History of China(Sinitic Peoples)-Every Year

[@dani.kn20]

Bruh honestly this guy is underrated as a mapper

[@Adams_140]

Ikr, so detailed and quality HD 1080 supported videos

[@ginater9202]

Yeah it’s good but he may need to start targeting a western audiance

[@fishcereal9940]

@@ginater9202 Aren't they already doing that by being bilingual between Turkish (I assume it's Turkish, if not Azeri) and English?

[@CheesiusCaesar69]

ikr

[@ffllllooooorrriiiaannnn848]

Troll

[@yanxishan6575]

Great work! This is probably the best non-Chinese mapping video about the history of China there is.

[@aii_penguin]

雨琛涂 I’m Chinese he honestly did pretty good, if he was really nationalist and biased he wouldn’t even have counted Qing. Or maybe if he was ultranationalist he wouldn’t have even shown Tang.

[@陈陳-t5c]

@@aii_penguin 唐是皇族母亲为异族，但是中国是以父系为血统继承统治观的，你说唐有异族血统就不属于中国是不符合中国传统观念的，否则在世家门阀控制的那个时代他们也不会信服这个关陇贵族。 元的统治阶级血统没有华夏族，清也一样没有，他们只是除华夏族外的统治中国区域的国家。他们统治中国在文人眼里是天命，是承接上天的指令。但以大汉族主义和西方史观不是一个单一民族或者主体民族统治的国家不属于传承有序的。但是官方是承认的，明朝皇族和士族承认，民国统治阶级和精英层也承认皇族承接明，以及接下来的退位接续，手续是完备的。 以这个地图为例，我不是很理解放清朝而不放元朝，清朝任用汉官，也有汉军旗。元也有汉官，只不过政策上没有形成制度，可能是以这个非政策性，隐含歧视性的非汉人的统治时期不属于中国吧。 但是朱元璋是承认的，毕竟这是传统观念符合中国人传统观念，又是政治性的以及法制完备的接续国家法统，后人是需要承认的，而不需要跟随西方的史观。明朝对待蒙古前朝贵族也是善待的，可以居养在国境内，这是属于皇朝制度的一部分，所以也是承认上朝，传承制度的一部分。西方制图是可以拿自己的理解，但是中国人自己理解史观，是需要有自己的观点的。不能因异族统治就有屈辱感，或者是外人看来是不要脸的安祖宗，这实际都是不准确的。异族统治属于前朝统治阶级的错误，然后又有新一轮主体民族的崛起和承认前朝的承序地位，因为清和元时程序正义，这在政治上是完备的，这是正常的。

[@russiaball2.027]

@Tu Iochi did you read the description?

[@russiaball2.027]

@Tu Iochi 4 things 1- Liao, Jin (?), N Wei, Qara Khitai, and Yuan were only sinicized in language and/or culture 2- even the chinese are agreeing with the video 3- I know what is turanism 4- Are you assuming that I'm russian only because a countryball?

[@lucacastellaro1615]

Why there's no yuan dinasty?

[@mrodwenderstarsmos9046]

Sunucu : Hanedan isminiz ne olsun? Çin : Harf alayım.

[@KyzaghanPecheneg]

.d

[@thehollandian]

@@KyzaghanPecheneg aaaaa pecheneq

[@NRooster]

XD

[@sparkharitalama383]

4 tl lik m harfi geldi ming diyorum doğru cevap şimdi çine benziyo ama değil uç kelimesinin zıttı tersi chu (çu) diyorum harika

[@mrodwenderstarsmos9046]

@@sparkharitalama383 : D

[@xdlol3236]

6:40 song but no song

[@necatihakangokdemir1660]

U R genious

[@necatihakangokdemir1660]

SuPeR sMaRt

[@MichaelWite19]

Lol I get it

[@จักรพรรดิฮั่นหวู่ตี้]

3:59 what is music for Chinese

[@Anwwoo]

05:10 I saw 606 to 608 and again, 608 to 610 were just skipped. plus, Emperor Yangdi of Sui, conquered Tuyuhun lands and divided it into four commanderies in 609. But, despite these, this video was very clean. great work!

[@KayraAtakanQX]

I cant saw this in my sources sorry but it isnt my mistake .d

[@Anwwoo]

It’s okay, keep on it 👍

[@musallat508]

@@KayraAtakanQX sa

[@arthurwellesley6169]

9:23 Çin: Bana bişeyler oluyo knk

[@nenenindonu]

7:20 Mongol Empire joined the chat

[@kebabwastaken16]

He joined at 7:10

[@masumkisi9454]

7:25

[@jacobl5488]

Yeah and guess what? He became more Chinese.

[@anotherhumanbeing3923]

@@jacobl5488 nope,he wasnt even chinese before (u said more)

[@上官康]

10:04 The last part is a bit problematic. The Han nationality is a national concept, while the other color blocks in the map (such as Wu, Minnan, etc.) are geographical concepts or language systems. These two things cannot be shown as the same thing. I live in the "Wu" area, where the local people are basically the Han nationality. The only ethnic minorities are even the third or fourth-generation ethnic blood relatives who claim to be ethnic minorities in order to enjoy government preferential policies. However, another point worth mentioning is that the Han nationality itself has also experienced many national integrations, so the so-called Han nationality itself is a mixed ethnic group. In terms of lineage alone, it is even possible to find some people who are Han nationality but the lineage are more like a minority than some people who claim to be minority.

[@zhu_zi4533]

√

[@Void_Dweller7]

Thank you for pointing this out.

[@橘居居]

This Tang dynasty map is so accurate. Best Tang map so far.

[@KayraAtakanQX]

I used wikipedia and chinese videos :)

[@zes3813]

wrr

[@Nigar5678]

Corona

[@yxb9182]

@VUSAL FF Is this your father’s name？

[@yxb9182]

@Kayra Atakan [Qırım Xan'ı]bro,you forgot yuan dy ,It is also a Chinese dy.

[@mustafaorhanakdemir1010]

Sonuna kadar bekle bir gün emeğinin karsiligini alacagina inaniyorum

[@Hinvestory]

Herzamanki gibi muhteşem olmuş

[@紫衣大食]

This is one of the most accurate history of China maps on youtube, well done!

[@papazataklaattiranimam]

Best mapping channel on youtube

[@Warsawke]

Great video !

[@historyrhymes1701]

6:10 Lets split up gang

[@Danail_Ivanov]

@Elleniki Kappadokia Lets split Turkey and Kurdistan :)

[@anotherhumanbeing3923]

@@Danail_Ivanov Kurdistan doesnt exist tho

[@ahmettheturk889]

@@Danail_Ivanov kurdistan doesn't exist

[@NRooster]

@Elleniki Kappadokia hey hi :)

[@cyanmist5752]

Why is the Manchu Qing Sinitic while the Shatuo five dynasties are non-Sinitic? The Shatuo people had used Han names for several generations when they established dynasties, but the Manchu kept their names until Qing ended!

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Please read the description and check my sources .

[@cyanmist5752]

@@KayraAtakanQX OK, but Former Qin is established by Di people

[@bozhao6640]

我想您可能关注的更多是中华王朝的正统性，比方说在南北朝的时候你只画了南朝而没有北朝。但我想问为什么您认为五代十国里的十个南方小国家能代表这种正统而不是在北部的五个大朝代？总不能因为南方有个自称唐朝的小国家就把正统性给这个小国家吧，并且这个小国家的地图还不太对

[@hahapi9849]

这个视频明显的私货，他明显的是用近代出现的民族划分来确立所谓的正统性，从而否诸如鲜卑，等东胡系在历史上的地位，无非就是想说元清非中国，殊不知尴尬的是东汉灭亡之后大量的周边民族进入中原并迅速汉化，按他的这个分法，东晋之后这些朝代都很尴尬。

[@dffgfgdff3736]

土耳其式历史可是认为鲜卑人是突厥人，当然不算中国历史

[@bozhao6640]

@@tck1347 汉民族占多数和划分少数民族没有多大关系。即使汉民族不占绝对多数以中国初期的民族政策也会仿照苏联划分少数民族。民族划分更多是仿照苏联的政策。如果是为了证明汉人继承了中国，等于否定了自己政权的合法性。既不能解释对西部的合法性，也不能解释关于满清-中华民国-新中国的继承关系。我猜您回复我无非是想说想视频里以汉族为正统性所做的图是正确的，但是这本身就是一团浆糊。比方说鲜卑人和沙陀人，要么被杀光了要么被汉族回族满族融合了。那北魏和后唐算是正统吗？在深入点商朝算正统吗？代商的周朝算正统吗？在西边的秦国算正统吗？楚国算正统吗？沛县发家的刘邦算正统吗？关陇集团算正统吗？没有纯粹的民族，别把一段有意思的文明狭隘化了。

[@johnwilson3350]

作者说他只画汉族王朝，后唐后晋后汉是沙佗人建立的。但奇怪的是他画了氐族的前秦却没画汉族的后周。

[@จักรพรรดิฮั่นหวู่ตี้]

我想龙之国不只是由普通话组成的，还有很多民族，但是秦始皇能够统一这片土地。 汉朝 汉后藤皇帝建立了汉朝。 唐朝将势力扩张到朝鲜，旧朝鲜王朝也与元朝阿拉伯人交战，入侵并消灭了蒲甘帝国。 我觉得清朝的每一位皇帝都是杰出的。

[@nucainchicksaw4411]

Her zamanki gibi ellerine sağlık!

[@WR102ka]

5:18 goguryeo downfalled 668 not 648

[@CannedFruit999]

9:20 I love when the Chinese anthem appears. It comes at just the right time

[@mimisong2302]

1271-1368: The Yuan Dynasty in China was one of the five khanates of the Mongol Empire, founded by Genghis Khan. It ruled most of the modern-day China from 1271 to 1368. Genghis Khan's grandson, Kublai Khan, was the founder and first emperor of the Yuan Dynasty.

[@KayraAtakanQX]

This video about sinitic peoples . Yuan want sinitic . It was a mongolian Dynasty.

[@manchuqing4560]

@@KayraAtakanQX And the Qing Dynasty was founded by the Manchus, not the Chinese.

[@satyasankalpapanigrahi9416]

@@manchuqing4560 yes, Manchus from Manchuria not those ethnic han chinese

[@Henrycus5321]

@@manchuqing4560shouldn’t add Qing dynasty inside the video

[@chentianhai]

​@@Henrycus5321but manchus dont have their own nation oriented country， that is the difference from Mongols

[@bilgekagan2981]

İntron bile efsane. Video da öyle. Ama bi sorum var mançu hanedanı imparatoru Qianlong 1799 tarihine kadar yaşamasına rağmen neden tahtını daha önce oğlu jiaqinge devredip oğlu tahttayken bile devleti yönetti.Bunu tahtta iken de yapabilirdi.Bunu neden yaptı ?

[@amazingpeterzhu]

On the surface, he respected his grandfather and did not want to rule for longer than his grandfather (61 years); In fact, he is still the ruler of the empire, and his son is just a puppet.

[@bilgekagan2981]

@@amazingpeterzhu thanks for information.

[@chewswisely7365]

Amazingly accurate! Not all non-Chinese mappers map the Dynasties based on Chinese Records...

[@ginater9202]

This is a great channel, HOWEVER I feel like your not targeting to a western audience so a way to do that is to probably yes you can keep using Turkish but I think English could become the main language of the channel that would probably get more Americans or Europeans to watch it

[@L1M.L4M]

I'm sure there doesn't need to be any other language to be able to look at a few colorful blobs.

[@magistermilitum1206]

Pls don't stop putting Turkish into it, continue this way

[@magistermilitum1206]

It would only get better if you put Latinnn.

[@parallel1890]

​@Northern mapping Your American history is only over 200 years old, while your Chinese history is 5,000 years old. Your US territory is surrounded by seas on the left and right, and has experienced fewer changes than China.

[@parallel1890]

​@Northern mapping Do you Americans know how many powerful opponents of different nationalities and countries China has faced in various dynasties in history? Such as modern Tsarist Russia and the British Empire.

[@onurtopkaya5662]

güzel video keşke ortadoğu tarihide gelse kalp

[@recepemrekaya8004]

Orta Doğu Tarihi yaptı kardeşim

[@recepemrekaya8004]

Daha doğrusu Avrupa ve Orta Doğu Tarihi birden 2 yıl önceki videosuna bakabilirsin

[@onurtopkaya5662]

Recep Emre Kaya işte ama daha detaylı ve iç savaşlı

[@Patlichan]

Fastest uploader in the west

[@dantesun9157]

Thank you.Your‘s china map is pretty interesting and accurate

[@SonofIndia1999]

So tibet was mostly independent kingdom throughout history only Qing dynasty conquer them

[@Adolph_shampoo]

And Yuan.

[@SonofIndia1999]

@@Adolph_shampoo THEY ARE MONGOL NOT CHINESE

[@Adolph_shampoo]

@@SonofIndia1999 ok but the birthplace of the Golden Family is Inner Mongolia, China. Today's Mongolia was a place where prisoners were exiled in ancient times.

[@SonofIndia1999]

@@Adolph_shampoo outside of great china wall is Mongolia and their kings dynasty all are Mongol not Chinese even if they slaughter Chinese and rule over them and shift their capital and most important their dna is mongol not han chinese

[@SonofIndia1999]

@@Adolph_shampoo and quing dynasty from Manchuria it's also non Chinese out side of great wall of china

[@zhu_zi4533]

10:00 I think the southern part of China is different cultural regions, not different nationalities. Due to the different geographical environment and historical background, the culture of these places is not as unified as the plain of North China, but there is no doubt that most of these are Chinese culture. And Chinese identity is more based on cultural identity than ethnic identity

[@FoggyOp]

he does show different subgroups of cultures like the Hakka, Min,....

[@arthurwellesley6169]

Sonunda neden singapurlu arkadaşımın çince konuştuğunu anladım.

[@先生-m8e]

Malaysia also said

[@RATSKETCHES]

Zheng he colonised Singapore according to galvin Menzies

[@manchuqing4560]

@@RATSKETCHES Most of the Chinese in Singapore are descendants of immigrants in the 18th and 19th centuries when British colonial Singapore.

[@feminism8583]

@@RATSKETCHES The Chinese migrated to Singapore under British colonization in the 19th century, just like Africans migrated to the Americas under European colonized.

[@chentianhai]

​@@RATSKETCHESZhang he has no balls, lol

[@svenkorlos5146]

Osman: so broke apart. China : same but I grown bigger.

[@islamimparatorlugu8401]

Çooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooook güzel olmuş ellerine sağlık

[@gokturkmapperbmo5800]

Çok güzel olmuş

[@someguysomeone3543]

Great content I must say you have yourself a new subscriber. Also next I would recommend to make a video on the Germans.

[@XuerLi]

The portrait of Liu Bang is incorrect, this one was drawn by some Qing dynasty freelance illustrator

[@KayraAtakanQX]

It is not my fault. I used the portraits from wikipedia. Also represent photos arent incorrect theys are just represent ;).

[@turkiyemuzik7509]

Eline sağlık reis 👍👍👍

[@thelettermradio5251]

5:21 Tang is so powerful in 660

[@zes3813]

wrr,nosuchthingas powerx or not, bigx doesn matter

[@link-nb9kg]

It was not that the Tang Dynasty owned these lands, but that these countries surrendered to the Tang, and respected the Emperor of Tang as the khan of heaven.并不是唐朝拥有这些土地，而是这些国家臣服于了唐，尊称唐皇帝为天可汗。

[@thelettermradio5251]

@@link-nb9kg I know, but also, four of the puppets were 'protectorate generals to pacify the [insert cardinal direction]'. The Anbei was to pacify the North, the Anxi was to pacify the West, the Andong was to pacify the East, and Anang (which should be vietnam) was to pacify the south.

[@xuanzongoftang7856]

Hi your channel is nice but underated

[@bengu8262]

Videoların çok güzel dil tarihi videoları yapabilirsin admin ^^ 💕

[@Emmet-sd8og]

What is the music used?

[@simich1601]

Which era? Check the description

[@gunaycakmak9669]

Tatarlardan böyle tarihi şeyleri sevenlerin çıkması ne hoş ne kadar Tatar tanıdıysam kimisi ressam, Çinici, Seramikçi, Halk Araştırmacısı

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Ben tatar değilim :)

[@erzurumludadas2470]

@@KayraAtakanQXpeki nerelisin Azerbaycan'lı mı merak ettim 😅

[@Aizen.Sousuke230]

@@erzurumludadas2470 Türkiyeli .

[@POGKPP]

Why its not titled just "History of China" and after this alternative title in Chinese.

[@POGKPP]

You could get much more views, so why Turkish in title.

[@POGKPP]

And also, its very well made, so "The History of China" is much better tittle to get more views for this work.

[@KayraAtakanQX]

​@@POGKPP some dynasties in china isnt chinese so i used sinitic peoples as title. and i making about races but china is an area , not race. and ı used Turkish because im a turkish channel and my some subscribers dont understand engliesh.

[@POGKPP]

@@KayraAtakanQX I think that The History of China would be a way better title to get more views for this amizing video.

[@POGKPP]

@@KayraAtakanQX Maybe add Chinese title in description to get some Chinese viewers.

[@spiritofthesteppe3701]

Ur so underrated as a mapper

[@Void_Dweller7]

You have the best music in most of your vids

[@無產階級-p2u]

Great Tang 5:19 Great Qing 8:57

[@pratzkaa]

Çok iyi olmuş 👌

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Sonunda teşrif edebilmişsiniz beyefendi ...

[@alguemai6636]

7:36 fact: in the rebelion, that is the first time that the gunpowder are used in weapon, the first firearms are used in bamboo's in this revolt.

[@Soldier.19]

Red turban?

[@rt9637]

Why did you show Qing as China? It was Manchu not Chinese dynasty.

[@blackphoenix3220]

@lizebek kugho ethnically they were not Chinese.

[@laikuanlee5297]

Ethinically they are not Chinese but they refer themselves as Chinese and both China claim that they are successors

[@amitpacidal9605]

8:33 Qing Dynasty was not established by Sinitic Peoples! They are Manchu people!!

[@fay-z5414]

满洲人就是中国人，他们都说中国话，穿中国传统服饰，不信自己去搜清代皇帝的历史录像，他们都说的普通话。而且我周围有满族人，他们从来没有认为自己不是中国人，别乱说行吗。

[@nabateans]

@@fay-z5414 The Manchurians are among the Chinese peoples, even if they are different from the Han. China is a giant country that contains many races, not only the Han.

[@feminism8583]

@@fay-z5414 Only Puyi has a video, and Qing died when he was 3 years old!The Manchu emperor said Manchu, they left a lot of Manchu articles!

[@gokturkmapperbmo5800]

Kayra atakan sıradaki vidyon nedir

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Izledin mi sıradaki videomu .d

[@gokturkmapperbmo5800]

@@KayraAtakanQX evet

[@hunimparatorlugu3570]

@@KayraAtakanQX peki Rus tarihini yapıcakmısınız (bu benim ikinci hesabım yani göktürk mapperim)

[@hunimparatorlugu3570]

@@KayraAtakanQX sadece Rus değil alman ingiliz moğol

[@musabiletarih2347]

Cok Güzel yapmışsın

[@musabiletarih2347]

Eline salık

[@recepemrekaya8004]

Musab beeee :D

[@G-Man-Toilet2023]

Hi Why Why Have You Never Posted Videos On Your Channel Again?

[@FreddyGaming3110]

I'm amazed... I bet this took ages to create. I barely even started lol. Keep up the good work!

[@KyzaghanPecheneg]

Çok güzel olmuş.

[@kiayungko7731]

Love this from China🇨🇳🌸🌷❤️

[@sjpark8860]

You forgot 🇹🇼 this

[@kiayungko7731]

SJ Park from China~🇨🇳🇹🇼🌷🌷

[@alperenbulbul3358]

🌹❤️🇹🇷🇨🇳❤️🌹

[@sjpark8860]

@@kiayungko7731 Republic of China 🇹🇼

[@TrevorBurton-y7g]

Love the map! I am an American that loves reading history books. Chinese history was such an interesting read, and I can understand why Chinese culture is akin to Rome for this part of the world. Only it’s a Asia’s Romana that always somehow recovered. And it gave so much to places like Japan, Vietnam, or South Korea like Rome did to Europe. I know I’m oversimplifying a radically different culture but many similarities exist too amongst all nations. Such an incredible history, culture, and people. Hopefully both our governments can stop behaving like middle schoolers and do what’s right for our citizens. Behind the politics, there is so much more to a people.

[@amazingpeterzhu]

You're right, but unfortunately, South Korea not only refuses to acknowledge it, but has been trying to steal Chinese culture.

[@JayadevJena-d7n]

If you get some time read Indian history too😊

[@咩咩喵]

Since the Greeks who become Türkiye's culture are counted as part of Turkic history, why can't the Turks who become Chinese culture be counted as Chinese history.

[@MongolEmpire77]

Because the Turks are the kings of assimilation

[@diyar-kn8wq]

Muhteşem video

[@maxdc988]

As a Malaysian Chinese with ancestors migrated from South China, I would like to add some accuracy to your narration. The term Chinese refers accurately to people originated from the land now called China. Many different ethnic groups lived in the land called China. We, Cantonese numbering 80 million people, like Zhuang people in neighbouring Guangxi province numbering 20 million, are quite different from the people from Northern China. Hence, you can consider Manchu people numbering 18 million or Mongol numbering 8 million, as Chinese. You can't grouped Manchu people or Mongol people apart from the Chinese because they are more similar to Northern Chinese than Southern Chinese, in terms of physical and facial features. So, Manchu/Mongol people will look more like Beijing people than Southern Chinese like me, Cantonese. Within Han Chinese there are actually various dialect groups and depending on location, has different physical and facial features. But your facts in general about the history of China except your omission of the Mongol rule which spanned almost a century, are in-depth, more knowledgeable than many Chinese. And your background music is wonderful.

[@Void_Dweller7]

Thank you, for giving your insight.

[@Henrycus5321]

@andrewyuyoungearn2799no you are wrong, Manchu and mongol are very different to han Chinese, but the southern minority such as Zhuang is similar to Han Chinese include north Han Chinese, I am Manchu

[@Henrycus5321]

I hope you can respect other ethnic groups, we Manchu and mongol are totally different to Han Chinese including linguistic and genetic

[@Henrycus5321]

@andrewyuyoungearn2799 but the video says they showed only sinitic people history, and Manchu are tungusic

[@kivancbektas1754]

9:47 sonlara doğru olan yeşil bölge neresi ve adı ne bilen var mı ?

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Üstünde yazıyor yandaki kutuda da yazıyor

[@kivancbektas1754]

@@KayraAtakanQX teşekürler dikkat etmemişim

[@At-jd9rv]

Buda tutmazsa daha neyedelim

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Inşallah tutar

[@KyzaghanPecheneg]

Tutar inşallah.

[@evlad-turk8358]

Kayra Atakan [Qırım Xan'ı] bi bakar mısın kardeşim

[@realgamer1099]

how do u match ur video with music😐

[@kinasya1484]

Kayra Abi History Of Altaic-Uralic videosu ne zaman gelecek 🇹🇷🇦🇿🇺🇿🇹🇲🇰🇿🇰🇬🇭🇺🇫🇮🇪🇪🇲🇳🇰🇵🇰🇷🇯🇵

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Gelmeyecek

[@cagantaylanozgun7892]

Hehe

[@islamimparatorlugu8401]

Kayra atakan meroitik tarihini yaparmısın lütfeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeen

[@Raidon8537]

Gerçek olmayan şeyi çekemez. Yoksa acayip linç yer

[@kipchakturkedits8358]

kral video atmış bize de beğenmek düşer

[@yourcup0322]

I am really glad to see Mongolia empire is not include as part of Chinese history in this video. The history books from my JR. high school said it was a Chinese empire and trying to make us proud of its size. The truth is Mongolians at that time weren’t Chinese, not even close. This video is very accurate on this matter. Good work

[@XuerLi]

The Mongols carried out mass massacres on populations in many northern China provinces till Yelu Chucai stopped them from doing so. As the Northern China peoples were seen as Jurchen-led Jin dynasty descendants who were oppressors of Mongol tribes for hundreds of years.

[@XuerLi]

@Altaic Sniper Yeap, Mongols and their great khans were slaves of Wanyan clan, Wanyan Chenheshang even defeated tens of thousands Mongol soldiers with only 2,000+ men. Search Wanyan Chenheshang on google.

[@XuerLi]

@Altaic Sniper The point is Mongos has been a hopeless nation since Yuan dynasty destroyed, yeah I don't care what lineage he belonged to but Mongolia is pathetic now don't you read the news China is trying to erase to your language

[@manchuqing4560]

@@XuerLi The Qing was not founded by the Chinese. It was founded by the Manchus, and the yuan founded by Mongolia,They all should not be a Chinese Dynasty.

[@user-sd5kh7lr2l]

Free Tibet❤, Free Hong Kong❤, Free Xinjiang uyghur❤, Free inner Mongolia❤

[@joshfish2]

Why is Singapore included at the end though?

[@bertugcelik5704]

Alternatif Türk Tarihi yaparmısın. Bu arada kardeşime tarihi sen sevdirdin

[@TheHistoricalMapping]

Great Job!

[@nikobellic776]

Ne diyon dayi

[@TheHistoricalMapping]

@@nikobellic776 Think?

[@nikobellic776]

@@TheHistoricalMapping ingilizce gonusam havalı olam

[@TheHistoricalMapping]

@@nikobellic776 ne sandın olm

[@nikobellic776]

@@TheHistoricalMapping qes len

[@이찬-z4d]

Qing was not chinese dynasty. They were manchus

[@nabateans]

The Manchus are a Chinese people

[@이찬-z4d]

@@nabateans They can be included in "chinese" in similar to "american" concept. But they are not "sinitic"

[@Closed0254]

He put Qing in Tungustic history video to. Dont worry.

[@BJHhoho]

영상 설명 읽어보셈

[@leMiG31]

Qing gangsta till march of the volunterr playing Bgw why the qing dies right when the lyrics suposed to start? And also did singapore was the third player?

[@EnesCagrTonyal]

Singapuru videonun sonunda hiç beklemiyordum

[@uyuyankedi7827]

Niye

[@feminism8583]

@donovanpham900 I don't think Singapore should be included.The Chinese migrated to Singapore under British colonised in the 19th century, just like Africans migrated to the Americas under European colonized.

[@kadirhandulger]

Abi ben üşeniyorum yapmaya bunun bi yolu var mı üşenmeyi gidermek için :D

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Hırs ! Başka kanalları geçme isteği . Yükselme isteği . Sevdiğin konuları yapmak.

[@statue1128]

Disiplin

[@elpresidente2066]

Where did you get that version of the Chinese national anthem? It sounds very nice!

[@mikronezyalinsan6550]

Neden çok uzun bir süre bütün imparatorluklar düz sarı bayrak kullanıyor

[@poyrazylmaz5259]

Çinliler İçin Kutsal Renktir Galiba Sarı

[@stardustuniverse6941]

Uzaktan görünsün diye

[@lhistoire4851]

Harika

[@yesilova7685]

İyi çalışma!

[@ehcalxuhtoo9155]

Could you please share me more about Ping Sing which is also known as Tchien? I want more clues about it. thank you so much for sharing.

[@ЯрославскийСатанист]

Hooray, you do it!

[@अजिङ्क्यगोखले]

Great work. Note though that while NE Kashmir and Arunachal Pradesh in NE India are both disputed territories, the former is administered by China and the latter by India.

[@satyasankalpapanigrahi9416]

Yes they are ruled by both during Qing Dynasty - the largest Chinese Empire. British took some land from Tibet as an exchange for protection them against Gurkha empire.

[@satyasankalpapanigrahi9416]

8:57 So this is how the mighty Qing empire looks like - the greatest extent of medieval china

[@satyasankalpapanigrahi9416]

@Iamnotracistlmao Yeah, similarly in India, the strongest and the largest empire is:- Mauryan Empire.

[@tersdunyal3736]

Kayra abi bende yapıcam tarihi ülkeleri nerden buluyosun hangi toprakları aldıklarını nerden biliyosun

[@Wandrative]

Why would you include Qing tho. I mean you excluded Liao, Yuan, Jin, Wei, etc. I think it would have been better if you followed the trend.

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Please read the description

[@zneytram1432]

I love the music you used

[@steadyzz2371]

How is the Qing dynasty Sinitic? Weren't they Manchus?

[@知-k3q]

Manchu is a concept established by Nurhachi. Before that, they had been ruled by Ming Empire and were servants of Jianzhou Corps.🥹

[@Closed0254]

He put Qing in Tungustic history video to.

[@feminism8583]

@@知-k3q The Manchus are the Tungusic people, an ethnic group different from China. Manchu China was once ruled by the Mongols. But neither Manchu nor Chinese is Mongolian.

[@SoujiOkitaTwo]

Manchus are still Sinitic despite not being Han

[@cennetulbaki7441]

Reis çok güzel olmuş ama videoları nerden yapıyosun?

[@emreabit857]

Hello!Most probably,I am in the most part,a Kirim Tatar.I mean,in my family,the old version of the Crimean Tatar language is spoken.I am from Dobroudja,Romania.I think my family came here perhaps,after The Crimean War (1853-1856).Can you make a video about this region? Selam! btw,my cousin’s name is Ata-Kaan 🤣🤣

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Ben türkçe biliyorum .d

[@KayraAtakanQX]

This region derken kırımı kastediyorsan kırım tarigi diye bir videom var. Yok eğer dobrucayi kastediyorsan orda roma bizans osmanlı bulgar imp. Ve dobruca beyliği disinda devlet yok zaten onların hepsi de videolarımda var . Spesifik olarak Türk tarihi videomu kontrol edebilirsin .

[@eden6056]

Singapore isn't Sinitic , though most people are Chinese but technically the National language and Anthem is in Malay

[@KayraAtakanQX]

It ıs like united states .

[@stanislavivball]

The most ancient and great culture.

[@messier8379]

Most United Acient Civilization

[@marilygutierrez956]

Como es que sacas tanta informacion?

[@LegendaryMapper]

Not Sea of the japan Please kyara Mapping The Sea Name is the "East Sea"

[@KayraAtakanQX]

But it writing like this in every maps i saw . And in google maps too.

[@LegendaryMapper]

@@KayraAtakanQX Please "Sea of japan" Name is the For the East Sea Japnese Imperialism Claimed. Please The name is an obvious error. The True Name is the East Sea. Japan is The Without apologizing for World War II rather Imperial ambition To realize Writing its name Please in The Future video's That sea Name is "East sea" Please be sure to write

[@KayraAtakanQX]

@@LegendaryMapper ok i will be careful.

[@慕容佑]

what is the name of bgm？

[@vladimirzelenovic7807]

Map is not accurate for two reasons, Yuan dynasty is part of the Chinese dynastic system and they were mostlu sinicized, and the second reason is that parts of Taiwan were under the Wu kingdom.

[@cagantaylanozgun7892]

Ab qing tunguz deyilmiydi hatta vidyo yapmıştı yanlis hatirlamiyosam

[@recepemrekaya8004]

Aynen Tunguzların kurduğu bir devlet diye biliyorum ben de

[@fatihsultanselim5696]

video açıklamasını okuyun

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Bir raddeden sonra mançulukla alakasi kalmıyor . Vikipediye gore de öyle ayrıca .

[@cagantaylanozgun7892]

@@KayraAtakanQX tmm

[@papazataklaattiranimam]

5:21 *Expand Time*

[@NRooster]

Buldum seni hocam :D

[@papazataklaattiranimam]

ayaz mapper bulgars videolarında da görürsün beni

[@ahmettheturk889]

@@papazataklaattiranimam olmadığın video yok

[@papazataklaattiranimam]

Ahmet The Turk 🤣🤣😂😂 Günde 40 bildirim geliyor sorma

[@papazataklaattiranimam]

Ahmet The Turk hele ölümlühayat vardı benim 10katım spam yapıyordu😂😂

[@josephstalin8838]

Qing tunguz değilmiydi çin tunguz ortak devletmi yoksa.

[@KayraAtakanQX]

Tunguz ama çinlileşiyor

[@josephstalin8838]

@@KayraAtakanQX teşekkür ederim.

[@Pikachu-sc1yc]

I like China. From France.

[@justsomeguywholikesdavidbo1085]

What’s the name of the song used in the middle of the video?

[@Thishyns]

1756-1757'de Qing ve Kazak Hanlığı savaştı, bunun sonucunda 3.000 Kazak 20.000 Çinli askeri yendi ve Kazak Hanlığı Ayagöz'e kadar olan toprakları geri aldı.

[@berkayavc2896]

Qing'in haritada gösterilip Yuan'ın gösterilmemesi biraz değişik geldi bana. Qing hanedanlığı da Yuan hanedanlığı gibi Çinli değildi. Qing hanedanlığı Mançuryalı iken Yuan hanedanlığı Moğol'du. Ama yine de ikisi de Çin tarihinin bir parçası. Bence Yuan'ı da göstermek gerek.

[@PaektuMountain]

Yes. but NOW most of Machu people become Chinese and Manchu country don’t exist. On the other hand, Mongolians have their own country.

[@Kin-75gcj]

蒙古虽然只统治了不到百年，但是他上位的时候就说了继承的明朝正统

[@nonancourt]

The maps look great, though what you chose as being chinese dynasties and what you excluded seems rather strange to me. For example, You inluded the Qing dynasty, which was founded by Sinicized Manchus(non-chinese) but omitted other such dynasties such as for example The Northern Wei, The Liao and Jin Dynasties, and The Yuan Dynasty. Those dynasties were also founded by sinified non-chinese tribal peoples (The Tuoba Xianbei, The Kitans, the Jurchen and the Mongols respectively), and their subjects were for a large part chinese, additionally their goverments were just as influenced by chinese culture and philosophy as that of the Qing dynasty's.

[@batuchen6103]

Manchu Chinese here. You're right. If you regard Norman dynasty as a British dynasty, then there is no reason to ignore Yuan dynasty. I think the reason that author included Qing rather than Yuan is because Qing was found on eight banners which itself consisted of Manchu, Han and Mongol, in which Han proportion was rather huge. Qing's expansion highly depended on eight banners and green army. However, Yuan dynasty except early days of Kublai khan, was largely a MONGOL dynasty. So even if mongol khans claimed themselves as the emperor of Middle Kingdom, they were not really that sinicized.

[@Void_Dweller7]

Good Points from the both of you.

[@khuzaitkhan9504]

Why Qing is included. It is found by Manchu

[@Qingep]

Why not