Historical Inaccuracies of Guts & Blackpowder

[@JMTRBX]

this comment section is historically inaccurate

[@jaredjosephsongheng372]

Obviously it's Historically Inaccurate

[@Subj-Ph0b]

the only thing that's historically accurate is bro's addiction to caffeine and votex simping over his natsu-jmt

[@wzjv]

why u post when i do my hair

[@Iloveidksomething]

Nuh uh

[@JMTRBX]

@@wzjvdo ur hair AND watch!

[@rtgjhty]

The biggest historical inaccuracy in this game is players having 0 teamwork and line infantry role playing as officer

[@Arandom_error]

Don’t forget about the fife players ignoring the people dying right in front of them, and the seamen shooting bombers right next to their teammates

[@SDC-666]

@@Arandom_error and all the sappers are either dead, or never existed

[@wapandaforever242]

​@@SDC-666 *dexists* Edit: NAH AUTO CORRECT MADE IT SEXISTS LOL😂

[@Loard2]

And the priests putting away their crucifix before it runs out

[@iane.2155]

they should make officer badge obtainable 🗣🗣

[@Fezezen]

The Historical Inaccuracies page is the only page I wrote in its entirety. 10:52 you're talking about Tricornes, but show pictures of bicornes, which are a different style of hat and were the fashion of that day.

[@Cosmicc228]

Does it feel like writing a school 20 paragraphs essay

[@Jesse_69420]

That’s something I didn’t know Fez

[@cheesenational]

do you like guts and blackpowder

[@toilet8635]

Real

[@MackieC007JR]

ty greg

[@Jmatthaeus184]

You forgot the biggest historical inaccuracy, there were no zombies in the napoleonic wars.

[@moodsquare]

🤯

[@spiritmoon5998]

🙄

[@Merejiah]

🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@coolaidenrb]

🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@mistermister737]

🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@WackyMoleTheClown]

Most of these inaccuracies can be summed up to their being a zombie apocalypse. A French soldier could have potentially found a nock gun or a brown Bess from a dead British soldier or maybe even a saber. The undaunted ship would have never passed by vardohus fortress unless there was a horde of blood thirsty cannibals terrorizing all of Great Britain. The shamblers might have been wearing the funny looking hat during the 18th century when they died and then re awakening during the blight in the 19th century as a shambler.

[@dumiahbro]

I was thinking the exact same thing! Good to see somebody else realized this

[@manteroid]

no not really, none of this works with “zombie apocalypse” because in every map we’re fresh units who’ve suddenly been thrusted into a map, fez hates this way of thinking. theres no way a soldier wouldve picked up these weapons canonically unless we’ve been in a map where soldiers had been scrounging around. builderman, a dev and lorewriter, said the hms undaunted, a british ship, being all the way in some random location in Denmark makes absolutely no sense and no one should rlly try to make sense of it, plus Britain is fine even during 1815, the hms undaunted has rlly no reason of being there imo shamblers are canonically people who’ve died after 1812 so it makes no sense that any of them would be wearing those hats lol

[@WackyMoleTheClown]

Good to know

[@emIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII]

British soldier in Leipzig.

[@Lucas-q2l5e]

1- Tricorns were still used in the 19 century. 2- wouldn't the zombies be only bones? Reviving 1 century after you died... your body would only be bones.

[@Axz652]

"I ATE A RAT ON THE FLOOR TODAY" can already tell this is the best character (real one)

[@khn4048]

G&B may not be historically accurate but just like cod waw it’s authentic enough where I don’t even question it or get mad about it.

[@NightspeakerR]

Fun historical inaccuracy: Most hats you see should be covered from the elements since they're likely going to get damaged, and if G&B added a hat accessory section to cover the hat from the elements then it would work well! (This also goes for the uniforms too by the way, all of your fancy uniforms require a lot of stuff so good luck making more.) REAL ONE 🗿

[@retro-bit3312]

i think the idea of every nation have a different variant of a gun sounds neat

[@The_VeryNubGoldenUnit]

Indeed, it kinda provides a little extra detail

[@biyurica]

I agree too but it will take lots of time modeling them

[@RuRoh_8214]

The quality of life update could be perfect for one of those different muskets for every nation drums, class uniforms bro the other nations like the French .

[@AzureRoseMarshal]

@@biyurica most guns were just copies of the french charleville, so they would just need to make a charlesville

[@ChiDang-zw7yf]

Pretty sure the infantry always have the bayonets on their musket due to the constant fear of being ambushed which made the bayonet a quick way to deal with an infected rather then pulling out your Sabre

[@ADcommenter]

The weapons being used by the wrong regiments and countries, i have a headcanon that bubbles is selling these weapons to the soldiers which is why some of them carry weapons that they're not supposed to be carrying.

[@tomminugames8093]

Really this video is a masterpiece, the fact that the wiki pays so much attention to Every detail shows just how much work was put into it, it’s just amazing how these people managed to go into All the tiny little inaccuracies in the game and explain them. This is one of the reasons why I Love this game so much, all the devs, admins and youtubers are amazing. One more thing, JMT you are an excellent youtuber. Your intros are amazing I’ve, Never seen anything like them and your videos are excellent and never fail to entertain me and Even if i’m sad your vids always put a smile on my face and I also try to watch parts of your streams. Thank you JMT, for everything.

[@JMTRBX]

I appreciate you much, im glad I can make you happy. Hopefully you’re doing well within this inflated world ❤️

[@tomminugames8093]

@@JMTRBX The comment also says real one if you look at the capital letters at the start of each line, again Thanks!

[@starfleetguy69]

@@JMTRBX white powder

[@終末大隊の漢斯]

From reenactor of french sapper,he told that a sapper equip cabine,for self-defence,of course with axe,but real world sapper's axe also have hook make it more destructive.sapper also equipped with sword with saw tooth

[@RandomAussie-dx9fj]

Not carbine, musket

[@racist_dustdust]

30 seconds in and already being called a fucking stupid. Great video 10/10

[@joyelluke9880]

Nah Less than 30 seconds

[@weezeezy3293]

They updated the irish regiment's uniforms recently to make it historically accurate

[@Cheeze_cak]

Although i do have a small reason why i get bothered about inaccurate uniforms is because if your making an oc there's a big chance the uniform may be 90% inaccurate although some of the uniforms are accurate to they're irl form there are some that don't have the accuracies or details the uniform has which would be make it difficult for me to see which is accurate and which is not, and even if you try to do research on the regiment and uniform there are going to be uniforms that are really documented much which would make things harder Also JMT IS THE REAL ONE 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@hjsweet3866]

I'd make the guess that most nations would ally together against the Zombies, this is confirmed slightly in maps like San Sebastian with you being able to play as the British, Portuguese or French.

[@ducksongfans]

the french let out the british and portugese prisoners to fight the zombies, there was peace after leipzig

[@German_Officer2]

Lord JMT is truly a real one, best video to ever exist: -funni -detail -good video -being called stupid -serial kiler -white powder

[@lostliam4901]

The biggest inaccuracy is people in the 1800s weren't blocky lego men

[@ruffianraffy]

10:21 Explaination: During the Napoleonic Wars, Prussian army Sappers, or "Pioneers" were picked from Regular Infantry companies and were separated into their own companies. However in G&B, it implies Prussian sappers were in the same companies as Regular Infantry, similar to the French sappers.

[@risingdue]

3:24 guts and white powder

[@OOM-Series]

hey, this game is during a zombie apocalypse and the shop just sells pre-made guns and weapons to whoever is interested so who really needs historical accuracy during an outbreak anybody can have anything at that point

[@Joleleme]

Got ham, Manbat?

[@JMTRBX]

WHAT DOES THIS MEAN

[@plushluigi7417]

Is bro from the alsume?!

[@fallingcrane1986]

Why would he post this in a G&B comment section? Is he stupid?

[@just_a_random_sturmtruppen]

7:34 "Every single class can use the sabre besides the Chaplain" Sapper: also *REAL ONE*

[@JMTRBX]

Sapper can secretly use the sabre but I wont tell you how 🤫

[@just_a_random_sturmtruppen]

@@JMTRBX HOW I WILL GIVE YOU 10K FRANCS IF YOU TEACH ME HOW TO USE SABRE ON SAPPER

[@kazueballesteros3665]

​@@just_a_random_sturmtruppen /give sabre

[@just_a_random_sturmtruppen]

@@kazueballesteros3665 oh my god you're a genuis

[@wapandaforever242]

Why would you want the saber on sapper?

[@Biker-gp1rp]

0:36 relatable

[@ABiblicallyAccuratePigeon]

4:11 if they were to add these to the game I would be very happy to have even more distinction between nations

[@oashky]

Another historical inaccuracy about Guts & Blackpowder is that people didn’t look like blocks

[@BethFernandez]

You could say that they were running low on weapons so they had to improvise by stealing from farmers citizens and more.

[@achkenaziball5093]

10:57 You realize zombies came from the ground, right? They could have, say, been buried pre-19th century. THE HISTORICAL INACCURACY PAGE HAS BEEN FLAWED

[@revanbang]

1:25 tater tots are cruny munchy

[@allenrosales9738]

Infantry did use Carbines. French Skirmishers called Voltigeurs were often armed with Carbines.

[@GermanSanitater]

That's only for the french

[@eza3850]

G&B is historically inaccurate because in the Napoleonic Wars there are not a zombies

[@lambda-m1676]

the bayonets being always fixed can be justified considering they have probably learned that the zombies don't need to reload

[@biyurica]

Well even though there's some inaccuracies in the game, the napoleonic wars vibe is still there

[@Tomas-qk5fy]

Pike and Lancers: The Lancers were used to stop horse charges, NOT Pike, Pikes are shorter and somewhat easier to wield Lances or Lancers are longer, and was able to stop calvary charges Formations are key for Lancers, such as the infamous Square formation which stopped calvary from tightening their encirclement upon the battalion Now the term Lance has changed significantly especially for Lance Corporal which rooted back to the days most armies (hired militias were present but in small amounts) restructured their ranks, UK and the Chosen Men (comprised of Green Uniforms) which evolved into specific branches U.S. Marines Lance Corporals, and The UK Army, and Marines Lance Corporals The term Lance Corporal has evolved over the centuries, from Pike and Shot to the modern day

[@theaceygeneral]

In game context, some of this historical inaccuracies may be due to the situations the soldiers are put in, causing them to use other weaponry employed by different regiments or old weaponry or other nations weaponry.

[@aidanrobert-bt1df]

Well the reason why the line infantry keep the bayonet on the musket is easily explained to the fact that the zombie would swarm you easily because of its number so keeping the bayonet on the musket gives them quick access to melee weapons and the reason sappers use axe instead of musket or carbine is probably because of lack of guns and because they can use axe to destroy any woods furnitures or chop trees to make a barrier or obstacle to holding the zombies

[@komrade_gagarin]

G&B is not historically inaccurate. History is inaccurate.

[@Subj-Ph0b]

white powder exists. fight me white powder that i was refering to is powdered sugar

[@Piercing_Mitez]

baby powder

[@odeixx]

cocaina

[@ThatGBplayer]

S A L T

[@vibraniumpotato6493]

flour cornstarch baking soda

[@commandereirik4452]

0:22 DORA THE F#$KING EXPLORER

[@FranciscoRosas-v7z]

1:38 the man who started the blight:

[@MelGibssbul]

Sabres would’ve been used usually by officers and rankers might have Sabre briquettes

[@thej8656]

4:26 DAWG WERE IN A FUCKING ZOMBIE APOCALYPSE

[@Wilhelm717]

“Real one” ah yes, my daily grind of watching JMT videos for five hours straight, one video down, who knows how many to go for today 😅

[@bilIs4772]

shhhhhh, don’t tell them about our inaccuracy 🤫

[@ProReel135]

the real inaccuracy is the friends we met along the way

[@Adinosaurandtrainlover]

Billy: tater tots are crunchy munchy! Me(someone who loves tater tots and is part Irish): amen to that 1 brother

[@Wertguzzz]

Ngl would be a fire idea to make each weapon's model change depending on what nation you play as

[@jaredjosephsongheng372]

1:47 Me: Wait there's literally people thinking this game is Historically Accurate Napoleonic Wars but with Zombies? Bruh

[@JMTRBX]

That is the main argument choice

[@manteroid]

@@JMTRBXlamest argument too, just cause theres zombies doesnt mean they can retain that charm of historical accuracy tbh,,,,

[@fghjkas5098]

The benefits of smokeless powder is that it creates less smoke (duh) and that the muzzle velocity is way higher than blackpowder.

[@Umpdiddly]

Tutorial on how to find calvary class or lancer sub class Step 1: be on the french nation Step 2: click on the calvary button Step 3: Choose the line enfantry (And have the pike) Congratulations gnb players you have found the sub class for the pike but there is also an officer and musician class on the french calvary have fun.

[@Overload-9G]

i am a happy consumer of white powder, aka peruvian Booger Sugar

[@SigmaRizzMonkey]

JMT, tomorrow is my birthday and I wish for a full-time supply of your videos.

[@Baldiegeekay]

I don't know you, but Happy Birthday tho!

[@終末大隊の漢斯]

If you want to play more historical accurate Napoleonic war games you shall try HOLDFAST NATIONS AT WAR

[@gavinstricklin9512]

This comment is historically, back during napoleonic times, they would say “thy mother” as an insult

[@imppaxd2790]

Another inaccuracy is that the björneborg regiment exists for sweden because it disbanded in 1809 after sweden lost finland

[@herbal-arsonist]

to be fair, it was during the blight so theres a possibility everyone grabbed whatever they had/could find

[@grayrobber]

Fun fact: sapper axes were meant for bashing gates in. No wonder the zappers deal so much damage

[@jackdaniel559]

White powder

[@Eddyshow102]

TATAR TOTS ARE CRUNCHY MUNCHY🗣🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯 1:26

[@Cosmicc228]

9:42 They're not adding a leveling system anytime soon lol

[@JMTRBX]

W IDEA THO?

[@isj_90]

Nope

[@grilchesesandwich]

​@@JMTRBXMods suggestion ban him!

[@Cosmicc228]

@@JMTRBX I get fed up with it, so it a uhhh I dunno? W..? Or L.... But it's both

[@German_Officer2]

@@Cosmicc228 it's lord JMT of course it's a W

[@henrythomasgaming]

this is so historically inaccurate, i can't figure out what is historically accurate or history inaccurate anymore. but thanks to mister JMT to helping me to figure it out! thanks mister JMT (please release me from your antic)

[@DaMartian]

Sapper's With A Gun Would Most Certainly Be Powerful. I Can See Why They Would've Changed It.

[@Red_Fascist2003]

3:27 White Powder but remove the d and watch your career disappear once you say it.

[@MelGibssbul]

Cramming would be the slow part because you have to hit it in then push real hard sometimes

[@extramangos2578]

Real One

[@Confusion_again]

God: sorry we don’t got any more room in hell so uh… you go back into your body as a zombie

[@Lucas-q2l5e]

Ah i love how he seatches even the smaller bacterias on the ground just to find the historical inaccuracies.

[@終末大隊の漢斯]

Btw,Nco could equip with pike,some of the red coats and Baguettes Nco equip with pike for close combats

[@Isaacthegamer123]

I like your idea for the shop

[@Thewaxbandit-ey8ly]

JMT should do the thug shake

[@XDSPACEMAN500]

The intro was smooth

[@centralhunter9169]

Real one. I am surprised G&B is this historically inaccurate.

[@virajkishore6960]

JMT the nock volley gun broke so many navy soldiers shoulders

[@Vi2001rn]

Sniff & Whitepowder

[@ritabalciuniene2678]

Lil' fella, all objective maps take place in different times

[@afreennaim8123]

real one dude where my caffeine at btw

[@Melee_barrel_now]

Three days for now 7 more days to play again on guts&blackpowder

[@swaggerboi69]

i mean if youre desperately trying to survive a zombie apocalypse youre gonna use every weapon you can use right? so i guess it makes sense that it would have some innacurancies (talking about the weapons only) but its just a game anyway

[@GutsandBlackpowderSweat]

You haven’t watched the full video have you?

[@charliemeharry4346]

Man shut u-

[@odiolalluviagd]

great video lord jmt keep cooking 🔥

[@Calebee204]

JMT, you should try doing a stream where it doesnt stop untill a fan gets OG

[@Calebee204]

Like me lol

[@Shmuxer]

my father staying home is historically inaccurate.

[@JMTRBX]

W comment

[@iankuhn-fm6qk]

I think for the weapons they would be using whatever they could get there hands on.

[@Silly3223]

I know it's unnecessary but I would like each nation in the game to have its own version of the weapons in the game

[@JMTRBX]

Or if we could purchase them in the shop to add more customization

[@AlejandroMPGx2]

​@@JMTRBX🙄

[@Bestien00]

2:21 that gun Is not historically accurate, in the 1800s they used officer pistols🤓

[@Ancientveda]

Sabres were either used by officers, cavalry,etc

[@終末大隊の漢斯]

For me, history inaccurate will be why the musket with high penetrate btw this inaccurate will be useful for us for survive

[@rosered669]

"every single class can use the sabre" *"Sapper Has Left The Chat"*

[@Juliorivera107]

People are making a poll so the dev can make Barry insult us on April fools day lets spread it🤞🏻

[@BanHammerFromPhighting]

im still confused why guts and gunpowder wasnt the name it sounds better anyway

[@seby2975]

I noticed that on the priest uniform there is the satanist sign

[@manteroid]

what satanist sign? an upside down cross? thats st. peter’s cross but ok

[@seby2975]

@@manteroid nono, if u see when its zoomed into the priest's face u can see on his nedcklace a cross but with 2 extra lines

[@manteroid]

@@seby2975 its a russian orthodox cross if im not wrong

[@seby2975]

@@manteroid oh then i got confused

[@hamegged.]

Real one. My daily internet intake is fulfilled. Goodbye.

[@noubkid_yt174]

My dumb brain thought the icon meant "Guts & BlackOut", like seriouslu tho

[@commanderultima6876]

Horrors of historical inaccuracies Funny to think the gane could've been called G&G (guts and gunpowder)

[@WyattFordyce-my8mj]

Bro the zombies with fake J's part was personal

[@ezzanfirash1255]

New sub

[@終末大隊の漢斯]

If you are a line infantry,you not able to use sabre because only grenadier can carry

[@KingdomofBavaria.official]

"tater tots are crunchy munchy" Billy, 1815

[@laetitialoveno1080]

5:15 not coool fact about the nock gun is that the powerful recoil was so powerful that it could breake or hurt the shoulder of the user so yeah they were risking their shoulder against their enemies

[@ryleeculla5570]

The old guard used them but only as an accesorie

[@NeoFunUniverse]

Yep there are uncountable historical inaccuracies