Horizon Forbidden West vs The Last of Us Part 2 - Details (Who Does it Best?)

[@oKnightzo]

Are there any other games you'd like to see me compare? If so, comment which ones! :) This video took way more time and effort than I thought it would, so I hope you at least enjoy it! 😅

[@thegamingking1972]

Horizon forbidden West is an incredibly detailed game makes sense it took so much time

[@eddiephoenix9698]

thank you for your effort! this was quite insightful! regardless of Console Gen or Engine, it really shows that devs really have to consider how they spend their time developing their game, some details might need to be dumbed down and other´s can be more focused on. I really admire both works and let´s me think, how far we´ve come and what future gaming might bring.

[@gusmagnusmcmanus]

Let’s do the usual vdos rather than comparing games from different generation.

[@mmidas580]

You should do HFW vs RDR2

[@muhdfarezwan2027]

Where is part 1

[@kaifarkas8837]

These two games are 2 years apart and it shows a little, but both are absolutely breath-taking and I am happy that all the artists and designers that worked on these games get to show their best work.

[@magnusalexander2965]

They're also two different generations. I'm still on a PS4 Pro and my version of Horizon does not look like that

[@JesusGonzalez-te8xg]

The last of us 2 is the full power of ps4

[@345funnyboy]

@@JesusGonzalez-te8xg horizon looks better though and was also primarily developed for ps4, literally all the improvements in this video are available on the ps4 version of the game with the sole exception being the peach fuzz on aloys face

[@jp_enduresurvive7374]

@@Beadlesstorh Get. Over. It. It's been almost 2 years.

[@itriyum]

@@Beadlesstorh You stuck in 2020 or sum? Nobody cares now, move on🤡

[@bretwilliams249]

I love that TLOU2 is still being used in comparisons with next gen games. Shows how talented Naughty Dog is, and good blown away we'll likely be my their next AAA title at the end of this gen.

[@TheRealRaihan]

TLOU2 is also a next gen game. It received a free PS5 upgrade several months back

[@craigscraig4000]

@@TheRealRaihan ps4 games upgraded to ps5 do not look as good as games developed specifically for the ps5

[@345funnyboy]

Horizon is not a next gen title is cross gen just like tlou 2 and not only it looks better on ps4 than tlou it’s also an open world game

[@345funnyboy]

Horizon was literally developed mostly for ps4 and the biggest improvement on the ps5 is the higher resolution, performance mode and the extra detail on the textures like the peach fuzz on aloys face

[@Jotevil]

@@craigscraig4000 Horizon is not new generation, it's crossgen.

[@eddiephoenix9698]

1:15 when the TLOU music starts, it immediately hits right in the feelings. Both are fantastic games!

[@timsonss]

Horizon main theme gets you right in the feels as well, but TLOU not only gets you right in the feels, but compresses them and puts them into an isolator, and if you want to feel something back again you must get those compressed feels out somehow. (I dont know if it was clear, but TLOU puts me in a state where its really hard to get back into your normal state once you hear the music)

[@eliasbonafe9236]

It's so powerful that just listening at three notes of the TLOU2's music after so much time, I immediately felt a fraction of the emotion I felt more than a year ago, and it really hitted in the feelings

[@py4nk417]

@@timsonss Same man just same

[@elliesfingersatthebottomof5887]

@@eliasbonafe9236 yes exactly! gustavo santaolalla is a master of his work, its incredible how only one second of a song can make you feel so much

[@kpo1233]

Tlous 2 isnt a fantastic game

[@cinematicgoodness7325]

While Forbidden West is a technologically a bit more immaculate than The Last of Us Part II which is also a bit more impressive than the former, the fact that they are both so technologically advanced in various ways is just incredible. The teams working on these games deserve every bit of praise.

[@lilrizq]

There like neck and neck when it comes to the small details, some things HFW does better, some things TLOU 2 do better.

[@jieqin7311]

But don’t forget TLOU2 is a PS4 game. With PS5’s power, the next TLOU will blow the completion out of water.

[@Thehumboldtvlogger]

Just wait for tlou part 3 and burning shores

[@timsonss]

Looking at Horizon's visuals just fills me with motivation to become an environment artist even more! Something to look up to those two games

[@NanocDark99]

U want become an inviroment artist for games, movies or real life projects?

[@dont5014]

WOWW YOU DON'T READ MY PROFILE PICTURE 😶😶❌❌

[@midhunmathew6121]

@@dont5014 I wont

[@hirobot3965]

Yup. It's the key difference between these two games.

[@timsonss]

@@NanocDark99 games

[@-hurtycann-1706]

Horizon 2 is just insane, Guerilla and Naughty Dogs are amazing. Can't wait to see TLOU 3 !

[@Lucasssssssss_]

That's gonna be the Best Game of the world LOLLK

[@coops1992]

RDR3 gonna kill both of them

[@BesserAlsDuInAllem]

Rdr is to boring , it s so realistic but its boring because its slow

[@Kazuma0305]

I hope TLOU 3 never sees the light of day

[@Southpaw22]

I hope TLOU3 sees the light of the day. And I hope it's the next game they're planning to release. People who could not appreciate the amazing storytelling and mindblowing game mechanics of the second game are just hypocrites and little crybabies. It felt real, all the emotions, expressions of the characters, physics. It just had to grab you into the world. Can't forget about the section where you're in the office with the stalkers. I've never had chills in a game before, but this..

[@karlabravo8351]

I love the detail that Ellie's breathing changes depending on whether she's tired from running, hurt or relaxed. I love both games, but I think TLOUII is way more polished on character details and reactions.

[@abellau4105]

HFW has those animations as well.

[@karlabravo8351]

@@abellau4105 not as detailed. Horizon has good animations. But for example in TLOU, sound design makes you kinda able to feel Ellie's breathing and heartbeat. It's different. There's a video on YT about the contextual animations and breathing system from the developers of TLOU2.

[@dont5014]

WOWW YOU DON'T READ MY PROFILE PICTURE

[@giancarloamc]

@@karlabravo8351 that might be so, but horizon is a game several times bigger that TLOU

[@karlabravo8351]

@@giancarloamc without a doubt. But in the mechanics for the characters and animations / reactions and contextual animations Naughty Dog really comes on top. Still Horizon is a pretty good second place and a massive improvement from HZD.

[@user-dg5vx8li8f]

Wow, can't believe how much detail is in Horizon and on top of that it's a huge open world

[@345funnyboy]

Ikr? And it looks this good on ps4 too

[@dont5014]

WOWW YOU DON'T READ MY PROFILE PICTURE

[@SL4PSH0CK]

well said, might be the only comment who is aware the Forbidden West is an open world getting comapred to a concise linear title

[@jamesmiles3341]

@@SL4PSH0CK well it’s fair considering how empty the "open world" of hfw is lmao

[@SL4PSH0CK]

@@jamesmiles3341 i lol'd, good one

[@okaybutwhythough7456]

HFW has surprisingly a lot more *fidelity* even though it's much larger in scale, but TLOU has more artist *polish* because it's smaller.

[@kirbz7395]

Appreciate the time it took just to do the comparison knightz , some of us don't always see what's right in front of us particularly in video games. developers put a lot of thought into making something that is so immersive we miss the little things when playing, great work highlighting them looking forward to seeing more. 👍

[@jdmlove4986]

I honestly prefer Horizon over TLOU, but in terms of small details like that Naughty Dog absolutely killed it with TLOU 2

[@brunotechinvest]

Open world vs linear game, bro.

[@pw9600]

@@brunotechinvest And 2 years apart, and Horizon is created for PS5 as TLOU2 is created on PS4. So makes sense that Horizon looks sharper and has higher resolution textures. Both games look amazing though...

[@flockelocke2297]

@@pw9600 Horizon FW is unrealistic colorful and people can say it's more beautiful because of the colors and pretty views but it does not have more detail and has much copy paste stuff. Same looking camps, caves and cauldrons everywhere while the Last of Us 2 has unique and different looking locations, buildings and is more realistic. Horizon has higher res textures and stuff but the E3 2018 Last of us 2 Demo stomps almost everything out there still in 2022. So I really hope for a PS5 version of Part 2 and can't wait for the Part 1 Remake.

[@-tcbms-8849]

@@flockelocke2297 either you haven’t played forbidden west or you just didn’t pay attention at all

[@TheRealAdachi]

@@pw9600hfw is on ps4 as well so not made exclusively for ps5

[@echo2413]

regardless of how you feel about TLOU 2, the attention to detail and just overall detail will not be surpassed for a while.

[@ahmad_irf42]

rdr2

[@oKnightzo]

Has some of the most impressive details to ever be seen in a game, Naughty Dog did a brilliant job!

[@thegamingking1972]

@@ahmad_irf42 Whoops looks like people forgot who'se the king here

[@Besnada]

People basically are angry at the people responsible with the story. Everything else, as far as I know, deserves only praise.

[@echo2413]

@@oKnightzo agreed!

[@aloyjoestar5757]

8:53 Storm, Great comparison btw love how you presented it, I know tlou2 was 2 years ago but HFW is open world and the map is insanely huge, to have these graphics and details it’s still insane.

[@jammerc64]

People kinda wrongly assume that if game is open world, it's way more work to code individual bahaviours, physics, etc. These mechanics are usually totally independent of the rest and might work in game of any scale/scope. It's not that you script it individually for every single object ;)

[@thetruthfrmtx]

Great comparison. With your attention to get detail, we were able to see how well talented both studios are.

[@heir2n018]

TLOU2 is a technical masterpiece in both gameplay details, Visuals, and atmosphere, regardless of how the fan base bitches about it its still an incredible game

[@netrunner36]

Been two years already and no game hooked me as much as this one. Naughtydog are on a whole new level.

[@netrunner36]

@@onma07ksa if your whole argument is based around the notion of "wokeness" you lose any credibility.

[@Pointman11111]

@@onma07ksa Maybe you're right, does that make everything wrong what the original comment said?

[@jaaaaaaaaaaaaaay]

@@onma07ksa A girl wanting to be a boy is barely important in the story, its just part of his character. Abbys muscles arent even that big, shes just tall. Ellie being gay was revealed in the first game. Your argument means nothing

[@pedrocapelari5373]

@@onma07ksa The game don't even try to push an agenda, only in the 2nd time playing I get that Lev was gay or whatever, it's so subtle. TLOU2 does something that i never had before with a game, it makes us see both sides of the story, abby is not bad, i would do the same if someone killed my father, who is about to discover the cure of everything is happening! the game often left me literally shaking, not with fear, but with the way the narrative made me complicit in events. The characters' facial expressions are so good and convincing that I felt how brutal the post-apocalyptic world is. The game doesn’t let us feel the satisfaction of revenge on both sides (ellie and abby) we see that they are destroyed by their seek for revenge, both characters lose everything, and I thought it was phenomenal how the world also destroys itself around the characters while the evolution story of the game, (bad weather that intensifies all around) for me the plot was equally deep, dense and audacious, telling a different and realistic story of the world, of how we can not be the protagonists / good guys.

[@bryanhauser2444]

I appreciate you only showing standard areas in Horizon, been trying to avoid anything before I actually play it so this is the first I’m seeing the game for the most part haha the eye ball comparison makes me feel like Horizon looks better, but Last of Us has those extra details, and the scene shooting arrows into the water with Ellie looks so good. The water is incredibly realistic.

[@norvinzor]

Aloy “dies” and all this Horizon stuff is just a dream and Aloy wakes up in modern day America 2022. 🤷🏻‍♂️ #forbidenwestspoiler

[@bryanhauser2444]

@@norvinzor What a twist!

[@ibrahimsaba1592]

Interaction featuring should be way more existing and active in hfw

[@anythinghead4309]

@@norvinzor lol cap

[@345funnyboy]

Lol not only is horizon more detailed (like how the arrows land realistically or the snow looks decent) red dead 2 has a lot more impressive details than tlou2 (or even horizon for that matter) and is also a last gen game and even an open world at that, last of us 2 is way overrated like not only red dead 2 looks way better it also does the whole revenge is fool’s game plot far better without having to resort to shock value to be memorable

[@Rockport1911]

Both games have lots of details, but TLOU2 per design is more realistic and details are more meaningful. Also even after 2 years new details can be found in TLOU2 that can fill hours long videos...

[@dont5014]

WOWW YOU DON'T READ MY PROFILE PICTURE 😶😶❌❌

[@ellie4601]

HZD/HFW hair always makes me laugh because it has a mind of it's own... even when Aloy is standing still, it's moving like she was walking

[@admilz]

HFW looks more beautiful and breathtaking but TLOU2 looks more realistic and detailed

[@ETGamer-yl6dm]

Not more detailed, did you look at the face comparison 😂

[@JackC11111]

In Horizon the whole planet was reduced to barren rock and then terraformed by an artificial intelligence over hundreds of years so that's why it looks different and not realistic.

[@runthejudes]

they're both groundbreaking, phenomenal experiences that i'm truly glad to be alive in this period of time to experience

[@stitch1088]

What I love most about TLoU 2 (graphics -wise) is how human the characters' looks and expressions are - which is a testament to both how talented the cast are as well as how devoted and skilled the devs are. Also the lines during the cutscenes and small talks during the gameplay feel so natural that its almost like watching real people interact in real life

[@lkhasumberel69]

man, i love watching your contents. they're pretty entertaining and has a good quality. goodluck mate!

[@oKnightzo]

Thanks dude!

[@Pointman11111]

While i like HFWs hair physics more i think TLOU 2s hair behaves more realistic. But both games have a crazy amount of Detail GG and Naughty Dog are top tier developers. But for some reason Finger nails and weapon models look weird and low res sometimes in HFW. Arkham Knight from 2015 looks much better in this case. Another top tier developer for graphics, details, physics, destruction and character models, Rocksteady studios. I would like to see it in comparison to sonys games. Great comparison, only watched it halfway through bc i havent reached the coast yet in HFW

[@themoviefan9990]

Hfw hair moves like a snake for some reason

[@gilbearth17]

I agree. I find it funny when Aloy is inside a cave or a building but her hair is still flowing madly.

[@timsonss]

Every developer should look up to TLOU PART II in terms of technical achievements. The very existence of this piece of software on PS4 is mind-blowing. Stable 30 FPS, in addition to amount of interactions and the complexity of animations and physics, then we have stunning visuals by which Naughty Dog set the benchmark for themselves to beat yet again. Just how they set the benchmark back in 2013. While Horizon does look visually better, which is understandable, since both games have 2 years between them, in most tech aspects TLOU gets the upper hand, however credit is due Guerilla made it look the best they could have on PS4 as well.

[@mrmoro11tv]

Don't forget these two different types of games, open world games and linear games.

[@broblowski]

*Every developer should look up to Red Dead Redemption 2 in terms is of technical achievements.

[@lilcorduroy4101]

@@broblowski imagine having different dialogue with people depending on the time of day you speak to them, only rdr2

[@idestructiiion974]

Spiderman has it when the player is flying and when the player is just walking

[@hurbman1736]

@@broblowski Rdr2 is an amazing game. But i refuse to believe today's Rockstar is anything devs should look up to.

[@evgenyyurichev]

Great job, about arrows on trees - in HFW - you break arrows when go near them and broken parts still be on tree.

[@thegamingking1972]

Wondering how intense of a 'Storm' God of war ragnarok will bring!!

[@oKnightzo]

Can't wait to find out! ⛈️ Thanks for watching! 👑

[@moabd7575]

it will be mostly the same as gow 4

[@jaaaaaaaaaaaaaay]

@@moabd7575 yeah they look pretty similar tbh

[@Leonardo_Chiti]

I am so happy to see in the comments so many compliments to The last of us 2 (I love this community), It is one of the most beautiful and detailed games I have ever played, it will remain in my heart for a lifetime. I'm really sorry for anyone who says it sucks just because the plot doesn't go the way they wanted (kids). But I am sure that in time it will be remembered by all as a majestic game.

[@hurbman1736]

Its definitely the type of the game that gets better over time. Just wait a few years and guess what, a lot more people will be praising it.

[@uItra.]

"kids" mfw people cant respect other opinions

[@thebatmanofneo-gotham5667]

@@uItra. Yeah, tbh, that's the one part of comment that stuck out as odd. I mean, I myself do strongly disagree with people's negative views on the game's story, but I wouldn't call them kids just because I don't agree with their opinion.

[@ChorfTV]

@@thebatmanofneo-gotham5667 That's the "wholesome" tlou2 community for you. Sure there's a lot of great people, but there's also a lot of people that think the game is the greatest thing since sliced bread and any opposing opinion is seen as some sort of an attack.

[@thebatmanofneo-gotham5667]

@@ChorfTV Yeah, unfortunately, a lot of communities are like that. I do my best to not be judgemental of anyone who thinks differently. If they don't like game, then they don't like the game. That simple.

[@thekingjulianz]

You didn't show it but the snow is melting with the blood in TLOU Great work by the way

[@oKnightzo]

Thanks, I did think about that one but I'm even sure if there is any blood in HFW, oddly enough

[@345funnyboy]

@@oKnightzo There’s no blood in HFW cause it’s rated T unlike tlou which is rated M

[@harishwark8373]

4:52 this game has arows only as a part but arrows picking are in next level

[@dlbutters7164]

You should compare with both running on the OG PS4 though, since both run on it and TLoU2 came out first and only on the PS4.

[@345funnyboy]

Horizon literally looks the exact same on ps4 the only differences are that it’s 1080p @ 30fps and aloys face doesn’t have the peach fuzz

[@Jotevil]

@@345funnyboy No man, I've played and it changes a lot, on ps4 tlou2 wins easily.

[@s3rv3r3rror8]

@@345funnyboy I guess you don't own a ps5?

[@goro_majima98]

@@Jotevil same payed on the Ps4 feels completely different

[@afibuffygirl]

Ya this is tough. You are comparing a game that are a couple years apart and on 2 different systems. Then you have art direction, purpose of mechanics, what is actually realistic and what people think is realistic, short hair vs long hair etc. To me, it's not really a good comparison but that being said,both of them are absolutely stunning and they are some examples of good developers putting the time and effort into small details when a lot of video game companies don't do. I always appreciate when they do this, little details matter

[@rahindawjee7616]

Now imagine a Naughty Dog game made for PS5. Can't wait to see what they do.

[@Savx323]

There the uncharted 4 remastered for ps5 and it’s incredible

[@thegamer6872]

@@Savx323 still its just mainly an fps boost.

[@Savx323]

@@thegamer6872 yea i know but still really good

[@PonTran194]

but tbh, HFW has impressive interactive but very inconsistent too. Some arrows flow on water surface in some major areas but not in some smaller areas, even some arrows dissappear immediately on the ground or wet surface. Some blasts can interact with foliage in one region (i don't remember where but it has the same foliage in HZD) but most other big region, the foliage didn't react with the blast at all. In that terms of details, stable interaction across the board and the smooth control with great momentium from climbing, jumping, running, taking items and even combat variety animations. The Last of Us Part 2 still the king of all PS exclusive games. I still very impress by the details animation and physic from Naughty Dog's engine. Edit: in TloUp2, when you throw a fire bomb into the snow, you can see the snow slowly deform by the heat. The blood also cause a deformation on snow too. While in HFW, you can try to shot a bomb and it didn't affect at all to snow ( just only had a dirt), but weird thing is... in HZD frozen Wilds dlc region, the blast can deform snow. Edit 2: after the latest update patch of HFW, now most of the foliage react to the blast from your weapons (bombs, spear, etc.)

[@alphaomega887654321]

Graphic is definitive better in horizon ... but the detailes are clearly better in tlou2 but it makes sense. An open world game with all detailes is sheer inpossible or they would need 10+years.

[@PonTran194]

@@alphaomega887654321 yeah, but there are something that bug me that some of the things I mentioned was already has in the HZD such as the blast from bomb weapons can effect on foliages and deform snow. But it is not improved and expanded and even lack of that in HFW. I don't want to compare to TW3 or RDR2 in terms of interactive details (this one is really the biggest game I don't want to compare to any openworld games because the human resources are the biggest so the difference will be the most clearly in details). But overall, HFW is still one of the best visuals out there yet.

[@alphaomega887654321]

@@PonTran194 tw3 would definitive lose but rdr2 would definitve win ;)

[@therealone_20]

I agree. Tlou2 is the king of details.

[@therealone_20]

@Carlos Valverde tf? You got something to say?

[@thegamingking1972]

Aesthetically, horizon forbidden West looks incredible!

[@Egenix52]

This video is very funny because I remember watching an interview of both game directors and Naughty Dog's director went : "That thing with the grass [in Horizon], it's the new standard for our next games"

[@The_Story_Of_Us]

Here’s what I will say, is that The Last Of Us 2 had a release that was vastly more polished than Forbidden West. When I first played this game on launch day back in 2020, I had a near ZERO BUG experience. Seriously, just ONE instance where a low-res texture of a door didn’t update in time. This game on PS4 Pro was littered with glitches and bugs, dozens, ranging from small to fucking huge, stuff that they didn’t even address from the first game, like how in a lot of instances, the audio balancing is total dogshit, with Ashly Burch’s voice lines being muffled to the point of inaudibility from background noise, often times as an obvious product of them literally being out into the game at vastly different volumes and then being totally drowned out by utterly imbalanced background noise. None of that in The Last Of Us: Part II. It was polished to damn near perfection.

[@ezustnyil8414]

interesting, I'm playing HFW in PS5 now, and no bug or glitch so far. Just one time one of the enemy somehow spawned underground, but it didnt cut me away from finishing the mission, and I could kill it. The Audio is perfectly okay, character has two voices as I hear, an inner, thinking style, it is generally harder to hear, but not a problem at all, and the usual conversation, it is louder. The voice acting is also great. However, I didnt play Last of Us, so I dont know about its physics, but in HZD and HFW it is a masterpiece, flying, overriding machines and the static and passive objects are also part of the game mechanics... The climbing and the use of various equipment is also done well, like the ropecaster. And climbing is in the game mechanics, you can almost climb anywhere, not just where the mission is.

[@vallykoool]

@@ezustnyil8414 you should try tlou2 and its ok if u dont handle the story and the game is really cheap now

[@mikaelandersson7463]

'Storm' This is amazing and good job! Keep it up with the good work!

[@butterflybrain100]

Fantastic Games Indeed! LastOfUs2 was way ahead of other games from gameplay, to environment details, and faces. Still one of the best looking games in my memory. HorizonForbiddenWest is stunning and you can see the improvment of PS5, snow, underwater and forests are crazy to expolre! Both not perfect but it comes all together very well, so it almost feels real.

[@alphaomega887654321]

Gameplay bahahhahaha xD chil bro. The gameplay from the first 1 was under average and from 2 it was about average and good and not ahaed of his time xD

[@345funnyboy]

Gameplay?!! Bro, metal gear solid was doing this and more on the ps2 back in the early 2000’s lmao

[@Pablojunior2006]

@@alphaomega887654321 have u played the game? the gameplay is excellent

[@alphaomega887654321]

@@Pablojunior2006 jeah how i said it was definitive better than the first one but its wasnt awesome or somelike that.

[@jojo1865]

The fact that a ps4 game can hold its own vs a ps5 game goes to show the amazing quality and work the guys at Naughty Dog put in Tlou2. Greatest game ever made IMO.

[@holyhead920]

One thing to note here is that HFW is a huge open world game... TLOU2 is a level based linear game

[@jonahaskelandsviknes2178]

And HFW was made years later for the next gen console

[@heychilly5074]

@@jonahaskelandsviknes2178 Both games are on ps4 however

[@jonahaskelandsviknes2178]

@@heychilly5074 But he showed the ps5 version

[@heychilly5074]

@@jonahaskelandsviknes2178 yes but the game wasn’t developed exclusively for ps5

[@jonahaskelandsviknes2178]

@@heychilly5074 The game was developed to take use of the ps5 improved gpu and othet components.

[@ozgundemirr]

while horizon series are technically very advanced games, they also have one of the best story in a game I've ever played, plus Aloy is such a loveable character.

[@HarshSingh-ti2tt]

Great quality videos,loved it bro❤️ Keep up the good work!!

[@oKnightzo]

Thanks dude! 🙏

[@olgabahirkina1286]

Some of the difference in the atmosphere vegetation etc would seem to be up to preference, but actually, if you think about it, the game’s story affects it a lot. TLOU2 is a zombie apocalypse story with lots of places bombed and destroyed, lots of spores growing everywhere, just generally not the healthiest atmosphere. While things are not going too great in HFW, it makes sense to be so colorful - first of all, everything was recreated by AI terraforming system, not Mother Nature, so ofc it looks much better. And even though in the game this AI hasn’t been present for a while (a short while in comparison to how long it had been taking care of this before that), the subfunctions it had overdid their job instead of not doing it at all. Too many floods, too many storms, rains etc, and the blight seems to be from overdoing smth with vegetation as well. So really, HFW is of course very beautiful and colorful, cudos to TLOU2 - besides an unbelievable story telling, its details are not too bad in comparison, and the atmosphere is up to the point.

[@RAD-LTF]

I think both games deserve so many credits and I'm so happy we have these games nowadays that are almost as realistic as real life

[@GummiAnd]

Considering the massive scale of the open world in Horizon, the amount of detail they put in is so amazing. TLOU2 is a way more linear path and therefore they can focus more on the smaller details. Both games are superb though and they both deserve to be played on PS5 rather than PS4, so they can be seen in all their glory. And just imagine what it's gonna look like when they get their inevitable PC ports :O

[@KevinAssalin]

You can say anything about Sony...but you cant denie they release masterpieces

[@JasonPriebe]

Both are amazing. Some of these details were the result of thousands of hours of work, and most players would probably never notice. But the effect of dozens of these little touches just makes the games so immersive. Kudos to both development teams!

[@shubham_M7777]

Your channel is underrated, you need lot of subscribers 💯👍 Can you make video on best/small deatils in racing games?

[@prajjwaltiwari8644]

6:34 Damn! Those water effects of TLOU 2. Best I've ever seen. Although HFW is the best looking game i've ever seen overall.

[@mss-rp8vh]

Both games excel in what they do and everyone who took part in developing them should be absolutely proud!

[@SL4PSH0CK]

the amount of people missing the point that Forbidden West is an open world for its scale compare to compact and concise linear derivative title that is TLOU2.

[@tishyo77]

The texture resolutions of HFW are out of this world, the best I have seen in any game...

[@blueish5063]

Really enjoyed the art you produced in the snow there

[@oKnightzo]

Lol It wasn't even intentional, I didn't even realise until I stopped saw that Dina's footpath was mirroring mine 😄

[@netrunner36]

The only game that hooked me as much as TLOU II in the last two years was Horizon Forbidden West. With that said, after the platinum, I still don't think anything else got me as impressed and amazed as TLOU II. Truly a masterpiece for me and I won't let anyone else make me believe otherwise!

[@Natan_Korkot]

Play Rdr2 this game is the most immersive I ever played

[@yvngtrost1686]

@@Natan_Korkot they ain't ready for that

[@Natan_Korkot]

@@yvngtrost1686 😂😂😂

[@yvngtrost1686]

@@Natan_Korkot it's blasphemous how many people here ignore rd 😪

[@brisonar]

@@Natan_Korkot TLOU2>>RDR2

[@KryzysX]

Storm .. The Water in TLOUT 2 is So Good

[@PinittoMosh]

Imagine tlou2 on ps5... omg 😱

[@khanyanqubelani1510]

I'm in a fortunate position to be owning both of these masterpieces

[@eddiephoenix9698]

8:58 there are two types of people :D :D

[@sfogli1]

*for me the last of us is a unique work that should not be compared to anything.*

[@patrick22014]

Battle of titans. TLOU2 still looks better in a few areas however it's clear that Horizon is already beyond that. I can't even imagine what marvel Naughty Dog will make in the future once they squeeze the power of PS5!

[@clerky771]

in comparison, it was clear that one was better than the other in some details, but in spite of that, it is worth recognizing that they are better than rdr 2)

[@William-Sunderland]

Forbidden West its just the best looking game to date, while being an open world, insane.

[@JayceMakesVideos]

I love both of these games, so this video was perfect for me

[@ademola1]

And thank you for this video. I played HFW right after playing TLOU2 and I felt like FW was a significant downgrade in everything except the visuals. TLOU2 is a masterpiece and I will die on that hill.

[@Rackstack234]

Agreed

[@saza23]

We are talking about PS4 vs PS5 here. Plus both games are fairly different in theme as well. I think they are both amazing.

[@travisfox8898]

Was hoping you were going to touch on swimming and the way the scum on top of the water moves and disappears in Horizon. It was one of the first things I noticed when I jumped in early on in Aloy's adventure. Such attention to details like that really help to suck you into this world! (Will say I'm shocked about the trees not interacting with you when they have snow on them! Guess I was too blown away by the snow effects on the ground to ever notice that before!)

[@Pointman11111]

I love the cinematic camera when you take a swan dive in HFW

[@paullo1846]

Never knew these 2 games have anything in common until this video showed up on my recommended list.

[@Heisen_burger-dude]

Make a red dead redemption 2 with Horizon forbidden West comparison. Two Monster Games against each other😈

[@ychan5407]

The amount of details put in are incredible. And the efforts simply should not be ignored. It is so unfair when someone says graphics don’t matter.

[@marktoth5741]

You can definetely tell that The Last of Us Part II was made for PS4, and Horizon Forbidden West is mainly a PS5 title, and the the 2 years between them. But man, both games look so good, and TLOU P2 has so many amazing little details, and the enviromental detail in HFW is on another level. Visually, of course HFW looks better, but in my opinion, TLOU P2 is so much better.

[@manmathgodre5360]

I personally like the horizon zero down Animation and physics Smooth and realistic I am not talking about forbidden west

[@minners71]

In the last of us 2 the water has no effect on the arrows - Actually the arrows in tlou2 fired into water are way more realistic they embed themselves into the seabed just like they would in real life. They certainly wouldn't float on the surface like in horizon.

[@vroxzyy_-1672]

Facts, TLOU 2 is the best

[@minners71]

@@vroxzyy_-1672 Both games are good but I've probably spent way more time on HZD than TLOU2 but then it is open world.

[@Forest762]

they wouldn't pierce trough the water like in tlou2 though, both arent realistic in that regard.

[@vuhkaisu]

The fact that probably the best looking game on the PS4 is still being compared to native PS5 games says something about the pure talent at Naughty Dog.

[@Nico_2k19]

So much more happening in Horizon FW and its open world, hard to compare to a very linear game such as TLoU

[@tinostarks]

yeah the smaller scale in TLoU2 means they can concentrate on the little things.

[@sebastiankulche]

But one is a PS5 game and the other is made for PS4. GTA 3 didnt look technically worse than GTA 2 despite being open world. A new generation makes the entire difference.

[@sebastiankulche]

@@tinostarks Dont understimate the power of a new generation. A new generation should be able to perform cutting edge tech demos of the previous one in real time and better.

[@wessident.o]

"STORM" Great video! 👍🏽

[@oKnightzo]

Thanks for watching! 🙏

[@sillkthashocker]

Last of Us 2 got me spoiled with crawling, they had to have got inspired from MGS3. I really wish you could crawl in Horizon and get really stealthy not just crouching. You actually can crawl up the side of a mountain on your hands so it's halfway there.

[@PatrickWDunne]

"Hot weather causes characters to sweat" is absolutely an amazing detail

[@amirsayfiddinov]

Gameplay-cinematic transitions, as well as animations in tlou are unparalleled. Yeah even in Forb.W. in my opinion its caused by the open world in horizon, more content(size of the map etc) lower quality. After all Tlou was much bigger product and event(the release)

[@jaredelderstudios4468]

Thanks for all your hard work 👍

[@kilroy987]

TLOU 2 to me feels more technically solid. But I enjoyed my time more with Forbidden West - except getting caught on every. single. outcropping.

[@astonnoor]

Nice Comparison Brother ❤️

[@Simplystimulating]

Definitely HFW but feel like if they made TLOU 2 more focused around the PlayStation 5 it would’ve looked similar unsure both great games !!

[@flipsolo]

These two games alone cost Sony almost half a billion dollars to produce!

[@arguekayes]

I just know Aloy’s hair weighs a good 10 pounds.

[@jonathaslimaxavier7741]

however the animation of Ellie taking and placing the arrows in the backpack is better done than Aloy

[@fpsqt]

Horizon shines in outdoor environments, but when you go inside some ruins or even the base, you can clearly see they're using last-gen assets and tech. When indoors, TLOU2 is way more detailed and realistic. Gotta say however, HFW is an open-world game, which is much harder to maintain high levels of realism everywhere you go. You gotta have compromises.

[@mmo1733]

Please do more of these! Maybe next you could do Batman Arkham Knight vs Spider-Man PS4

[@Pointman11111]

Yeah Rocksteady is another Top tier developer. Arkham Knight is still an technical mastapeece that puts some of todays games to shame. Im so excited for Suicide squad kill the justice league

[@mmo1733]

@@Pointman11111 Could not agree more! Arkham Knight looks and runs great even 7 years after it's launch!

[@Pointman11111]

@@mmo1733 this level of detail for a multiplat open world game is incredible. Arkham is maybe the worst game of the series in story and bosses but the technical side is 100

[@mmo1733]

@@Pointman11111 Could not agree more!

[@bioshootoverload9135]

who is the winner pls reply knightz

[@zayn1172]

good video good work keep up knightz 😁👍🏼

[@ffx5846]

The thing about TLOU2 is that's a horrible game, no matter the graphics...nothing will make me re-buy/play that game or saga again. No matter how realistic/good loking the next one will be

[@345funnyboy]

The last of us 2 is the prettiest turd in video games.

[@kristoffseisler2163]

tlou 2 looks better cause forbidden west has its animations in 30fps for some reason but the background looks 60

[@GLITCHED1]

2 of the most breathtaking games I've ever had the pleasure of playing. TLOU2 is impressive but it game out 2-3 years before this piece of art came out and I don't think it's much of a comparison. To me Horizon wins by a longshot but TLOU2 is definitely a close second to Forbidden West

[@mg-lm6tg]

So true

[@christofferhoff6669]

HFW is just gorgeous piece of art visually. TLOU is more a story driven game to wake human emotion.

[@okiramadhan2788]

Both game are great

[@Jack1986ZE]

Apart nice graphics both games are SJW-garbage

[@jaaaaaaaaaaaaaay]

@@Jack1986ZE how

[@TheBatCat101]

On horizon, if you walk through the arrows on trees they will brake. Thank you for your great content bro!

[@matjakobs8612]

Tlou 2 is the best game ever made.

[@bioshootoverload9135]

right

[@Jack1986ZE]

@@bioshootoverload9135 TLOU 2 is SJW-garbage with nice graphics, technically great but essentially hollow

[@bioshootoverload9135]

@@Jack1986ZE wtf

[@DasheFelton]

Comparing a PS4 game to a PS5 game is crazy but I'll watch it

[@monoxsix6282]

Can you make Tlou 1 vs Something Game?

[@biggiecheese1280]

Rdr2 Tlou2 are 2 years apart and horizon and Tlou2 is 2 years apart, all look really good, you can see the improvement in graphics when comparing all of them