Hamza Yusuf - Weak Hadith in Ihya Ulumuddin

Hamza Yusuf - Weak Hadith in Ihya Ulumuddin

[@HamzaTheHistorian]

Why do I gotta keep explaining this over and over again to people!? haha, Allah musta'an.

[@tuanjohatuanyusof9257]

Nice

[@lightandreality]

MashAllah knowledge and wisdom, which is lacking todays muslims.

[@QuranSprouts]

If a hadith is weak or fabricated, doesnt that mean that you're learning lies against the prophet?

[@erayseyma]

JazaakAllah

[@faresasfary]

3:20

[@dinbachok6424]

How can a book by a man be compared to the Al Quran? Isn't that blasphemous?

[@shzammpatapon9865]

yes, this place here are hardcore true sufi. if you ever heard someone said that a man creation is the same as quran. they are kafiir

[@kacapiring7415]

It was said by one of the greatest Shafi'i Scholar Imam An-Nawawi. The author of Riyadus Salihin, and many other great books. He never said that he was comparing Ihya with the Quran. Read it carefully.

[@kacapiring7415]

@@shzammpatapon9865 Takfiri guy gonna get the Kafir back on you!

[@farsii5455]

Yes it is blasphemous. But who did such a thing in this video? Nobody has ever said that about the ihya

[@Maturidi333]

Mashallah!

[@MrRINTINTIN261]

great lecture

[@Emsyaz]

Poor methodology. If you base your Islamic knowledge on weak and fabricated hadith, that means the knowledge that you acquired is incorrect

[@harunbilin1768]

Al-Dhahabi narrated in his book Siyar A’laam al-Nubala’ that Muhammad ibn al-Waleed al-Tartooshi said in a letter which he sent to Ibn Muzaffar: As for what you mentioned about Abu Haamid, I have seen him and spoken to him, and I think that he is a man of great knowledge, he is intelligent and capable, and has been studying all of his life, spending most of his time in study, but then he drifted away from the path of the scholars and entered the crowd of worshippers. Then he became a Sufi and forsook knowledge and its people, then he got involved with “inspiration”, those who claim to have spiritual knowledge, and the insinuating whispers of the Shaytaan. Then he mixed that with the views of the philosophers and the symbolic phrases of al-Hallaaj, and he started to criticize the fuqaha’ and the scholars of ‘ilm al-kalaam. He almost went astray from the religion altogether. When he wrote al-Ihya’ [i.e., Ihya’ ‘Uloom al-Deen], he started to speak of the inspiration and symbolic words of the Sufis, although he was not qualified to do that and had no deep knowledge of such matters. Hence he failed, and filled his book with fabricated reports. I (al-Dhahabi) say: as for al-Ihya’, it contains many false ahaadeeth, and it contains much that is good. I wish that it did not contain etiquette, rituals and asceticism that are in accordance with the ways of the philosophers and deviant Sufis. We ask Allaah for beneficial knowledge. Do you know what is beneficial knowledge? It is that which Allaah revealed in the Qur’aan, which was explained by the Messenger (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) in word and deed, and the type of knowledge which we are not forbidden to acquire. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “Whoever turns away from my Sunnah does not belong to me.” So, my brother, you must ponder the words of Allaah and persist in studying al-Saheehayn, Sunan al-Nasaa’i, Riyaadh al-Nawawi and al-Adhkaar by al-Nawawi, then you will succeed and prosper. Islamqa: islamqa.info/en/answers/13473/who-was-al-ghazzaali

[@hendrimahrudi2509]

Terjemahkan