How halal products affect the economy | DW Documentary

[@face13ful]

The woman who said Muslims don’t care about halal or haram except orthodox Muslims is completely wrong. The majority of normal everyday Muslims ensure they eat halal and try to conduct themselves in a halal manner. It does not mean you’re an authoritarian figure. Wow she’s so wrong

[@everythingnothing2978]

Yeah she's wrong but if a Muslim are from muslim majority country,I feel like many Muslims don't care about what they eat either since they already know that all of it can be halal

[@mahmodulhasan7]

@@everythingnothing2978 hmm that only in Muslim majority country

[@spongegameryoloz8633]

@@everythingnothing2978 no they still do care because like in candy they useually use gelatine from pork and they can just write on the package "gelatine"

[@shirinnaveed1109]

I thought exactly the same!! I'm not shocked but wow I was shocked how she could even say that

[@meenafree5931]

Who is she n how can she speak on halal, keep quiet if you don’t understand!

[@PK.Civil.Servant]

He blatantly lied at 14:39 Eating harm is conditional: i. to survive from death & ii. when there is no availability of halal food and you are dying. And the halal food can't be arranged to remain alive. If it can be made available, a Muslim is prohibited to consume haram.

[@ahmedwaleed2687]

Well said bro 👏

[@itistrueitisafact5432]

True brother. This man called Islamic scholar is confused or sold out. He said many misleading statements.

[@faisalz8849]

That guy have doubtful credentials.

[@kingabc4136]

Hallal is indirectly funding terrorist organisation. So stop this to all my muslim brothers.

[@itistrueitisafact5432]

@@kingabc4136 This is not true 100%. Halal business is a business of 2B+ people of the world. What you are saying is the same as eating a pork will increase hate groups in the west which is untrue too. Please stop spreading lies and propaganda.

[@T.O.T.I.N]

Before buying halal food you must make 100% sure that your income is Halal. Haram or forbidden way of income dose not make your food totally Halal.

[@adwaitvedant3297]

*Halal is evil practice of giving suffering to innocent animals by slitting their neck alive + The tax paid by non believers unknowingly for Halal certificate goes for propagation of Izlam , terror activities and other kind of activities like buying media houses to peddle their propaganda and even ban other kind of criticism. Halal is modern age Jizziya*

[@hanipasha8859]

Stop eating meat 🍖

[@ahmedchothia5766]

well said ashraful

[@to-yn2wg]

👌👌👌

[@Healthtoday24]

Absolutly TRUE bro

[@ryanardan09]

I saw this documentary video about halal restaurants in Japan to accommodate the increasing number of Muslim tourists. They send the staff to learn what it's all about up to the process. Japan is always seen as disciplined and trustworthy, the convenience and peace of mind from the halal label in Japan could add some factor to the increasing number of Muslim tourists to Japan.

[@naimachrifi6519]

Ä

[@MrG3ST]

yes more tourism and good economy, nothing to do with segregation etc

[@sinabagherisarvestani8924]

I'm not religious and I don't pray or anything and I try not to eat meat because I'm trying to eat less meat but when I do , I eat halal and it tastes better than regular meat , I think its a better cut of meat , I've tried halal and non-halal meat and I think the halal meat tastes better , there is a difference in taste I think

[@dontbeallergictostudying9179]

@@sinabagherisarvestani8924 I always wonder about this, I live in a country where majority of people are muslim, so without the label, we can consider things sold are halal here, unless you go to eastern side of our country or there's "non-halal" tag/label. I often read about this comment, that halal meat taste better. I wonder if it's because the blood, because one of the reason why halal meat is slaughtered that way is, so that there's less blood in the meat after all.

[@ghondalkhan2465]

Honestly here they once sold us horse meat with cow meat meat labels in our main supermarket brands. Forget about trusting them with halal labels but all is not bad.

[@DarioHaruni]

Ali ibn Abi Talib said: "Do not make your belly an animal grave." Stop with the consumerist attitude. The Qur'an doesn't say "Eat what is permissible (halal)." but it says "Eat what is permissible (halal) and healthy (tayyib)."

[@GoldenuggetZMC]

Fabricated hadith?

[@DarioHaruni]

@@GoldenuggetZMC It doesn't mean that we can't use it to place an example. It is well known that the Prophet ate a plant-based diet. 90% of the time he was semi-vegetarian, 10% of the time he ate meat.

[@GoldenuggetZMC]

@@DarioHaruni you're right, but you shouldn't post inauthentic hadiths, you could've said the Prophet PBUH had a mostly vegetarian diet, May Allah bless you.

[@DarioHaruni]

@@GoldenuggetZMC it's a saying of Imam Ali. I didn't check the authenticity but it is quite poetic.

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

good cult Ibn 'Abbas said: "The Messenger of Allah [SAW] said: 'Whoever changes his religion, kill him.'" Grade: Sahih (Darussalam) Reference : Sunan an-Nasa'i 4059 In-book reference : Book 37, Hadith 94 English translation : Vol. 5, Book 37, Hadith 4064

[@MujtabaTareen-hc3eu]

I as a Muslim completely disapprove of the statements made by so called "Islamic scholars"(referring to the people in the video only, not generalizing other scholars of course) . Muslims cannot choose to eat Haram when in non Muslim countries. Please bring legitimate scholars who speak the truth and not whoever you find at the end of the street, or whoever meets your agenda of portraying the religion in a different, non permissable way.

[@stampmaker9384]

.....but didn't he say this statement quoting the Holy Quran?

[@NineSeptims]

@@jamilamalluf7160 To avoid death and can not arrange halal

[@farismustafa5389]

@@stampmaker9384 he didnt.

[@abdullahozek8016]

In the name of Allah, the Beneficent,the Merciful : The Table Spread, Chapter 5 , Revealed at Al-Madinah by the Holy Spirit ( Angel Gabriel ) to the Prophet Muhammed, peace be upon him, in the early 7th century : 3. ...Whoso is forced by hunger , not by will , to sin : ( for him ) Lo ! Allah is Forgiving , Merciful. The Glorious Qur'an Also Cattle , Chapter 6 , Revealed at Mecca by the Holy Spirit ( Angel Gabriel) to the Prophet Muhammed, peace be upon him, in the early 7th century ; In the name of Allah, the Beneficent,the Merciful : 119. ... , unless you are compelled thereto . ... The Glorious Qur'an

[@halalpolice23]

@@jamilamalluf7160 You can only eat Haram food like pigs if you only starving to death. That is it nothing else we can eat Haram

[@TheSchiffReport]

The first time I saw a Halal label on a yogurt I understood that whoever is using (abusing ) this label has no clue of what Halal is , and that he is probably just confusing it with Kosher ....this is all marketing, often done by non Muslim ...next we will see Halal Pork Chop ......this is getting ridiculous...consumerism is not Halal by itself ...eating meat everyday no matter what you call it cannot be Halal by itself ....

[@harukrentz435]

thats nothing. we had halal chicken eggs here in my country.

[@BioSlayer111]

Yogurt is made with rennet and sometimes this enzyme is sourced from a non-halal animal, this could by why

[@stampmaker9384]

I live in Canada and Halal goat meat costs more than twice compared to non-halal.

[@TheSchiffReport]

@@harukrentz435 LOL 😅😅😅😅😅

[@TheSchiffReport]

@@harukrentz435 I have seen a Chinese Halal restaurant in Canada , also the Buddhist country of Thailand labels all its food exports to Islamic and sometimes non Islamic countries as halal....these people have no clue what halal means they don't understand that it is not halal for a Muslim to eat what a Buddhist prepared no matter what ....

[@mankmantos9292]

I've noticed 2 things missing out so far: 1. The Halal way for slaughtering: - Draining out the blood ASAP which if left, makes the meat harmful. - And drains much more blood than the stunned ones. 2. Men vs Women islamic wear, The long white shirt you showed as "Islamic Men wear" is actually only in hot environments like Saudi Arabia, Bangladesh, etc.. It's more cultural, but not religious. - Technically, for men, anything that covers from the bellybutton to the knee, is Islamic. It would not matter if it's a pair of pants, or Galabiya or something else.

[@engineeringwithprogramming]

Blood in a body "washes" harmful substances, and if left in the body, it defenately worsen the meat

[@mrcrush3r534]

if the pants are tight men shouldn't wear it .

[@ghilbzvilgadz8816]

a food product certified as halal is it really indeed halal when it is grown, manufactured and produced by atheist?????

[@Hi5Ripon]

Bangladesh??? Dude I'm a Bangladeshi and the white robe isn't our clothes either

[@mankmantos9292]

@@Hi5Ripon hey, the documentary showed gulf state clothing and south Asian clothing too.

[@markward3981]

Very interesting DW , I am a Muslim in the U.S.A watching this during Ramadan. The video got a lot right and a few things incorrect however it is really informative on the growing situation in Germany which, I think, mirrors the situation in other areas

[@auguaauaguga6517]

"Mark Ward" is a Christian name as far as I know Are you a revert Muslim

[@markward3981]

@@auguaauaguga6517 I am fasting . I am fasting.

[@alexikamran7039]

Bro, its not that good and I encounter types of issues on regular basis that whether IB is something exist or not. It is not only financial system but its a moral standpoint/

[@ghilbzvilgadz8816]

can you offer something not belonging to you but to someone else???? We as human beings have a sense of decency not to accept anything from someone whom we know for a fact is not the owner of the thing offered, then how much more the almighty, all powerful and supreme being??????? Imagine a faithful offering somethimg not belonging to him but belonging to someone who is unfaithful or atheist, is obviously offering haram and haram should never be offered!!!

[@3-Kashmir]

@@markward3981 lol. Ramadan Mubarak

[@VoicesrilankaSinhala]

The Guy Who said that muslims can eat non halal meat if they in a non muslim country actually telling rubbish. the Hadeeth says if you doubt the meat is halal or haram, say bismillah and eat but avoiding is better. Muslims are only allowed to eat non Halal food when they are life is danger. Thats it.

[@High_Mauntains]

Actually he is telling the truth, even Muslims can eat pork too… read up the Quran

[@RGN737]

islam is very old religion. it can not follow develop of the world. Can you answer me about when a muslim astrounot go to mars/moon , where direction they facing to pray? facing to the west (earth)? :)) that religion just fit for teroris only.

[@roseinayah651]

100% agreed.. I'll choose not to eat the meat or chicken if there is no lalal label.

[@Rommel_209]

Same, I would much more preferred vegetarian or seafood option is the meat product is doubtful

[@islamwithproof20]

Why Halal Food Is Healthy? According to the Halal slaughtering, first we take the name of GOD and then begins... In Halal slaughtering, there are some points that one must remember: 1. Knife must be sharp. 2. Slaughtering should be done quickly. 3. While slaughtering an animal, one must see that other animals are not looking that and many others.(this may cause release adrenaline hormone which is dangerous) 4. You must give water before slaughter 5.The animal should not be infected in any way. While Halal slaughtering, we firstly cut the front part of neck i.e. The wind pipe, vessels of the neck and All arteries and veins because the front part of neck (containing other veins after the throat) is responsible for feeling of pain... So, the animal doesn't feels pain but the shivering portion we see after slaughtering it is due to contraction of muscles and the heart still beats and pumps out much more blood and throws more blood. Blood is a very good medium for germs. So, the halal slaughtering becomes more hygenic and Medical Science also says that "Slaughtered Meat remains fresh for longer period". Whereas if we see this in non-halal i.e cutting from the spinal cords then it may damage the vein connected to heart and brain which may stops pumping of heart and whole blood would collect inside which isn't good for eating. Between 1974 and 1978 professort william schulze carried out a study in hannover University of Germany. They concluded that "Islamic way of slaughtering is the most humane method and that captivate bolt stunning, practiced in the west causes severe pain to the animal." On the study they used 2 devices : EEG And ECG recorder. The first three seconds from the time of islamic slaughter as recorded the EEG device didnt show any cahnge in the graph before slaughter, Thus indicating the animal didnt feel any pain during or immediately after incision. For the following three seconds EEG recorded a condition of deep sleep which shows unconsciousness. After all six seconds EEG shows zero level showing no feel o pain at all. Doctor Vk Modi of central food technology of research institute in mysore says " The halal method is effective in draining out most of the blood from slaughtered animal which is vital if it meats to be soft ". ( Times of India article 27 march 2012 ) In a 2009 study in New Zealand by Professor Craig Johnson, found that stunned animals did not experience pain. But they gave anesthesia on the study. after the anesthesia injection, how the animal feel pain? WANNA KNOW MORE ISLAMIC FACT? Look At My Name.

[@jwh0122]

3:03 glossary 9:00 Halal Food 11:11 slaughter with anesthesia vs ritual slaughter 16:26 Katjes; Decathlon 17:45 Halal Finance 18:36 biz model of halal banking 26:01 halal challenge 31:29 Halal Fashion 35:12 Halal Tourism

[@iforindia8509]

Halal food is Proof of Islamic cultural dominance

[@thinkbeforeyoutype7106]

Thank you. This was very informative.

[@thinkbeforeyoutype7106]

18:35 Wow why can’t we have that in our banks overall? Instead, the big banks take advantage of our hard earn money through interest and unnecessary fees while gambling with our money through speculation nonsense.

[@13Humanbeing]

There is a big potential danger with halal. Halal should be prepared by Muslims only, thus making employment opportunities for Muslims only in specific areas. Besides, non Muslims who deal with similar businesses will have less potential customers as well.

[@containedhurricane]

@@13Humanbeing Everybody should know about this exclusivity

[@carlosgalan1057]

Terimakasih DW atas Dokumenternya. DW kalo bikin dokumenter gak nanggung2 dan sangat mengedukasi memberikan pemahaman tentang halal bagi yang tidak paham salut.

[@someone1089]

Muslims has forgotten the meaning and purpose of Islam. All the attention is given to material, not to the ethics.

[@COMPTROL]

as an exmuslim I can guarantee that you would rather muslim pay attention to material, rather than islamic ethis ( in that whether other people, muslims and nonmuslims, live their life according to islam )

[@israal-mofty5558]

@@COMPTROL Out of curiosity, may I ask why you left Islam?

[@azamkhan1526]

@@COMPTROL as a "exmuslim" answer just one question how many witr are there in zuhr(afternoon) prayer?

[@p4ukp4uk32]

@@azamkhan1526 Good question

[@Omer1996E.C]

@@azamkhan1526 lol, he can search on Google and and answer you

[@Munthasir123]

There are some things that are open to interpretation. I am sure the person who said the following comments said so from their perspective I assume. Around 14 minute someone said Muslims are allowed to eat non Halal food when they live in a Christian society. That is I think absolutely false. Most agree that what was said is that in circumstances when there is no way for one to get Halal food that they are allowed to eat or drink anything to survive. The key word is survival and if halal food is out of reach. If we go by that person’s logic it would be logical to say Muslims can also drink alcohol if they live in a Christian society. Again I think it maybe his perspective but I strongly differ from it and wanted to point it out to anyone interested.

[@ekramkhanshafi]

Exactly. Instead if him, there should be a proper mufti

[@tetadore4778]

Exactly! The same guy also said interest “might not be haram “🥴

[@ekramkhanshafi]

Some serious misrepresentation

[@toshareknowledge]

Masha Allah👍🏼

[@Ruffles2012]

There are Imams in the US who say it's okay to eat non-halal meat because America is a Christian country. It's more common amongst Arabs. All the Arabs I knew in NC said the meat at local grocery stores and even at restaurants is halal. My family was more strict but just saying it is pretty common view in some areas

[@kingsadmin]

14:37 unfortunately he is totally incorrect! scholar says the only exception to eat non halal just in case you don't find anything to eat! (rare of rare)

[@A05-x5e]

I know right. Why a documenter can spread a false information like this.

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

beautifult cult SAHIH BUKHARI HADITH NO. 6922 Some Zanadiqa (atheists) were brought to `Ali and he burnt them. The news of this event, reached Ibn `Abbas who said, "If I had been in his place, I would not have burnt them, as Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) forbade it, saying, 'Do not punish anybody with Allah's punishment (fire).' I would have killed them according to the statement of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), 'Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"

[@halalpolice23]

Only if you dying for hunger is allow, nothing else. That guys just lied

[@mohsankhan9149]

@@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT Obviously if you see non Muslims to cause Muslims to stray from the truth, there would be a logical reason for not having Muslims who leave the religion in your society. I’m sure you’re supportive of Western “tolerance”. So “tolerant” that you’re brain has been emptied. Can’t even distinguish between men and women because you’re hurting someone’s “feelings”

[@ALLAHwithdaughterALLAT]

@@mohsankhan9149 it is cool to hide atheist belief with this cult No doubt I heard Allah's Apostle saying, "During the last days there will appear some young foolish people who will say the best words but their faith will not go beyond their throats (i.e. they will have no faith) and will go out from (leave) their religion as an arrow goes out of the game. So, where-ever you find them, kill them, for who-ever kills them shall have reward on the Day of Resurrection." Reference : Sahih al-Bukhari 6930 In-book reference : Book 88, Hadith 12

[@reviathan3524]

As a Muslim, what's important is what we consume whether it's halal or haram. But my problem is, coming from Malaysia, is when halal and haram is politicized.

[@anekareka7551]

What is that mean friend.

[@sitimrs3221]

Pls elaborate bro...would like to listen more

[@kobo-kanaeru]

@nh Indonesia is currently a halal revolution, who handles halal is now the minister of religion

[@anitkundur5403]

Halal n haram is politicized such as??

[@metalfire86able]

Which one bro, as fellow Malaysian i would like to know too. Maybe u prefer the case before, import meat was non Halal but certificate as Halal. That case should be political level because it raised worries for Muslim people

[@thompsonjake04]

This video at least gets the fundamentals right, such as the vocabulary definitions of halal, haram, makrooh, four main schools of Sunni thought (madhab), etc. at the beginning. While this should be expected and standard, the sheer amount of disinformation across the web about Islam and Muslims on basic concepts is astounding, which is why these basic factoids are remarkable.

[@liberty4175]

You mean Makrull

[@يمانيه_حفيدة_الصحابه]

👍🏻👍🏻

[@thinkbeforeyoutype7106]

Exactly! Contrary to the lies and distortions against Islam by the establishment media and now by the so called "alternative media" as well, Islam is NOT a new religion. In fact, Jesus and all the other Prophets in the Bible were Muslims. Here's the proof… 1. Islam = Submission/Peace. 2. Muslim = One who submits to God peacefully. 3. Prostration = The ultimate way to submit to your Creator. 4. Muslims Prostrate by placing their heads on the ground to worship God. So how did Jesus and all the other Prophets prayed to their Lord in the Bible? Let’s take a look... 5. Jesus Matthews 26:39 39 "Going a little farther, he fell with his face to the ground and prayed" 6. Abraham Genesis 17:3 3 "And Abraham fell on his face: and God talked with him." 7. Moses and Aaron Numbers 20:6 6 "...they fell upon their faces: and the glory of the Lord appeared unto them." 8. Joshua Joshua 7:6 6 “Then Joshua tore his clothes and fell facedown to the ground before the ark of the Lord, remaining there till evening. The elders of Israel did the same, and sprinkled dust on their heads.” 9. Solomon 2 Chronicles 7:3 3 "When all the Israelites saw the fire coming down and the glory of the Lord above the temple, they knelt on the pavement with their faces to the ground, and they worshiped and gave thanks to the Lord, saying, ‘He is good; his love endures forever.” 10. Ezra Nehemiah 8:6 6 "Ezra praised the Lord, the great God; and all the people lifted their hands and responded, “Amen! Amen!” Then they bowed down and worshiped the Lord with their faces to the ground." 11. Revelation 7:11 11 "All the angels were standing around the throne and around the elders and the four living creatures. They fell down on their faces before the throne and worshiped God." May Allah continue to guide and bless us and our fellow human beings

[@thompsonjake04]

@@thinkbeforeyoutype7106 Allahuma Ameen.

[@Vaibhav199327]

Why should I as an atheist know any ‘so called facts’ from someone’s imagination?

[@Likeyzet]

Untuk semua tim DW yang terlibat melakukan riset ini,hingga tersampaikan dengan begitu baik melalui video ini, baik dari muslim ataupun non muslim. Insyaallah video ini akan jadi amal zariah kalian,aminn. yang akan terus mengalir dan menjadi bekal di akhirat. meski roh telah meninggalkan dunia. Semoga allah selalu merahmati kita semua.aminn

[@DWDocumentary]

Thanks a lot for taking the time to comment. We kindly ask our viewers to comment on our channel in English so that we can answer questions and encourage dialogue. Thank you and all the best, The DW Documentary Team

[@sabriritonga8734]

Happy Ramadhan from Bali - Indonesia

[@sephatu6521]

7:55 Now this is the problem with commercialization in any religion. Once people see the potential market, companies just package with labels that sometimes don't really have any true meaning or backing behind it. As consumers and as Muslims, we have to learn and to be thoughtful of what we consume, not taking things at face values. As also a duty with educating the sellers.

[@Fsdgm]

Yes, and we should check what we sell and their certificates by themselves and not allow corrupted certificates companies to run business

[@charmedkitten]

EXACTLY! I’ve always been suspicious of companies who jump on the organic train. We all saw what happened bts with Fairlife. I also found out about “cage free” chickens who really aren’t.

[@thinkbeforeyoutype7106]

@@charmedkitten Exactly! I couldn’t agree with you and everyone else so far.

[@mmamedia2834]

@@Fsdgm anyone can open a company and provide certifications…. The halal certifications industry is very corrupt

[@LA-fr7fx]

Keep halal in Muslim countries? Why does it need to be exported to the West? If Muslims want a Halal life, there is plenty of living space in Arab / Muslim countries?

[@xShariNgaN01x]

This guy who is so called “scholar “ is so far off . Interest aka riba is clearly forbidden , mentioned so many times.

[@fridgemagnet9831]

Riba is excessive interest, like exploitative loans.

[@SassanMedia]

Yet blowing up schools is still Halal

[@wakilimuhamed9766]

Scholar wa mchongo 🤣🤣🤣

[@mezzzgeor8247]

Where is it in the quran?

[@halalpolice23]

@@mezzzgeor8247 یَـٰۤأَیُّهَا ٱلَّذِینَ ءَامَنُوا۟ لَا تَأۡكُلُوا۟ ٱلرِّبَوٰۤا۟ أَضۡعَـٰفࣰا مُّضَـٰعَفَةࣰۖ وَٱتَّقُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ لَعَلَّكُمۡ تُفۡلِحُونَ﴿ ١٣٠ ﴾ • Muhsin Khan and Taqi-ud-Din al-Hilali: O you who believe! Eat not Riba (usury) doubled and multiplied, but fear Allah that you may be successful. Aal-E-Imran, Ayah 130

[@abdurrahimwhytea.zanyoh8833]

DW’s documentaries are always out-of-the-box, unique, thought-provoking and very relevant to the the times. Kudos to the DW team for shedding light on this very critical and important issue. May Allah bless you and the good work you are doing. Ramadan Mubarak to all Muslims across the Globe!🙏🏽 With lots of love from Sweden🇸🇪♥️😊

[@hassanabdul6707]

Ramadan Mubarak to you to brother....

[@britishempireno1fan851]

Sweden used to be a far safer and happier country before you lot arrived.

[@Hollylivengood]

The rest of us could use some blessing too, now. In the neighborhood I lived in in Florida, there were a lot of Palistinians and Jews who fled various countries, so ... in Florida... they were the only ones who understood each other, and they were very close to each other, and explained each other's ways to us. Just proves that religions are impressive looking politics, but God is one. A blessed Ramadan to you as well.

[@kwameadams1140]

i know!!! we are not worthy. the docs are just so well done and what i would never have thought about. Praise to them.

[@suzimonkey345]

🌹❤️🌹❤️🌹

[@troooooper100]

Interest is forbidden and very clearly defined. It was clearly said that from now on people would only have to pay back what they borrowed nothing more and doing so is declaring war on God himself.

[@Quranly]

True

[@mithuyt1]

DW is spreading lies and falsehood by hiring so called Islamic scholar who doesn't know anything about Islam.

[@robmancuso964]

Under Sharia Law subjugating nonbelievers(non-Muslims) and demanding they pay the Jizyah is perfectly acceptable, how lovely!

[@troooooper100]

@@robmancuso964 There is very simple explanation for this, all muslims are required by Islam to pay 2.5% of their total wealth into charity, called Zakat. This is sort of a tax, which is then spent on less well off. Problem became that people who qualify to get this aid don't have to be muslims, they just have to be poor. So in essence, muslim population was subsidizing non-muslim populations. So to make it fair, it was decided that although non-muslims aren't required to pay charity as they are not muslims, they shall still do to make it fair to their muslim counter parts. Imagine that conquerers paying conquered. But this new ruling made the burden equal for everyone.

[@robmancuso964]

@@troooooper100 No, that is not what paying the Jizyah was about. Back in the day, non-Muslims who lived under Islamic rule, had the choice to either convert to Islam, or they had to pay the Jizyah in order to continue practicing their religion. However they were subjugated to Dhimmi status and if they did not pay the Jizyah, they could be killed or enslaved. Dhimmis living under Islamic rule were not considered as equals to Muslims, and were certainly not treated with the same respect as Muslims, to put it very mildly. Do not try to equate paying Zakat(charity) with paying Jizyah, they are not the same at all! Jizyah could best be described as paying ''protection money'', kind of like the Italian Mafia would demand from businesses in their area of control. It was a case of pay up, or else!

[@rhtv3292]

Halal is not business That's our rool of life That's our rlagion

[@jugulawang8696]

Halal is not a business. That's our rule of life. That's from our religion.

[@sakatagintoki8835]

Halal is not business Thats a rule of Allah And people using religion to do businesses

[@nedludd7622]

So who cares? Religion is just superstition for the ignorant.

[@Hmnp910]

It's not yours rather who sell products. It's now a question that whether they are really following Islamic process of making food or not. Whether question is not answered clearly but available in everywhere in the world. That's the point.

[@islamwithproof20]

Why Halal Food Is Healthy? According to the Halal slaughtering, first we take the name of GOD and then begins... In Halal slaughtering, there are some points that one must remember: 1. Knife must be sharp. 2. Slaughtering should be done quickly. 3. While slaughtering an animal, one must see that other animals are not looking that and many others.(this may cause release adrenaline hormone which is dangerous) 4. You must give water before slaughter 5.The animal should not be infected in any way. While Halal slaughtering, we firstly cut the front part of neck i.e. The wind pipe, vessels of the neck and All arteries and veins because the front part of neck (containing other veins after the throat) is responsible for feeling of pain... So, the animal doesn't feels pain but the shivering portion we see after slaughtering it is due to contraction of muscles and the heart still beats and pumps out much more blood and throws more blood. Blood is a very good medium for germs. So, the halal slaughtering becomes more hygenic and Medical Science also says that "Slaughtered Meat remains fresh for longer period". Whereas if we see this in non-halal i.e cutting from the spinal cords then it may damage the vein connected to heart and brain which may stops pumping of heart and whole blood would collect inside which isn't good for eating. Between 1974 and 1978 professort william schulze carried out a study in hannover University of Germany. They concluded that "Islamic way of slaughtering is the most humane method and that captivate bolt stunning, practiced in the west causes severe pain to the animal." On the study they used 2 devices : EEG And ECG recorder. The first three seconds from the time of islamic slaughter as recorded the EEG device didnt show any cahnge in the graph before slaughter, Thus indicating the animal didnt feel any pain during or immediately after incision. For the following three seconds EEG recorded a condition of deep sleep which shows unconsciousness. After all six seconds EEG shows zero level showing no feel o pain at all. Doctor Vk Modi of central food technology of research institute in mysore says " The halal method is effective in draining out most of the blood from slaughtered animal which is vital if it meats to be soft ". ( Times of India article 27 march 2012 ) In a 2009 study in New Zealand by Professor Craig Johnson, found that stunned animals did not experience pain. But they gave anesthesia on the study. after the anesthesia injection, how the animal feel pain? WANNA KNOW MORE ISLAMIC FACT? Look At My Name.

[@makize8428]

Esselamu aleykum from Bosnia ⚜️🇧🇦🙃 Ramadan Mubarek to all muslims brothers and sisters 🌜💚🌾

[@screen_recording]

walaikum salam Ramadan Mubarak to you also brother from saudi arabia

[@rasheed12th38]

Ramadan Kareem from Detroit.

[@arolemaprarath6615]

Bosnia is not European

[@heybudi]

Waalaikum salam sister and brithers

[@heybudi]

@@arolemaprarath6615 they're Muslim Slavic people for sure

[@koalatheworld]

I like halal. Although I am a non Muslim, I feel halal is better suited for my lifestyle.

[@ExposingHindutva101]

Peace be upon you....

[@mintCAT666]

I grow up with mostly home produced meat and I prefer halal meat. Meat tastes yucky if meat has blood left in it, usually can taste it in chicken legs, especially if it got mishandled and had hematoma.

[@everythingnothing2978]

@@mintCAT666 wait so non halal meat is like that? I thought all meat is just the same

[@usmanbinaffan8405]

@@mintCAT666 ❤

[@mintCAT666]

@@everythingnothing2978 if animal is killed properly - it shouldn't be distressed before killing. Halal slaughter meant to be most humane way at times of prophets (and to be honest I don't see a better alternative now too for an actual method). Due to killing animals one by one, even a small ones, care can be taken that animal wouldn't be injured before actual slaughter. In comparison in mass produced meat you get stunned chickens hanged up side down in killing machines by their legs where some that don't get properly stunned starts trashing about. Without additional points of cruelty - method itself has many chances for a chicken to broke bones or bruise. You can't see such big difference on beef or lamb, unless you are very unlucky, but poutry is like a day and night. In Islam animal cruelty or killing animals without purpose is haram.

[@iamsulok2893]

From this we learn that the Qur'an is not only for Muslims and Arabs, but the Qur'an has explained as a way of life for all mankind.

[@TheAlchemist1089]

That's mostly true for all religious books right?

[@everythingnothing2978]

It certainly should have been in English tho

[@d.jmamba7237]

Lmao 🤣

[@no.964]

@@everythingnothing2978 arabic is the language that was chosen and there’s a profound wisdom for it. You can read a translation anytime

[@brave_new_india_science]

That is nothing in front of eastern religion just open your eyes

[@TulangTele]

Halal business is the new concept of capitalism. And using religion is the most effective to con your consumer.

[@anaid5387]

In Malaysia, you can find halal logo on water filter, the reversed osmosis ones. 😅

[@badbadrobotrobot959]

@xenü 2 billion of them and growing every fcuking day. It's going to stay for a long time.

[@md.walidhasan7760]

No, What DW failed to portray is that in Islam " the prerequisite of prayer is to be feed your stomach with Halal food. Unless your prayers will not be granted to Allah according to Muslim monotheism.

[@md.walidhasan7760]

@xenü it will never stop because it has health benefits.

[@TulangTele]

It’s going to stay for long or short periods of time is depends on the awareness of consumer / how human use their intelligence. There are five universal law of stupidity. In economic and business people learn this human behavior to keep them consuming and get benefits. Using religion is the most effective ways to sell and usually the most stupid buying it without thinking twice. To stay healthy not only learning your religious advice but also awareness in environmental health for everyone and surrounding. It’s easy to sell stuff because human born natural greedy, it’s like you sell ice to an Eskimo.

[@RePhantomz]

Hmm i did find the islamic scholar source rather questionable when he state that interest in banking is not prohibited in quran while the contrary the act of lending money with interest was stated several time under the term ribaa. It is prohibited. You can find it in quran surrah ar rum, an nisa al baqarah and ali imran

[@faisalz8849]

Yes I agree, that guy is kind of skewed. Perhaps he’s the so called ‘liberals’ that’s been appointed by non muslims.

[@voiceofnature4714]

Halal is not a economy is a strategy , religious strategy.

[@itistrueitisafact5432]

This is a good step forward. For me I see a lot of potential businesses in HALAL industry not a religion.Iam in Canada and it is hard to find vitamins without gelatin especially OMEGA 3. producing more vitamins without gelatin means increasing your customers, business and profits. ❤️Halal Business 🇸🇴

[@waryaawariiri1812]

Dukaamada Toronto waaka heleysaa, plus Amazon.

[@itistrueitisafact5432]

@@waryaawariiri1812 Aniga Calgary ayaan joogaa. tukaamada waawayn ee ON iyo Albertana badanaa isku mid ma ah in yar mooyaane marka tukaankee ka iibsataan inad adeer. thanks

[@hotmess2766]

Gelatin doesn't mean just pork bones tho

[@sanctvary]

@@hotmess2766 that's true, but the majority of food that contains gelatin is mostly for pigs

[@hotmess2766]

@@sanctvary not necessarily sis where do you get that from? There are many products of gelatin made form cows

[@metaljy08]

14:37 his stament is wrong, Muslims can eat non-Halal food only in extreme cases to not die from hungar, and the ammount of the feed eaten are minimal.

[@muhammadsyed5496]

dont think he knows what he is talking about

[@AAS-fd6qb]

Just wondering have you read Qur'an ever in your life?

[@strawberry-fj7zu]

yeah that man is not Muslim. He is anti-islam and shouldn't be teaching it if he doesn't believe in it. Plus he needs an education about islam and not say everything is misinterpreted just because he wants to be western. He even said women cover up because men told them to. What a liar. Women do it because they love to and respect themselves and they love their religion. What a deluded manipulative fake man.

[@muhammadsyed5496]

@@AAS-fd6qb Are you trying to gaslight?

[@AAS-fd6qb]

@@muhammadsyed5496 You don't even know the definition of the word. Answer me, have you ever read the Qur'an?

[@ibraheemo.olasupo1145]

The choice of food, financial system, dressing and so on does not in any way make someone an extremist or fundamentalist. It's just a choice, exactly the same way a liberalist lives according to whatever pleases him. Therefore, let the world become inclusive of the Islamic code of life. We all belong here. Thank you DW for bringing knowledge to the fore

[@chitrachannelvlog4822]

In Singapore, 17% of the population are Muslims, halal food, restaurants are plenty, but most are owned by non-Muslims, certification costs money, payable to halal food consultations, certification is easy, but followup checks are almost non-existence, flagrant offences at kitchens persists, using of chinese wine, unproper washing of hands on non-muslim kitchen staff after eating pork, purchase of unvaried halal meat, Singapore muslim customers just blindly follow the halal logos, or patronise restaurants that have muslims cashiers as a front attraction. Unscroupulous business earns millions from the muslim comminity.

[@md.walidhasan7760]

This is trust issue but businesses ethics must be ensured if it says Halal.

[@edwin20070]

What's wrong with a non muslim running the store. Please explain

[@chitrachannelvlog4822]

@@edwin20070 theres nothing wrong with non-Muslims running a halal shop, jus follow the guidelines, my concern there are unscrupulous businessman that break the rules.

[@abegum622]

Wow...thanks for sharing...this is sick

[@ikhdarahmatina4272]

Muslim are not allowed to eat non halal meat just because they live in non muslim countries. It totally opposed to the meaning of Qur'an.

[@ghilbzvilgadz8816]

here is my simple question. A food like beef, can it be certified as halal when it is raised, produced and manufactored by an owner who happens to be an unbeliever or atheist????

[@try2justbe]

Both the halal meat and interest is mentioned in the holy quraan with clear instructions on how to handle both.

[@hasyinatulula1413]

@@ghilbzvilgadz8816 if the slaughterer is a muslim and follow the rule of slaughtering, it's halal

[@ghilbzvilgadz8816]

@@hasyinatulula1413 how could it be Halal when it is not owned by the one who offered it?????? Can you offer something to someone which is not owned by you??????? Try to offer something to your parents and them them that what you offer to them doesnt belong to you as it is owned by someone. Let see how will they react.

[@hasyinatulula1413]

@@ghilbzvilgadz8816 ?????? the one who slaughter it take the most important part in halal meat industry! no matter if he just a worker there or an owner, you don't understand

[@shahrulsukirin5875]

Malaysian Halal standard is very strict. Even Kingdom of Saudi Arabia follow Malaysian ban on Australian beef some times ago.

[@__TechAI__]

One think DW got wrong is implying that some clothes can be deemed as halal. This is not true. All clothing is halal. It's how you wear it that makes it suitable or not, in Islam.

[@mh24khan]

You need to exclude BIKINI from your "ALL" 😂

[@IulianYT]

I heard the clothing made out of silk is forbidden in Islam, and clothing of some red nuance also is forbidden for men. But otherwise yes. Also they didn't understood correctly the religion and nation, speaking about men's clothing. The clothing of the Arab men - are not related to Islam, they are not haram, but they are not obligatory. The requirement for the clothing is to cover the body from the knees to belly, but it is not a problem if it covers more than that. Also clothing should not be too restraint, so it wouldn't show the forms of the genitals. So according to these rules - most men clothing in the Europe/"West" is halal, the traditional Arab clothing - is also halal, but it is not required.

[@CoronaViRUS-nk7dx]

What about a clothes made from pigs leather..?

[@TheDtid]

there are no needs which completely halal, there must be a limit between what categorized as halal and haram. Not only from the matters or sources, the method or standard operation, the intention, etc. The one who interest with the halal way should be more critic about this practice, hence not regret.

[@marlengood1972]

@@mh24khan probably not if it’s use in a private setting?

[@GoodGuyChucky-666]

When it comes to meat, there is no guarantee that the meat is halal, if you haven't seen the animal killed in front of your own eyes, because the average person or business owner doesn't have the time, resources or the manpower to scrutinise the supply chain & i know from experience

[@wasimkhan-ic4uj]

That's y people always try to buy meat from renewed person or muslims only bcos they have faith on person butcher

[@sinabagherisarvestani8924]

I'm not religious and I don't pray or anything and I try not to eat meat because I'm trying to eat less meat but when I do , I eat halal and it tastes better than regular meat , I think its a better cut of meat , I've tried halal and non-halal meat and I think the halal meat tastes better , there is a difference in taste I think

[@alikhan-ri5ye]

If a muslim sells you meat as halal, then he takes the responsibility and burden is on that muslim.That is my understanding.

[@itistrueitisafact5432]

@@sinabagherisarvestani8924 It tasts good because it is HALAL. It is slaughtered the way God, the creator of animals allowed to be slaughtered.❤️

[@dhenoyznero]

In Indonesia with a Muslim majority, slaughterhouses if they use a machine then it is enough once to read In the name of God the most merciful then let the machine work to slaughter many animals and all the meat is halal, it's just a formality because it is impossible for you to slaughter many animals by mentioning God's name a lot, Islam is easy religion Even if you are a Muslim and live in a western country then you can eat meat that is slaughtered without using Islamic rituals and that is permissible.

[@emfrhazes]

Good view from DW about Muslim in German generally, very insightful. Islam is a religion of peace very pragmatic and dynamic according to culture of places it's based. Salam from Malaysia.

[@wecare838]

Can you suggest me any read about the dynamic character ? It would be very interesting

[@3-Kashmir]

@@wecare838 If you type in on KZbin. Mufti menk stories of the prophets you should have alot of videos to go through

[@wecare838]

@@3-Kashmir Mufti Menk? Is it in english?

[@emfrhazes]

@@wecare838 I'm in the midst of reading Reasoning With God by Khaled Abou El Fadl.

[@wecare838]

@@emfrhazes thanks. I have to check. He is Algerian?

[@madconstruction1900]

What a sensible topic 🤔 thanks to put it on the table

[@lucaskp16]

is not a sensible topic people just like to panic against people that are different.i am from a catholic family and I cant understand why people would get bothered by Muslim people living Muslim lives in the countries they emigrate to. no one ever says to jews to don't follow their traditions in Cristian countries or get alarmed by them. also don't care what people wear as long as they don't wanna change what I wear.

[@ernesttanabaev7302]

Its not a sensible topic, its just another topic thats okay to discuss openly.

[@vikashsharma9837]

Rubbish topic

[@danielyonas9928]

Check out CHRISTIANITY & ISLAM DEBATES

[@youtube-user25]

@@lucaskp16 I’m sorry but Catholic has nothing to do with religion and Christianity.

[@bitter_truth8646]

Europeans, I really don't understand why we need to negotiate our customs and traditions in our countries with the foreigners. If they don't like our ways, then they are free to go somewhere with the same beliefs and traditions they believe.

[@balbal4982]

They are not foreigners at all. They are European but converted to Islam.

[@familyacounttv6667]

The world has changed vastly and more accessible to humans then any time in history. Having a Mosque a long time ago in the UK is acceptable now in 2022 than in 1022. If Europe is willing to have mosques than the middle East should equally have churches

[@elpresidente1822]

Very tolerant of you

[@francisd3740]

@@balbal4982 they are not

[@PK-tt5kk]

@@elpresidente1822 very intolerant of u. u want segregated public spaces ?? Animals butchered in the worst way ?? Woman covered up ?? NEVER

[@alembess9129]

24:05 " Strict adherence to halal and haram can lead to an authoritarian system of normative or political Islam." -- Hit the nail right on the head...

[@russelhavard7818]

First of all, thank you for the subtitle on Bahasa Indonesia, secondly Thank you for spreading the good and nice info about halal on islam, also the details on the principle (there are fundamentalist and the modern, which cannot be seen as the same for everyone and everything) Hoping this info will reach to many Happy Ramadhan fasting 🙏

[@daisyfleur2334]

Faktanya di Barat sertifikat HALAL itu hanyalah sebuah bisnis semata...

[@mobbu6527]

Halal is evil

[@pustakarileks7404]

@@daisyfleur2334 faktanya sama aja di indo juga, kulkas, baju, kerudung bisa halal

[@ahmadnaufalridlo1489]

@@daisyfleur2334 indo gak beda jauh

[@ahmadin5681]

Iyah kenapa DW bela-belain taruh bahasa Indonesia ? Dugaan saya karena pasara halal di Indonesia dan negara muslim di asia tenggara yang melayu adalah yang terbesar dan fakta bahwa region ini adalah kawasan kedua di asia dengan jumlah kelompok pendapatan menengah terbesar setelah asia timur

[@naturallight4745]

*2:15* “It can influence diet, clothing, work & *EVEN* one's choice of a partner”. Girl, *PARTICULARLY* one's choice of a partner‼️

[@mariajuvie]

I'M NOT MUSLIM, BUT I TRUELY 👍❤ HALAL FOODS. #CLEAN #HEALTHY❤❤❤🙏

[@laiththetruthseeker2745]

❤️

[@bitosan7800]

You mean you like to buy from it

[@islamwithproof20]

Why Halal Food Is Healthy? According to the Halal slaughtering, first we take the name of GOD and then begins... In Halal slaughtering, there are some points that one must remember: 1. Knife must be sharp. 2. Slaughtering should be done quickly. 3. While slaughtering an animal, one must see that other animals are not looking that and many others.(this may cause release adrenaline hormone which is dangerous) 4. You must give water before slaughter 5.The animal should not be infected in any way. While Halal slaughtering, we firstly cut the front part of neck i.e. The wind pipe, vessels of the neck and All arteries and veins because the front part of neck (containing other veins after the throat) is responsible for feeling of pain... So, the animal doesn't feels pain but the shivering portion we see after slaughtering it is due to contraction of muscles and the heart still beats and pumps out much more blood and throws more blood. Blood is a very good medium for germs. So, the halal slaughtering becomes more hygenic and Medical Science also says that "Slaughtered Meat remains fresh for longer period". Whereas if we see this in non-halal i.e cutting from the spinal cords then it may damage the vein connected to heart and brain which may stops pumping of heart and whole blood would collect inside which isn't good for eating. Between 1974 and 1978 professort william schulze carried out a study in hannover University of Germany. They concluded that "Islamic way of slaughtering is the most humane method and that captivate bolt stunning, practiced in the west causes severe pain to the animal." On the study they used 2 devices : EEG And ECG recorder. The first three seconds from the time of islamic slaughter as recorded the EEG device didnt show any cahnge in the graph before slaughter, Thus indicating the animal didnt feel any pain during or immediately after incision. For the following three seconds EEG recorded a condition of deep sleep which shows unconsciousness. After all six seconds EEG shows zero level showing no feel o pain at all. Doctor Vk Modi of central food technology of research institute in mysore says " The halal method is effective in draining out most of the blood from slaughtered animal which is vital if it meats to be soft ". ( Times of India article 27 march 2012 ) In a 2009 study in New Zealand by Professor Craig Johnson, found that stunned animals did not experience pain. But they gave anesthesia on the study. after the anesthesia injection, how the animal feel pain? WANNA KNOW MORE ISLAMIC FACT? Look At My Name.

[@Mambra2u]

It is not about segregation. It is about choice. If you want muslim to buy you must provide what they want. If you ok with vegetarian. So do to halal product. It is about providing choice.

[@lo2740]

no, its all about money and bigotry

[@ggeo1364]

it is about funding the Al-Quida

[@wsvdwrgvbrwfv]

If M wants to stay in non Muslim country u have to adjust otherwise leave, don't expect others to accommodate u all the time

[@miorfaizulsabki6667]

​@@wsvdwrgvbrwfvthen why there are non muslim eating non halal food in Indonesia?

[@wsvdwrgvbrwfv]

@@miorfaizulsabki6667 coz Indonesians are culturally Hindu so are tolerant of others

[@read7641]

Please do a segment on Kashmir. It’s history and struggle. Non biased opinion please.

[@sabujsen9498]

Also Kashmiri Pandits genocide ✌️

[@orionpacks]

@@sabujsen9498 and also on the war crimes of indian army

[@christianacaroline2452]

This inspired me a lot to become a Muslim ❤

[@niranjansrinivasan4042]

lol, good luck trying to get out of that cult

[@Ducktility]

@@niranjansrinivasan4042 it's an abdul with a fake name

[@Palestine4Ever169]

Welcome sister Btw Ignore the radical hindutva they are radical and dont represents all hindus

[@bm8292]

Hotel California song by the Eagles group is worth listening to.

[@zibrantaybie]

Masha Allah

[@SherifaNakalema]

KZbin just got me to this video maybe because just yesterday I recorded a video about halal money. Here in USA it's hard to avoid interest so I am sharing how to earn money that is halal. This is a good educational video! Thank you.

[@asrofficialviews]

Send me that interest if it is haram..🤣🤣

[@kingabc4136]

Hallal = terrorism.

[@memnem3787]

Why you don't go to 58 your religion majority nations?. Why come with your third world culture to West?

[@clarkstonga]

I am dumbfounded by a blind hate by those who claim to follow Jesus, who dresses as Muslim, grew beard and his mother also covered her hair and surprisingly didn’t eat pork.

[@ns.hidayat]

read Al Quran surah Almunafiqun. It explains clearly

[@therighteousrighthand]

That's because Jesus said it's not what goes into your mouth but what comes out that defiles you.

[@yassine073t]

Also he named his Lord, Allah which means God in both Aramaic and Arabic.

[@keybordfighter7672]

@@therighteousrighthand but can a Jew say such nonsense?

[@TamimLB]

I'm from South Africa, usually things here are Halal and you don't often see false halal or even non-halal meats (other than pork). When I went to Australia however, I found lettuce with the halal label on it. I died

[@BASMA13-w9p]

ههههههه😂😂😂😂

[@ans42131]

Never thought I'd see Halal (حلال) label from so many perspectives and in so many different industries. Thank you DW for such an insightful documentary.😄

[@daisyfleur2334]

"Halal it's about money, NOT religion"

[@ans42131]

@@daisyfleur2334 either way it's benefitting people . With your type of mindset one should stop wearing clothes stop using your smartphone,SIM card or anything cause it earns someone money 💲🤷🏻 Edit; infact you shouldn't even be watching this video cause it helps a German channel and it's not about informing people .

[@vikashsharma9837]

@@ans42131 This is apparently discrimination to those people who have distinctive religious notion; treating all people in same way is a safe&secure society according to you all these business model great way for Muslims to do whatever they can segregation can never create harmony between communities all this delineates radical Islamisation

[@elennet4116]

@@ans42131 it's beneffing only Muslims, who are monopolizing on industries imposing their Sharia Law based Halal on Non Muslims

[@ans42131]

@@vikashsharma9837 Muslims didn't force those companies to get a halal lineup , the industry saw benefit in it and so they made one . It's just like how during Kashmir solidarity day(5th Feb) some major companies like Hyundai,Toyota, Honda and many others gave ads on Pakistan media channels and tweets about it on the other hand the same companies were apologizing for it in India cause India is a bigger market for them , I can give you countless examples That's just how things work ,it's just business for them.

[@haddingtoniangcp2464]

An Asian asked me for a place to eat and I recommended a Mexican spot. "Is it halal?" "It Is Mexican". They laughed.

[@imransiddique8794]

🙏

[@aminmhmd1395]

22:07 there's no one among our scholars who says that interest is allowed

[@aquibizhar7361]

Brother I think he is on an agenda

[@no.964]

@@aquibizhar7361 they’re all shayateen

[@dembobatchilly3143]

Wonderful Doc!! Great insight Thanks DW

[@lA-tv1qt]

14:37 These are the kind of people who sell their religion for a small price, just like Quran says.

[@timothyzakaria7397]

This is good to know I have Afghan heritage and learning the halal process is important. I'm not a Muslim but Kosher or Halal products I have consumed in the past

[@dchegu]

In my country, the halal thing has gone way overboard Example, hot dogs can't be called hot dogs if they want a halal certification. Reason? The name is not halal. Not the ingredients mind you, the word hot dog is not halal. Another example, a hotel restaurant wants to have halal certification so that it can get government functions. It has a Chinese restaurant as a neighbor. The halal board wants the Chinese restaurant to move out if the hotel wants the certificate. Apparently having a non halal restaurant in the same building is not halal

[@immortalwombat7095]

which country is this?

[@Jakabokbotch2nd]

You Malaysian is it 😏

[@robertusthemac]

Malaysia is an Islamic theocracy, where religious minorities (Hindus, Christians) are routinely persecuted. Not surprised

[@bayersbluebayoubioweapon8477]

Wow, it sounds like the halal thing is now halal

[@dchegu]

@@immortalwombat7095 the only country in the world where politicians caught red handed stealing billions of taxpayers money are venerated n celebrated as saviour of the country

[@complicatedjason]

Why should we pay organisation to certify food that will take money to donate to a religion which we don’t believe?

[@amb5176]

exactly right. Halal certification = forced religious donations built into the price of your groceries = violation of religious freedom

[@princesscindrella1507]

You right

[@lil_jong-un6668]

Because you want to profit from muslims, duh.

[@mohammadinthiyaz7422]

@complicatedjason it's your choice no one forcing you to sell halal products

[@razeka62]

Isn’t the concept the same as kosher food? Do you have a problem with that too ?

[@Abu_Shawarib]

Thanks, DW. Really nice documentary. I would like to note a small error, which is that Islam don't put that many restrictions on clothing for men. Thus, I would not call it a dress code. Things I know to be forbidden for men are wearing gold, silk, long dangling robes, and shorts. There's no recommendation of a specific type of clothing, like white robes as you mentioned.

[@mufaaz97]

White robes is a cultural thing

[@MC-fw5vt]

they are supposed to wear clothes that cover from belly button to below knees, but most can't be bothered. just check out men from Muslim countries at the Olympics (vs women, who are seriously policed and potentially killed for lapses by their families or societies).

[@demoncloud6147]

There is no such thing as 'Halal Banking', renaming interests as profit/revenue-sharing does not make banking halal. This is how I see it, disagree is you like

[@omarsaker4475]

The main difference is that the Halal banking has a higher risk of losing its money, because it does not use interest. Regular banks who use interest will always win and have a vey low risk (if none) to lose its money. Another huge factor is that interest is neverending and can keep adding for years. On the other hand, the final price is always stipulated at first, and it does not change. Example: You want to buy a car, in a regular bank you get the loan, and pay it monthly plus interest, if you start missing payments, the interest will add, mking you final payment bigger than it should have been. In an islamic bank, the first thing that the bank tries to make is to contact the dealership and try to get a discount by paying full. If the dealership gives, let us say -1,500$ discount, then the bank sells it to you at the first price and has its profit. If the discount does not happen, the bank buys the car, and adds a profit magin diectly to the price. The change is here, monthly you will be making payments, but if you miss on them, the final amount of money does not change.

[@jamesspent7101]

Fully agree with you. Islamic banking is a sham. You can spin it whichever way you like. Interest is wrong.

[@MahanMirza]

@@omarsaker4475 Though your example is a good one of how it works in principle. The reality is that I doesn't work like this! The risk premium on halal banking is higher. Therefore the final amount you pay on the loan is almost always higher than well established non halal banks in the UK or other western countries! Another example is that in Iran the current interest you get paid on leaving your money in the bank is around 20%. They say that this 20% comes from halal investment of your money. This is an utter lie and all they do is print money and label it halal. Its funny people don't mind when they receive interest on their cash but don't like to pay in on their purchases! Lol

[@LA-fr7fx]

Keep halal in Muslim countries? Why does it need to be exported to the West? If Muslims want a Halal life, there is plenty of living space in Arab / Muslim countries?

[@anaid5387]

There is no such thing as halal fashion too. Halal is now the term used to sell more things appealing to Muslims.

[@whhusa]

Love how the world is becoming more segregated vs integrated.

[@bayersbluebayoubioweapon8477]

Do you think the same about kosher food? I don’t. I have friends who won’t eat meat on fridays either: are they wrong?

[@heybudi]

If the integration means we have to follow your Haram standards so, no thank you!

[@ireneroth8252]

@@bayersbluebayoubioweapon8477 Kosher only concerns food; while Islam is a way of life. And muslims' first loyalty is to their allah. I find that disturbing, and dangerous, And no comparison to some Jewish traditions that do NOT affect anyone else but the people who observe the Kosher laws. Which I, being an atheist Jew, certainly do not.

[@whhusa]

@@heybudi no one is asking you to adopt to anything.....just stay in cave

[@whhusa]

@@bayersbluebayoubioweapon8477 what I'm saying is that the world is becoming less tolerant of others. To me integration is better communications vs drawing a line in the sand and telling I will go to hell just my beliefs are different.

[@marwakhateeb3721]

As I come from a muslim ,conservative family, I know that Islamic teachings are incredibly able to structure our lives and tackle many modern issues that we face on a daily basis. By carefully following Islamic rules dedicated in the holy quran and Sunnah. Not to mention that Allah did not prohibit without reasons so that by reading the Quran and its valid interpretation, we will be able to understand why Allah has categorized into haram and halal because everything Allah is doing fror reasons. However, may Allah accepts fasting and prayers from us I this holy month (RAMADAN )

[@usmanbinaffan8405]

exactly

[@cobidbeksin5200]

Pork is delicious though

[@Lyallpuriya]

@@cobidbeksin5200 So? What's your point?

[@misterx3770]

@@cobidbeksin5200 in my country there are many pigs, especially wild boars, if you want you can come here, eat them if you want

[@Whoami1988_]

What a BS 😂😆

[@ym8447]

The Ethnologist, the guy from the university, the "scholar" seem to lack a vast knowledge about the Islamic halal and haram concepts. Halal and haram are at the core of the Islamic belief. The three guests are there in a way to lessen the importance of halal of everything.

[@yamizer0]

halal is not only refer to food, clothing and bank. even you eat halal food, but you get it by stealing from another person. that food is considered haram ( forbidden ).

[@Stocksandflows]

Nice documentary. This is an eye-opener for me as a Catholic. I just learned now that there are even halal hotels and banks. So sad to know though about the hate crimes. Stop Islamophobia. We should embrace diversity. Peace to our Muslim friends. 🙂🙂🙂

[@kaka09876543210]

Lol, you must ask what halal about it if you found it somewhere.

[@19859999]

Wow. Soon Halal will take over the business of non Muslims. Its food Racism. The halal certification charge are going to mysterious activities.

[@KS-kw1gb]

No... Great Dane wake up ....its yt hate

[@imsoenlightened9199]

He is lying from 14:40. Muslims aren't allowed to consume haram food just because they live in a non-muslim country. This guy doesn't know what he is talking about. If he likes to eat haram stuff so to please the secular state so be it but don't force your viewpoint on other muslims.

[@face13ful]

This documentary has some very strange views. They should have done their due diligence when interviewing such people. That guy is so wrong.

[@zahoramour3344]

14:38 he better provides the verse in quran that allows that. The only way we are allowed to consume non halal food is when we are starving to a possible death, only then we can consume a sufficient amount of non halal food just to survive

[@irmakharisma2198]

This video showed social phenomena, pros and cons, and opinions about Islam from a different side. great work DW

[@angelobugini6771]

It's an outstanding documentary. Thanks DW.

[@streetscienceofficial8675]

Angelo you must be Bugini

[@MOHAMEDALI-rl7kx]

The last people who spoke just gave the right answer,we just need people expect our views and it should be a mutual one

[@tajammulsiddiq9880]

34:53 : "Halal and Haram are designed by Man" This is again the wrong interpretation of Religion. Halal and Haram are not designed by Man. It is given by God. Woman Covering themselves is not Patriarchy. It's a Protection for Women so that they won't be teased or judged on the basis of their physical body and it protects from evil eyes of few Man. And women can do all sorts of work outside (productive in nature) in Hijab. Regarding cosmetics, we should understand that there is a difference in using light makeup and heavy makeup. Light makeup won't change the complexion of face of women contrary to heavy makeup. And every woman understands what they are doing with their face. She knows and understands their own intentions. Here But it's very rightly said by women(who wore makeup) in this video that showing beauty/charm is for partners. Decency in dressing should be adopted outside but when it comes to showing beauty and charm it's for partners. People who says that we are using makeup, dresses up well are for themselves. They are not right here because majority wants to look themselves good/attractive in other eyes. That's why they present themselves like they want to see. We should be well dressed but there should be a decency in dressing so your outlook should not be result in being uncomfortable to opposite gender. Personally I am not in the favor of using Cosmetics by Woman because cosmetics gives women an artificial look and hides their originality. We should be comfortable with our Skin/Face. We can freshen up our face by adopting a healthy lifestyle: proper diet, healthy food, exercise, not to take stress, meditation/prayers, use natural skin care products. These are the things that help in developing a healthy body and skin.

[@faizafaiza6524]

Ramadan Mubarak to All my brother's, sister's around the world 💖

[@arigisku]

@ 22:18 minutes, the Quran specifically bans Interest; 'Riba". See Surah Al Imran verse 129-130; Surah An Nisa verse 161. So the argument that the Quran does NOT forbid Interest or Usury, is not tenable. Secondly, the speaker #SusanneSchroter, an ethologist claiming, Muslims in Germany or any other country do not need to follow the Quranic or Islamic Jurisprudence in their daily lives except the few extremist is NOT True. If you are a Muslim, you are enjoined and expected to live by the Quran and hadith in both personal, social, political and professional lives. Accordingly, she is simply displaying her ignorance of Islam as normally displayed by most Orientalist and Ethnologists from the Western world. They normally claim knowledge of a Religion or People, yet they neither can read the religious texts in its original language nor speak the language of the people they claim to be experts of. Despite the good intentions of the producers #DW, its clear the choice of persons to speak on the subject of #Halal falls short of expectation, and thus portrays it as bias, like most presentation from western media on Islam.

[@try2justbe]

Thank you!👏

[@KS-gv8jy]

Agreed I was shocked by the interest comment true Islam is both simple and vast subject at the same time ,I looked in to one subject of Islam and it took 2 years and a teacher to understand it and most people now a days neither care or have the time

[@basismoslem6436]

in Islam, Margin is allowed, but interest is forbidden. It is just changing the terms.

[@zaheer855]

In India there is a conspiracy theory that Halal is way to deprive others of buisness, but it's completely baseless. Halal is just making sure the product is pure and most importantly money you use it to buy products is halal hard earned.

[@zukhriddin8388]

MashaAllah, I didn't expect accurate explanation from DW 11:53

[@PK.Civil.Servant]

Halal or harm is the essence of being Muslim. That is the very meaning of Islam i-e to do what pleases lord and to stay away from what displeases him! No more no less refer 24:18 It is important to adhere to norms

[@daninu7026]

I appreciate DW for bringing up this theme, in my country this topic is common. but I read the comments and it turns out this topic is quite sensitive for some non-Muslims

[@robmancuso964]

@@blueberrycanelloni5724 Hey Einstein, if ''no harm'' was done to the animal then it wouldn't die!

[@maryreid4273]

@@blueberrycanelloni5724 I understand Halal slaughter does not include stunning beforehand, this is why I would always avoid it.

[@mohamednor4528]

DW is always informative and it's viewers gain a great knowledge from it. Keep up the good work DW.

[@DWDocumentary]

Thanks for commenting. We appreciate the positive feedback.

[@learningpointinlife8311]

World no have human rights watch for Palestine girl and women crying?

[@learningpointinlife8311]

@@DWDocumentary we love you million of people in the world because you are world hero understanding Quran explain Allah bless you and reward you paradise Thanks for sharing true news

[@DGraze]

Personally never heard this statement and argument 14:44 Which he imply that we 100% can eat haram food in other non-muslim country.

[@opuntian]

??????

[@DGraze]

@@opuntian yes buddy ?

[@jasminhabeeb]

Only if you are travelling/visiting, and haram food is offered to you(this is done so as to respect your host, islam is not inhuman guys 🤷🏽), not if you are living there.

[@FishingAdventuresDubai]

That dude has nothing to do with Islam except that his ancestors were probably remotely Muslims. Now he is giving advise on Islamic topics 😂

[@face13ful]

@@jasminhabeeb as Muslims you should not be eating haram food at all. Except if an extreme situation such as you’re dying from hunger etc. A respectful host will never offer haram food to a Muslim guest anyway.

[@peachnaise5221]

In Indonesia, refrigerators even have a halal certificate 😭I thought halal only for food and drink no bacon no alcohol but I was wrong

[@viewer1755]

I think thats so pork and halal products don’t get mixed together

[@peachnaise5221]

@@viewer1755 maybe My mom bought a new refrigerator and after arriving there was a halal sticker until now it hasn't been removed

[@galaddiinahmed7091]

I always watch DW documentaries love 💕 it Thank you for the info about halal🥰

[@josephfamiyeheduful2495]

I wonder what I wouldn't have known without your outputs 🤗🤗🤗. Thank you @DW

[@sagalmaxamedsaakin8920]

I have never ever drunk alcohol and never ate pork meat and never made a sexual intercourse with other strange girl and never killed a person and that’s what Holy Qur’aan is prohibited me to do and I really liked to be safe from that all thing and I think that’s what I different from other non-Muslims. Allah may give me bless. Thnks allah to became me Muslim and I proud of it❣️❣️❣️

[@nabilh.6357]

So called Islamic banking is frudelent business indeed. It's a different way of labelling a financial organization dealing with the central bank.

[@PHlophe]

Nabeel, find me a bank that ain't corrupt and i'll sell you a damned bridge

[@davel9514]

@@PHlophe The bank of me isn't corrupt, but it never has any money in it - can I have my bridge now?

[@roughroadrunner88]

Almost everything is compromised. Hard to find "pure" these days.

[@WAHRHEIT402]

24:00 islam is an integrative whole law to lead the best life

[@faazk]

A good documentary, covering how a way of practice/ a way of living: 'Halal', is being abuse. In the whole documentary, the interpreter Burhan Kesici was the most sensible person, everything he said was logical and to the root. Some interpreters unfortunately did not fully understand it either and had their own far right views.

[@100monotheist-fkeroffalseg8]

I mean slowly making animal die is cruel too, animals do the same, we shud be more humane....like guillotine type

[@mohdghazali3473]

@@100monotheist-fkeroffalseg8 How did you know the animal die slowly, did the animal tell you or it's just based on observation without prior knowledge. Beside, Halal is not just about slaughtering ritual.

[@kingabc4136]

Hallal = terrorism.

[@omnipotent3955]

@@mohdghazali3473 instant death is better than slow death

[@MD-uz6nc]

@@omnipotent3955 I once saw a chicken running around with a chopped of head. That was supposed to be instant death, but it was awful.

[@boburzod]

There's a book called "Destiny Distupted: A history of the world through Islamic eyes". Recommended to both Muslims and non-Muslims who want to know a little bit more about Islam from scientific point

[@rarindraprakarsa4376]

Halal is big business in Indonesia. Your product simply doesnt contain pork or alcohol, thats consider 'halal" most of the time. Any product with the logo, it might multiply the selling. Wondering there is no 'halal" logo in cigarette pack but there is "halal" logo in one brand of refrigerator .

[@Get-Agar]

Refrigerator! 😊

[@syrenasketches6902]

All I know is that Middle Eastern food is fire.

[@danielahmed8162]

@@Cav205 Yeah in Ukraine 😁😁😁😁 lots of prove.right

[@vitalijslebedevs1629]

A well-made sheesh kebab is a nice fire, though. Maby i'm a jack-ass eating fire, funnily enough not sh|tting fire afterwards🤔

[@alembess9129]

14:23"With all due respect, religion does not have the right of way in our democratic system."... you got it right.

[@onlineeducationnepal7842]

*Halal, Umrah and Hajj are some of biggest religious business, Saudis consider Atheist as terrorist as it harms their business if people became less religious* ❤️❤️

[@arbaz79]

Thank you DW for this informative documentary on the topic of Halal products.

[@sarbjitkloy2437]

Can't understand How's banking system is halal or haram.

[@syedsalman2374]

Being a Muslim still I dont understand it. I guess its just a marketing tactic to attract customers. The working of these banks are same as any other bank but banking terms are changed to islamic terms.

[@nuknuk331]

Answer hidden mainly in interest .. if bank profits using ur money then u can receive interest the money u keep in bank.. and if bank won’t profit anything then u can’t get any interest.. and their is more..

[@syedsalman2374]

@@nuknuk331 thanks for increasing my knowledge

[@sunnyday4055]

interest is forbidden in Islam

[@nuknuk331]

@@sunnyday4055 that’s true and Islamic way it’s called profit /loss sharing…

[@Abdullahbd56]

14:39 He has no clear knowledge on halal & haram food. Haram food is conditionally permissible 1. For survival from death when there is no halal food for survival

[@fahri.konevi]

HALAL EAT, STAY FIT ‼️ يَٓا اَيُّهَا النَّاسُ كُلُوا مِمَّا فِي الْاَرْضِ حَـلَالاً طَـيِّباً ⁠ۘ   وَلَا تَتَّبِعُوا خُطُوَاتِ الشَّيْطَانِ⁠ۜ   اِنَّهُ لَكُمْ عَدُوٌّ مُب۪ينٌ Baqara, 2/168)

[@xoxofrancoise7077]

I'm laughing about the fish😅🤣😂 as a Muslim, I knew how he felt right away, I too have the same experience.

[@flyingnutrition6199]

they put vegan on almonds and packed apples ... the thing is , a lot of people live all their lives in cubicles and know nothing about food and the origin.... more and more have no idea ...

[@alixasan8667]

This beautiful thank you DW Team 💕

[@naturerules7176]

Total non-sense that Muslims can eat non-halal meat as per Quran interpretation. May be some of these people are from Middle East or Iran who can even eat Haram meat sometime in foreign countries.

[@sdaniaal]

this is taken severely out of context, I believe the only reason given for someone to be able to eat non-halal food is if there is absolutely no halal food nearby and would otherwise die of starvation... so yeah pretty extreme and not quiet simple.

[@solovetsky6683]

He is a cunning fox bro, he was allured to say something cunning in favour of christianity so that he get money. I even doubt who made him scholar ? Is a Haram scholars.