Harvard Economist and Two-Time Finance Minister Lists Reasons for Consistent Failures | Kamran Khan

[@icctvs]

Dear Kamran Excellent podcast, it will be a treasure for young generations to understand the problems of Pakistan and to draw some strategies to come out of this mess of many decades In other words your podcast including Husain Haqani and this Hafeez Pirzada is the documentation of our political and economic history Well done! Umer Farooq

[@bilalnasir8785]

The discussion concludes to one thing . Those who have sense , have no power to implement . And those who can implement , have no sense . The situation will remain dreadful as ever .

[@allahbukhshkhosa5130]

سر۔۔بہت اچھا کام کر رھے ہیں۔۔سر گزارش ھے کہ ھر مہمان سے سوال کے بعد انہیں جواب مکمل کرنے دیں۔

[@ibadshumali2543]

Excellent podcast dear Kamran, as always you are highlighting the deep insights of Pakistan and educating young ppl of Pakistan. Best wishes as always 🇵🇰❤️🇵🇰

[@JangBahadur-zn1ft]

18:45 absolutely right. The only step is to improve relationships with all neighbours. Nothing else is needed.

[@BAAZAUQLOG]

The Right person to ask such questions. Aisay tasali say detail main informative interviews with quality questions honay chahiye, ta keh logo ko samjh bhi aye .

[@atifhussain3409]

MashaAllah, both are 77 yrs almost Full credit to them, for country Debacle Both angels stay blessed for another 77 yrs, to visit country ruins Aameen

[@AstralProjections-oy8ue]

[@rabiatabassum8494]

Kamran sb thanks for making things simple,especially economic terms

[@Azeem.Farooqui]

Kamran sb, pls let him complete first.

[@tariqzia2927]

The most intellectual person

[@manzooralam86]

Very nice and informative discussion we are proud of you

[@ranaatif865]

Mai ne aapki podcast dekhi hai. Is podcast se yahi conclude kia ja skta ha ke IK ke daur hakoomat main pakistan har sector main growth develop kr rha tha.

[@ShahNawaz-ns9vy]

@@ranaatif865 0+0+0-0%0/0+0/0-0=00000

[@Adnan-cm9zp]

😂

[@Umair_Ali_Abro]

Jab tak Shaikh sb kam kar rahy thy wo achha perform kar rahy thy. Dr sb k chhorhny k bad economy hal kharab kardia Khan sb ne jis ki wajja se unki government chali gayee.

[@ShahNawaz-ns9vy]

@@Umair_Ali_Abro phr ap na in ki history pori ni pari sirf tiktok dakhi ha

[@Umair_Ali_Abro]

@@ShahNawaz-ns9vy comments to aapky TikTok waly lag rahy he, he is noble and mentor for me.

[@manojchowdhary4208]

Sir - Pakistan should never worry. Pakistan is a nazriati mulq like Israel, formed during the holy month, and Waahid Islamic nuclear power of the world. Pakistan’s problems are caused by saazish of yahood o hanood o nissara though China is a trusted friend. Pakistan is also a leader of the Muslim ummah and provides security to them all over the world.

[@Yankee7000]

And you should get a life. Nothing better to do in your misery? Is this what you do every day? Look in the mirror and bring that sadness to your tr0lling? What a waste.

[@Yankee7000]

You really need to seriously look at your l1fe and reflect on the waste that it is. You wake up every morning, look in the mirror and bring that pathet1c sadness to your tr0lling. Kindly examine your l1fe and figure out something better than being a waste of DNA.

[@KhizarNaushad-ko4ts]

Yeh chutyapay wali soch hum ko iss position par ley aye hai

[@angeleyessvenska9330]

atmi taaqat............ghaas pakode.............wahidissalami mulk hah (punjabbbbbbbbbi hah...........ghaas jo khaye hah)

[@MIsmail-r6e]

Being a country you must be aware of who is against and who is with you.😊 DON'T BLAMING OTHER.

[@shoaibnizami5972]

Dr Abdul Hafeez sheikh was true in Feb 2021, but all of the cabinet opinion was against him

[@wahidgulz]

بد. معا شىيه establishment both civil and others are not supporting such policies

[@taimoorkhan1301]

Please bring on his excellency Atif Mian.

[@SomnathDe-h7d]

Watching from India.

[@Umair_Ali_Abro]

Great Interview ❤

[@aamirnajeeb3411]

Discussion revolved around theoretical aspects. Specifics should have been discussed. Second, why did dr sahib served for short periods with different regimes.

[@tzmedicine4821]

Kamran sir please let your guests to complete their answers first

[@faizawan3144]

Everybody who had been at top policy level couldn't do anything are not ashamed

[@NezaamHaider]

Ur great kamran khan jernarlist

[@globalislamicreminders]

This countries army is the biggest reason for its failure

[@SomnathDe-h7d]

The main cause of failure Pakistan as a state is army's interference.

[@masudqaim4658]

Thanks for being true... Mr Kamran Khan you had always been listened and watched with trust... Your concern for Pakistan and Pakistanis had always been far ahead of any other media source... Present day problems are pushing us in a corner with blindfolds on our hand cuffed and legs tied with a pole called 'Selfish Interests' ...

[@saleemadil6333]

There should be proportional disbursement of funds from federation according to economic generation. Centre should not be responsible for provincial expenses.

[@niazmuhammad6629]

Bro discussed like a text book model, and would not go or touch area which mention word army involvement which is a root cause of everything!

[@Shigri123]

بصد احترام عرض ہے کامران صاحب سوال کرنے کے بعد پہلے مہمان کو جواب مکمل کرنے دیں ،بیچ میں ڈسٹریکٹ نہ کریں ،خاموشی سے سنیں جب انکا جواب مکمل ہوں پھر دوسرا سوال کریں

[@mshazaf]

First Pakistan should consecrate not in Export but should focus on import substitutes. Try to manufacture things we need to lmport.

[@babloo355]

Excellent interview

[@khuramfraz5765]

After long time I seen an informative programme. I am not viewer of Kamran Khan sine PPP govt and PTI his discussion was totally baised.

[@zoaibhalai8153]

What ever we look at, the problem is corruption in each and every department, and the 2nd problem is of spending more than the income.

[@AstralProjections-oy8ue]

Actually real problems are: Kshmir obsession, mazhabi inteha pasandi, no trade with neighbours, strategic depth sargarmian, Amrican ke bister me so jana, Cheen ke bister me so jana etc

[@saeeddeen7304]

​@@AstralProjections-oy8ueTrue

[@muhammaddanish1531]

Good method

[@premprakashkala2384]

Pakistan’s current economic situation is a consequence of it being a security state with large military expenditure and extremely poor management and high corruption. The country is more of a Punjabistan than a federal state.

[@shoaibnizami5972]

فروری 2021 میں ڈاکٹر عبدالحفیظ شیخ نے آئی ایم ایف کے پروگرام میں جن سخت فیصلوں پر زور دیا، اس پر اس وقت کی پوری کابینہ مخالف تھی، اس پر عمل نہ ہوا، پھر قوم نے دہرے مشکل فیصلے بھگتے، اور معیشت وہی 2.5 فیصد گروتھ ریٹ میں پھنسی ہوئی ہے۔

[@ajitsuttatti]

Arre Mr Kamran Khan....kuch toh manners rakho. Sawaal poochne ke baad mooh bandh rakhna seekho aur saamne Wale ka jawaab itminaan se sunna seekho. Tumhari yeh beech mein bolne ki aadat ke chalte video dekhna sardard bann jaata hai. Ithne saal iss field mein ho...kuch seekha hi nahi😂. Jahalath ki hadd ho yaar😂

[@avtarwasson4875]

Pak also doesn't collect taxes ar the border, despite army being in charge.

[@chooranchannel769]

60s Pakistan economy was doing well Because they were following capitalism means privatization. 1972. Government of Pakistan switched from capitalism to socialism. 1972 with one penstroke Nationalization of industries policy open the flood gate for corruptions, incompetency, Loot, favoritism. After 1972 policy, Pakistan never recovered its economy. Communist socialist USSR buried In Afghanistan due to their government run economy. Privatization is the only solution for better economy.

[@SomnathDe-h7d]

Pl allow guest speaker to complete his answer. In short, as anchor you talk less and allow guest to talk more.

[@zafarmalik4192]

Pakistan could not hold free fair election what to talk about progress

[@rafeeqahmed379]

Dr HP and KK both of them know very well, what’s are the root causes, wasting time to reinvent the wheel, both of them lack audacity to speak loud and clear, kK busy minting money through his podcast! If he is really a man with balls, than talk about road map, and his contribution to get out of the mess! All hats no cattles 👎🏻

[@AstralProjections-oy8ue]

hm deh shatgard mulk (war economy) ban gaye

[@angeleyessvenska9330]

[@docblue8081]

timestamps needed

[@Talhakashif-u3j]

سر اگر ہم امپورٹ کو کم کر لیتے اور انرجی سیکٹر میں اصلاحات لے آتے تو کافی حد تک معاملات سدھر جاتے مگر پتہ نہیں کیوں اس میں دلچسپی لینے کی بجائے ادارے بیچنے میں دلچسپی ہے جبکہ امپورٹس کم کرکے بیس سے تیس ارب ڈالر سالانہ بچا سکتے ہیں انرجی سیکٹر سولر پر کر کے بھی 6 سے سات ارب ڈالر بچا سکتے ہیں مگر اس پر بات ہی نہیں کرتے

[@shafilashari84]

Let the guest speak

[@SalahudinMalik]

watch it on 1.5x speed

[@nasirjohn4483]

حفیظ صاحب میں نے اپ کا انٹرویو سنا بہت خوشی ہوئی کیا یہ سب اگر اپ جانتے تھے تو اپ نے اپنے دور حکومت میں یہ سب باتیں کیوں نہیں کہیں

[@wahidgulz]

Mr.Kamran please let complete the answer as we need to listen scholars

[@faizawan3144]

Mr sheikh was total failure three times should at least admit.reason...........

[@angeleyessvenska9330]

[@oscarcollier5141]

Both speakers are slow speakers. Watch at 2 times the speed.

[@dharmmangwani1894]

Jaisee Awam Vaisey hukraam

[@GuzzarAwan]

Chin factory kab lga rha h

[@vherlekar]

Very sound intellect and reasoning... But... He seems too "slow" (even in speech!👆) and soft-spoken... And lacks "Jazbaa" of typical impatient Pakistani!!

[@gulzargulzarcheema5668]

جُرنیلوں کے دلوں اور ٹاؤٹوں سے کسی فلاح کی اُمید رکھنا ہی چُداپا پہے

[@shahnawaz1576]

One of the best mindset for management of economy, our govt must focus to hire these mindset managers.

[@MuhammadAfzaalSiddiqui-g1m]

Send zardari and nawaz sharif to all those developed countries then see they will destrusted within no time likewise pakistan today😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@saeeddeen7304]

Send Imran,,Afghanistan to bring their Modern Economic system 😊

[@DrAahad-xo6ev]

Ab matam kya karen b/c none priminister allowed to be completed his or her tenure. Wonderful explaination but why not taxation on huge sector I.e. Agriculture; now a source of blackmoney since most stakeholders and businessmen claim profitability from Agric produces and additional income which is non-taxable. Currently country have repelled multinational eg. Imperial chemical Industry, karachi, Shell AND etc. We have been unable to requisit economic engines and unable to develop skillful farm labors and hygienic good practices as well as temperature controlled cold storages non-availabilty at the agric production hubs or zones.

[@hamzain2000]

Economist? I am elon musk now

[@masudqaim4658]

Allahhoakbar Allahhoakbar Allahhoakbar, Subhanallah Alhamdolillah, Allahhoakbar Allahhoakbar Allahhoakbar...

[@zafarmalik4192]

Bold judicial system only answer

[@saeeddeen7304]

😮

[@saeeddeen7304]

Sawal Gundam, Jawab Chana,,

[@essakhan-oh2vh]

خدا ھم پر رحم کرے۔ اس ذلالت جس کی تباھی بربادی سے ساری دنیا چیخ چلا رھی ھے مگر کسی کو پرواہ نھین ۔

[@essakhan-oh2vh]

خاص بیماری کی تشخیص خطر ناک ھوتی ھے ۔

[@aanakrukavi]

Arey Aakhirat, Ghazwa e Hind, Kashmir ke baare mein baat karo yeah kya economy ka baat kar rahe ho. Jannat, hooron ke baare mein bataaon.

[@GhulamRasool-hh1pq]

Mara bahi !! Jiss mulk ka peon sa laker President tak sab choor hoon. Jiss mulk ke 70 % budget foog pa kharch ho. Wo mulk tarake Kara. Wo aisa ha jassa aap kisse gadha sa doodh ke tawaqa rakheen. Iss laya aap jitne bhe talk shock ya bak bak ker lean . Koe faida ha !!

[@ShahNawaz-ns9vy]

Rallo katta😊

[@MalikHaris-b5d]

Kamran sahb ki jahalat ka level hai ye Banda kitni dafa Finance Minister Laga har dafa imf ke pas Pakistan ko lekr gia or aj tk iski koi performance dikha de

[@Imran-gabol]

A third rated person and third rated economist.

[@storyverse705]

Funny people all the time

[@ibrahimnadeem1064]

Kamran khan is one of those anchors who got paid by Brigadiers and Generals.

[@AstralProjections-oy8ue]

[@NezaamHaider]

Imran khan zindabad ❤❤❤❤

[@saeeddeen7304]

FITNA

[@GhulamRasool-hh1pq]

Aap dono public ko bashan da raha hean ka iss mulk mean tax chore ha. Jab ka aap dono ka khata khola jai too aap dono bhe tax choor naklan ga. Iss ka alawa Aap kehta hean ka FBR corrupt adara ha. Iss mulk ka koon sa aidara ha joo corrupt naheen ha. Gadhoon ka mulk mean aap kahta hean ka soba andaz mean challen. Wo insan chalta hean. Gadha naheen.