Guru Prakash - A Dalit Perspective On Caste

[@ashutoshsharmash]

Guru Prakash is so erudite and educated. Thank you so much to the Sham Sharma show for bringing him to the show.

[@girdharisinghgurjar1884]

Yes he is

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

He can never understand Ambedkarism even after another Ph. D.

[@pranjalsrivastav8870]

@@alekhkumbhar2040 Ambedkar's views on Islam will give u chills however i wud love to ask u Ambedkar's views on savarkar,Swami shraddhanand,Shivaji and also Savitri bai PHULE'S views on savarkar even JAGJIVAN Ram's views on Savarakar and Ever heard of Paramath Thakur?

[@statickk14]

@@alekhkumbhar2040 looks like you can’t

[@kuunaldeshmukh7752]

i had read the 'Who'll clean our toilets if dalits leave pakistan ' statement &I use this statement aggresively when justifying CAA than you Mr Guru prakash for confirming this..

[@prataproy3925]

Yes , same with Kashmiri pandits , they brought in Dalits to clean toilet never talk about their basic human rights but cried hoards when throwout of Kashmir

[@kunwar9667]

@@prataproy3925 it was ghulam Mohamed bakshi who brought them not Kp's ,learn their history from 47' to 90' before putting KPs in bad light

[@prataproy3925]

@@kunwar9667 whoever brought them in , y bramins never talk about their human rights y they never spoke about them🤔

[@prataproy3925]

@Goofy AM u dumbass fuck when I said that it s cast problem , use Google translator of u can t read proper english

[@prataproy3925]

@Yadnyesh I had full ympathy with Kashmiri Hindus I never saw them as pundits , but when i read a austrailion Kashmiri pundit s story then I realised they themselves r castist , supermacist bigots ,he wrote" we were the wealthiest community ,we always looked down upon Indians as inferior specially sought Indians coz of their skin . Kp s would Lways taunt s Kashmiri Muslims who talk about ) say anything go to Pakistan , the had so much superiority complex that when Kashmiri raja wanted to convert Muslims into hinduism ( Muslim themselves wanted to be convert) rajguru(kp) vehemently oopose it n whole KP rally behind him. They reap what they saw . They never ever cared about any other community , Jammu s Hindus were completely ignored , they never talked about Dalits who lived without state recognition . Go to kasmir u will no the reality the KP who r stated back in kasmir they r vehemently opposing repealing of art 370 only those who r living outside velly r supporting coz they knew they r not going to go back

[@RaviSankarRao1]

In my early 11th class days, my grandmother used to say how can you go to Dalit's house and have lunch or dinner with them. I explained her not to carry such differences further. Your generation did things which were not correct. We belong to a generation where we have grown up together in schools and colleges, studying, playing, eating together. We are correcting what your generation carried a false pride for yourselves being from higher caste.

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

The so called political leaders use to have lunch /dinners with dalits at their residence. We cannot say that they have given up the social practice. Untouchability is practiced in Bihar every where. The high castes look down upon the dalits. Educated dalits are despised by the high castes. The discussion is going on even if there is nothing called caste. It seems that both the persons have not even read the basic Ambedkarite literature. We know what is Ph.D. now a days especially in Bihar U.P. People are occupying high places but forgotten how they had gone there. This is the problem with them. They are the psychophant actually. The real hypocrisy is displayed by these type of people.

[@docno1117]

Very good! Keep it up!

[@GarudAtma]

You should also asked in which part of Hindu scriptures it is written Man made then over exerted PR

[@tusharrawat6670]

Hahaha what about enjoying thousand of years of education,money and opportunities through your generations and social structure and networking needed today in private sector it's all in the hands of REAL MINORITY of India, that's us the UC. Will need more reservation including private sector too.

[@katherinerachel8011]

This is like two friends discussing chilling after a long time discussing important issues. Man it's lots fun really hope for it's part 2

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

Both must undergo training for 5 years to understand the subject.

[@abhijitkurse53]

@@alekhkumbhar2040 Katherine isn't claiming that they understand it- she is simply pointing out how they are having a civil conversation, which most Indians don't seem to know how to do. You seem to be among those ranks as well. Civil conversations are the first step in the direction of progress, so it is no wonder India is still struggling... Also, I don't think any number of years of training would suffice in your eyes to understand the subject- an upper caste person like Sham Sharma would always be in the wrong to people like you, and Guru Prakash would also be guilty by association. It is a shame that so many Indians fail to give others the benefit of the doubt and respect unique, fresh, or nuanced viewpoints. I hope people like you change in the future and become kinder and willing to listen, rather than self-righteous, judgmental, and suspicious of others. Certainly, most Indians operate out of contempt, not compassion, which is not good for anyone in the long run.

[@jaibhimjaibharatjaisamvidh4739]

I am a Dalit Buddhist, but I don't support MIM neither do I like their ideology

[@saav757]

✌️❤️🙏

[@jaibhimjaibharatjaisamvidh4739]

@Debadeep Das 😁

[@जयचव्हाण-च3घ]

You mean neobuddhist

[@prathameshwankhade1458]

Godse murdabaad Babasaheb zindabaad

[@prathameshwankhade1458]

@Invest In Future BHAGAT SINGH AMBEDKAR AUR PHOOLE KO MANTE HAIN GODSE KO NAHI APKA PATA NAHI. JAI OBC JAI SAVIDHAN

[@maryadapurushottam331]

What an awesome conversation . Wish you boys can do this more often. It will heal many wrong ideas.

[@an1ketsharma]

Just two hindu bros chillin together.

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

But one is a slave who is expressing his joy of enjoing slavery. We may call him a fit slave.

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

@'` You have to study the language first for replying. Better reply in Hindi if you do not know English. People will otherwise laugh at you.

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

@'` I could not understand anything from your comment. You can refer it to any of your friend to confirm it. Everybody is not supposed to know everything. When this is the case you have to manage with other language I.e. the linguafranca. My intention is not to undermine you. When nobody understands from a particular thing then what to do. It was simply a suggestion. If it has just your sentiment I am sorry. But if you continue like this you may invite criticism which is not good. I especially do not like this as I respect everybody. It is upto you to decide.

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

@'` Are you asking about my caste? If the question is that then I am a person having no caste and also no religion. I am born in a Hindu family and I have given up the Hindu belief system and no more following it. Humanity is my religion.

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

@'` I do not remember. Please tell me the year and about the reason for the riot. Thereafter I can reply what you mean to say.

[@shashishekhar1316]

What a discussion Shambhav and Guru Prakash ji ! Kudos and congrats.

[@Abzxdwx]

Muslim use Dalits for propoganda.

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

Muslims never use dalits. Dalits can teach the Brahmins now.

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

Certainly we can teach RSS. We know to safeguard our interests . We cannot sit idle and allow 3% of people to enjoy everything. This is a democracy and Peswa rule. We have our constitution. The anchor does not understand anything about the subject. He is becoming oversmart without understanding the things.

[@happyman6178]

@@alekhkumbhar2040 stfu dumbass

[@nitish523]

Even Christians and Communist. Don't forget them.

[@nitish523]

@@alekhkumbhar2040 I can agree on this one. Muslims directly convert, the Christians will convert you with a method called Rice Christians and charity and Communist coz they have class and caste system.

[@vijayasriiyer1156]

I'm so glad to finally see a civil and insightful conversation happening on such an important topic

[@ankurgaikwad7252]

I wish there'd be a part 2. And mainly focus on criteria of determining "minority" communities in India. Bcoz currently, the 2nd most numerous majority is taking all the benefits of minorities.

[@GreenBatAman]

Man, this was a far fucking better discussion than OpIndia's Genesis of caste discussion they did such injustice with such good panelists among them. This was a much needed perspective. Thanks 😃

[@TzarD369]

Yea I saw that , it was all noise nothing substantial just fictional benign stories and imagination

[@GreenBatAman]

@@TzarD369 Without a single person from lower castes, they thought they can have a discussion on caste LMAO

[@ankurgaikwad7252]

I think that discussion was just to let some ppl vent out their thoughts, "think out loud". I think they should also bring Dalit IAS/UPSC aspirants to discuss about these issues. It'd give direct understanding on their life situation, as well as their own solutions.

[@shashankshrivastava791]

Great to see Guru Prakash sir on Sham Sharma show. Have known him since college days. He knows how to put his opinion across without digression. Would love to see an educated and smart person like him in the Parliament soon.

[@akashpawar5517]

Need more such conversation with guru and specially on your hindi channel where you have more followers from India and yes guru is a gem.

[@vanitayogi9957]

Very happy to see him on the show

[@swarnag6427]

This is the best conversation I have heard in your channel

[@tonystark7632]

I request you to bring J Sai Deepak Advocate of Supreme Court and have a conversation.

[@RakeshYadav-xz4kk]

Yes. J sai Deepak and Guru Prakash on the same discussion and both should come to some kind of solution through discussion so that we can be more clear on these issues.

[@darshantrivedi4355]

I doubt that Sai will come on this forum. Also majority of audience of sham sharma wouldn't get what Sai says.

[@hironmayisore4624]

Thank you for having this conversation. The only bad part is I was notonline during livestreaming.

[@ANUJSHARMA-zn5vt]

Very healthy discussion 🙏 helps change perceptions

[@krupashankaronjanaushadhis7722]

Key words summary: birth vs worth, disrespect for trades, dignity of labor ,respect for all vocations, dehumanizing jobs, reservation reform, integrationist vs violent approaches to reform, recognition of unspoken roles, exploitation of social fault lines by external forces, from focusing on problems to focusing on solutions, equality of opportunity, connections vs concessions. Halalonomics. jhatka meat ,industrialization of traditional trades leading to loss of jobs and relevance .

[@mayurpatil861]

Enjoyed the whole conversation 👍

[@harisharma4211]

This is the best program I have ever watched on this very important issues. Keep it up Sham Sharma and Guru Prakash.

[@ManojKumar-ii4yd]

Clean and transparent discussion! This is what will take humanity forward. Thank you for hosting this.

[@1097-t4m]

Please do part 2 with Guru Prakash ji. PLEASE!! Best episode in the history of your English channel

[@snair8448]

Looking forward to Jhatka products! Bring these to market ASAP. Proud of Guru Prakash and his work!

[@athmakur01]

Thank you Guru for the information and education you shared,.

[@Humanity901]

Lot of respect for guruprakashji and sham Sharmaji for a candid and beautiful discussion

[@nobody..8040]

Rubbish kumar promote castism more than others in India.. every time he asks people “kaun se jaat se ho??”

[@rahulpaswan8052]

Aranab guu swami

[@billybutcher6504]

I'm proud to be Buddhist. Indubiously, Buddhism is mere religion which provides Freedom, equality, liberty, and fraternity. I take refuge in Buddha. I take refuge in Dhamma. I take refuge in Sangha. JAI BHIM 💙💙💙 NAMO BUDDHAY 😊🙏

[@vatsalraval]

Budhha too believed in Birth Based Caste , but Caste System is problem of our civilization we have to edificate it from our country !

[@billybutcher6504]

@@vatsalraval U also one of the graduate of WhatsApp University.😂😂😂 Where it's written that Buddha followed castism???😂😂 Have u even read a single Buddhist book?😂 I have read several including most authentic tipitaka and pali canon. U castist people are so obsessed with cast that u people desperately wanted cast must need to get crept into other religions aswell. Buddhism has no cast, if u love cast then call urself hindu, u don't need to interfere in some completely other religion to spread fake news. If u Love to spread fake news than do it in ur religion and not mine coz we Buddhist are rational, so anyways we never gonna get convinced with ur sheer spurious narrative in regard with Buddhism. JAI BHIM 💙💙💙 NAMO BUDDHAY 😊🙏

[@akmjsr01]

Thanks for doing this

[@jonik2121]

We had a muslim maid whose son my mother gave free tuitions on weekends... She was very grateful for his improved scores...hence every EID she gave us home made sweets...I was 14 years old wouldn't eat it...just because she lived in a hut n ate meat ..I wasn't mean to her but wouldn't eat...My grandfather saw that n he said firstly this is FOOD ....secondly it is made with LOVE...never disrespect Both are special things in life... Again it was a lesson wel learnt Coming from A 70 year old... So proud of my old fellow

[@jonik2121]

@ 😔 No...he passed away in 2008..miss him n our debates on every topic under the sun..but his legacy lives on

[@prasadpopuri9019]

Nationalism is above religion. We love Verghese Kurian, Homi J Bhba and Vikram Sarabhai. They made India strong and scientific. Dr. Ambedkar was an intellectual giant and made India strong. He rightly fought against caste discrimination. Caste was worst form of discrimination. India was invaded by every Tom,Dick and Harry due to caste divisions. Now Indian army has every caste and every religion. Army is a true Indian institution. As long as Indian army is there no evil country can do any thing. Already Indian army has called Chinese bluff. My pranaams to 20 heroes who sacrificed their lives for our tomorrow.

[@Sameer-yq3ke]

I agree caste issues are real but are the current castes have any meaning? Consider if the world move on over leather work and now no leather work happen, what will be the identity of the castes realated to this work. I think the current castes are obsolete.

[@chahatsagar7299]

Caste system is already in ICU. The politicians want to keep it alive at any cost.

[@Sameer-yq3ke]

@Vidhya Dhara class system is based of economic standards

[@shibanighose8694]

Guru was great as always

[@sasdasbd]

Very Good Shaam. I was thinking of making effort to reach out to Dalit youths to counter this Hinduphobic narratives.

[@prathameshwankhade1458]

Waah re waah jo log savidhan Jalaya tha ab naya drama kar rahe hain.

[@prathameshwankhade1458]

@Saurabh Adhikari BRAMIN LOG HAIN SAVIDHAN JALAANE WALE. UNKO FANSI KAB HOGI?

[@abhijeetdolai5820]

West Bengal, once the richest state in India and then communists happened

[@YenkammaNe]

British DISTORTED Hindu history, Hindu literature, scriptures....to destroy Hindu civilsation. www.hindustantimes.com/kolkata/indian-history-was-distorted-by-the-british/story-0XmF9oSZpLPrFMcdwQdsOP.html The Mahabharata defined ethnic groups as jatis, whereas the British brought in the term tribes to describe the same thing, thus denigrating the homogenous culture of India. Jatis were defined on ecological terms. There is a popular perception that casteism started in India since the Vedas but that is not true. There was no casteism even during the Mahabharata period,” he said. Danino also rued the fact that Indians are apathetic towards the preservation of their rich culture and heritage. “1170 sites of the ancient Harappan civilization have been identified during its mature phase. But till date only around 100 sites have been excavated. There is a fear that 90% of the sites might disappear due to expansion of urban areas or agricultural land being converted to residential high rises,” Danino said.

[@funnykarty2107]

Wow Brahmin & dalit are talking together 🤟🤟😘😘

[@funnykarty2107]

@Shailesh Bahuguna 😅😅 kuch nhi bhai jay shri ram 🙏🏻 🚩

[@ashutoshsharmash]

Our country's PM, President and Speaker of the House are from the traditional lower castes. We eliminated caste from our system, but not our thoughts. It's time we do. Jai Shri Ram.

[@devkumardenray2439]

No brahmin no dalit only hindu

[@anitav7799]

It's not even anything to mention. I'm from a brahmin family and one of our best family friends are dalit. We have been close for decades. We've never even thought about it let alone talk about it. Neither of us cares.

[@chars_78]

And? Hai toh sab Hindu hi naa

[@jonik2121]

My grandma from kokan in maharashtra...as a kid used to bathe if she crossed a lower caste person...her mother ( my great grandmother) noticed this n asked her what she was upto..then my grandma confessed...then her mother said that the only thing that can make u Unclean are....such negative thoughts..n all are made by God...so dont discriminate... I m so proud that it came from an elder n earlier generation. .my grandma moved to Mumbai at 18 after marriage...she was loved by many..helped so many ppl with whatever she could..without discrimination...It was a lesson well taught n recieved

[@baibhavanand528]

Keep it up bro.We need more people like you both.

[@nobody..8040]

This is time to follow the way showed by BabaSaheb Ambedkar...

[@N0m0re_abnormal]

This one is my favourite podcast on Shyam's show. Thanks 👍

[@ravikantshah2010]

Guru ji you u r incredible, very delighted to know your perspective about very reverent issues of our society. Sir I will like u hear you on various platforms. Thanks sham for bringing such scholar to show.

[@krupashankaronjanaushadhis7722]

i respect this man. he can gives a perspective in a way we would be unable to figure out on our own,

[@vipulkumar5399]

love for guru sir

[@shashishekhar1316]

So enlightening

[@ajayydv]

Glad to see Guru, hope many more Guru's from dalit community join him being thought leaders for India and society at large.

[@jaym_108]

Very good point on the dignity of labor. This is a very key thing that keeps Indian society from progressing. There needs to be a social effort with a push from the top leadership at various levels to instill a sense of dignity for labor - people who make our day to day life easy and predictable.

[@ankurgaikwad7252]

Top leadership won't do anything. Parents should themselves teach at young age about respecting people's work.

[@jcd776]

22:24 **The author of Caste As Social Capital is Prof R Vaidyanathan, who has regularly been appearing in many podcasts over the past 3 years, especially on PGurus KZbin channel.

[@amanjha7157]

Thank you sham for biharis voice ♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@sandeepdixit5597]

45:30 most Indians, Dalit or not, do not have uncle, aunt, father working at plum places. A son of a Dalit IAS officer or minister is more privileged than most Indians. Many of the examples given by Mr. Paswan are a bit extreme. He does not look at, How Dalit community politics has been using abusive language. (तिलक तराजू और तलवार इनके मारो जूते चार and what not ). That's language is widespread even now. It should also be noted How brahmins voted for Mayavati, despite this abusive language. You see How Dalits insult religious icons. Why everyone ignores these incidents? it is because society wants to include them. Society is opening arms and Dalit politics is becoming arrogant. Having said all this, I get his point though, family experience makes a difference in today's India. If we invest a lot in education we may reduce this difference for everyone.

[@Pu-nishant]

good debate'

[@vijayprathap]

I completely sympathize with people who are undergoing caste discrimination. But I have the opinion that benefits of reservation should be to the most vulnerable sections of the population.

[@prataproy3925]

Who r u to decide for them , let them decide , isn't it enough that we have been decided for them for the last 2500 years .

[@vijayprathap]

@@prataproy3925 I am in no position of power to decide for anybody. I have every right to voice my opinion and who are you to question me if I can say something or not!?

[@alpeshmittal3779]

Mostly these opinions come out of jealousy and nothing else. Ever seen any guy worried about quality of education in Private colleges? 10 % diya to chupchap le liya. Us waqt reservation bheekh nahi lagti.

[@prataproy3925]

@@vijayprathap so do I .

[@suryapratap2852]

Reservation is for representation it's not poverty elevation program.

[@sridarannambiar709]

It is great to know that the caste system is something of the past. Swami Ramdev is a great example who stood against the caste system.

[@akshajpurandare3067]

Not at all. If you listened you would realise how real caste system is in india.

[@sourabhbilgaiya9058]

Nice to hear guru prakash

[@bhaskarpaladugu5897]

Guru Prakash's analogy of "When you are ready to accept your fore fathers property, why are you not accepting their mistakes" is not a solid argument, there are many instances of someone born in so called upper caste but had been dirt poor to start with and was discriminated against by the system. The point should be : "As a whole society we have to take responsible actions to correct the mistakes done by our predecessors." Personal caste based preferences will continue to exist for many generations to come. Even in SC/ST category a person from one caste won't usually marry a person from other caste. The goal should be to provide social and economical (and political) opportunities to everyone irrespective of their caste. So long Indian political and social system focus on giving socialistic subsidies based on caste instead of growth options, different castes will always fight for a share. It is a never ending vicious cycle.

[@mukulpal8875]

Bhagavad Gita: Chapter 4, Verse 13 चातुर्वर्ण्यं मया सृष्टं गुणकर्मविभागश: | तस्य कर्तारमपि मां विद्ध्यकर्तारमव्ययम् || 13|| chātur-varṇyaṁ mayā sṛiṣhṭaṁ guṇa-karma-vibhāgaśhaḥ tasya kartāram api māṁ viddhyakartāram avyayam chātuḥ-varṇyam-the four categories of occupations; mayā-by me; sṛiṣhṭam-were created; guṇa-of quality; karma-and activities; vibhāgaśhaḥ-according to divisions; tasya-of that; kartāram-the creator; api-although; mām-me; viddhi-know; akartāram-non-doer; avyayam-unchangeable Translation BG 4.13: The four categories of occupations were created by Me according to people’s qualities and activities. Although I am the Creator of this system, know Me to be the Non-doer and Eternal.

[@Nikhil-ty3rk]

22:30 that book is written by Prof R Vaidyanathan, or Prof RV. Not Jaggi.

[@Amitparashar14]

Guru Prakash is an intelligent man..

[@omshanti910]

Great Respect for Guru ji...We need people like u...we are one & no castism should be ..

[@royalkumar795]

Bro, people is already moved to caste system, some people do intercaste marriage .. Hindu is not only religion who have caste system. Just like another religion community Like Catholic and Protestant, Shia and Sunni , hiina and mahaayaan Why don't Media and some leftist address these caste issue from another religion.. In these days, caste system is nothing just Fush who people use This to make own stupid agenda

[@Sanatani7727]

Castism still exist. I have seen it. And we have to focus on our self bhai

[@1097-t4m]

I'm sorry but stfu with your surface understanding lol

[@ankysid8022]

@@Sanatani7727 That's the spirit .We need to get the F away from Virtue signalling ans work hard for real changes. do you have any suggestions that we as a community can work on from ground up in real scenario ?

[@ankysid8022]

@Kung Fu Money Bee 1.Yup , that's a problem . But we'll have to realise that the absolute power lies in the economy and better living standards .. That can only be possible if we can criticise our own and be the best of ourselves . In a broader sense ,we can only push our Dharmic principles if it resonates with the "betterment" of society and we are far from it. Remember , People respect culture ,not because what it works in theory ,but in the way it's implemented and the real world impacts the community has once it interact with others. Remembering that we aren't perfect ,so we need to push for it. 2 .Yes,But again We need to find a better and faster way of uplifting the poors and taking up hardworking people whichever class they come from. We need to ensure basic minimum. 3.Yes , we'll need to respecting someone's position and think logically to arrive at solution instead of shutting them up.

[@dharmavarta]

@@1097-t4m He is right .. there is no caste system , but politically driven casteism. By default , we don't have a rigid societal rules , but a dynamic one. We dont have a quran or a bible to follow blindly. 🙏🙏

[@girdharisinghgurjar1884]

Some ppl use dalit as propoganda

[@girdharisinghgurjar1884]

@``. Bhakt is good in hindu dharma , what about chamcha and gulam 😂 .... Stop gulami yar 😂🤣

[@girdharisinghgurjar1884]

@``. ok !!! But Stop jihad 🤣🤣

[@girdharisinghgurjar1884]

@``. Catvas fail in doing this ....😂🤣🤣. But siya vs sunny prevailing

[@girdharisinghgurjar1884]

@``. ho !!! Jihadi 😂 I got

[@linaraay]

I had few bihari friends who were highly educated. I got surprised when I saw them believing n practising caste discrimination. I used to think only village people do.

[@prad949]

ব্রাক্ষণ আচণ্ডাল কুক্কুরান্ত করি। দণ্ডবৎ করিবে বহু মান্য করি। Sri Chaitanya Dev said this but where is it's application? One has to respect all from Brahmans to Chandal even the dogs. Unless it is done one is not doing his dharma. Hindus are sinner when they disrespect Dalits.

[@hironmayisore4624]

The 4 Varna system is based on quality or Guna accordingaccording to Slok number 13 , Chapter 4 of the Bhagwat Geeta.

[@prataproy3925]

OK , then how come bramin got janew ceremony at the age 9f seven , is there any way to decide guns of a 7 year old😐

[@VSM101]

@@prataproy3925Manusmrity written in the 5th centry distorted based on Jatti

[@VSM101]

@@prataproy3925 second births ceremonies are based off the education in your Gurukul not on your brith Varana is associated with teenagers becoming adults since all start out as servants.FYI

[@ankurgaikwad7252]

It wasn't mentioned to be hereditary if I remember it rightly.

[@ankurgaikwad7252]

@@prataproy3925 Jyotish can be used for it.

[@Sunny-rh6ik]

Important discussion 👍

[@adithyamanoharravi3451]

people please know caste is not varna. It is not the right word. varna is just a division of labour. Varna is not defined by birth. if you want to know more about this please also know the views of Dr. Subramanyam swami

[@krupashankaronjanaushadhis7722]

equality of opportunity is a central concept

[@MrRk540]

Excellent Show Sham!!! Keep it up.... For the first time I have heard someone that holds views as I do!! Way to go Guru Prakash.... good will se kuch nahi hoga!!! I am a Brahmin that hails from Bengaluru. Most of my friends group is Brahmin!!! There are very few that are not..... It is such a echo chamber it is not even funny. The ones that are not Brahmin's are usually other upper caste folk.... IT makes me wonder ... It should be a result casteist descrimination. There is nothing else that explains it.... If the problem is solved... there is not need to exist!!! so it is an existential crisis for the left!!! The indian Left... Kanaka Daasa!!! anyone? Buddhism is the second in the series of Ideas... Jainism being the First Matha!!! So Athiestic sects were the first ones and the most successful ones in India... till Shankara Came and subsumed the other two!!!! Let us not forget that... The end... AWESOME... Indeed right, Valmiki and Vyasa were both Dalits....

[@poojlove2021]

There is something wrong with this video. I can’t offline it and i have to keep restarting it to play it. It stops every five minutes or so.

[@hironmayisore4624]

Sorry, I was offline during the livestreaming.

[@sontuudaybhasker5187]

Even during Jahangeer"s reign Jijya for Brahmins were paid by others and stopped them from dieing ....Foreign Historian books till 1650 can help us understand that the cast is not what India practised....

[@subratachowdhury4601]

A very good discussion indeed....

[@thegreatestdemon1288]

At 1:05:50, tina dhabi belonged to rich family, her mother is a ies officer & her father is a doctor

[@rohansingh8444]

guru Prakash changed my perception of reservation completely🙂

[@GreenBatAman]

@Ganga Din Reservation college jane pe khatm ho jata uske baad apne merit pe hi pass hona paadta h agar kaabil nhi ho to lode lagenge college me 😂

[@GreenBatAman]

@Ganga Din Ha to ab surname dekh ke karwa lena aap ilaaj kon rok rha h aapko?

[@GreenBatAman]

@Ganga Din Valid point. What's the alternative then?

[@rohansingh8444]

@Ganga Din I think that reservation definitely require reforms in what form it is being practiced for now, but what is imp is the principle of helping those who have been exploited ofcourse it can be made in a more efficient way although govt jobs only constitute 3% of total jobs in the country

[@harikris5]

VeRy good talk👏

[@pradeepshetty641]

There should get reservation in certain sectors like education politics business but not in medical sector i dont was a reserve category guy operating on me.

[@sumukhhegde6677]

Very true...

[@ankurgaikwad7252]

You mean to say that you don't want a surgeon who got into college due to low cutoff and employed at hospital on quota?

[@suvedi5334]

Shudras(I would not use the D word)are more Hindu than the Brahmans. Brahmans only preach, it’s the other castes who practice. And you see most of the so called leftists are actually upper-caste people. I as a Vedik would embrace a wise Shudra over any number of Brahmans that are hypocrites. There is nothing in Brahmacharya that promotes hatred for any other caste or even any other life in general. But off course discrimination have been a living reality for sure unfortunately. We’ll have to unite as one and fight it together. Those who want to keep us divided will never want the caste system to end, if you know what I mean. That’s the hidden truth.

[@namboodiries9069]

Looking down on others and feeling bad by various people can be gradually reduced by economic development over all and particular. The govt can bring two legislations 1.50%resrvation across the board including private enterprises including schools. 2.No registered or legitimate association of any kind will have more than forty-five percent of members belonging to the same cast denomination (major)

[@newsprint323]

In our northeast there is no such issue of cast, dowry, and all we never face such rumour also. By my name can anyone please tell me what is my cast

[@vishalsinghbaghel]

We should use caste neutral surname. My caste is Baghel I use Singh as surname

[@katherinerachel8011]

Bas karo ye virtue signalling

[@Mira-gu6we]

@@katherinerachel8011 wtf??

[@dewendrapratapsingh2803]

Look before 10th century you won't find any surname.

[@ankysid8022]

@@Mira-gu6we It's about finding real solutions to problems .Do you have any real solutions in terms of development we can do as a betterment of community from ground up?

[@ankysid8022]

@Ganga Din pardon me .I haven't seen the full video . I guess , I'm missing some context..Can you please explain.

[@PhotonShower]

caste will always be there.. legally speaking im from a higher caste..but i dont know why.. all i know is that when i go for admission or govt jobs i am pushed back because by 10 generations ago we were rich.. will the so called low caste people give away they freebies..no.. actually i know many so called high castes who live in poverty.. as long as politics is there there will be freebies for the low caste not the poor.. that is why we fly off from india.. when will this stop? when will there be equality?.. right now with all this opression i will proudly say i am from a higher caste.. because thats all i have..

[@prataproy3925]

Bhai , 10 percent to tumko bhi mil gaya . Ab aur Kitna beekh chahiye

[@PhotonShower]

@@prataproy3925 when they get its cakked reservation when we get its called begging? that too is under scrutiny..

[@prataproy3925]

@@PhotonShower yes it s called begging . They had everyright to get freebies if u don t like fuckoff I am also so called uppercast but I am not ignorant . Most of the time when I saw a uppercast cribbing about reservation deep down inside they knew that they r Tring to hide their incompetence .

[@PhotonShower]

@@prataproy3925 oh is it so? wow.. go fuck yourself..

[@Avtar_0]

I am a brahmin and my whole village is of brahmins who are very very poor , i mean bpl and they have no reservation.

[@sushantverma3558]

I have a village which in which there is brahmin community they are more educated than us but they still do caste discrimination🙄

[@ViveekChaudhaary]

ब्राह्मण वादी आतंकवाद बन्द कर

[@eatsleepmotivatedworkrepea609]

@@ViveekChaudhaary are bhai ye sb chtiyap bnd kro. Yha Koi attankwad ni h

[@eatsleepmotivatedworkrepea609]

@@sushantverma3558 I'm from a low caste but I'll still support equality over this caste status. If he is brahmn it doesn't mean he's rich and criticises lower caste. After being ruled for hundreds of year our mind has only left with negative things. Let's forgive them and head a step toward equality

[@sushantverma3558]

@@eatsleepmotivatedworkrepea609 I am alwayse ready for equality i just do not more dalits to be killed only because of caste. If this stops reservation will automatically vanish And at that time their will be no dalits who will ask for reservation But do you know their also exist a caste based reservation in courts where lawyers are made judges because they belong to upper caste. And there are many more . Bring equalty there also

[@सत्यमेवजयते-य1ब]

Kya Aisa Ho Jaaye ki sirname hi hata Diya jaaye, Sirf nam hi rakha jaaye. Jatisuchak Shabd sath nahi rahega to Har koi unity feel kar sakega 🚩💪

[@uttamkumardas769]

In U.P. & in Bihar, dalit can't purchase or sale land to general cast and general cast can't purchase or sale land to dalit by law, what kind of Law is implemented in secular country?

[@vatsalraval]

Some times it helps live here in Gujarat there is very special law that no one can buy land of Aadivasis expect Aadivasi , bcz it saves their land , people destroy them by fraud ! Sometimes it is needed ....

[@pawan50]

गुरु बहुत अच्छा

[@gauravsingh3827]

Education and financial upliftment only can n will reduce the gap.

[@ahamasmiarinm]

From what I have seen and experienced, this caste system, community grouping, it has less to do with economy and social status and has more to do with social security, general lack of law and order enforcement and complete distrust over institutions. The day people won't feel the need to associate and identify themselves with a caste or a community to feel secure about their life and livelihood, caste system would die a natural death. However, till then, whatever glorified ideas might be put forward to counter the caste system, as per me, nothing effective would happen on ground. A food for thought, "untouchability" is an accepted evil and it's been almost done with and I'm as happy about it as I have ever been. However, talking with context, the "untouchables" were people who mostly used to do menial and "dirty" jobs like sewage handling and other such things. So, was it too "harsh" on them if they were not allowed to mix with general public, given the medical and health infrastructure of those days? And those who say that yes, it was still very harsh on them, I would simply ask them, what are we doing today with covid? Much like those "untouchables" who were prone to get various infections due to their work and could spread the infections in general public, even in this age of advanced medicine and health-care, our most potent weapon till date against covid has been to "treat" the patients as "untouchables", isn't it? Isolation and quarantine are the only two weapons to stop the spread, isn't it? anyone disagreeing? The point I'm trying to make, people often go on talking about things without having even the slightest of ideas of what they are talking about. Oh, ok, I missed the other question with which I always get those people trying to inflict a guilt feeling on the Hindus, I simply ask, considering the then existing medical and health infrastructure, please propose an implementable solution other than what existed? and I'm yet to hear one. Bottom-line, many things in our society existed because it might have been the need of the hour. Living in this age, to say something of the past as nasty and obnoxious is simply talking without any knowledge. Like my example, "untouchability" isn't for this age but back then, it might have saved thousands of lives, no one can prove it but no one can disprove it either, not to mention that we are kind of following it in the current pandemic as well.

[@ravindersharma6620]

NO to Casteism.Believe in Unity.

[@sonjoy8301]

Jia Ho Bihar Ki Lala

[@abhayagarwal2589]

We can ensure equal opportunity but how to ensure equal outcome.

[@hironmayisore4624]

Cast system of India is already internationalised by left , antinational Communist mindset people. I have also faced racist comments once . I don't want beat that person , I just want that person realise his mistakes ,& do something​ to positive to erase that misdeed or misdeeds before me typing this comment. Only then I will count the apology as real & accept the apology .

[@alekhkumbhar2040]

He is saying that caste discrimination does not exist. Another century will pass , but we cannot expect the Bramhins to treat the dalits at par.

[@bhaskarpaladugu5897]

Brahmin and Kshtriya caste people (Like Sham Sharma) from North don't understand there are castes in southern India who are 'Shudra' as per caste system but are considered OC. They are beaten from both sides.

[@umasarat2983]

Prejudice is a human need for oneself to see better than the other and they make the divide of the 'other' in one way or the other, be it cast, colour, north, south, east,west, religion, language or the food one eats! Just to name a few!!! Reservation has to change to financial disadvantage position, structural disadvantage and disability. Generational support is baseless!

[@rahulpaswan8052]

RSS idealogy dalit. This professor not take about discrimination present day in goverment job and cancle scholarships. I think guru prakesh paswan take a safest ways to raya shabha😉. And make his safest future like ram nath kovind. Paphet president

[@sumantgautam7074]

Sham sharma bhi patniya hei maloom.nh tha.. 😊

[@asadkamal4329]

Bhim rao ambedkar called gandhi enemy of the dalits because of the poona pact

[@61.pranamyajoshi23]

Please make a video on India's new 5+3+3+4 pattern

[@hariompathak5784]

❤️❤️

[@indirasharma7199]

That thela ghatna was of jharkhand

[@sontuudaybhasker5187]

Grand father's property has not been passed to me in toto and today its owned by some one else... Hope cast is read in the light of The beautiful tree... The Case For India... and the Niyogi reprort in the light of British Population census discussions....