Hogwarts Legacy vs. Red Dead Redemption 2 Comparison (Physics and Details)

[@anotherweasley]

I love both of these games, and this comparison is not meant to determine which one is better or worse. Both games are incredible in their own right, and each has its own unique strengths and weaknesses.

[@SacredPDK]

rdr2 is still better in every aspect

[@Mirinovic]

Well minus wizard estetic, Hogwarts colothing loooks a like one in RDR2 sinc bouth games take place on colose of 19th century

[@mostarticaltravels6532]

@@SacredPDK clown fan alert.

[@jenniferkeates]

@@mostarticaltravels6532 I'm inclined to agree with @PDK here. Hogwarts RPG elements is like a puddle, choices don't really matter. RDR2 made a much more engaging world where NPCs react alot more to what you do.

[@JarringSteak]

@@jenniferkeates @J Gates True! And every NPC has a daily rutine! The NPCs eat realistically, but it's enough to think about the shirking horse balls, but don't worry, I didn't discover it, but that's the craziest detail ever. The most realistic game and the best story ever!

[@Biscit29]

Amazing comparison! I wish Hogwarts Legacy was like rdr2 in all these ways, especially the npcs. I hope atleast gta 6 will be similar or better than red dead like this

[@jomeugene8492]

Rockstar is just way too advanced in the open world genre and well polished in their game mechanics. Intricate attention to detail is just simply astounding. Avalanche studios is incredible though, they made a topnotch game on their first attempt in the open world genre.

[@secondchance6603]

"they made a topnotch game on their first attempt in the open world genre." Pretty much sums it up right there.

[@AmandaSchnaare]

RDR2 was way ahead of it's time and can't wait to see what RDR3 has in store for us in the next few years. However.. HL is equally as beautiful in it's own way. Both are amazing games and have so much more potential in their futures!

[@heebiejeebies9888]

It won't be here for at least another 8 years.

[@Nitrox_909]

​@@heebiejeebies9888 atleast it's confirmed

[@emmastone8068]

5:43 poor guy goes through the window lmao

[@flouserschird]

Reminder it’s all about money. Hogwarts Legacy is a 150 Million dollar budget, while Red Dead Redemption 2 is a 540 Million budget game…🤠

[@shatteredsentient5321]

540m damn.

[@JarringSteak]

It's not ALL about the money, it takes a lot of talented programmers, actors, artists, screenwriters, musicians, and directors to create a masterpiece like RDR2.

[@flouserschird]

@@JarringSteak with moneyyy.. yes.

[@itsjustchelsea838]

Money also = time. RDR 2 was in development for like 8 years.

[@okaybones]

⁠@@JarringSteak who you have to pay 💀

[@samiad4730]

Hogwarts Legacy Made 1 Billion As Red Dead 2 Made 725 million but red dead still solo's

[@ETGamer-yl6dm]

So why did you just compare that irrelevant difference

[@badbunny9116]

I feel like the water in HL is like mud based on how you swim. The thing is HL is developed as if i were a book or a movie so the interactions would be limited and with that thought, it is fine.

[@noobystyles]

you can put everything in hogwats as majic

[@jimbomanivanh9697]

I played both and loved them both

[@goldbrickstudios6903]

Hopefully HWL will get to make some updates. Great game, but I wish it was like rdr2.

[@michaeld8280]

They are set around the same time too lol

[@FantasyNero]

Do you make the same as ENXGMA Channel?

[@fabianoperes2155]

0:55 "Visibly wet" was way too strong. If you didn't compare I would barely notice. Opposite to RDR2 which does a MUCH BETTER JOB at this.

[@rochelimit55555]

It’s differences between wizardkind and muggles

[@TheGlest]

2018 game vs 2023 game

[@rashmir1246]

Imagine a 2018 game defeats a 2023 game wow

[@ramansharif2765]

Nothing can be compared to RDR2

[@nitinmann]

Red dead is gem you can't even compare that that took 8 years of work where as Hogwarts legacy is kid but alltho nice video good work

[@anaghbasak]

Arthur smokes a lot bro.

[@gamingolicios4123]

You are comparing GOD(RDR2) with a DemiGod(HL).. God will always win

[@axel8427]

Imagine red dead redemption 2 is ps4 games too😎

[@Whocares158]

Ugh.. I hate it when people compare games. I'm a fan of both Ip's and not once did I ever compare the two. It's unfair to compare games from different companies.

[@Shihimase]

No offence, but this is like comparing apples and oranges. 😂

[@EziosBladez]

Red dead will for a long time always be the better game in all aspects.

[@ariflukmansyah781]

i need RDR3 😋

[@makasi60]

cool and when you eat in rdr2 you eat realy

[@bbokari9880]

Well it isn't a survival game like rdr

[@andreweades6248]

RDR is not a survival game.... It's literally just cowboy GTA...

[@danishchawla690]

@@andreweades6248 you haven't play rdr 2, have you?

[@christiansanchez7448]

i will never understand people who make these kind of comparisons lol