‘Hindi Padhna Gunaah Lagta…’: FM Sitharaman Recalls Being Mocked For Learning Hindi In Tamil Nadu

[@darcsoul5087]

She never answers the questions about tax,middle class burden etc... she is an expert in diverting the topic.

[@goodnature13g19]

The FM suppose talk about finance related subject in the parliament and why wasting time and tax payers money on the topic which is not relevant for the position

[@1984kuntal]

Worst ever to ever do it

[@Raja_Simhan]

1:50 can't u see he was the one trying to divert the topic

[@a.u.j6340]

Worst finance minister with hell of a attitude

[@DCM2463]

We are not interested in her language skills but her ministry skills.

[@antarac.s9034]

Both are in the gutter.

[@AlexZender-ej7jy]

Please enlighten about her ministry skills.

[@raphulali8937]

bhai sahab aap btado tax jo lagane wale hai wo kesa hai​@@AlexZender-ej7jy

[@varunvachaspathyam]

Teach Kannada Tamil and Telugu to all the North Indian states because these are the people coming down south for opportunities. Already people in South know and speak fluent Hindi

[@Savitrooo]

The problem is no one wants to learn this language in the North; if they want to learn it's there freedom to learn, unlike in South India. speak Tamil Saaar.😵‍💫😵‍💫

[@varunvachaspathyam]

@@SavitroooI already told you the reason . If I’m going to a Hindu soekaing or any regional language soekaing state I will learn that language . But it’s the Hindi speaking belt coming down to south so why doesn’t it make sense to learn any South Indian language so that they can communicate better here .

[@michiokaku98]

Ghanta

[@abhishekpujari8298]

@@varunvachaspathyam See as an Indian I would feel pride in learning any Indian Language, specially the more ancient it is the proud I would feel about it. It's only sad to know that sometimes in the name of Pride, People of Tamil Nadu would completely deject Hindi(Indian Language) but still would let English dominate everywhere.

[@chromatic_10]

Maam please resign you are not eligible for your post .

[@ayoutubecommenter1914]

@@chromatic_10 don’t respect that thot

[@srikanthncsrikanth2958]

Mam is super right.

[@whatsappstatusrdj9898]

Worst finance minister 😡😡

[@sambitkumardutta2006]

​@@srikanthncsrikanth2958 jaake chat le😂

[@krishnanvasudevan916]

why?

[@mks3006]

The same FM also made fun of hindi language of CM Revanth reddy in one of the conversations that his hindi lanugage was not good. Now she is getting offended..

[@SrikanthGBCom]

She said revanth reddy to ask questions in Telugu bcoz both are good in speaking telugu than hindi.

[@ashishrana6411]

I am from North of India & she said the right thing. Why is she being harassed for not speaking Hindi properly. No language should be imposed. People understood the meaning that's it

[@gopalakrishnan7001]

Irresponsible DMK govt when people are going for employment they are happy But no facility in Tamil nadu to learn hindi It is mistake of khandhani rulers.

[@memeupadates3579]

You are idiot or what she said they don't taught her hindi in her state and you are saying that no one should impose language ?😂😂😂 South State never impose hindi they feel proud on their language and here finance minister said that she couldn't learn because her state never impose hindi??? means what you and FM trying to say we should impose hindi or not.? Matlab impose Kare to bhi problem aur Nahi Kare to bhi bolenge ki hamare state me Hindi allow Nahi kiyya 😅😅😅

[@descendantsofjoshuaministr3551]

Wow I'm from TN, most of us know Hindi, why is this bekaar natak, in fact most south indians know atleast Tamil, kannada, Telugu, Hindi apart from English, urdu, and managing Malayalam....in fact we are trying to understand Urdu and Punjabi also this is what happens when a person cannot do their job, they come up with vain topic, why not teach whole India free skills to come up in life eg free electrician, electronics repair, automobile repair, 3-4 driving, advanced tailoring, local guides, as people learn these skills and start earning automatically they will learn multiple languages....here skills are more vital, which will in turn lead them to learn multiple languages

[@descendantsofjoshuaministr3551]

If the people in north want to stick to only hindi go ahead, in south we not only learn Hindi, we focus on other languages too a minimum of 3 Indian languages apart from English and if possible french, german and the recent Korean language fascination, we would like to learn Marathi and Bengali too.... she is making a fool of those who want to hear such futile topics, I pity the north that they can be taken for a ride by such people, arre yaar since 1950 same tamasha, but you are still believing it in 2024, our parents learnt Hindi and other languages through self interest....teach north indians more languages maybe even German, get them on board to compete globally and improvise the standard of living, Instead of that they are just making the North Indian catch the bait of Hindi, which is why so many north indian want to become construction workers in south India, soon the demand of construction labour will end in south as construction technology of gulf countries is slowly being incorporated in south, stop fooling North with Hindi, *teach them to compete globally with skills, teach them technology, maths, science etc*

[@rohitparnerkar]

Launguage is not the point her understanding of economics is poor and that cannot be blamed on regional divide.

[@PaldinTamang]

This is what happens when you get directly elected by the prime minister not by the public.....

[@anuradhanayakmajila6842]

Please change the Constitution then!!! How Rajyasabha elects people??? Under Constitutional provision...One should check facts before commenting

[@PaldinTamang]

@anuradhanayakmajila6842 thank you for your facts.... U didn't understand my sentence... First get enough maturity to understand the Constitution and my sentence..... Thank you....

[@anuradhanayakmajila6842]

@@PaldinTamang by the way no Rajyasabha MPs are elected by People.....I know the facts...so I don't uttar unnecessary stuffs...it doesn't need maturity...it needs little knowledge on facts

[@PaldinTamang]

Yes ur right upper house members get selected by the state for the majority of time... But sometimes what happens is P. M or central majority party also selected on behalf of the state... So the selected member returns the favour by talking such utter-ness like this and not thinking of normal public..... Since they are only answerable to the person who brought them to the power, like union ministry....

[@BadarinathGopalakrishna]

Madam should re-watch at 0:30.. Instead of unnecessary argument, focus on not squeezing blood of middle class..

[@elginjosec]

This lady used the word thing it was a great joke, but when she realized it had gone horribly wrong, she dropped the blame on others. Every single place where she studied including school to college gave her the opportunity to study Hindi, if she didn't use it, it was her fault. No one stopped any one from studying Hindi in Tamil Nadu.

[@YKC888]

7:50 why you are imposing unnecessary taxes despite of getting any benefit

[@Anonymous22thoda]

Hindi is not our national language Proud Punjabi

[@saikatdas2160]

Hindi is a just merely official language. Jay Bangla

[@Harry_2003]

​Exactly and people should understand this asap..@@saikatdas2160

[@antondev8388]

One of the official languages, Vazha Tamil ​@@saikatdas2160

[@suvosarkar9136]

​@@saikatdas2160 जय‌ हिन्दी বাংলা থেকে 🚩🇮🇳🚩🇮🇳 মনে হচ্ছে বর্ডার টপকে এসছিস😂😂😂

[@NehaSingh-px7ni]

For us it is

[@selvamoorthy9322]

She had her education from school to college in Hindi medium institutions.(Villuppuram, Madurai, Tiruchirappalli) Afterwards joined JNU of New Delhi. If even after these, her knowledge in Hindi is poor, it exhibit her inefficiency. No Tamilian preventing the people who wish to learn Hindi. She is, time and again, lying and uttering false allegations against Tamils among the Hindi speaking BJP MPs to protect her post, acquired from back door

[@elginjosec]

Not Hindi medium, but she had the option of choosing Hindi as a language. She had studied in missionary schools (most missionary schools teach Hindi). The UG college she studied offered stipend for studying Hindi.

[@selvamoorthy9322]

@elginjosec please, refer former editor of Frontline, Vijayasankar's repeated statement kzbin.info/www/bejne/h3O3h3hsbtppqaMsi=Pk2b8Yyz4qGWe_XL

[@mv4297]

Absolutely right one has the option to learn Hindi in Tamil Nadu if one wanted to no one stops anyone in TN they only oppose imposition of Hindi

[@venkatachalamthiagarajan2404]

@@mv4297do the government schools in TN where maximum number of below middle class people go, teach Hindi as a language at least?

[@skm-kolkata]

Shameless PM and FM in India ever

[@antarac.s9034]

I can't believe india has such a bad finance minister. Madam Sitaraman you should resign. We want you to resign. The middle class wants you to resign.

[@Raja_Simhan]

She's the best finance minister we've ever had who gives befitting reply to trolls

[@DurgaPrasad-me5cp]

she is the best finance minister in the whole world . I am proud that we have such a good finance minister. The 99.5 percentage of the Indian population believe that she is the best .

[@betterthanyesterday9346]

This lady will never allow BJP to get a seat in Tamil Nadu

[@ommnamahshivay7848]

worst of the worst FM in indian history

[@MovieGoers854]

She don’t deserve such position and she put middle class and lower middle class people in hell situation

[@windragon1235]

Mrs SONIA Gandhi being a foreigner learnt hindi

[@mks3006]

Simply diverting the matter. Please give us a list what has been done for working class people?

[@hiteshmahajan1805]

Atleast see the video properly. She was introducing the bill it is actually the opposition which mocked her Hindi and diverted the matter.

[@KumarGauravSagar]

She just extends her speech without any logical sense.

[@rajdeepnayak3412]

I can say one thing her own husband gave interview that she is dangerous 😅

[@pinkiepinku6168]

This lady just uttered Likhya, Lukhya etc. and immediately says I didn't pronounce Lukhya. She should be awarded the Nobel Prize for Lies.

[@msel04]

This woman her poor hindi skills on the Tamil population...horrible diversion

[@ragubathyg9524]

She is so irritating

[@SO_SELL_ICE.]

Worst Fm ever She shall resign immediately 💢

[@anuradhanayakmajila6842]

Is it???

[@abhilashos1588]

Sure, 2 days or later?

[@nwc.fringe]

she didn't said something wrong

[@YKC888]

She diverted the topic, very good strategy 😂😂

[@Vijaya070]

Puppets of Modi ji what is her answer and what was MP s Quistion. I think she even didn't know Quistion.

[@venkateshdhandapani311]

Not answering questions and she swiftly transferred to Hindi politics

[@mahajansushil]

The biggest Politics played with Tamil, Telugu, Kannada and Malayalam people is that they are not supprted to learn Hindi, which is a Sanskrit Udbhav Laguage and 3rd largesr spoken language worldwide... But they have no issues in learning foreign languages like English, Urdu, etc... Naturally, the talent from South India is unable to go to north for jobs, money, etc. On the other side, North Indian people know English along with Hindi and their Regional languages of their state... So they can adjust themselves in South India too... The regressive decisions taken by politicians has actually harmed Tamil, Telugu, Kannada people... Take films for example... If they've had produced movies in Hindi and if people would've understood Hindi, entire Bollywood wouldve been shifted to Chennai/Hyderabad from Bombay, as their movie production and proficient behaviour surpasses Bombay Film Industry... But language divided everyone and unfortunately, innocent people of these 4 states of Bharat had to suffer... So sad, but truth... Barring to learn and speak Hindi has costed South Indian States financially....

[@thishandle123]

Bro there is nothing in North hence North Indians are migrating to south

[@gowthamtechy94]

fun fact : she is from south india tamil nadu where anti - hindi policy followed 😂. she trying to defend bjp & show her as a true politician... shame on her... worst finance minister india has ever admitted.

[@wealthifyme]

Madam you are not fit for FM role... please resign

[@kashmiraraibaruah7908]

Nonsence and worst Finance minister ever

[@vivekmuradayil5594]

Correct reply for congress 😮😮😮😮😮😮after vomiting hate now they eat 😮😮

[@Umar-w7o]

Fm must focus on gdp , not on hindi ,

[@sainadha2989]

Worest finance minister Entire indian history

[@thishandle123]

Mam please speak about finance, you are finance minister. Hindi is not national language. Why give so much importance to it ? Why don't Nirth Indians learn South languages ?

[@dhritimankakati9483]

This woman is unbearable!

[@SudhakarNayak-lz7vf]

She is not able to be a finance minister...

[@sudeshnanayak765]

Fm is wating time but spekar sir smiling

[@donobasumatray5833]

I'll give vote for BJP in Assam but not for central just for this women's shameless women.

[@rbalachandran880]

FM is always against middle class and heavy GST on basic necessities. To divert the people, she is raising Hindi issue which is baseless. In tamilnadu at any point of time people are not prohibited from learning hindi

[@rkpraveen123]

Excellent 👌, we Tamil people are put apart from learning Hindi from decades, it was soo intelligently imposed on us, the main intention behind was to separate us from India, we can't watch Hindi news vedios, we don't know anything happening in our country

[@guydarj]

A large number of Tamil people belonging to your generation, before your generation and after your generation speak fluent Hindi. Don't blame it on others... you probably didn't want to learn it. In India, a bulk of people speak at least 3 languages fluently, which includes hindi. Your Hindi is like your finance.

[@vidyaranyavijayapura1121]

Govt should conduct education program on diversity to most of elected reps from hindi belt.

[@ArnaudRaufMaanickam]

Diversion tactics, answer on falling rupee?? Low economy!! Development?? Decentralization

[@yuvanpradeepcm4070]

ofc😂 What can this lady do, other than doing this!

[@clarity_craftt]

And i want to know why she is imposing so much taxes on us . Shame on her!

[@iammayurn]

Such arrogance of no use. She is not an exception now but an error. She is out of topic. What her role and what she is doing is just shameful

[@sadgurucollections6730]

I love her Parliamentary vocabulary...hatsoff🙏

[@deepakpratapgangwar583]

Desh ka gdp 4 percent kyu hy

[@ganeshprasadsahoo8972]

Because of Pappu

[@NiteshKumar-hy4fr]

Because pappu is current pm right😂​@@ganeshprasadsahoo8972

[@alextom-n4f]

5.4% not 4%

[@-bl2lu]

​@@ganeshprasadsahoo8972Pappu ne barbad kar diya sab,, cylinder 1000, petrol 110 ,,dollar 84,,aur gdp 5.4%,,,fir bhi andhbhakt khush he,,,

[@pratyushji6813]

Gdp 4% h....yaar thoda ri padh le cmnt krne se pehle tera he image defame hoga....ekdm tereko right h jo bolna h bolo koi tera chehra nii dekhega online par u should atleast have basic awareness before forming conclusions

[@Mysangeeet]

Lukhha 0:30 jhuthi kahin ki. 2:01 peeche dekho peeche

[@tamislive9304]

Shameless liar

[@himalayabastia7376]

He bhagwan please bless us with a good FM... Not single citizen want to see this lady anymore...

[@Eramitkamble2055]

लुखा हैं च अर्थ माहित नाही पण बोलायच कळतय कसं 😂😂

[@staystrong6896]

Please remove Sitaramn from her post..worst fm in india history

[@anonymoushuman524]

Did she ever contest and win in a direct election?

[@balanaik1]

Alexander was shaken by the tall heavily built King Purushottam with 400 tall elephants. In Modern times, even a fly weight person with Powerful oratory skills can shake 400 plus Alexanders.

[@NiftyPathshala]

although i don't support Nirmala Taai or this govt on many issues... but she was absolutely right on the HINDI issue in tamilnadu... i too have experienced the same there...

[@MaFiaMaxx]

Hindustan ki FinanceMinister ko HINDI nahi Aati, Wah #MODI ji WAH

[@jmjkumar2283]

As per " The Hindu", The State accounts for 73% of active Hindi pracharaks (teachers) in South India. Chennai has 4,678 pracharaks, more than the number of teachers in the other three southern States of Andhra Pradesh (undivided), Karnataka and Kerala. Together, these States have 3,787 pracharaks and Tamil Nadu has 10,709 teachers. This madam is full of lies. I never studied Hindi at school, but I know Hindi better than her. Also I know 3 South state languages. Learning a language should be a choice. Not compulsion. I strongly believe that, BJP & DMK, keep fighting to divert us from the main issues like poverty, corruptions and scams.

[@BKM2407]

Her attitude is matching with Smriti Irani attitude's.

[@YKC888]

The way she is dealing looks like South Indian movie female villain 😂

[@Drai4482]

Worst finance minister nirmala if she is there i will not vote for modi

[@cynthia7737]

Getting hate without any reason= Nirmala Sitaraman

[@Smankysheen]

Dont you have any working brain cells?

[@shalinidolai7254]

I am from andhra. Most people speak hindi. I can also speak hindi. I lived in Tamilnadu and they also learn hindi if needed. This lady is a shameless liar. We have second language hindi in all school. We have kendra vidhyalaya where hindi is primary language

[@gajananbant4873]

If tamilnadu is not part of india then you go out of this country

[@amalnag5672]

How can a person talk like this in Hindi,seating in the temple of democracy.

[@agnesfreed5428]

She will not have a proper reply about tax related questions or bank or money related problems faced by common people.... She will utter bla bla and seek attention to change the topics in parliament infornt of all MPs and the speaker just praising Modi 😂 the speaker will listen to her 😮 like she is a glorious speaker....

[@maverikcommon4582]

Madam don't forget that you are nominated from Karnataka not from Tamilnadu. All our MPs know Hindi very well.

[@SkniandarWanniang-w4i]

Wow!!! Even in parliament, there is a big joke.

[@sudeshnanayak765]

This fm not sutiable for this country

[@williammawlong493]

In northeast India too hindi is not mandatory to use ......we should respect our mother tongue

[@Rutvijmorey26]

I feel ashamed that the listener is smiling when hindi the rashtra bhasha is indirectly being disrespected

[@avinashsingh-ru4zc]

fm must resign as soon as possible

[@skm-kolkata]

Member of parliament ko hindi nehi hain... Shame

[@geethanagajyothidatla6467]

There is no such rule? Why should every MP know Hindi? They are from diff states.

[@vo67]

I don’t choose her to be FM leave please leave

[@goodnature13g19]

The FM suppose talk about finance related subject in the parliament and why wasting time and tax payers money on the topic which is not relevant for the position

[@mohansundaram100]

Not only Hindi, you are not good in any language and subject. The state Tamil Nadu is not against any language, but do not impose any language forcefully, as it was done during 1967. There are lakhs of migrant north Indian workers in Tamil Nadu, happily working in our state and trying to speak in Tamil and their employer are speaking in Hindi to run their business. The North Indian migrant workers are happily living here, the children are studying in Tamil medium, they will never go back to their state again. We provide them a better living condition and safe society. I used to talk with them in Hindi and enquirer about their well being, most of them are happy here because there is a definiteness in their life, which is a question mark in their native.They say that, the wages for their hard work was uncertain in their native, most of them expressed the same experience. They are happy to work here because they are respected here as a human being and getting regular payment for the hard work, especially there is no discrimination in the name of cast and community. The North Indian workers say that the Tamil Nadu is HEAVEN for them.

[@mohamedissac8692]

She is a big liar. No one was stopped from learning Hindi in Tamil Nadu. I myself went to Hindi prachar sabha.

[@vigneswararaja014]

BROTHER THEN WHY HINDI WENDAM PODA

[@vigneswararaja014]

What's a problem to learn hindi and talk

[@ayoutubecommenter1914]

@@vigneswararaja014if a person doesn’t wanna learn a language then u cannot impose it on him….i would rather learn English which is useful everywhere

[@vigneswararaja014]

@ayoutubecommenter1914 Brother Don't Think English works everywhere if Want to have a conversation with Chinese max they don't know English knowledge same malay Javanese sorry to say,it's my experience tc have a great day

[@srhiram51]

My two children learnt hindi Privately and passed Praveen and visharat exams between 90-97

[@anonymoushuman524]

The one in black coat behind her is a TDP MP, instead of fighting for the state just watching this drama

[@rmondal9090]

Nirmalaji is absolutely right.

[@PrakashSahoo-sl7hx]

After she become the finance minister all middle class people are facing financial troubles 😭 and she cannot feel the pain of poor people 😭 that's why she is doing that 😡and parlament also supporting her 😢

[@descendantsofjoshuaministr3551]

Bewkuf bana rahe hain north indians ko ... south mei hum theen ya char Indian languages plus Hindi janthei hain....Hundi is actually imposed on North Indians, making them stick to hindi alone *Please teach Indians to compete globally especially north bhaiyon ko* Stop north south language nautanki....

[@spicybone22]

She is not fit for Finance Minister post. The way she changed the topic shows that who she is.

[@travelfood5309]

Nirmala Sitaraman worst finance minister ever.

[@irudayamanohar7667]

Madam it is a nice speech,you have spoken good Hindi and good English,no one will challenge you in speaking.

[@tiktokhater2193]

Lukha hai was personal 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@RavindraNiranjan-xu1cf]

Shameless .........desh ki kya halat kar di hai tax laga laga ke........

[@PranjalKhatri-uj4xm]

One of my oldest friends is a Tamilian. I tried to learn Tamil from him. He was not very interested in teaching me Tamil. I insisted but our project fell down very soon. Now tell me how am I at fault. There are next to no sources for learning Tamil on the internet. If Tamilians are so intent on teaching the so called "Foreigners" tamil, why do you not get together and create such sources

[@deepakoneonly]

All Fake Certificate Holders are like this only 😂😂. Useless to common man.

[@manojm.c7392]

Who is that shouting honourable member in the parliament. If this is the case,,,,what is the meaning of good culture to be maintained in the social arena. This is why our social circle is being manipulated in the wrong way.....😢

[@vaibhavbhatii]

why are Converted crying in comment section🤔?

[@amitkdas007]

Our India. God save it please.

[@parthasarathik.s8024]

FM is correctly said regarding hindy

[@ganeshprasadsahoo8972]

Superb Madam You are the best finance minister in Indian history 💯👍

[@saikatdas2160]

Bal

[@hiteshsalian8259]

What do you know about Finance?

[@AlexZender-ej7jy]

Blind modi followers spotted

[@sambitkumardutta2006]

Jaake chat le 😂

[@sreenikap9492]

Paytm bjp chaddi

[@rudrachauhan404]

Well she has a point ❤❤

[@Rakesh3-r6i]

Shameless women 😒

[@descendantsofjoshuaministr3551]

@@rudrachauhan404 in fact she is making a fool of North Indians by restricting them to hindi, down south each individual knows 3-4 Indian languages plus English, instead of giving north indians good free skills to uplift their standard of living (like free electronic repair, tailoring, electrician, chef training, local guides, help creating entrepreneur and self employment.... instead of all the vikas project she is still fooling the north indians, and the north trusts her word.... please jago bhaiyon, get skills to compete globally.... dividing north south through languages and creating hatred is the British empire gimmicks ...don't fall prey to such cheap propaganda.... south mei hum theen ya char Indian languages janthei hain aur English bi....tum logon ko bewkuf banaya Jaa Raha hain ... please jaago, hum urdu, bhojpuri or Punjabi bi manage kar sakte hain....why you people trust this nautanki, *they are making you sentimental fools by actually imposing Hindi on North Indians* ....learn not only many Indian languages, please also learn skills, *if possible even German, Korean, Japanese and bring their technology to India*

[@SunilKumar-3001sr]

Shameless fm 😂😂

[@asishsarangi663]

Though i am a neutral citizen of this country ...but she is the worst FM in Indian history and she should resign on her own as she is not eligible to hold that post

[@leemukhim6681]

she has nothing important to discuss

[@karthiksharma2218]

She has to apologise revanth reddy for kamjor hindi remark

[@yashwantkumar1387]

Almost 11 min she agrued for useless topic instead of discussing about the problem faced by middle class people due to his policies. Worst minister of bjp.