How HYBE Failed fromis_9

[@snsdkbopper7819]

Unfortunately 1 thing that I've learned as a longtime Kpop fan, Is that superior talent & music quality strangely doesn't guarantee success.

[@IY_Official1]

@@snsdkbopper7819 True ! Same here Look At fromis_9 best vocals and dance in Whole HYBE GG's but no support from Company !

[@onetwothree8359]

nahh if the group have good n hit songs ,they will success . n have strong based

[@sphixion]

@@onetwothree8359 Nine Muses. Amazing songs. Talented and beautiful girls. Horrible agency.

[@SBBunny93]

@@onetwothree8359 lol this is not true. A “good and hit” song does not equate to success.

[@juanshaftpatel7488]

they need to do the diddy ritual with Bang

[@theaceyuchan6007]

What hurts me the most is Their albums are literally soo good but they aren't popular international

[@davey6022]

So true I love their music

[@SeolJeongg]

Glad they are out of PLS DIE entertainment, Please continue to support them where ever they go! AND STREAM THE FAN SONG ON THE 23RD!!

[@Limonelguey]

I mean what you expect from Pledis? They failed after school, orange caramel, pristin, and now fromis_9.

[@nicoleloss7987]

Pledis entertainment girl group never have long contracts

[@banjo3986]

Except the past 3 comebacks had each sold almost 200k albums and almost always entered the top 20 of all streaming charts in Korea, getting many wins as well. Pristin has minimal sales and 0 wins.

[@20f124]

The saddest part in all of this is that this video only discusses the mistreatment they faced after joing Pledis/hybe in 2021. They've been through hell since 2017 and none of that was mentioned.

[@dmontegar]

I need them to redebut😢

[@tianx9275]

In a super saturated and competitive market like Kpop, that will be very difficult.

[@hallooos7585]

I hope Gyuri comes back…

[@djmenez10]

Hope they find a new label

[@Rbosikwig]

The BIGGEST failure from HYBE ever, putting them in a long hiatus IS a big mistake, they are 8 now, I thought the music wil be lousy BUT their music are amazing as 8,hope they can bring the FROMIS name when they leave, flover forever ❤❤❤they are in their PRIME

[@Ellakimmy-i9s]

That's pledis fault not hybe !

[@sakurakou2009]

Hybe biggest mistake was hiring mhj and giving her total control and even her own sub label, and also disbanding gfrined but now they trying to correct those mistakes, but formis_9 is totally pledis false the group was struggling since they debut even before pledis join hybe

[@Rbosikwig]

@@Ellakimmy-i9s you're a CONTRARIAN

[@Ellakimmy-i9s]

@@Rbosikwig 😅and at the back of ur head u really think I would care what ur opinion about my statement is u def sound ridiculous to me

[@Rbosikwig]

@Ellakimmy-i9s put this on your brain your on my payroll

[@wizardshome9686]

In the end, they come up with a huge hit in SUPERSONIC - Let's not forget The Game Caterers event they literally stole away from the other groups attending that event. These girls have huge talents and personalities to match - they are completely different from any other girl group in Korea.

[@davey6022]

It’s a damn shame the way Fromis 9 is treated. I will follow them in their next chapter if that is what they choose to do.😭❤️

[@Pledisboos13]

They deserve better!!

[@Nieves001]

The fact that Hybe and their companies take their talented girl groups for granted first it was Gfriend and now Fromis9. I will never forgive them for what they did to Gfriend and I'm glad at least Fromis9 are staying together and not disbanding

[@Babee76]

Pledis is their label & they have already had track records of mismanagement of artists even before they joined HYBE.

[@Kpopsele]

Fromis truly deserved better but pledis has a strong history of failing their girl groups.

[@banjo3986]

Supersonic really put them on the whole of the general public’s radar in Korea, just for Pledis to not try to renew with them

[@Serena-Vanderwoodsen]

Hybe is eager to promote a certain 5 member girl group that cannot sing to save their lives, yet, they treat my Fromis_9 girlies like dirt. Despite them having vocals, looks, amazing sync in dance. Smh. But at the same time, I’m really pleased for my girls (atleast they’re free of being treated so horribly). I really do hope they thrive once they leave.

[@Ellakimmy-i9s]

Blame pledis for not giving them songs they're the ones incharge of that many more over fromis 9

[@TheLeif001]

@@Ellakimmy-i9s Why not make their own songs? or atleast have the voice to choose better songs? Music is also very subjective hence this could also be an issue. It is possible that fans are not the hoarder type hence less album sales. There are a lot of reasons for this but on business perspective, less sales = less investments.

[@chocolat4193]

Assuming that you're referring to Illit, why pin the blame on hybe for debuting the girls when in the first place it was done by the netizens choice lol. And it wasn't also their fault for Pledis to not manage them properly.

[@tchea186]

@@chocolat4193 i think its another group, not illit. fearless i assume

[@Serena-Vanderwoodsen]

@@chocolat4193it’s not illit.

[@tianx9275]

This video pretty much hit the nail on the head. GG popularity has nothing to do with talent, but how they are being promoted and managed.

[@chiiiiweeeee]

chaeyoung shouldnt be sorry, its terrible when your group is treated like the middle child

[@MadcookieBG]

fromis_9 will always have a special place in my heart and I hope they find a way to stay together and continue to do music❤

[@cashilla]

Since HYBE bought other companies some of the Label who produced the group just got over shadowed. Why? Because HYBE didn't created or produced them. It was clearly had no focus or interested on the group's talents. Shame on this failure of HYBE. Fromise9 deserve better.

[@nicoleloss7987]

Wow. You don't even understand how hybe works. Hybe is a multi label corporation. Hybe only responsibility is to supply resources, creative funds and music distribution for each label. All labels under hybe work independently and are responsible for their own artists management. Please do research.

[@bisolagbadamosi4865]

They don’t deserve this 😢

[@davey6022]

True that😭

[@txelthv_]

Hybe girl curse is real. I don't know but someone really said this right. First glam, then gfriend, then new jeans and then fromis9. WHAT's wrong with hybe?

[@Harshita_Sharma_Kaushik]

And also lesserafim's garam scandal and Coachella performance hate . Illit's runext? Rigging scandal and plagiarism scandal...... Hybe girl curse is really real .. hybe doesn't know how to manage their girl groups 🥲🥲

[@nicoleloss7987]

Wow. Fromis9 is manger by pledis entertainment. Fromis9 was transferred from cjenm to pledis entertainment. Glam was under source music and bighit long before hybe. One of the members blackmailed a actor. How is that the company fault. Gfriend is comeback to source music in jan. Newjeans is manger by ador. Mhj breech her contract. Crimes. Nj did it to themselves.

[@txelthv_]

@nicoleloss7987 Girl, stop defending HYBE. You are really out of your mind. Don't forget GFriend and Fromis9 disbanded after becoming a part of Hybe; their companies did mistreat them, but the share of their company is in the hands of Hybe only; they could have done something. Hybe could have given them more opportunities to expand given the fact that Gfriend and Fromis9 are so famous in Korea. And about New Jeans, yeah, they left it. Why? Because they were mistreated collectively by Ador and Hybe. And don't name companies like that; first go and educate yourself. No one really says it like this: Oh, she is from Pledis, or He is from there. They collectively say it as hybe. And about glam, I just wrote it because I wanted to stress the girl curse concept. Stans like you give the opportunity to companies to mistreat their artists.

[@ashberto6041]

The cancer is in the head of the beast.

[@BillyWhaler]

The Triple P: No payment. No promotions. No company party. 😔

[@beniirama4076]

what do you mean no payment?

[@BillyWhaler]

@ the girls complained they were not getting paid.

[@Cameron984]

The good news for them is that despite all this, their songs have been successful since talk and talk. Every comeback since has won awards and done well on the Korean charts. That should give them some leverage to have an agency take them.

[@Unknownandbyes]

Supersonic was their success of them and was entering in the major industry how tf pledis fked up with them

[@nicoleloss7987]

Fromis9 contracts ends. It is always the artists decisions to renew their contracts or not. It is no one fault it they are not successful globally. They were successful in Korea.

[@20f124]

​@@nicoleloss7987it it their labels fault. fromis_9 have not been allowed to promote outside of Korea and Japan since 2019. Hybe starts off promoting their other groups internationally before debut.

[@terencelee880]

@@20f124 but why not allowed? I don't understand.....

[@20f124]

@@terencelee880 because their company put all their efforts and resources for every other group they manage. They refused to promote them. 2019 is the last time they left Asia.

[@terencelee880]

@@20f124 that's too bad. Fromis 9 was quite marginalised in promotion

[@srkpk3808]

I don’t think Hybe ruined them,but this group was formed in a bad way from start. Before they moved to Hybe, they were about to be Nugu. They have gained number of sale and better at Chart after joining Hybe.

[@niKute201101]

Hybe and Pledis do not have any respect for girl groups~ they consistently showcase this~

[@marcoryskyfall6382]

I remember when DM was released and I was obsessed with it. They had a lot of potential, however despite being transferred to the biggest company in K-Pop they didn't invest a lot on them. They focused more on their more successful artists.

[@20f124]

Those artists were successful because they debuted with millions and millions of dollars in investment

[@marcoryskyfall6382]

@@20f124 Yes, I believe if Pledis invested a bit more they would succeed more.

[@Rbosikwig]

I hope they can take FROMIS name with them and they bring their discography with for no charge, according to the company they lost money on them, it's only fair,flover forever ❤❤❤

[@brielledenise2011]

hybe was only focusing on the newer groups like newjeans and le serrafim, ever since i started stanning enhypen (2023) i would always notice that fromis 9 wasnt that active and not making much music than newjeans and le serrafim itself

[@Sandrinarhonda]

Fromis was failed by Hybe & Pledis, I hope BPM or Klap will take them in and treat them much better even if it’s a subunit situation. They really wasted their time.

[@bonelakiranmai4573]

I don't know why people are blaming hybe when the real culprit is pledis those girls were never treated properly they were in the same condition even before hybe bought pledis infact pledis is same with all their girl groups

[@daelwit]

maybe because pledis owns less than a 10% of themselves and clearly are not the ones that has the final word but the ones in charge to provide for fromis during activities, not to set them. also another reason to blame hybe and not pledis is the fact that things got worse for fromis when lee dahye, personal friend of bang sihyuk and ex vice president of bighit took the ceo position under pledis, so trying to justify hybe when they are the ones that make the decisions for all their sublabels is terribly blind.

[@ZAstrayZ]

It is simple. It is easy to jump onto the Hybe hate train right now. Would you get more clicks having a title that says Pledis failed fromis_9, or Hybe failed fromis_9? Kookielit's forte.

[@daelwit]

@@ZAstrayZ both pledis and hybe failed to fromis and im tired of people defending hybe just because its hybe. fromis was getting so much better treatment when they were the only hybe gg at the moment, nothing changed under pledis but the company started debuting more rookies and fromis ended up in the basement with long periods of no activity. this is both labels fault.

[@ZAstrayZ]

I'm just glad that more and more people are able to see through her BS. There are more and more people calling her out in the comments nowadays.

[@Kpopforlife1995]

And fans for not buying albums

[@ardiansatria2952]

Because their fans don't buy their Album...so ask to their fans...if their are true fans..they should support their album with buying their's offcourse

[@Lizzyses]

I am also a True Fan im a multistan but I don’t have a Single Album, u can’t say just bc someone doesn’t but their albums mean they aren’t real fans

[@fjnxtgdjsjeeh6073]

I dont like how people completely blame hybe when pledis treated them this way even before being bought by hybe, hybe isnt this single supervillain, ALL kpop companies have instances of mistreatment. Hybe is just a punching bag right now. Jyp does the same/worse to groups like vcha, itzy, niziu, sm has done the same to their groups, mistreatment runs rampant in small companies. So many people act like hybe is the only company who does stuff like this, when its actually a problem EVERYWHERE.

[@Bloom_Jiya]

Can't deny they're still the most successful. Other company stans can't handle it. They even hired their own team to put negative stuff about HYBE but guess who gets the most success in the end? 😂

[@nicoleloss7987]

Why don't fans understand. Hybe only responsibility is to supply resources, creative funds and music distribution for each label. All labels under hybe work independently and are responsible for their own artists management.

[@chuang3393]

What???BTS next 🎉🎉🎉 HYBE is going bank off thus without money to pay for MHJ🎉🎉🎉

[@alexwee8875]

​@nicoleloss7987 so that give them the right to treat him bad

[@Ellakimmy-i9s]

​@@chuang3393what do u mean by hybe is going bank off

[@kaydunton2037]

This: this! People say there's no way Hybe would sabotage New Jeans because they were successful. But they got rid of Gfriend and didn't promote Fromis9.

[@brainburn03]

Hybe only wants money coming in not going out.

[@Ellakimmy-i9s]

@@brainburn03 which label doesn't

[@jasonc212]

Hybe has failed a lot of established artist. I don't dislike them, but I'm not a fan of any label. I only support the artists

[@nicoleloss7987]

Who did hybe fail. You do know hybe only owns the labels. Hybe only responsibility is to supply resources, creative funds and music distribution for each label. All labels under hybe work independently and are responsible for their own artists. Fromis9 was transferred from cjenm to pledis entertainment. Pledis entertainment is who manger Fromis9.

[@jasonc212]

@nicoleloss7987 not true. If you keep up with just the most current events, they don't "Just own" the labels.

[@tortega-z7t]

Hayoung's vocals are wasted. Such a powerful singer but no opportunity to showcase it

[@kachine0606]

Thankyou for this but please talk about VCHA & STARLIGHTBOYS too

[@tralalalalaminhol]

she has already made a video about starlight boys with title "the worst kpop survival show" or smth like that

[@kachine0606]

@@tralalalalaminhol excuse me There are many things going on still about the show and the trainees are getting mistreatment so Yinghao pointed out via his letter to his fans and we fans stopped voting - I'm not talking about the ‘stop’

[@TheHispanicJukeBox]

She's probably making a video about VCHA, so we have to be patient and wait

[@20f124]

Also it should go without saying. Putting quotas on how much a group is allowed to interact with their fans has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with sales and streams. In fact it's setting them up for exactly what the company wanted for an excuse.

[@brainburn03]

They give attention to people who are useful to them. 2 groups have disbanded in HYBE. And yet they are fighting with the one that makes them money. And witj Fromis 9 HYBE is quick to make a statement that the members did not renew their contract instead of fighting for them and make an effort to further their careers.

[@theofficialpeterkim]

Hybe is on a roll.

[@imapotatochip5481]

I hope they redebut

[@scallywags666]

Worst news for me this year. Hopefully they can somehow continue.

[@artisticvampire]

Yep sounds about right drama gets what drama wants.

[@artisticvampire]

Have lauren help them later if she is up for it.

[@arhilinadaine779]

From what I notice this channel keep on reporting hybe or new jeans? What about VCHA and Starlightboys?

[@jin_xlmv]

They're hired by mhj obviously

[@arhilinadaine779]

Or maybe because of algorithm thats why I failed to saw their other videos? I am really curious of the condition of VCHA and starlight boys.

[@Ellakimmy-i9s]

​@@arhilinadaine779well seems the owner of this page is obsessed in painting hybe as the worst company ever

[@ichinisa2583]

I hate this media trend of either brake records or not exist at all, if something is making profits that's a successful product, why must every group be the number one, let groups make music and make people happy as long as they're making money

[@Hahahaha10188]

Hybe new slogans should be ‘we believe in toxic’ or ‘we believe in profits not music’ 😂😂

[@ardiansatria2952]

Just ask to Pledis Ent...

[@derekmorinaga1594]

Pledis has not been good to any of their idol groups

[@kklljj70]

HYBE just buys out other companies just to kill out their groups that's it we just need to go back to the big three YG, JYP, and SM the good ol days

[@fjnxtgdjsjeeh6073]

Do you really think those companies are any better?? Youre delusional, just open your eyes and look at their mistreatment!

[@kklljj70]

@@fjnxtgdjsjeeh6073 delusional ?! Do you not see HYBE is killing NewJeans ?

[@Bloom_Jiya]

All are devils but y'all choose to blame only HYBE until your faves get exposed. It's embarrassing, stop it.

[@chocolat4193]

Dont be blind, the companies that you mentioned ain't even a saint either. Pledis was at fault here for not promoting them properly.

[@SnapMonster8]

Most Pledis groups don't last long except self-produced group like Seventeen

[@wilcisco1159]

But before they leave their current agency, did they already planned on how they handle things? Because when they finally leave and venture on their own, they need to secure a management deal with key people. They still need a competent manager to find them gigs, sponsorship and endorsements which they surely can't handle on their own. My suggestion is they have to find a skilled and competent manager that can handle behind the scene paperworks. So the girl group can focus on their craft.

[@WillTheRealBishPleaseStandUp]

NOT HYBE. PLEDIS. THEIR AGENCY ISNT HYBE.

[@minuii]

Coping is bad.🖕

[@Unknownandbyes]

You guys forgot hybe supports talentless payola so called star quality trainees not actual talent the fact that fromis 9 is the gg in hybe who has powerhouse vocalist. Embarrassment

[@nicoleloss7987]

Wow . Hybe is a corporate. All labels under hybe work independently and are responsible for their own artists. Hybe only responsibility is to supply resources, creative funds and music distribution for each label. All artists under hybe are talented. Why are you jealous. Fromis9 contracts is with pledis entertainment. It is always the artists decisions to renew their contracts or not.

[@449polsc.sephalimanishatet9]

Everyone is talented in hybe except some 5 member group lol 😂

[@rayusingame]

They'll always have us flovers to support them. Screw HYBE and PLEDIS.

[@sophya3410]

Am yet waiting to hear about a kpop agency, big, small or medium, that actually nurtures and invests positively in their non primary groups. It’s unbelievable the way these idols are treated. Meanwhile the execs fill their pockets and their shareholders’. It’s disgusting and the girls deserve better, just like many other idol groups.

[@Your_miserys_misery]

If you want the perspective of an actual fan who has been with them everyday for years instead of someone making a video for clicks just ask me

[@Farah-nv7qn]

at this point this is forced hate towards hybe..! as a kpop fan I never heard of fromis9 until they joined hybe ... isn't this pledis fault from the start ? why is hybe always to blame ?

[@Ellakimmy-i9s]

@@Farah-nv7qn I second ur statement 😌

[@minuii]

Nah you all just coping for hybe. Cant admit that company is trash and full of toxic culture of south korea has.

[@theGinthebuilding]

Hybe Is literally fumbling left and right...

[@nicoleloss7987]

Wow. You do know hybe is a multi label corporation. All labels under hybe work independently and are responsible for their own artists management

[@NeerajKumar-ju2vg]

For your information itss not hybe itss pledis

[@wonnie9138]

I think fromis_9's disbandment is for pledis's new gg

[@kskutty100]

yes new gg pledis 2025 good

[@kskutty100]

really so hot

[@DommRan]

New gg to be wasted, much better if they focus with boy groups.

[@kurzweber3041]

Y'all forgot what happened to Pristin....Why should you be so surprised!

[@banjo3986]

Because pristin didn’t sell or get wins. Fromis 9 had both.

[@nagyungf9]

it's funny to see kpop fans put all the blame on hybe and pledis. when half of the blame also on you for not supporting fromis_9. kpop fans being sympathetic to fromis are so fake, feels more like a mockery.

[@BRONSTEINER]

So much unrealized and untapped potential. This group has it but every company they been in failed them

[@deluxis4991]

Hybe counting album sales is a joke after it was revealed that the label itself was buying albums of some of thier groups to artifictally make sales bigger.

[@BLINKWORLD-26774]

Lol true

[@Ellakimmy-i9s]

@@deluxis4991 which groups ?

[@nicoleloss7987]

That is not true. Why do you keep spreading false information.

[@BLINKWORLD-26774]

@@nicoleloss7987 well hybe former ceo bangsihyuk? Was buying it a week prior to the album release for lesserrafim tho

[@silentnight4025]

Hybe only focus on profit now, if the group ain't bringing in money they getting X out

[@Aesthetique_Strawberry]

Please cover what happened with VCHA

[@renuka1741]

Trust Me In 2025 New Comeback Soon

[@kpopxbanu]

Enjoy watching the video, guys !! you can leave your opinion here ⬇⬇

[@ComplexRoblox]

I’ll miss em 😭😭

[@FkiyaniKiyani]

Under 2 min gang 😁

[@kitcloudkicker72]

That's what she said

[@Lenny_Louu]

can you talk about whats going on with vcha? i dont really understand the situation

[@hyunjaestan5897]

Why did Hybe get them in the first place? They got a nugu group and expected they would succeed?

[@DommRan]

Nugu ? Why because they're not internationally famous? So your locally famous celebrities are also nugu because we don't know them ? Logic bro logic.

[@banjo3986]

Nugu is crazy. They are so popular in Korea

[@TheHispanicJukeBox]

HYBE has failed a lot of their girl groups, it's like this company is incapable of protecting their girl groups, I'm surprised le serafim is still going strong...🤷🤦

[@mixtapehq6341]

Lessarafim is going strong because it’s bang si hyuk’s baby. He doesn’t care about what he isn’t involved in

[@Your_miserys_misery]

Hybe would burn it's building down before hurting lsf. Hybe literally took fromis' staff and gave them away to lsf.

[@ashberto6041]

@@Your_miserys_misery and Gfriend's, and they still are mid.

[@velatacu]

my glorious queens

[@Cynalittle]

Is this not what they were trying to do to newjeans? Put them on a 2 year hiatus at the peak of their career just cos… and yet hybe Stans are m@d those girls are fight!ng back, I wonder what would happen with fromis 9 now, would they stay together and keep their name since this was a mutual split? Would the 9th girl who left comeback or would they all venture on their own things?

[@rajriyaj5464]

And they say new jeans was wrong 😅

[@SnapMonster8]

Because it's true. And most Pledis groups don't last long except self-produced group like Seventeen

[@Bloom_Jiya]

You just wouldn't stop talking about HYBE when there's other big issues going on. Well all despise HYBE but what type of circus is this?

[@Kiwi_isforever]

Please cover what just happened to VCHA

[@IY_Official1]

They'll comeback in 2025

[@Itzymidzykpop]

@@IY_Official1Look up what happened to KG…

[@IY_Official1]

@KpopfanITZYMIDZY787-9 i just know they are having a comeback in 2025 can you tell me ?

[@Itzymidzykpop]

@@IY_Official1 basically KG terminated her contract with JYPE because of alleged mistreatment and even a member wanting to do suicide so KG ended her contract so VCHAs future is more uncertain again

[@VeryTired-c7b]

Why does this channel blame everything on Hybe???. First they're under Pledis and they were never treated fairly as svt probably bz they weren't popular and Ive never seen svt support them either. Even after hybe ...pledis used all the funds from hybe on svt and tws.

[@joenathanz7474]

Because HYBE truly a trash company for neglected GGs like fromis & newjeans

[@Wonyoungism_.defender]

@@joenathanz7474mkay but Svt gets comebacks, TWS gets promoted, so why isn’t Fromis_9? “It’s HYBE’s fault” if it were HYBE’s fault none of the Pledis groups would be getting promotions, but no, it’s only Fromis_9, it’s clear as day that it’s Pledis’ fault.

[@apresmoa]

@Wonyoungism_.defender It's not just fromis_9. Please don't take yourself seriously if you believe that. But I'm sure you're anti NewJeans too so I won't bother bringing up their mistreatment. Just wait until HYBE does the same thing again. I wonder who you all will find the next incident on since you'll never blame HYBE.

[@Wonyoungism_.defender]

@@apresmoa it is tho. Svt didn’t have to wait a year for a comeback, Svt didn’t have to get 2 comeback’s in 3 years. TWS didn’t have to get neglected during their rookie era. So it quite literally is just Fromis_9, they already disbanded Gfriend and Pristin so they’re alone at Pledis. Comparing them to NewJeans is actually so funny because NewJeans hasn’t even experienced a fraction of what they have.

[@danilloconnery2841]

Please update about VCHA. KG has been leaving the group due to child labor abuse and mistreatment. She filed a lawsuit and sue JYP😭😭😭

[@endrickcuyos6965]

I dont get why hybe is getting the blame here while their agency is Pledis. Not so called hybe fan but as far as i know is is only guving these agencies some resources so that these agencies under hybe could produce more music and gain resources from them its the agencies responsibility for their idols lol

[@nicoleloss7987]

Wow. Hybe only responsibility is to supply resources, creative funds and music distribution for each label. All labels under hybe work independently and manger their own artists. Fromis9 came from cjenm sublabel. They full the groups contract. It is always the artists decisions to renew their contracts or not.

[@jcstark47]

Worst company. It is like the combined CONS of JYP, SM and YG worst - no vocal training, no marketing, more focused on new groups, less comebacks

[@nicoleloss7987]

Really. Because hybe is the best company. Artists are well trained. Hybe is a multi label corporation. Hybe only responsibility is to supply resources ,creative funds and music distribution for each label. All labels under hybe work independently and are responsible for their own artists management.

[@joeblack3623]

Never heard of them.

[@deukaeon]

sad for them, love bomb was a hit! ❤💣

[@lcutie36]

They had no fanbase anyway to support them. 😮

[@rhynzard]

HYBE really didn't gave any opportunity to the groups already present in labels they absorbed. They just pushed their new groups and disbanding the old ones.

[@nicoleloss7987]

Wow you people dont even understand how hybe works. Hybe is a multi label corporation. Hybe only responsibility is to supply resources, creative funds and music distribution for each label. All labels under hybe work independently and are responsible for their own artists management. Hybe doesn't work like yg,jyp or smoke entertainment. Hybe is structure like umg,Sony or Warner bros. Hybe didn't disband any groups. It is always the artists decisions to renew their contracts or not.

[@rhynzard]

@nicoleloss7987 ahahahahahaah please educate yourself. G Friend got immediately disbanded under HYBE indication as soon the labal was selled. If you check new jeans debut, HYBE indeed delayed the debut to give priority to le sserafin. And probably you don't understand how much influence got who manage the money.

[@Fearless.cat1209]

Hybe always failing their gg

[@alphafox2498]

What vid is the first clip from

[@MadcookieBG]

fromis_9 - Supersonic Live stage from MCountdown 240822

[@dreinxoxo]

Pledis has never managed girl groups well 😅

[@UTuber-l7t]

This is how HYBE management functions. Bring in young new faces, make money then discard them like old pair of Jeans! They will probably rename "NewJeans" to "OldJeans" and "Le sserafim" to "vieille Séraphin".

[@lawtraf8008]

I'm actually surprise your video today isn't about VCHA and the evil acts JYP did to those poor girls. You're usually very quick with the news so it's surprising that you still haven't made a video about it knowing everything that just went down with KG finally breaking the silence and telling us how horribly they have been treated leading to the girls being in depression, developing eating disorders, committing self harms and one girl literally attempting suicide which is likely Kaylee. JYP lied for months saying she was in hiatus for health issues but with KG's lawsiuit and her exposing everything, we know it's definitely Kaylee the unnamed group member who did that. Sad that a 15 year old girl would have experienced such a hell to even try to do that. JYP has been covering up all these horrible things. They need to pay. VCHA are Americans and are based in California. The USA is not Korea, they won't get away with it, especially not in the state of California which is the toughest state on these kind of issues due to Hollywood and the multiple child star abuse cases they have experienced. They are hopefully going down for what they did to these girls. I can't wait to watch your video about it.

[@HeartXHeart0888]

Off topic BUT LOOK AT THE STUFF WITH VCHA AND KG AHSHGSGSHHS

[@salvadorramirez4114]

I remember no one cared about aespa when they first started; look at them now! No doubt Fromis has untapped talent and looks

[@DianaOsazenaye]

they let them down

[@irsyadasyrafmohamad9784]

yet another gfriend incident. thnx for letting go of talented girl groups like gfriend,newjeans and fromis_9 and keeping illit. hopefully HYBE let go of BTS and Seventeen next...

[@Samo-p3w]

Ah HYBE….kpop industry’s official retirement house…😢 worst company for girl groups

[@minjunim0]

Most of these incidents are the fault of pledis entertainment not hybe

[@SukiSuki562]

This isn’t on HYBE. Pledis wanted them but at the same time didn’t. They just didn’t fit what HYBE was looking for.

[@nicoleloss7987]

People really don't understand how hybe works. Hybe is a multi label corporation. Hybe only responsibility is to supply resources ,creative funds and music distribution for each label. All labels under hybe work independently and are responsible for their own artists management.

[@nicoleloss7987]

This is a hybe hate channels. You know nothing about how hybe works. You really need to stop believing false information. Learn how business works.

[@Esqm]

It feels like hybe just wants to push out older groups from subsidiaries. Groups they can’t take credit from or as much profit from. I’m still upset over gfriend