Heartland Season 18 Episode 5 Breakdown & Ending Explained | Amy, Caleb, and Nathan's Love Triangle!

[@josephfratto]

The real success of Heartland was and still is the Amy and Ty love story. The dating in the season 18 trailer and the current episodes especially Amy's relationship with Nathan is simply the writers attempt to keep the storyline interesting, and not boring.Assuming Ty doesn't return the writers will conclude the series with Amy unable to accept another(not just because Ty can't be replaced} because of her continuing strong love and feelings for Ty. She will conclude that her peace and happiness is with her as a single mother raising Lindy in the manner Ty would have wanted. In my opinion, because we had 14 years of this remarkable love story, whereby the viewers got to intimately know Ty, it makes it nearly impossible to erase him from the viewers minds and on a larger scale future Heartland seasons. It's a testament toTy's impact on the series, in that he still remains the topic of much fan discussion and love even though he has been missing for over 4 years.

[@tinaathanasakos7933]

Ty should be the only person to bring back the sparkle in Amy's eyes. I don't see a sparkle. I see deep sadness in Amy trying to cover it up with this nonsense Nathan thing. Joseph Fratto describes it very well why Amy and the viewers cannot accept anyone other than Ty for Amy, wether he comes back or not. In reality, Ty has never left us. God Bless!

[@tinaathanasakos7933]

When does Ty come back? It's the only reason I'm still watching this show.

[@lexiesawaya2355]

He’s not coming back. I’m sorry. I still think it’s a good show though

[@tinaathanasakos7933]

If he's not coming back then I'm done with Heartland. I can't stand to see Amy betraying Ty. I'll stick to the old reruns - the REAL Heartland!!!

[@tinaathanasakos7933]

I can't stand Nathan! Season 18 is ruining Amy's character! I used to love this show - it used to be my favourite. The internet keeps talking about Ty coming back. I can't wait for Ty to come back and kick the pants off Nathan the way he did with Prince Ahmed and Chase! Nathan makes me nauseous! Go home Nathan! Amy wake up and get your integrity back! You have a daughter to raise and be a good example!

[@patdumont1686]

I love Nathan!!! He is bringing a sparkle back into Amy's eyes!