HasanAbi reacts to Amanda Knox Reflects on Her Trial on the JRE

HasanAbi reacts to Amanda Knox Reflects on Her Trial by ‪@joerogan‬. HasanAbi was left confused about the whole case despite watching the 1h+ long reportage on the case... probably even more confused because the documentation left out a lot of essential events
Original Video: • Amanda Knox Reflects o...
Subscribe for daily HasanAbi react videos: /tinyurl.com/dailydoseofhasanabiSub
Watch more TopVideos! tinyurl.com/dd...
Stay Connected:
► HasanAbi is live daily 11am PST on / hasanabi
► Twitter: / hasanthehun
► KZbin: / @hasanabi
► Instagram: / hasandpiker
Outro: Song: • Hasan is Streaming [Ha... Art: / maggray_art
Thank you all for watching!
Edited by: Daily Dose of HasanAbi
If you own the copyright of the content shown in this video and would like it to be removed or the Ad-Revenue made from it please contact:
► / ddohasanabi
► [e-mail]
About HasanAbi:
Hasan Piker (born July 25, 1991), also known as HasanAbi, is an American Twitch streamer and a left-wing political commentator. If you have watched HasanAbi live on twitch before you might already have listened to his iconic intro:
"What's going on everybody. I hope eveyone's having a fantastic evening, afternoon, prenoon no matter where you are in the world this is Hasan Piker and this is the HasanAbi broadcast coming to you LIVE from (most of the times) sunny California, Los Angeles." Hasan Piker enjoys covering politics, reacting to Jubilee, Channel 5 with Andrew Callaghan (formerly known as Andrew from All Gas No Brakes), Daily Dose Of Internet, Unusual Memes, Joe Rogan, Ben Shapiro and so much more. Usually 1/3 of his 10h+ streams contain gameplay of a variety of games such as the Dark Souls Series, Zelda, GTA V and all of the trendy game releases on PS5, PC and Nintendo Switch.
#HasanAbi #DailyDoseOfHasanAbi #twitch #HasanPiker

[@lexiharris2172]

Let’s not forget the initial victim in all of this: MEREDITH KERCHER. I can only hope she and her father are now reunited in whatever the afterlife brings.

[@hollytree3379]

Meredith is a victim, but Amanda is too. She lost years of her life due to the corruption of Italian authorities. It's like the Harlem Six case, where a woman was raped, but six innocent boys were incorrectly convicted for her assault.

[@lexiharris2172]

@@hollytree3379 I agree Amanda is a victim as well. I was referring to Hasan making this about race for no reason

[@nychris2258]

They were both victims

[@NemesiFPV]

@@hollytree3379 next time they will find my bloodprints, my dna on the scene and on the murder weapon, i will point them to this silly comments. it is honestly baffling that with the amount of incongruences from her, plus her dna all over the place, almost 20 fokkin years later ppl still thinks that she is completley innocent. there were a lot of corruption that is for sure and not only from italian authorities.

[@JRB568]

⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@NemesiFPV ctfu. You should research this case fr. They didn’t find any blood prints from Knox. Her DNA was found at the apartment because SHE LIVED THERE. You can’t be serious bro. No dna on the murder weapon man. It is baffling to assume someone is guilty of murder because you found their DNA in their own apartment. She was just an unlikeable promiscuous American. That’s the only reason she was charged lol. She is obviously the victim of an unfair and ridiculous Justice system.

[@chavez6417]

So where is the actual knife that was used ?!?

[@timffoster6301]

Allegedly found in RS apartment with dna that the defense dismissed at trial

[@carllwalkerjr1682]

This is kinda human nature. Who is the one alive? It’s the person alive and with money that can make the story. The only person that knows the honest truth is the person that is dead. This human if she wanted to show empathy or forgiveness what is she doing? Treating the situation like it’s a game show situation. There isn’t an once of empathy in her body language or speech. She’s sitting there only worrying about what happened to her and showing no compassion for the loss of life. It’s not funny at all.

[@dreamofsprings]

4:00 why did she talk and didnt ask for a lawyer immediataly

[@quinndawsonosgood5261]

What are the laws regarding that in Italy??

[@riase]

She was a naive 20 year old american girl navigating a completely different system. She wanted to be helpful and agreed to be questioned. A guilty person would not have done so.

[@dreamofsprings]

@@quinndawsonosgood5261 i dont know im from sweden. Here in sweden the police doesnt talk to yoy before a lawyer is with you.

[@carlmclemore6104]

Why do most people do that, innocent or not, especially teenagers (Knox was twenty)? Because they stupidly trust the police.

[@lilyungtoaster1304]

@@riase several of the jcs videos are dudes that turned out to be guilty but also tried to "help" the police it is not a guarantee that anyone that helps the authorities is innocent

[@ellaundermae3834]

“Dont get mad at me, but who took the shit?” I know I usually lecture ppl irl bout revolution, socialism and stuff but tbh Im a leftist just for these amazing quotes.

[@Jonmad17]

@@Marco-1997 You mean a trend. Just like Libertarianism in 2008, and lib centrism in 2012.

[@stephenbarry666]

Wut. How's any of this left

[@carlmclemore6104]

Dumbass chat: "She's too cavalier." She's supposed to be broken down and sobbing two decades later.

[@lilyungtoaster1304]

someone in chat said "she has nice triceps"

[@ongobongo8333]

well she did do it, so

[@jeagerjeager9171]

@@ongobongo8333 stop get some help you're insane

[@danielandree3947]

While I agree, it’s only been one decade… it happened in 07 and she spent 4 years in prison getting out in 2011, so it’s been 10 years.

[@Ihasfinger911]

Dumbass chat: Italian cops are totally sigma, she must have dunnit.

[@CR-oc3vy]

I feel like her referring to Meredith as bitch and using such violent terms to hypothetically recount the murder for Joe Rogan, like taking on this light tone with him and mirroring his humour....is extremely disrespectful to the memory of the victim

[@haileybetancourt4115]

I understand how it may seem disrespectful but she's mirroring what the Italian police tried to say her perspective was. I find it more disrespectful that the media surrounding this case made headlines on Amanda and "Foxy Knoxy" and not about the horrible murder or Meredith

[@sweetest-of-memes]

I immediately felt gross when she said that. I understood she was recounting what the Italian police thought happened, but the violent terminology and how casual she was about it was weird. I don't think she did or didn't do it I honestly go back and forth on it, her behavior can just be so weird sometimes.

[@grandsome1]

One of the main problems with the justice system is that if you act weird or look menacing that's often enough to get your ass thrown into prison, the police will bend backwards to put you at the scene of the crime, the prosecutor backed by the police will say some bullshit like "they were acting guilty" or "look at their face, in my 20 years of experience I know what the face of a murderer/guilty person looks like".

[@luneoner]

As a white kid from the hood I was arrested many many times and, let go many many times by sympathetic Judges until, I had face tattoos, The very first time I stood in front of a judge with face tattoos I was held without bail indefinitely or until I agreed to sign the plea deal.. I imagine they would of held me for years before ever allowing me a trial but, after 3 and, a half months I as forced to sign the plea deal in order to attend my murdered brothers funeral... If you want to kiss your white privilege's good by, look no further than some gangster letters on your face... lmmfao

[@illkissyourightnow]

@@luneoner i’m gonna go ahead and say the face tattoos were probably definitely universally the wrong decision…lol

[@luneoner]

@@illkissyourightnow I am a tattooer by trade, it's good for business soooo you're wrong... Judging people on how they look however, def a universally bad decision...

[@bushikciwa]

@@luneoner very insightful experience, hope your life turned for the better

[@Junksaint]

This is absurd lol

[@lexiharris2172]

Wow this guy valid. Reading from his chat like it’s a reliable source. Nice!

[@mytrip6991]

In just the first 3 1/2 minutes, Hasan Abi makes several false claims or statements that show not even the most basic knowledge of the case: 1. "did this dude like know her at all or like he just randomly broke into her house and raped her like i don't understand. Guede had met Kercher very casually a couple of times. He also knew the boys who lived in the downstairs apartment and had been to it on at least 2 occasions, including once when Kercher and Knox there. 2. "she dated him" Neither Kercher nor Knox 'dated' Guede. Not even once. 3. "they said the break-in was staged that's what i read yeah" The police said it was staged because the glass was ONLY on top of things rather than under and that the rock was thrown from the inside. However, testimony from the room's occupant, Filomena Romanelli, said she saw glass both on top and under items. Police photos showed no glass on top of of several items strewn on the floor except for the rug and floor or things that were there before the break-in. 4. "the break-in looked staged because the rock was too big to go through the window." The rock was proved to have been thrown from outside from the parking parapet in a triple reconstruction by a ballistic expert, Francesco Pasquali, and shown in court. He constructed a window of the same size, with the same paint and the same type of glass, and threw the rock through it into a room with the same characteristics as Romanelli's room. Two video cameras -- one inside and one outside -- filmed the rock being thrown through the glass. 5. "like whose poopy was it in the bathroom" Really? It was Guede's as proven by not only his own admission, but by his DNA, as presented in court. 6. "wasn't that some of the first evidence that it couldn't have been a one-man homicide? Um...no. The biological evidence was inconclusive as to whether it "couldn't have been a one-man homicide" or not when it comes to the wounds/abrasions/bruises. That was testified to in court by the pathologist, Dr. Lalli. In fact, several (5+) experts testified it could have been carried out by one person. Only one said it had to be multiple people, an expert hired by the Kerchers. There was NO evidence of anyone else in Kercher's bedroom except for Rudy Guede. No DNA, no fingerprints, no shoe/footprints.

[@Darling_Nicci]

When Joe is talking to people about their stories, their lives he's really good, he does great interviews. I wish he stayed away from politics or from loony people in an effort to "listen to both sides". And stay away from anything Covid.

[@greenmoon8075]

Pretty much , the episode with Daryl Davis is awesome because of this

[@davesprivatelounge]

The problem is he platformed demons

[@muaddib989]

His fighter talks are great as well. Can’t wait till he interviews Khabib Nurmagemov.

[@AxeMurderer1983]

Most of the people he interviews have their own platforms, her story is interesting even without Joe. His exposure certainly helps. It was never episodes like this that made me wary of him.

[@ananousous]

@@davesprivatelounge I look in their eyes, they've got shark eyes, with that little pig smile. They're gone! There's a demon in there running the show!

[@Rapscallion227]

As a person of carbonara, I wouldn’t trust the Italian police. And before anyone says that she only got an appeal due to pressure, Italy regularly convicts and then releases on appeals a shit ton of people. People who usually have done it.

[@sleepwalking1554]

wait a minute, carbonara is a place? or you're just a avid carbonara eater/enthusiast? interesting point nonetheless.

[@rosapaga1776]

Non ho forti opinioni sulla nostra polizia/carabinieri ma dopo aver letto l'articolo di Wikipedia sull'omicidio di Meredith Kercher è chiaro che ad Amanda Knox è stata fatta moltissima pressione per ricevere una "confessione"

[@odoibe3620]

@@sleepwalking1554 hes fucking with u. Look at his name, hes from fucking Finland, the absolute opposite of Italy lol

[@nicholaslornadek8234]

@@rosapaga1776 come altri omicidi dello stesso periodo che diventarono casi mediatici, c'è sempre un certo grado di incompetenza della polizia che rallenta tutto al punto da perdere senso; detto questo io non ho per niente stima della polizia italiana, ma vabbè

[@Rapscallion227]

@@odoibe3620 I just use a Finnish handle lol

[@zakaryrichmond396]

I love how you can see joe try to use his brain he looks up when he needs to think otherwise his brain is just shut off

[@beepboopbleep3695]

he's always trying to figure out why someone he likes isn't racist

[@zakaryrichmond396]

@@beepboopbleep3695 or alternatively if your brain is constantly shut off you don't have to acknowledge it at all its like they aren't saying it

[@shmadeshlimore3322]

Im gonna assume the irony of the illiteracy in this post is lost on you.

[@zakaryrichmond396]

@@shmadeshlimore3322 sorry for missing one (1) period but not all of us are too stupid to understand a simple comment

[@CarlsCozyCorner]

@@alwaysright5593 what is American standard white? Joe is American and he's white. He's white.

[@HonRevPTB]

And yes she did apologize profusely to Patrick La Mumba for accusing him after they sleep deprived and beat it out of her!!!!!!! She also tried to recant the testimony immediately and wasn't allowed!!!!!!!

[@cornpop7805]

I've had multiple ex-cops tell me never to be interviewed without an attorney and never accept anything to eat or drink from the cops. The cops use something called a "sloppy coffee", which is a drug that makes you barely lucid, but still able to talk. Then they tell you a story over and over and ask you to remember. Eventually, the person will repeat the story the cops have been telling. They told her that the text to her boss was to meet up with him, so she said he came over.

[@HonRevPTB]

@@cornpop7805 That's probably true!

[@cornpop7805]

@@HonRevPTB Also, never talk to feds - EVER! The majority of the convictions they get are for perjury, which gets you 3 to 5 years (I believe for every count). The problem is, this isn't something you have to say under oath, it could just be them coming to your door, asking you questions about someone or something else they're investigating. Also, you don't have to actually lie, just say something that doesn't jive with what someone else says and they're going to charge someone with perjury. It's like they get points for putting innocent people in prison for perjury. The best defense is to never talk to a fed, unless you are sitting with your attorney and you're totally ready.

[@84blizzle]

So because the upper middle class white girl stereo typed a black guy in her 20s that means she's capable of murder as well? This is one of the most frustrating things about people who's content is driven by politics. The way you nit pick to stimulate your animosity against someone makes you incapable of seeing nuances. Amanda Knox is/was a dumb ass, especially at 20, but there's more evidence to support her innocence for murder than not. And just because the black guy was stereo typed doesn't mean he didn't do it.

[@__yklim]

If you racist just say that

[@marlock6573]

She didn't stereotype anybody. It was that cops who came to the conclusion that her boss was in on the crime and manipulated her into implicating him. The local authorities in Perugia also refused to let him reopen his bar for months after they knew he had nothing to do with the case. He blames Knox, but the racist Italian cops are the ones who ruined his life. Also, Hasan's understanding of this case is based on incredibly biased UK press coverage.

[@davidhughes4089]

She's such a psychopath, I'm not being hateful towards all Americans but the way her supporters portrayed they were "rescuing" her from the justice system of another comparable nation is so typical of the way the US shields it's citizens from prosecution when they commit crimes overseas. There was the senior airforce officer's (or maybe a diplomats?) wife in the UK that killed someone because she was driving on the wrong side of the road, they just flew her out of the country to avoid her standing trial - it's disgusting when they lecture the world on the rule of law.

[@nicholaslornadek8234]

jeez so weird seeing this, it was such a big story here in Italy while i was in high school, not to mention how nowdays Sollecito is a meme edgelord guy...

[@CP-ir3ft]

sollecito is what? lol

[@nicholaslornadek8234]

@@CP-ir3ft Like two years ago he became infamous in italian facebook meme pages cause he kept shitposting or making edgelord comments related to the murder and things like that

[@yeraldyncaceres3792]

@@nicholaslornadek8234 wow, is the consensus in Italy that they got away with murder ?

[@nicholaslornadek8234]

@@yeraldyncaceres3792 kinda, many people think he got away with it, especially older people, i personally think the situation is such a mess (police was abhorrent, but it always is, no matter where you look at) that there will never be one straight answer to what happened I also remember the media here in Italy salivating about the chance to charge an black immigrant

[@Broken-xi5io]

That is so fucked up.

[@alexandersalmas21]

I can't blame Hasan too much because that documentary was pretty bad but he was weirdly biased against Amanda Knox the whole time and most of his chat follow him. He assumed a total cop mentality of guilt as the default against Amanda.

[@diegorivera6500]

Not really. She was not even a person of interest in the beginning. She went to the police station insisting of being with his bf Rafaello and there was when she wanted to do a statement blaming his boss, Patrick. Why did the Italian police want to frame an American girl when they know all the media would scrutinised the case? She went on holiday to a nice European country she was not in Iran or China

[@marlock6573]

@@diegorivera6500 LOL Where are you getting your information about the case? British tabloids from ten years ago?

[@jacobchalkler1652]

I can't believe people watch this guy lmap

[@NotSandraBullock]

Meredith: *r-worded, stabbed to death* Amanda: I’m the real victim here. I feel for Meredith’s family. I hope they have found peace especially since their daughter’s roommate has taken the spotlight/attention from what happened to their child.

[@vinnym5607]

So Amanda Knox appeared on Rogan? Yeah, she guilty.

[@LemonSte]

there's a lot of circumstantial evidence that makes her seem suspicious imo, but her blaming an innocent man isn't one of them. the way she described it during and after the fact is a perfect example of what happens when an interrogated person is under a lot of duress and is directly offered not only a scapegoat, but a theoretical version of events that they're told DID happen so many times they get confused and start to believe they had blocked out the memory. They showed her the texts between her and her boss and created a narrative for her to agree to. I think hi race was a component, but less so on her side as much as the italian police who put him forward as a possible suspect just because they literally texted the same night. she's constantly saying 'it COULD have happened', no outright statements of fact, which is very common language in these scenarios. It happens every day, it's why even though the viral video of detectives cracking psychopaths are entertaining and fascinating, they really gloss over the fact that many many vulnerable, innocent people are talked into false confessions on a regular basis.

[@chigeh]

Kind of annoying that Hasan skipped over her version of why she "blamed" the innocent black dude. That confession was basically suggested to her over an over because she recently had received a text from her boss (the innocent black dude). Hasan was being biased in blaming her for racism. (or it was the police who was being racist, that is a possibility).

[@muaddib989]

How is he biased. She DID blame the black guy and then blamed another black guy.

[@AlexeiKazakov-s7i]

@@muaddib989 i would love to see you act differently at age 20 in a foreign country without knowing the language your interrogators are using, suspected for murder and act differently.

[@muaddib989]

@@AlexeiKazakov-s7i I wouldn’t blame my black employer for it. There’s gotta be a way to say “I’m not guilty but neither is the black guy I know”

[@StoveToTheFace]

@@AlexeiKazakov-s7i So it's ok if you're scared?

[@AlexeiKazakov-s7i]

@@muaddib989 dont disagree, i believe the interrogators heavily implied to her though that she could blame the black guy and go away scot free and with the added pressure of the pretty inhumane things Italian police do in interrogations i think she cracked and just said what they wanted to hear. still of course doesn't justify what she did but i dont thinks its right to say its all her fault.

[@ixiladams4275]

I am half way through this and I watched the doc with Hasan’s reaction. I literally don’t understand anything about the case. What’s the evidence and who did it? I’m so confused haha

[@tylerbingo1022]

yeah def watch the netflix doc. the bbc doc is shockingly bad lmao

[@justingifford4425]

Are you regarded? The documentary lays it out. DNA was used to convict her, but later examination showed that the DNA evidence her was bunk.

[@peewee450]

The people in chat are flat out wrong: the forensic tests done all point to guede as being the killer of meredith kercher: 1. Guede admitted he was in the room 2. Guede’s semen was found in and on meredith’s body 3. Guede’s DNA and meredith’s blood were found in her purse 4. Guede’s excrement was found in the toilet 5. Guede’s shoeprints and handprints of meredith’s blood were found in the bedroom, pillow, and hallway 6. Guede fled the country shortly after the incident Not to mention: The official DNA tests confirmed Amanda’s DNA was never found in the room meredith was killed And the tactics used to get information out of amanda were extremely manipulative giving her a bad image to the public. (I’ve actually spoken to amanda dont assume i get all this from a netflix documentary) more importantly though don’t forget the victim of the murder and how painful her experiences must have been.

[@mnbgt101]

5:56 chat message flew by that killed me "that guy is notoriously racist in the oldschool runescape community"

[@cornpop7805]

One year of foriegn language, as taught in the US puts you at a kindergartner level. My wife is no dummy (she's now a science professor at a major university) yet she's had 3yrs of high school French and when we to France, she couldn't speak at a 2nd grade level.

[@Vgs183]

I still think she’s guilty

[@timffoster6301]

She knows more for sure

[@TheSupernaturalx3]

There's a really good Lifetime documentary on this case, with Hayden Panettiere playing Amanda Knox.

[@Pikachu-qr4yb]

You lost me at Lifetime

[@Jonmad17]

Imagine saying "Lifetime" and "good" in the same sentence.

[@Anthonycheesman33]

I feel bad for her if she's actually innocent lol.

[@DoneDealAC]

She is the killer you simp

[@samuelbekele3601]

@@DoneDealAC Citation needed

[@CP-ir3ft]

@@DoneDealAC source: dude trust me

[@CP-ir3ft]

@Shaheen Shad then explain what makes her guilty

[@CP-ir3ft]

@Shaheen Shad ok so you don't have anything.

[@arago90]

this lady knows something i dont know if she did it or not but FOR SURE she knows whats up, she is sus as fuck. By the way this is my biggest fear as a world traveler to end up in a fucking foreign jail out of nowhere that shit terrifies me

[@DT-471]

I wonder if she'll find a way to profit from all of this similarly to like how OJ wrote a book titled " If I Did It".

[@richrod0122]

She did write her book but most of the profit was used on legal expenses

[@scoobertmcruppert2915]

That’s literally what we are watching right now….

[@TheTruthCalls]

@star child As if giving interviews is somehow illegal. As for asking her wedding guests (those were the only people who were supposed to see the request) to donate cash instead of gifts is a very common thing to do, and to in any way suggest this has any bearing on the case or it's aftermath is illogical. But then, haters are gonna hate, and star child, you are a hater.

[@jujutrini8412]

She has.

[@kingcrab1924]

Her and oj are both ♋ that's the top killer sign according to fbi

[@alwayshaley325]

This is so frustrating to watch

[@Rozzebella]

Joe literally asked how did you FEEL when you found out she was dead and she did everything but actually answer that question

[@jess_bounce]

14:11 He literally did not ask that question. She answered the question he asked. She described how she found out and her thoughts about it

[@isoakkfgy4462]

@@jess_bounce yea and she thought ‘someone close to me died and that couldve been me’, kind of odd thing to think.

[@og666]

she literally said "confused"

[@ScorpioSW]

So many in chat are like "oh she is guilty" or "she didn't do it" like they really know anything... there is just too little information to make that call. Even after the "documentary" we maybe have like 5% of all the info about the case and even that was described in such a bad messy way. Unfortunately this is a case where without actually going back in time and witnessing it we have no way to know for sure how it exactly happened and if those 2 were actually involved.

[@mytrip6991]

The Supreme Court of Italy has annulled Knox's calunnia conviction and ordered a new trial. It was ruled in 2008 that the statements Knox signed on Nov. 6 during the interrogation were not admissible in the defamation case but only in the murder case against her. Without those statements, it's likely the conviction will be annulled. If the calunnia conviction is annulled, the fine awarded to Lumumba will also be annulled. THIS is why Knox's lawyers advised her NOT to pay the fine awarded to Lumumba until all legal avenues had been exhausted.

[@hg-p7542]

What I got from this, is that you are incapable of admitting being wrong. You get *close* occasionally, but it's immediately followed up with justifications of why it's not your fault, and doubling down on demonstrably false previous assertions. Hard to watch.

[@cazperw3557]

All the reddit detectives in chat LOL

[@RandomU5erName]

Who's next Casey Anthony

[@dadcaylor1385]

You think Mario down at the corner Pizza Shop has an attitude? Sicilian conservative judges. Forget about it

[@dirtmasta2960]

"Instead of saying we made a mistake they doubled down." Just like when Joe said all his episodes would go to Spotify and when they didn't he denied any knowledge but come to find out he agreed to drop some episode to sell his soul to Spotify. And then to talk about power and cronyism like he also doesn't have power and influence, and didn't move to Texas to better himself from the government.. how about next episode he says it's all about taking care of yourself and your body while drinking and smoking cigars... Wait... Fuck... WHO THE FUCK LISTENS TO THIS GUY AND THINKS HES ACTUALLY GENUINE!? 30seconds in and I want to lose my mind...

There is a difference between recreationaly smoking or drinking and doing it every day or so. Joe looks healthy for his age.

[@guy2334]

song at the end was Awesome :)

[@cxjar5890]

This woman gives me the creeps.

[@michellebelle5327]

I don’t believe her. She’s guilty.

[@NorthWestPvPlolrektnoob]

well it doesn’t matter if you believe her because she was acquitted and is innocent

[@michellebelle5327]

@@NorthWestPvPlolrektnoob doesn’t matter that she was acquitted she’s still guilty

[@diegorivera6500]

She wasn’t interrogated for three days for gods sake. Stop lying

[@friendsmaster12233]

Imagine cops all knowing each other and looking out for each other? Outrageous!

[@toastonryeYT]

So what's her motive for murdering this girl? First time hearing this case and this clip is confusing as fuck.

[@sirrios02]

Why are you in my feed? I keep saying I'm not interested in your videos yet you keep popping up

[@Apathesis0]

Rudy was definitely involved.

[@Hobbit0nCN]

Wouldn’t her and Meredith have had mutual friends who knew of their relationship? Amanda is super sussy but honestly what the hell is her motive to kill a girl once in such a sloppy way?

[@Elemenace]

AND she kills Rogan out of pure killer instinct.

[@chaosactually311]

I don't think she's actually guilty based on what we actually know, but, she really does sound guilty. I wish I had access to all the info the police had.

[@anon123214]

There's still a lot to her story and the events that don't add up. Couple that with never apologizing for accusing an innocent and I smell some rank shit coming from her.

[@Darkpara1]

The Italian police are so lazy, there probably isn't much actual evidence

[@ongobongo8333]

I mean her DNA was on the murder weapon lmao

[@CP-ir3ft]

@@ongobongo8333 it was on the handle. you can use a knife for cooking.

[@Matkustajakone]

@@ongobongo8333 The handle of the knife from the victim's kitchen had her roommate's DNA on it? What a shocker, it's like... she lived in the same apartment 🤯

[@audreydavidson7357]

the hasan is streaming song always makes me cry

[@Apathesis0]

14:11 a lot of obfuscation

[@johnviera3884]

No one heard a woman screaming bloody murder? Maybe because another person was holding her mouth.

[@mytrip6991]

Or because she had a knife held to her throat? Or because her throat had been sliced open and she was physically incapable of screaming?

[@OliverFlinn]

How nice of Roe Jogan to platform murderers

[@lexusgodina2296]

I don’t know what I like that she called Meredith a bitch even though it was a hypothetical paraphrase. Just doesn’t seem very respectful. I don’t think she did it anymore but she’s a bit narcissistic which I don’t enjoy.

[@rdg7250]

She would be in prison without her privilege and italophobia !

[@wetjigsawpuzzle7]

she is doing such a bad job answering the questions

[@everything.for.a.reason]

I think she made an interview or two before coming to Joe Rogan.

[@waka1834]

I think this whole interview is pretty hypocritical cause if it was someone who had the same experience from american cops he wouldnt be as hard on them

[@lexiharris2172]

That’s a fair point

[@Parsrebel]

lol yes he would. He literally just had a guest who was framed and wrongfully imprisoned by cops here, and Rogan said they should throw the book at all law enforcement involved.

[@waka1834]

@@Parsrebel it was noticeably different in the types of probing questions he asked you can tell how there is a bias there, in the amanda knox there was more speculation on how cops couldve fucked up whereas the video you’re mentioning joe asked broader questions and left it more to his guest to talk about the subject

[@artomarto679]

And the Oscar goes to... Dun dun dun..

[@kennybrown3085]

Although that this is a quiet little college town. There is a criminal element in Perugia. Not only locals but immigrants who are hardworking and those who are there to exploit the trusting nature of the young college students. These students think that because they are in a beautiful Italian place they are safe. Well that is not the case. I was approached by West African young men who wanted me to give them my credit card so they could buy goods like televisions. And sell them. Then I would report my card stolen so I wouldn't be charged. It's not a black and white issue. It's a crime of opportunity. And said to say yes there are dangerous people of different races there in Perugia. There is also a huge drug dealing Muslim influence. Mostly Algiers and Morocco as well as other groups.

[@moz4639]

Don't know if she did it or not but she looks like a female version of american psycho to me

[@anthonyl9126]

Yeah, most of her prosecution was constructed on similar logic. She looks guilty therefore she must have done it.

[@HAOSxy]

4:08 AHAHAHAHAHAHAH like our interrogations can get people to "crack", man this shows the lack of knowledge regarding the incompetence of our(italian) legali system

[@adamp2426]

Don't trust her.

[@adriandaniels1]

I was listening to a podcast about this case and there was an explanation for Amanda's DNA on the knife. I think it was basically that Amanda spends time with her boyfriend, cooks with him, so uses the utensils.. and of course because Meridith was killed with the knife, her DNA would be on there too. But lab results ( re examined at a later date) showed that there was only a trace amount, suggesting some kind of interference. kzbin.info/www/bejne/g5m4i6GveZ6Yo68 2:08:20

[@anthonyl9126]

It's not just that. We like to think that evidence of a crime is meticulously handled all the way until it's analyzed at a crime scene. Nope. Not here. They were fucking mixing clothes and items and shuffling them all around and none of it was with the care you would expect from professionals. The fact a mere speck of Amanda's dna was found is shocking.

[@scoobertmcruppert2915]

@@anthonyl9126 Lmao She killed her roommate…face it.

[@anthonyl9126]

@@scoobertmcruppert2915 don't give me shit just because you don't care about facts and evidence my dude.

[@adriandaniels1]

@@scoobertmcruppert2915 you should listen to that podcast! Gives additional info. They're pretty good at gathering information whenever talking about their segments. Just listen Christine's though.

[@TheTruthCalls]

Actually, the knife did not have Meredith's DNA on it nor was it the murder weapon. Meredith suffered three major knife wounds. Two of them couldn't possibly have been made by the kitchen knife. The depth of the third wound was less than a third the length of the kitchen knife blade. Since the wound was made into soft tissue and did not strike bone or cartilage it's very unlikely a long bladed knife made the wound. Further, there was bruising around the perimeter of the wound consistent with a knife hilt striking the skin. Finally, there was an imprint of a knife blade, much smaller than the kitchen knife, found on the bed sheets made in blood. All three wounds were consistent with a much smaller knife like the one that made the imprint. The ONLY reason the kitchen knife ever became 'the murder weapon' is because they needed something - anything - to link Amanda to the crime. The problem was, the incompetent police, not knowing anything about the wounds, went and grabbed a ridiculously large knife, all but eliminating it as the weapon. Another clue as to the police desperation is that the sample from the knife (36B) tested negative for blood, negative for human species (i.e., it was not human biological material) and despite multiple runs it repeatedly returned a result of "Too Low" from the Qubit Flurometer used to quantify DNA. In other words, per the lab equipment the sample wasn't DNA. Undaunted, Stefanoni still amplified the sample and managed to get a faint trace of Meredith, which is almost certainly nothing more than lab contamination.

[@mockdawg]

I'm watching a podcaster watch a podcast.. Why do we have this...?

[@twt3716]

Obviously guilty.

[@TheTruthCalls]

Obviously you know nothing of the case.

[@twt3716]

@@TheTruthCalls Happy in your assumptions ? Bellend.

[@TheTruthCalls]

@@twt3716 Bellend? Now that's nasty... shame on you! But no, I wasn't assuming. You said "Obviously guilty", which is a clear indication you don't know anything about the case since there's no evidence of involvement. And no, it does not make me happy pointing this out, but someone has to do it.

[@twt3716]

@@TheTruthCalls Guilty as sin.

[@TheTruthCalls]

@@twt3716 Yes, yes... we've already established you believe that, just as we've already established you know nothing of the case. You don't need to prove it.

[@aaronallan8652]

“This will help” a mother fucking Reddit article I’m dead.

[@perryj1230]

Hasan Piker? Is that you? Why'd you change your screen name? 😂

[@marylandsworld3428]

She likes the word obviously when nothing was obvious in this case

[@cornpop7805]

Why does the documentary not mention Fillamino (the other roommate)?

[@timffoster6301]

That all knew each other The case files are interesting Alleged breaking evidence Testimonies, hair samples and luminol tests.

[@Punkrock.Chrysalis]

It seems like that documentary did no favors to the truth.

[@YakimaBob]

Get your facts straight. Knife was not at the boyfriends house

[@SparkySteve.]

Giving this murderer a platform is absolutely disgusting. All the evidence and her blatant lying shows she was not only present on the murder, but was holding the murder weapon. Absolutely abhorrent

[@mytrip6991]

LOL. The alleged murder weapon that was found NOT to have any blood on it and NO DNA of Kercher and incapable of making the smaller knife wounds? Yes, she held a knife she had been using to cook with for the past week. "All the evidence"? Hmmm. What 'evidence' would that be? Her DNA, fingerprints and foot/shoeprints that were NOT found in Kercher's bedroom?

[@Graeberwave]

If you saw the documentary, you would see she was not guilty. End of story.

[@ongobongo8333]

documentarys, especially on Netflix, are biased as fuck. the scene was staged and her DNA was on the weapon. she at least hid evidence and tried to cover it up. why?

[@Graeberwave]

@@ongobongo8333 GOOD I WANT BIAS. You acting like you don't is really funny. Oh you want to talk about evidence??!?!?

[@sommerblume9671]

@@Graeberwave Thanks for the brain damage reading that. I hope you’re not a native English speaker

[@anthonyl9126]

@@ongobongo8333 yes, biased for the truth and what actually happened. Netflix interviewed her overzealous prosecutor too if it makes you feel any less skeptical. Listen to what Amanda says @3:05 this is literally the scenario that they painted against her.

[@jamesbraniff7834]

Ask Patric Lumumba about Amanda.

[@marylandsworld3428]

What’s weird is she went in and got a shower and went back to the house with her boyfriend and they lied about calling the police and what time... then the weapon was at her bf’s house. She also tried to have black dude locked up. She didn’t explain buying the cleaning supplies. They turned off their phones and lied about what time they woke up.

[@Broken-xi5io]

There is so much evidence of Amanda being at the crime scene the night it happened, and evidence that someone was trying to stage a cover up. But what really makes me believe she is guilty is her blaming the innocent bar owner LaMumba I think was his name. No matter how exhausted you are or afraid you have to be a psycho to just want to throw an innocent man in prison like that. Also how tf was the murder weapon in her bf's house if they weren't there the night it happened.

[@LackofEthics]

the most "wtf chat" video yet

[@KarlMarxUSA]

She did it, right? or no...?

[@stoneyisland007]

12:20 Vaccine side effects!!

[@emresevindik2977]

Rudy took a duty

[@ceaseless246]

she did it

[@mr.dr0bot731]

So you meet someone and live with them for a few weeks then all of a sudden they are murdered. Doesn't sound sussy at all.

[@TheTruthCalls]

So you live your entire 20+ years a goofy, athletic, fun loving person who never hurt a fly and then suddenly you become a cold blooded killer. Doesn't sound sussy at all.

[@NorthWestPvPlolrektnoob]

your opinion is automatically invalid because you said sussy

[@chrispeterson4463]

I just can’t see a Joe Rogan interview without thinking, “but he’s so dumb..”

[@tylerhackner9731]

Oh damn lol

[@openmind2161]

She is involved

[@cornpop7805]

Forget the rock not fitting through the window, it was clearly done after the fact. 1) The girl would have fled the house if someone threw a giant rock through the window. 2) The girl was lying in the room where the glass was on the floor and the bottom of her foot was NOT cut to hell. 3) The cops said there was glass on top of the blanket that covered her, not underneath it. Knowing that the rock was after the fact does not help indicate who killed her. As far as their odd behavior, I think Amanda and her boyfriend were high as sh!t and paranoid fuk. They showed up and found the body of the girl, and thinking they would be blamed, starting doing weird shit and acting strange. Remember, they were there when the postal cops showed up. Can you imagine that bad trip? We know the one guy admitted to raping the girl and we know that she's dead. Stabbed with two different knives 40+ times and her knowing karate doesn't indicate that 3 different people were involved. One guy raping her and killing her with knife in each hand is very plausible. She might have called him a racial slur as he was raping her...

[@TheTruthCalls]

You got an awful lot wrong with this post. The rock absolutely fit not only through the window, but through the break in the glass. Forensically speaking, there is nothing to contradict the rock being thrown to break the window to get into the cottage. Meredith might have fled the house if a rock (NOT a "giant" rock) was thrown through the window if she was there. But since we know Guede's second trip to the cottage happened around 20:30 and Meredith didn't return home until 21:00, there's every reason to believe he broke in well before she arrived home. Meredith was found in her bedroom, the break-in occurred in Filomena's bedroom, so there is no reason to expect her foot to be "cut to hell" There was testimony that glass was found on top of clothes in Filomena's bedroom, not on the duvet in Meredith's bedroom. Further, most of the glass was found under the clothes and across the floor. Guede did not admit to raping Meredith. He claimed their sexual contact was consensual. This is one of those lies that not even the pro-guilt accept. There is no evidence that two knives were used, this was just a theory of the police. All of the physical evidence is consistent with a single knife, much smaller than the kitchen knife the police took from Raffaele's kitchen. Meredith suffered only three major knife wounds. All of the other injuries were minor nicks and scrapes, not stab wounds.

[@cornpop7805]

@@TheTruthCalls Wait a minute, I'm a random guy on the internet, I can't be wrong about anything! How dare you?

[@TheTruthCalls]

@@cornpop7805 Hey, don't stress it. Over the years I've run into the occasional Internet posters who got a thing or two wrong, but don't take that as an insult... I'm sure you're a helluva nice guy. You just got a few things wrong about this case and I thought I'd help you out. No thanks necessary... happy to help. Oh, and Happy New Year (a wee bit early, but...).

[@cornpop7805]

@@TheTruthCalls Thanks and Happy New Years. Also, you're right I'm a hellava nice guy!

[@NateD4WGG]

wait. netty pots are dangerous?... .

[@madalyn6230]

idk why he said that lol my doctor always advises me to use sinus rinses like neti pots. maybe he’s thinking of the stories of people using neti pots with tap water rather than distilled

[@NorthWestPvPlolrektnoob]

they are dangerous if you don’t use distilled water.

[@francesco8000]

She is innocent in the same way O.J. Simpson is innocent.

[@HiNRGboy]

I think she's hot, i need therapy lol

[@Darkpara1]

It was a big thing when the story broke that she was a fox

[@timffoster6301]

Jodi Arias…… just saying

[@KT-pu3gn]

Yo she's one of those people that you meet, and as much as they are smiling and being nice you can tell they're fake af

[@Dark_Hart]

She had to be at least an accomplice in the murder.

[@onaaap]

Honestly I feel like this girl knows what happened, she gives me the creeps

[@Badbufon]

yeah, the way she talks about the victim sounds like a robot trying to sound human.

[@littlegravitas9898]

@Gertrude Bell you get it was over a decade ago, was a person she only knew for a few weeks and that maybe any emotion may have been rung out of her in jail? Just saying, you seem to have strange views about how people act over time and are using that as evidence?

[@anthonyl9126]

She's not sobbing uncontrollably over an event that hasn't escaped her life everyday since it happened. Totally suspect.

[@onaaap]

@@anthonyl9126 exactly, see? you get it lol🙄

[@Badbufon]

@@thingusbingus1268 I mean, in that case I won't just act based on my gut instinct, I was just sharing that eerie uncanny valley feeling while hearing her talk like a human.

[@kuleaidmaster3247]

She def did it

[@LowTempDabr]

Hasan "I cant go one minute without bringing up racism" Piker

[@somebody355]

She def did that shit