How Donald Trump Won The White House: Jonathan Pie's American Pie

It’s the US midterm elections, and spoof news reporter, Jonathan Pie, is sent across the pond on the campaign trail.
You can watch Jonathan Pie's American Pie on the BBC Three iPlayer page here: www.bbc.co.uk/...
--
Click here to subscribe to BBC Three: bit.ly/BBC-Thre...
Did you know that we’re up to other things in other places too?
Best of BBC Three: www.bbc.co.uk/bbcthree
iPlayer: www.bbc.co.uk/t...
Twitter: / bbcthree
Facebook: / bbcthree
Instagram: / bbcthree
Tumblr: / bbcthree
Oh, we’re on Snapchat too - just in case you were wondering… add us, bbcthree.

[@namefinder]

It's sad to see that a comedy piece on the BBC seems to be better at analysing the election than their news teams are.

[@stevencarr4002]

One assumes you are not talking about the Mash Report here which once explained that you should not vote for Jacob Rees-Mogg because he is a Catholic.

[@ComicGladiator]

A society always relies on comedy to reveal the naked truths about itself. That's why there has been an attack on comedy. Look at who you can't make jokes about in a society and you see which groups have power.

[@rickh3714]

Satire has always been the knife that pares politics and political personalities and their public to the essentials! From Gillray to Daumier to Giles and Spitting Image he's continuing a great tradition!

[@owenb8636]

Nice backhanded compliment.

[@simonwinn8757]

The line not to cross in comedy, has been the king's anger.

[@tomralph8540]

Jesus Christ, some bloody sense being spoken about the Trump phenomenon from someone who leans left.

[@Sketch1ish]

Its like, i disagree with your disagreement but at least you acknowledge im not coming from a position of hate

[@killgriffinnow]

This viewpoint is actually pretty common on the left; look at people like Jimmy Dore and Kyle Kullinski.

[@TheSupremeDominator]

@@killgriffinnow common. But not as common as the usual left leaning supporter.

[@notanactualuser]

@@killgriffinnow the problem is what is the left anymore, it seems to be being further and further to the far left.

[@vitalybilo]

@@killgriffinnow actually those 2 are the exception not the rule...if the entire oeft would have listend trump wouldn't have won. Kyle dore and few more are probably no more than 10 people all combined..

[@tzuyd]

I'm surprised BBC hasn't denounced this as hate speech yet.

[@schrodingersferret4092]

It's there pretend way of showing they are impartial. They know the public don't believe them anymore.

[@schrodingersferret4092]

@@Praedyth_ honestly> Calling people with a different political view alt-right for one. Theres probably less than 100 actual far right people in the UK, yet this term seems to be applied to any group from centre right to the extremes. Also 17.4 million people vioted to leave the EU, and over the last 2 years we have had litereally hundreds of negative stories, I dont think ive seen more than 3 positive news stories regarding Brexit or peoples opinions and the side of 17.4, its all the same narrative about doom and gloom, almost nothing about the success of 17.4 million fighting for what they believe in, huge swathes of the country simply ignored.

[@icameherejusttocomment550]

Schrodingers Ferret The last EDL rally had about 500 people, and just look at #FreeTommyRobinson on Twitter. There are more than 100 far-right people, maybe even a million. This government is indeed far-right at its core; surveillance, islamophobia, Windrush, austerity....While the average Conservative voter may not advocate for a police state or people being deported to their deaths because of their skin colour, this government certainly does.

[@tzuyd]

Wow, it's like you're suffering from some kind of Derangement Syndrome. I wholeheartedly recommend you seek professional help. God speed.

[@icameherejusttocomment550]

@@tzuyd Who?

[@AoyagiAichou]

Ooooh, Pie is on BBC? Since when? This is excellent news.

[@MrDaiseymay]

YOU MUST BE A SICK AS HIM

[@weswheel4834]

@@MrDaiseymay Its just to the left of the 'A' key ;)

[@dantaylor7344]

It's terrible news, man sold out.

[@andrewphillips8341]

This will be terrible! The BBC will water down and corrupt his work.

[@watercolourmark]

Pie On Sky for the win.

[@TheFluffyDuck]

I love this guy. He is the only center left moderate in the media it seeks these days.

[@okok72277]

He's left, not centre left

[@sho-m-er5194]

Nah he hates centrists, he is definitely left

[@flatscreengamer9725]

He's pretty left wing. He's just not part of the stupid left.

[@JanSanono]

Ginmhilleadh I always wonder what people mean with centre left: to me, it'a at the centre of the left wing, not socialist, but definitely not centrist, bur I think to most it's in between centrism and social-democracy

[@hoebread7584]

The moderates will die moderately. He's a true leftist, he represents the majority of us, unlike those annoying fuckin liberals who have taken the name leftist without taking the ideology into practice

[@SanRemoMotelBar]

Good to see Pie getting the airtime we all know he deserves.

[@Degenevesting]

"Its a neat trick if you can hold a biro that way"

[@Lobsterwithinternet]

There’s a lot of neat tricks you can do with a bayonet too except sit on it.

[@philiposborne982]

That made me laugh too. Probably not many that could these days... He didn't mention religion. That's hiw Trump won. Christian vote. Blatantly. Will happen again. Mark my words. My algo is quite adamant. It's normally right.

[@SuperIbi96]

@@philiposborne982 you were wrong

[@PatioRS]

this was refreshingly accurate, it's nice to see the bitter reality being confronted on a mainstream outlet like this

[@Blackerer]

2:00 oh the ducks timing was perfect. it should be a stand-up...err... paddling comedian!

[@RBGHfam]

Some Americans were sick of taking it in both directions, so they chose a rock to the window instead. It might have been a lop sided rock... but it was still a rock.

[@drearmouse9510]

Ahahaha, I can't help but laugh at that long walk.

[@pandaeyez]

why...?

[@josephinewinter]

that's one of his jokes, he did a great video of being a political presenter while spouting rubbish, it's on youtube somewhere

[@BrusierWeight]

Josephine Winter Well actually that’s what he does, pretending to be a political presenter while talking shit about politics.

[@drearmouse9510]

@@josephinewinter ... Yeah. Tom Walker's a genius.

[@JoeBleasdaleReal]

Omg! He's on t' telly! He's made it!

[@dantaylor7344]

man sold out.

[@FakeSchrodingersCat]

At least this time he sold out to the BBC rather then RT

[@heliumtrophy]

Not quite BBC 3 is BBC's internet department these days.

[@redberries8039]

another 10 years and the BBC will be the place where over-the-hill comedians go to die ...#legacymedia

[@thanksfordoxingpeopleyoutube]

bbc 3 is not a tv channel

[@gdfggggg]

A lefty that is willing to appreciate the other sides reasoning is rare.

[@mathewhale3581]

And vice versa

[@quasarsphere]

You are both correct.

[@tobi888100]

No it isn't. That's literally what he adresses in this video, lol.

[@Chris-0703]

There is no such thing as “reasoning” on the right. Arriving at a conclusion without actually processing information is called bigotry, not reasoning.

[@danmccaffrey2157]

He's a fictional character...

[@samurai215]

This guy's best video was his Trump election win reaction one. Pure gold!!🤣

[@johncodmore]

I'm going to enjoy watching it in Nov 2020

[@adamphillips7072]

it's so rare that someone in the MSM actually nails it like this guy.

[@dsugimoto313]

Jonathan Pie is the best political commentator anywhere. Thank you, Tom Walker for creating him and Britain for sharing him with us. Most sensible analysis I've ever seen. Those hacks that pass for journalists on American cable news networks should be required to watch this and write a high school level paper on this (if they know how to write and analyze at all.)

[@krishm16]

Hit the nail, right on the head! Fantastic summary!

[@ThePainterr]

...same conclusion is reached about Brexit......both who voted and did not vote to leave are responsible for the outcome of the Brexit referendum...bitter truth to swallow!

[@SKELTER.]

Weird that so many people have forgotten how democracy works.

[@ThePainterr]

yup......why look at all the UNdemocratic remoaners in the UK that have rejected democracy....now they want another vote, yet couldn't uphold the first one?????

[@SKELTER.]

@@ThePainterr All this bollox about "The People's Vote", who do they think voted in the first referendum? Or do you think they don't consider Brexiters as people? That sounds a bit fascist to me.

[@ThePainterr]

.... sounds like its gone passed the point of "a bit fascist" to me and is rather blatant Uncle Jo Stalinesque to me. Next we'll have the KGB sending us of to Gulags if we don't give the Leftards a second "predictable" commie outcome they so badly desire comrade......

[@SKELTER.]

@@ThePainterr most on the left don't know what they're supporting, they're stuck in a mindset indoctrinated into them by the media, politicians and Silicon Valley. I'm leftwing myself but I can see the erosion of our freedoms and the danger democracy is facing. I also still see rightwingers as people with different ideas and perspectives. Ya know, rather than Nazis. It's a helluva job trying to get other lefties to open their eyes. But most are still good people blinded by the narrative. Hopefully Jonathan Pie can wake enough up before they send us all to re-education camps.

[@abrokedude8164]

That duck responded with "that's right"

[@Top-Lip]

2:00 see, even the duck agrees with him. This man speaks truth.

[@thewitchsfamiliar]

I read this comment just as it happened! XD

[@abasketofcrutches2955]

best thing to come out of the bbc in a long time

[@KHasan-de6yq]

Seriously, never heard a better explanation of 2016 US election than this

[@FaithRox]

Odd. Is this BBC? Have I stepped into a different realm of reality?

[@__-fm5qv]

Its BBC3 things aren't as strict there, probably because the rest of the beeb forgets it exists.

[@nutsackmania]

No you're just stupid.

[@SusannaSaunders]

Well said! 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👏 👍 loved the punch line "and that is on you".

[@martialme84]

Yeap. "Vote for hillary or there´s a special place in hell for you!" (real quote from some bright light feminist genius) That´s gonna breed resentment, if anything will. Especially when said about a person as.... controversial as mrs clinton.

[@lukasklister7206]

Somehow the best piece of serious journalism that I’ve seen for a long time!

[@rok1475]

Now replace the background picture, replace the word “Trump” with “Brexit “ and repeat the monologue.

[@lovescatsthing]

You would think the truth of that statement would hurt?..but...if we had a second referendum we would probably vote the same way.......which is why Trump will win another term.......and everything you once took for granted about America will go down the toilet. The world is watching with baited breath....best show in the world 😉

[@DavidAllen-fo4jl]

Hello Guv'. That was the best piece to camera I've seen on the subject, and it had to be comedy for you to make it. I'll watch you over mainstream any day. Your commentary is the best. Bloody well done.

[@woolseyallen1048]

He will be back soon explaining how Donald Trump won a second term Lol!

[@tanker1759]

Spot on and brilliant! We need to make and keep common ground with people.

[@mrtalos]

I'd love to think that with people like Pie finally getting a much more accurate point across, people will calm down. Trouble is, it shouldn't really be coming from a comedian.

[@gentlespirit4]

I'm so glad that everyone here knows this brilliant man is a comedian who writes jokes for a living. Surely they're aware of the freedom to NOT view this video if they're THAT offended. They can just move on. Just a thought. 🤔😂👍🏾😉🇺🇸🇬🇧

[@lukaszwason5031]

This has been the problem with liberalism for many years - pure arrogance when it came to many issues particularly social in nature. It's forced wild opposing views underground to galvanize and gain traction, and it's united people of similar viewpoints. Whereas the left was become toxic and authoritative in many areas with so many liberals turning on themselves. It's so hard sometimes to agree with popular liberal opinions in this day and age. And I'm actaully a liberal myself. We need to start conducting ourselves better, and start to understand the opposing view (not necessarily agree) before we dismiss it. Just my opinion

[@generaLRager]

I think the best solution is both sides listen to each other, both denounce their extreme sides and ensure the extremes are shut down and dealt with, what you see too much of is the Left saying its ok for them to do things the Right are doing because they are more moral and therefore justified, but to everyday people they just see them as hypocrites, and the sad thing is the Left don't see it back firing. They are totally blind to everything that happens around them. Antifa are free to roam the country protesting and making fools of themselves and the left in general, using all the tactics they say they are fighting against. The right seems to be more contained or perhaps better at hiding themselves, because in truth the dont need to do anything the Left is showing itself up more often than anything, all the Right has to do is sit back and watch them implode then walk out with some common sense idea's & Policies for people to get behind, and people will side with the moderates not the mentals.

[@lukaszwason5031]

@@generaLRager I agree. Unfortunately I sensible conversation between people of opposing sides is easier said than done. But the first step of both sides would be to denounce the extreme views, absolutely.

[@naapalm82]

LONG LIVE THE ENLIGHTENMENT!

[@justamannothingmore1999]

lukasz wason can some explain to me what’s the difference between a left wing, a SJW, and a liberal please?

[@lukaszwason5031]

@@justamannothingmore1999 I suppose there is a certain amount of overlap. But an SJW to me is someone (with good intentions) trying to defend groups or minorities who they feel are underrepresented or mistreated in society regardless if they personally identify with those groups or not. And often is the case, they neglect to include facts and are dismissive of everyone with a differing opinion, labelling them as bigots, even though their points may have genuine merit. And their actions often turn into the very thing they were trying to fight. A liberal to me, and liberal values also stem from compassion - trying to help everyone regardless of who they are, but facts and pragmatism also play large roles in forming opinions and policies.

[@jacobzaranyika9334]

You get me ALL the time. EVERY SINGLE TIME ! Without exception.

[@aaronlewis702]

Great message. Also liked your first point about him appealing to the whole country rather than certain demos.

[@lukethomas.125]

Finally someone who speaks their mind

[@raysullivan6168]

You know, I'm really starting to like this man. He's funny and very well spoken. As for Trump, say what you will but know that he does stand for something and weather or not this reporter likes him, he at least spoke of him in a respectful manner!

[@LisaHuff-o6k]

Tom, thank you! Sharing.

[@gapper3]

Love this guy. He started this shtick as a lark a while ago and now produces commentary that is better than 99% of the crap in the msm. I'm about as far to the right as he is to the left, but I appreciate honest discourse and legitimate arguments, even when I disagree with them. Wish a lot more people on the left were like him.

[@handlemonium]

At friggin RT mind you 🤣

[@ArturoPRADA-ORTIZ-fy3fj]

Best Comedian journalist ever. Very clever geezer...

[@christianr1240]

I like how he can analyze the election from a left wing perspective but still make damn good sense.

[@LFOVCF]

Like the left cant make damn good sense🙄

[@milesjolly6173]

"It's a neat trick if you can hold a biro that way"

[@artalexander4952]

Conclusion....?! Trump 2020😂

[@georgebenwell664]

..this should be shown in schools, churches and government run education seminars....absolutely brilliant.

[@kevincruz7958]

Pie always on right the money

[@twentyone753]

Good man

[@steffenschiller3189]

Spoof news reporter became serious reporter and absolutely nailed it. What he said when walks along the Reflecting Pool is about the best description about the lack of meaningful open political discussion I have ever heard.

[@guittadabe5214]

Funny how the most honest people about Trump on the Left will NOT mention that he HAS made life better for almost all Americans, starting with the economy and jobs that are coming back. The truth is that he has been impossibly better than his voters EVER expected! We rank him as one of our best presidents ever.

[@dante6563]

Yeahhhh...that's not true...

[@howler6490]

Who is we? He is a man in name only. He has not 1 saving grace. A liar, a pig, a shameful episode in americas history who will cause many years of trouble after he is taken away, either in chains or a coffin...I'd prefer chains.

[@grumpydave6558]

Ha ha! Clearly not my lines!! You are an absolute gem!! You need to run for PM I'd vote for you!!

[@KlipsenTube]

His comments about “not allowing an opinion” and having “taken a flame thrower to this city seem eerily prophetic of what has been going on for the last few weeks - not because of Trump, but because of SJW’s.

[@gbcontolini]

Can't believe I missed this one until now. Please come back to the States soon!

[@vol.9543]

Why is he holding his hands like that?

[@prunehead]

He's playing a character, the character of a British news presenter. That's generally how they hold their hands and gesticulate.

[@terryl7855]

Was expecting something else, pleasantly surprised. JP's take on Trudeau next, many of us Canadians can't wait to show him the door! Cheers!!

[@richardouvrier3078]

Actually, mate, that's pretty good for the BBC.

[@iamreg1965]

That was fucking TOP CLASS. It takes a comedian to actually report the REAL NEWS.

[@null090909]

Nothing has changed. Trump will win a second turn.

[@Varilpsa]

Man he must have not been a very good president if nothing has changed then?

[@michaelzilm4099]

Spot on

[@Dywindel]

Debates about the refugee crisis, yes, we should talk about how we achieve this. Debates about trans rights, no, trans people are within the catogory of 'people' and, thus, deserve rights. That's not something that needs debating. Pie, don't conflate two items like they're the same thing.

[@Chiscringle]

Many of these issues ARE given airtime on major news networks. They're STILL debating climate change, albeit with most of the 'skeptics' fighting the 'no ACC' rearguard. We were the nation that had hearings and public debates where people successfully (for a long time) argued that some lead in your diet was a good thing, cigarettes were healthy, and DDT was A-OK. Now it's the current argument over climate, the number of genders/sexes in human biology/psychology, and whether we should be isolationist for awhile. It's easy for Pie to argue that lack of debate breeds resentment, but there isn't a refusal to argue, just condemnation. The USA has always tried to have a happy medium and take the middle road about everything. Sometimes it leads to high atmospheric lead levels. High atmospheric lead levels during the childhood years of most of the US Senate, Congress, and the President. Lead tends to get absorbed into bone. They're old enough to be having loss of bone mass, which means any lead would be leeching back into their blood. The words used back in their day for the psychological effects of lead poisoning: Florid Psychosis No matter what your political beliefs, you can think of a few floridly psychotic people in the highest levels of government. Maybe we should have them tested to see what their blood lead levels are.

[@timothyarnold1679]

Well, he's wrong in almost EVERY view politically, as the performance data proves... but he's not wrong about the arrogance and elitism of his side. Keep calling us names, we'll just keep winning.

[@rolfs2165]

Who's "he" - Trump or Pie?

[@blackandgold978]

@@rolfs2165 Pie, Genius.

[@__-fm5qv]

There isn't such a thing as "wrong" politically imo. There are just different sides of the same coin, and most of the time both sides are reasonable. It all just depends on what you personally value more in any given situation, and that perfectly fine.

[@Super-yw7ss]

Right on!!!!

[@PhilipJackson03]

That was one of the best videos discussing how he won. I especially loved that debate part, I’m a centralist but I would call myself a progressive. And I think all of us in the centre, who try and understand all sides do understand that you can’t underestimate Trump. But you certainly cannot underestimate the voter. Polls may say one thing, but the voters may say another. It’s really just that progressives go to far, while the ones who can’t join them feel left out and worried. That is what Trump fuels himself on and that’s why, even with his rhetoric I am 100% positive he will win a second term (unless a Bernie/Beto ticket were to happen.) I think Progressives really need to dial it down a bit with the extreme PC shit, subjecting one group into one single narrative and start working and understanding. Because if you don’t more and more right wing leaders will pop up. We’re seeing it in Canada. It’s the problem, because we all know overall Progressives will win (just how History is) but we need to understand that some people don’t agree with us and it is perfectly healthy.

[@TheChrevil]

Someone once said that in order to joke about something you must know and understand what you are about to make fun of. Hence when Johnathan Pie is making fun of something he understands that behind it all is a fundamental truth.

[@jaziel3684]

Second term boys

[@PasteteDoeniel]

"...but if you do that you hand him a second term, and that is on YOU." it's mind boggling that so many have not seen this and keep on doubling down.

[@nfnf7109]

College educated women for Trump 2020!!!!

[@phalangeish]

Oxymoron

[@georger64]

This! Oh, so very much this. Thanks.

[@tomhulme1176]

People were sick of lying politicians saying 1 thing but doing another. He does what he says.

[@Tucarius]

What do you mean by that? He lies every time he opens his mouth and makes a concerted effort to take both sides of every position he speaks about. It'd be damned near impossible for him to *not* do what he says, because what he says he does, is *everything*.

[@asfrmaster2011]

Jonathan pie! you rock!

[@jamesmatthew1903]

Trump was a Democrat until 2009. He's a centrist / nationalist and that's why he won; he appeals to EVERYONE except the extremes on both sides.

[@TheDundeeBiscuitLuvU]

So, for starters Democrats are already right of centre by most political spectrums, so even a centrist in America is right wing, and his views and policies are not centrist they're pretty far to the right, hence why far-right groups and publications like him so much, an affiliation he encourages.

[@jamesmatthew1903]

​@@TheDundeeBiscuitLuvU I suppose it seems that way from a European perspective because from an American perspective all the European parties (in every country, even Hungary and Italy) are left-wing. The last MPQ's was basically socialist arguing with socialists about who's more socialists. Corbyn and May want the same things, they only disagree on implementation.

[@tomasbickel58]

"EVERYONE" .. imgur.com/gallery/ocM1bVD

[@samfitzpatrick7891]

He’s very right leaning on the economic spectrum with his tax cuts for corps. He’s also authoritarian on his immigration, Bush Jr for example was not nearly as anti illegal immigration as Trump. Only centrist thing I see on Trump is his social values. He doesn’t care much about Abortion or Gay marriage but has to say he opposes them as his whole party does, he won’t do anything to help overturn them though

[@mattevans4377]

Look up the political compass. Much better at explaining politics than a simple, ineffective line. On that compass, Trump would end up on the libertarian side, Hillary would end up on the authoritarian side. In fact, people who are described as 'left' or 'extreme left', would be considered authoritarian on the chart. That's why people get enraged by them. And honestly, we should. Anyone who is authoritarian, whatever 'side' they are in, if they take away freedoms, they are the enemy. If only others could remove sides, and understand what the real threat is, no one could take away their freedoms, ever again.

[@lennytheleopard]

Excellent "Mr. Pie"

[@BuschidoEra]

I voted for Trump because I do not believe that the first US Secretary of State to have to eulogize one of her Ambassadors for being killed in action (the first in American history) is qualified to lead a government. In Japan or China, perhaps even in the UK, a minister presiding over such a failure would have been forced to resign and shamed out of public service.

[@benmitchell161]

Trump has presided over botched missions which have resulted in the deaths of American military personnel. A simple Google search would do you well. Yet I assume you're not calling for him to resign?

[@midgetwars1]

Then why vote for Trump? Especially how Clinton was grilled for many many hours and not even the republicans found much wrong doing. Trump on the other hand...Not going too well for him.

[@pandaeyez]

China's president is immune to impeachment. UK's Theresa May is a reoccurring time bomb. Shinzo Abe of Japan ends up in scandals all the time. Your examples are completely flawed,

[@13tuyuti]

I get that people don't like Hillary. I'm not sure if I would have voted for her if Iived in the US. But the man who bankrupted at least four of his own businesses and who keeps his other busineses afloat by stiffing contractors and who conned a bunch of poor people with a fake universtity is even less qualified.

[@Dockhead]

even in the UK? something tells me you dont know as much as you make it out to be.

[@mikepug1]

Brilliant as always.

[@krish224488]

After all this bitter truth they had to put the snake oil part to not annoy their bosses at bbc..

[@BrusierWeight]

Nope, it was probably Jonathan Pie’s idea.

[@thescopedogable]

It was a snake oil since he has gotten into power he has given himself and his rich buddies a MASSIVE TAX CUT increased the already insanely over sized military budget opened up the national parks for oil drilling he has been slowly dismantling protections for workers and attacking unions basically if you are a working man and you voted for trump you are a massive sucker.

[@jamiecaudle447]

Jonathan Pie on the BBC? Yes please.

[@anthonyhudson3540]

One thing nobody acknowledges is that he is actually doing a good job.

[@mokiloke]

Lol, he barely works or knows whats going on around him.

[@anthonyhudson3540]

@@mokiloke im no supporter but econnomy and foreign relstions best shape for years. We do t hear this as liberal elite media continue to demonise him

[@Bruce-vq7ni]

How can he be doing a good job. When all he does is tweet nonsence while sitting on the toilet.

[@anthonyhudson3540]

@@Bruce-vq7ni because the economic figures say so. The mainstream media are trying to remove him and replace him with globalist puppets like Hillary Clinton. Whether me or you like it or not, he was voted in by working class people who have been forgotten in this modern world. Where global business, banking/finance, media and the political elites think they dont have to obey democracy. The same way they are trying to stop brexit. If this carries on and they keep ignoring the working class, you will see more than the citizens of france putting on their yellow vests

[@Professicchio]

"Economy" is just a bunch of stock market made up numbers with no relation to reality whatsoever, and eventually someone is going to get a tough wake-up call about that, wait and see.

[@Bojan8309]

Spot on.. Again 👍

[@Nine-Signs]

- sigh - Pie is missing the bigger picture. How did Donald Trump win? simple. Capitalism. Let me explain: In 2008 capitalism collapsed, the centrists and classic right wing in control of the advanced nations chose to take the peoples money and bail out the system in order to continue as if business as usual. This came on top of wages being stagnant to falling for the last 40 years for the bottom 70% of advanced nations due to the primary law of capitalism, profit seeks the lowest cost of labour, which means: A) Employers bring cheaper workers to the jobs or stagnate wages as best they can which they can do due to surplus labour granted by productivity gains. But if unable B) Employers send the jobs abroad to cheaper labour, but if unable C) More machines and automation. The centrists and classical rights failure to resolve the contradictions of capitalism that have been fucking the workers for decades, resulted in a collapse of legitimacy in the centre ground of politics all over the globe, with 2008 breaking the near subconscious consent of the masses for things as they are, the poor getting poorer, the rich getting richer, never to change. This opens the door to two types of people, the righteous, and the demagogue. The righteous blames the economic system, the righteous tells people not to blame migrants who are exploited equally by the system with them, the righteous wants to end wars, resolve difference, help the poor, but because the righteous would take wealth from the few to help the many, that person and their politics are destroyed by a tag team of centrists, the right wing, the media, and the rich who own them all, simultaneously. The Demagogue blames "migrants/muslims/gays/blacks/jews/insert a minority of choice" in order to divert enough of the peoples attention away from the economic system that is fucking them so as to preserve that economic system. Trump, Matteo Salvini, Jair Bolsonaro, Sebastian Kurz, these are examples of demagogues. Bernie Sanders, Jeremy Corbyn, Jean-Luc Mélenchon, these are examples of the righteous. If our world slips into demagogues in this age, it will be our last age as capitalism itself is incompatible with the physics required to have a future and we have less than ten years left to do something about that before nothing we do will make any difference to the final outcome. If there is a God I hope he will help us as we seem incapable of helping ourselves. www.reddit.com/user/Darkstar-82/comments/a27gy9/statement_capitalism_is_incompatible_with_having/

[@nobblkpraetorian5623]

At least he didn't say Russian bots or that he appealed to racists.

[@DeepsyShade]

Ive never heard a bigger pile of shite.

[@rosshoyt2030]

This is some good satire here , it will piss off both sides prolly innit but probably funny to both too so good job. Good montage at the end too 😂😂😂😂

[@Kampup]

Nobel peace prise for Trump 2019

[@nobblkpraetorian5623]

The Nobel Peace prize is a sham anyway, I don't care if Trump wins it or not.

[@jacobzaranyika9334]

Thank you🙏 accepting your portion of responsibility and NOT threatening and bullying me.

[@sci-fifuture465]

TRUMP 2020! MAGA :D

[@LazyJack2003]

2:00 ... the duck clearly agreed! (So do I, btw.)

[@presidentbean6725]

I’ll vote trump if he gives more tax breaks to the 1% because those guys need a break too

[@susanneyuk-pingpong8705]

👏

[@CaesarsLegion1]

Why the 1%?

[@my_temporary_name]

@@CaesarsLegion1 Isn't it obvious? If you give tax breaks to 99% the budget will lose much money and these people will buy food, change it into shit, and burn the energy waching TV. If you give tax breaks to the 1% the budget will still be alright and these people will invest their money in even more great endevours. Most people in the 1% do great things for the society so taking less money from them will improve the society even more.

[@presidentbean6725]

temporary_name lmao

[@alexanderbeck9337]

Well they do pay more in taxes than the other classes...

[@joshuanesbit]

wow one of your best videos, Pie!

[@makcity7850]

Ugh, Pie gone woke and now peddles for the BBC. Disappointing.

[@MrDaiseymay]

ANOTHER TOSSER

[@manooxi327]

well, we just gotta wait and see how he changes. who knows, maybe he's gonna stay the same, but have a more steady revenue.

[@dantaylor7344]

man sold out.

[@psyberklown3434]

How is trying to convince the left extremists that not everyone on the right is a cartoon villain being woke? And it is possible to hate Trump and not be woke I blame the feminazis for him as it is. They are the cancer Trump is just a tumour.

[@rcm926]

Did you even watch the video?

[@jonnybgood9162]

The most accurate summary and that coming from a comedic actor/comedian says it all about the mainstream media who after 2odd years still hasn't figured it out or secondly who hasn't gotten over it either.

[@ArcanePath360]

MAGA

[@benmitchell161]

I'm curious at what point America is gonna be great again? And when did it lose its greatness? Its just a myth, America has been a superpower since the end of WW2, and the only superpower after the Cold War. Biggest military and economy. How is it not 'great'?

[@ArcanePath360]

The word great is a nebulous term used in an arbitrary manner, so it could apply to any number of things. In terms of growth, employment, and even carbon emissions (despite the news not reporting it) it is better now than it was under Obama. As Trump is a nationalist we can assume that it's these things that he will make great again. America for Americans, not free loaders.

[@benmitchell161]

@@ArcanePath360 The economy was beginning to grow in Obama's last years, let's not forget he came to power in 2009, the greatest recession since the Great Depression occurred in 2008. If you look at statistics from things like growth rate, you'll find that in many cases they were actually higher in Obama's last years. I can tell you one thing is that America is less respected than it was before Trump. I'm from UK and even those who may disagree with his politics think he's a bumbling idiot.

[@pandaeyez]

is MAGA short for 'magazine' because you all kill each other with guns?

[@SCI_WALKER]

MAGA is the whiny cry of entitled angry babies, begging for Big Brother to save them and make them feel nice again.

[@tombicknell5868]

Nailed it.

[@rmatakovich]

Who cares In just glad he did.

[@briaravioli3542]

Rebecca M are you sure?

[@rmatakovich]

Bria ravioli Yes he’s great at business. I do not agree with everything. But the economy is working well. I liked Obama but he just wasn’t a good president. Everyone loved him before he ran.

[@julianskinner3697]

Why?

[@julianskinner3697]

@@rmatakovich Obama rescued us from Bush's recession. Trump has added over a trillion to our debt. The number of new jobs has gone down since trump took over. Now trumps tariffs are making the share market very wobbly. Trump started with 400 million dollars from his dad and became bankrupt. He is crap with money.

[@briaravioli3542]

cary bary not only that but in my opinion, tear gassing people and sending your condolences to families that have gone through trauma is trash. not saying that it’s going to stop all the violence but a gun reform instead of a “i’m sorry” would help. i feel like it’s all personal gain with him.

[@bodyloverz30]

Sort little guy, aren't you Pie!

[@TheActiveAssault]

Brilliant. Well done from a conservative American. I know many conservatives who did not vote for Trump. 🇺🇸🇬🇧

[@roberttaylor3594]

watching this in July 2022...

[@Infernal460]

Round 2 lets go. = )

[@albertardiscohn4900]

Thank you for coming to America.

[@LennyCole96]

Even Obama ran on the words "Yes We Can" like he was talking about everyone together

[@creatorgenerator1998]

Nicely done!

[@buddhistsympathizer1136]

Absolutely nailed it

[@yusufrizvi7219]

Pie walking should be a meme

[@TechnoMediaStation]

JONATHAN PIE IS CRUSHING IT RIGHT NOW, HATS FUCKING OFF

[@Ben-wi6ux]

Anyone remember his old breakdown video in London?