hoshizora orchestra comparison (read description)

many ppl had trouble finding the difference so here u go :) yet again, please be respectful in the comments and respect others' opinions c:
#pjsk #projectsekai #プロセカ #pjsekai

[@neneneruiui]

i think they removed the strings in the background 😭 so its hoshizora orchestra but the orchestra is an afterthought 💀

[@RandomGoldieStuff]

Hoshizora

[@horikiii]

also drums from og are missing or went so quiet bc i can hear them in certain parts

[@isegeese]

the strings were like the backbone in the chorus especially it's so weird without them 😭😭

[@nozominous2956]

They went from an orchestra to a fucking middle school marching band

[@Yuki-Kun98]

HELP😭😭

[@Lbozo-nw8yf]

FR IM GONNA CRY

[@acheronsoverusedV1br4t0r]

UR RIGHT??

[@M4DETOORDERS]

I AGREE FR??

[@internetangelnadenna]

星空の中学生のマーチングバンド

[@Rlm3_9]

I think original version sounds like more orchestra, so I like it more than re-release version tbh… that makes me sad

[@rikaimai12]

the rerelease makes me so upset tbh 😭 it sounds so empty and it genuinely makes me mad and kinda freaks me out 💀💀

[@ICrazor]

REALLL where is the fun and sillyness

[@Lizzysinyourhouse]

NAH FRRRR FYM THEY REMOVED THE DRUMS DURING EMU'S "Wonderland yume ni" WHATTTT 😭😭

[@naruun076]

At first I was like, "oh okay, it's just a little bit quieter. It's not that bad :D" But listening to the rereleased version without the 'orchestra' building up into the pre-choruses are just so, SO wrong for me :"

[@popthemop]

I CAN HEAR THE DIFFERENCE NOW!! honestly i think i like the original version just a tad more but i’m not that bothered by the re release as i thought i’d be!! edit: tbh i think i like both the og and the re release!!

[@eliknight1810]

Same here!

[@chich-ai]

WHERE ARE THE SPRAKLE SOUNDS??? THE STARS.... I COULD HEAR THE STARS BEFORE. No joy and whimsy ☹️ all the dramatic instruments that hyped up the song in the background.... There was a lot more going on before

[@d3xtny_]

THEY RIPPED THE EMU OUTTA THE SONG!!! WHERES THE POP!!? WHERES THE HOOK???

[@ICrazor]

this BETTER be a mistake that they will fix.

[@mythicalspoonboi]

So, is this how Niigo and WxS get a collab? But seriously, there’s no starry sound effects or orchestra. It’s just “zora” now

[@VOCARITZ]

sky 😭

[@nausicaa2997]

THW INSTRUMENTAL WAS SO MUCH BETTER BEFORE

[@lowerrred]

By itself the rerelease isn’t even that bad, especially considering that it’s the beta version of the song 😭😭 hopefully they’ll change it back, but there will probably be reuploads of the og on spotify so it isn’t a big deal

[@rui.superfan]

WHERE IS THE FUN AND JOY AND WHIMSY WHAT

[@qtcham]

i see you everyhwrte😭😭

[@sunshinee_felixx]

NOOOO the re release sounds very empty I miss the silly fun one!!!😭😭

[@ThatRandomDoodleFan]

SEGA I will go to your headquarters just so that we can get the “Orchestra” of “Hoshizora Orchestra” back. I notice the difference now and all of us want the Orchestra back.

[@midorii__]

rerelease still sounds pretty cute honestly, even if it may not be as whimsical as before :) hoshizora orchestra will always be one of my favorite comms

[@RyuuApologist]

I think they fixed it on the spotify version yippeee

[@Pamiiyama]

I hate and love the re-release at the same time 1:40 2:00 this part though sounds so off without the extra instrumentals 😭😭😭

[@Pamiiyama]

The reason Hoshizora Orchestra was my favorite Emu comm was because of how much I loved the joy and whimsy in the instrumentals and they removed it ??? 😭😭😭😭

[@EmuOtoriWANDAHOI]

⁠@@Pamiiyama THATS WHAT IM SAYING the original release made me feel like I was ACTUALLY floating in a starry night sky (maybe that’s why it’s called starry sky orchestra) MEANWHILE THE RERELEASED VERSION FEELS LIKE IM WALKING IN THE MIDDLE OF A TOWN STREET FROM BACK IN THE DAY. Also you’re so right about that part IT FEELS SO EMPTY! MOST OF THE RERELEASE FEELS SO EMPTY WITHOUT THE ADDED JOY AND WHIMSY IN THE ORIGINAL VERSION

[@saraholuwatoyinadebayomars3594]

re-release ver sounds like if they were to sing this at a concert cause 😭 wheres the silliness? the whimsicality???!

[@artemiiix_]

WHAT DID THEY DOOOOOOOO OMG IM SORRY BUT I HATE THE NEW VERSION SM…ITS OKAY but the original literally takes me on an adventure LIKE WHAT 😭 I noticed the difference right away and it’s so weird without the pretty instrumental:C

[@TheMimicAlix]

I’m not mad that it doesn’t have the ‘whimsy’ anymore, I honestly think it’s fine even if it’s unfortunately a bit ‘weaker’, but WE LOST RUI HUMMING. THEY RUINED ITTT😭😭

[@cc-rv1oh]

Wait, where does he do that in the song? I haven’t noticed it before

[@TheMimicAlix]

@@cc-rv1oh 0:18 and 2:36

[@cc-rv1oh]

@@TheMimicAlixI don’t hear it 😭

[@cc-rv1oh]

@@TheMimicAlixBut thank you either way 😞

[@Marsiix]

​@@TheMimicAlixI THOUGHT IT'S A GUITAR??

[@arrow777.d5]

Ngl i like that we can hear the other instruments this way! More is better anw!

[@K1ttyHearts]

The re release version sounds good to me it feels more calmer and relaxing!

[@LonelyGhost7]

You’re the first I’ve seen that likes it😭😭😭 I like too😂

[@K1ttyHearts]

@@LonelyGhost7 we’re 2 peas in a pod 🫛

[@la.gran.cachirula]

Fr it does sound so calm its rlly nice

[@Kairi998]

They sound like they don’t even want to sing this song

[@JamieMieLi]

... AH!! no wonder something lacking in both version!!! The composer and arrangement having fun while the singers aren't, even in both version. Causing lack of vocal power in both version, atleast i can tell Luka and Rui are having fun!

[@haruweeb]

OKAY OKAY IM GLAD I WASNT TRIPPING OUT CUZ WHEN I LISTENED TO IT ON SPOTIFY I WAS LIKE “why does it sound different 🧍” BUT I HATE THE NEW ONE SO MUCH IT FEELS SO EMPTY

[@D14MOND]

GUYYYSS S THE RERELEASE IS BETA VERSION 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺😭😭😭😭

[@KatieIsVibing]

WHAT HAPPENED TOCTHE CHORUS HELP ME

[@user-zh4mt4bf3f]

QUICK QUESTION DO YOU STILL HAVE THE RERELEASE VER SINCE THEY FIXED IT I HAVE NO OTHER WAY TO LISTEN TO IT SO IF YOU WOULD UPLOAD IT I WILL FOREVER BE GRATEFUL TO YOU

[@cutiesmileharuka]

i do have it still! i could upload a unlisted version and put it in a playlist if you want since i dont want to make anymore public vids about it haha

[@user-zh4mt4bf3f]

@@cutiesmileharuka i would love that if it doesn’t cause any trouble for you

[@cutiesmileharuka]

@@user-zh4mt4bf3f okay ill release it sometime today :D

[@cutiesmileharuka]

@@user-zh4mt4bf3fits up! i pinged u in the desc and its in my yt playlist on my channel

[@user-zh4mt4bf3f]

@@cutiesmileharuka THANK YOU SO MUCH

[@JasmineMelbourne]

They fixed it woohoo

[@topiaz]

hoshizora orchestra is my favorite song in the game, and I think this rerelease has removed one of the main reasons I loved it. I hope they fix this

[@Lizzysinyourhouse]

same here 😭

[@theodorech20]

The re-release version sounds like Wonderlands Showtime

[@theodorech20]

In case you don't get it, it's missing a "X"

[@ruikasasfixer]

The first one sounded magical and whimsy, but now it just feels empty.. Hoshizora I still love you but idk if I can listen to the bland version (BOTH STILL SOUND GOOD, IM JUST USED TO TO OG)

[@mantarhea]

i still have the original version on apple music even though it has the rerelease cover… weird

[@cutiesmileharuka]

same! it used to be the rereleased version, but i think they fixed it on apple music. im not gonna say its fully fixed yet until it gets to spotify

[@mantarhea]

@@cutiesmileharuka oh yay!! to be honest i didnt know it was rereleased until like 20 minutes ago so i mustve just missed the other version loll. good to see that theyre fixing it though!!

[@ladyylauuren]

THANK YOU FOR HELPING ME HEAR IT. I can hear the silliness and flair in the OG, but the re-release.. I hate how I can hear the difference so well now 😞

[@ladyylauuren]

NO BECAUSE THEY COULD'VE KEPT THE SAME ONE THEY RELEASED AND JS GET RID OF DONKETSU AND CHANGED THE COVER????

[@Kyoni-Sans]

Ill be real honest, since i got this vid recommended i actually like this song. I hated on it for a bit bc the cut in PJSK didn't sound appealing but yeah

[@intermezzo_gz]

did they reupload it again?

[@Lizzysinyourhouse]

I THOUGHT I WAS GOING INSANE AFTER REVISION, BUT SHITTTTT WHY DID THEY CHANGE IT???? IT SOUNDS SO EMPTY :CC NVM I READ THE OTHER COMMENTS, HOPE IT GETS FIXED SOON

[@akid_nayr]

i think this is just mixing problem, idk it's just a random guess

[@diirectorr_]

one of my friends thinks the rerelease uses the instrumental from the teaser (yknow. from like a year and a half ago when the song wasn’t in the game), which could mean they actually released an unfinished version. this makes me scared for the l/n second album since it’s been privated too…

[@cutiesmileharuka]

thats what i suspected too! and im pretty sure leo/need's album is okay. from the songs i heard from the reuploads it seems like they weren't affected

[@inheritingtheblazingspirit]

I love the re-release version to be honest. But I think the Original version really suits the pink clouds theme(or something)

[@inheritingtheblazingspirit]

Now I'm thinking how it'll sound when both of the instrumentals are merged

[@Kori_Shimo]

BOTH ARE GOOD!!! The instrumental is all that changed. The original sounds like its more of a raw/live version while the updated is more polished and not as overwhelming as the previous instrumental

[@weevirn]

Wait I’m so confused why is there a re-release??? The song was fine??? 😭

[@cutiesmileharuka]

@@weevirn hoshizora orchestra was originally released along "what sort of ending are you wishing for" but since that song got removed, the album of both hoshizora orchestra and that song were removed, so it had to be reuploaded

[@MiriRevived]

@@cutiesmileharukaTHAT SONG GOT REMOVED? WHY AM I STILL ABLE TO PLAY IT??…

[@cutiesmileharuka]

@@MiriRevived it only got removed from the streaming services

[@MiriRevived]

@@cutiesmileharuka OOHH

[@CaptsuneMiku]

This is Hoshizora No-rchestra

[@asterzi]

re release is also more quieter, its definitely a mistake

[@kenmaswatermelon]

still cute imo, y'all gotta stop being mad abt the rereleased version. honestly, it's really silly and goofy and a bit calmer, which softens emu's personality a bit (that sounds a bit fine to me). still, both versions are good so it's no use comparing both bangers >:3

[@znaltxt]

got no clue how they fucked this up so badly because its not like they deleted the fully finished version once it was officially released like..

[@znaltxt]

its so obviously an incomplete version especially when we get to the bridge(?) where its so clear that there's something missing (the Orchestra) to it, also with the guitar in the background that you don't hear much at all in the original version the song is supposed to be grandiose and loud, it is literally orchestral and you dont get any of that in the re-release

[@1EmuFan]

I’m pretty sure the one they re-released is from the event trailer so it might just be a demo and it was a mistake?

[@cutiesmileharuka]

@@1EmuFan thats what i suspect too!

[@gashakori]

This isnt starry sky orchestra its clear ground one man band

[@mikumatt]

4:29 Hot take, but the backing guitar during the waltz section in the re release actually sounds pretty good

[@cutiesmileharuka]

@@mikumatt i agree

[@Lbozo-nw8yf]

NO MORE FUN JOY AND WHIMSY???

[@superstarri_04]

Eventhough i prefer the orginal, i love them both and i think the marching band still sounds really fun and joyful.

[@justTxu]

No more silliness 🥲🙁

[@cielchan111]

ok the rerelease is sorta fire…its just less hype but WHO CARES I LOVE IT!!!! :333333

[@_rainy.days_]

Bruh the mixing feels even worse somehow ☠️

[@_rainy.days_]

BRO WHAT IS 4:28 ☠️☠️ THAT'S ACTUALLY CURSED

[@AegbGo]

Re-release is kinda cool too, obviously is less polished but I kinda like how it sounds like a small band trying to recreate the og ver

[@cielchan111]

THE SPARKLES!1!1!1!1!!

[@eliknight1810]

Nice!

[@Melo_pi_]

Spotify realease vs live show

[@Lizzysinyourhouse]

Guess I need to find a new favourite song...I found someone that uploaded the full song as an episode, I'll use that as a replacement for now

[@akemiemil]

TYSM

[@ruiimeow_]

hoshizora orchestra but the orchestra went missing

[@snicksss]

I do like the instrumental vibes in the re-release, but overall I do hope they fix it.

[@MidoriDay]

They look like they're js doing a rehearsal in the re released version 😭😭😭

[@Ghost_A.2]

0:37 this shows how important bass is, that part sounds so damn empty without the bass line

[@onelighti]

My emu stan friend will not being liking this one 😭

[@Kori_Shimo]

The mastering for the instrumental is different. The original was too loud but it gave it a more orchestra feel. While the re-release definitely sounds like a studio official version. I think the original composer either changed the instrumental because they wanted to or were asked to. The updated version is definitely clear improvement of the original creators work. I honestly prefer the newer version

[@Ahiruru0]

Isn't the re-release version the one that was used in the event preview?

[@cutiesmileharuka]

@@Ahiruru0 precisely

[@megurinehsan]

i think its still good

[@CEOofAn]

I looove Hoshizora Orchestra, the new one sounds so flat, hope they fix it soon!!

[@ririnikite]

i mean, i do like the rerelease version, but it's quite unlike the in-game version (i think it's just a minor difference to me) why do people not like the rerelease version…

[@cutiesmileharuka]

for a lot of people, and including me, it sounds way emptier and the emotion connected to this song is missing!

[@enashinonomeirl-09]

i hate the rerelease version its so empty and bland

[@kaysecarvalho5742]

Hoping it gets fixed asap

[@lowerrred]

As a music producer the old version isn’t horrible, it’s just different lol

[@lowerrred]

really sad abt the lack of orchestra but yk it’s the beta version

[@mashiroruna6822]

i heard the vocaloid ver by the composer, and it's more like the rereleased version... i think they nerf it to sound more like to the composer uploaded one

[@Oyasumii061]

Why is the re release version so sad and non energetic

[@LonelyGhost7]

I subscribed

[@venti2569]

It feels sm more empty...

[@Idkhowtonamemyself300]

Sega better fix that :< this is my fav emu commissioned song

[@Lizzysinyourhouse]

Real :C

[@emuotorizz]

the original had the strings and the sparkle sounds 🙁 now its just empty and not an orchestra anymore 😔

[@Hopes_Peak]

Thank god of the old lyric videos. I despise the new version it just took out the jazz out of it and made it super boring and made it sound more like a cover than the actual version like bandori who changes the tone of the music according to the singer like Mashiro would be higher key or D4DJ who changes the genre of the song according to the group who is singing it like for Black Shout, they made it more techno and upbeat for Peaky P-aky. But I’m pretty sure they used the instrumental version from the event.

[@brightdays_123]

there's less impact now... 😕

[@hirumaiya]

omg i live under a rock butbutbutbut why did they re-release it? what happened? still love it tho they could never make me hate u hoshizora orchestra

[@itsmichote3587]

So basically the song "What kind of ending do you want" was made by the band tuyu and the composer became problematic and so the band (tuyu) wanted all their songs gone (covers and etc) so Sega removed it but in order to remove it they have to delete the album (which also had Hozhira orchestra) so after it was deleted Sega released this ver which people wonder if this was on purpose or not cause it sounds very boring and different

[@itsmichote3587]

And if your curious on the story on why the composer is problematic you can look up "pusu incident" it will tell you what he did:)

[@hirumaiya]

​@@itsmichote3587OHHH, i didn't know this song was part of that incident. thanks !!

[@Marriotte1708]

I feel like it needs the violin in the re release cuz... i feels so empty 😢

[@srfn127]

By the way i combined re-released and original ver. And i love both rhythms and this is happened 😅 kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXq2g3aXZcSXsK8si=xiM_VohNaHYsemej

[@11usion_al]

now that I listen to the rerelease again it sounds like farm music, kinda like the bgm for the minori armadillo event which ngl makes me dislike the new ver. a little less, I can imagine wxs in a farm with all the wacky stuff they do lol

[@guess_hoo]

the little pause before the first chorus in rerelease gives it a slightly better anticipation so i enjoy it!! original sounds much more regal, and rerelease makes it slightly toned down but i personally emjoy rerelease better :3

[@_thesilly]

I HATE THE RE-RELEASE ONE UGAGSHAJKANANSJS IN MY OPINION THO sega better fix that. literally one of my fav song, fav emu comm, the original one always makes me feel happy :3

[@yadkario]

they removed the wonder in wonderland x showtime 😭😭

[@user-zh4mt4bf3f]

yall are just haters I thought it was cute it’s like the more calm ver of it and it a vibe like once upon a dream

[@thisstreammuststop8321]

That is the problem. it is no longer an Hoshzora orchestra, but just a Hoshizora. a dream where there is no place for fun, but only a peaceful and calm emptiness😢

[@yourhanez]

I think, they have change title, dont use orchestra 😡

[@Kris-ds6wj]

But wai 🥺

[@crispychichen]

so whose funeral are we going to btw?

[@SharShxr]

NOOO WHAT KIND OF ORCHESTRA IS THIS AND WHY IS THE PIANO SOUND SO SAD NOW

[@romifox_k]

I noticed it when I heard they rereleased it Honestly its such a big mistake that ColoPale released what sounds like a goddamm Demo 💀

[@0mega-pan206]

What the hell it sounds so empty what is this sega

[@ENJKI]

Why the fuck though?

[@circusniuw]

I hate the new version sm IS SO UGLY I CANT 😭

[@Mintyyyt]

THIS SUCKS SO BAD OH MY GOD