesn’t make it true.

[@Xorphial]

@@josm1481 awwm the apologist is mad.... poor muffin.

[@chefandmusician9170]

Lack of transportation, communication After rail got built less famines Stop lying

[@harikrishnagummalla1573]

​@@chefandmusician9170 ass***e those died of famine were villagers. Up to now every village in bharath is full of grains. Only because of british it happend

[@chefandmusician9170]

@@harikrishnagummalla1573 There's something called cyclones and shortage of water Stop lying Drought affects everyone, every land

[@Ashlesh....]

Indian side suffered most and even minorities in Pakistan are still suffering.

[@80lala08]

wasnt it just united india that suffered, i dont think the british were affected at all

[@eliotmuso]

Is there anything to back your argument, genuinely curious

[@Ashlesh....]

@@eliotmuso True & legitimate Historical proofs and international research. I have everything to back my argument. You can even check on Google too...

[@eliotmuso]

@Ashlesh.... can you direct me to any articles, books, documentaries to read and watch. Thanks in advance

[@vishv1814]

its not a competittion! innocent people who did no one any wrong died and suffered horrificly from both sides...there is no trophy for which side suffered more..

[@RinzSach]

I want to ask my grandmother but I don't want to make her upset. She is very strong for doing this.

[@peacheyearth]

Ask. Life is too short 🙏

[@Nazyaali110]

Ask her. Give her space and comfort and find out. So we can know the truth.

[@eshamalik9942]

I wish I’d asked my dad about it but we just couldn’t because of what he saw as a 5 year old.

[@sandyrocks88]

मोहम्मद अगर पैदा ही नहीं हुआ होता तो यह धरती स्वर्ग होता

[@user-cz2eb8ic9r]

Roshan Mashaal Se humesha Andhere K kaale Sayo ko darr lagta hai.Andhera Mita diye Mere Noor E Khuda s.a.w ne.

[@dr.amanraj6326]

As a doctor from India I felt broken

[@__Man__]

Imagine the land was sliced by a man who never went to India. It is the same like African partition, causing tribal land to split, cultural conflicts and many more

[@__Man__]

@@josm1481 not violent, at least slice it correctly

[@__Man__]

@@josm1481 but, they could facilitate and secure the migration. If they could rule India, why could'nt they secure the migration process?

[@__Man__]

@@josm1481 that's the problem, they seems like they are amused with the chaos, instead of trying to resolve it. I know this because my land becomes the victim of partition until now

[@10poundnote]

The partition was not planned by the British, that was India's ethnic leaders idea, a mindset that had grown for years. The British were for the most part only witnesses to what unfolded.

[@shashankshekhar46]

@@josm1481 india was the nation of the crown so called "crown jewel " of british empire now who has the responsibility of taking care of its citizens ?

[@madhukalal5554]

Abhi Pakistan me hinduo ki halat ke bare me kya khayal he????????

[@ornament_of_throne12346]

Jaise bhi 1 hafte mein 3000 musalamaanon jaise guhrat mei maarey gaye ya bombay mei 2000 1 mahine maarey gaye aisa kuch nhi hua hei

[@raj2487]

@@ornament_of_throne12346fir bhi wo India nahi chorte. 75 saal ho gaye

[@fahadghazanfar9733]

@@raj2487 Because they are Indian . Anyone can change religion from one to other but ethnicity decides .

[@fahadghazanfar9733]

@@raj2487 Better everyone should respect each other and avoid the people who promotes hate in name of religion , race , wealth and etc . at the end of day we all are human . and we all have one life . that's why live and let other live

[@postmessage135]

47 ke baad pakistan me godhra 84 type ka danga bata do ??

[@Braveheart.22]

How very horrible. There really is no healing from such a tragedy. 😥

[@Success_with_Touhid]

I know it is heartbreaking i feel the same

[@ThePierre58]

Thank you for using subtitles, many will understand her first hand. God bless her soul.

[@elanhafjones]

Absolutely heartbreaking and shocking💔😞

[@Braveheart.22]

@M Y T H I C A L N O V A grow up

[@Braveheart.22]

@M Y T H I C A L N O V A then bless you...though that is nieve

[@jk2705197a7]

@M Y T H I C A L N O V A Read proper history, not the one you learn at school

[@samlebon9884]

@M Y T H I C A L N O V A Try to use some empathy.

[@Thatoneidiot001]

The thing is the name partition of India makes no sense cause India was a colonial term and neither did Bharat Hindustan and India never existed until August 15 of 1947 tho I feel bad for those who died were injured or anything.

[@jdmmg4904]

Thank you for covering this. I'm half white-half Anglo Indian and this is part of my family's story as well. Just heartbreaking 😭💟

[@assassinskillz123]

You’re white

[@jdmmg4904]

@@assassinskillz123 you probably don't know a lot about Anglo Indians then. But anyways, thanks for explaining myself to me, it was a pleasure 😘

[@ns687]

does that make you ¾ white

[@jdmmg4904]

@@ns687 you seemingly don't know that Anglo-Indians come in all colors, right? some are very dark, some are almost white. plus... no matter how I or my Anglo-Indian parent looks like (as this is also just a matter of luck) the heritage stays the same. But it's always lovely to hear from Indians not accepting my parent as Indian who grew up there their whole life and never knew another life.

[@AnimatedBlast]

@@jdmmg4904 I’m also Anglo Indian, from both parents. My Anglo side lived in India generations ke liye, aur Bharatiya ho gaye.

[@dreamofbihar]

And British never apologised......

[@chefandmusician9170]

Pretty sure Indian and Pakistani leaders agreed at the time hence no need apologize

[@gelbsucht947]

Why would they apologise for preventing people from slaughtering each other? If they had done nothing, they would have been criticised for doing nothing. Lives were saved in the long run.

[@kmc7876]

@@chefandmusician9170 cool..face the mess ur forefathers created.. enjoy

[@chefandmusician9170]

@@kmc7876 I don't live in south Asia

[@kmc7876]

@@chefandmusician9170 I'm referring to The indians Pakistani Bangladeshis asylum seekers coming by boats ,the takeover of East London, birmingham,leeds brDford etc etc.. THIS is what I was referring to..

[@Travelleramit]

Who asked for Partition 🤔

[@josm1206]

Why did he ask for partition is a better question?

[@ImranKhan1976]

@@josm1481 actually partition wasn't Jinnah's idea - it was Nehru's. Jinnah had originally been aiming for a loose federation and less centralised Indian union. Nehru explicitly stated partition was preferable to a loose federation but conveniently developed amnesia about the whole issue once it had taken place.

[@shashankshekhar46]

@@ImranKhan1976 the inc were never in favour of a seperate nation

[@kalidasswaminathan4341]

​@@ImranKhan1976 read more than what Pakistan Studies class taught you. You could beging with Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed's book on Jinnah.

[@SakSarIns]

Most important point

[@shahidkamal8318]

Thanks britain for the horrific night of partion . The pain and suffering you caused between india and pakistan .

[@assassinskillz123]

You do realise Jinnah wanted partition

[@ImranKhan1976]

@@assassinskillz123 it was actually Nehru who suggested partition.

[@muslim_first]

@@assassinskillz123 Britain could have provided security for the migrants.

[@alecgurney9305]

Your welcome shahid?

[@sindyiathakur5507]

@@ImranKhan1976 just read history properly

[@vijitpatel2331]

my heart started shivering after listening to this

[@crisvlog3536]

Unbearable pain. 😭

[@albanianedits]

this is heart breaking to me, after the mother and brother got killed

[@HarpreetSingh-yp8zq]

Partition se 10 saal pehle musalmano ne raval Pindi me sikhon ka katleaam Kiya koi musalman nahi bola, Lahore se lashon ki train bheji sath ek letter bhi jispe likha tha nehru ko hamari taraf se tohfa, jinna sahab ki zid se pakistan banna, ye kyu nahi padate Pakistan ke log apne bachhon ko, currency note pe tasvir lagane se koi mahan nahi ho jata, apne pichwade pe rakte hain log noton se bhare huye wallets.

[@deshbhakt1670]

Its the same story on the other side of border...

[@omprakashsaharan5296]

This is one side story Others suffered 100 times more

[@sajidsaddaq2685]

😴

[@msumode4493]

100 times worse than being killed?

[@shubham943]

​@@msumode4493Yes

[@badpiggies988]

Whatsapp alumni

[@KT-ke3nl]

How the ego of jinnah led to massacre of millions

[@saintsoldier5671]

Mata ji my whole village was slaughtered by bad people's in village 33 chak layalpur ,

[@mariarauf3280]

I'm so sorry for your loss🙏i hope your heart heals ❤️‍🩹 My grandma's father and most of his family were also killed while coming from ludhiana to lahore

[@abhijitguha494]

Hope such madness and evil never repeats itself again

[@hardeepsingh-sg2kz]

My family is also from chak 33. Marwaha from Lyallpur. Most survived

[@saanea2000]

My paternal grandfather's family migrated from Ludhiana too. Only two members of his family survived including him.

[@saanea2000]

​@@mariarauf3280My paternal grandfather's family migrated from Ludhiana too. Only two members of his family survived including him.

[@surayyayousaf3907]

Shocking and heart breaking 😢

[@Littleboy159]

What East India company and it's country did in India,that won't be forgotten and forgiven

[@Vaibhav6384]

We will try to complete partition in future let's see what happens 😅

[@major2707]

Jai Hind

[@a2d2charlie13]

I’m sindhi… my grandfather migrated from ladkana when he was 9

[@DearBill]

Hello. When partition happened , Buddhist Jain and Christian also left Pakistan for India ?

[@shahidhabibadvocate6946]

And my father left Gwallior when he was only 14, at the time of Partition. He lost his first wife during that horrific time.

[@bassman9485]

It is an horrible event.

[@dotnb]

No words. Truly terrible.

[@biturboism]

Another job well done for the British empire! What a disaster even by their “Great” standards…

[@tastypymp1287]

What's your standards?

[@nihalreddy1451]

U guys are terrible. u British news are terrible at fact check

[@csmahi2046]

Unbearable and terrifying situation, both side people beacame insane😢

[@chrislogan33]

Ironically her sons Generation did the very same thing to my people in 1971

[@ab36935]

Surprisingly there is no responsibility by the British.

[@joelpetersen2480]

As long as the royals had a great time, everything is fine.

[@Macho98]

😂😂

[@Macho98]

@@josm1481 @Jo Sm what does Indian royals have got to do with any of this. India was divided by mountabatten plan. Infact many kingdoms have no choice but to cede to India. Some gave up their rule voluntarily, some were coerced(kashmir) some ceded later. You have no idea what you are talking about. All royal titles are abolished in India after Independence.

[@z00ey]

@@josm1481 astonishing ignorance from you Jo Sm. You say “Many were paid to give up the crown” - what do you think would have happened if they refused? Do you understand nothing of basic politics, let alone human nature?

[@onthestreet4350]

And now children, grandchildren of those royals are enjoying great rich life in foreign countries and also in India...while poor population kept on suffering then and now.

[@EarnYourCitizenship]

Power vacuums always lead to problems. It's unfortunate that some people choose to bring violence and hate in these circumstances. The Indians and Pakistanis have managed to mostly overcome their issues, hope for the future.

[@nihalreddy1451]

British media is terrible at fact check

[@StratsRUs]

Wow, you Historian you !!!

[@EarnYourCitizenship]

@@StratsRUs It's really easy to brush up on history, especially with the internet. Knowledge for everyone 🙂

[@EarnYourCitizenship]

@@nihalreddy1451 Fact checkers are just gatekeepers, not just in Britain.

[@uzochiokeke4328]

They have not overcome their issues. The Indians tried to make peace but the pakistanis were too greedy, now India has just moved on and pakistan is still in shambles.

[@soodabhi]

Britishers showing one side of their crimes

[@roysharma5284]

Terrible tragedy Auntyji. This made me cry. One day all these people will give account for their actions. No-one is going to get away with it!

[@sakbhu001]

Still reeling from the effects of this incomplete partition..

[@Sadashiv_bhau]

ऐसी नफ़रत फिर कभी ना लगे, कैसे लोग मासूमों का कत्ल कर देते हैं, भगवान उन सभी आत्माओं को शांति दे ।

[@satyamrajvanshi2160]

Direct action day inhone khud kiya ab rore hai

[@MP_mp20]

British was responsible for this, accept it and apologize for that

[@wayu8334]

Independence doesn't mean mere change of government from the British to Indians. It should lead to real liberation of people. Tull now people of the two countries are suffering from many disabilities fuelled by the government

[@dhruvnegi8910]

It starts from Pakistani Bullas.. If it not happend from another side.. So also not happend in there.

[@samlebon9884]

The British Empire left a lot of messy places.

[@sharadavinjamuri9913]

Sorry for all that you had to go thru

[@rameshnag1983]

All credit goes to Gandhi , Nehru and Jinna.....

[@AyanKarim-hs5ho]

gandhi was the only one who could have stopped the violence but the britishers sidelined him

[@sunjae87]

Currently reading Ice-Candy man by Bapsi Sidhwa...And even though, I grew up listening about the mass murders during the partition, I'm still horrified watching this.

[@saanea2000]

Ice Candy Man is such a great work of literature representing partition. I always felt it should be required reading in the high school syllabus in India and Pakistan.

[@A2Vvlogs]

Everyone knows who started it. There have been so many examples in front of us of a particular community first starting chain of violence and then making hue and cry over their side of blood loss while completely ignoring their own acts..

[@tarlochansingh620]

She does admit that life under British India was much better than what she got in the free nations. It's horrible to imagine what a bad job our governments did that British India seemed better.

[@Austenite762]

lol life in british India was horrible, my grandmother lost her entire family in a plague when she was 7. Grandpa grew up in abject poverty. Only after the Brit left, prosperity came to India. Yes we still have huge problems but if brits were here our condition would have been much worse. Bangladesh too is doing pretty well. Pakistan is kinda facing huge problems though

[@Aestheteswati]

It's was absolutely horrible and India needed time. It just started its journey. Britishers literally took everything. It was though.

[@manannaik1341]

And without Brits we are 5th largest gdp… within just 75 years… lol

[@zay_kash]

My grandfather was put in prison in Peshawar cuz he was anti British

[@Aestheteswati]

BENGAL FAMINES

[@Asskicker14]

What humans are capable of doing is beyond imagination

[@dhanashri5661]

Both sides suffered sooo much due to the partition why did Jinnah wanted other nation same things happened with Kashmiir Pandits back in 1980's .. the sufferings are unspeakable due to partition people died the World suffered due to British invasion both sides faced alot

[@qasmb1546]

Why do so many ignore the religious conflict which caused a lot problems? And just focus on the british?

[@bhar.apoooo]

I also recall my unarmed grandfather who was murd€red by the blo0dthirsty British forces in Amritsar in 1919..

[@MrSlanderer]

You were alive in 1919?

[@shaylazaman1882]

​@@MrSlandererHis grandfather was alive in 1919

[@pedrolplgm]

GARLAND CAN BE STOPPED.

[@rwfgh123]

Partition is the best thing that happened to us. Wish Lahore and Guru Nanak birth place be included in our territory as well. An entire district extra won't be bad.

[@chefandmusician9170]

Should've been done in seventy five years time

[@ssimba2785]

Ruthless warrior One that will happen as the new generation of India is waking up. Including whole of Kashmir.

[@gourabdas7251.]

Should come and take it 😂😆

[@karantikoo9302]

@@gourabdas7251. East pakistan ki tarah le lenge don't worry

[@gourabdas7251.]

@@karantikoo9302 it was us who break Bharat into pieces we will breat it into 100 pieces and will fight a 1000 years war with India .

[@Gaiafreak6969]

Not a single anglo was held accountable

[@Photon-1927]

What I don’t understand if the countries were divided , and people were moving to other parts, why they got killed in the way ? What triggered the mobs ? As the whole nation used to live togather earlier.

[@rogoffx8313]

These politicians destroy our Punjab 😢

[@KK.Everywhere]

Chachi start kishne kiya tha yee nahi bataya Direct Action ka bareme

[@ranjitganguly1416]

Please read the book - Punjab the bloodied partion and athnic cleansing by Prof Istaq Ahmed, Pakistani professor in Stockholm University, Sweden

[@chetangoswami7872]

Another example of great efforts of great Britain

[@anjidoyle9006]

I feel your pain, but it was the English aristocracy/high ranking military and government who called themselves the British Raj. Nothing to do with the ordinary british person.

[@i.m.r336]

Anyone who benefits from colonialism and does not try to stop it when they do is complicit in the evils that happen. From 1747-1947 it wasn't just the aristocracy who benefited, alot of the British public (the middle class) benefitted too. They are just as complicit and at fault for the evil of colonialism they benefitted from.

[@jamie306]

@@i.m.r336 ffs they’re not. there’s a huge diff bw a serial killer and someone w no relation to him other than they both live in the same town who can’t do anything ab it

[@ssap4amgpmjayab307]

yes. lay man can not change the decisions taken by high ranking people

[@libshastra]

It has everything to do with current British people. You folks have the responsibility to learn the true atrocities of the Raj and the Partition. The British Govt today refuses to open up it's archives and refuses to acknowledge the atrocities it committed. It is incumbent on the current British people to get the British Govt to recognize it's excesses.

[@chefandmusician9170]

@@i.m.r336 including schools , parliament, rail, hockey cricket, law courts too Read about Edward Jenner, Joseph lister, Ronald Ross, Rudyard Kipling and lord bentick too

[@dannykumar2410]

Shocking that the evil people that did this were never brought to justice… How and why?one nation and one people …the ancestral families of Pakistan and India are the same.

[@chefandmusician9170]

It wasn't Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Myanmar are all different It's better separate and the leaders agreed for separation

[@Thatoneidiot001]

Also gotta point out Pakistan isn't completely the same as India cause of ethnic diversity they are not the same if they were Pakistan would be more stable because there would be ethnic conflict indoors

[@ibtisammaaz3109]

It's your point of view, But our point of view is very clear, whoever does perform evil in his life, would face the consequences in his afterlife.

[@Homie-world]

If Netaji hadn't vanished, if British hadn't exploited the power vacuum, Indian subcontinent would've never been destroyed.

[@bhar.apoooo]

All thanks to british for fueling this hate and dividing people on religious grounds.

[@ThinkDeep_Official]

Very True

[@lalboimanlun1230]

I think it's bound to happen anyway and the British just accelerate it. Just my opinion and I don't mena the British were right.

[@roysharma5284]

The leaders at the time could have organised an orderly transfer of people from one place to the other. Why did they not? Apart from the British who bear most of the burden, where were the Indian and pakistani leaders? Why did they not foresee the tragedies? Incompetent leadership? Or just did not care?

[@STRANGERINMOSCOW1]

Horrific

[@Jenvlogs404]

And who wanted it, the Brits only had the power.

[@vishv1814]

people celebrate jinnah, but that man and his actions caused death of millions of innocent people and still ongoing....before partition gandhi begged him not to go ahead with it and even offered him to lead india....during his dying breath jinnahs last words were of regret he spoke of how his idea of partition was the biggest mistake of his life as it was succh a disaster....

[@saanea2000]

🤦‍♀️ pls refer us to the source where it says these are his dying words. Utter nonsense

[@tyagizone2219]

So she is 105 years old

[@thikthik3629]

No she is 87 while she give interview

[@postmessage135]

Currently british govt is replicating same policy in gaza....its same same its shame shame..

[@user-xy2ge2fw8t]

Britan government do this , make India three parts , we know very well , Britishers mistake , and guard ian media against india

[@yupp_]

🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺 Love to this woman ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@awesomestevie27]

All my homies hate the Radcliffe line

[@haqeeqatreport7729]

Bohut dukh hua suna k sikho ne b bht zulm kiya

[@ridhamatri9447]

Pehle Pakistanio ne kiya. Sikho ne bas response diya.

[@engrimran04f]

India should not be divided.

[@omsharansingh7333]

Liars always tells lie. Ku rand teaches for one lie tell 1000 lies.

[@dilenaking4746]

This is exactly what happened to Palestine!!

[@chefandmusician9170]

Since 1948?

[@muslim_first]

It's different brother. We Pakistanis always lived on our soil.

[@itr8247]

​@@muslim_firstlol no longer claiming to be arab or turkish?

[@AidanTheLoverBoyOhDwyer]

is she speaking urdu or punjabi

[@prateeksharma6706]

Hindi

[@apoorvsalar9452]

Urdu in punjabi accent

[@updeshsingh3951]

@@apoorvsalar9452 no

[@assassinskillz123]

Thank you Jinnah

[@chrisivory121]

Any actionable evidence please

[@kimsana8880]

Are you out of your Mind? Do you think these things will be recorded at that time??

[@chrisivory121]

@@kimsana8880 any actionable evidence please for not recorded

[@_rahul1996]

@@chrisivory121 you should read pakistan or partition of india by b r ambedkar

[@desistarktm7270]

As an Indian, i don't blame British for partition, i blame it for making the partition incomplete. Now we have many Pakistans within India causing trouble everyday.

[@molanahalaludeenalharami]

​@Aarish D abb nhi hoya abb tandav hoga jo dusra Pakistan manega wo pele jayega

[@pranav26051989]

True...it should have been completed once and for all.

[@sahilsingh6048]

Andhbhakt

[@Ashlesh....]

Complete nonsense comment... spreading hate..ignore...

[@alphacapital2425]

​@@sahilsingh6048tell this to yourself when same will happen to you like this woman!

[@elara2498]

Why every now and then the name of British comes in other countries issue's?

[@thecrusader6401]

Thanks for your service England.

[@mrexpress8002]

@@josm1481 there was no sectarian violence until the British came over, Divide and rule.

[@chefandmusician9170]

@@mrexpress8002 1829 Sati stopped Religious extremism is still prevalent in India, Pakistan

[@chefandmusician9170]

@@josm1481 law courts, police departments, parliament were built for the sake of some justice in India

[@shashankshekhar46]

@@chefandmusician9170 you say religious extremism can you tell me what was the peroiod like in britain when they used to follow the bibal like its the constitution ?

[@chefandmusician9170]

@@shashankshekhar46 religious extremism is most high in south Asia And sati was the worst culture ever Stop comparing, blaming and just accept there were terrible times Even now there is dalit lives matter Prime minister supporting Indian billionaires only hence Indian leave the country and travel elsewhere

[@suvigyamishra]

Waheguru ❤️

[@anupamasharma8898]

British did this , divide and rule

[@Ghanshyamtiwari19]

Anupama abhi bhi

[@jimbocho660]

'India' was not partitioned in 1947 because 'India' did not then exist as a country or an identity. What was partitioned was Punjab, which was then one nation. After all these years people in the West still don't understand these simple facts.

[@mihirshetye4624]

Ever heard of the "East India Company" ?

[@Thatoneidiot001]

India is a colonial term and thank you for knowing India was never partitioned

[@hijazlander]

Punjab wasn't a country either, it was a region.

[@qadeerhussain4838]

بہت ہی درد ناک پہلو ہیں اس پارٹیشن کے ۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔۔دل خون کے آنسو روتا ہے

[@techkolkata2678]

That what butcher Britishers did with us 🥺 shame on you Britishers

[@godofdata1662]

It was on both sides my great grand dad had same fate in lahore .

[@ahmerjamil2629]

Salute to Britain for the 1947 Massacre Night

[@MunawwarHussain-hu9sw]

Oh..., it's very panic 😢

[@objectsmedia4523]

One sided are we ?

[@ankitkataria7136]

Thats why i dont like british,Gandhi,Nehru,Jinnah

[@hina30930]

Thanks this channel for showing the story of the other side ❤ other wise we are just fed up listening that we are oppressor 😢