Battle of Cumae, 215 BC ⚔️ Hannibal (Part 18) ⚔️ Second Punic War

[@HistoryMarche]

🚩 Play World of Tanks for free here: tanks.ly/3gw5P5U -- Use the code TANKMANIA to get Excelsior, 7 Premium Days, and 250k credits, as well as 3 rental tanks for 10 battles each (Tiger 131, Cromwell B, and T34-85M) *Only applicable to new players. 🚩 In this episode we see Hannibal trying to take the city of Cumae by storm! One of the few occasions when Hannibal attempted to assault a walled city.

[@RisNataka]

Iya kak

[@dk.3803]

حاطين كل اللغات الا العربية !!!؟؟؟ 👎🏼

[@HistoryMarche]

@@dk.3803 What's wrong with the subs?

[@dk.3803]

@@HistoryMarche I was surprised why there is no Arabic translation

[@HistoryMarche]

@@dk.3803 But there is

[@Boxghost102]

Rome should have made Hanno II an honorary Praetor, since he was their biggest ally in the war.

[@HistoryMarche]

lol pretty much

[@kittogashi8561]

They didn't want Hannibal as emperor, so they outsourced for the position.

[@tylerscofield9799]

Agreed, what is funny, I have never heard what happened to him after Rome defeated them much less when they complete destroyed Carthage

[@SudoKnightlyNonsense]

@@tylerscofield9799 He went on to join another nation, can't remember which one, even becoming an admiral that fought against the Romans. Sadly, he wasn't as good of an admiral as he was a general: apparently his "elephants" (as in, his "secret weapon") was to throw jars of snakes at Roman ships. This didn't work out, of course, but I can't remember if he died naturally, committed suicide or was killed by the Romans.

[@jsoth2675]

Lol

[@dubravkokovacevic3489]

i'll never forgive you not making new episodes for more than 6 months. This is your masterpiece, you have to continue it!

[@josephmurillo6832]

Let’s levy a army cause not finishing this series is a crime

[@the_forth_of_his_name7961]

@@josephmurillo6832 i agree

[@dunrossb]

HistoryMarche is simply employing the Fabian Strategy

[@MaizeRage23]

When are they going to finish this does anytime know?

[@dubravkokovacevic3489]

@@MaizeRage23 he keeps telling "soon" I refuse to learn about the Punic wars from another source since he describes it so well

[@HoH]

Hannibal, quite literally the victim of his own success in this episode. Great work as always!

[@MalayArcher]

DJ Hannibal - Suffering from Success

[@KHK001]

lol

[@roomonleft]

@@MalayArcher I was coming here to support the main comment, but ended up supporting yours :)

[@brokenbridge6316]

Theirs some truth in that.

[@asmrnaturecat984]

hannibal simps assemble!

[@buinghiathuan4595]

Continue this series please. Seeing the end make me deeply saddened

[@CowboyChuntis]

Just watched all the parts and am sad there is no part 19 yet plz finish this amazing series.

[@ericmcdonald7313]

Never underestimate the motives of the deep state….. even in BC

[@Silence.......356]

I did some research on the last battle before rome one this war and Hannibal lost not because he wasn't brilliant but because no one had sent reinforcements and by the time of this battle his army was so decrepit and weak it no wonder he lost it Hanno the second sucks

[@ironmankc8142]

I just finished all 18 parts... WOW. I knew Hannibal was a great general and he almost defeated Rome, but I had no idea just how brilliant he was, and how deep into Rome he made it. Also, how did Rome muster so many men even after they kept losing so many against Hannibal. Seems never ending.

[@linuswidell7659]

Yeah how, how does he defeat 250,000 and there is still men left. Especially when half the peninsula changes side

[@drakehashimoto685]

@@linuswidell7659 During this period, I'm sure the population of the Roman Republic, in Italia, was perhaps in the millions.

[@williamloosman]

War is about economics my friend

[@drakehashimoto685]

@@williamloosman True, it's also about ambition, power, glory, among other things. It usually varies. But well said

[@kairon5249]

the roman republic was just too powerful manpower wise to defeat. If hannibal led the carthaginian army during the first punic war (when carthage actually had a chance) then history would be very different.

[@joaorathis8157]

Hannibal was probably on of the most brilliant men that ever existed

[@Hannibal_Barca_from_Carthage]

I think so too

[@kaiswork3998]

Nah Ceasar is better

[@joaorathis8157]

@@kaiswork3998 dude got killed by his own step son

[@oneshortgamer2540]

@@joaorathis8157 literally anybody can be assassinated it means absolutely nothing, while he chose Ceasar (obviously) the true Hannibal equal was Aurelian for me.

[@jchea1764]

​@@oneshortgamer2540Germanicus, who led the legions to recover the lost Eagle Standards of Varus' legions and defeated Arminius as well is a close contender too

[@solace895]

Hannibal is one of my all time favorites, what a genius, I waited for a new episode for so long! Thank you

[@beepboop204]

i prefer Scipio personally... for both of them, imagine the greatness they would had achieved if the full weight of the state was behind them............

[@redaissami9380]

Hannibal Is Da Best

[@michimatsch5862]

A tactical genius, sure. Politically and/or strategically on the other hand...

[@mrhumble2937]

@@michimatsch5862 well sometimes there isn't anything you can do if your government is weak. Caesae was great politically and they still all whooped his ass in the Senate.

[@AbbeyRoadkill1]

Hannibal, you know how to win a victory, you do not know how to use it. -Maharbal

[@EleazarVides]

I hope you guys continue this series, the work you guys put into this is amazing. Please keep making more of these, I don’t mean to pressure you, it’s just that the second Punic war is amazing to always study.

[@spasjt]

So the Carthaginian senate had the same concerns the Roman senate did about Caesar? Truly fascinating how history repeats itself. Also, I CANNOT WAIT for the next video since I have just binged watch all 18 parts you all have so professionally, clearly, and scholarly assembled for our educational enrichment. Many thanks!

[@josephmurillo6832]

There’s was never another episode

[@spasjt]

@@josephmurillo6832 So I have noticed. Hopefully, they will go back and fix this.

[@aam5162]

Dear HistoryMarche team please please continue this fantastic series!

[@ArchonShon]

Roman Generals: I need more troops! Rome: Yes! Hannibal: I need more troops! Carthage: And I took that personally

[@HistoryMarche]

Pretty much...

[@tyegra6665]

Modern day carthage tunisia is still like that when i watched what happend to hannibal it made me laugh to see that these people havent change since the beggining of time...its just laughble.

[@DaimonaC]

@@HistoryMarche where is ep 19

[@erostheelder6831]

Lol yeah Carthage is like we can just stop and wait until this all burns .. I mean blows over it's not like Rome is going to un-exist us from most of history pour salt over everything and only save a one recipe book because they like our wine.

[@omrimuhamed2768]

@@tyegra6665 am tunisian and i live in chartage ... we live in 2022 what you talk about it ??? ... times change and peoples change also you didnt learn anything from history sadly ...

[@ele7864]

I repeated this series 4 times at this point im glad theres finally a new episode

[@GoogleUserOne]

Totally

[@medievalist8441]

Same haha

[@TheStrategos392]

Excellent job again HistoryMarche. One of the reasons Hannibal ultimately lost was because he did not have the full support of the Carthaginian senate and he never committed to destroying the city of Rome. The Romans were the opposite, they were uni- lateral with their foreign policy and they destroyed Carthage. This is why Grand Strategy and unity against the enemy in warfare is of vital importance. Well done 👍.

[@bandit6272]

Hannibal also failed to get any members of the core Latin tribes to turn on Rome, and mostly had what support he had, in southern Italy. Hannibal never sparked the widespread uprising against the Romans that he expected. I think he hated Rome so much that he thought everyone else did too, and if you thought that, of *course* you'd expect the populace to rise up and join him in overthrowing Rome. As history shows, he was mistaken, and eventually he lost.

[@mitch8072]

@@bandit6272you'd expect the populace to rise up and join him: just like Putin in ukraine.

[@bandit6272]

@@mitch8072 I wouldn't expect that.

[@mitch8072]

@@bandit6272 no i agree. but both hannibal and putin expected support from the locals. and neither got it.

[@bandit6272]

@@mitch8072 Yeah, and a lot of the support we expected from the locals in Afghanistan and Iraq never materialized either, lol. This seems to be an old mistake.

[@razorbird789]

This is one of the best series of history made. No one has gone to this depth of information with accompanying graphics. As a history buff I never knew Hannibal's campaign in Italy was so long or how it ends, All I need to know is where the hell are those Macedonian reinforcements!

[@lukehaddad6387]

Hannibal didn't have control over the 'heel of italy', that's the region where Tarentum is located. Which is why he needed reinforcements. With 10,000 - 20,000 he'd be able to control that region, secure a supply line with his new ally in the Kingdom of Macedonia, and be able to implement whatever his 'winning strategy' was. Probably a direct attack on Rome. But due to Hanno II political clout, and the ammunition provided by Hasdrubal's loss at the battle of Hibera, he was denied the reinforcements to make the security of Macedonian supplies reliable.

[@ethancash8870]

When ever I read about the second Punic War I always feel so intense despite knowing what happens.

[@Rathallan]

Same, I felt sorry for Hannibal

[@ramonsalu563]

@@Rathallan bro why

[@Rathallan]

@@ramonsalu563 one of the only generals in history that should have won but got defeated by his own people

[@Owen-pj3ms]

@@Rathallan I'm curious as to who the others would be. This could be fun.

[@ramonsalu563]

@@Rathallan yeah nobody gives props to the Romans, they were able to still win the war after they lost multiple battles

[@zaidbayaty3865]

I really don't want this series to be ended, It's deciding points to have strong allies among your own people rather than to seek allies within the enemy's territory, if Hannibal had all carthage in his support the history would take another course with no future roman as power at all. But the roman unity and resolve had won the day.

[@michaelvonbiskhoff7771]

Well, the war would last 13 more years, so I think we can expect at least 10 more episodes, if not more.

[@Sealdeam]

This is going to be a long series specially given that it is scope goes beyond just the actions Hannibal was directly involved with, could easily last a couple of years more, now when it ends is going to be a bittersweet thing, at least to me.

[@christopherthrawn1333]

Your right 100%.

[@StoicFC]

Not just the day. But the entire war

[@totalwartimelapses6359]

The series has been going on for 4 years now and only covered about 3-4 years of the war I think it'll take them about 4-5 years to finish the entire war

[@fire2790]

Started watching this series right after watching oversimplifieds take on the 1st Punic war. Boy I am glad I did ran through the whole series in a day and can’t wait for the next parts. Definitely subscribed.

[@HistoryMarche]

Thank you for watching. And welcome aboard.

[@thewiseameer]

@@HistoryMarche please give us part 19

[@ellioyjolly734]

When is next episode

[@bluebloxyt]

@@HistoryMarche it’s literally been 10 months

[@verumpopulare9107]

This is the best series of history that i've ever seen. Please continue. Support from Argentina

[@SparklyRug]

I'm sad there isn't more episodes of this because I'm so invested at this point.

[@HistoryMarche]

Coming soon.

[@lazyguy3081]

@@HistoryMarche W

[@Faris-bk6xu]

@@lazyguy3081 ITS HEREEEE SIUUUUUUUUUUUU

[@Faris-bk6xu]

Well not here but we got a sneak peak

[@barrackobama2422]

@@HistoryMarche YES! You have at least 1 guaranteed viewer

[@rkitchen1967]

As an ancient wargamer, I am always impressed how your videos make the strategic situation so clear.

[@Elysium346]

Not even started the video yet but liked and comment because I know its gonna be quality, thank you guys for teaching history in such an intuitive and engaging way!

[@HistoryMarche]

Much appreciated!

[@keith1290]

@@HistoryMarche Have absolutely loved watching these and learning about Hannibal and 2nd Punic war, such well made videos :). When’s the next part due?

[@ricardocabrita4148]

great work. cannot wait for the rest of the second punic war.

[@Rathallan]

It occurs to me that the one who the lost the war for the Carthage is Hanno, not Hannibal

[@ahmadrahman456]

Not only him pretty much every single carthaginians commanders are responsible for Carthage defeat if Hannibal wasn't patriotic he would have join Rome to see his own country fall.

[@leonmuller8475]

@@ahmadrahman456 His own country would have won, though. It was only because they were divided and not focused on taking down Rome. Rome also likely would not have just accepted Hannibal's change of sides. They likely would have just imprisoned him to put more pressure on Carthage.

[@ecurewitz]

Exactly. if he was a bit more far sighted, he could have dealt with political problems at home after the war. But in the end Carthage was destroyed because Hanno wouldn’t back Hannibal

[@Rathallan]

@waddle Wars are caused my friend. Polybius's patron was a Roman, but even he acknowledged that the treaty was unfair to begin with and the Roman's interfered in territory that was Carthaginian in direct opposition to the treaty they had signed, and... after breaking the treaty themselves, the Roman's tried to force Carthage to give up Hannibal. So no, like almost EVERY single war in their early period, Rome was at fault. Even according to Roman sources. Look at the first Punic war, Rome broke the treaty there too. I honestly wish the Roman's had been wiped off the face of the earth. World would have been better for it

[@Gwynnbleid95]

I find it incredible that a human being like Hannibal even existed, like Phillip and Alexander, he's just crazy impressive👏🏻

[@velstadtvonausterlitz2338]

Julius Caesar has by far have a much better military career.

[@N0TYALC]

@@velstadtvonausterlitz2338 I think he was comparing Hannibal to other men, not gods.

[@N0TYALC]

@@velstadtvonausterlitz2338 I think he was comparing Hannibal to other men, not gods.

[@velstadtvonausterlitz2338]

@Danny Tallmage both fought an empire. Hannibal was better than alexander, because he fought far better enemies and commanders than the persians, and darius ever will, whose main strategy is to flee the battlefield. Plus, Caesar far outclassed Hannibal, because he managed to defeat Rome itself in the civil war. Alexander is nothing without parmenion. It was parmenion who manages Alexander's supply lines, it was parmenion who holds the phalanx for alexander to deliver the hammer of his companion cavalry, it is parmenion who keeps alexander in a leash to not recklessly charge into battle without a proper plan that always cost them precious macedonian lives that they can't easily replace in the front lines, and "alexander the great *Ingrate* " killed him for his outstanding contributions to his campaign. What a great general. He never lost a battle that he didn't have a direct command in the first place. Without Philip II's veteran officers, alexander is nothing.

[@Gwynnbleid95]

@@velstadtvonausterlitz2338 completey disagree. Alexander is nothing without parmineon? Ha! Alexander constantly ignored what he and his other diadochi said, gaugamela is a great example, proving the tactical and strategic brilliance was his own. Hannibal's italian campaign and victory at Cannae far far far outclasses anything caesar did. caesars men were far better than anything he went up against, by the time caesar fought other romans his own men were hard-core veterans after the campaign in Gaul, often his army far outmatched his opponents. caesar was also a piece of shit, who committed what most historians agree is a genocide in Gaul for his own personal gain and glory as he was in debt, that's why the true romans wanted him to abandon his army have him be tried as the criminal he is.

[@danieljoseph255]

The Hannibal series deserves a formal award and recognition for its brilliance

[@davidhughes8357]

I watch these over and over etc. With nearly thirty years of interest in Roman warfare I just want more and more. Your excellent channel makes this possible. And me happy. Thank you.

[@thesilentassassin1167]

It was almost infuriating to watch this episode lol, Carthage didnt deserved Hannibal

[@lapizlazuli9304]

The first time I watched this I almost cried. Carthage indeed didn’t deserve Hannibal.

[@afonsoferreira2652]

rome deserved Hannibal, they would give EVERYTHING to this guys

[@lapizlazuli9304]

@@afonsoferreira2652 If Hannibal was a Roman Africa would have been named after him.

[@afonsoferreira2652]

@@lapizlazuli9304 absolutely. Amazing général I had NOOO idea he was sooo good and cleaver.

[@ultraslay7635]

Yes but what happened to hano || after this. I hope he died in horrific conditions.

[@emanevilla4143]

Press 👍 if you're like me waiting for another great episode of Hannibal.

[@Radrook353]

Weird that they could not foresee that a defeat of Hannibal would mean the end of their city including them.

[@Palasdin]

Talk about a Fantastic way to start the weekend with the continuation of this amazing series!

[@HistoryMarche]

Have a great weekend.

[@Palasdin]

@@HistoryMarche 😱😱 I am not worthy of your acknowledgment. Rome is in your debt. ❤️❤️

[@Conorp77]

You guys really need to finish this series, it's one of the best on the channel.

[@rahimbukhari6966]

This is just an amazing series. A standing ovation to the @HistoryMarche Team. When will Episode 19 come out? It is hard to wait for new episodes after just having finished a marathon of 18 episodes in one day.

[@HistoryMarche]

Part 19 very soon.

[@ameytiwari1247]

@@HistoryMarche I am literally following this series like people were following Game of Thrones at its peak. And there are many like me!

[@ameytiwari1247]

@@HistoryMarche I am literally following this series like people were following Game of Thrones at its peak. And there are many like me!

[@vking8084]

@@HistoryMarche you said that 4 months ago

[@jarek_gadek]

@@HistoryMarche could you share your definition of “very soon”? Because in general meaning it would be let say few hours. Ok, in KZbin reality few days, even a week. But another month? Come on guys… you want people to beg?

[@remember2023]

After lingering around on Netflix trying to find a documentary that isn't a miniserie about sex or some populistic topic, I found this channel and clicked on the first video on Hannibal and I'm hooked. The way both the prelude to campaigns and battles are narrated and without the skimming on the tactical analysis of the battles and also going over the political side of these conquests is just pure gold. In my toop 3 of war docu channels/sources togheter with kings and generals and epic history time.

[@MrBellsBlues]

Hannibal was truly the greatest of all time. Against all odds. It makes me so sad his own senate would not support him... It makes no sense. Perhaps Rome had something to do with this. Promising them to be filthy rich and bribing them to try cut Hannibal off. The fact he's doing this without the support of Carthage makes it that more of a truly epic ancient tale however.

[@bigmonkedong]

they were losing in Iberia while he was winning in Italy. It really makes sense sending troops to spain if you think about it. Iberia's silver was funding hannibal's war. No Iberia = No war.

[@shalomhaim4270]

@@bigmonkedong But taking mainland Italy and Rome would no doubt end the war, and with those troops sent to Iberia Hannibal would've been able to successfully defeat or at least outmaneuver the Roman Armies

[@rangerbobcat]

Khalid Ibn al Waleed, who fought over two hundred skirmishes and battles during the early expansion of the Islamic Armies against the Sassanid Persians and the Byzantine Empire without losing a single one has to be considered at least a close rival

[@totalwartimelapses6359]

@waddle This is what I wonder about, was there no possibility that his reinforcements would be cut off? Especially if Rome got news of it

[@johnnyboy3410]

Hannibal wasn’t the greatest by his own admission, he and Sicpio at some point met and Sicpio asked him to rank the best generals the history at that time, Hannibal put Alexander the great first and Pyrrhus 2nd, Sicpio asked him who was the third and Hannibal said himself and Sicpio laughed and then asked him if he defeated him where would he put himself, Hannibal said he would have put himself first

[@dwikiadriyanto7682]

i can't believe that i was watch this Hannibal series from part 1 to 18 in a day, what a great story, great narrator, i will be waiting this series to the end. Thanks to all HistoryMarche's crew for all great job.

[@Spiderfisch]

Its depressing watching Hannibal lose so slowly

[@kogerugaming]

It's also depressing watching romans lose hundred thousands of manpower because most of the generals were like: pfft, the general before me was amateur! I would never walk into a trap! *walks into a trap*

[@quintusfabiusmaximus8700]

i was just too good.. 😁

[@lildicky8973]

Vorro lost is stomach and fleed maby as lest preveinting complete incirclement and maby and helping with a Tatical retreat making where maby the bulk of of romwn army to hold on wven longer they lost due to being ti tire to fight but Hannibal cav was still thier so thiers that to consider to also if vorro was willing to fight

[@ultraslay7635]

@@quintusfabiusmaximus8700 you were too idiot to fight Hannibal.

[@RexGalilae]

The more I watch this series, the more I'm awestruck by the genius of both Fabius and Hannibal. The Strategist vs The Tactician. The Wolf vs The Fox. Two very different but equally competent commanders. I'm sure they both had massive mutual respect for one another.

[@ashuranero5721]

Who is the wolf and who is the fox? Fabius = Fox and Hannibal = Wolf?

[@dougmartinson9991]

Love this series....would be great to see a netflix series based off HistoryMarche of Hannibal

[@naimnefzi3762]

Yess thank you

[@mikecheston4580]

The Hannibal videos are the best you produce. I would love to see you finish them!

[@HistoryMarche]

That's the plan!

[@hoejoecinco3253]

@@HistoryMarchelet’s go 🎉

[@SAMax2268]

The entire Hannibal series is just outstanding and so well put together. 👍🏽

[@imakaze]

I finished this series in only 2 days and I love it. I hope you will continue the history. This channel is gold! Thank you.

[@thearabian772]

Finally, another Hannibal episode!

[@Iceking_3334]

Finally more parts for Hannibal.Great work.Keep them going 👌👌

[@Andyman89.]

We need part 19 of this series!!!

[@HistoryMarche]

Working on it

[@Andyman89.]

@@HistoryMarche awsome! Looking forward to it ❤️

[@Vicente_RO7]

Man, this series is some of the best content I've watched in a long time.... simply masterful storytelling. The level of detail is so satisfying for us history nerds!

[@adamwhite6401]

Please continue this series!

[@davidedigiuseppe9947]

That's the best series ever made on the second Punic war, please continue!! :(

[@thereddeath2534]

Amazing work guys, I love these can’t wait for episode 19? Really keen to see how this ends, has had me on the edge of my seat and I’ve been learning a lot with it aswell. Just wanna say a massive thank you. It’s really fun and intresting.

[@Alienalloy]

found and all the episodes watched in one hit in an afternoon at the workshop....iv learnt so much today.. as said, a master piece !!

[@teobec]

More Hannibal stories to watch!Amazing video as always!Keep up the good work!

[@HistoryMarche]

More to come!

[@FelixTheCat94]

Man this is a suffering ! You're the best by far to describe this amazing period of history and my favorite general of all time ! I beg you to finish this before we all pass away hahaha ! Otherwise we'll have miss a little bit of heaven on earth !

[@jamesshore3191]

Can't wait for Zama! Also this is probably the best series on the 2nd punic war I've seen on youtube to date. Keep up the awesome work guys!

[@lifeisshort.9869]

I learned from this channel MORE than I learned in 12 years of regular school, I don't know how I should feel about this xD

[@unclebounce1495]

Amazing work. I sniffled two or three times when I reached this episode and realized the series wasn't finished yet. My hats to you. Do you still plan to finish this series? I'll give you all the thumbs and commentary support I can. You're a creator of real content, not merely superficial modern time-sink fluffery.

[@burningphoneix]

11:50 I don't know why but I always love that trumpet sound in your videos. I try to listen out for it whenever I'm watching. Kinda like a Wilheim scream. 🤣

[@KHK001]

My favorite punic series is back! great work as always HM!

[@HistoryMarche]

Glad you enjoy it! Awesome to see you here KHK

[@9999deoxys]

I wish that learning History was like this in High School. This is better than anything on TV.

[@cheriefsadeksadek2108]

Another Hannibal Video ,My Favourite series, Thank you so Much !!!

[@HistoryMarche]

More to come!

[@JWW1941]

@@HistoryMarche when is the next Hannibal video gonna get released!? I’m so keen for it hahaha

[@abdoali7237]

@@HistoryMarche we are still waiting since 7 months ago

[@matischamplain7624]

Hi folks, I want to congratulate you for this serie about 2nd Punic War so far .... Really a fantastic serie as far as I know this part of the history as a historian. Even if Polybios must me handled with care because he was pro roman there are enough hard datas known to figure out what happened. What I am missing - and this is not a critic only a suggestion - is one part which describes the political and social difference between this 2 societies. Rome leave the Hellenistic concept of society far behind and was very modern for its time with assets on his hands to survive such a battle of attrition far better than Carthage. The 2 fractions inside the political system of Carthage ar mentioned briefly but it would be worth to introduce the viewers to the political and social differences of Rome and Carthage. Without Hannibal Carthage would have had not the slightest chance to win this war. The genius of Hannibal and with all ressources of Carthage at his hand there would have been a chance to win ... probably or a least a good chance. I hope you will continue this serie ... GOOD LUCK

[@Danymok]

Glorious, i was waiting for this series to continue

[@sonnyb7612]

How is it over a year without more vids on this subject? By far the best series on Hannibal and the 2nd punic war and its a crime to only half ass something like this.

[@MithridatesOfficial]

Wish these were longer.. hate having to wait a month for the next.. I do appreciate the work you guys put into these regardless. I'm just rather anxious to see more 😁

[@mahmoudkhairy5653]

Thank you very much Historymarche, I have seen the second punic war many times from you and not once i did bored from it, Thank you to show us this important stage of History

[@napoleonibonaparte7198]

Have the Romans learned their lesson? Will Hannibal decisively defeat Rome? Find out next time on, Hannibal B!

[@fher_id]

yoo napoleon, big fans..

[@gizel4376]

if i didn't know the end i would have say it's been a while that Rome is Doom, they are reduce to enrole slave and teenager, they losed half of their land, their ally are defecting, their economy is on the limit and Carthage is gaining new ally and enroling a lot more troups

[@totalwartimelapses6359]

@@gizel4376 I'm gonna spoil the series for you: Macedon later joins the war on Rome And Carthage wins some victories in Spain So yeah Rome is pretty much done, Carthage is gonna win at the end of the show

[@raidang]

@@totalwartimelapses6359 u forgot the part where 500 Romans under Scipio captures Carthago Nova and destroys the core Carthaginian Army in Spain almost as bad as cannae one but from Carthaginian perspective The Scipio takes 4 legions to Africa where he allies with one fraction of the numindian kingdom then his 23,000 men finally defeats 45,000 strong Hannibal's troops Finally the war ends

[@totalwartimelapses6359]

@@raidang Come on man we're doing a bit here, you didn't have to ruin it Yes duh Rome ends up crushing Carthage, I know every detail of this war

[@Mr_Ro6ot]

Hannibal reminds me the Napoleon against coalition forces. One can easily find the similarity since both men invaded Italy bu crossing the Alps and surprised their enemy counterparts. Another one is that as Roman army avoided confrontation with Hannibal and attack his allies, Coalition forces also only attacked Napoleon's marshalls and avoided confrontation with French army if he is commanding the troops.

[@aaauuup]

سلسله حروب هانيبال افضل ما شاهدت حتى الان 🇮🇶♥️.

[@jokemonpokemon]

I want morrrrrrre. And I want this type of detail re: 3rd Punic war. No one else on KZbin has this level of detail to this portion of history. Thank you for sharing knowledge with the rest of us.

[@monikachojnacka5917]

HistoryMarche We're waiting :D !!! Any sneak peak when we can see another episode ? 🐎🐎

[@vinnieg6161]

I like that the Romans finally learned caution and scouting are important against good generals

[@StoicHistorian]

Was Hannibal the best general at maneuvering around his enemies to gain an advantage? Personally I feel like he is

[@birdyhans2452]

Yes he was one of the best Generatrals in history they should teach more about him on school.

[@omarbradley6807]

@@birdyhans2452 The fact who he was great is probably something who will not help to make the mediocre education system of "insert any country here" teach more about him. that is the sad true.

[@MrSwifty404]

yo i just binge watched everything up to this point........... this was epic so far. thank u

[@HistoryMarche]

Working on part 19

[@MrSwifty404]

@@HistoryMarche it took me a few minutes to realize that after I couldn't find part 19. It is so epic how you display the battles. I love the sleeping Carthage senator bit too.

[@jonny-b4954]

God, I feel like this series has been going on for years to the point I'm always like "is this a new one, have I seen this one yet?" I bet I've watched each episode 2 or 3 times as a result haha. I'm addicted. The quality is so good. I wish there would be more random facts at the end though ;) My favorite tidbit. I've never heard of building a siege tower defensively and a tower vs tower battle haha

[@paultyson4389]

I have really been looking forward to the continuation of this series of yours on the Second Punic War. You do a fantastic job. Thanks.

[@bassemslimani2741]

We need Episode #19 ASAP !!

[@marceloseixas895]

this hannibal series are already my favorite on youtube

[@grigordoydoyan2406]

what happened next ?? so excited to see part 19 - 20 -etc till the end .please continue this story

[@HistoryMarche]

Working on it.

[@ellioyjolly734]

Yes!!

[@ellioyjolly734]

But when?

[@raidang]

@@HistoryMarche 9 months has passed

[@thecrusaderhistorian9820]

Love to see another Hannibal episode! Great video! I said it before and I will say it again. Hanno II is not my favorite Carthaginian.

[@Jackshephardlostie]

These second Punic war series are awesome, big congrats and please, go ahead with it!

[@vking8084]

i already watch this part 13 times still waiting for part 19

[@rezaabasi2187]

you guys are doing such an amazing job explaining everything down to minor details, im enjoying your work so much. please continue and finish this.

[@shz1981n]

Eagerly waiting for the next episode!

[@BartyTardy]

Worst part about watching these videos....is knowing we gotta wait a while for the next one 😭😭😭. Quality takes time though, so it's worth it. Another great vid!

[@robbabcock_]

Fantastic video! I can't wait for Part 19! ⚔⚔⚔

[@waltershoults8803]

Full tin of Texas Pecan coffee ☕️ and nobody about , sharpening my blade and ready for battle!! Thank you for bringing history to my living room. 🙏

[@avivg.4971]

waited for this for a long time, thanks!

[@HistoryMarche]

Hope you enjoyed it!

[@Uchiha.obito.999]

My lord . Its been 8 months since i have watched this episode and I can't find anything else to feed my family and myself. I have been waiting for months so the king may continue the series'

[@ellioyjolly734]

Where is new Hannibal episodes? We NEED them!

[@HistoryMarche]

Working on part 19. It's coming along, shouldn't be much longer.

[@ellioyjolly734]

Yay!

[@ameytiwari1247]

this is best series on history I have watched. The narration and factual info go hand in hand so well

[@calebyee4738]

I think it’s mandatory for me to watch the whole story once in a while

[@marceloseixas895]

I'm happu that people haven't forgotten this amazing series, neither me! Plz, continue the hannibal's history, we all would love to see what happened!

[@Ahmed_Malrogi.750]

OH YEA , HERE COMES THE MAN , THE MYTH , THE LEGEND HANNIBAL 🙌

[@steveharwell7567]

The sheer quality of this channel is astounding. Thank you!

[@HistoryMarche]

Wow, thank you!

[@Ebrrrrq]

So excited for the next part!!!

[@HistoryMarche]

Working on it.

[@blagovestgeorgiev9776]

@@HistoryMarche for 6 months? Come on

[@scottofficer8772]

Just found this channel. Been binge watching this series all Christmas holidays! Keep it going its really good! Particularly this series on 2nd punic war! Thanks so much

[@Dantheman813]

Still waiting for the rest!!!

[@theflyeragaric]

Bloody brilliant series! Thanks to everyone involved.

[@ilumi421]

Please continue

[@ellioyjolly734]

What happened to Hannibal? It’s been 8 months. We want more Hannibal! Hannibal = Good

[@HistoryMarche]

Soon.

[@ISawABear]

I'm always surprised how many of Hannibals battles i've never heard of.

[@Jean_Jacques148]

Awesome episode guys. I am thinking of starting this, what software do you use to make these?

[@HistoryMarche]

Photoshop for graphics and After Effects for animations.