Har Charan Saran (Rababi composition) | Bhai Kirpal Singh Panesar | SOAS Film Launch Pt. 1

[@rajkumarsaluja4203]

I don't have the words to write in the praise of this kirtan. Only feels 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@rajkumarsaluja4203]

निहाल, निहाल, निहाल और सिर्फ निहाल, बहुत बहुत ही निहाल 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@clizzoud9819]

Very Good. Respect to the Sikhs who keep this style of Kirtan alive!

[@InderjitSingh-mu5co]

DHAN DHAN JAGAT GURU GURU NANAK SAHAB JI MAHARAJ❤❤ 🙏 ❤❤

[@surjlyall1]

It's absolutely amazing.🙏🏻❤️👌👍

[@Preetisachdeva-z7q]

Dhan satguru Jagjit singh ji ❤

[@SantokhBains-c4x]

Wha keya baat hay He is absolutely blessed it's the result of keen interest and hard work no doubt remarkable remarkable remarkable

[@Preetisachdeva-z7q]

Dhan guru Nanak dev ji❤

[@jsinghaytan6968]

🎉

[@SantokhBains-c4x]

Totally amazing

[@jashonsingh]

The one and only Kirpal Singh Panesar! Amazing.

[@manmohansingh2473]

It is great honour to the great soul named Mardana if we keep intact the title Bhaee given to him by our fore father who were more close to the time of those souls than we who are in the era of west dominated culture the first and foremost companion of Guru Nanak, latter the title Bhaee was given to Bhaee Gurdas the soul who wrote the very first copy of Guru Granth Sahib in the supervision of Guru Arjan.

[@SantokhBains-c4x]

Certainly very well said thanks

[@karandeepsingh2311]

how can i watch the short film?

[@KirtanAnmolRatan]

Also out of curiosity, could you please elaborate on what defines an old composition “rababi” ? then what is the tag for other puratan compositions? Does rababi composition indicates only sung by or in the repertoire of rababis and no one else ?

[@AvneepSinghBrar]

Rababi composition are those which are sung traditionally from the time of Guru Arjan dev ji especially by the darbari Rababi’s in Guru Arjan dev ji ‘s darbar many of most of compositions are mainly dhrupad style mainly created or carried from their heritage of their respected elders And it’s a common practice that the coming generations also who have become the masters create new compositions [like the dhuni’s are inspired by bhai taba ji’ s. Video recording But were also sung at times of fifth guru so actually telling that where and from which time the composition have come from is difficult but Important is to present or preserve the composition and represent it to the new generation which is very well done by The namdhari’s ] thank you A.S Brar

[@KirtanAnmolRatan]

Your first paragraph assumes quite a lot. Claiming that this repertoire was created and sung exclusively by Rababis is a narrow perspective on Gurbani Sangeet. Unless you can cite specific elders or sources, this assumption overlooks the significant contributions of other streams of ragis and Gursikhs who sang alongside Rababis and learned directly from the Guru Sahibs. I encourage you to explore the broader and richer tradition of Gurbani Sangeet. If you’re interested, I’ve included some reading material in the bio for further context.

[@AvneepSinghBrar]

@@KirtanAnmolRatan what do you even want to say , i think you are confused yourself first sit alone for some time and think about what you want to say and then question yourself about it. And then ask clearly what you want to ask for ..

[@KirtanAnmolRatan]

@@AvneepSinghBrar 🙏🏼

[@AvneepSinghBrar]

@@KirtanAnmolRatan About you just said The Gursikh the ragis (likewise them the rababis were also staying with the sikh guru’s and also learned with them alongside keeping their own composition’s ). Like example of Bhai Mardana ji Who accompanied Guru Nanak Dev ji but why is that he was chosen. Because bhai mardana knew Musical instrument already (the rubab) and was a master of it and the music subject itself but was humble indeed why guru Nanak ji took him as his company. And throughout the travel he must have had learnt many things from Guru Nanak dev ji including music and knowledge about the (creation) . But here is an interesting thing “Is it that Guru Nanak dev ji had created any new raga ?” Yes because he was a Master like no one in the world and never will someone be as great as him but it’s is a simple logic. “ that Guru Nanak ji also used the old ragas we know from the vedas but created many of marvellous composition in them . Apologies for Any mistakes

[@yoursamrit2000]

What does he sing after dandaut in the beginning... Can anyone please tell me.

[@kuldeepsingh2358]

The Namdhari Sikhs have their own guruship line which is still running. That's why he's reciting as twelfth Gobind. They kind of don't have faith in the Guruship as established by Sh Guru Gobind Singh Ji.

[@randeepsingh6382]

a bunch of bollocks that has no meaning except to the namdhari cult they've twisted the original meaning of the dwadas guru which guru gobind singh used to refer to satguru granth sahib as instead they call these random men who have no lineage to the real satgurus the 11th and 12th guru

[@clizzoud9819]

@@randeepsingh6382 Let’s not fight with these brothers. They are part of the larger Sikh Community and should be welcomed, not ostracized. Maybe one day they will realize the command of Sri Guru Kalgidarh Maharaj. I do not believe that the Namdhari Leaders are a legitimate continuation of the Gurgaddi, as we are all well aware that the Gurgaddi was given to the Shri Guru Granth Sahib and to the Khalsa. Despite this, the Namdhari Leaders are learned, and spiritual men. Their cause has historically made great sacrifices for the Sikh Community. They were an integral part in fighting against British Imperialism.

[@jassimarsingh6505]

@@kuldeepsingh2358 its from gorindnama

[@AssaSingh]

Hi it's from the Sri Gorindnama which like the Karninama was composed by Guru Gobind Singh Ji, you can find it quiet easily.

[@KirtanAnmolRatan]

Does “Rababi composition” tag and “attributed to Bhai taba” is meant to imply that this is Bhai Taba’s own composition? Because other ragis in the past have sung this composition too *CORRECTION: sorry to Mardana Project, I missed the part where Kirpal Singh states this was composed by Bhai Taba. So this comment would be relayed to him.

[@sroysingh]

it means that the composition was created and popularised by Bhai Taba Ji, but it is still sung by other ragis and are in gurmat sangeet books such as gurmat sangeet sagar

[@KirtanAnmolRatan]

@@sroysinghwhat is the source of this being Bhai Taba composition. It’s an old composition which was sung by other ragis (not rababi stream as well). Bhai Avtar Singh and Bhai Gurcharan Singh have sung this too and their first two antra’s are slightly different rest same composition.

[@sroysingh]

@KirtanAnmolRatan tbh I don't know fully. bhai manbir singh australia who runs gsv has also said it is bhai taba composition

[@KirtanAnmolRatan]

@ i recommend you ask them directly for their source of information about this and maybe other claims.

[@griffin512]

A namdhari ustaad suggested to me that it was actually just the famous bhimpalasi khayal bandish, Ja ja re apane mandirwa. If you listen to both they do sound very similar so maybe that’s where Bhai Taba got the “idea” from for this bandish 🤷🏽‍♂️

[@sukhmansinghsukh2299]

Bhai saab ji kol kehra saaj hai

[@PURATANGURBANIKIRTAN]

Taar shehnai

[@jaswinderahluwalia]

Listen to Bhai Gurmeet Singh Shaant 's rendition of Har Charan Saran Gobind Dukh Bhanjna. To my mind a far better piece.

[@ravtejsingh4402]

Bhai gurmeet singh shants rendition is a padtaal composition he created himself. Whereas, this is a padtaal composition that has been in circulation since olden times. I suggest you maybe also check out bhai taba, the legend himself singing this composition

[@jassimarsingh6505]

This is much older composition btw

[@ravtejsingh4402]

@@jassimarsingh6505 yes the one kirpal singh is singing is of olden times

[@Osingh325]

@KirtanAnmolRatan Could you just shut up and actually try to enjoy someone else’s kirtan instead of always nitpicking? You’ve gotten to such a level of arrogance that it seems you can’t even connect to the Shabad unless kirtan is done a specific way….that defeats the whole purpose of kirtan. Kirtan is fist and foremost bhagti (devotional worship) Please let it remain that way 🙏🏼

[@DavBhandal]

If you are not giving credit to Bhai Baldeep Singh or his family, then it is said you are doing kirtan wrong only. This Kirtan Anmol Ratan has become like a cult, and Baldeep Singh is the leader. If credit is not going to him, their social media will surely insult and humiliate you.

[@Osingh325]

@ EXACTLY!! They have become so blind in their arrogance !!

[@sahibnoorsingh2940]

@@DavBhandalbecause they are the reasons the parampara is surviving otherwise the amount of the ignorance that has been shown in these comments not accepting what reality is would have washed away the parampara

[@DavBhandal]

@@sahibnoorsingh2940 😂 Arre yaar, this is exactly like what Satta and Balwand must have said back in the day. Lesser-known fact-Bhai Baldeep was actually disowned by his own granduncles. The guy’s entire personality revolves around gatekeeping and pulling others down. In the Indian classical fraternity, he’s considered a total joke. I’ve met so many high-level artistes who think even less of kirtan after talking to him. Take this one incident-at the Darbar Festival, he claimed he was going to sing Jaijaivanti. Ended up singing everything except Jaijaivanti and made a complete fool of himself. Same festival, he tried to demonstrate the ‘oldest South Asian gharana’ on Jori, and bro, the entire front row of Pandits and Ustaads walked out within the first five minutes-including legends like Pt. Swapan Chaudhary and Pt. Shankar Ghosh. And let’s not even go far-his own students have admitted that his compositions only make sense on paper. They’re practically impossible to execute, which is why he doesn’t even play the Jori to teach. He just recites stuff and leaves it at that. And this is the same guy claiming he’s the reason Gurbani Kirtan parampara still exists. Like, seriously? What would we have done without the great Baldeep Singh? 😂

[@sahibnoorsingh2940]

@ 😹are yaar this is the most common example to be given when ur own vague theory is grappled with a cogent point. This is like the most basic level diversion from the main scene., so you are basically saying bbs did nothing 😹ok sir

[@iamphull]

Stop using Christian baja..

[@jassimarsingh6505]

It’s a tarshehnai which is native to India

[@jagdeepsandhu9659]

There is clearly a harmonium being played by a lady .

[@MohanKumar-ub5ib]

Then stop using their technology also from Mike to light to youtube.

[@iamphull]

@@MohanKumar-ub5ib Do Christian uses our instruments in their churches no they don't.. Why don't u celebrate chrismas & be a Abdullah..