Has China won?

The competition between China and the United States is the defining geopolitical reality of the 21st century. The evolution of its new Great Game will determine whether our collective future will be one of prosperity or disaster. In this...
The competition between China and the United States is the defining geopolitical reality of the 21st century. The evolution of its new Great Game will determine whether our collective future will be one of prosperity or disaster.
In this episode of New Thinking for a New World, Alan Stoga talks to Kishore Mahbubani, the renowned Singaporean global strategist. He knows both super powers, understand the risks of a potential collision and has ideas about how to avoid one. His most recent book-as well as this conversation-asks, Has China Won?

[@davidyeung9115]

Nothing to do with winning or losing. The 1.4 billion Chinese are working hard days in and days out !

[@TacticalMayo]

That's not how we 🇺🇲 see it.

[@user-tr5vs9gm4r]

@@TacticalMayo Who cares. 😆

[@user-rl5dd1ex2k]

@@TacticalMayo we just live our life

[@user-xl1wr9wm4f]

It is amazing how much patience China has with the western world despite their atrocious behaviour, communication & actions. If one studies the 5000 history of China, one will certainly understand their will power, innovation & long-term strategy. Mr Mahbubani truly understands China & the Asian world.

[@kaladass7194]

What Patience are talking about?? China 5000 year culture does not exist because communism destroyed.. Mao was responsible for the death of 70 million chinese because his great leap forward totally failed.

[@skydragon23101979]

@@kaladass7194A big and powerful country like China not being involved in any armed conflict with anyone for 45 years that is patience.

[@kaladass7194]

@@skydragon23101979 It think you are not aware that every week PRC n Philippines are having skirmishes n confrontation in the SOUTH CHINA SEA..The Spartly Islands rightfully belong to Philippines as decided by the ICJ. Despite that decision CHINA REFUSES TO VACATE the Spartly Islands..When you look at the map of SOUTH CHINA SEA Philippines is the closest country to the Spratly Islands..Are you still trying to say China does not land grab n bully poorer countries. China has laid claims on Senkaku Island n Taiwan. China lays claim on Arunachal Pradesh n Ladakh...How she lay claim I wonder because tibet was never part of China..it was illegally occupied by PRC..

[@charliecheng3340]

China is the adults here . The US is acting like a Cry Baby huh huh huh

[@TacticalMayo]

Don't worry they're going to make up for that with what's coming​@@skydragon23101979

[@vanveakrin276]

Professor Kishore is spot on ... Kishore talks the truth

[@ABritishRefugeeinChina]

Kishore Mahbubani and Jeffrey Sachs, the American economist, are hugely important voices for the world to listen to. As a Brit who has lived ten years in Singapore and 17 years in China, I know that their understanding of China is spot on.

[@emkoh2746]

Agree with you totally 💯

[@TacticalMayo]

The US is not going to listen to nothing. China already knows what's going to happen if they reach for the crown.

[@simonooi2544]

Abritishrefugeeinchina, You must be very wise in your views. Unfortunately not many can see like you because their basic belief is built from a position of superiority embedded by the colonial proud and daily western misinformation News network. Even many have lived in Asia but the mindset remained superiority moulded from old beliefs.

[@sweetyandjoshuaenjoytheirb718]

America should know ignorance and arrogance are not a good combination.

[@alaltest9319]

hard to change one's dna with just 200 years existence.

[@patriceesela5000]

So far, that ignorance and arrogance has served them well

[@TacticalMayo]

Stop wait till you see what comes

[@bobbylow175]

@@TacticalMayoalways threatening people. Typical sore loser.

[@tonytan6547]

Can't help it . The Arrogance of Power

[@charlesoh14]

KISHORE is very knowledgeable, seen in all the truth he writes/say. He is much love by Singaporeans, students and fans.

[@pramoddevkota]

Mahbubani is great analyzer.....

[@henryyip1]

Kishore is a shameless, vicious , inferiority complex sufferer. He keeps harping about China's 100 years of dealing with the criminal west and tries his best to humiliate China while he forgotten that india suffers a worst fate of 200 years of rape & punder and he only harp on China. And the worst type of historians that instead of calling out the west for their crimes against humanity, he put all the blames on India & China. He is a malicious menace

[@HanS662]

@20:35 much easier than you think. Majority of the South East Asian countries have Chinese ancestors. They don’t fear the yellow man like the west.

[@chriswong9158]

Three thousand year history, Chinese ancestors, their "Surname" have change but still network inside China PRC.

[@RaymondLi604]

Maybe update moniker to the "golden" man? 💛

[@zhengwenping4764]

😅 7:51

[@davidz7858]

No, because they did not done bad thing to China,

[@alaltest9319]

the yellow peril is invented by western imperal powers when they occupied china and burned the summer palace.

[@zafarm6101]

Mahbubani .... great scholar.

[@henryyip1]

Kishore is a shameless, vicious , inferiority complex sufferer. He keeps harping about China's 100 years of dealing with the criminal west and tries his best to humiliate China while he forgotten that india suffers a worst fate of 200 years of rape & punder and he only harp on China. And the worst type of historians that instead of calling out the west for their crimes against humanity, he put all the blames on India & China. He is a malicious menace

[@PsicologiaSocialBrasil]

Great BRICS and all Global South!

[@TacticalMayo]

USA 🇺🇲 USA 🇺🇲 USA 🇺🇲

[@chriswong9158]

13:00 When USA is playing Checker, Russia is playing Chess... China PRC is playing GO China will not take on US traps

[@RaymondLi604]

Game tree complexity: Chess @ 10^120, Go @ 10^360 🧮

[@freegatemy]

GO is Japanese version, the ancient Chinese chess game is really wei-qi 圍棋

[@TELLALL.]

@@freegatemy Go originated in China more 2500 years ago and spread to Korea and Japan. It is a game of strategy, logic and intuition, where two players compete to surround more territory than their opponent on a grid of lines. In the realm of geopolitics, Xi Jinping's strategic moves are often compared to a seasoned player of Go. Just as in Go, where the aim is to surround more territory than the opponent, Xi Jinping's pursuit of comprehensive global dominance over the U.S. involves intricate and calculated maneuvers. Xi Jinping strategic approach to leadership and global influence mirrors the game's principles. Sources: Joe Plays Tik Tac Toe Against Xi's Global ‘Go’ Game Strategy.

[@TacticalMayo]

The US will win.

[@PhiloSurfer]

@@TELLALL. freegatemy is saying use the correct term - weiqi, instead of the copycat Go.

[@chriswong9158]

23:00 Australia combat China in favor of USA under AUKUS 2022: Australia's Defense Policy In 2023 reply (see video) kzbin.info/www/bejne/qZjWoZ6um9CGas0 China reply: Just do nothing. Today over 100 Australian Grape farmer are out of business

[@josephlionellin3004]

You are correct. An old saying goes:"There will be pride before the downfall" This is what happened with the Australian govt. Typically prioritising the show of muscles and arm fist over their citizens hardship and grouses.😂

[@kingsleyperera9655]

​@@josephlionellin3004 Also consequences of being a Lap 🐕‍🦺 !

[@alaltest9319]

For the West, all countries, big or small, such as Lithuania, Canada or the United States, can challenge and insult China. This is democracy. But if China responds by stopping mutual exchange activities, then China is bullying and aggressive...

[@TacticalMayo]

​​@@josephlionellin3004LOL keep thinking that the US will lose 🤣

[@user-tr5vs9gm4r]

@@TacticalMayo Outside America nobody has respect for America 🤣🤣🤣

[@tien7742]

👏💯🌹to Prof. Krishore Mahbubani corrected statements of the problems in the US government's systems👍..

[@TacticalMayo]

This guy is a pro China shill.

[@kalipotmeng]

Love to Kishore ❤

[@ansa336]

Thanks for your reasonable last comment to Professor Kishore Mahbubani. I do hope Americans are listening to discussions like this.

[@TacticalMayo]

No we 🇺🇲 will not.

[@lasidh4777]

Yes, Sir. No truer words have been said. China will never, ever be humiliated by the western powers, or by anyone for that matter, again. From Righteous, a 73 years old non-Chinese, born and raised in Hong Kong. China.

[@kinchau4764]

I feel you brother,🇨🇳🫡

[@TacticalMayo]

Oh yes they will be.

[@TacticalMayo]

🇺🇲​@kinchau4764 🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲

[@tonytan6547]

@@TacticalMayo let's see then !

[@TacticalMayo]

@@tonytan6547 we're are already there.

[@swatisquantum]

I as an American traveled to ASEAN countries and China.. I was so impressed by their progress.. it felt more advanced than america but the people were kinder..prices were cheap. The future is asia. That’s where the people are.

[@TacticalMayo]

LOL you are not an American 🤣

[@bobbylow175]

@@TacticalMayoso being American means you must suck its balls like you?

[@ganboonmeng5370]

​@TacticalMayo you too

[@TacticalMayo]

@@ganboonmeng5370nope I'm 100% pure tried and true born and raised red white and blue 🇺🇲

[@KennyL0009]

Mahbubani's rule based order equates UN chartered laws. US rules-based order laws are whatever US/western nations interpret, under neoliberal ideology, rules-based orders always favor the west. If you google US rules-based order, it does not exist like specific laws.

[@RaymondLi604]

Sigh. That's why software has version control. Get with the digitization, already 😜

[@TacticalMayo]

United Nations is American 🇺🇲

[@ganboonmeng5370]

​@TacticalMayo that is what the International thug and bully wanted...but the rest of the world with China as the leader...saying NO...fuc,.k off

[@chriswong9158]

10:00 China PRC is governing under Law Base Order... Not Democracy. Set the Rules All can follow equally.

[@RaymondLi604]

Enforced equally as well ⚖️

[@freegatemy]

Democracy has been proven as fake, even the Greeks who invented the system also claimed it would not work, the Chinese centralized system worked for the past four thousand years provided there's good leadership/governance

[@TacticalMayo]

LOL glorifying totalitarianism 🤣

[@TacticalMayo]

@@Freedmen-American-Reparations of course not tankie

[@IrradioMan]

@@TacticalMayototalitarianism is perfectly fine if the results are good. Americans seem to believe democracy is the end goal, when it should actually be an optional path to prosperity.. if a meritocratic confucian society like china is much more successful on every front, then their system is superior, and america would need to adjust their primitive approach to governance if they want to be any sort of competition to china.

[@Arcy0429]

Mr. Kishore Mahbubani, as usual, is exceptional! 👍👏

[@philostreet781]

George Canon’s wide words fell on deaf ears 😢 :: “The outcome of the contest with the United States will not depend on how many bullets, but on the internal spiritual vitality of its society.” 25:51

[@qake2021]

👏👏👏🇨🇳 is still winning ‼️👏👏👏

[@TacticalMayo]

No they are not.

[@user-tr5vs9gm4r]

@@TacticalMayo But America is not winning, that's what count. 🤣🤣🤣

[@TacticalMayo]

@@user-tr5vs9gm4r oh yes it is.

[@TacticalMayo]

@@user-tr5vs9gm4r oh how wrong you are 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@user-tr5vs9gm4r]

@@TacticalMayo We are only seeing it losing a bit every single day 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@frankliu7118]

Professor Mahbubani is a knowledgeable and fair-minded scholar, who understands China and the West. It’s always refreshing and informative to listen to his talk.

[@MsOceanstar]

❤👏❤👍👍👍Thank you Kishore! Long live China👍👍👍❤

[@barrywong4327]

Kishore is a wise statesman and a wise human being. He sees the big picture of humanity, the human species and planet earth. China is day and night from the US. Yearning for peace, stability and harmony are in China’s DNA, not violence, imperialism and world domination as in the case of the US. Frankly, with few exceptions, the US ruling elites and think-tanks are hubristic, intoxicated with domination, narrow-minded and short-sighted. The US’ system makes a lot of noise, a lot of theatrics but accomplishes very little substance. The US policy makers know no reverse gear. They have way too much foolish pride to admit mistakes and course-correct. Doubling down on every failed policy is the mode of operandi. As an American, I don’t see our government being able to act rationally and intelligently. It’s all about hype and nothing else. Very sad. Thank you for the broadcast.

[@alaltest9319]

The WESTERN DEMOCRACY, isn't it the best system ? if attacking a foreign country is the most important strategy to run a compaign to get the votes of the supportors, are these supportors smart or stupid ?

[@TacticalMayo]

Number one you are absolutely not an American that's 100% guaranteed. Number two the United States has the wolf of wood Stockton and that will stay in effect till the very end of time.

[@liaojohnweechun7454]

The World should HEED to the Advice of Professor KISHORE MAHDUBANI and form a Better World 👌👍👏👏🥰💚💚💚

[@TacticalMayo]

Absolutely not the United States will stay number one no matter what or all hell will break loose.

[@TacticalMayo]

The answer is no.

[@edddiscaya47]

Best explanations ever!

[@jianmunnelly9052]

Thanks for your channel, such a great talks Gentleman ❤

[@elielee7364]

Professor Kishore Mahbubani possesses the finest brain on modern China. Why can't politicians from India learn something positive from him instead of hiding the truth (see declassified docs from London) about its border dispute with China?

[@rajnikantchande2677]

@eleelee7364 Kindly please narrate in as much detail as possible about the " declassified documents from London " about China's border dispute with India....kindly also indicate the date when these documents were released & what was the reaction from India & China on these documents...it would help me & many other Indians a great deal to take a detached, objective view of this long- simmering dispute between two great neighbours, both of whom possess so much wisdom , to work collaboratively primarily for the greater good of global humanity. In so doing, both China & India working selflessly, will not only bring about peace, harmony & prosperity worldwide, but also automatically achieve their own country's goal of economic development, peace & prosperity. That's what Hindu scriptures say. At rhis critical moment, when China & US are not far from a major war in the Indo- Pacific & India ,as a key member of QUAD, is going to take on China jointly with US, surely, if, in your opinion, the declassified documents released in London show the way forward for India & China to resolve their border disputes amicably, then, you've a responsibility to put your views across in the Indian & major global media to support your case for the settlement of China- India once & for all....Jai Hind: Jai Bharat. 12.04.2024 .

[@jimrule8652]

AMERICA NEEDS TO SPEND MONEY BIG TIME ON THE WELLBEEN ON IT PEOPLE ON EDUCATION AND HEALTH AND HOUSING AND SAFETY

[@petervote7914]

I think it is nonsense to say that everyone wants to see strong United States.

[@pomicultorul]

Great guest!

[@vanveakrin276]

Apple iPhone sale in China is falling..so Apple 🍎 iPhone is adapting their New Apple 🍎 iPHONE for the future Chinese Market . .HUA WEI 🛰️ SATELLITE phones are leading the market followed by XIAOMI which also has Chinese Satellite phone 🛰️🛰️ system..

[@SYChow-wh2kr]

Yes

[@vanveakrin276]

Thailand gives you VISA FREE for entry into Thailand... for your information..all HIGH SPEED TRAIN seats from APIWAT STATION to SARA BURI or to Nakhon Ratcha Sima are fully booked for SonKran the Water Festival...

[@boris7417]

There is no way that a country changing party rules every four or eight years can have any long term strategies!

[@TacticalMayo]

Yes they do and you're seeing it happen right now.

[@davisho3638]

Yes , China has..... AMAZING CHINA

[@javiergo9560]

Yes, totally.

[@truthaboveall7988]

Won what? If by win we mean going from poorer than Haiti to the 2nd richest & most successful economic/govt model in world history then yes they “won” If by winning we mean dominating the world w brute force well that’s an American thing not a Chinese one

[@ZweiZwolf]

China decided to dominate the world with economic power, instead.

[@TacticalMayo]

Well reaching for the United States number one spot will get you that and even worse than ever before.

[@TacticalMayo]

Well they should have never reached for the United States number one spot

[@jacobomega5991]

One thing only that I cannot agree with; a strong US is good for the world! No a strong US is not good for the world since at least 2008 if not earlier!

[@TacticalMayo]

Speak for yourself.

[@bobbylow175]

@@TacticalMayothe West including US is only 15% of World population. So yes you speak for your own self.

[@vanveakrin276]

I just came out of China in Kun Min by Rail to LAO ... THE train is full , full of Chinese tourists entering Lao ...I advise people not to go through the Land border between LAO AND CHINA tourists and goods transport checking point.... thousands of Chinese are passing through this land point MOHAN daily....big big human JAM at immigration point..

[@vanveakrin276]

Thousands of Chinese are going to Thailand via Lao train daily.... you can take a Night bus in Non - Kai daily at 7 .30 p m ... and you will arrive in the next morning at 6.30 a m ..in Mochit 2 ...

[@simonooi2544]

I thought of going to Kunming through the high speed rail in Laos. I need to fly to Udonthani with stopover in BKK. Now I might need to consider the plan. Thanks for your information. Great blessings.

[@horridohobbies]

People are always saying that China has the second largest economy by nominal GDP. However, China has the world's largest economy *_by purchasing power parity._* Why do we insist on using nominal GDP over GDP PPP to compare national economies? GDP PPP is a better metric of the *_standard of living_* in these countries. A hamburger in USA costs more than the same hamburger in Philippines. Historically, China and India have alternately been the world's largest economies *_by purchasing power parity_* over the last 2,000 years (except for 1900-2013), according to the Maddison Project. This was well before the United States even existed. Thus, nominal GDP is a biased metric.

[@MultiMyNickName]

You have answered your own question. The USA pushes a measure which favors its power. They dont want to be behind China.

[@TacticalMayo]

The United States has the largest economy in the world.

[@horridohobbies]

@@TacticalMayo By nominal GDP, not by purchasing power parity. So what?

[@MultiMyNickName]

@@TacticalMayo The United states has nothing. It depends entirely on external sources for everything. It has a tiny population and Chinas internal market eclipses it by a mile. GPD means nothing. 1 dollar in the USA is worth ten times less than 1 dollar in China. In real terms China can outspend, out build, out invest, research, develop and create the USA by a huge ratio. The gap is so vast the chances of the USA catching up are literal zero, same with Europe, the West is over. Its desperation in clinging to African theft to prop up its flagging economic state, also ended, meaning very soon the noose will tighten on the populations and the people will start to see exactly what their Governments and Corrupt corporations have done. People in the US and Europe should be very afraid of their own leaders right now, because the writing is on the wall, they have no moves left to bridge the collapse, and that means they are desperate. The only way they have ever known to control you is fear and terror, which means in their minds right now, they need you all scared and broken so you dont overthrown them. Be afraid of the coming storm and know that this is what you brought on yourselves following, blindly, knowingly in false ignorance. Its a lie to say that Western people haven't known their nations were built on blood, murder and global genocide, you just chose to look the other way, well its time to face the dark truth. The question is what will you do? You are the Africans now, the Asians, the Central and South Americans, you are the targets of your leaders, you are the ones they will hit. What will you do when that storm comes I wonder?

[@TacticalMayo]

​@@horridohobbiespurchasing power parity does not matter what matters is GDP per capita.

[@laubockseng1994]

GREAT!

[@medialcanthus9681]

Expected bad attitude from USA. But Australia India and Philippines ?? Silly.

[@TacticalMayo]

Wait till you see how bad it gets.

[@horridohobbies]

Pew Research said that the collective West views China negatively. This is true. However, the collective West represents less than 20% of the world's population and less than 20% of the world's nations. In other words, the collective West is a relatively small minority. Why, then, does it matter that the collective West views China negatively? Why isn't it more significant that the global majority views China positively? Is it because of the collective West's global dominance and imperialist control? Is it because we fear the collective West? Of course, the answer is obvious. It is the collective West that, for that last 70 years, has imposed its will on the entire planet, waging endless wars, imposing endless sanctions, conducting endless coups, and suppressing the development of the Global South nations.

[@arthurhwang117]

The general public in the “Collective West” view China increasingly negatively because the Main Stream Media in Western countries have blanketed the information space with lies, vitriol, and hate for the last five to ten years. Today, EVERY article is negative. If there is a flood in China, it’s how the Chinese destroy the environment. If Chinese EV exports increase, it’s intellectual property theft and unfair government subsidy. It’s lies about forced labor and genocide in Xinjiang. And so on and so on. A free press and reliable information is fundamental to functional democracy, but today, the MSM has become propaganda organs of the AngloAmerican system, and you ask why public opinion has changed. If you challenge the man on the street about his opinions on China, he says “But look at what the papers say” and the papers say “look at the opinion polls”. Yet we talk about these things as if they are unrelated. They are ABSOLUTELY related. In fact, public opinion is entirely based on the media - those that escape from the media narrative are the exceptions : the people who actually take the time to think and to do their own research are as rare as diamonds in the sand.

[@TacticalMayo]

LOL listen to this leftist tankie 🤣

[@nnfefe9451]

Any country praised as being a democracy means that anything done or written in past belong to the ash heap of history. Any country evading this label means that the past is referenced. The Chinese writing itself could pass as a chip so there should be no surprise.

[@cb250nighthawk3]

But you can't claim victory when the battle is still ongoing.

[@RaymondLi604]

That's Ukraine's current battle "cry"? 😭

[@TacticalMayo]

​😂 can you see the US soldiers on the kinmen island from your window@@RaymondLi604

[@johnqueripel2001]

Is he actually saying Australia is not located somewhere between London and New York? lol

[@kbmblizz1940]

Interviewer: "US want a peaceful world order." 😅😂 Endless offshore wars, weaponed economic sanctions, 800+ military bases in foreign lands...it is a strange way to promote 🕊️☮️.

[@TacticalMayo]

Don't worry because reaching for the United States crown is going to guarantee you the last one ever.

[@jinsoonchin5205]

Who is the adult in the room?

[@TacticalMayo]

Not Kishore

[@ChuckWilliamsTechnology]

China will never allow the 100 years of humiliation again...they won't allow it!!!!

[@jaytso1883]

Remember the LKY's 'WTOA' warning about Australia back in 1980???

[@jmc8076]

Then why so much western $ invested in HK? Not all as it seems?

[@qake2021]

👍👍🇧🇷🇷🇺🇮🇳🇨🇳🇿🇦➕️‼️👏👏👏

[@genelarson6849]

Maybe im wrong but the belt and road initiative seems to be a method to export tofu dreg construction projects first loan money to developing countries to be paid to Chinese construction companies initiating these projects sounds good for the Chinese

[@Arcy0429]

Allan, treat your audience with respect, please!

[@kenpeters7127]

A new world order would expect its citizens to aspire to defending statues to maintain order and self respect for the challenging situations which will confront our way of life and our plannet.

[@drmamu7777]

In fact US helped china get into the WTO and became the most favored nation in terms of investments and trade to help china after the cultural revolution.

[@btgan3838]

Don't think "help" is the correct verb to use in this context. Like Kishore said, benevolence isn't applicable to great powers, only strategic interests. Befriending China in the 1970s, led to the eventual breakup of the former Soviet Union and the end of that Cold War. China's entry into the WTO was supported by American globalists, who profited handsomely from extending globalisation beyond the 1980/90s. 😊

[@emmawang1999]

Define help. Help means you offer someone something with nothing in return. Trading relation is not a ``help'' because it is mutually beneficial. In fact, the US gets more out of the trading relation with China than China does. You do not call that help.

[@user-ey6ce3tb2j]

these scenes across America have already given us the answer !!! ' What happened to this Neighborhood? ' ' I've never seen anything like it': Inside the center of the tranq drug crisis ' ' Streets of Philadelphia, Kensington Ave Documentary, October 25-26 2023 ' - youtube

[@hydroac9387]

I would argue that time is not on China's side. The reason? Demographics. China already has one of the lowest birth rates in the world and has one of the fastest aging populations (using Chinese data). The medium estimate is that Chinese population will go from 1.4 billion today to ~750 million by 2100. The worst case scenario is where population will be 650 million by 2100. By ~2085 there may be more post-65 pensioners than working age people. Think about the implications of that for a moment. It is hard to see China as the hegemon of the 21st Century with half empty mega cities comprised mostly of pensioners. In drive home the point, the Shanghai Academy of Social Science (a Chinese think tank) says that the 2020 Chinese census overcounted the Chinese population by 100 million (that is the population of many countries!!!!), almost all of whom are under 40 (e.g - reproductive age). Moreover, most of these missing 100 million are women because during One Child most families preferred sons. In the meantime, the population of the USA will increase according the UN estimates from 330 million currently to slightly less than 400 million by 2100. The reason is that the USA is one of the few countries of immigrants (the other countries of immigrants that come to mind are Australia and Canada) and people want to be here because of economic opportunity. The USA already has a younger population on average than China, and this gulf will only get worse with time. I see hard times for China as it struggles with this problem and the myriad of other problems that will afflict it (such as the housing crisis). This will strain resources and provide Beijing with unpleasant choices.

[@edddiscaya47]

We love u 🇨🇳

[@jimrule8652]

Australia has to do what America wants other wise America will over through the Australian government which they have done in the past, It time for Australian political got together To stop America bullying Australian around ,with a separate political system, We don't do what America wants ,we do what the Australian people want

[@orvilleclisby6748]

I am Australian, there are three major powers in the world; the US, China, and Europe, we must choose which one to side with. But having said that we are not given a choice anyway, we are a conquered people.

[@swatisquantum]

China already controls all the supply lines for literally every product. All Americans do (a great job too) is put it into new packaging, market, and sell it (Apple). What supply chain does America have? America already lost.. but they haven’t realized that this is a multi polar world and it’s better to work together. Wasn’t america championing the benefits of globalism? That every country should do what they’re best at and share it with the world? What happened to that. America wants to use its military industrial complex to gain power over the Asians. Why can’t we just get along? Hasnt there been enough blood shed in the last 200 years?

[@TacticalMayo]

Who told you this crazy nonsense? 🤣 the US controls everything LOL what world do you live in? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@TacticalMayo]

The answer is no.

[@aldofromsf]

Hahahaha!😅

[@csplau]

It’s not about China is winning or not! They just wanna survive! But the truth is that China is ready to compete with any country in the world!

[@TacticalMayo]

That's not how we see it in the United States.

[@csplau]

@@TacticalMayo we live in the democracy world! I respect your views! No issue!

[@TacticalMayo]

@@csplau no we don't live in a democratic world, we used to. You are correct, you are entitled to your opinion.

[@csplau]

@@TacticalMayo yeah! Back to the topic of China! The business model commonly employed by the companies in China involves selling products in bulk at low prices. This strategy is aimed at capturing market share by undercutting competitors. Once these competitors are no longer financially viable, the companies can then potentially increase prices to regain profitability. This approach contrasts significantly with typical Western business strategies, which often focus on brand value and customer loyalty alongside competitive pricing.

[@TacticalMayo]

It is 100% unavoidable.

[@Arcy0429]

Hey, Allan! How could you say that the U.S. wants peace? Iraq, Afghanistan, Vietnam, Korea, Philippines, Ukraine, Israel, etc. Are you joking????😮

[@da_mer89er44]

China we will be respected if not bully Asian neighboring countries and do not grab their land and their shore. Respect the international law of the sea which they also signed in the UN.

[@AmaPeters-pj6pm]

Somebody just teach the Wedt ethics if vonduct gir others

[@kaladass7194]

Does he really assess PRC economy.

[@btgan3838]

If you need some alternative perspectives to the Gordon Chang, Peter Zeihan, and Western msm's "China's Economy is Collapsing" (forever) cries: 1. Prof Radhika Desai, Michael Hudson & Mick Dunford: (Part1) What's China's Future? Economic decline, or the next industrial revolution? kzbin.info/www/bejne/aXyUh56rZrh3mpo 2024.03.12 (1:16:53) (Geopolitical Economy Report) (Part2) The Truths about China's economy: Debunking Western media myths. kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6Stg2iaiJdqp6M 2024.03.21 (1:06:24) (Geopolitical Economy Report) 2. Kevin Walmsley: How did Wall Street lose money in China? By buying high, and selling low, we are the dumb money. kzbin.info/www/bejne/nmLKfKB8fLJmiKs 2024.02.28 (18:20) (Inside China Business) Wall Street investment funds lose billions on Evergrande bonds gamble. kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3S1aYeng8ypqq8 2024.02.29 (13:14) (Inside China Business) US Dollars are racing home to feed titanic deficit spending. Chinese RMB are filling the vacuum. kzbin.info/www/bejne/aqq9fJ2YfMyrfLs 2024.03.28 (16:19) (Inside China Business) 3. Pascal Coopen: The Great Wall of Fear kzbin.info/www/bejne/m2Glp62jdq9pgbM 2024.03.25 (44:53) (Pascal Coopen) 4. Jerry: They say China has peaked: I'm here to tell you they're wrong. kzbin.info/www/bejne/pJaldKZme8ijidU 2024.03.29 (8:40) (Jerry's Take on China) 😊

[@TacticalMayo]

No

[@user-tr5vs9gm4r]

@@TacticalMayo You are a No man. 😂

[@Parasuram5]

Very clearly sold out.

[@senseofliving4724]

..and now China is bullying the Philippines because of their humilation? Remember, Philippine also was colonized. How do you account for that?

[@rap3208]

Bullying? They are only defending their claim on the islands like the Philippines are doing. Those are islands being claimed by several nations, not one officially owns them, the Philippines is making a mistake trying to act tit for tat with China, it will lose -China is much much bigger and richer. Diplomacy and bilateral talks is the only way to go. remember, america colonized the Philippines. The chinese have been to the Philippines since ancient times and it never colonized it, it just traded with the Philippine natives.

[@marinaclarasanchezsuarez2905]

It' d be Lovely to Agree a peaceful way forward, but im afraid its wishfull thinking... China cut the undersea cables btween Estonia & Finnland. NATO found the chinese ship's anchor...

[@pcsing2006]

What is your premise for China cutting undersea cable? Is Estonia and Finland enemies of China?

[@taiwanstillisntacountry]

Sure. And India is a superpower since 2020 and the USA has no debts.

[@taiwanstillisntacountry]

And India is a superpower since 2020 and the USA has no debts

[@michaelmarchal4004]

Top exporter of Ship anchors in the world is 1 China: With 136 millions. India 2 with 31 millions. You see what I mean

[@chriswong9158]

You must knowledge that the Chinese also taking down the Francis Scott Key Bridge collapse by Wishful Thinking.

[@wilsonfu1258]

This guy is a very biased opportunist! Ask him that if he has ever lived in China? Why he gave his fake image that he is the most knowledgeable China expert?!

[@VCSELdiode]

How much CCP poison you had taken?

[@thomaschan7906]

You meant Cunning Criminals Parties of America? Indeed they are very very very toxic and people like you like them stupid and dangerous.

[@wdp7128]

You don't even know that the correct name is CPC. Instead of the ccp you are writing.. Just like America is USA, and not ASU. 😂😂😂

[@akomseni1153]

Never mind him. He’s been on a Kool-Aid diet all these years.

[@isacr4063]

Mahbubani is chinas man.

[@pcsing2006]

And which country are you?

[@taiwanstillisntacountry]

He is from the British-Raj

[@isacr4063]

@@pcsing2006 And why should I tell you? You didn't tell where you are from?

[@pcsing2006]

@@isacr4063 I expected this stupid question. If you're intelligent, you would hae guessed I'm from one of those neighbouring countries were Mahbubani is from. BUT, you're not smart enough to even make a guess so I'll back the question back at you dumbF!🤣

[@tecumsehneo2174]

Mahbubani is humanity's man. May god bless him. I'm American and I thank him for speaking for Americans who want the American elites to stop destroying the world in our name.

[@johnleghorn9756]

I could only subject myself to full duration . How can you talk about China and not even mention the fact that the country / people are dominated / dictated by the CCP even once? This is a waste of time.

[@ZweiZwolf]

The Communist Party of China (CPC) has 100 Million members and over 90% support of the Chinese people because they do a very professional job of governing.

[@ZhenYae]

It ain't the be all and end all. The Western paradigm is not universal. It should not be.

[@2017phattang]

Whi pay for fine money and penalties money high ,who is won and his country everyone won ..

[@derekee1973]

The Kishore Hypocrisy. We Singaporeans despise him. A Person Without Wisdom.

[@rap3208]

Perhaps you despise him because you are racist? or you don't like what you hear from him? Why don't you try disputing his points instead of including the whole singapore in your dislike of him. Show us of his hypocrisy. Just go back up and you'll see some singaporeans say mahbubani is much loved by singaporeans, shall I believe him or you?

[@ZhenYae]

​@@rap3208 Just like there are many Singaporeans who despise LHL for no other reasons other than the handling of the Little Indian Riot.