Hogwarts Legacy vs RDR2 - Physics and Details Comparison

[@GameLight]

Hogwarts Legacy vs RDR2: Map size, Budget Hogwarts Legacy map size: 2.95 square miles, and $150 million was spent on making the game. RDR2 map size with Mexico is 75 square miles, without 29 square miles and 370-540 million dollars was spent on making the game. If you played Hogwarts Legacy did you enjoy the game?

[@delta__404]

What's the music name used throughout the video, is it from rdr2?

[@GameLight]

@@delta__404 RDR 2 The aftermath of Genesis

[@Cedisdead]

As a HP fan it was fun just to walk the castle. But the game itself was horrific

[@ДаніілМіщенко-й7н]

I was enjoy in Hogwarts only first 35 hours. In RDR2 i enjoy every game session

[@itsuplike9947]

Eh, they did well on world and design lore wise, but it’s missing things that would make the game replay-able after you beat the main story. Every now and then i turn it on just to walk around and then i get off the game lol

[@alexj6269]

To be honest RDR2 has been better than every other game on realism since it came out

[@goqnogkowol]

kingdom come deliverance is better in some aspects

[@Cedisdead]

Yes but you can tell Hogwarts physics are extremely bad right?

[@choppax9454]

​@@goqnogkowol mannn shut your bam

[@mebansutnga2566]

@@goqnogkowol witcher 3 feels so boring and plastic world

[@FriedrichKarlvonWoltmann]

What are you talking about? HL looks worse than The Witcher 3! In textures, in the quality of models in general, and even in animation scripts. ;))

[@ziadnour3998]

No one can beat rdr2 until rdr3

[@capolean2902]

gta 6

[@mateturmainze8659]

​@@capolean2902 and the wicker 3

[@DirolXfresh-v6l]

100%

[@Cedisdead]

This Hogwarts game is really bad tho, you can tell that right?

[@bungiecrimes7247]

Idk rockstar be slipping up lately. A giant will eventually fall under its own weight.

[@candle2005]

Crazy how even 2023 games cant be properly compared to a 2018 game

[@GameLight]

Agree with you

[@GoodFishMan]

You say that when uncharted 4 came out around 2016

[@ggh7161]

Can't ask much from devs that made cars 3 before this

[@Reinhou]

At the same time for the dev of hogwarts its their first AAA game

[@TommyPrime4]

@@ggh7161 cars 3 was a masterpiece

[@QRcode02]

4:15 holy smokes, draw distance on rdr2 is just amazing

[@delta__404]

And we only get that to see only once in the whole story officially. Unless you're using mods to revisit

[@Chuchi_Gucci]

I never seen it before but now i noticed how clothes deformation from body moving in RDR at 2:23 Look at shoulders of Arthur when he swimming. Awesome.

[@MafJora]

rdr 2 has an awesome fire propogation mechanic, so comparison at 0:44 is incomplete, should've hit the grass or wood object to show a clear superiority of rdr 2

[@DaWootzi]

bro. u. know art. I've told this to some friends and they said that* I don't know shit*... but, broski... smalles things can change alot

[@arthurcallahan4735]

Arthur morgan be like: "Incindio" *throws dynamite into saloon*

[@GameLight]

😂😂😅

[@Nitrox_909]

more like bombardo

[@xxxSaiyan228]

Back then, the goal of making games was just to make something realistic by their standards Nova days, the goal of making games is to beat the realism of RDR2

[@DaWootzi]

true. yet nobody has surpass them

[@nuckerball1259]

@@DaWootzi gta 6 is the only contender lol

[@DaWootzi]

@@nuckerball1259 true lol

[@sidemissions4127]

You buy rdr2 you get all games

[@shambollock6861]

Rdr2 is just the far superior game

[@GameLight]

I agree with you, Rdr2 is an excellent game in every way, the game came out in 2018 even now in 2023 games cannot compare with RDR2

[@dokinstmynballensugje]

Precisely

[@ericleal157]

It's a far superior movie yes, a game though? with 20 hours of cut scenes and recycled mechanics? no

[@dokinstmynballensugje]

@@ericleal157 actually, the entire game contains 10 hours of cutscenes and a total of 40+ hours worth of actual gameplay, so, you're wrong.

[@ericleal157]

@@dokinstmynballensugje kzbin.info/www/bejne/jYTbm2SLhtOpeLc Moments where all you do is walk around and listen to dialogue don't exactly count as gameplay, so I count them as cutscenes, and even if your estimate was correct even commonly called interactive movies like god of war have 60 hours of gameplay and 6 of cutscenes, imagine what a "game" where 1/4 is totally non-interactive and the rest is mostly walking around the map and shooting with an auto-aim every now and then could be classified, it's close to Point and Clicks as Detroit become human, since throughout the game you use a maximum of 5 buttons.

[@the_black_leg_sanji2624]

Hei You can't compare between a game (HL) and and an art (RdR2)

[@xsite232]

Comparing any game to Red Dead Redemption 2 is just unfair in all way. 😂

[@brianbailey1681]

Rdr2 is literally the most detailed and perfect game in every way that ive ever seen, it puts many others to shame, dont know how GoW beat it for goty but even being 4 years or so old nothing compares really. Forbidden West and Ragnarok are pretty new and they still arent as good. Hogwarts legacy is still good…although it feels very unpolished and missed so many opportunities, would’ve been better as an MMO

[@winter2899]

Rdr2 was made with black magic or something I have a 1070 and I can run it at 60 fps on max graphics 1440p and its staggeringly beautiful

[@waduheklite3800]

Meanwhile 1080ti user crying due to unstable 60fps max graphics 1080p 🙄🙄🙄

[@hiktius2948]

@@waduheklite3800 atleast better than mine.

[@waduheklite3800]

@@hiktius2948 😬😬😬😬

[@waduheklite3800]

@@hiktius2948 u didn't understand my comment, when 1080ti can't handle at 1080p how can 1070 can handle at 1440p

[@hiktius2948]

@@waduheklite3800 that how it work i guess

[@Janquin-ie6vk]

Haven’t played either game, but I can totally agree that red dead redemption 2 was way better.

[@deanridley8]

Play it.

[@anonymous_dot_com2326]

Do yourself a favour and play RDR2 man.. but make sure you play other games on your list before RDR2, it might ruin gaming for you because of how good it is.

[@ericleal157]

unless you only play games to see realistic graphics then no, Hogwarts legacy at least is fun.

[@kuky4054]

@@ericleal157 but the game sucks in performance!, and i see a lot of people call it a next gen title but, i dont see a lot of difference vs a game of 2018! texture wins hogwarts, effects, physics, and all the rest wins RDR2

[@ericleal157]

@@kuky4054 yes, after all, like it or not red dead 2 is still red dead 2.

[@deswithahoodiegaming]

Rdr2 will always remains the best game I ever played , but for a Harry Potter fan , Hogwarts legacy has blown me away with everything inside the game is massive Story quest and side quest are amazing etc. But Rdr2 #1

[@Sfa_WarriorID]

4:41😂 Saw this glitch today😆

[@llalanll]

RDR2 is the proof that PS5 and SX are capable of so much more. Developers are just kind of mediocre

[@shatteredsentient5321]

I never played rd but I have a friend who let me play the first one a little on ps3 days. Sad ending too.

[@kkungkkung6013]

rdr2 wins, but hogwarts legacy is always a beautiful amusement park for my childhood self

[@ivsonpereiradasilva4157]

RDR 2 ♾

[@terabyte8141]

Don’t raven compare the two we all know who wins it’s RD2

[@DoctorCrowGimi..]

No other game can match Rdr2's Realism!

[@zhovany_k]

нужно было еще свет ночью сравнить.

[@przemekterlikowski1211]

Ciekawa która seria gier dorówna realizmem do rdr2. Obstawiam że najbliżej będzie gta 6 albo seria far cry?

[@axel8427]

Graphics of red dead redemption 2 looks UE5

[@GameLight]

Nobody has won RDR2 so far

[@tasidar3]

@@GameLight STALKER 2 maybe, but we will see. R* just makes the most beautiful and life like worlds like no other developers.

[@yetiigaminglive8402]

Rdr2 was ahead of its time like gta5

[@mersad82]

It is clear that the development team of Hogwarts Legacy has worked hard for this game, but not as much as Red Dead 2. Rockstar Games took eight or nine years to develop Red Dead 2, and most importantly, no studio can compete with Rockstar Games. No, Rockstar Games is an expert in creating masterpieces. I do not recommend any studio to compete with Rockstar Games because it is definitely a loser.😉

[@zvezdazvijezda3594]

Both games are miles and miles better than Cyberpunk

[@raptorOP23]

RDR2 is something else

[@kayesahmedT]

Hogwarts Legacy is a good game there is no doubt about that but RDR2 is Masterpiece.

[@Sfa_WarriorID]

5:17 🤣🤣🤣

[@Charsson]

En animales te faltaron los famosos testículos cambiantes según clima de los caballo en RDR2

[@dingakakinaja3893]

No one can beat rdr2 no one maybe rdr3

[@Sirdecam]

Avada kadavera in rdr2 5:36😂

[@civilengineer6779]

RDR 2 - игра, опередившая время, до сих пор образец для подражания. Лично для меня сюжет скучноват и затянут, но техническое исполнение игры - просто космос, до которого еще ни одна игра не дотянулась даже близко.

[@3d-281]

Сюжет тоже хороший, просто темп повествования такой.

[@LahoriGamerYT007]

Red dead redemption 2 masterpiece

[@comedyvadik3006]

Rockstar games the best always

[@perfectedperfection1964]

Not even close. Rdr it’s a masterpiece!

[@Kfknrjtjfuifjfjfjfnnthtufuxu]

Я в день выхода сразу же купил рдр2 отыграл 30 минут и забросил игру и теперь думаю может спустя годы снова скачать и попробовать пройти)

[@nickxenon9288]

Купил игру в день выхода. И прошел спустя два года только.

[@АДВИС]

Ths games are completely different! RDR2 has its own beautiful, special atmosphere

[@the-best_lion9832]

El RDR2 para ser de PS4 sin tener versión de PS5 es una joya, lastima que Rockstar lo a dejado de lado

[@shahbazawais7793]

why all people saying rdr2 . they are seeing graphics only but its gameplay is so booring.open world is also booring there is few things to do and gameplay is too slow.please stop saying rdr2 rdr2 rdr2 try other games far cry 6 graphics are also realastic .

[@Evil_]

It's don't boring, it's slowly and we love it's slow gameplay

[@srmillar2268]

RDR 2 is the GAME of the CENTURY

[@Nitrox_909]

Can't wait for Witcher 3 stans to join the comment section

[@dagger_games101]

Hogwarts legacy has no reapect for physic details.. It's just based on magic stuff

[@adriansamuel55yearsago13]

Witcher 3, Hogwarts Legacy and Hogwarts Legacy are masterpieces game

[@nelsonabreu5963]

What?

[@GameLight]

@@nelsonabreu5963 I think he meant RDR2, sometimes we all make mistakes

[@nelsonabreu5963]

Ahhhh I see

[@Cedisdead]

Calling Hogwarts a masterpiece, omg I'm crying 😂

[@GoodStories71]

@@GameLight hahah nice joke 😂

[@simracer792]

RDR2 should be compare with Real Life

[@mr.keshyou3224]

RDR 2 the best

[@priyadarshini.01]

no one can beat rockstar

[@skyhigh7855]

Stop comparing RDR2 to other games. Rockstar is a major power in AAA games so your comparing a game that has been proven to work and a game rockstar knows ppl are going to play vs a new idea for a game that could flop so yes RDR2 is gonna look better in every way because of a budget 2 times bigger then Hogwarts smh

[@GameLight]

Don’t be negative friend. Videos are created mainly for entertainment purposes, and comparing games is the best way to get acquainted with the game, because it is difficult to convey the details of the game through the trailer and gameplay. I agree Rdr2 is at the highest level, and the budget is big, but the game was released in 2018, new engines are coming out, the technology is developing. I hope I was able to convince you.

[@euricoaw1535]

imagine GTA 6, even today RDR 2 is the king of Open world game

[@GameLight]

I think GTA 6 will definitely hold the lead until a new game from Rockstar comes out

[@noyou1933]

no game beats rdr2

[@ABO_GKM]

Rockstar for ever

[@iszntness]

Rdr2 solos

[@happybuggy1582]

One is R rated one isn’t

[@Кекшрек-ч7ю]

Hogwarts-сырой ширпотреб! Это как сравнивать телегу запряженную козлами и Lamborghini

[@rusan5229]

Rdr2 после стольких лет показывает великолепную,скропулёзно проработанную графику не достижимую современным играм.

[@vul7ureftw]

Отдаю предпочтение rdr2, визуально вообще не уступает и отлично оптимизирована, в отличии от hogwarts

[@LW_dm]

rdr top1

[@byrger2010]

Да всё круто выглядит в rdr2, только эта скучная, унылая игра, при всём своём великолепии... С дэбильной системой сохранений...

[@nosorock2481]

Нет Хогвартс конечно неплох, но до рокзвёзд им далеко)

[@anton-m8d]

50/50

[@ДмитрийСафонов-м4ш]

Ясно одно,оптимизация херовая и там и там!

[@LeGrandBlondRF]

Когда 60 фпс привезут в рдр2

[@crus9792]

хогвартс - мертвая игра, с ужасной графикой, не понимаю, чего это она многим нравится... хотя и самому фильмы нравятся

[@cinesesorridente1133]

Hogwars win

[@insanesociety4]

Lmao rdr2 fanboys. 😂 Over rated game.

[@kjhuncho4631]

Desperate for attention ain’t ya

[@insanesociety4]

@@kjhuncho4631 yes

[@QRcode02]

Broke mf

[@mesh8349]

@@insanesociety4 At least he’s honest

[@SAHILKHAN-mp6kc]

Eeeesy boah A brain is precious thing to looose

[@Jumbo_bimbo]

Rdr2 ist the best open world this magic shit can not beat the magic western world

[@STRIKEking228]

Почему у тебя все видео с задержкой звука

[@GameLight]

Вроде исправил, завтра публикую новое видео, если не трудно будет тебе дружище посмотришь и скажешь с задержкой или нет. (Translated)

[@2fisse]

Is this hogwarts gameplay from ps5?

[@Cinedragon]

Ever since playing RDR2, no other open world game has managed to impress me as much as that game did.

[@TomCLancyTM]

Same here. I always compare each open world with RDR2

[@zicojanis3237]

yep. after playing that game. there is no other game that ever make me immerse like rdr2 did. its a blessed and a curse tbh

[@georgeaskeladd742]

Rdr2 is truly a masterpiece. I love hogwarts legacy but nothing can beat rdr2. It's just perfect. It looks so good and yet I can run it on ultra with 60fps on my not so new pc while im stuck with 25fps on low in hogwarts legacy. Rdr2 is perfectly optimized and literally the best looking game with probably also the best physics. Don't even know in which aspect it is not the best

[@godzillazfriction]

*gawk *gawk I love you rockstar

[@thegreatbigraggedrock]

@@godzillazfrictionarthur (with TB) solos your favourite character no diff 😹 pack it up and move kid

[@carbon5363]

Swimmimg after chapter 6

[@Concise_Parakeet]

​@@thegreatbigraggedrock Omg--- That's so true. 😭

[@Concise_Parakeet]

Facts

[@ankushsharma-cz3dd]

Rdr2 is clear winner

[@SinnerTrent]

No comparison rdr2 always wins

[@ed-zn7272]

4:35 wait, that really happens in the movies, it's a detail

[@GameLight]

There are no bugs and glitches in Hogwarts Legacy, it's all magic. 🤣

[@KarlDjentis]

RDR 2 это не игра, это Искусство!

[@GoodStories71]

Невероятно, никто не смог превзойти эту игру с 2018 года

[@blackmane1999]

My thoughts: Rdr2 is something you would want to be in Hogwarts Legacy is something you would want to play

[@joelstockwell4183]

Red dead is better then any game to date 👍🏻

[@BBurakYildiz]

About physics or details no game has chance against rdr2

[@X_Chris23]

Funny how I can run RDR 2 max settings no lag, but seems to struggle with Hogwarts Legacy 😂

[@KHUZ_98]

What a stupid comparison !!😅

[@ayoubsbaihi7239]

The graphics and realism of this game are stunning. The lighting, shadows, textures, and animations are all top-notch.

[@bartibartol2349]

Hogwarts Legacy is an excellent game, but it cannot be compared to a masterpiece like RDR2

[@IseVable]

Rdr2 is a game that has left impressions for a lifetime. No one will make the game better even in 10 years

[@DirolXfresh-v6l]

некоторыми сравнениями кажется что это одна игра в разных локациях) правда разница между ними 5 лет)))))))

[@GoodStories71]

Только сам Рокстар может сделать игру, которая превзойдет свое же детище

[@waseem8830]

I can't blame hogwars lagacy, because Rockstar Games are unbeatable. 😕 Waiting for GTA VI

[@FanOfKittens]

by the way, there are about 200 species of animals in rdr 2

[@Forest762]

Cap

[@Monkeyamingus777]

​@@Forest762there's 234 animals in the game bro has not played Red Dead

[@JoachimBraun1981]

Rdr 2 is still a better Game ! Hogwars Legacy is very bad in my opinion !

[@danykwood]

Почему никто не говорит, что в хогвартс Легаси нельзя сидеть? Банально нельзя сесть на стул или кровать. Это прямо таки убивает

[@GoodStories71]

Некоторые не заморачиваются над такими, казалось бы, мелочами. Мне кажется, такие механики вырезают/не делают из-за того, что мало игроков просто напросто эту механику используют. Но иногда ведь так хочется присесть и подумать о бытности происходящего. РДР тем и прекрасен, что сделано до мелочей практически все.

[@danykwood]

@@GoodStories71 полностью согласен. Меня прямо таки разочаровало, что я не смог сесть за общий стол в столовой(

[@zoubeirfaouzi149]

If Rockstar Games made Hogwarts, pfff let's just stop here.

[@pro100_dima]

Наверное только ребенок не заметит что рдм 2 это игра про детали

[@axel8427]

I don't want to buy Hogwarts legacy after I watch it.🤣 Im happy to my ps4 with red dead redemption 2

[@Agente-tm2mi]

Red dead 2>>>>>>>

[@DaWootzi]

RDR2 wow. an amazing game.

[@RyanRusin]

The worlds of the recent AC games and Far Cry 5 are both better than Hogwarts Legacy. Still don’t come close to Red Dead, but definitely superior to Hogwarts. The game just feels absolutely dulled down. NPCs react to nothing

[@eonunas4641]

Eu acho q eles focaram em deixar o Hogwarts legacy um jogo mais aconchegante, principalmente dentro do castelo

[@TayRich93]

Honestly being on a level to be compared to a gem like red dead 2 is great! Fr tho 🔥both games are on my all time favorites list

[@Agent0154]

not fair of a comparison rdr2 is too good in terms of details

[@swegast]

Проходняк VS Шедевр Хм... Кто же победит!...