Historian DEMOLISHES Zionist Talking Points

Watch the full conversation here: / patreon-rania-104700517
00:00 Intro
00:07 The blind spots of Israel supporters
03:54 Rashid's response to the comparison of Palestinians and Native Americans
05:15 Reparations for Natives should NOT be a radical idea
Palestinian-American historian and Edward Said Professor of Modern Arab Studies at Columbia University Rashid Khalidi explains the connection between wars abroad and wars at home, fascism and imperialism and why Israel could never exist and there would be no war on Gaza without the direct participation of the United States. "We're more than just backers" of the war, Khalidi says. Plus Khalidi discusses the connection between Ireland and Palestine and Katie mocks fired Israeli propagandist Eylon Levy for his self-own on Ireland and Palestine.
Rashid Khalidi (history.columb...) is the Edward Said professor of modern Arab studies at Columbia University and was an advisor to the Palestinian delegation to the Madrid and Washington Arab-Israeli peace negotiations from October 1991 until June 1993. He is the author of: The Hundred Years' War on Palestine: A History of Settler Colonialism and Resistance, 1917- 2017 (2020); Brokers of Deceit: How the U.S. has Undermined Peace in the Middle East (2013); Sowing Crisis: American Dominance and the Cold War in the Middle East (2009);The Iron Cage: The Story of the Palestinian Struggle for Statehood (2006); Resurrecting Empire: Western Footprints and America's Perilous Path in the Middle East (2004); Palestinian Identity: The Construction of Modern National Consciousness (1996); Under Siege: PLO Decision-Making During the 1982 War (1986); British Policy Towards Syria and Palestine, 1906-1914 (1980); and co-editor of Palestine and the Gulf (1982) and The Origins of Arab Nationalism (1991), and The Other Jerusalem: Rethinking the History of the Sacred City (2020).
**Please support The Katie Halper Show **
For bonus content, exclusive interviews, to support independent media & to help make this program possible, please join us on Patreon - / thekatiehalpershow
Get your Katie Halper Show Merch here! katiehalper.my...
Follow Katie on Twitter: @kthalps

[@petergiaschi35]

Dr. Khalidi has found a place in the Political Science/History pantheon. He needs to be talked about together with Chomsky. An inspiring man.

[@RichardPepperman-kk9yb]

The Pantheon? Of Anti-Semitism!!!

[@questionmark7045]

True - Chomsky is a famous genocide denier - manufactured lies about Pol - Pot atrocities reports and denied Serbian war crimes in Sarajewo.

[@KateBates22zabu]

Excellent analysis Dr Khalidi Thank you❤from USA

[@akko328]

Thank you Katie for continuing to shed more light on the core issues of the conflict such as international law, history of colonialism, etc and less on the semantics. Excellent job!

[@SvendBosanvovski]

Thank you, Katie, for bringing Professor Khalidi to a wider audience. His most recent publication The Hundred Years' War on Palestine is compelling reading, especially the Afterword composed in April this year.

[@Indebtwetrust535]

USS Liberty Never again Never forget ❤

[@Faiez-rh1gm]

What about 9/11

[@ryanawesome69]

As an Indigenous person from Turtle Island (KKKanada) whenever these Zios use that dismissive talking point, I tell them to keep me and my people’s name out their mouths. It is exactly cynical and gross. They even try to co-opt the Land Back movement. It made me sick to learn about that. Btw Blackface Trudeau has shown us, in his enthusiastic support for the genocide, exactly how committed he really is to “truth and reconciliation,” which is not at all. Free Palestine. Free Turtle Island.

[@OllieOckbar]

Ef Fakestine and nobody gives a crapola about Turtle Island. Wake up, boy. Allah is and always will be a Zionist.

[@andrew_owens7680]

If it wasn't for place names like The Potomac, we'd have no record at all. There were some survivors among the Patowamack tribe who were forced to hide their ancestry and who have names like Sullivan.

[@valeriewedel2775]

What do you feel about the land statements many universities now state at public addresses?

[@BamBamGT1]

You should all support each other. The Europeans colonized America, the Arabs colonized the Middle East and North Africa. You were all in the same boat. You don't have to be jealous because Israel is that uniquely succesful decolonization project where the indigenous people managed to crawl back from having become a tiny minority, to once again having their own state and being a majority. You don't have to support another part of the world's colonizers out of spite.

[@michaelbrewster3736]

@@valeriewedel2775It’s a start but never be sufficient! Privilege is never returned!

[@gabrielleangelica1977]

In my Jewish chat group, the Rabbi shut me down because I questioned Israel.

[@ShSy-ni6zq]

והיה = Torah and Jews welcome questions ויהי. Not by questions of four sons I know the feeling my cyberfriend Ultra Orthodox of past become tomorrow's Apikorsim Torturing Ba'al HaTanya Ba'al SHEM Tov Rambam Chasidim Do not go to palestine Be strong BeSTRONG And we will probably be lo al' be massacred 😢

[@gabrielleangelica1977]

@@ShSy-ni6zq Actually, it's a progressive Jewish forum!

[@user-nc2kt8ze7o]

The King David Hotel....never forget

[@freedom4639]

Well said 👍

[@aminimahsada]

The British were sent a warning to get out of their Headquarters in the King David, which they chose to ignore. Later the British sent arabs into the heart of Jerusalem with a truck filled with explosives and did not warn the local Israelis. That was a really shameful act of revenge which the British are still ashamed of.

[@kaizen960]

Its a genocide!

[@missypaws2500]

But to his point, He’s saying it’s learned behavior. Most human only use 3% to f their mind. 90% is unconscious. Meaning most people grt through life in a semi zombie state; some are evil zombies, some are passive, some are victims, etc. but much of what we do is via programming/ learned behavior.

[@Shanti-0M]

Thank you professor Khalidi for giving me a wonderful education; reading your 100 Years book was like sitting inside your lecture hall and receiving the keys to the door of knowledge. Opening the door allowed the light of understanding to provide a footing for the strongest foundational wisdom. Your book is filled with so many magnificent footnotes; which will lead one to further in depth truths for any mind. The wisdom gained has been vital sustenance for an open and honest summation. I wholeheartedly believe that it is of utmost importance that everyone outside of Palestine becomes educated and use the truth as a sword to cut through the walls of deception created by the misinformation ministry of lobbyists and complicit media outlets aligned against the Palestinian population everywhere. We owe it to every martyr and their loved ones to become a citizen lobby within your present homeland for Truth and Justice. Please study everyone; work diligently to gain the light of knowledge that will destroy the dark veiling cover that has blinded so many; and never stop shining the light of truth for as long as you live and breath. ✌🏼❤️🙏🕉

[@BruceWayne-zk5jc]

The so called Palestinian cause, kindly look back in history, they were thrown out of Morocco, given refuge in Lebanon, a Christian nation and look what they have made Beirut, the Paris of the middle East, look like today. Kindly ask the knowledgeable people as to what happened to the Palestinian people who were living in Kuwait, after the Gulf War, they were all thrown out,where are they after the war,?.

[@greendragonspirit1646]

"Britain" should be a curse word!

[@raistlin3462]

India: "Took you long enough".

[@fcb9950]

It is believe me

[@rajarsi6438]

Again you're wrong, childish one.

[@marissakeynes2532]

​@@rajarsi6438Sit down and be quiet. 🙄

[@rajarsi6438]

@@marissakeynes2532 Comical, your meaningless babbling. How old are you, mentally, 9, 10?

[@paulgibby6932]

Reading his book, "The Hundred Years' War on Palestine Book". Thanks for having him on again -- and for what you do, Katie. 5:09 "The United States is a settler colonial project...That's not such a radical idea." Yes, some kind of reparations is due. However western hegemony is falling apart, so there won't be any $ to pay back.

[@katiekane5247]

They're due reparations first

[@gregkle9384]

@@katiekane5247 that’s what it’s all about ,you start with empty slogans and then hello we want money.Most people read you like open book

[@KingForever-zu5jl]

Where are the Palestinian roots? Fathi Hamad, the interior minister in the Hamas government in the Gaza Strip said... "we all have Arab roots and every Palestinian in Gaza and all over Palestine can prove their Arab roots, whether they be in Saudi Arabia and Yemen, or anywhere else. Speaking personally, half of my family is Egyptian," he said. There are over 30 families in the Gaza Strip with the surname Al-Masri, 'Egyptian.' Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptian, and the other half are Saudi. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri whose roots are Egyptian! They come from Alexandria, Cairo, and Aswan. We are Egyptians." Palestinians are not even from Palestine! They are from Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and Yemen! Walid Shoebat, a former Fatah activist claims that everyone he met in Palestine "knew to trace the roots of their families to the country from which their great-grandfathers came." He stated: "We knew full well that our origin was not Canaanite, despite what they tried to teach us," he said. "My grandfather would often remind us that our village, Beit Sahour, near Bethlehem, was empty when his father arrived there with six other families. Today, there are over 30,000 residents in the village." In an interview with the Dutch newspaper "Dagblad de Verdieping Trouw", March 31, 1977, PLO executive committee member Zahir Muhsein stated: "The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people.” In 1937, the Arab leader Auni Bey Abdul Hadi told the Peel Commission: "There is no such country as Palestine. Palestine is a term the Zionists invented. Palestine is alien to us." In 1946, Princeton's Arab professor of Middle East history, Philip Hitti, told the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry: "It's common knowledge, there is no such thing as Palestine in history."

[@paulgibby6932]

@@KingForever-zu5jl Tell it to the people who were kicked out and murdered during the Nakba in 1948 by the Eastern Europeans such as David Gruen (oops) I mean David Ben-Gurion.

[@paulgibby6932]

@@KingForever-zu5jl brevity is the soul of wit, witless

[@bruceclark4754]

That said , I would be the first to criticise NZ for its disgustingly weak'kneed response to the genocide in Gaza. I do not argue that NZ is free of racist and colonial attitudes

[@garrett2439]

Sure, but New Zealand is not actively arming the Israelis either.

[@charleswilson8038]

What a world we live in?

[@naomideguyane]

I am asking myself this question every day now! It is HORRIFYING what we, as people have to support financially! They use Tax payers' money to commit atrocities with smirks on their corrupted faces !!! And I am not American! I live overseas! :'(

[@rajarsi6438]

God's infallible law of karma rules the material world. That's why never ever anything goes wrong.

[@DMC1982]

@@rajarsi6438 Karma? Wich of your 33 Million different versions of Karma???

[@rajarsi6438]

@@DMC1982 What childish nonsense are you babbling?

[@katiekane5247]

How easy it was to gain popular support for our crimes after 9/11, they've been steering their population for decades too. It's not an excuse, it's an understanding of agenda 😕

[@xxrazaxx]

That was good in depth analysis..in a way..definitely enlightening. Nevertheless, the quagmire is ridiculous.

[@59vlada]

"Civilized" way of killing innocents? Who turned off the light?

[@AnBreadanFeasa]

Irishman here... Britain deployed the Black & Tans, who terrorised civilians during the Irish War of Independence 1919-21, to Palestine after Ireland won its freedom. Ronald Storrs, the British military governor, was clear that their objective during the Palestine Mandate was to create “A little loyal Jewish Ulster in a sea of potentially hostile Arabism”. That colonial, imperialist and apartheid mindset was started by the British, developed by the Zionists and now recognised as government policy under Netanyahu.

[@stephenchappell7512]

Indeed they looked on Zionism favourably in order to secure the right flank of the Suez Canal Britain's lifeline to India

[@yasminc7827]

Ronald Storrs was not, as you falsely claim, justifying the Palestine Mandate when he spoke of a loyal Jewish Ulster. Storrs was actually justifying the Balfour Declaration. But his justification was also a false claim! The British made a deal - the Balfour Declaration and in return the Zionists would get the USA to join the allies in WW1. Britain would have lost WW1 otherwise.

[@salopian4037]

What obsessive British-haters like you tend to conveniently forget is that all this was a very long time ago, and the British people had little or no idea what its government were up to. There was not even universal suffrage at the time. Also, at the time of the Balfour Declaration Ireland was part of Britain - therefore, to continue with your collective blaming, the Irish had some responsibility too. We live in a different world today, and the people of Britain feel as strongly about what is happening to the Palestinians as the Irish. The difference being the Israelis can see exactly what their government is up to - as they have done for over 75 years - as largely support it. Recent dissent is more about a 'not me, Guv' pretence than any real compassion. Politicians and governments are the problem - and you Irish should now begin to see that in reality they care little for the opinions and wishes of the population.

[@IcarianX]

​@@salopian4037Wind your neck in. I don't see anything there that expresses hate towards the modern British people. He was just talking about settler colonial groups and projects from the early 20th century.

[@stephenchappell7512]

@@salopian4037 I'm a Brit myself but nothing he wrote was historically inaccurate + we have to consider (with this being prior to partition) that the Irish were still British subjects and therefore entitled to protection from what was still their government

[@RobertHeling69_420]

I'm currently reading his "100 years" book and i would encourage everyone to do the same. It is essential for understanding the history of the Palestinian people and the history of colonialism in Palestine

[@felixdim3977]

👍

[@DaraghORourke]

Propaganda works extremely well on people who couldn't be arsed to pick up a book and read because it's not happening to them!

[@freedom4639]

Well said read all history with an open mind.

[@valeriewedel2775]

Here in America, there was a massive death toll after the first Spanish explorers, who came bringing diseases, and left again. Entire nations like the Mandan were wiped out by flu and small pox. The Spaniards did not know they were bringing these diseases. This wiped out millions of people. The development of horses escaping and developing a new culture for plains tribes caused major changes in the nations also. And then finally we come to the war the American settler colonials made against the surviving tribes for land theft… and this is part of why I am fighting for the Palestinian people. My family in earlier generations have done the same for our First Nations. I still periodically fight to free Lenard Peltier. ❤

[@KingForever-zu5jl]

The names of modern-day Palestinians tell us of their non-Palestine origins. Just like "Saddam Hussein al-Tikriti" born in "tikrit iraq"... The family names(Nisbah نسبة) of Arabs who now occupy Judea and other parts of Israel reveal their country of origin: "Masri" OR "al-masri" =from Egypt ,Hamas member of Parliament in gaza, Mushir al-Masri (the word "masri" littelery means "the egyption" in arabic !). "Khamis"= from Bahrain "Salem Hanna Khamis" "al-ubayyidi" or "al-Obeidi"= from sudan "al-ubayyid" "al-Faruqi"= Mosul iraq "al-Araj" = Morocco,a member of the Saadi Dynasty "Hussein al-Araj" "al-Lubnani" =the lebanese "al-Mughrabi" = the Moroccan ("Maghreb" -- meaning "West" in Arabic, and usually referring to North Africa or specifically to Morocco) ,"Dalal Mughrabi" "al-Djazair"=the Algerian "al-Qurashi"=saudi arabia "clan of Quraish" "al-azd" =yemen "Azd tribe" "al-Yamani"= the Yemeni "Issam Al Yamani" "al-Afghani" = the Afghan "Al-Sidawi" = from "Sidon" lebanon "Al-fayyumi" = from "Faiyum" egypt "al-Hijazi" or "Hijazi" = present-day saudi arabia "Ahlam Higazi, a "Palestinian" artist from Hebron" "al-Hindi" =the Indian "Amin al-Hindi" "al-Tamimi" or "Tamimi" = from the tribe or clan of Banu-Tamim "Azzam Tamimi" "Hamati" = from syria ( HAMA city) "Omayya" = from saudi arabia "Banu Omayya tribe" "Omayya Joha" "palestinian artist" " "Othman" = turkey "murad" =yemen "murad tribe" "Alawi" = from syria (minority religious group in syria) "Iraqi" =from Iraq. "halabi" =from aleppo syria "Dajani"= from saudi arabia "Mattar" = from YEMEN (the village of BANI Mattar) "al-baghdadi"= from bagdad iraq. "Tarabulsi"= Tarabulus-Tripoli, Lebanon. "Hourani" =Houran Syria. "Zubeidi"= from iraq "Zubeidi tribe" "Zakaria Zubeidi" "al-Husayni" =saudi arabia. "Saudi" =Saudi Arabia. "Metzarwah"=egypt. "Barda­­­­­­­­­­­wil" ="salah bardawil" HAMAS legislator in gaza,egypt "bardawil lake" area "nashashibi"= syria. "Bushnak" =bosnia "zoabi"= from iraq "Haneen Zoabi". "Turki" =turkey "Daud Turki" "al-Kurd" = kurdistan. "Haddadins" = YEMEN descended from Ghassanid Christian Arabs. "Arab Abu-Kishk" = Egypt.(Bedouins) "Arab al shakirat" = Egypt (Bedouins) "Arab al zabidat" = Egypt (Bedouins) "Arab al aramsha" = Egypt (Bedouins) "Abu Sitta" =In Arabic' Abu means father and sitta means six. Translated it actually means father of six. The Abu Sitta family primarily received this name because around the year 1700, a well known knight of the large Al-Tarabeen tribe always had six slaves (i.e. fedawyah, bodyguards), 3 on each side, with him. They were with him wherever he went, day or night. Hence the name "ABU SITTA." =Egypt (Bedouins) "Salman Abu Sitta " "Nuba, Hebron" =founded by the "nuba people" Even "Arafat", the most famous fakestinian and leader of the terrorist grup the  P.L.O, is not native to Judea. He called himself a "Palestinian refugee" and claimed he was born in jerusalem ! BUT spoke Arabic with Egyptian dialect. He was born in 1929 Cairo, Egypt. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956 ! Arafat's full name was Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat al-Qudwa al-Husseini. "Al-Qudwa" tribe origin?

[@syriacchristianity9007]

Love you Katie!

[@carolineogara9004]

Is it the case that Chomsky has also argued the many nation states emerge from brutal violence?

[@sarachiba6012]

Professor Rashid Khalidi 💐🦋🍃

[@ashfaquei.k.426]

Long live Palestine, Long live As Sham, Long Live Resistance.

[@daisychainsmusicpublishing4789]

He is fantastic

[@richardwitty3666]

Rashied Khalidi is a decent man. He conspicuously does NOT advocate for denial of the Jewish community, the Jewish nation. He does not advocate to "send them back where they came from". He advocates for assertive recognition of Palestinian identity and history, AND for creating a form for mutual acceptance. This is NOT Hamas' position. It is not the far left's position.

[@ShSy-ni6zq]

Why should the State of Israel exist Christkillers are perverted and far from acting Chosen ! Hate the State ! I'm a Yid 2 Neturei Karta

[@lgar2554]

this isnt just a netanyahu problem.

[@bobbyokeefe4285]

The case of the US and Israel are not the same,when the Europeans arrived in North America,the natives had no collective national identity,it was mostly a bunch of isolated tribes who fought eachother,and there was no unifying idea of Statehood,whereas Palestine for centuries,from the Ottoman Empire to the Caliphates to the Roman Empire did share an identity.

[@sh25098]

Nonsense. There was no Palestinian identity. There is no historical records talking about a Palestinian nation or group of people. They were arab tribes with 0 collective identity.

[@bobbyokeefe4285]

@@sh25098 Well the Roman province of Palestina goes way back so,at least they had that,it's Historical.

[@mikeg2306]

@@bobbyokeefe4285The Roman province of Palestina was named after the long-dead Philistines who were NOT Arabs.

[@bobbyokeefe4285]

@@mikeg2306 The Philistines who were of Minoan descend ended up becoming the Palestinians they merged with local Semitic populations(like the Anglo Saxons did with the Celts,to become the British people),regardless what you call it,Palestine,Judea,or Cannan,(I don't want to get lost in a petty semantics debate)the modern day Palestinians are their descends,end of the story.

[@DMC1982]

Free Palestine 🇵🇸☪️🕎✝️☦️🇵🇸 One Nation under God with Justice and Liberty for all.

[@henkmagnetic3103]

I appreciate Prof. Rashid Khalidi emphasising the British role in World affairs. More specifically, UUK (Un-United Kingdom) English elite and aristocracy. Their off-spring and others certainly learnt well from Mother England. (edit, line repositioned to here from there). Slave trade from Africa, fine example of pious hypocritical Christian values keeping the capitalist philosophies in check, whilst transporting to Australia their many criminals, who most probably were just trying to survive. Ah, the good old days. Workhouses. Nothing like a jolly good roger - ing to keep all in line. Often wondered with the African slaves for the US of A, what colour the fathers could have been of the first half-castes. While thinking what colour person might be hanging in there yonder tree and why that might be, as per 'Strange Fruit' sung by Billie Holiday. Maybe Emmett Till. Opium Wars, awesome, not. Such an old culture is not going to forget that too soon. Stole tea plants from China for England, Robert Fortune. Second crime to the stealing is adding milk to tea, so, so, wrong. Land clearances in Scotland because more money in sheep. Hence, lack of trees as the land converted to pasture. Bluff and bluster. Divide and conquer. Once bitten, twice shy Once is a mistake, twice is stupidity. Fornicating priests and pregnant nuns. Only mad dogs and Englishmen go out in the mid-day sun. Jail is where the small criminals, get sent by the big criminals. Wonder what quotes/saying are applicable to criminal behaviour of the incestuous family of these good Christian folk from the UUK, US of A, (please, do not misappropriate the name America unless it is attached to the title, the United States of ...), and even Canada. They certainly perpetuated a myth of civility only to find out how many indigenous people, many children, buried 183 cm below in many a schoolyard. Nothing like a good bit of Christian tuition. I wonder what morals, values and ethics are driving today's Whitie Westie World policy? * Film - Billy Budd. As a child I was bit shaken watching this, as this is where I first became aware of the difference between justice, and the law.

[@PerceivedREALITY999]

76 year long apartheid, 17 year long blockade of Gaza and now committing genocide. Pure evil

[@RoseGold-24kt]

Law vs Ethics

[@user-en1wx6tj2m]

People are dying…where are the courts. Why taking so much time

[@nolitetebastardescarborund9761]

Thank you!

[@alvaronieto2734]

What’s “has a blind spot on this issue, but is otherwise intelligent.”? Those are not blind spots, it’s the morality of tribal people. Tribal people can’t see or think past their biases and it trumps their intelligence.

[@l23918]

Hannibal directive admitted by Israel newspaper

[@ShSy-ni6zq]

It is sad and frustrating Here Chareidim do not care about the world Who cares they will say The only thing what matters Is Torah

[@staticcouch135]

Please bring on Sami Hamdi Katie🙏🙏🙏

[@KingForever-zu5jl]

The names of modern-day Palestinians tell us of their non-Palestine origins. Just like "Saddam Hussein al-Tikriti" born in "tikrit iraq"...The family names(Nisbah نسبة) of Arabs who now occupy Judea and other parts of Israel reveal their country of origin: "Masri" OR "al-masri" =from Egypt ,Hamas member of Parliament in gaza, Mushir al-Masri (the word "masri" littelery means "the egyption" in arabic !). "Khamis"= from Bahrain "Salem Hanna Khamis" "al-ubayyidi" or "al-Obeidi"= from sudan "al-ubayyid" "al-Faruqi"= Mosul iraq "al-Araj" = Morocco,a member of the Saadi Dynasty "Hussein al-Araj" "al-Lubnani" =the lebanese "al-Mughrabi" = the Moroccan ("Maghreb" -- meaning "West" in Arabic, and usually referring to North Africa or specifically to Morocco) ,"Dalal Mughrabi" "al-Djazair"=the Algerian "al-Qurashi"=saudi arabia "clan of Quraish" "al-azd" =yemen "Azd tribe" "al-Yamani"= the Yemeni "Issam Al Yamani" "al-Afghani" = the Afghan "Al-Sidawi" = from "Sidon" lebanon "Al-fayyumi" = from "Faiyum" egypt "al-Hijazi" or "Hijazi" = present-day saudi arabia "Ahlam Higazi, a "Palestinian" artist from Hebron" "al-Hindi" =the Indian "Amin al-Hindi" "al-Tamimi" or "Tamimi" = from the tribe or clan of Banu-Tamim "Azzam Tamimi" "Hamati" = from syria ( HAMA city) "Omayya" = from saudi arabia "Banu Omayya tribe" "Omayya Joha" "palestinian artist" " "Othman" = turkey "murad" =yemen "murad tribe" "Alawi" = from syria (minority religious group in syria) "Iraqi" =from Iraq. "halabi" =from aleppo syria "Dajani"= from saudi arabia "Mattar" = from YEMEN (the village of BANI Mattar) "al-baghdadi"= from bagdad iraq. "Tarabulsi"= Tarabulus-Tripoli, Lebanon. "Hourani" =Houran Syria. "Zubeidi"= from iraq "Zubeidi tribe" "Zakaria Zubeidi" "al-Husayni" =saudi arabia. "Saudi" =Saudi Arabia. "Metzarwah"=egypt. "Barda­­­­­­­­­­­wil" ="salah bardawil" HAMAS legislator in gaza,egypt "bardawil lake" area "nashashibi"= syria. "Bushnak" =bosnia "zoabi"= from iraq "Haneen Zoabi". "Turki" =turkey "Daud Turki" "al-Kurd" = kurdistan. "Haddadins" = YEMEN descended from Ghassanid Christian Arabs. "Arab Abu-Kishk" = Egypt.(Bedouins) "Arab al shakirat" = Egypt (Bedouins) "Arab al zabidat" = Egypt (Bedouins) "Arab al aramsha" = Egypt (Bedouins) "Abu Sitta" =In Arabic' Abu means father and sitta means six. Translated it actually means father of six. The Abu Sitta family primarily received this name because around the year 1700, a well known knight of the large Al-Tarabeen tribe always had six slaves (i.e. fedawyah, bodyguards), 3 on each side, with him. They were with him wherever he went, day or night. Hence the name "ABU SITTA." =Egypt (Bedouins) "Salman Abu Sitta " "Nuba, Hebron" =founded by the "nuba people" Even "Arafat", the most famous fakestinian and leader of the terrorist grup the  P.L.O, is not native to Judea. He called himself a "Palestinian refugee" and claimed he was born in jerusalem ! BUT spoke Arabic with Egyptian dialect. He was born in 1929 Cairo, Egypt. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956 ! Arafat's full name was Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat al-Qudwa al-Husseini. "Al-Qudwa" tribe origin?

[@laserprawn]

If you look at the activities of the Haganah and the Palmach, as well, they are very open--oral histories etc--in speaking about the fact that they assaulted villages, killed civilians, bulldozed or demolished their homes etc. There was never any distinction between Arab civilian and militant, from day 1 of the occupation.

[@bruceclark4754]

New Zealand HAS been doing this for some decades Rashid. We have the Treaty of Waitangi and efforts to achieve justice for past wrongs. Its not perfect of course but be careful about lumping different countries together if you don't know your facts.

[@garrett2439]

There's also the Maori seats. Show me another country, anywhere on Earth, that was guaranteeing democratic political representation to a minority group in the 1860s.

[@Nicki-x2m]

The settlement of New Zealand was in no way similar to that of Australia or the US or any other country.

[@TJtheDJonWMCN]

He's Edward Said Professor Emeritus....

[@215Gallagher]

I'm actually glad I was born in Northern Ireland in 1959 of a mixed marriage which resulted in my mother's father not speaking to her again, and while he was alive I only ever saw the back of his head. In 1970 my family move to Australia, a mere three years after the first nations people, the 'aboriginies' as we called them, were recognised as human being by referendum. I've seen the Bogside people firsthand as they were at my school which was on the Lecky Road, I've watched the Land Rights struggle in Australia, I've never voted for a candidate whose won a seat in Parliament, and I'm a natural born outsider. Now I can analyse and critique all societies from the object position of any personal interest, human being are bloody ignorant apes has been my motto since 1975 and I've seen nothing since that could ever lead to a change from that opinion.

[@sylviewalker7560]

186K dead in Gaza.

[@felixdim3977]

The toll is higher than this

[@coleengoodell7523]

We can't change the past. We can learn from it and try to do better. We can change the now. What's happening right now and we can keep fighting back with our words, protests, marches, votes, calls and letters. May Justice prevail!

[@jurgenrohrbach4499]

👍

[@BoycottApartheid_org]

Thank you Katie and Rashid, keep up the fantastic work.

[@jacquejones96793]

Don't forget Hawaii

[@PerceivedREALITY999]

Thank you Katie and Rashid. We must not be silent while witnessing injustice.

[@noahstevens3060]

Turn off ads if you don't support the problem.

[@laserprawn]

Well, it actually means that those people are not smart--it means they have never taken the time to look and see what the effects of bombs are. I mean, you shouldn't really need to--how hard is it to imagine that bombs and artillery will destroy a human body in a way that bullets struggle to.

[@maestoso47]

How much can we explain away the Jewish settlers actions to that of a traumatized group?

[@RoseGold-24kt]

Recent opportunist colonist settlers in occupied Palestine are Zionist jews from usa & europe with dual citizenship , so what " trauma" ?

[@noahstevens3060]

Why am I getting ads for the democratic party on this channel? Hippocratic.

[@eric57016]

Satans Toilet❤

[@antonipeters2333]

They didn't have to wait for the British colonialists to teach them how to attack the civilian population. They learned it from the Bolsheviks.

[@robertmaitino5674]

Reparations? Ha!

[@jeronimotamayolopera4834]

THAT'S NICE DEAR.

[@Coconutkid788]

Were are the 1.000.000 Jews that lived in Arab countries...what happened to their homes...their institutions their synagogues their business's ?

[@petermcculloch4933]

New Zealand seems to be a little different.While they did have war, they also have a treaty.And white Kiwis have absorbed many Maori traditions and practices into the national culture

[@garrett2439]

Yet this guy claimed that the Europeans "destroyed the native population". Clearly he has never been to New Zealand.

[@wewenang5167]

@@garrett2439 he was talking in general...not just the kiwi, he mention US as first example and US did destroyed the native nations and deported them to conservation land after killing more than half of their population. Even in news Zealand the British did destroyed many tribes and native populations but they are not very successful because the native Maori fought back very hard just like the Palestinian did and they never surrender willy nilly! If the Native Māori didn't fought back, 100% all of them will be destroyed. Many Maori original tribals land are now under the hands of white settlers. They were forced to move to other locations. The only reason why the British did not do more harms to native Māori is because they see that it was not worth it because New Zealand unlike other British colonies dint really have any huge natural resources or strategic important. If News Zealand is in the middle east and have oil and gas....same thing will happen to the Maori like in Palestine now. The only people who are willing to moved to New Zealand back then was poor farmers who didnt have land in England so most of these settlers are mere farmers and the British dont really care about them. What rights the Māori have todays was fought and bleed for, not given freely by the British or the white settlers. even today many white settlers are still racist toward the native Māori.

[@igalsx]

Is it moral to fight from highly populated areas as hamas do? Seems to me that they use their own population as human shield.

[@718junius]

Dr khalidi is a historically ignorant that there were not settler colonialism before European colonialism.. from the spread of Islam in the 7th century conquering the Levant , North Africa, Iberian peninsula, Mesopotamia, South Asia. The Assyrians, Romans, Chinese, various empires created colonies and settled their coethnics in conquered lands. Nice try, anti westerners.

[@scottmcloughlin4371]

Watch the video. Listen harder.

[@craigprince555]

Quran mentions Israel 🇮🇱 43 times. There is no palestine in quran.

[@pinealservo]

Did you know that Israel, before 1948, was not by itself the name of a land? The Quran names no land "Israel". It uses "Israel" aka Jacob twice, in reference to the man, and the other times it uses "Bani-Israel" or "people of Jacob". There was a "kingdom of Israel" and a "kingdom of Judah"; neither is mentioned by the Quran and both refer to the names of their patriarchs. Neither encompassed all of Palestine (or the land of Canaan if you want a name from that time). Your quip doesn't seem so clever anymore, does it?

[@craigprince555]

@@pinealservo So show me where in the quran it spells out that “Jacob is Israel” and “the land of Canaan” (a name from that time) complete with sura, chapter, and verse??? Keep pretending to be smart! 🙈 There was never an independent palestine before 1948. There has never been a country called palestine. 🥲 Pretend you know what you’re talking about. Ooops…🙊

[@olgasokurova9559]

​@@craigprince555read about Philistia (Philistian pentapolis) which existed at the same time as jewish kingdom

[@freedom4639]

Gentile good read their book.

[@olgasokurova9559]

@@craigprince555 hm, my answer got deleted. So what about Philistia?

[@yasminc7827]

WHAT THE HELL!!! The British DID NOT TEACH the Haganah, Irgun and Lehi. The British were AT WAR with the Haganah, Irgun and Lehi. The British were CONSTANTLY TARGETED by the Haganah, Irgun and Lehi.

[@nathanielmartins5930]

Yes, during the "Independence war" Prior to that, the British trained Jewish fighters to help in World War 2 and in settlement establishment.

[@yasminc7827]

@@nathanielmartins5930 the British did NOT “train Jewish fighters in settlement establishment”. What is your evidence for this claim? The British actually capped the number of Jewish Europeans entering Palestine.

[@nathanielmartins5930]

@yasminc7827 Yes they did.

[@yasminc7827]

@@nathanielmartins5930 what is the evidence for your claim?

[@nathanielmartins5930]

@@yasminc7827 kzbin.info/www/bejne/gqqsc3yuataDqbMsi=sDv9Y9ovV0DBa1GC

[@PerceivedREALITY999]

We must not be silent while witnessing injustice. Israel is committing war crimes and US is complicit in those crimes.

[@gregkle9384]

@per Russian Federation just bombed children s hospital,but who cares no Jews involved,pathetic hypocrites,that’s who you are

[@mfre897]

😂😂😂 Historian? Big deal.Who cares what he says.

[@QueenTiye2024]

Tragically, 100 million Indigenous Americans were killed--stemming from genocide, enslavement, disease, and so forth--during 5 centuries of European colonialism throughout the Americas and Caribbean. It's a history that must be incorporated into the curricula so Americans can learn from the nation's past. The same can be said for centuries of African enslavement, lynchings, the deadly race riots, and segregation. America and other colonial nations, including Australia, must reckon with the past in order to move forward in the areas of race-relations, socio-economic equality, and justice for all.

[@tonybanks1035]

Katie: "some people want to claim there's a moral difference between bombs and the barbaric acts committed by Hamas" Professor: "then they don't know much about international law". Talk about basic, incoherent, category error. Using random legal conventions to analyze the moral content of acts, that's the whole strategy of anti zionists and it doesn't make the slightest sense. DEI professor right there.

[@rosariocannistraro3561]

Ok Klan boy .

[@Marina-sm9xt]

I have the utmost respect for Dr Khalidi, but I am confused. Yes, the indigenous people of America, Canada and Australia (and all the other colonies of the English) were victims of genocides and reparations should be made, however it is my understanding that the remaining indigenous people of these countries are now equal under the law. Should that not be the starting point for Palestinians. First 100% equal rights, then they can talk reperations. Genocide and Apartheid in 2024, surely that is the point of difference.

[@JAG8691]

Reparations for Colonial events from 200 to 300 years ago? Only the British Colonies? Maybe 2 generations forward is appropriate but to give Reparations for the whole Colonial historical period after 2 generations have passed from the time of obtaining 100% equal rights/ Independence is ridiculous and will be abused by especially Marxists and Racial Grifters.

[@garrett2439]

Please provide evidence that there was a genocide against the native population at any point in the history of European activity in New Zealand.

[@eliyahukonn3245]

Lie nuch in your titles? Didn't see any history debunked.

[@freedom4639]

Holocaust 🤔

[@jeffreywilheim5970]

Have you ever thought about all of the good you could be doing instead of demonizing Israel? Because there's still time to come back to common decency.

[@RichardPepperman-kk9yb]

HISTORIAN DEMOLISHES? SOUNDS LIKE A GENOCIDE.

[@massoverride478]

im not ok with how things have transpired by any stretch but to say colonial powers are the only ones that have acted in such a way in warfare is egregious and a bold face lie ask the south african farmers that had to watch their children raped and then parents murdered the lists go on and on in the name of this our country and they rolled out the genocide carpet after a month of war because that was the default defense already pre ordained if the military took a overpowering stance against the hostile forces using guerilla tactics along with every other countries sick pasts and present conflicts so give me a break with this load of crap colonial powers like they are the damn fathers of un just war just stfu

[@KingForever-zu5jl]

Where are the Palestinian roots? Fathi Hamad, the interior minister in the Hamas government in the Gaza Strip said... "we all have Arab roots and every Palestinian in Gaza and all over Palestine can prove their Arab roots, whether they be in Saudi Arabia and Yemen, or anywhere else. Speaking personally, half of my family is Egyptian," he said. There are over 30 families in the Gaza Strip with the surname Al-Masri, 'Egyptian.' Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptian, and the other half are Saudi. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri whose roots are Egyptian! They come from Alexandria, Cairo, and Aswan. We are Egyptians." Palestinians are not even from Palestine! They are from Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and Yemen! Walid Shoebat, a former Fatah activist claims that everyone he met in Palestine "knew to trace the roots of their families to the country from which their great-grandfathers came." He stated: "We knew full well that our origin was not Canaanite, despite what they tried to teach us," he said. "My grandfather would often remind us that our village, Beit Sahour, near Bethlehem, was empty when his father arrived there with six other families. Today, there are over 30,000 residents in the village." In an interview with the Dutch newspaper "Dagblad de Verdieping Trouw", March 31, 1977, PLO executive committee member Zahir Muhsein stated: "The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel. Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people.” In 1937, the Arab leader Auni Bey Abdul Hadi told the Peel Commission: "There is no such country as Palestine. Palestine is a term the Zionists invented. Palestine is alien to us." In 1946, Princeton's Arab professor of Middle East history, Philip Hitti, told the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry: "It's common knowledge, there is no such thing as Palestine in history."

[@JAG8691]

The South African European ancestry population is predominantly of Dutch and French Hugenot origin. Most of their lineage traces back to 300 years ago. There are many Millions of Sub- Saharan African descendants that have been present less than half that time in what is now the RSA. The British did reduce the Dutch ancestry population during the 2nd Anglo-Boer war which cost them their Republics. Where do you think that the term " Concentration Camp " comes from? History is hardly ever as simplistic as he presented.

[@tomzukouski6041]

When the europeans came to america there was no (america) as such there were many various compleately autonomous tribes in a vast land ,no central government ,no national identity and a largely hunter gather societies ,except for the cahokia with more agricultural, this isnt anywhere near the same as palestine!..palestillians had a common identity,arab,a national relegion

[@gregkle9384]

@tom there isn’t specific Palestinian people,there are Palestinian Arabs,Palestinian Jews, Palestinian Christians etc. If Israel lost 1948 war these co called Palestinians would be Egyptians,Jordanians,Lebanese or Syrians and together with Jews,Christians and others who lived on geographical territory called Palestine would be citizens of these countries . 48-67 Egypt and Jordan controlled Gaza and Judea and Samaria and Palestinian Arabs didn’t establish Palestinian state.Why? Waiting for answer if you can manage

[@tomzukouski6041]

@@gregkle9384 the overwelming majority of people living in palestine were arab in 1945.the jews illegally streaming there by the hundreds of thousands after ww2 were citizens of european countries!...the zionist movement even before the war planned to make it there country.there isnt specific jewish people!...they are german jews,hungarian jews,russian jews.and the 1948 war was started to create israel and remove the palestillian arabs.the nakba ever hear of it.

[@KingForever-zu5jl]

The names of modern-day Palestinians tell us of their non-Palestine origins. Just like "Saddam Hussein al-Tikriti" born in "tikrit iraq"...The family names(Nisbah نسبة) of Arabs who now occupy Judea and other parts of Israel reveal their country of origin: "Masri" OR "al-masri" =from Egypt ,Hamas member of Parliament in gaza, Mushir al-Masri (the word "masri" littelery means "the egyption" in arabic !). "Khamis"= from Bahrain "Salem Hanna Khamis" "al-ubayyidi" or "al-Obeidi"= from sudan "al-ubayyid" "al-Faruqi"= Mosul iraq "al-Araj" = Morocco,a member of the Saadi Dynasty "Hussein al-Araj" "al-Lubnani" =the lebanese "al-Mughrabi" = the Moroccan ("Maghreb" -- meaning "West" in Arabic, and usually referring to North Africa or specifically to Morocco) ,"Dalal Mughrabi" "al-Djazair"=the Algerian "al-Qurashi"=saudi arabia "clan of Quraish" "al-azd" =yemen "Azd tribe" "al-Yamani"= the Yemeni "Issam Al Yamani" "al-Afghani" = the Afghan "Al-Sidawi" = from "Sidon" lebanon "Al-fayyumi" = from "Faiyum" egypt "al-Hijazi" or "Hijazi" = present-day saudi arabia "Ahlam Higazi, a "Palestinian" artist from Hebron" "al-Hindi" =the Indian "Amin al-Hindi" "al-Tamimi" or "Tamimi" = from the tribe or clan of Banu-Tamim "Azzam Tamimi" "Hamati" = from syria ( HAMA city) "Omayya" = from saudi arabia "Banu Omayya tribe" "Omayya Joha" "palestinian artist" " "Othman" = turkey "murad" =yemen "murad tribe" "Alawi" = from syria (minority religious group in syria) "Iraqi" =from Iraq. "halabi" =from aleppo syria "Dajani"= from saudi arabia "Mattar" = from YEMEN (the village of BANI Mattar) "al-baghdadi"= from bagdad iraq. "Tarabulsi"= Tarabulus-Tripoli, Lebanon. "Hourani" =Houran Syria. "Zubeidi"= from iraq "Zubeidi tribe" "Zakaria Zubeidi" "al-Husayni" =saudi arabia. "Saudi" =Saudi Arabia. "Metzarwah"=egypt. "Barda­­­­­­­­­­­wil" ="salah bardawil" HAMAS legislator in gaza,egypt "bardawil lake" area "nashashibi"= syria. "Bushnak" =bosnia "zoabi"= from iraq "Haneen Zoabi". "Turki" =turkey "Daud Turki" "al-Kurd" = kurdistan. "Haddadins" = YEMEN descended from Ghassanid Christian Arabs. "Arab Abu-Kishk" = Egypt.(Bedouins) "Arab al shakirat" = Egypt (Bedouins) "Arab al zabidat" = Egypt (Bedouins) "Arab al aramsha" = Egypt (Bedouins) "Abu Sitta" =In Arabic' Abu means father and sitta means six. Translated it actually means father of six. The Abu Sitta family primarily received this name because around the year 1700, a well known knight of the large Al-Tarabeen tribe always had six slaves (i.e. fedawyah, bodyguards), 3 on each side, with him. They were with him wherever he went, day or night. Hence the name "ABU SITTA." =Egypt (Bedouins) "Salman Abu Sitta " "Nuba, Hebron" =founded by the "nuba people" Even "Arafat", the most famous fakestinian and leader of the terrorist grup the  P.L.O, is not native to Judea. He called himself a "Palestinian refugee" and claimed he was born in jerusalem ! BUT spoke Arabic with Egyptian dialect. He was born in 1929 Cairo, Egypt. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956 ! Arafat's full name was Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat al-Qudwa al-Husseini. "Al-Qudwa" tribe origin?

[@user-en1wx6tj2m]

Colonial isn’t good. US it happened…..Israel it is happening now. What is reparation for their heirs. DK. Money shouldn’t be answer. Free education for the future. Growth. I can stand behind that

[@alanstech3724]

Saying, it's what the Israelis do. Have you looked at the Arab world. Israel compared to the Arab countries, it's like night and day

[@wapi8411]

they can both be shit at the same time. also what part of APARTHEID do you not understand?

[@garrett2439]

Which Arab country is currently committing a genocide?

[@BamBamGT1]

He's hilarious So the Arabs started the civil war in Palestine, Arab militia's kill cvilians, Jewsih militia's retaliate and besides the militiamen there are also civlian casualties. His take is: the jews are the bad guys, they killed civilians. This is so typical for Pro-palestinians.

[@mikeg2306]

@@garrett2439Sudan

[@garrett2439]

The Europeans destroyed the native population in New Zealand? Huh? No they didn't lol wtf is this guy on about? He knows nothing of New Zealand.

[@freedom4639]

You can't stand the truth.

[@garrett2439]

@@freedom4639 Have you ever even been to New Zealand? Have you ever heard of the Treaty of Waitangi? If the Europeans goal was to destroy the Maori people, why did they sign a treaty with them? Why was there no genocide? Why did we create the Maori seats in our parliament all the way back in the 1860s? Btw I'm from a Maori family and we don't seem all that destroyed.

[@gabrielleangelica1977]

​@garrett2439America made the same false claim. We still have Indians don't we? They signed a treaty! Thank you Master.

[@garrett2439]

@@gabrielleangelica1977 Comparing New Zealand's colonialism to that of the US just shows me you don't know anything about New Zealand. Did the US create Native American seats in Congress in the 1860s?

[@gabrielleangelica1977]

@@garrett2439 Stop lying; you are NOT a Maori!

[@BruceWayne-zk5jc]

This man is pro sharia. Why don't people like him talk about yemenis children dying of starvation, os Assad who starved million of sunni muslim in Syria, this man should be asked his views on that.

[@freedom4639]

You need to get of that medication MSM isn't good for you.

[@francih923]

her poor parents , siding with hamas

[@layinlow77]

you mean siding with humanity

[@garrett2439]

Yeah, she should be siding with the genociders, like you are! Right?

[@Coconutkid788]

This guy is unbiaed after all he s name is Rashid...he must be independent...he must be employed by the Hamas Health Industry and a second job for UNWRA...