How Bollywood DESTROYED Indian Cinema

[@LokeshMarathe]

Hello I'm sorry for the some mispronounced words some mistakes in this video Like i- i said the story revolves around the Ramayana for the first film "Raja harishchandra "but it's actually inspired from Markandeya Purana not ramayana which I'm sorry I also mispronounced some words, like 'Pather Panchali', which i already put a disclaimer in the beginning but still sorry and used incorrect titles like 'Main Hoon Joker' instead of 'Mera Naam Joker', and 'Momento' instead of 'Memento'. Additionally, I referred to Rohit Shetty's 'Spy Universe' as 'Cop Universe'. I apologize for these errors, which were due to a tight deadline. I had only one week to read and research, one week to script, and one week to edit. Unfortunately, I didn't have enough time to double-check my mistakes. I promise to correct them in my next video. Thank you for watching, and I apologize again for any mistakes in this video if I missed.

[@Kaito028]

It's alright. Mistake happened. But regardless the topic of the video was very serious and interesting. And I enjoyed it. Keep it up. ❤

[@dsbdsb6637]

You tried to tackle too many issues which made the video a mess {acc. to me} & there are certain arcs which need a more nuanced discussions but i agree with many of the issues though with my own spin.

[@dsbdsb6637]

P.S. - I have watched Iranian, French & other nationalities movies, International masala & art movies etc. I have read intellectual takes abt. them and never felt satisfied with any of them {found most of them to be too pretentious} though they helped me learn abt. noting nuances which i missed when i watched movied without any info. Also Indian movies used to have political ideological propaganda esp. since 60's {notice which political parties were overtly shown or which ideoological position movie portrayed as good}, 80's were high mark of 'Parallel cinema' & all this in 90's got replaced by romance, thriller-suspence etc. I don't see copying movies or art as wrong / bad as well but the issues of homogenity & stories becoming too formulayic are real but not limited to Indian cinema alone.

[@melonydivineq]

It was good broo

[@অর্ণবচ্যাটার্জী-ধ১খ]

just liek kids need to be told what is good food, audience need to be told whats good cinema...left alone everyone will consume adult films and slapstick comedies...problem stvarted when the mafia and underworld started getting dominannt in indian cinema and economic turmoil made quick profits more enticing than real art...also the whole filmfare, IIFA circus, basically created cartels and a feudal system that most big industry suffers from...Indian audience initially was backward...now it is being intentionally kept so...

[@DipIntoFilms]

Something which concerns me is that what Sir Satyajit Ray said decades ago is still relevant today :)

[@futurefamousguy4073]

He was indeed ahead of his time sad part is he have influenced every filmmaker except the Indians.

[@rushabhback838]

​@@futurefamousguy4073indians are fools from the start

[@d-orbital]

​@@futurefamousguy4073The last line is it!

[@nandanasalvi]

🎯

[@radianbeast]

Jab janta gadha hain toh .....unko gadhe bale movies he dikhana padega.... Ache dikhaoge toh paise ki barbadi hogi

[@AdiBushan-z9b]

Unrealism is NOT the problem with indian cinema, the issue is the lack of basic sense and lack of creativity and lack of proper execution in story telling plus action. Audience need to accept other genres and new types of movies as well while preserving and evolving masala movies.

[@AnupamMaurya-qf8kj]

The thing is if it's advertised properly with great trailer many will go to see like dev d tzp,dch, Hindi medium,minnal murli,piku,bala

[@darpankonwar598]

​@AnupamMaurya-qf8kjnaah bro, still most of 'heavy topic' movies fails to get recognition in India, although the same film can get many awards outside india

[@AnupamMaurya-qf8kj]

@@darpankonwar598yea I kinda agree all we imagine as light has similar problem but then again if it's gets good marketing it could be hit like lipstick under my burkha

[@premprabhakar805]

@@darpankonwar598 bcz most people ki apki life hi eke heavy topic h to kamse Kam movies me to unhe unrealistic experience karne do

[@brc123321]

​@AnupamMaurya-qf8kjVulgar, Boring films ! Most of the Indian people don't like to watch such films.

[@keerthikumarmgk7835]

Only when we stop arguing which film got more collection and argue using the quality and art of film, Indian cinema will get fixed

[@mrsandeepreddyjtn]

Will get fixed by political woke propaganda? "Kala rajneeti se alag nahi hosakti". Entertainment is also a form of art. Propogandic art movies are still being made. Include OTT and there are literally 100s of them, it is just that no one watches them..

[@TheUnvanquishable]

We'll never have a satyajit ray ever again.That man, was beyond an epitome.

[@mrvengeance404]

Ab koi ky hi kre sb wildpire dekhna h sbko to 🤡

[@Pav-i4m]

Watch allu arjun Arya movies or his old telugu movies​@@mrvengeance404

[@praveen.m2591]

One day who knows i can become one❤ of my dream job

[@brc123321]

We also have Guru Dutt, Raj Kapoor, Chetan Anand. Currently S. S. Rajamouli

[@praveen.m2591]

@@brc123321 they are masala directors though

[@yashsingh6793]

The Indian cinema problem is not that it's unrealistic but that it lacks creativity.

[@nihaalsandim9986]

True , filma dont have to be 'realistic. They simply have to be more artistic, made with more effort and love than just to be made money.

[@indrejeetmilwar]

Creative people are selling panipuri in streets and Cringe people printing money

[@zohebrafi]

I agree and also add that modern Indian films, especially, lack heart and soul.

[@AnupamMaurya-qf8kj]

Stanley ka dabba,udaan, Mohan Joshi hazir ho,tu hi hai mera sunday,i want to speak,all we imagine as light ye wali toh mushkil se dekh paya, lunchbox

[@supranshtiwari5121]

@@yashsingh6793 you didn't even watch many good films released previous years and came here to tell what India cinema is 😂

[@TheUnvanquishable]

Cinema isn't the problem, the people are.

[@abhijeetshaw8843]

I agree with you

[@TheGoodfella2012]

Yes i agree to a certain degree. Although artists should strive to uplift the consciousness and spirit of their countrymen. Trouble is the "artists" in India are just appealing to the lowest bottom denominator emotions of the public. So it's a vicious cycle.

[@harpreetsingh-dz6qf]

Right brother. Creativity is gone from india

[@nandanasalvi]

Not 100% Eventually, the people should be given a choice. If there's no buffet, the hungry one consumes whatever is served on his plate. You can see, despite the recent Boycott Bollywood movement, they have kept producing bulshit films. They have found a new trick to promote their nepo kids, using fine actors like Raj Kumar Rao or Vikrant Massey, selling false dreams to the attract quality seekers.

[@Tomiokasan99]

Then where are the creative people who can make good art? Does creativity dies if it's not profitable??

[@sayanmandal1289]

In search of entertainment we lost art in our cinemas . Only few are exceptional .

[@CrownRenowned]

Cinema's = corn hubs/ only fans platform

[@brc123321]

Entertainment movies are also arts..Arts is a broader term and can't be used for only one type of movies

[@bhushanpatil1019]

Yes but bollywood movies destroyed the taste of nation,stupid love stories, overacting, inmotional music ,lack of good knowledge, chapri heroes , so called superstars etc etc total nonsense ,tv ,award shows, magazines,ads , posters total cringe 😢

[@brc123321]

​@@bhushanpatil1019 Bollywood movies mostly before year 2000 did not destroy taste on Indian audiences. They were according to the taste of Indian mass audiences. They were modelled after Nautankis (Indian dramas) which were famous among Indian public before the advent of movies. Nautankis had songs, dance along with drama. They were known with different names in different places in India. For example they were known as Jatra in Bengal. Mumbai film industry was heavily influenced by Parsi Theatres centred in Mumbai. Parsi theatres were done by mostly Parsi community. This explains why most of the actors and actresses of bollywood looked like Parsian or Parsian looking people were preferred in Bollywood cinema

[@jojosoni]

Artful movies are still made. Just that they don't 1000 crore business

[@TheUnvanquishable]

Even the directors and actors we make fun of have certain flopped artful movies, art and commerce is like oil and water, you can't mix then unless you add emulsifiers (great film-makers) . Do you believe in gravity?

[@futurefamousguy4073]

@@jojosoni indeed they're been made but only outside hindi cinema last time where you saw some artistic films made in hindi cinema after tumbadd?

[@supranshtiwari5121]

@@futurefamousguy4073 Define artistic film

[@asdfnew352]

if these artful started making 1000 crores, indian cinema landscape would turn arond completely, and with itself, complete social structure and ideology. Dont u think brother?

[@asdfnew352]

@@futurefamousguy4073 12th fail is gud. not a masterpiece, but really good. chamkila is nice, maidan is good and maybe a few more. Still year 2023 and 2024 were really good for indian cinema with movies like maharaja, kill, aavesham, manjumal boys etc. beating hollywood movies in almost all categories. East asia is doing pretty good considering current situation of cinema in the west.

[@ashchase-n9x]

Sir Satyajit Ray's statement was so true because Indian cinema particularly Bollywood has no identity of its own, we can barely produce timeless pieces of cinema, we refuse to authentically connect with our true culture and past and it is sadly reflective of the mindset the masses possess, absolutely no will for introspection, no tolerance for criticism of the colonization induced morals we still uphold and seemingly no will to improve . Bollywood seriously needs to understand that the same cycle of mundane thrown in and out ideas won't cut it anymore especially now that more people have access to more foreign cinema. True creativity is never nurtured through trends

[@SankyGamerUHD00]

Its same with tollywood, very few good movies rest is all mass entertainment.

[@saumikdasxa2142]

Not only Bollywood but also by all the movie industries of south

[@TapasGhosh-ig9co]

Realistic art cinema is just an one side of a coin, because without popular commercial cinema like "Bollywood" which is the other side of a coin, film industry can't be survive in any way. Cinema is a mixture of both realistic and unrealistic art.

[@ashchase-n9x]

@@TapasGhosh-ig9co Very true, however even with commercial cinema we appear to be at the latter end of the spectrum

[@amygdala_HUH]

The problem also lies with the Indian audience. We don't make good movies successful. The audience nowadays are more inerested in the VFX effects and fighting scenes of a movie, the plot barely matters to them. That's why we have Pushpa and Animal pulling such great numbers. On the other hand movies like "All we Imagine As Light" gets ignored not only by the audience but also by the government.

[@tahiribnmaqbool]

Satyajit ray is legendary film maker, he use to do all things by himself, costume design, set design , dop , storyboard, what a legend , master of all trades

[@Sinchan123-p7q]

Art films are still made in India very much but the audience of India don't watch masterpieces in theatres because of lack of hype...and those art films should promote their movies

[@shankhanilsarkar2161]

Satyajit Roy and Ritwik Ghatak are the brightest gems of Indian cinema ❤

[@utsabmoitra1245]

I am lucky that I am a Bengali and understand what Satyajit Ray and Ravindranath Tagore gave us.

[@thebongkumedian4708]

Exactly ❤

[@drakausabyss6908]

Ekdom bhai

[@rikomandal9470]

Ar naki aj kal log bole bangali ra kalo jadu kore. Eisob log history konodin poreini

[@thekanchanshow1301]

Satyajit ray is overrated..just hype..I'm Bengali but I don't like ray..bullshit

[@drakausabyss6908]

@@thekanchanshow1301 that's personal preference, which is absolutely fine, similar to us, we love Satyajit Roy and Rabindranath Tagore's work and want it to be appreciated more

[@shahmirjalal_999]

Bollywood simply ran out of coping movies, since back then it was much easier to do that.

[@Itiswhatitis54]

Satyajit Ray was not only a filmmaker but also an author&artist, I'm glad i grew up cherishing his Novels/Stories/ScienceFictions and the fabulous drawings in it.

[@Kakarot542]

8:51 My mother tongue is Hindi and used to only watch Hindi movies but later I tried watching movies from other language and I came to know about malayalam movies(mollywood) which actually made me fall in love with movies again, they make movies so many diverse movies which explores all kinds of genres, and also I came to know that even some of the most popular Hindi films was just the remakes of malayalam movies. But unfortunately malayalam movies are not really getting the attention it deserves so I would highly recommend you guys to try to watch malayalam movies.❤

[@dixantaparajuli3172]

because most of the movies are woke how will people like it?

[@hanantkm]

​@@dixantaparajuli3172 Out of curiosity may I ask, which are the movies that you consider "woke"? I asked because you have claimed that 'majority' of the moviee are woke

[@VenkataPradeep24]

@@dixantaparajuli3172 Woke matlab?

[@srikrishnak196]

​@@dixantaparajuli3172 do you even know the meaning of woke? It means being progressive and not being a boomer trad uncle or aunty

[@dixantaparajuli3172]

@@VenkataPradeep24 unnecessary subtle propaganda to promote their ideology so subtle you will never actually find t without understanding

[@HumanxHuman]

Pushpa 2 crosses 1700+cr, is literally the disrespect of Cinema.

[@hitesh1491]

Pushpa 2 is surely ab amazing mass film. Climax have goosebumps and cultural moments it shows true cultural impact of India.❤ Cry hard haters 😭1800+ cr🎉

[@shogun_sanji]

Grow up

[@Looking-for-shanti]

​@@hitesh1491 peelings song is also full of culture

[@pras6]

@@hitesh1491 Grow up dude, stop glazing D rated movies

[@WhiteTiger12R]

lol 😂 , you and your view of cinema

[@Ayusztche]

Profound and subtle analyzation! People are slowly but surely going to realize that the inception they have of liking the trending forms are not as important as real art forms, or perhaps, people who understand the intense situation of negativity reflected by modern content will likely spread this to other generations and it will slowly make it revolutionized. And this analyzation is proof of that, there are people that still understand the art and literature. This type of content should spread to the larger part of the audience and should be much appreciated.

[@roxxxxxy]

indian cinema will deliver what people want.... and you know what people want

[@brc123321]

Every movie industry delivers what their audience want

[@PurobiChatterjee-oo2zh]

Then indians audience are dumb 😅

[@jerobyarts5654]

Audience also plays a part in this . Like for the most part even in the US , most people who watch movies in theatres are big families or teenagers who mostly go to theaters to have a good time and enjoy any flashy movie that has a huge poster or advertisement behind it, these flashy movies who have spend a lot of time in marketing gain a huge amount of profit from it too. People who enjoy watching creative and artistic movies are the same people who go to theatres just to enjoy watching movies , they don't care about marketing or flashing posters and ads , nor they care about having occasional fun with their families and friends , they are simply there to watch the movies and enjoy the experience. The latter kind of people are the main audience of creative and artistic movies

[@Chetukundu]

As soon as Bengali directors and actors disappeared, art disappeared, harsh but true.

[@motoggaming8484]

The apt question should be "What happened to Indian Audiance". Family audiance had completely ditched the theaters for other affordable forms of entertainment. 70% of theater audiance these days are teenagers and young adults mostly mens, they prefer action, hero elevation, item songs, stunts, boom baam like a circus. The rest are young females accompanying the males. Since the Target audiance Today is under 30 age men's, the product (cinema) has also changed. This same stuff is seen in USA aswell, these days only superhero or remakes of old franchises get funded in USA, everything else fails to work, Like satyajit said theater audiance are turning unsophisticated(again). There is no turning back, because the exact type of movies which excites you are available online for free ,theater is just for couples or fanbois now days i feel :(

[@RudraRaut-b5s]

After few year taste of people changes what south is doing now bollywood was doing it in 80s and 90s and then they changed because of audience was fed up of repetive content same will happen with south too

[@motoggaming8484]

@RudraRaut-b5s yes I feel it's a cycle, just like clothes, once they act smart and dive into new age type, futuristic,art house cinema, then they flip completely and watch mindless masala films, then the realises these are all mindless and they been cheated , they switch to art house, serious films . There is no balance in humans i feel

[@raja-jl9os]

​​@@RudraRaut-b5s what about cinematography, action, production design? mujhe bollywood movies har chiz medicore lagti h

[@raja-jl9os]

​@@RudraRaut-b5s Indian cinema always look cheap but nowadays production quality and cinematography better ho gayi h

[@RudraRaut-b5s]

@@raja-jl9os pura Indian cinema mediocre hi he if you compare it to to international cinema not even bollywood or south movie industry have produced a single movie jo international standard me sare department me excel kare

[@ramasarkahc6781]

Art is only for few to savour. Art is never produced for the mass. Mass wants pleasure and entertainment, not art. And so art is so precious. One needs intellect to appreciate art. Only few here got intellect.

[@baajey]

its NOT bollywood which destroyed Indian parallel cinema, its the masala loving audience.

[@Randomly.assembled.molecules]

Only a few people understand art spically in India

[@cinephilebuddy464]

Bro where did you find orchestral version of Pather Panchali theme at the end ? Can you please tell the name of that music

[@frodoBagginsfromIndia]

😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@thisisbm1]

Apur Panchali Instrumental Theme

[@JustaRandomAnimeFan653]

9:57 I mean Ghajini was not a complete copy, Memento is much better in every aspect

[@hemangkorane1797]

People used to talk about this thing 8 yrs ago, still for views spreading misinformation, pretending to be rebel of sort. Ghajini is a remake of 2005 film of same name which is inspired by memento, the overall story is pretty much similar but the structure and themes are completely different

[@shish_sahu07]

​@@hemangkorane1797 I think the narration of the story and some plots are different and everything else is the same.

[@ifidontgetajobmyparentswil286]

Agree, ghajini was really better and it has nothing to do with being intellectual

[@M4DN3355]

1st movie was not ramayana ,it was raja harishchandra (satyug era) patthar panchali nhi pather panchali hai .

[@futurefamousguy4073]

*Revolves around our ramayana and indian culture

[@princesolanki5914]

Also 'main hoon joker' nahin 'Mera naam joker' Bro is making videos on art or serious films without even watching films 'seriously'

[@Fistsane]

​@@princesolanki5914 He also said that Sholay is a copy of Seven samurai, if he did actually watched that movie he would have realised it's not a copy, this guy showed a character laugh who is from "for a few dollars more" is not even remotely similar to Gabbar Singh except that both are dacoits and Seven samurai has 7 protagonists and Sholay has 2 they and it doesn't even have a character like gabbar and the whole story is very different how the hell he is calling it a copy man this guy seriously doesn't watch movies

[@suryendusaha4231]

So good and sensible discussion on the evolution of Indian cinema and the perspective of Indian audience.

[@STARK50]

Not everything has to be a picture perfect artistic movie. Sometimes people watch movies just to escape reality. For a common man with no knowledge of science, art or cinema would probably not watch a film with an artistic angle and heavy message, for them a movie with hero flying and kicking ten people is everything.

[@somnathsinha872]

Comedian Jagdeep used to say that the cinema was the biggest classroom where fiction was used to embellish the fact and values were used to inspire virtue. Starting with the hollowness of the Garibi Hatao movement and its subsequent avatars of the Nav Nirman movement, the youth became self-indulgent and addicted to the quick fix of violence. So, the medium moved into the escapist domain of fantasy, where all problems were not resolved by the force of conviction of the character, but dissipation of a Dionysean orgy. The hero stopped being an epitome of virtue like Dharmendra, and instead became an embodiment of self-indulgence like Bachchan. O tempora, o mores ! The hero is not an embodiment of Apollo, but is an expression of Dionysius.

[@thecinematicdude]

So good to see someone talking about the different sides of Cinema. Loved the video.

[@TapasGhosh-ig9co]

Both art and commercial cinema r two sides of a coin called "CINEMA" .

[@raja-jl9os]

Indian cinema can't make decent action fantasy

[@MadihaKhan13]

Can We Just Appreciate How Hard He Works To Entertain Us His Editing,His Script,His Voice His Humour and Everything About His Content His Knowledgeable and informative Content You Deserves Millions of Subscribers❤

[@kalakritistudios]

Best definition of art I ever heard in these years of research: "Somebody should be just there to call it art."

[@stranger.2006]

Bhavesh joshi the superhero is the latest example of this.that was one gem of a movie made in such a low cost.still it failed miserably.audience are the problem,good movies are still made.

[@raja-jl9os]

😂😂😂😂 are you dumb

[@JustaRandomAnimeFan653]

I mean I don't really mind commercial/mass cinema as long as the movie is good ir i enjiy it. Like Kabir Singh, Animal, Rockstar, Kantara, Maharaja .... I liked them all even through they were commercial. Also, I have a bias towards documentaries, biopics and historical movies like Bajirao Mastani, MS Dhoni, Sardar Udham, URI, Sarabjeet ..... so i like them too doesn't matter if they are a hit or flop on the box office.

[@supranshtiwari5121]

The thing is they are commercial but they have some artistic value, we need to mix them both for making films.

[@praveen.m2591]

Maharaja is not a commercial masala film though🤔

[@raja-jl9os]

​@@praveen.m2591 maharaja is typical comercial

[@highspeedtechnical]

Really loved it like I was watching a documentary but yes I hate twitter for disrespecting SRK always he always tried something new and when he tried the audience failed him we got FAN, RA-ONE, SWADES. like films which were not meant for bollywood.1 like for SRK for trying different always in this era and yes There is a artistic film that vanished released with pathaan named GANDHI GODSE EK YUDH that film should have worked but it flopped so miserably that we can't even see it on OTTs now.

[@tiaflies]

SRK is a great actor and very talented... shame that when he tried to be experimental it failed.

[@evilbrothers8001]

Most of them were mid leaving some

[@AtleeAnna]

Fan's first half was great but the second half was all over the place and Ra-One lost the plot with the unnecessary commercial elements they shoved in just to appeal to a wider audience. But Swades is great and has over the years gotten the deserved recognition it always should've gotten

[@cringekiller348]

Raone and fan were genuinely terrible. Swades however was amazing

[@Pav-i4m]

​@@cringekiller348 Swades is remake of Kannada film "Chigurida Kanasu". ❤

[@AnanyaPratihar]

Patthar Panchali ❌ Pather Panchali ✅ Pronunciation : P(aw)th-er Pa(in nasalized voice)-cha-li

[@theartist-s2t]

Main Reason Downfall Of Indian Cinema is Indian Audience who went to watch crap films and appreciate them 😢😢😢😢😢

[@brc123321]

There is no Downfall of Indian cinema. Only downfall of Bollywood (Hindi movie industry) has happened. Thats because they had given up their unique style of filmmaking and was trying to be (a poorer version) of Hollywood

[@essaaby]

Indian audience needs masala masala and more masala.

[@mrvengeance404]

Exactly gutterchap ,, punchar chaap, thele wale auto driver yhi h inki at the end target audience 😂😂😂😂

[@prasannaighe5188]

Yes we do

[@raja-jl9os]

Indian cinema cringe

[@elamcyril]

​@@raja-jl9os Indian audience cringe too

[@censrrd]

Bahut khoobsurat video banayi bhai. Very appreciated! Keep making such good content❤

[@nandishhegde9025]

When you say Indian Cinema but only talk about Bollywood and Satyajit ray and refer to everything else as regional cinema, there lies the issue. Have you seen GGVV, Swati muttina Male Haniye, SSE side A and B, aattam, All we imagine as light. There's so much to see if you become comfortable with subtitles

[@futurefamousguy4073]

@@nandishhegde9025 he included all we imagine as a light while appreciating regional cinema

[@Pav-i4m]

Kannada films are underrated 😢😢

[@onewe2298e]

Subtitles, yes this!!! I have noticed there no hindi subtitles because reading is what Hindi people can't do, they want dubs and I feel lack of connection with dubs.idk why Hindi people don't like reading and quality of dubs is worse too much nonformal cringe, as for non Hindi cinemas can they also provide other language subtitles to reach them not just english, not everyone know English I am afraid this may be related to lack of education, people don't engage in reading literature activities which is closely related to lack of art film making..

[@princesolanki5914]

I doubt he even watched the films he mentioned Various mispronunciations

[@vaibhav17S10]

We can read hindi bro ,but people when watching a movie are not going to focus on subtitle to read to watch a movie ​@@onewe2298e

[@ArtcomsenVisual]

You are the commentator that Indian cinema needs today! Bhai you have toppled everyone on this subject I think! None of the others could say what you said so beautifully in this video!! Great work, great expectations!!!!

[@BabulDas-ek5bi]

Finally someone addressed this. There will alaways be 2 types of cinema for the 2 types of people. Ykiyk

[@SquarerootDepression]

A crucial topic that must be dwelled into by everyone cause This is a major part of our modern culture. Liked the video

[@TheRishijoesanu]

Malayalam cinema is still committed to art.

[@Pav-i4m]

Kannada also. Shetty brothers ❤

[@RudraRaut-b5s]

That's why there has 700cr loss last year even though Malayalam cinema is experimenting and become face of art cinema in India they should focus on making profit too sometimes art movie need good budget too because they don't even launch movies in my city which is tier 2 city but malyalam movies rarely relases here

[@Krishana-o7i]

All Malayalam are not good bro...only few..I felt some Block busters malayalam also felt bore..

[@ayushchakrabarty5543]

Bengali films❤ 🎬

[@jibangkurbaishya221]

But I Like Commercial Movies Like Bahubali And RRR, Even Steven Spielberg And James Cameron Praised SS Rajamouli For RRR...

[@prasannaighe5188]

SS Rajamouli is basically Art + Commercial director. A lot of detailing has gone in His films

[@AdiBushan-z9b]

Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada and many other cinema in India are also indian national cinema. Not just Hindi cinema.

[@tarusht2085]

They have the same problem terribly made movies gross a lot but good movies get no recognition except on ott.

[@kunalchoudhary3457]

Telugu and Kannada cinema is even worse than Hindi Cinema. Tamil and Malayalam cinema is good

[@AnupamMaurya-qf8kj]

​@@tarusht2085many watches mass movies to have some fun that's why some are even watching badass ravish kumar to have fun in theatres

[@idontknowmyname2827]

And they are also bad so the INDIAN cinema still sucks

[@cringekiller348]

​@@kunalchoudhary3457Tamil movies are also bad

[@rururuchi]

This video is so so good. Subscribed instantly.

[@cinephilebuddy464]

2:07 correction, patthar nahi bro 'pather'

[@TheUnvanquishable]

it can be hard or non bengali speakers i guess

[@futurefamousguy4073]

@@cinephilebuddy464 he is not bengali

[@indiangirl727]

Still " patthar " pronounce karenge kya? "Patheer" hoga

[@HOPE-wg5pb]

You should be consistent and upload more short form content under 10 mins Ig it will help you grow ur channel more maybe try your luck with shorts too

[@air-inyeegaa5584]

compromise art for algorithm? no

[@Voice-j9q]

​@@air-inyeegaa5584 he won't be able to make more if he doesn't earn

[@ronzanime]

I think aap is video se kuch nahi samjhe bhai

[@Shivam-xo6lg]

bro with longer videos, Loyal fan base is formed.

[@pras6]

Konse bhi small creator ke channel pe jau, channel growth krneka gyaan dene wale aate hi rehte hai

[@kjeet007]

great work brother, I'm a cinematography enthusiast and love to understand art...keep it up

[@Shelzastark]

It's Haunting how Mr Ray's statement really aged well.Their are few projects of Raj Kapoor that I really appreciate..one of them being Shree 420. But tbh, the authentic and real version of Indian Cinema died with movie directors Like Hrishikesh Mukherjee, Bimal Roy, Shakti Samanth,Basu Chatterjee, Vijay Aanand and My personal favorite- Gurudutt Sahab...these were the people who created the idea of Indian cinema. Sad to see that I am living in dumb era full of dumb Mfs who will never understand what Indian cinema really was..

[@princesolanki5914]

Just saw Pyaasa a few days ago And I bet that film will be relevant even after centuries He was amongst the top filmmakers of world Sad that the World didn't recognise him just like vijay in film

[@avi2125]

Correct. A lot of mainstream movies have a lot of creativity...

[@raja-jl9os]

​@@princesolanki5914 bahut melodramatic thi

[@raja-jl9os]

​@@avi2125 mujhe bollywood ka melodrama and concept mostly cringe lagta h

[@Shelzastark]

​​ The world needs more people like you who are open on exploring the 'almost lost' side of indian cinematography... I've been watching Gurudutt's movie since 7/8 because my grandparents made me fall in love with cinema from those era who were themselves a big fan of Gurudutt and Mr Ray respectively.so much so, that my grandma Travelled all the way to Bombay for the first time to attend the premiere of his movie 'Chaudhavi ka Chand'...I also suggest you to also watch Kaagaz ke Phool which is also a complete masterpiece, it's sad for me that he never got his recognition in his lifetime.Trust me, you'll fall in love with his work!.​@@princesolanki5914

[@Randomly.assembled.molecules]

An artist's biggest accomplishment is when he/she successfully hides his work in the illusion of "Original" by making it's work that nobody ever knows from where this is copied or inspired from Original things aren't real

[@user-to3ho5xx3d]

True. Good artist copy. Great artist steal.

[@agniswar3]

Only God's creation is original as all artists are inspired from nature which is God's creation.

[@princesolanki5914]

True nothing is original And I saw people fighting over credits for people who themselves were thieves 😂

[@LORDAKV69]

A great video bhai 🙇‍♂️❤️ last wala part to

[@parthomusic69]

Love this ❤❤ Keep going mann!!

[@shrihansuchit6647]

Art is one of the many medicines for the sorrow of people in their lives. But the sad thing is that the Taste and Choice of people globally is getting worse. Whether we talk about literary works, cinematic works or music or painting or philosophy or fashion works and many more. For developing a "good" taste we have turn our heads and look for the classics, The legendary canons. Only after that we can classify which should be consumed and then only the very rare but deserving artists who are losing motivation will arise and a significant change in the whole artistic industries may be seen. Nice Video.

[@tanmaykumar2279]

Me who watches both commercial and hardcore artistic movies. Commercial movies like :- KGF, Bahubali, RRR, Pushpa-1 etc.. Artistic movies like - Elippathayam, Anantaram,Vidheyan,Chidambaram,Kummatty etc.. You have to just pass the language barrier and there is a ocean of artistic blend with masala stylized movies out there.. Mostly in Malayalam cinema.

[@SpaceCowboy5634]

the new style minimalistic editing feels so good

[@kunaldas5325]

Kya kehte ho dost ek documentary ho jaye Satyajit Ray ke upar.❤

[@suplays]

This is why lord himesh had to come back. To save cinema.

[@brc123321]

I will go to watch

[@kalakritistudios]

Why is art more important than entertainment? What will these art films achieve which can't be learned any other way?

[@raja-jl9os]

Art means storytelling

[@kalakritistudios]

@raja-jl9os That's all you've to say?

[@Rajs-12]

Because movies show the world your culture and u want them to think them that our culture is what shown in pushpa

[@kalakritistudios]

@Rajs-12 Every Italian must be in the fucking Mafia then. And apparently Superheroes exist. Dream within a Dream machines exist. We truly are in The Matrix. Humans are saving us through Time Travel. How many of us even KNOW the real America? Movies are PRIMARILY for emotions. It's just in recent years that our movies are reaching foreign at such heights. All thanks to Blockbuster Mass Entertainers. Do you KNOW how happy I AM? That now we're not comparing our movies with foreign films, there are fights like KGFvsRRRvsVIKRAM! Nobody even cares about Hollywood anymore! And then here you're.

[@Zzmaster_-mj2xv]

The catch is art is already found in theatre. But unfortunately almost no one watches Theatre in India. I would love it if more people ditch cinema for theatre

[@jyotirmoyroy186]

Sad but true is Puspa 2 is the worst overhyped movie that India has ever produce! It's not a disrespect but fact! Thanks for making such content bro🎉

[@StudyDope]

Great work, Lokesh ❤🙌

[@user-RAj_Hunter]

Why Satyajit Ray's image in thumbnail?

[@sundarihema25]

You plz watch what K. vishwanath of telugu cinema did movies like sagarasangamam, swarnakamalam, shankarabharanam, swathi muthyam, swayam krushi ... and also, Many movies of Senior NTR who played krishna and Rama.. It was just something else.. The dialogue delivery and every character actor was extremely good even if it is a small role.. Some movies are MAYABAZAAR.. this movie has all veteran legendary stars of telugu industry and true legends. Krishna pandeveeyam, krisharjuna yudham, shri krishna tulabharam and many more. Rama in lava kusa, shri ramanjaneya yudham. Watch also movies such as Bala bharatham which is the childhood version of mahabharatham where rivalry between pandavas and kauravas is shown. This movie has Sri devi as a child artist. I am disappointed that you didnt include any south movie which is legendary but you put a poster of all south heros and satyajith ray as ultimate... There were others too..

[@satrajitmaitra4553]

If you never watched Ray's movies, you'll never understand

[@UnTalked_Official]

OHOO 20k on first day!! Congrats my dude😍

[@Shaun-gm9dw]

Bro is becoming consistent 😱😱😱

[@SathvikBhat-q3q]

this video changed my perspective, thanks

[@RamanujBhattacharyya-ww5lc]

Bengali cinemas which were made by Satyajit Ray and other Bengali director,are the original best and heart touching cinema,which Bollywood cannot make a cinema like them.😂😂

[@cosmicpebble-s7z]

One thing I like to mention is that Swades movie is inspired by the 2003 Kannada film Chigurida Kanasu. Another point is every movie in history is inspired from some other movie or novels at differing extents, that itself is not an issue as long as they bring something new to their audience.

[@higherpower254]

No it’s lengthened from yule love stories episode staring gowariker himself in 1993

[@youthindian1593]

Jawan pathan pushpa kgf these movies are earning 1000 cr,,,its just shame for cinema

[@heiAMB]

Commercial Cinema made for Money, don't try to became so called Intellectual.

[@raja-jl9os]

​@@heiAMB but i prefer fast furious and kung fu movies

[@raja-jl9os]

​@@heiAMB action choreography tak mehnat nhi krna h

[@viveksg1020]

Jawan and pathan is shameful for Indian cinema because of its corporate e

[@viveksg1020]

SSR murder is really downfall of bollywood

[@amygdala_HUH]

I am only dropping this comment because I wanted to mention the name of another Bengali Film Maker, Ritwik Ghatak. Since I am seeing so much mention of Satyajit Ray in the comments I also wanted people to discover this amazing Director of old times. His movies have a very strong and raw storytelling. He upholds the reality in front of the audience at it's truest form. You will have to stop and think for at least an hour to process what you just saw. I will highly recommend him and his works.

[@quicklessluck916]

I think south indian movies are really great their cinematography and realism mahn really awesome...i think what hindi movies lack is realism and a good storyline...they used to rock before even with the songs but now all they do is remakes and still manage to be the worst version of remakes

[@Jisu-q1f]

Movies are reflection of a society

[@JustaRandomAnimeFan653]

1:00 Parallel ki spelling galat hai 🥲

[@AryanPandey-l8x]

Typing mistake ho jati he bhai 🤓🤓

[@kirankumarbhadane9370]

Parellel world main aisey hi likhtey hain😂

[@headheart2608]

Waise कलात्मक ki bhi. But I guess that's okay.

[@madyati]

Nice, did u have copyright claim in this video?

[@IRFRAJ]

at 09:17 You are saying “Seven Samurai”(Japanese) but you are showing Once upon a time in the west (American western).

[@NeerajBaid007]

Arre Bhai sahab the primary story is copied from seven samurai but scenes are straight up copied from OUATITW! Samjh gaye..

[@Zzmaster_-mj2xv]

​@@NeerajBaid007seven samurai and sholay don't have similar plot actually unless you mean two men come to protect a village. This is fairly common

[@kambhamshreyank4341]

Cinema is ENTERTAINMENT NOT LESSON SO TO DISMISS ALL PROBLEMS IN DAILY LIFE CINEMA IS PART OF LIFE NOT ONLY PART OF LIFE 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Sumit_Girhe]

Another pushpa lover.

[@NishantSingh-zx3cd]

What a beautiful video essay. Sharp references, beautiful music, spot on editing. One thing that you should try and improve is your script. The material is spot on, but the language can improve. It looks like hindi is not your first language, which is not at all a problem. But if you write the script beforehand, practice english and hindi pronunciations and then go for the recording, it will take the essay to another level. Maza aaya bhai!

[@Subu-u7i]

There's no director like The Satyajit ray and ritwik ghatak. In morden world era no one can match them.

[@raja-jl9os]

Isliye Indian cinema itna piche h 😂

[@Subu-u7i]

@raja-jl9os I don't know the context of your laugh, but if you have the mindset of a pan gutka wala then you just the crowd for me. Both of them are Bengali director n we consuming their work since childhood.

[@raja-jl9os]

@@Subu-u7i hongkong, Korean, japan waha creativity dikhti h

[@Just-Merit]

If they Try showing Foreign Culture, How can the Indians relate with It .. We are common Middle class People We Like what we want.... Not your Elegant Art But... Cinema what shows Our Culture.. If you don't like it .. then keep doing your business, we are doing ours...🔥

[@onsidesports]

There are so many stories of Satyajit Ray still are uncovered,if those we make into cinema,you can't imagine what gonna happen across the world❤

[@srijanmishra4713]

bhai maine momento & ghajni dono dekhi hai.. par momento ka tatoo & short term memory loss plot nhi hai.. both have different plot

[@shish_sahu07]

Hmm... Kaafi kuch same hai aur kafi kuch alag hai. The main plot aur story is copied whereas narration is different. Correct me if I'm wrong 😊

[@AnupamMaurya-qf8kj]

Jo Southern version tha uska kya plot tha

[@parulgarg4502]

Exactly both are very different films one is concerned about exploring psychology of a psychopath and the other is your usual pyar ke liye badla le liya type of movie

[@parulgarg4502]

​@Living_Dead007wrong bruh, main plot and story is totally different only the concept of forgetting after 15 minutes is same both are very diff filma

[@thedarkknaik]

One of the best videos and the harshest of all truths about Bollywood history!!! Thank you, Lokesh Marathe, keep it up.

[@28maitreyagupta21]

A real exception to this is Kill and Jigra some of the best made movies of our time.

[@raja-jl9os]

Medicore

[@JEFF2002-q7q]

@raja-jl9os How so? Even Chad Stahelski is making a remake of Kill

[@veydantjivimal]

This topic is something I was wondering about for some time now. Thanks for making a video on it.

[@DENIALSON7]

6:50 true words till today. Commercialization inflected badly our indian brain.

[@sastianimation]

The Story telling is really impressive man

[@LateseReview]

Ending mai tumne yaar emotional kar diya❤️‍🩹. Hindi belt mai tumse accha documentary banane wala nehi dekha. Meri ek humble request hai ke tum ek documentary video banao Satyajit ke upar ya fir unke Films ke upar. Please 😅

[@mr.nobody7914]

Someone has to speak out....and you said it

[@shrikantmahamuni7411]

Some future directors are reading comment section. I hope they will show art and creative cinema to indian audience to make world better ✨

[@Gotocut]

Bhai aap ko aaj yad kia or aap. Ka video aa gaya 😅😊

[@diehardcynic]

Very sweetly narrated, best part was Patthar Panchali. Keep it up.

[@Rebellgamers]

How ironic the person who is crying about the state of indian cinema in this video also made a video about how versatile shahrukh khan is. 😂😂 Think twice before pointing fingers at others.

[@SSwathi-ge5wj]

Is Mr. Shahrukh Khan not versatile?🤔🤔

[@Rebellgamers]

@SSwathi-ge5wj he is not.

[@SSwathi-ge5wj]

@@Rebellgamers But I thought he was......................................................

[@Rebellgamers]

@SSwathi-ge5wj Do you have any examples of it?

[@rajkumar-pz8hy]

itni acha apka obsorvation hai film ko lekr hame lgta hai ki aap filmmakr banna chahte ho isi lie movie ko old se new movie ka cultural shift ko app dekh pa rahe ho [1950-- 2024]

[@ratnamsai3796]

Lol most Art films in India are Leftist oriented, Poverty glorifying boring dramas ...no wonder people stopped watching them...Simplicity dose not mean showing poverty and praising them for Western validation...Big or Small budget...Artistic and entertaining movies can be made without mocking and abusing Indian Culture,Gods and Nation irespective of the film Genre...hope new age filmmakers understand this ...otherwise people are fed up with this same old "Indians are uneducated" , "Indians don't know how to watch ART films"....Blah Blah Blah.

[@SonGojit456]

Aapka Response Badhiya Hai

[@prasannaighe5188]

You cooked them.

[@Absence-999]

I agree

[@NotKinetic]

There are still a few movies that do walk upon "the Satyajit Ray definition of flicks as an art form" trail. One of the biggest examples is All We Imagine Is Light, which was unfortunately not so well received in our own country. The bigger problem is interpretations of the audience, as Mr. Ray once firmly remarked that we have a fairly backward audience. It is very hard for them to watch and analyze a beautiful art piece. They are not able to comprehend a satire (they are certainly not going to enjoy Dr. Strangelove). It is often said that boredom leads to success... It is one of the key factors to make a person intellectual. Certainly, the mass audience does not want to get bored (they certainly won’t enjoy Tarkovsky’s work). Turning around a movie that shows the art of living a life is certainly the most blissful solution for those chaps, and I do not possess any doubt in my mind that large directors exploit their thoughts to imbue their pockets full of crunchy papers. I am not ridiculing any genre. Films like Psycho and Tumbbad are some of the finest examples of good films coming from the horror genre. They make perfect use of literary devices, and certainly give the audience a cavernous message. Satyajit Ray, too, delved within various other genres. I might get hated upon, but I shall speak with utter resilience that flicks like Pushpa, KGF, and Singham are in fact the biggest shame of Indian cinema.