Harulu’s apology: Water under the bridge or only to save face?

[@emerychi]

I have a little correction regarding her ban in gacha shop/chibimation She was banned from chibimation for art theft, not gacha shop. And her excuse of "not having interest in the project and wasn't trying to become a designer" falls apart, when she was banned from chibimation the server was incredibly small, the link for the server was very very hard to find. Only people who where really interested in the project would even find it, she also asked me a lot of questions in dms about the project during that time, clearly showing her interest in the project. she posted many traced and stolen assets in media channel as an attempt to get into the team but we banned them for the art theft. So she either lied about it in her apology to make it seem like it happended a long time and in a completely different server where she can throw all blame away from herself, or she misunderstood what beo said when she called her out for "art theft" Either way, her apology is definitely not great, I'm not willing to accept it. But I don't like grudges or drama so I want harulu to move on from this and change, let's hope this happens. She deleted the 2 videos that insulted me after beo had a long conversation with her (I don't know why it took so long and so much bargain but atleast it's finally done) Thank you for covering it flo :)

[@Flotalendy]

You’re welcome really, your hard work shouldn’t have been insulted that way in the first place, especially with the « it’s criticism so it’s fine » argument I’m sure you’ll go far in the future with the amount of talent you have, and I truly hope this doesn’t happen again

[@ItsKrisEmer]

your assets look amazing i love the artstyle you use and Harulu should have had no reason to insult them :] Keep doing amazing art pls💜

[@NeptizzleOffical]

Hello! I am an Artist and I would like to share my works with you, I don’t have discord but I have Pinterest and Everskies. If you have any of these apps maybe I cna show you my works

[@NeptizzleOffical]

@@Flotalendy I agree, the mascot looks very elegant (compliment) . I love how original it is

[@johnpoopjayyt7914]

I love how half of the chat just didn't care about the stream and just spammed e

[@freekzyisjustfreekzy]

Same, but it definitely got annoying which is why I stopped

[@istoleurmom]

Even after Flo told them to stop 💀

[@johnpoopjayyt7914]

​@@istoleurmom the chat: lets spam A instead

[@istoleurmom]

​@@johnpoopjayyt7914 Did they go from E to F to A? Either way, it went from okay/silly to just straight up annoying and stupid 😭

[@johnpoopjayyt7914]

@@istoleurmom it was fun but got a little annoying so much flo had to time out those who spammed

[@FriskTheChildnChara]

As an I am actually so devastated by the racist part, like it's actually the opposite of weird. There were many light colors in the mascot, and dark skin tone fits it good as it's create a balance. It's called C O N T R A S T

[@FriskTheChildnChara]

*As an artist in progress

[@istoleurmom]

I agree with this... The mascot's design and colours are really nice. Even a non-artist would be able to tell that contrast can actually make something look better. Even if someone doesn't like the contrast, I doubt they'll actually hate it. But ofc opinions exists. Still, even if Harulu has a different opinion, I don't get why she thought it's a good point to bring up. It's an unnecessary statement that'll obviously start problems. I can't help but wonder if she is aware about the concept of contrasting colours and only used it as an excuse to make racist statements for attention and more clout.

[@FriskTheChildnChara]

@@istoleurmom If it was in 2023 I would have thought that she's doing it for clout but in the older times(I sound like a parent lmao) there wasn't much drama so she probably just spoke whatever

[@Sun_S3t_22_Official]

Exactly! Light colors fit people with dark skins And the mascot is beatiful😊

[@mdjdyana]

for real

[@henryreed4697]

That "reasoning" for the racism is just so bizarre and so incredibly counter productive.

[@fateofyou9rs]

It looks like harulu can make her assets, without stealing, her art looks great. But yeah.

[@mooniecake]

the kirby pokemon thing should be the least of her worries yet it sounded like the most genuine apology lmao

[@fiorello9516]

its so funny tbh but like its so damn weird 😭

[@anzumblestars]

fr 😭

[@Bracelety2763]

Fr but tbh calling Kirby in my opinion would be a crime against society/sarcasm

[@MeekoNya]

A pjsk and BFDI fan in the same place? Is this a dream?

[@MeekoNya]

I feel like I’ve seen you in an entirely different comment section

[@AlienFriend]

Nah not the laughing emoji at the end of a serious apology 😃

[@DANI_HAHA]

That means that she doesn't want to apologise. She just tries to escape

[@breadbird]

“sorry i was racist and spread misinformation and art theft and stuff lmao 😂” are you sorry or unable to hold back ur lil baby giggles??

[@KoiKlutz]

Harulu, Needs to Pack Her Bags rn-

[@Quitting_Byebye]

Best pfp ever

[@glazeyyy]

"kirby is a pokémon" more sounds like one of those adults who know nothing about pop culture trying to be "how do you do fellow kids" to get 4 yesr olds to download their ad filled game

[@mono-san200]

About her reason about Cecilia tho... Like gurl- 💀 (I know she's trying to apologize, but it's not really sincere and it's like she's not ready for this, plus she's like only care about her subs or somethin-)

[@k1tty.cr1es]

No bcs- "I'm not trying to insult black people" "I find it weird that the skin is dark" 💀💀💀 Trying to apologize for being racist, only to be more racist 😭

[@PWRart]

I can't believe she did this, I used to watch her

[@unknown60167]

I can't keep up with so much drama. Wherever I go there is always so much drama. Flo needs a break from all this.

[@Zenith_Studios8]

I used to be friends with Harulu but she unfriended me after the whole conflict time. The funniest part was when she called herself a mobile game.

[@4shl3y_G4m3r]

Why does ur voice sound so calming? (Sorry I’m weird I have this Chinese and American accent and I don’t rlly like it but urs sounds so amazing its kinda my dream voice!)

[@BigComfyCouchBronyGal]

[TW / CW: Bad words from me, I'm still apologizing for any comment I make, counts as harrassment / attacking / witchhunting.] But, what's with Gachatubers taking so long in making their apology? Is it because they're scared of losing their fame? Nah! Those kind of Gachatubers need to get their heads out of their @s and make a proper apology. Not towards the fans / viewers, but towards the people they either stole art from, harrassed, etc. First, we got a certain youtuber (Not going to say the name for the sake of your channel) who waited 3 YEARS to make a bs apology in using a disability / disorder as a shield. And I FINALLY know who he reminded me off, but I'll get to that some other time. Then, we get Harulu trying to save her @s while waiting 2 weeks (please remind me if I'm wrong on that count) to make an apology towards the Chibimation team and Beowulf. I'm just seeing gachatubers, who cause / made all these dramas, don't even give a flying flank on what anyone else would think or say about them. Again, I do apologise if this long-lookin comment counts as harrassment. And I hope you have a good day / afternoon / night. Bye Bye!

[@Thereal_NC]

I think Haluru is up to something, but I don’t think there’s enough evidence to prove that yet. Also, I think that you are doing a good job. You worked hard on making this video and having evidence and research on the issue that is taking place. :D Thank you for making this video and for informing us about this. 😊👍

[@ItsKrisEmer]

I agree with ur opionon i never saw the "apologies" she made on discord but i did see a video she made saying sorry and explaining what she did and trying tto defend herself i saw it was fake immediately i bet a 8 year old could probably tell how insincere it was

[@0phe3b0p.mp4]

I'm glad this has been covered (I'm still not sure why past me even decided to subscribe to her) but there's probably even more pathetic drama in the gacha community that we still (luckily) don't know about. (Yes, even the small gachatubers, and I happen to know a few with one being a past drama which I sadly somehow got involved in, and no, someone else started it.)

[@ansuahissilly]

I find it so funny how some Gachatubers make the biggest drama of all time, and then make the most unorganized, crappy, and fake apology, and then expect people to forgive them. Like, I'm not even gonna look at you, I'm tryna stay away from problematic people. On the other hand, I actually feel a good feeling in me when people are genuine with an apology.

[@akeelahbruce1821]

I'm literally wearing a tie-dye cream sundress while watching this- ✋🏾😃

[@why_akariii]

This is crazy,I hope she learns a lesson.

[@HammyNotFat]

I'm sorry but why did she even talk abt black ppl in the racism part?? The racism is towards brown ppl not black, Cecilia isn't black? god I hate it sm when ppl mix up brown ppl with black.. we're literally 2 different races ☠

[@Sun_S3t_22_Official]

There are lots of skintones that can be considered black, the mascot for example, could be considered black, that's the reason I think, I hope it helps? 😅

[@HammyNotFat]

@@Sun_S3t_22_Official no it can't dude... brown isn't just a different shade of black it's a whole different race, brown is from desi/asian Countries and black is from African-American(?) Please don't mix us with black ppl it's kinda disrespectful

[@Stxrrl1ghtFr1ght]

@@HammyNotFatI used to mix black people with brown people, but I was a child at the time I now know the diffrence

[@Ilikefluffycats_11]

I like saying e, is literally my favorite word:D also i dont know nothing about this harulu, but your really cool, i love the fact your good at ranting. So clear, and have evidence every time you rant. im so glad i found this channel.

[@Darla11]

I really can believe some people cant do proper credit, I MIGHT understand if Haralulu got it from a video she couldn't find or something but there was a whole discord server they could have went back and forth to plus they even added a laughing face as if it was a JOKE she even deleted it after man I lose hope In gacha creators every day 😢

[@SierraTheTCGPlayer]

I agree but ur voice is beautiful

[@EditzbySkii]

I don’t know if you talked about and I just missed this or not, but harulu uploaded apology videos on her channel a few weeks ago, and like these apologies, it was very fake (or at least seemed like it), dramatic, and drawn out. I believe they were about the situation with insulting the “weird” designs in chibimation.

[@Flotalendy]

I talked about it in my previous video, but since it wasn’t mentioned in the current ones, I couldn’t make the connection

[@EditzbySkii]

Okay, thanks for the clarification!

[@PunkHallie]

To be completely honest, i found harlulu a bit back and i liked her content, i liked what she posted and such then i started to get suspicious about her. When I found her her comments were open ans flooding it most of the time i came back to find them turned off? That's when i decided to stop watching her content because hey it felt off. But, i don't think Harlulu IS sorry about all of that even if her apology sounds apologetic, it also has to LOOK Apologetic, which she doesn’t have, the laughing emoji just shows and proves thats she possibly doesn’t really care for what she just said and wanted to post an apology to get out of the “drama limelight” so it would escalate any quicker and faster like the other dramas thats have been circulating.

[@sxg4rfr3e]

This is insane

[@erisplaneta8]

Did anyone notice that the speed paint harulu provided literally had he OC with no eyes, mouth, whatsoever but instead a text that covered her face and said AI. She is literally victimizing herself, sign that she hasn't changed yet and is trying to put the blame on Flo.

[@ELSIE.4UU]

Ur voice reminds me of faline san

[@MazKun3000]

Same-

[@こいか]

same

[@Flotalendy]

Who?

[@FriskTheChildnChara]

@@Flotalendy faline San. A non-gacha KZbinr who mostly posts about their experiences or things they did in an entertaining way (I have no idea how it sounds familiar tho, but that's just me.)

[@MazKun3000]

@@Flotalendy a very chaotic non - gachatuber :D

[@Toko-fukawa198]

She just deleted... all her videos... and all that's left is an apology to Keaku. Flo, you better watch it yourself- it seemed rather immature to me. They used a rather non-serious ai voice bot, the one they use all the time, and there was "depressing" music in the background. I honestly don't think Harulu means it and just doesn't like the hate.

[@cmool]

Unlisted*. She can put them back up whenever she wants.

[@lunastarzpink3562]

Yeah, I really don't think Harulu is sorry at all for what they did. If they were truly sorry, they wouldn't have music in the video.

[@Toko-fukawa198]

@@cmool all the videos are back up.

[@destinysutton5676]

​@@lunastarzpink3562I don't think it work like that. She's still faking though.

[@bingthebee7114]

instantly apologized right after you exposed her

[@Cutie_patootie123]

BRO CONGRATS ON 70K SUBS OMGGGGGG!!!??

[@akeelahbruce1821]

1:36.... I've heard about Kirby but I also believed she was a pink Pokemon. Never said it out loud tho. 🤔

[@DeceptiveEgg]

I'm positive almost everyone who didn't know a thing about them thought they were a Pokémon at some point

[@0phe3b0p.mp4]

​@@DeceptiveEgg Including me

[@akeelahbruce1821]

Guess I'm not alone

[@Hello_tuka]

I got shocked when harulu disrespected and I thought she looks innocent and then I found out that she was racist😢

[@kiaraofficial_artz]

kirby is a pokemon 💅

[@johnpoopjayyt7914]

No its digimon 👹👹👹👹👹👹👹👹

[@mellifluousml]

@@johnpoopjayyt7914 no its a yugioh card creature idk 🐦

[@johnpoopjayyt7914]

@@mellifluousml NO ITS OBVIOUSLY A YOKAI WATCH GHOST TF YOU ON ABOUT?

[@Sun_S3t_22_Official]

​@@johnpoopjayyt7914 WHAT!?!!?!?!!? KIRBY'S OBVIOUSLY AN UPPERMOON 😤😤😤😤😤

[@mlol8730]

No he's a ball

[@taxisthrone]

Am I the only one who is starting to think her apology was AI generated? I'm not trying to be rude but her grammar isn't always that good but the apology was really complex and well written. Might just be me being paranoid but yk.. if it turns out to be AI generated i'll be here shaking my head in the corner.

[@PokedigiZ]

1:11 Kirby is not a Pokémon 🥲🔫.

[@RedStarBoi416]

That was just really crazy.

[@crazy_world_we_live_in]

mosaiced = pixelated ? I don't know if my theory is right, but maybe Harulu meant that term.

[@candle-uc1ei]

As a black person. I have learnt to live with being racisted bc i am black and i deserve it.

[@Fallen_Ezzie]

No you don't! NO ONE deserves to he racisted. Tell me, who said that to you? Theyre dumb, don't worry. You're BEAUTIFUL! PRETTY! GORGEOUS! All humans are gorgeous. They just have to slowly, patiently learn to love themselves. Everyone willl learn in diffrent ways, its alright. Theres never too late. You are loved ❤️

[@Pistachios_The_Parasite]

In 1:15 let's say that maybe she said that kirby is her favorite pokemon because someone made a pokemon mod by adding kirby in it i guess

[@paru_joined]

R.I.P "E" CHAIN ⛓️ ⛓️ ⛓️ ⛓️ ⛓️ ⛓️ ⛓️ 🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩 ⚰️ (Here lies the E chain, you will be missed by many until the next stream) 🚶‍♀️ -RIP e chain, maybe we can make in this comment?

[@paru_joined]

E

[@AxoNugz]

E

[@deriko11d]

E

[@gmel5557]

E

[@paru_joined]

E

[@aurora.mha.]

Ohhh ok i got understand flo!

[@AymNBlast]

To summarize the situation, Harulu just needed help with her past mistakes

[@CalvinKnowsYourSins]

harulu committed the worst sin you could imagine when it comes to content creation: the sin of hubris. they believed themselves to be untouchable, running away from the situation like a coward instead of owning up to their mistakes. their apology is incredibly lackluster, and i see no sincerity in it. if harulu is reading, i think it's best for you to throw in the towel, kid. you blew your career out of the water and there is no coming back from this.

[@temmiehoi688]

I completely forgot about harulu til now and i guess they blasted out of youtube cause i cant find her channel which is good

[@fumiko.cup1d]

Harulu deleted her post and made an apology video, with once again comments being turned off by her.

[@sweetthesuperpup]

If you look, it’s not resolved anymore so…

[@AayotaribbonheartXD]

Well... Atleast she apologized... I guess..

[@Stxrrl1ghtFr1ght]

If the apology was bad no it does not count as an “at least💀”

[@こいか]

i love the spamming

[@johnpoopjayyt7914]

Im assuming you got a time out

[@istoleurmom]

💀

[@こいか]

@@johnpoopjayyt7914 sure did

[@shadowkf22]

Bro when I heard this part I was like “WHY NOT SHE LOOKS COOL TO ME 😭” 2:37 I think Cecilia her design looks nice

[@The_ONLY_Kiyuko]

Why did this get recommended to me 1 year later 😭

[@Dyngnilam]

Did you make a video about the "deaths music taste" trend?

[@ShadowGalaxyWarriorEdits]

I don’t want to be mean to her I think this will stop in a few months, and I do agree with you

[@lunastarzpink3562]

What's with Gacha KZbinr's apologizing right after they were exposed in a video? 💀 I agree with you that if you didn't make that video about Harulu I think they would continue to insult the Chibimation artists, since they deleted their apology in that post is clear that they weren't actually sorry and that new video they posted seemed like they just did it for fame and want their subs they lost back. I really don't think their sorry for what they did, they did delete those videos insulting one of the artists, but they didn't delete the video that they said that the main menu of the game looked childish which I find disrespectful and the fact that they still have the comments off means that they don't want anyone calling them out telling them to apologize. I understand if they are worried about death threats, but I feel like they just don't want people telling them to apologize to the Chibimation team. An apology video that has music in it doesn't feel like they're really sorry in my opinion, if they were truly sorry, they wouldn't put music in their video. You could hardly hear what they were saying since the music was too loud so yeah... I still don't think they were sorry at all. I don't blame you Flo, for thinking that was AI art because it did indeed look like AI art which I thought they just used AI to make their KZbin banner.

[@Beanx_xTheMcflurry]

She deleted all her vids now

[@R0S3MARY831]

First like, woah.

[@Meveyethin]

Second!

[@imaminyourwalls168]

3rd

[@Lakshikamudugamuwa42]

4th

[@AKE-Fam]

Third!

[@54144]

7th

[@ihavenoideawhattomakethis]

this is really off topic but how do those eyes actually look good on your oc 😭

[@Illuminated-.x]

Its clearly very clear that she is lying because of her subscribers and because of your video, she clearly would've just ignored everyone, i think this so called " apology " is fake, she even put a laughing emoji when she apologised that's a red flag right there, she also deletes her apologys like what the heck, she is not sneaky at hiding the truth and this apology is genuinely 100% fake, i dont know about you guys but i find this fake enough she's just trying to save herself.

[@huskyartistsartandstuff]

Am I allowed to make a positive reaction to the assets that are only going to be part of the chibimation game? (I don't have to do it just to avoid offending everyone who created an assets for Beowulf's game?)

[@MazKun3000]

I think im the only one listening to the stream💀

[@DowntownHusband]

Nahhh you're not the only one here. I was also focusing on the stream while reviewing the live

[@MazKun3000]

@@DowntownHusband lol

[@-cherry.the.bunny-]

How did she try to Say she wasn't racist by saying something even more racist

[@millegraphy]

the racism at cecilia🧍

[@Cupdev]

woah

[@Nothere083q]

Hi Flotalendy anyways there is a wierd guy call Yar who are annoying my friends called Shuki and mervasaju he stole Shuki's videos and we are trying to spam report his channel but idk if YT will listen

[@lielovestill]

Yayayyayayayya

[@Tangoisanorange]

When she said kirby is my favorite pokemon like gurl kirby is from hal laboratory ™ not Pokemon™

[@Troublethecat]

Looks like she just deleted all her videos and left an apology video specifically for Keake four days ago.

[@destinysutton5676]

Is Chibination is coming back? I'm really sad about it.

[@catzzie_01]

I think she was trying to be genuine with her apologies by saying rather " fancy " or finding " cool " words. Like mosaic, that makes not much sense. And something really bothers me, " A thing is not the most perfect. " I don't understand what she's trying to say. Also, for the " strange assets " thing, strange is a synonym for peculiar, and it comes to a synonym called " weird " . So, inoffensively, she was trying to call the assets weird, but she said strange instead, so it didn't sound too offensive. For the pokémon thing, I think that should be the least of her worries since it is just a game, but she wrote a very genuine apology, which I guess is good, but it really doesn't matter that much. I don't know why she deleted her other apologies, but I think Harulu thought her apologies were like, bad and un-genuine? I don't know.

[@ashyypaws]

about the Kirby part, why should we be mad at Harlulu for that... not everyone cares for Kirby/Pokemon (coming from a fan of both Kirby and Pokemon)

[@erikascottk1216]

meow meow meow Say meow in reply’s

[@acinorev.nikk10]

MEOW MEOW MEEEOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

[@Candy_AddictBandu]

MEOW MEW MEOW MEOWWWWE

[@4shl3y_G4m3r]

Rawr. I mean meow-

[@Candy_AddictBandu]

@@4shl3y_G4m3r i heard tha- i mean MEOW MEWO MEOW

[@Sun_S3t_22_Official]

nya- I mean meow 😳

[@Kiryu_chan1]

Damn it, i missed this

[@Epicman33456]

Oh

[@ForestTheBulbasaur]

Harulu says white and black people as if they're the only races that exist. Of course I don't know the race of the color but it just seems weird... Also saying that it was "surprising" for a character not being white is just??? 😐

[@ItsAparnagaming_mlb-Lol]

:00

[@AkitaroKira]

E.

[@SP1DELLA]

'mosaiced' just means mosaic-

[@lielovestill]

Yayayyayayayya