Henry vs Marlin

[@hickok45]

If you're perplexed about the NRA plug, you must have missed our NRA Announcement video, as well as recent "Shooting the Breeze " videos. This video was recorded prior to our decision to stop recruiting for the NRA. Many did not agree with our allowing the NRA to be a sponsor, and now many do not agree with our dropping them as a sponsor. Another reminder that everybody just has to do what they think is best and let the chips fall, or rather let the Trolls Troll and the Haters Hate. :-)

[@TKO593]

We all know you wouldn’t do a thing to hurt the 2nd amendment. Sometimes you got to use some Kentucky windage.

[@maxcady645]

Yes sir, good to see some more lever guns! :-)

[@mr.painfultruth2771]

I posted an anti NRA comment but JUST READ THIS...OOPS , thanks for the explanation brother

[@danwendt2169]

Review the ruger 44mag carbine semi auto rifle please hickock 45 .

[@MrUberZombie]

Man guys yall do you. We all know that your the man.

[@jimmyruger7529]

I been watching Mr Hickok for years. Hes just a knowledged, down to Earth, Solid Man.

[@cbo9090]

They say he has a way bigger gun than John Holmes ever had too.

[@codyallen2838]

@@cbo9090 Ha! He does put off that energy

[@craiglarson3759]

hickok45 is a real gentleman. . .i watch a lot of blogs and i know most of the guys that have pages. . .there is nothing in his manner that is abrasive whatsover----no cursing, eff-bombs etc. ----just the facts, delivered in a gracious & humble manner ---the world needs more of his ilk

booooooooring.........give me a few cusswords and throw in some insults.............

[@devinharrison5359]

Two christmases ago my Grandpa gave me my great-grandfather's Marlin 336 .30-.30 that he bought new in back in the 60s or so and it has been the best rifle I've ever used. I hope one I'll be able to pass it along to my grandson😊

[@Dad2ADaughter_Cpt_Blakesbeard]

I love my brushed nickel Marlin. Gives off Wild West vibes. Hoping I can pass it along to my daughter before they make that illegal.

[@PatriotPaulUSA]

We're so lucky Ruger picked up Marlin when Remington went down. I am sure Ruger will have Marlins being made better than ever. I am partial to the brass Henry's myself, but both are beautiful guns.

[@johnsnyder1751]

Yes. Remington is garbage

[@jesusisalive3227]

The new marlins are selling for way above msrp. I'd love to buy one but just can't afford $2500 for a $1500 rifle.

[@davematney1918]

@@jesusisalive3227 yeah. True street price should eventually be around 1200

[@tombeacher9667]

@@davematney1918 probably going to take 3 years to get there

[@johnserrano9689]

@@jesusisalive3227 You ain't kidding hey lol wtf is goin on man! Free market is meant to create competitive pricing....but when they can make an extra couple hundred dollars all at the same time they say fck the Workin Man.. Thank God Himself my local shop is owned/ran by a dam good man too, picked up my Henry 30-30 side gate all brass for I believe like 1015 bucks out the door. If you were to find one (it was incredibly difficult to find one when I did too) you know dam well it'd be much more expensive. Still waiting to find either an X or an all weather in .44 mag aswell as the little pea shooter 45-70... Henry's raised the bar so high overall man it's forced Ruger to make damn sure the Marlins start to bring back some of that good ole American Pride. That's a win there I guess 👍🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

[@thomasfreeman3262]

The fit and finish on my Henry's is second to none on my lever actions. I own both Marlin and Henry lever actions. There is absolutely no comparison in machining and attention to detail between the two. Henry is without a doubt the better firearm in that arena. As far as accuracy is concerned, I cannot tell any noticeable difference inside 100 - 150 yards. As always Mr. Hickok is majorly objective and spot on. Thanks again for all you do for the shooting community with these videos.

[@garytotty3971]

Marlin seven days a week and twice on Sunday.

[@kevinrollman3101]

Remington Marlin were the first ones to make the carriers out of billet block steel instead of machining. I do not believe Henry nor Winchester do this. I realize now what looks so different about Henry forearm stocks. They are elongated and flat, verses Marlin’s being more rounded.

[@davidshapiro7361]

I just got handed down a 1949 marlin 336 and I love it. Such a smooth and satisfying gun.

[@thanos9846]

Same. 1950s 336SC in .35 Remington. What a gem.

[@bjarkehansen4911]

yes they were nice then. Today naaah want henry

[@Bucky1836]

@J Mills the same ZAMAK that hi point uses

[@uralbob1]

Lucky, lucky you! Happy for you brother! NEVER sell it!

[@likesanddislikesetc]

David Shapiro it’s a very good all around hunting rifle

[@umphman6253]

I own three Henry lever-action rifles and one Marlin lever-action rifle. I can vouch for the accuracy and smoothness of the Henry vs the Marlin. Fit, Finish, and quality of the gun are superior in every way to the Marlin. If you can only buy one lever-action rifle, buy a Henry, you always get rave reviews from friends and fellow shooters regardless of size and bullet caliber. Also, if you ever need service there is a huge difference. Henry will send you a mailing label and return it within a week to ten days. Sometimes they can do it even faster. I returned a Henry pump twice because I was unhappy with the smoothness of the action and Anthony Imperato called me and said He's sending me a replacement Pump-action or any other gun of my choice in the same caliber. I chose a Silver Boy. That's customer service when the President of a company follows up personally on a service call. I don't know what Marlin would do but Henry is famous for their Service and lifetime warranty.

[@olcowhand]

The Henry warranty is second to NONE! Simply can't be beat! I had to buy the only remaining golden 45-70 side gate at my local gun shop, and found a small putty repair in rear stock nest to sling lug. Got home and immediately sent them a message and did not see the spot to send them a pic. This was Monday, and Friday, just 4 days later, I receive not only a rear stock complete with butt plate and sling lug, but also a new fore stock! WOW was all I could say when I got them! Fantastic service, bar none!

[@Jerry-jg1uc]

@@olcowhand I wouldn't say their warranty is second to none. I had a Henry after a few Range days it started to jam. The magazine tube had came loose and was causing it to jam. I called Henry and the guy o talked to said to "send it in and we'll replace the tube, it probably won't fix it but we can try." I asked if it didn't fix it would they be willing to replace the gun? he laughed and said don't count on it. He said cause I'm sure you have already tried to put the tube back in yourself, so how do we know you didn't screw it up. i got rid of the Henry and bought a Marlin. I love my Marlin.

[@wildfireslayerjesse3112]

@@Jerry-jg1uc Just shot my marlin this season today. Had it sighted in from last year and it's been in the safe since. I was shooting 50 yards and it was dead on. I love my Marlin as well, the smoothness of the operation is what I really like. The sweet succulent flow of the lever as you pump another round In...great feeling

[@wildfireslayerjesse3112]

I just take mine to my local shop and they fix my guns up. Never really tried going through the gun company like marlin or Henry. Will definitely look into it, thank you!

[@stevefreidell5081]

@@Jerry-jg1uc I’m sure you got someone at Henry who picked up the phone by accident. Call Anthony and tell him this story. Who ever told you that was dead wrong and Anthony will say so too. Henry will do anything including replace the gun to make a customer happy. They absolutely did that for me and I didn’t even have to ask. Call Anthony and you will understand what customer satisfaction is all about. If he doesn’t take care of you let me know.

[@mytwocents7693]

I've been shooting a Marlin .30-30 since I was a kid, have a 1995 .30-30 in my inventory to this day. Never had a problem, shoots great, still tight, and very accurate. The Henry's are nice, shot two of them in the past. Not enough difference to choose one over the other. Guess it's more personal preference than anything.

[@donaldduke2233]

Best 22 plinker I ever had was a Marlin Golden Mountie 39A which I lost when Hurricane Katrina put my house under 20 feet of water. I sure miss that rifle. Great video, Hickok. I learn a lot from your videos. Keep 'em coming.

[@BrickyardPowerMan]

Absolutely this! I have my Dads from the 1950’s. My favorite firearm!

[@Mike-ny6sf]

I bought three 39As over the years. . first when I was 18 for $50 could have had his matching 30/30 for another $50. That was in the 60s.

[@timsim1940]

I love them all!!! Winchester, Marlin and Henry!! Levers are awesome! Cheers from Alberta, Canada!

[@D45VR]

and Uberti who makes great replicas of the classic rifles

[@tonymanns8249]

My Henry "Big Boy, Steel" .357 magnum lever-action carbine is top notch in quality. And I had experience with Henry's customer service and they were top notch. :)

[@pfslik]

I have the same. It's so loved that it has been added to our collection of heirloom firearms that will be handed down to children and grandchildren. It's in good company with a H&K 22Mag, Weatherby 257 mag, an Ithaca 16ga and a Winchester 22 LR pump

[@hobbz4921]

Agreed, it is the prize of my collection. Everyone wants to shoot it when I bring it to the range.

[@bengarcia3063]

My favorite of my fathers guns. So beautiful and such a well rounded rifle. Just wish he was more careful with it he gets scratches from stuffing his gunsafe full.

[@hobbz4921]

@@bengarcia3063 Yeah, either you never use it and just hang it on a wall as a decorative piece, or you actually use it, and it gets scratched, rusty, or the finish of the brass starts to come off. But still, it's so fun to shoot that I could never just hang it on a wall forever!

[@slypperyfox]

Ditto. I bought the same model last year. Only changes I've made is changed out the lever loop for an oversized lever loop, put a hammer cross tab to pull back the hammer with and I scoped it with a 4X30 scope. I never hunt at distances over 100 yards but my old eyes can't see with the iron sights at those distances.

[@doughesson]

That mass produced firearms can have such tight tolerances between wood & metal is just amazing. I've always admired people who can work wood and/or metal to make such fascinating objects.

[@robertboyd3863]

None of the wood metal fit compares with the old Winchesters of a 100 years ago

[@shankarbalan3813]

Truly informative, solid video reviews and information. Mr Hickok is extremely knowledgeable. And I love the way he has that skin on the gun table so that the lovely woodwork and metalwork on the guns remains cared for and remain un-scratched.

[@bikerk562]

I just bought a new Marlin 1895 CB in 45-70. Shot it today for the first time. That thing shoots like a dream! Smooth action, easier to load as my other lever guns, and the feel was fantastic. I put a rear peep site on it (Williams) and the sight picture is fantastic. I love that Marlin.....I've had old Marlins before and this one is no different in my opinion.

[@markschoenberger8485]

Have a Marlin 30 30, that belonged to my Dad (gun at least 60yrs old). It has put plenty of meat on the table. Still shoots sweet.

[@Arto257]

I got one from my grandad that's about 50-60 years old. It's been put through the ringer and still shoots beautifully

[@elflordyt6830]

@@Arto257 my great grandpa will bequeath his onto me which hes had for 40-60 years, IF i can shoot a deer dead in one shot with it due to bot having enough .243 ammo for me to properly sight in my rifle's scope for once. I tested the marlin out and wow its lighter, has even less kick, quieter shots somehow, and more ammo and better accuracy.

[@domingofung]

My grandpa's Marlin 30 30 been with him for 70

[@j.alanmersereau9970]

Enjoy your videos. I'm a Marlin guy. Bought my first one almost 40 years ago. A used 336 R.C. the most reliable rifle I've owned.

[@Thirsty_Fox]

Love levers! Cheers from Canada, where the firearm sports are growing in popularity! We've even started a federation for universities and colleges to compete.

[@cjr4286]

That's great!

[@buymoreguns5924]

Do they get support from any universities?

[@patrickirish9427]

As a Canadian gun owner all I can say is our beloved sport is more at risk now than ever. Maybe competition Olympic shooting, but the current liberal government would ban everything including slingshots if they knew it wouldn't stop a re election.

[@patrickirish9427]

Meaning I'm glad to hear out any fellow Canadian who takes pride in their firearm ownership, we need all the help we can get. Cheers.

[@Thirsty_Fox]

@@buymoreguns5924 The universities are becoming quite supportive of the firearms sports. My university has two official clubs, one for firearms in general and another for the clays. They are both experiencing healthy growth and interest from all kinds of people who hadn't considered the sports before.

[@edwardclark2695]

My Dad bought me a Marlin 22. automatic from Western Auto in late 70s. Silver trigger w leaf. forearms & squirrel on the front of stock. Still got it...

[@michaeldavis5775]

Always keep the rifle your dad bought you!

[@sleepthoughamostqruelandde1116]

Hold on to those your dad gave u! I let a few slip away when I was 18,now at 45 I regret that greatly!😢

[@rosannaanisi4642]

Just bought the exact Henry side gate 30 30 and shot it few days ago, it’s beautiful and shoots right on target. Very happy with it!

[@bp-ob8ic]

Game warden: "So, Mr Hickok, you claim the deer ran in front of your bullet?"

[@martinschulz9381]

Game warden "Tell it to the judge."

[@muffin2147]

I don't get it

[@bp-ob8ic]

@@muffin2147 Just before the 17 minute mark, he sees a deer react to his shot, and talks about what would happen if he hit one.

[@MrUberZombie]

Thanks Hickock! I was literally wondering about these two. You have helped me cement the Henry side gate as my first lever I shall buy. I'm halfway saved up.

[@BilgePump]

You go kid!!

[@joe13h]

Picked up the Henry side gate couple weeks ago. I love this rifle!

[@beijingbiden5931]

Do they have it in .357?

[@lancenorton1117]

@@beijingbiden5931 Not yet, currently it is only chambered in 30-30, .38-55 and .35 Remington.

[@joe13h]

I hope they bring out the .357 soon that’s for sure!

[@terrypublow7038]

@@joe13h Looking at getting a Henry big boy in 357 magnum. If available in side gate model, certainly would consider.

[@jamieoconnorF]

@@terrypublow7038 as soon as they make one in .410 with a steel reciever ima getn one

[@mattbell3362]

Marlin would almost always be the first choice except when it’s compared to a Henry. Marlins are fantastic. Henry’s are exceptional.

[@65stang98]

true statement. every henry ive ever bought has been a tack driver right out of the box

[@helodriver20]

True statement.

[@ronlafitte6864]

I love every one of my JM Marlins. I also love every one of my Henry’s! My 35 Remington Henry is identical to that Henry you are shooting. It’s really a fine rifle and I’ll never part with it OR any of my JM Marlins!

[@larrymiller5171]

Winchester 94

[@riverrivers250]

What guys say when they dont have a marlin ^^^^^ ,,, jk

[@barrystarr22]

Using some of the high tech ammo out for the lever action 30/30's I was shooting nice groups at 200 yds so the new tech helps stretch out the effective ranges for these older style hunting rifles.

[@robertwinn1118]

Thanks for the great video.both are great rifles.Just bought a new dark series 45-70 marlin for my son's graduation which field tested excellently . Also purchased a Henry all weather 45-70 for myself because it is so slick and fits my scabbard nicely . It also shoots well.One thing I've noticed is that when you purchase a new rifle it instantly becomes a whole lot better than before you own it.Love lever guns!! Thanks for the videos!

[@anthonyspicer874]

Love the lever action 30/30. Wouldn't mind having a Marlin, Henry and Winchester..

[@RickJames-xy6io]

I don’t know if there is a gun I dislike! I love the marlin ... well I love them all but I prefer the marlin.

[@jackwatkins7382]

I love the Winchester, but the only thing is you can't top mount a scope on a Winchester.

[@towtruckmafia]

@@jackwatkins7382 Find a Winchester 94 AE.

[@jackwatkins7382]

@@towtruckmafia well mr. Matteson I have actually thought about that but I wasn't sure about their angle eject. I've heard some dislikes over them but I've never owned one so I wouldn't know. One guy said that the case is still a little long but that wouldn't matter to me if I can get it in a 44 caliber because the shoulder case I think would not give no problem. But finding one in 44 is kind of a problem. I guess I'll have to buy it new. I don't spect you know anyone that has got a 44 for sale? Thanks for the reply, Jack

[@salg.5153]

I have all 3. Love them all

[@l.peytonadams8570]

Really classic designs. I shot a Marlin 39A and a Marlin 357 lever gun for years. Then I got my first Henry. I like old Marlin's and new Henry's ever since that moment. I think both shown are good looking but my eye kept coming to the Henry.

[@RickJames-xy6io]

I would love to have that 39A! I’m in the market for one. I just bought an old 1894cs in 357 and one in 44 magnum. I love those marlins.

[@teamjon3]

I own a 1951 336 Marlin 35 rem and it is in perfect condition . Back when Marlin made really good guns, I also have a Ruger /Marlin 1895 45-70 SBL and this gun is just as perfect as the 51, So I feel that Marlin is in good hands now

[@guaporeturns9472]

I have a 1965 Marlin 336 44 magnum that is smooth as silk and never given me a bit of trouble.

[@backwoods6050]

I've got the same year Marlin 30-30, also in mint condition. If you want my Marlin, you'd better be prepared to kill me. That said, I'd also love to own a Henry.

[@guaporeturns9472]

@@backwoods6050 How about just buy it from you? Seems easier and less messy than killing you.

[@bobsbarnworkshop]

I couldn’t decide so I bought a Marlin 336 .30-30 and Henry .22 with octagon barrel and brass receiver! Love them both!

[@scotthajney4127]

If you dont like lever guns there's sumpin' wrong with ya

[@Smasho8000]

They are very underrated.

[@Glock2201]

@@Smasho8000 I like lever guns but I would not say they were underrated. Henry and Winchester are both north of a $1,000 and you can buy a decent bolt action rifle with a scope for well south of $500 that will shoot a more effective cartridge.

[@karstensebastian7598]

They are my favorite action.

[@seirbhiseach]

@@Glock2201 Winchester for sure, but Henry gets in the 700s on their more popular stuff, and their “fun guns” in 22 are around 250, which isn’t bad for their quality. In fact, it’s GREAT for their quality

[@wteuscher85]

Well you’re not American if you don’t like them.

[@Anthony-pq3gh]

I can’t tell you how much I enjoy these videos. They make my day.

[@PropsandWings]

If one listens to the mechanics of the lever action during a round loading into the chamber and discharge, you can tell which brand has spent a little more time on quality work. It's the suttle details, sounds and feel that is key in my decision: Henry for sure if I had the cash.

[@kevinrollman3101]

Just my opinion but since I own a Marlin 1895 I can tell you after handling, firing, and cleaning my Marlin it is the Marlin that reigns supreme!!

[@sorryociffer]

@@kevinrollman3101 When was yours made? Is it a JM? I recently compared a Henry and marlin side by side and the fit finish and mechanical feel of the Henry was just superior.

[@alj.granda8252]

16.5" Henry Big Boy Side Gate in .357 Carbine/Color Cased Receiver with large lever is what I have!! Love Henry quality!! Very few discounts with some hard to find Henrys. I payed MSRP of $1198!! Marlin 336 no longer in production! Thanks for another great video!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@darrylfricke2375]

Throughly enjoy these videos, Great Guy ! Any firearms enthusiast can enjoy and understand that many rifles are very close in comparison, it’s just like Mr.Hickok-45 states “Sometimes it just comes down to personal preference.” I own several levers, Winchester, Marlin and Henry… I also enjoy them all for some reason or other ! Keep up the Great information and comparisons . Thank You Mr.Hickok !

[@lukewarm2075]

Love that henry is doing side gates thank you to all the people that asked henry to do this much appreciated

[@sorryociffer]

I like that Henry went gate as well, but ALSO keep the tube load option. Nice…

[@tandyman1330]

Deer in the back ground @7:25. I guess they hear shooting and come running for that tasty red soda before it all soaks in the ground.

[@ericn7677]

I saw that and thought "LIVE TARGET!" I know Hickok wouldn't shoot it, nor would I. I'm glad it was able to sneak across, while John was recording.

[@davehart1027]

Guess to them, the bangs are just like the birds in the background by now, must be more than used to it

[@flytebandtampa2499]

Great eyes man! LOL!! Deer has courage, also knows Hick was talkin, made his move!

[@joefair4139]

I love it when you bring out the lever action rifles. Great video Hickok! Thanks for sharing.

[@dexterwarrington8615]

After years of shooting with open or iron sights, I've come to prefer the semi-buckhorn sight over the the full buckhorn. That might be enough to swing me to the Henry~!! Marlin has been in turmoil for a couple of years now while Henry is very stable. I've also read that Henry's service is as good as it gets~! My choice is clear~!!

[@MortuusTyrannus]

I picked up a Henry because it has a transfer bar safety (and doesn’t have a manual safety) That sealed the deal for me. But both are wonderful lever guns!!!

[@Tom-xp7dl]

Im normally a Marlin guy. But this Henry is so nice. I love the shine and the wood work on the Henry.

[@jimmygarrett735]

That's about all it's good for the name and the looks I have the Henry golden boy octagon barrel 30/30 tube fed garbage gun

[@guaporeturns9472]

@@jimmygarrett735 yeah my two Henrys never did feed correctly , got rid of them but kept my JM Marlins

[@chrisredwolf3130]

If Henry puts a Octagonal Barrel on the Side Loading 30-30 that would make it a MUST Have! at the top of my List.

[@seeoh300]

And heavier if you're actually going to hunt with?

[@cbeaudry4646]

Same. If they throw a side-gate on their current Color-Case Hardened 30-30 I'd probably pick it up really quick

[@kipkleimenhagen8434]

It would be nice if Henry tapered their octagon barrels properly... the original Winchesters and Marlins of the 19th century all had gracefully tapered barrels. I believe that for ease of manufacturing Henry is using straight octagons, which look ungainly and add needless weight.

[@nickmoore1967]

Then it would be a complet knock off of marlin Bicentennial 30-30 with the octagonal barrel.

[@buckshotaaa]

Wow, that Henry sure is a lovely rifle. You're one of the best (if not THE best) reviewer from the States. keep 'em coming. ATB from the UK.

[@dougrogers835]

I still have my Marlin that my Dad bought me in 1971 when I was 15 years old. The action is smooth as silk and still looks like new.

[@jacobivey4789]

The old marlins are the best

[@waynehankinson8210]

That Henry is beautiful and well finished. The Henry looks like it would cost twice the money. Also like the ability to load side gate or tube loading on the Henry. I bet the wildlife have become accustomed to the firing on the range and keep coming back for the free watermelons and pumpkins.

[@prismospickles4947]

7:25 anyone else see that deer run across the range? Haha

[@yosojubo5392]

They do that from time to time lol

[@jimh3500]

No I didn’t notice until I read your comment. Good eye, Bear

[@red13lade]

yep from 7:26 to 7:29 he darted across it was hilarious.

[@Machria23]

BEAR TOOTH LOL!! THAT is one BRAVE deer!!!!

[@gregfuzi1069]

I didn't see the deer. And I looked again.

[@usethetools]

i used my dads .444 Marlin for deer hunting... absolutely love that lever action.

[@umphman6253]

Just an FYI, I also have a Henry all weather gun .357 and some how when cleaning it I caught the extractor and the lever would not close. I contacted Henry and set up a warranty repair and a day later they sent me a return postage paid label to return the rifle for repair. I guess guaranteed for life means just that, even when I screw things up.

[@wagonmaster1974]

Never shot a Henry, but I love my Marlin. Also have a .22 Marlin. Both great and dependable. My model 336 was made in the early sixties and has a curved, rounded lever, topped by a Redfield scope. Steel butt plate. Same for the .22.

[@bigh6530]

Just putting these two lever actions side by side for comparison speaks volumes for the quality of both. I have a Marlin and never shot a Henry but would love to own one in the near future.

[@NefariousKoel]

The old Marlin .35 was my favorite, out of a numerous rifles dad sent me off with, hunting in the deer woods as a kid & teen. So light. Great for walking up and down the forested ridges of the Ozark Mts, and a good brush gun for those deadfall-heavy backwoods. Still did great, open sights, even at longer ranges after coming out of the thick brushy woods.

[@Tree_Dee]

The world needs more pistol caliber lever actions!

[@fiveowaf454]

With side loading gates!!!

[@awizardalso]

I do have a Marlin 336W 30/30. I chose it because it has the ejection port on the side, which makes it suitable to use a scope. I also have a hammer spur accessory that makes access to the hammer under the scope easy. I bought it in July, 2012 for $409.99.

[@houndsmanone4563]

I own several Henry lever action rifles, a couple Winchester lever action rifles and even a lever action shotgun. I've never owned a Marlin. Marlin has never been one of the big go-to lever action rifles when I was growing up. I'm sure they're exceptionally built rifles but I went with what I grew up with and what I know what works. Deer hunting was our way of life when I was a kid and to this day, everyone at home still carries on the deer hunting tradition. I'm from Franklin County in Pa and school would close down for first days of buck season. I think that's changed now but that's how serious deer hunting was and still is in Pennsylvania. Thanks for the great video. I always enjoy your videos. Another full-watch. 👍🏽🤠 12/14/22

[@amyhepker9025]

When I was 11 in 1967, I started collecting reloading equipment for a 30-30, I knew that was what I wanted. I went to Sears with my dad and I checked out a New Winchester 30-30 and it felt good right up until I went to put it up to my shoulder. It was very light and the butt of the gun went over my shoulder. We went to a Gun dealer and he had a 30-30 Marlin and when I put it up to my shoulder it went in the right place. So, I decided I wanted a Marlin. A year later my dad traded in his old Webley for a 30-30 Marlin for me. It was a 336RC with the Pistol grip stock, which I preferred. I already had over 300 rounds loaded up with cast bullets, I cast and Sized with Lyman mold and Sizer and lubricator. I used 19 Grain of IMR 4227. The Bullet was a 173gr. with a gas check. I used to shoot a couple hundred rounds whenever we went shooting. I was pretty good with that Carbine, I could hit anything within 200 yards without a scope and further with. I dididn't like using a scope and took it off after a few months. I put a sling on it. I had that gun for 40 years and ran about 3000 round through her all Lead bullets and about 500 jacketed 170gr bullets. I used IMR 3031 powder for that, I do not remember the weight. I NEVER had any problem with that Marlin, I Highly Recommend them. Great gun for in brush or around a lot of trees. You need to do a comparison between the Marlin and the Winchester both in 30-30.

[@randyslone-wh6ki]

Will the Marlin unload out the side gate . Some are made to ?

[@TimS-i4v]

Own a Henry 45-70, Henry .22, Marlin .357/38 and a Rossi .22 mag. All lever action and all shoot great. The Henry is brass so it looks the best.

[@dutyshoesdan2323]

If Henry comes out with a side gate model with steel/all-weather receivers they will DOMINATE the market. I don’t understand why they haven’t done that yet. Brass receivers aren’t good for hunting.

[@gabbyhayes1568]

I think Henry is waiting to see how their stealing of the Marlin design for this rifle plays out before expanding production with steel/all-weather receivers. lol

[@glenn1035]

@@gabbyhayes1568 Pretty sure any Marlin patents have expired, how many companies are "stealing" the design of Colt's 1911 and Single Action Army.

[@Zenmaster4596]

Marlin: We have the best side loading lever gun. Henry: Hold my beer.

[@lancehorrocks1305]

Ha Marlin is better I want to see a Henry 26 inch octagon Barrell

[@oldwarmonger8750]

Im sorry but Rossi still smokes Henry and Marlin.....

[@therealsenorisgrig]

I SmithNwesson I have not found that to be the case

[@sonjosuaperkins6774]

I SmithNwesson this isn’t me arguing. I want to know why you think this? I want to get into lever guns

[@jakkbatt4711]

Winchester 😁

[@ritesideofthefence5857]

I have two old marlins from early 60’s 30/30 , 35 rem and all my new lever guns are Henrys’s and I’ll be staying with Henry.

[@Juliang61]

Same for me, they are just better made and need nothing out of the box

[@jeremythompson7361]

wanna sell the Marlin?

[@johnnyleah7589]

Hickok patting the Henry while he's explaining how upset people get when he doesn't outright pick one was enough for me. Henry wins. lol

[@davidharrah3703]

Not even close, brother. Henry is a copy. Great workmanship…etc. Marlin stands alone. That Marlin he has is a REM made.

[@bluem00n88]

I’ve always wanted a Henry and a couple of days ago I got the 22. Now I’m going to buy the 3030. Great Video thank you

[@jimmygarrett735]

Dont get the tube fed one its garbage

[@jamesg1367]

Henry certainly is a good bet. My one Henry firearm is a .22 rifle, beautifully made, superb fit and finish, shoots flawlessly. I inherited it quite unexpectedly and soon learned just what good fortune that was. The rifle has a scope, for which mounting the rear sight had been removed -- and was lost. I called Henry to ask about buying that part, finding none anywhere on offer for sale. They asked for my address. The sight arrived in the mail a few days later, no charge. What a service-minded company!

[@paulshayter1113]

JamesG, Henry's customer service second to none. Truly one of the best I've dealt with in any industry.

[@jamesg1367]

@@paulshayter1113 Unrelated to guns, I recently had a similar experience with another American company, Thermo Fisher Scientific. I had a piece of lab equipment that had a problem. When I called seeking a replacement part that would have sufficed to repair it, they informed me (rather than me informing them!) that it was in-warranty, and with no further ado they sent an entire new device. Then they informed me I need not bother to return the ailing one. Well, the "bad" device still has most of its function intact so I reckon I hit a jackpot of sorts. Both now see productive use in the lab. The superb service had the proper effect: I'll happily buy more of their products anytime, even at a price premium.

[@georged9234]

I’m new to firearms and a recent subscriber. I really enjoy your channel. Besides the history lessons on firearms, I’m learning how to look at the details. I’ve seen 2 of your Marlin videos, this being one, where I’ve learned to look at details differently. I’d pick the Henry here, but the details on a specific Marlin I held could make the difference because of workmanship. FYI Passed through Tennessee for the first time this summer. Beautiful state and people. On the short list for my upcoming retirement transition!

[@christoFlair777]

Me too !!! First time in Tennessee!! Wonderful state!! I like the Henry!!🤓

[@danw.3291]

For me the choice is easy: Henry. I've had the Henry Big Boy in 44mag for several years & absolutely love it.

[@jakkbatt4711]

Might be buying a big boy in .44 myself

[@garylong7096]

Always loved Marlin. Started with model 60, 22 long rifle, age 12. Now 53, my Marlin 22 mag and 17HMR heavy barrel. Both will hold dime groups at 100yd. Got to love it. :).

[@CoalMiner379]

Just picked up a 1972 JM stamped marlin 336 today and put 20 rounds down range and it ran better than my newer one. 30-30 is probably my all time favorite rifle caliber, both my girls learn to shoot with a 30-30 and they love it to, they said they prefer my 1873 model 44-40wcf.

[@HarrisonCountyStudio]

I’m looking at a a lightly used Henry in .44 magnum, octagon barrel, brass receiver. Beautiful lever action.

[@jeffreylocke8808]

The Henry side-gate and tube load/unload lever-action is the best design hands down.

[@austinwhite969]

Opinions vary, that was the reason I picked a marlin over the henry.

[@jeffreylocke8808]

@@austinwhite969 opinions vary yes but features are my muse.

[@Michael_Scott_Howard]

Wanted: Henry side loading, octagon barrel 26", 45-70. BLUED... waiting... waiting...

[@cbeaudry4646]

Thank you! Finally somebody else haha. I really want a Henry with a 24"-28" barrel length (and the extra capacity from the longer tube), just like Marlin's 1895CB. Although, I would rather it be in 30-30 myself. Hopefully one day we get our wish

[@kevingipe6923]

@@cbeaudry4646 for real, I also really want someone to reproduce the trapdoor Springfield

[@nicholasmapes]

Blued, or case hardened, that looks beautiful as well

[@thecowboy6317]

@@kevingipe6923 YEEEESSSSS, finally someone, but not only a 45-70 trapdoor, one in .357 mag or .44 mag for plinking and combining with a revolver or even one in .30-30 winchester

[@u.p.woodtick3296]

Michael Scott Howard sweet

[@edwardbailey9868]

I’m a traditional original JM Marlin fan & own several Marlin rifles, but I recently acquired a Henry X (all black) with a side load gate 45/70 & love the feel of it, the side gate was the closer for me, I’ve always wanted a Henry & said if they put a gate in it, I’d buy it. So there you go, love both.

[@bradcoffey8984]

I've owned all of the Winchester 30-30's, owned the Henry, pumped countless rounds thru all... No disrespect to Winchester nor Henry at all, they are all fine rifles. I've owned a marlin model 60 for 43 years...fine, accurate rifle . Then I bought a Marlin 336 GT. .. I sold my Henry and all of my Winchesters...for me, the 336 is the epitome of the perfect 30-30. Fit, finish, action, reliability and above all, accuracy is superb..

[@JP-ee8ni]

I own a Henry 30-30, no side gate and that would be nice. Bottom line with me, Henry is 100% made in the USA and that makes my choice easy. Keep up the great work!!

[@Rijuo]

For the past year I’ve been debating what to get, a henry or a marlin for 45-70. After researching for months, I finally decided to go to henry for the better quality firearm and I won’t have to worry about potentially having a “marlin” issue.

[@TheWestlandgirl]

I'm a Lifetime Member of the NRA. Love your videos!

[@jimtaylor8009]

NRA has gotten a bad rap lately. I'm a life member too. NRA has always stood up for freedom. More gun owners should join us in the NRA.

[@GoodGuysCarry]

Thankfully we have the NRA. I’m a life member too... without NRA we wouldn’t have (be able to keep) the gun rights we have.

[@Cowboybiker87]

You have officially helped me settle on the Henry sir. Thank you!

[@gary3270]

I have both! They both are great guns! One in 30-30 and one in 45-70! Both are really good!

[@scottc.real_2legit_4u55]

I am happy to see a new Marlin that does look good and functions well. The loading gate from Henry is a nice feature also. Great Video

[@WHOTEEWHO]

👍👍

[@christophernemeth421]

Back in the Spring I bought a new 1894 in 357 mag and its a beautiful rifle and functions perfectly. It is a much better rifle than my previous 1894 that I bought in the 90's. It's much smoother and runs 38's with no issues

[@nelsonm5032]

for me i like the look of the Marlin the best. but, thetight tolerances on the henry is above and beyond. very nice rifles, both of them!

[@markadams7597]

Great vid, as always. Ty. I like the 30-30 arm cannon! I've been shooting Marlin since 1977; Marlin's the ONE! (Love the 336's traditional brass trigger; Henry's too shinny, glitzy, and flashy.)

[@russellleavitt4449]

I have contacted Henry several times via there email and there response was quite quick. The helped me in decisions on sight changes and attaching a scope. I did order the Talley 1" base/rings to attach my scope. The also have a great selection of Henry parts and accessories. If you own a Henry their site is a must. Life time warranty on all Henry's.

[@gloppy101]

As always, another excellent video. I have a Henry in 30-30 and love it. I do hope you get back with the NRA and if not, thanks for your long support. I'm a 40 year member and will continue. Stay well and looking to seeing more of your videos.

[@ForFucksSake57591]

Curious if you still support nra in 2022?

[@IndyFied]

I actually like the cross bolt safety on my Marlin. It allows me to fully lock and load my rifle so it's ready at the the drop of a hammer. Fully loaded holds at 7... and it's a gorgeous gun. Not likely to find many like it. Wish I knew how to post pics cause I certainly would

[@ClickKlack43]

Old comment but just FYI you can keep Henrys with one in the pipe with the hammer full down perfectly safely. They can’t and won’t fire from dropping the hammer from full cock by thumb drop or random bump, due to the built in “transfer bar” safety that won’t fire unless it’s full cocked and the trigger is pulled. It’s worth looking into just because the technology itself is very interesting. However, I love my Marlin too, so this is certainly not a nod either way. Just a heads up on interesting design. They’re both great rifles.

[@dtmurray]

I would have to give the advantage to Henry, for sure, if customer service is factored in.

[@sheepdog271]

That Henry is a Beauty!

[@williamdenton5494]

Great topic & video! Team Henry for me! More importantly, Team Hickok45!

[@mikekalvin7309]

Had a Marlin 3030 for 20yrs. Scope (Cheap Tasco) 4x set at 200yrds. Lots of Deer! Cost me 199.00 for rifle 40.00 for scope n mount in 1991.

[@huntingwolf20]

I think I would go with Henry just for the name. It's just the history for me. I like the look of both. 30/30 is still my favorite rifle and lever action my favorite action. Takes me back to all the old Westerns.

[@hickok45]

Henry Repeating Arms was founded in 1996; Marlin goes back into the 1800's. WAY more history. :-)

[@adorabledeplorable1045]

Henry!!! I love my Henry 44mag. Just an absolute joy to play with. Henry’s customer service is #1.

[@Worthrhetime]

Have one as well , goes great with my Ruger Bisley Vaquero. Fun day ...

[@stevenyoung1687]

That Henry stock, both pieces are absolutely beautiful!!! The Marlin’s wood is top notch also, IMO

[@KillerDoc42]

Henry is crazy, put a side loader on all of them! DAMN

[@ranndomundead9112]

i just paid a couple hundred more for a marlin 357 over a henry 357 simply because henry doesn't have a loading gate on theirs. and damn did I really want that brass look

[@bsmithhammer]

People make way too big of a deal out of Henrys not having a side gate. I bet I can tube load a Henry as fast as most people can side gate load.

[@ranndomundead9112]

@@bsmithhammer not speed I care about. 1, its convenience. 2, its 1 more part that can break

[@bsmithhammer]

@@ranndomundead9112 Sure, I get that. But I find most people who are put off by the idea of not having a loading gate have never really spent much time with a lever that doesn't have one. It's still easy to load, or top off. And it would take a fair bit of effort to to break the mag tube. Even so, they're cheap and having an extra one on hand isn't a bad idea. Gates can jam/break as well.

[@sandervanduren2779]

Hammer 67 yeah, but when I want to put a suppressor on one the side gate is important. It’s also annoying to have to put your hands near the muzzle if you’re topping off(and yes, I know you can just have the action open and have no danger, but still)

[@waltoak]

I have a 30-30'lever action with the western auto name on it. Except for a few differences it is a marlin I bought it in late 1963. It has great performance.

[@ParkerPPipe]

Thank you for this video. My favorite part was how you showed how the wood doesn’t seat flush against the steel parts on the marlin. Those are the tiny details that helped me decide to buy the Henry 30-30 I just got. Woohoo!

[@manuelyidonoy1802]

Great guns! But, I tend to side with the new Henry side loader. Sure hope Henry comes out with a 357 and 44 side loaders. Will buy the 44 mag for sure!

[@sorryociffer]

Wish Marlin and Henry would do a 445 Supermag and 357 maximum version… would be a very versatile option that falls in between the 44mag and 45-70 and 357/30-30 models…

[@leonarddaneman810]

I bought one of the last JM Marlins (2011) and it needed a lot of work finishing/polishing the innards. But, action very nice and buttery now. Fit and finish are fine. What delayed good production from Remington was the conversion of the old, worn out tooling from the Connecticut factory to CNC. Then, getting the CNC refined . . . CZ had to do the same thing with Dan Wesson. Anyway, seems the revised Marlin out of Remington are worth looking at . . . better than the latter days of Marlin.

[@Jeanie363034]

Ruger owns Marlin now...They will keep the Marlin name but they will improve the quality.

[@mkshffr4936]

Have always been a bit of a Marlin fan but now that Henry is adding the loading gates I am really taking shine to them.

[@dannygoss2649]

Another great video by Hickok both are good guns with that being said I grew up with a 336 my father bought me when I was 14 gun has served me well for many years but as I got older I wanted more nock down power and I hunt thick brush I decided threw a friend using one a 45 70 was going to be my new one so I was looking at marlins but at the time I didn't know but remington was going down hill and they where hard to find so I did my home work read the reviews and watched countless videos on KZbin and ordered a herny all weather in 45 70 I have not been disappointed it a beautiful gun the accuracy is unmatched to the marlin and it the smoothest laver action and trigger iv have ever shot but I still carry the 30 30 some days during deer season

[@manningjackson2723]

Great video mate! A great rundown on both rifles, well done champ from all of us in the top end (Darwin NT) 👍

[@uscgsemperparatus6472]

Love your videos !! Huge lever action fan !! You and John Wayne and your lever guns. Thanks for all you do and have done.

[@brando81]

A couple years back I shot my cousin's brand new henry 45-70. I hadn't shot a gun in a decade, and right out of the box I was amazed how accurate it was.

[@henrywilliams1965]

Best shooting rifle I ever owned was a 22 marlin semi automatic. It had a 4 power scope and was probably the cheapest rifle you could buy at the time. I believe I got it at K Mart. I took it out of the box and put the scope on it and set up a target at about 70 yards to zero it in. A friend was with me and I fired about five shots from a rest in a prone position. We couldn't tel were the bullets hit so we walked to the target. Every round was within the small bullseye, im still amazed at the accuracy of that little rifle, it was the demise of many a bullfog and squrriel. I sold that rifle many years ago when I guit hunting whised now that I had kept it.

[@Jamestfarrell]

That Micro-Groove rifling! That's what sold Pop and I on our jointly-owned Model 80 when I was 13-back in 1959. Still shoots straight.

[@raymcintire6296]

Just from the sound when ejecting the spent round the Henry sounded much more solid. Would love to have either. I do have a knockoff Marlin that was bought from Montgomery Wards way back when. Actually have never had the chance to shoot it. I really need to go to a range.

[@granthagen2996]

I'm a Henry guy. Got a 22lr Henry at 13 and a 30-30 brass receiver and blued octagonal barrel at 18. Love em both