Guerlain L'Homme Ideal Extreme OG vs Reformulation - Is There A Difference?

[@DontAtMeThanks]

Hard choice but im picking L'HOMME IDEAL EXTREME

[@michaelallen9364]

L’Homme Ideal Cologne is probably my favorite. The whole line rocks. So classy and refined.

[@shadynebula6948]

Have you tried platine prive yet?

[@DS-mo5db]

Yes I have ! they are very similar but not redundant. Platine is a somewhat more mature version of the cologne

[@ivantrudeau8974]

The cologne is unique I must admit. 😁

[@EvolutionOfMan]

Cologne is beautiful. Unfortunately only have a 10ml sample almost gone and didn't get a chance to pickup a bottle. Also really wanted to try Cool! Have you guys tried that one?

[@michaelallen9364]

@@EvolutionOfMan I have not smelled Cool. That one goes in a minty direction as I understand.

[@sunfalll]

L’homme ideal extreme is by far my favorite. I never had a chance to smell the old bottle style so I’m extremely satisfied with the new bottle style I currently own.

[@KurushimiVrishraka]

Long lasting? How long does it last on your skin?

[@sunfalll]

@@KurushimiVrishraka 6-7 hours

[@SmellsAddicted]

I have a few Guerlain fragrances and I love them all...Vetiver, L'Instant de Guerlain EDP (The current LIDGE), and L'Homme Ideal EDP. It's really hard to pick a favorite because I like each one in different situations. Vetiver for spring, Ideal and LIDGE for fall/winter. As a side note, my mom has been wearing Guerlain Shalimar EDT longer than I've been living and I am 46. Of course, Shalimar was the original Oriental fragrance and has been sold to the public for nearly 100 years

[@brianpeters5356]

My favorite is cologne. Love the freshness and year round versatility.

[@eliashjort4018]

My favourite must be the l'homme ideal extreme. The cherry note hits so well with the tobacco.

[@stevep.589]

My favorite is the EDP. I'd be interested in you comparing the "old vs. new" bottle styles of that one too!

[@cedricsaintpaul9465]

do you have the black cap bottle or the old one?

[@huhndaking777]

id like to know aswell. im considering pulling the trigger, but ive read the new formulation seems to be a lot weaker... any news?

[@whatsupjash]

My favorites from the line are the Extreme and Eau de Parfum. The cherry almond combo to me is perfection. Bought the Extreme before a business trip from the airport. It was my first trip abroad, and I wanted something which will work well in colder weather. It did the trick, It was the first time I got compliments from clients and colleagues and it instantly became my go-to scent and has reserved a special place in my collection ever since. On my way back, I had to get the EDP and it's great too.

[@alexreyes6257]

Guerlain L’homme Ideal Extreme is definitely my favorite. I got myself a decant and fell in love with it. Now i will say i fell into the trap that the red bottle and new bottle could be different. I would love to be able to get that OG bottle to calm my nerves haha

[@DocRock71]

My favorite from the Ideal line is the OG. It's just more versatile than the EDP to me, which is also great, as well as the d/c Ideal Cologne. The entire line is actually amazing...one of the best lines out their in the designer world.

[@flatfootandflexible5098]

To each their own, I didn’t like it and gave it to my brother in law. Edp and cologne are great and hope to get extreme.

[@szeki2076]

My favorite from the line is the EDP. That leathery cherry and almond smell is just sublime.

[@jimmy3984]

Hey Ash, I’m a big fan of the whole line. If I had to pick one it’d actually be L’Homme Ideal L’intense.. I think the addition of smoke, and pepper gives it a very unique and masculine feel

[@illyanavale6328]

I adore the EDT! It's one of my all time favorite can't live without scents. I especially love wearing it in on cooler spring days.

[@kunaalsinngh]

I've used both the Guerlain L'Homme Ideal EDT and the L'Homme Ideal EDP... and I'm definitely picking the EDP as my favourite. A little expensive here in India but definitely worth it 🙌🏼

[@rishabhtripathi1175]

I bought L’Homme Ideal EDP for around ₹5500 and that's a solid price for the fragrance and worth every penny 😍

[@hrishikeshsarda9046]

@@rishabhtripathi1175 where did you get it for 5500 in india??

[@smokieop1206]

@@rishabhtripathi1175 I bought it for 6,500🥲

[@sukshammahajan1958]

U can buy for 5500rs in india from mom perfumes delhi. ( Ankur bhai )

[@aldrinartuz4310]

Just got the L'Homme Ideal EDP a few days and instantly became my fave. Idk why I still wear it here since it's the hottest summer in a while in our country. Second is the L'Homme Ideal L'Intense and I get more compliments in this. Thanks Ash!

[@freundlichermensch7540]

I really like the entire line, unfortunately my favorite is discontinued, which was l'homme ideal cool and when you find it, you pay a huge premium. It was such a great cheapie for a while. Talking about bottle style; i really like the slightly different stickers and caps, so the bottles look great next to each other, but are still distinct.

[@attilaboda9881]

You can still biy GHI Cool in all over Hungary in the Müller stores.

[@kevino73]

Here's a pro tip. If there is a brand new release that you happen to really like, it might be worth it to buy a back up bottle along with the bottle you plan on using. It's the only way to know for sure and not have to deal with this bs.

[@jeanpierrefrederick5612]

I've never smelled any of the Geurlain fragrances, so I don't have a favorite personally but its always nice to watch your videos and learn more about different fragrances that I haven't gotten my nose on.

[@Zarslanian]

L’Homme Ideal Extreme is my favorite in the line, and I have the reformulated version. I would love to have the original version to compare with. I love the reformulated version so much, it’s hard to believe it was once even better!!

[@jokaasama1529]

they are the exact same thing, its just a placibo they didnt change a thing about juice just the bottle, and i know that becus i have the old reformulation with the old bottle (red cap for extreme and purple for edp)

[@Silvio_TF]

it really is most likely placebo 👍🏼

[@jesusbracho271293]

Thanks for this Ash! I gotta say my favorite has to be Intense. That chili note is amazing!

[@Q_N-]

My fave is hands down Lhomme ideal Cologne. Luckily I have 2 backup bottles. The prices on those are quite ridiculous in their own rite.

[@chrischio86]

I got the EDP a few months ago and was fortunate enough to get the old style bottle. I don't know if the EDP was reformulated at all, but the EDP is my fav. That cherry note is mouth watering. Would definitely like to hear your thoughts on the EDP "old vs new" 👍✌️

[@ibrpwtw]

as a person who's tried the whole line in new bottles, there is no difference and these fragrances are stil sooo amazing, but im happy for you to get the better looking bottle:)

[@kennyc2281]

​@@ibrpwtw Sir I need your input a lil bit more about this. Want to get the edp, but not sure about the new design since everyone said its weaker than the old bottle. Is there any difference with the scent? And how about the performance that you get normally on your skin? Thank youu

[@ImBenGee]

@@kennyc2281 I tried the old bottle at a departmental store and then I got a new bottle. I feel like the new ones are less smooth, really tickles the nose, and way smokier. Not sure if it's just me though.

[@MrDavekek]

@@kennyc2281 I also have both beige and black cap, and i dont feel theres any difference really. If people claim the old one is more smooth, then its just because the new one havent had much time to steep.

[@potentatewags]

Smoke? Are you sure you didn't smell the parfum rather than the edp? The former does have a smoke note I believe

[@MrHARMCITY]

L’Homme Ideal Extreme is my favorite.. never smelled the pre-reformulated version before , but I’m not gonna throw out the new version that I own cuz it still smells amazing.

[@nightmare159357]

Thank you very much for the chance. My favorite in Ideal line definite L'homme Ideal EDP

[@JoeAverage1469]

Great topic to cover, thanks Ash! But the zooming and graphics....

[@michaeldelisi6394]

I think my favorite so far is the EDP. That cherry note is so nice.

[@chrishirata157]

Guerlain L’homme ideal extreme is by far my favorite. I had been searching for it a long time and found it at the airport in Frankfurt at the beginning of a vacation in 2022. Now many great memories are tied to it!

[@tabjuba5141]

Wonderful line, I enjoy the Original .. Which was a blind buy and Love it, straight into my top 5 of my collection

[@benjouhaziz]

The EDP is for sure my favorite. That incense note with the cherry drives me crazy

[@miguelgonzalez-floyd1376]

L’homme Ideal Edp was my introduction to the line, and still has my heart to this day for those sentimental reasons. Appreciate you Ash! One of my fave channels in frag comm.

[@tom_schroeder]

I have been enjoying L’Homme Ideal Intense and L’Homme Ideal Cologne the most recently. Thanks for the video and giveaway, Ash.

[@StevenTwoTwo]

Same

[@wynonasbigbrowndragon6121]

My favourite from the L'Homme Idéal line is the Eau De Parfum. That cherry note 👌

[@evanistheman9154]

Ideal extreme is one of my favorite scents! Something about how classy and sophisticated it is that gives the chills

[@josephmills4858]

My favorite is L'HOMME IDEAL EXTREME I love the tabocco,pink pepper and plum make it so smooth it Breaks my heart to hear that it is different This is one of my signature scents and I am on my last bottle 😮

[@gomezjim]

By far, my favortire is L’Homme Ideal Cologne. Such an amazing Spring/Summer scent. One of my go to scents this time of year.

[@edmond5625]

My favorite from the line is l’homme ideal cologne, but I also enjoy a lot the eau de parfum and the extreme. Thanks for the opportunity ash

[@brenthopper8394]

I like the citrusy Guerlain L’Homme Platine Prive - a great warm weather scent now that the sun is coming back out

[@morganmallory1198]

I really the the EDP. It just such a great scent. I haven’t tried many of the others yet. Thanks for the chance to try this one!

[@TheSneakGame]

My favorite is the EDP. Great scent for the fall and winter!

[@primetime0074]

Hey Ash, great content as always. My favorite from the line is the L'Homme Ideal Extreme. I love the way they used plum as a contrasting note alongside tobacco & leather which makes it the most sophisticated one among all others from this line.

[@brianzhere]

Thanks for comparing these 2! So sad that the reformulation is so noticable. My favorite is the EDP. One of my favorite fragrances that I own. Appreciate your generosity

[@armentutundjian6800]

My favorite is definitely the EDP 👍 thanks for the opportunity.

[@Keiz1122]

Thanks for the comparison. Love Guerlain ideal. Have some of them. Love to have the red Extreme.

[@CraigCrowder]

My favorite is probably L'homme Ideal Extreme. Cheers!

[@MrAdrianWinata]

My favorite from L'Homme Ideal line is definitely L’homme Ideal EDP. It carries that great Guerlain L'homme sweet signature smell. The sweet lavender, almond and cherry notes gives this fragrance enough versatility to be worn all year around.

[@justadam5761]

My favorite is l’homme ideal cologne, it’s the most unique warm weather fragrance in my collection and something I love to wear

[@markhutzler9242]

I would have to say L'homme Ideal the original edt for me. Love the almond note. Fantastic scent.

[@ryanarmstrong8042]

Great explanation. My fav is actually the EDT and then Cologne.

[@Top_Lad]

Also compare the EDP please, EDT also. This is a service to the community, maybe do some more of these on the extra gents scents channel?

[@joeyswaney8497]

I really like the Ideal Extreme the best. That plum note is amazing.

[@Bxrlito97]

I’m loving the new production in the recent videos, adds extra quality, humor, and entertainment. Keep it up 👍🏽

[@HorologicRannygazoo]

So far my favorite is the only one I've tried -- Guerlain L'Homme Ideal for Men EDT, but I do like that one. So many things on the "to get" list already. . .

[@juliopena5122]

I've only had the original and just recently got the parfum and between those two I prefer the parfum. That cherry sweetness is to DIE for!!!! 😊

[@CeeJ1717]

Guerlain Lhomme Ideal cologne is my favorite but the whole collection is a must have!

[@johnrivers9037]

My favorite is L'homme Ideal Edp. Thanks man.

[@nottoobadgg8023]

My favourite has to be L'Homme Idéal L'Intense. Loved the breakdown!!

[@b_broom]

Editor: How many effects should be added to the video? Ashton: YES

[@paulk4458]

Hi, Luckly I do have 3 from this line, all newest formulations and they are all unique for the line. Sport, L'intese and Extreme. Out of the 3, Extreme has to be my favorite.

[@harleyblankenship2963]

I have not tried any any of the L'Homme Ideal fragrances but I would like to. Thanks Ash

[@emiliosman820]

Great review and thanks for the info, I have three of the original IDEAL and I really love Cologne and the original, I always wanted the Extreme in the older bottle style to join his brothers!

[@hugoevo2561]

This types of videos are very important for the fragrance comunity. The one that I like the most is l'homme ideal edp.

[@Ripsnort12]

Thanks for the great giveaway. Guerlain L'Homme Ideal Extreme is my favorite. I haven't smelled the new version yet.

[@na5ek]

Have not gotten a chance to experience this line of fragrance yet. But my bottle of L’Homme Ideal Platine Prive was just delivered this morning! Can’t wait to try it tonight!!!

[@ASE-VII]

For me , first is the l’intense then Edp then Extreme. The whole line is a work of art, they all smell amazing 👌🏽

[@MrBoddy72]

At last a worthwhile video ~ was gonna get this but have changed my mind now. Cheers Ash 👍🏼

[@favinzano]

Oh wow! I love your passion for fragrance! What amazing choices you have there - Givenchy L’Homme EDP and Extreme sound absolutely fantastic! And did you say cherry almond? Mmmm...that does sound like perfume heaven on earth! I can imagine the warmth and comfort the L’Homme Extreme scent provided during cold weather situations. Plus, nothing better than a lovely companion on those dates that keep us up all night ❤️ Wishing you wonderful scented memories around every corner😊. My favorite: L’Homme Extreme, absolutely…

[@sulaimanaljabari]

My favorite is L'Himme ideal cologne! Fantastic fragrance and unique in its own right I use it sparingly!

[@EddyBlackApocalypse]

Great, in depth video, Ash. My favorite L'Homme Ideal is the EDP. But it's also the only one I've tried. I would love to try the Extreme.

[@nathannicchitta1317]

My favorite in the line is L’Homme Ideal EDP because of that cherry!

[@anthonybartilucci4278]

L’homme Ideal EDP was the first version I ever got and has always remained my favorite.

[@janceedagreat]

L'HOMME IDEAL EXTREME - Awesome video as usual. Wishing the best!

[@samyyyyyyy]

L'Homme Ideal Cologne is my favorite 🔥 - For Science Thanks Ashton!! - I tried the OG Extreme 2 years back and I didn't like it 😂 the reform might have fixed it for me lol guess I'll need to try it again if I'm lucky 🤞

[@scott1311]

L'Homme Ideal EDT is the only one I’ve had so far and really liked it

[@thehaymaker3660]

Ideal EDF is my new favorite fragrance. Great for the office!

[@chi-towncalifornia5916]

The L’Homme ideal line is my absolute favorite line of sweeter, more gourmand fragrances, particularly because none of them are too sweet for my tastes. I have EDP, Cologne, and I’m looking into getting the original.

[@michaelbullock8011]

Great video and I enjoyed it and I'm going to try it and have a blessed day

[@w00tah1]

I love the original L'Homme Ideal EDT. So much so I bought the 5oz bottle. Cheers.

[@Marc-fragances]

I would love to try the L'homne ideal Extreme. I really Like the whole line. Thanks Ash . Another great video.

[@bradleygriffeth4403]

Never owned any of the line other than samples of the Extreme version. Really enjoy your videos and thanks for the giveaway Ashton.

[@robertpatterson3108]

I only own two Guerlain fragrances. Vetiver and Ideal Cologne. I enjoy both and would love to explore this house more.

[@s.a.smigiel3935]

Thanks for great video, my favourite so far is L'HOMME IDEAL L'INTENSE EDP EDITION.

[@Mfab6]

L’homme ideal EDP is my favorite so far but extreme and the EDT are up there.

[@ricardocasto]

My first guerlain and so far my favorite is ideal edp! I love the smell!

[@malika5435]

Never had this line in my collection. I would love to own EXTREME. I have been eyeing it for a long time. Very hard to find. Thanks for the video

[@smthreet21]

Glad you covered this! I have the new extreme and was shocked to get almost none of the tobacco talked about. It doesnt really project as well as the edp. Kinda rattled me when i first got it.

[@shawnmohamed6034]

Thanks Ash, another great video! I’m not familiar with the line but the Extreme sounds like my kind of jam.

[@hangtimedangjang]

L'Homme Ideal EDP is my fave. Got a backup on deck!

[@nickadamczyk3732]

Hi AshMy favourite from the line is the Extreme version. It’s sad that there are differences to the detriment of the new version.

[@dieselronald]

tough, I like them all, but I think the EDP and this extreme are probably the best. Keep up the great vids.

[@karthikkeyan7639]

Hard choice! the whole line is so classy but I love L'HOMME IDEAL EXTREME the most.

[@mune191]

Hi. My favourite is L'homme Ideal Cologne for sure! Would be interesting to see comparison of Guerlain Vetivers. Column bottle and new square bottle. Thanks, Ash, for such a great content. Reformulations comparing always are very interesting. 😊

[@woodstock480]

Guerlain is so fantastic. I have Vetiver and Heritage EDT, and have sampled Homme EDP, LIDGE, L'Instant de Guerlain EDT, Habit Rouge EDT, L'Homme Ideal EDT, EDP and Cologne. All are so, SO great.

[@johntran4228]

Guerlain L’homme Ideal EDP is my favorite. Thinking to pick up the Extreme

[@Jayrohh]

My favorite in the Lhomme Ideal line is the EDP! Such a banger of a fragrance.

[@steliospolitakis8416]

My favourite is LHomme ideal extreme. Thanks for the giveaway Ashton!

[@mikeboochie1]

Didn’t realize I wasn’t subscribed already. My bad! My favorite in the cologne. I’ve been rocking it a lot the past couple weeks. Honestly haven’t tried the extreme but think I’d really like it.

[@christopherneithardt]

My favorite, in this fantastic line, would be L’Homme Ideal L’intense. I have never owned extreme so it would be awesome to get. Appreciate the content Ash

[@jaredward2863]

Love them all from the EDT to L’Intense but the Extreme is probably the one I reach for the most

[@figplucker3052]

Still rockin' L'Homme Ideal EDT, can't wait to hear your take on the parfum

[@EllaMinnowPeaNess]

The Ideal line is my favorite line of any perfume line with Extreme being my very top pick. Would be awesome to get that bottle!