Historian EXPOSES Colonialism, Gandhi, And Delhi Snobs | Dostcast w/ Hindol Sengupta

[@dostcast]

If you enjoyed this episode, could you please hit the like button 👍 it helps us massively. Appreciate you all! 🙏

[@sanatmohanta7243]

I think you have started to cut your guests mid sentence before letting them finish, like ranveer does....I like to watch your content because you generally listen to them first, also because you mostly reasearch or read their works, hence you have better questions for them. It's been two episodes with kushal & definitely from that I got directed towards hindol's, am noticing you interrupting. Just a positive criticism, nothing against you brother.

[@sanatmohanta7243]

Also because you used to try to understand your guests' perspective rather than pushing your beliefs. The podcaster/interviewer is just a medium, people are there for the guests. Nobody likes snobby journalists.

[@vasua2348]

Another RSS BJP paid stooges arrived who defame Nehru Gandhi legacy and trying to portray the incidents in some sort of Negative light. These Godi KZbinrs (KZbinrs sitting in lap of modi) will not invite historian from other side

[@rsn180690]

What a pleasant surprise to see Hindol Sengupta on a podcast! Don’t think he does many.

[@dharmikpatel2894]

P😊p

[@zaara33]

What a brilliant podcast! Read Soul and swords and it was a revelation, a mix of anger and sadness and finally pride for our country to owning the bharatiya narrative. And this is a podcast for EVERYONE and I mean every Bharatiya young and old. Thank you Vinamre and Hindol for such a fantastic session 🙏🏾

[@mosesl.nonglait545]

I couldn't find any better words to praise this conversation, thankyou very very much sadar pranam shrimant dhanyawad Bharat ki jai ho.

[@Valkyier911]

Hindol sounds like a calmer more civilised AIM

[@Arjun499__]

OMG yes 😂😂😂 I'm dying laughing now 😂🤣

[@AA13494]

i disagree. AIM hates gandhi and his ideology while hindol still believes india needs gandhi. i believe india dsnt need any of its freedom leaders now. they all were equally confused and egoistic.

[@AA13494]

but Aim dislikes gandhi and his ideology, while hindol belives we need gandhi. I believe we dnt need any of those freedom leaders. they all were equally confused.

[@Arjun499__]

@@AA13494 he said he sounds like AIM doesn't mean he shares the same values, how AIM speaks is what's same with hindol

[@Arjun499__]

@@AA13494 and I strongly disagree with you on India not needing it's freedom fighters only Gandhi parivaar was eager for political power made us believe that they did all of it, if you read biographies of other people you will understand how INC wasn't even made by an Indian, it was made by an English men after the revolt of 1857 to make Indians feel that they are being represented but on the main stage britishers didn't care of INC, it was just a boundary for Indians to keep them at bay Then comes subhas Chandra Bose Saab, bhagat Singh Saab, Veer Savarkar Saab, chandrashekhar azad Saab and many more who really wanted to unite people and push the Britishers out NOTHING CAN BE GAINED WITH NON VIOLENCE IN A COLONIAL ERA, MAHATMA GANDHI WAS A BIG SCAM FOR INDIANS, AND SO IS THE CONGRESS PARTY NOWADAYS

[@rosewater6778]

Vinamre you have an incredible penchant for fishing out hidden gems. I've read books written by Hindol Sengupta and watched that odd KZbin short that I loved. But I've always wondered why he's not interviewed more often. Thrilled to watch this. He's a dark horse and among those whose ideas will shape that new India we're hoping to see. Thanks for having him on Dostcast 😊

[@Haveagodday-w8m]

Great podcast! Could you kindly invite Mr. Rajiv Malhotra on this podcast? He is a highly intellectual man and has contributed more than 30 years in dismantling Western and liberal propanganda abroad against India . He has made significant contributions in this field and has also published many critically accalimed books.He is probably coming to India around mid-March

[@06musicfan]

I really enjoyed this podcast, thankyou so much!

[@chaitanyadubey2914]

This was a great podcast thoroughly enjoyed it from the beginning to the end

[@subhashishdutta]

What a podcast. This is among one of my best listens. The Ujjain Mahakal mandir and Rhinoplasty examples were mind blowing. As Hindol says, "cultural confidence doesn't come from thin air, it comes from understanding your culture". We are at a hugely exciting time in our nation's journey where more and more people are engaging and trying to understand our culture.

[@htnaku4947]

Gandhi was Father of Anti-Hindu and Muslim Appeasement Politics in India.

[@NikhilKumar-lp9bn]

Thanks for the effort...both of u.

[@adityatiwari1022]

Kushal Bhai ki recommendation pe le aaye. Nice. Dekhta hoon pura ab

[@suen3634]

Really enjoying this discussion. Hindol Sengupta’s views on a number of issues like Bhakti, spirituality, rewriting of history all resonates deeply. Look forward to more books from him.

[@logicalthinker48]

Book recommendation: India A Wounded Civilization by VS Naipaul🥰🥰

[@KumarSanket11]

Single most wholesome podcast episode ever! Thanks for this one mate, it is indeed entirely down to how you opened up so many themes

[@riya_beautifulchaos]

Wow! Amazing conversation and exciting topics! All topics picked up are really good! Thanks Vinamre for introducing us to new people and enlightened personalities by way of your podcast. The fact that you read the books beforehand, makes you an informed person who is asking all the right questions. Thank you! ❤

[@viswanathanseshadri1047]

A very wholesome podcast and a wholesome guest. Hindol and his books are profoundly informativevand insightful

[@rajendradangi2585]

When I was I college I came across a person saying Hinduism is not a religion and it angered me deeply and then the journey begin to know what so called Hinduism rather hinduismS is? Before that Hinduism to me was just pujas n festivals...

[@rosewater6778]

Ya it's one of those inane pieces of rhetoric the left has cursed us with.

[@ridhiagarwal8524]

Yeee after kushals podcast i read swords and souls and i m glad u invited hindol sengupta

[@saishirdi2014]

Thanks Hindol 👍

[@Cha-s2w]

Fascinating discussion

[@BongChakraborty]

8:04 "Right !" .... typical Calcuttan expression 😂😂

[@vickeykooper2674]

Hey dostcast, if possible please invite Acharya Prashant as well. He is ex IIT, IIM, cracked UPSC CSE exam,and then left these to become proponent of Vedanta philosophy!!

[@Sasha_Lara]

Thank you for this masterpiece!!

[@Karshneya]

A really informative and intelligent conversation. Thank you.

[@aradhanasingh3441]

extremely pleasing for my dose of history and political awareness. scintillating podcast ❤

[@AnjuSingh-ov2qr]

Please make a video on the book the beautiful tree by historian Dharampal ji it's about indigenous Indian education system and dalit and women education system and because of casteism people defame and leave Hinduism please sir 😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@diptibistaswal4604]

What an amazing podcast!!....brilliant conversation.

[@anonymouslyopinionated656]

Veering off towards the end, thank god we didn't get to Pushpak Vimana

[@anonymous-yf6ur]

Really enjoyed this podcast!

[@sauravroychow]

Superb talk. These are the intellectual discussions that are required that have different perspectives, more holistic and not one-sided agenda.

[@neueman]

It's Gandhi's professed ideals which are even more problematic and deeply troubling. It's in exposing the fallacy of these ideals that we begin to uncover the reasons behind them, which, in my assessment were far more sinister than is supposed.

[@TheCrazyconfused]

Brilliant

[@Indianoamericanorussiano]

Thanks to Bengalis like Hindol Sengupta, still we north indians respect bengalis. Otherwise everyone would think that bengal only means communism.

[@ronojoybasu9126]

There's no need to specify 'Bengali' scholar, anybody reading his name will know where he is from..

[@TapasMukherjee-xl7iu]

Sorry, I can't agree on his interpretation of gandhi nehru

[@rka-truthalwayswins5127]

WHY

[@vasua2348]

@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 because he is RSS BJP inclined historian and see his debate with purushottam aggarwal on aajtak. you will see how these sanghis(RSS people) getting slapped with facts

[@lakshmipathirao8371]

Truly fascinating..

[@VJMOJO]

Susrutha, the father of Surgery in ancient India who was from Varanasi started Rhinoplasty (the predecessor to today's Plastic Surgery); hence we can rightfully say that he was the father of Plastic Surgery and he was not from Tamil Nadu.

[@hyugakarn]

Wonderful conversation. I want to be Hindols Friend

[@dvikauglaumishrauca]

9:30 I liked how Vinamra started the podcast😅। Nice one

[@indirashetty5962]

Geart explanation.

[@arpan9937]

A real bengali scholar.

[@saradaramsatyavada4943]

Telugu people are from Andhra and Telangana not Tamil Nadu please ! I don’t know he mentioned just like that of these three states when he was talking about Damascus sword !

[@SlaHu.]

I respect Macaulay , atleast he was a clear enemy and he said it openly. I would argue , Indian Culture is ruined more by Indians themselves. G & N & gangs included.

[@keshavsharmasmpr]

You guys are brainwashed

[@adityaghildiyal6630]

You are right. Macaulay was a Britisher so can't really blame him for trying to subvert us. G & N on the other hand wanted to create a 'peaceful India' by subverting hindus, all for glorification of their image on the global stage. They are the most undemocratic and narcissistic leaders we have seen till date.

[@venkateshchaubey1267]

Could you share a book recommendation after every episode or through a newsletter with the summary.

[@SanataniJoe]

If you don’t experience it, it is all mental gymnastics. And you experience it once you can’t talk about it

[@varunkhugshal9049]

So it should not be talked about?

[@system7962]

​@@varunkhugshal9049no, not by this clearly biased guy

[@varunkhugshal9049]

@@system7962 so you'll decide who should talk about what?

[@system7962]

@@varunkhugshal9049 so is this a fu*kin interview??

[@varunkhugshal9049]

@@system7962 very enlightening answer

[@jeetroychowdhury5490]

❤

[@shreyamukherjee9792]

3 hrs of absolute pleasure

[@sonofanun2634]

The opening question should have been about Yeti and onanism ... Totally disappointed 😢😢😢. On my way to down a pint of beer and hit the gym to work on my biceps

[@ajaytomar111]

BESSSTTTTT ❤

[@AnjuSingh-ov2qr]

Please bring j Sai Deepak please 😢😢

[@sharmilakalain7549]

Very interesting conversation. Regd Gandhi,apart from his abominable tactics in India, he was also a rascist in South Africa. Regd dress aesthetics, I recently visited India and was utterly disgusted at the women's dressing. Looked like they walked out of the Victorian Era with all the frills and grotesque prints. Seriously ugly. Regd books, being avid readers we looked for book stores as we toured and they were very hard to come by. And no stores selling Bhagavad Gita in Dwaraka!!! Nonetheless will try and get a copy of this book. I love India and I love Sanatana Dharma.

[@devanshu6335]

If something good happens it is because of patel and something bad then nehru or gandhi...got it👍

[@aayushhh95]

Read books to know about Nehru's debacles and how Patel was almost always right in his arguments. Read Tripurdaman Singh's books

[@niranjanpattanaik7471]

The sarcasm is on you.

[@devanshu6335]

@@aayushhh95 I can't prove someone wrong who while reading a books thinks whatever he is reading to doesn't have ideology and from next time read diverse ideology if you are reading vikram sampath then read Ramchandra Guha too and if not then you will just become just another puppet of an ideology.

[@devanshu6335]

@@niranjanpattanaik7471 it wasn't sarcasm i believe whatever i said👍

[@tejasamrutkar2544]

​​@@aayushhh95 Do I really think if u read someone's book who has already an agenda/ narrative before writing book would come to any other conclusion rather than his narrative. We should read both types of books ,one which was written by right Wing historian and left wing too without ignoring anything them I'm sure u will come to right conclusion. Just reading what suits u makes u bhakt of someone be it right or left. These people nowadays discrediting gandhi and nehru have their fixed right wing biased so of course they won't tell u good sides and reason behind the things they did. Hope u get it.

[@mohans1832]

Shani's vahana is crow (Kavva) Garuda is Vishnu's

[@adityaghildiyal6630]

Gandhi was the father of muslim appeasement politics in India.

[@SDFNI3894YR]

Eye opening

[@Rahulkumar-tk5vv]

You should call prakhar shrivastav or Dr. Shankar saran if you want to talk about Gandhi. They were like encyclopaedia on Gandhi. And also one suggestion when we are talking about such topics, ask them to tell references or book names etc.

[@premdaheriya8455]

😂😂😂😂 प्रखर श्रीवास्तव जिसको गांधी के बारे में कुछ नही पता जिसने उसका हिन्द स्वराज तक नहीं पड़ा वो क्या जानता है गांधी के बारे में सिर्फ बकवास करने के शिवाय

[@vasua2348]

they are biggest RSS godi historian 🤣

[@Rahulkumar-tk5vv]

@@vasua2348 so if someone criticise Gandhi then they becomes rss agent?

[@Vyom4676]

Gandhi as an ideal and then the juatification sayingbfollow the words and not actions ia completely bullshit,given the guy was a politician results alone matter not talks,because it is easy to say anything but not the same withh actions,those who say something and do something else that is a classic case of"muh me raam baagal me churi" or better example kalnemi.

[@user-gn8gz1vn3b]

It is surprising to see that the host doesn't have the knowledge of Mopalah Riots & Khilafat movement. 😮

[@ankitchellani]

Nache nagin gali gali 1:24:12

[@harshwaichal7533]

Please bring Prshant Kishore on your podcast

[@rka-truthalwayswins5127]

He is a Anti Hindu & anti Bhartiye crook & should be shamed; NOT accliamed in society!!

[@vasua2348]

@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 RSS typed kattar tanatani hindu spotted🤣🤣

[@Bhavik630]

If we have the best of living conditions that human race has ever witnessed thanks to medical science and technology, how can we justify that we are living in Kalyug?

[@adityaghildiyal6630]

Every yuga gets technologically advanced before collapsing (like mahabharata collapse), just like present kaliyuga is witnessing rapid growth. However, Kaliyuga is defined by moral wickedness, paramountcy of greed and corruption over basic morality. And loss of dharma I.e. wrongful conduct being the new norm.

[@saishirdi2014]

Sardar Patel 🎉❤❤🎉🇮🇳

[@himanshugoel653]

Bro anuj dhar ka sath bhi podcast karo

[@prajwaldapke6557]

He is wise...

[@mayanarayan854]

What about how Nehru treated Netaji?

[@ridhiagarwal8524]

I m disliking foe the title...stop using these clickbaits 😊

[@livevidyarthi567]

Ye Podcast bhi thik hai par please next podcast with DIPANSHU GIRI SIR if possible 🫡😀🥲🥲🥲

[@pmishra786]

Bhai ye Bangaali kitna bolte h yaar 😂😂

[@shivaditya_myway]

Bhai bolne ke liye hi toh aya hai vo

[@aayushmansharrma7632]

Great podcast but everytime he said so on and so forth I wanted to do something bad lol jk

[@jinmuwon1108]

Lalu yadav k bare me aapko ghanta nhi pata hai,

[@rahulmodi8706]

Gandhi ideal is great if he was a leader from another country say Brazil, Mongolia or Morocco But you’d hate to have him as a father or leader

[@pinakpanibhattacharjee87]

Hindolda should also hv said what Bose(then a hardcore gandhi follower) had said after mooplah massacre? 😂😂😂 this would hv made everything ultaaa pultaa 😂😂😂.

[@shivangjoshi104]

Bhai hickey chupa raha hai

[@brightpigments6749]

Bro is still speaking in English

[@rutvikrs]

So?

[@TheBakuganmaster99]

Abey kitne indians ko hindi ya bengali aati hai? Ofc he's speaking in english to reach more indians.

[@rawadosa90210]

You're still writing in English 😢

[@rajivhumain]

I remember this guy He was bashed and destroyed by MR. Purshottam Aggarwal on tv 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@pinakibhattacharya3966]

ghoti

[@amrisha12]

Arre ye Banda full obsessed with Gandhi and Lehru

[@vasua2348]

Another RSS BJP paid stooges arrived who defame Nehru Gandhi legacy and trying to portray the incidents in some sort of Negative light. These Godi KZbinrs (KZbinrs sitting in lap of modi) will not invite historian from other side

[@sushmitajha2624]

I just wasted 30 mins of my time. It still feels one sided. Why don't you call Devadutt Patnayak for knowledge on Hinduism.

[@rutvikrs]

Devdutt Pattnaik. 😂 Sushmita, it would have been forgivable if we lived in 2008-11. His refusal to debate Nityananda Mishra on lexicological misinterpretations was shameful. He still blocks you on any platform if you utter Mishra's name. As a liberal, non religious and modernist, I was in support of Pattnaik but the whole fiasco showed he is a Donigerian mistake we have all moved past.

[@sushmitajha2624]

@@rutvikrs I don't follow him to comment on this. I used to watch a show on Epic channel(which I don't exist or not). But for now I really fail to understand this podcast and this person's timeline is not timelining. I vaguely understand his interpretations even though I know some facts but it seems he is presenting it all in a twisted form. Again even in my History classes I was bad with dates. I surely can be ignorant.As for religion, I am religious enough but not knowledgeable enough. I believe in Karma though.

[@TheBakuganmaster99]

Lol. Liberandus like you will never change. 😂😂

[@theniravpanchal]

Devdutt patnaik is a Anti-Hindu Bigot. He has shown his real face through Vulgar Comments on Hindu deities.

[@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi]

​@@sushmitajha2624I haven't read any of his work, but once my friend pulled me to his talk at the literary fest of our college. I am a rational person, but still, I respect the teachings of Gita and Buddha. My friend admired Mr Pattanaik a lot, but I haven't even heard of him before (maybe cause I am not into mythology and spirituality). So, Mr Pattanaik's talk went on for an hour, and it left me stumped. The guy was openly criticising Lord Buddha. According to him, Buddha conned people to acquire disciples and made everyone believe that he was an incarnation. I was dumbstruck, and so was my friend. I respect the teachings of Buddha, and for me, each of Buddha's quote is enlightening. Nevertheless, I wasn't much bothered by Mr Pattanaik's opinion as I know what I cared about was the teachings of Buddha not about his god status. After the talk, there was a question-answer session, and excellent questions were raised to Mr Pattanaik but what he did was just escape the questions. He never even answered a single question and manipulated the questioner to take back his question. So, in the end, what did I learn about him after the talk? I cannot answer that question as I am nobody to judge anyone, but what I can answer is what I learned from him. I learned the importance of oratory skills and manipulation. I learned how to escape the questions you can't answer and want to thank Mr Pattanaik for helping me realise the significance of such skills.

[@INSTAFLIXMEDIA]

Interestingly, it's 4:57 am now and I am lying down with my balaposh 😝😝😝

[@Parvathpura]

54:05

[@vasua2348]

Another RSS BJP paid stooges arrived who defame Nehru Gandhi legacy and trying to portray the incidents in some sort of Negative light. These Godi KZbinrs (KZbinrs sitting in lap of modi) will not invite historian from other side

[@tusharsharma__]

11:00💀

[@divyanshsh]

Ramana 🙏🏼 maharishi

[@prathammittal1786]

bro what happened to pro podcaster course

[@Raj_wardhan123]

Best articulated podcast ❤

[@vasua2348]

Another RSS BJP paid stooges arrived who defame Nehru Gandhi legacy and trying to portray the incidents in some sort of Negative light. These Godi KZbinrs (KZbinrs sitting in lap of modi) will not invite historian from other side