How Many Holes Are in a Straw? -Objection.lol

Straws!
Yeah but what about no holes?
🤨🤨🤨
[discord]: / discord

[@FrostDeino]

Enjoy the video? Wanna join the server where these debates happen, and get turned into videos? discord.gg/z2WM4xa8Pb Watch the "Barbecue Sauce Incident" debate...: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jp2ZendqlNhpns0si=ZGBqWlJV7qc61nml

[@justincarino9653]

*Karma:* Fatherless. *Edgeworth:* AND WHOSE FAULT IS THAT!?

[@PAWSAREONGRASS]

Karma adopte him?!

[@justincarino9653]

@@PAWSAREONGRASS Edgeworth being adopted into the von Karma family is popular fanon that is based on Franziska calling him little brother in the English translation and the general sibling rivalry-esque dynamic they have, but as far as the game continuity is concerned, all textual evidence suggests that Edgeworth is just Manfred’s student and not his legally adopted ward.

[@justincarino9653]

Admittedly, he might be adopted in the anime continuity, according to some anime exclusive flashback scenes.

[@PAWSAREONGRASS]

@@justincarino9653 k

[@star_fru1tz]

In the anime, Von Karma says "Sometimes I wonder why I adopted that boy" and was once going to put him in an adoption center

[@serisdovakhin]

Karma and Phoenix on the same side is literally Edgeworth's nightmare why must our boy suffer like this

[@Def_not_a.Kaeyasimp]

Soooo true lol

[@Miles--Edgeworth]

Send help 😔

[@reginaldcopperbottom1406]

Karma and Phoenix are wrong though

[@catrinaquenon6582]

​@@Miles--EdgeworthOH OK (gives rocket launcher)

[@Miles--Edgeworth]

@@catrinaquenon6582why the hell is this on ur person.

[@kissena3830]

The problem with hole is it depends on how you have defined it. Like how Phoenix defines it "a hollow place in a solid body" In this case a straw only have one hole. I think.

[@ඩඩඩඩඩඩඩ-ප7ඹ]

FBI OPEN UP

[@Firefly256]

In that case the broken short also has 1 hole only?? Because they’re connected??

[@Randomness78]

objection!

[@nsei7828]

The problem persists, what defines the number of empty spaces? They exist like gas theres no way to count it like you count ice cubes for example

[@blockfox0235]

Tbh hatiku has a point

[@sergantanthony216]

Phoenix busted out text book definition with out the book. When he said he had this discussion before he meant many times.

[@brentithecutiejkidk6116]

N9

[@Thecommentmolester]

Busted? Edgeworth??!?!!?!!?!

[@diegovasquez840]

Topologically speaking, straws have one hole, because they can be deformed continuously into a torus. What I think Phoenix is instead referring to is an *opening*. In that regard he is correct, there are two openings to the hole.

[@spl420]

So basically straw has one hole as an object but two holes as a set of surfaces?

[@destructchronos3125]

It's always great seeing another pal who know's advanced math knowledge

[@geometrividad7716]

1) A straw cannot be deformed into a torus continiously, it is clearly not homeomorphic, for instance they have different fundamental group, so they do not even have the same homotopic type. A straw is homotopically equivalent to a circumference (S^1) or a hollow circle, so it is correct saying that it has one hole. 2) Under most notions of "hole" I'd assume most people would say a Torus has two because its 1 degree homology has two generators or something like that. That said, one good way to see that a straw has one hole is to ask how many holes a ring has, i feel most people would intuitively say just one and in reality a straw is just a stretched ring. It's great when things get preserved by continious transformations.

[@myau9912]

Each opening is a hole. A hole in a piece of paper wouldn't have two holes though. A straw has two holes for one tunnel. However the hole in a piece of paper would be too thin for the middle to be a tunnel, thus there's no distinct entrance or exit holes.

[@mcarrowtime7095]

@myau9912 Too thin to be a tunnel for people, but for microscopic organisms the thickness of paper isn’t negligible like it is to humans. So at what level of thickness does something become a tunnel? 1 micron? .5 microns?

[@infinityStraws]

Dividing a finite object in an unlimited amount of arbitrarily small units, huh. Dude just reinvented integrals. He'd do well in calculus ! But none of them seemed to notice that this definition they quoted was actually two definitions in one: "A hollow space in an object or surface" can be separated as "A hollow space in an object"OR"A hollow space in a surface". The two groups thought they had agreed on a single definition, but they were really using different ones with different implications. To re-take the example of someone drilling through the earth. Assuming there is no collapse in the gallery, there is a single continuous hollow space in earth. But that is considering the earth as a solid object, if you only consider the earth's surface, it has two separate empty spaces. Nothing connects them, since the gallery isn't part of earth's surface, and therefore not considered. Meaning if you consider the definition with "object", you have one hole, and considering the definition with "surface" you have two holes. Same apply to the straw : If you consider it as a cylinder, then are two holes on it's outer surface, but only one in the object. However, if you don't consider it a cylinder, but simply "straw-shaped", you could even say it has no hole at all, because you consider the space that a tiny ant coul walk on if you put it on the straw for the surface, and the actual volume of plastic for the volume. But to get back at what Phoenix said near the end : He's basically using the "surface" version of definitions, while considering a volume to be made of an infinity of juxtaposed surfaces. That kind of logic is genuinely used in some fields of physics ! Phoenix is just a misunderstood genius.

[@FrostDeino]

This wins the comment section. This all makes sense! And the part about a juxtaposed surface is indeed what I was trying to say (just uh, you said it smarter)

[@firasempire5294]

except you can't actually cut the straw infinitely there for you can't have an infinite number of all the least you can go is atomic level holes in which they'll be finite

[@D.KlWA-aG]

@@firasempire5294 Technically you can just cause an explosion which would make another hole

[@Aidenzsnow]

I'm not reading this

[@pitapockets5481]

What does you mean by gallery??

[@vunshsharma1817]

I love how in this most of them actually changed team

[@artistwithouttalent]

Zero holes. Like all 3D circles with holes in the middle, straws are 4D objects projected in 3D space. It's like asking how many sides a Klein bottle has

[@FrostDeino]

🤓🤓🤓

[@deymiandelgado8813]

@@FrostDeino Based

[@ren96706]

Bro it cant be zero holes… how would you suck out of it. Its 1 hole

[@nicholas7743]

I think there was a through hole in all of your skulls

[@ththrshpnd]

Straws have one hole, Klein bottles have one side.

[@naveenmaurya8802]

As a prospective mathematician, this video explores surprisingly well what should be considered the definition of a 'hole', of course, in a more heuristic and trial-and-error-like manner.

[@FrostDeino]

I'm literally Einstein

[@yeezestdeezest]

A straw can't have holes, it's already a hole

[@youtuberjestforfun9074]

air is a hole, a straw is not just air it has air in the center, its not a hole, it has 1, 2, or infinite holes

[@YouGotNo_maidens]

What about the plastic

[@robvadeberg]

Oh yeah? And what if I punch a hole on the side of the straw?

[@Thecommentmolester]

​@@youtuberjestforfun9074eewryiokkllllpooûhgc🪑😔wwéghbb

[@Slimyboi500]

⁠@@robvadeberg It depends, if you punch it all the way through, it would have 3 holes (one continuous hole, two holes where you punch it.) But if you don’t punch all the way through, you will have 2. The reason why your punch counts as 2 holes is because those holes are not connected horizontally. Whereas, the main hole counts as one because it is connected horizontally.

[@overz00m]

i havent seen manfred in objection lols in so long

[@FrostDeino]

I like using him

[@Splatenohno]

Phoenix: *Shows attorney badge* Everyone else: “I’m sorry”

[@artofmore7197]

1:25 I always wondered if that would ever happen. One of the lawyers objects, iconic and epic Cornered theme plays...and they have nothing to say. You have fulfilled my expectations.

[@DanishAryap]

Im not gonna even talk to one of these guys, they made a simple object complicated, i just want to drink with a straw 💀

[@builted3189]

A straw is a cylinder with one hollow inside, with two openings. As a mathematician who has done an immense amount of research on this topological question, you can assume it is the correct approach to say that a straw can’t have holes because the definition of what a straw is already takes into consideration the single vertical hollow inside (the hole corresponding volume) and the two openings (the holes corresponding to second dimensional area while at the same time having relevancy with the single hole corresponding to volume).

[@blank4502]

A straw is topologically similar to a donut, therefore it is one hole

[@boredombandit647]

*OBJECTION* 3:20 Godot makes a point, an entrance and a exit. Mugs are MORE similar to straws and there are entrance and exit points. How come if I rip one side of a shirt its one hole, but the other its still 2 holes. You are acting as if we are in the second dimension….

[@BIackhole]

You are right

[@BurstFlare]

To counter Phoenix's argument about paper having two holes, the number of sides doesn't actually matter: what does matter is the *location* of the hole. The reason why a shirt having a hole in the front and a hole in the back counts as two holes is because the front and back are two separate areas on the shirt. But with a sheet of paper, the front and back sides occupy the same space, so even though it has two sides, it's only one hole. Additionally, while some holes have bottoms to them, such as cups, others do not, such as holes in clothing, paper, etc., which is how we can actually determine the exact number of holes a straw has. Because the space from one opening of a straw has nothing to block it off, it is one single hole that goes from one end to the other.

[@oqo3310]

Saul killed me lmao

[@the_chill_man]

4:02 to be fair he’s not wrong, if you use sticky tape and pull it off sometimes a layer of paper comes off technically being one thin hole so going through the whole paper leads to two holes

[@JustSomeGuy010]

At this point we are just arguing if holes are 2 dimensional or 3 dimensional. If we define them as 2 dimensional like wright, we can get infinite wholes, but if we define them as infinitely 3 dimensional, then that would mean we are just defining all empty spaces in the universe as one big hole, if we define the universe as an object. I'll take the second approach for this one. This means that any single object we look at , whether inside or outside the universe, has one whole, but a different amount of openings. This also applies to simple shapes like spheres and squares because of the holes between atoms. This also presents a problem of infinite openings, however i would like to present the jury with an opinion on openings that we should all be able to agree on. If there is an opening smaller than what the human eye can see, it's not an opening. Case, closed

[@nsei7828]

Yes you managed to formulate that argument very well thanks man

[@gergelyritter4412]

Objection! I would like to draw your attention to small animals such as tardigrades and other microscopic or maybe even a bit bigger living organisms. They obviously have holes on/in them since they need it for their survival as well. So I recommend changing the definition. Holes should only qualify as holes if they can be made visible with technology. This shouldnt include drawings and theoratical models on the atomic, subatomic level. Images from electron microscope would be included however.

[@joeshanklin2791]

If we start defining things by their ability to be observed by humans we'd be throwing all of theoretical physics, a good chunk of quantum physics

[@serv3534]

3:03 he really just pulled out a jerma by using a death threat as example

[@FrostDeino]

Okay, if I… if I chop you up in a meat grinder, and the only thing that comes out, that's left of you, is your eyeball, you'r- you're ... probably dead

[@--CHARLIE--]

If a hole is a hollow place in a solid body, then the number of e tranves is irrelecant to the number of holes. A straw has one hole. In fact, a straw with sealed entry points, and thus 0 entrances or exists, still has a hole, the hole is just inaccessible.

[@Arcsin27]

Phoenix just invented calculus what a chad

[@mrdunklestein]

So is no one going to mention Saul being here?

[@DrYeet2704]

0:44 be looking very suspicious.

[@FrostDeino]

0_o

[@bv83x]

sounding too

[@FrostDeino]

Guys why 💀

[@ashrafwew5481]

Im glad they noticed :)

[@CygnusLaboratorys2056]

as a self proclaimed Topologist my eyes and ears bleeding

[@manupm9161]

Phoenix theory fall down in the moment in the moment you start adding openings to the straw, a Y shaped straw obviously has the same amount of holes as an X shaped straw

[@miodancer-pu7fd]

i like how humble Godot is because he actually uses his mind and thinks through the answers that the rest gave out

[@mohammedalfath7801]

"Holes, we all have 'em. We all use them" the whole world :PARDON ME, WHAT!?!?!?

[@Sir_Snakeington]

Godot: I want what wright is smoking Godot later: Nevermind I don't want what wright is smoking

[@Attaxalotl]

How many holes does a doughnut have? One. If we extend a donut vertically, we get a straw-like shape. Therefore a straw has one hole.

[@Davi-zo4lu]

i never though Von Karma would be fighting side to side with Phoenix

[@manillablanck]

Both answers are correct, with _hole_ reffering to two similar yet distinct things. There is 1 hole (hollow space in thing) and 2 holes (opening in thing that can, but doesn't have to, lead to aftermentioned hollow space) in straw. Edit: Hole type nr 2 doesn't have sides - each opening counts as one hole

[@Kakashisensei829]

But An opening Is still a hole.

[@chilidog2469]

What we need to do is clarify that a hole has to be dug out of something, that way holes are made from openings, and that straws are tubes

[@Voiding210]

0:28 Michael:vsauce,Michael here Topology:Bye Topology has left the chat Micheal:A hole in a mathematical object is a topological structure which prevents the object from being continuously shrunk to a point. 5:13 Leibniz:HELP,this guy didn't listen Leibniz left the chat.

[@sharkygameworld]

It depends on how hot it is. The temperature tells how fast the molecules are moving in the straw. And, the moving molecules form empty spaces in between them. Those are holes. So, I would prob say around 50 quintillion XD

[@chrisnaririhena4690]

2:08 I like how Edgeworth said one with confidence

[@YEWCHENGYINMoe]

No, its straw length/planck length holes, as the planck Length is the smallest distance possible.

[@Lgame0143]

I agree with Wright. If you cut a straw multiple times you can get more holes

[@FrostDeino]

Well when you put it that way...

[@reviandelumiel2833]

But then it's not the same body, you are getting a system of bodies that isn't an equivalent as the original body (a straw on a table is not the same as a multiple ring fragments on a table)

[@FrostDeino]

@@reviandelumiel2833 Put it back together

[@stickman207]

But the logic doesnt work, when you cut a straw you DO get more holes but you also get more straws, just shorter ones and the question was how many holes in ONE straw

[@UnknownGamer40464]

@@stickman207 If cutting a straw in half gave you a new straw, they would've only ever made one straw.

[@squigglemons1265]

A cup has one hole that has the same exit as its entryway. If you broke the bottom of the cup, you would then have a thick straw. The length of the object must have something to do with the number of holes, so a straw must have one hole. That reason being that not only was it created using a method of extrusion molding (heated material forms around an object), but it is also exactly the same shape on both sides. This excludes bendy straws, even though they are still straws. The fact being that you wouldn't be able to tell the sides apart without it being marked in some way, so it is just a long hole. An argument against this may be describing the two ends and what ends up where (one side in the cup, the other in the mouth), but it is the same liquid touching the same material of the same thickness. It tastes the same either way, and the path to get to the mouth is constant. Look at it from the perspective of one side of the straw. if you look through it, you see the world from the other side. It is connected as a single hole. Please give me your opinions! Edit: 8 months later, I have a new thought. The original mention of length being a factor is all together wrong, but I think I had a good idea. 😆 I think a mug handle can indeed be a hole depending on how you look at it. Either it is a hole, or just a handle, just something to grasp. There are many types of things that we refer to as holes. A keyhole, a hole in the ground, a hole in the wall, holes in a shirt. Perhaps what defines a hole is "an opening," one that can have both a constant path or a blocked one. (This makes sense, right? Ww)

[@FrostDeino]

I've really summoned a whole league of philosophers, huh? I'm not sure I'd considering being able to tell the difference between the two sides as an important factor... I just can't explain why

[@squigglemons1265]

@@FrostDeino Oh yeah! I get why it would be difficult to understand. I suppose it would mostly work for things that are symmetrical in some way. I guess you can think of it as no matter the length of the straw, no matter the shape, it is still a constant. Even bendy straws are a constant. They aren't symmetrical, but they still make the same result. Thank you for your reply! It was a great video to think about, and it was made better with Ace Attorney!

[@shannonhoward4792]

@@FrostDeino well, if I were to take a square of clay, and poke a small hole on two opposite sides in the same spot, it would have two holes. If I were to press hard, and I penetrate the square, the two holes would connect, forming a conjoined hole. If I poked another hole, and repeated the process, i would have 3 conjoined holes. 1 hole total. Much like a compound formula of the periodic table. We can keep on adding conjoining holes, and forming the clay square into a whole ant colony. So, the straw is just two conjoined holes, or 1 hole. If I were to take the shirt with 6 holes in it, it would technically be 8 conjoined holes, including the backs of the holes in the middle, so the shirt with holes in it is one hole. Which does prove Pheonix to be partly correct, but nobody could count the correct amount of holes in a shirt. Referring to the example of cutting the straw into pieces, our 6 conjoined hole square would be split in two, but each half would retain all 6 if you put one whole directly in the center of each side. So, even a square can duplicate its conjoined holes. Like the humble energy, it cannot be created or destroyed, only morphed. You would be morphing the straw, giving it more holes by technicality. You would achieve the same result of adding holes as cutting the shirt or square in halves. You are splitting the colony into multiple colonies, therefore increasing the amount of holes. So Wright's straw example was correct, and it is also true that straws have one hole, so everybody is partly correct, and bendy straws keep their count of holes. Putting the bits of the straw back together would reform the colonies, theoretically decreasing the amount of holes in the straw. For a shape to have two different holes, there has to be a gap inbetween both colonies. One hole. Problem solved.

[@squigglemons1265]

@@shannonhoward4792 I agree with what you said. I had trouble explaining my thoughts on this, but I can see that we have the same idea. I like to think that the object itself determines the number of holes. What I mean is that a t-shirt and a straw are totally different when it comes to determinating the amount of holes. The straw is seen as if it were connected to something on both ends, like if a shirt has a hole through the middle, it would be on both sides. If you look at its entirety, you can see that it has the purpose of transferring at a constant. An escalator does the same. It travels at a constant speed in a certain direction, going to a specific place. I'm quite bad at giving my thoughts, so forgive me.

[@dropfish3109]

uhhhhhhh does the handle count as a hole????????

[@jkbscopes1233]

These always feel like real discord convos betweem a group of friends and i love it

[@Treviisolion]

Topologically speaking, a straw and coffee mug have 1 hole along with a donut, the shirt would have 4 holes. Defining a hole as an entrance/exit, a straw has 2 holes, a coffee mug 3, and the shirt 8. Defining by feel, straw has 2, donut 1, mug 2, and shirt 6.

[@memerboi69.0]

6 - saul goodman

[@Abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz1024]

Humans have a constantly changing number of holes, pores for example

[@picrete]

For the record, using phoenix’s logic, that shirt could have 12 holes, because each hole in the center of the shirt has 4 holes, since the front of the shirt has a hole, the back of the shirt has a hole, but the inside of the front side of the shirt is ALSO a hole, and so is the back-inside.

[@milowannebo-sorensen1776]

No, he’s saying it’s 2 holes and there’s a set boundary around the space between them? Idk

[@TheCreCre]

here's my take on how many holes there are: OBJECTION! All the holes are connected inside the shirt, hence it has...... 1 hole.

[@boredombandit647]

@@TheCreCre *HOLD IT* Imagine a parasite trying to enter your body. It could go through only one way: Through your privates, nose, mouth, ears, maybe eyes if small enough.

[@danydady6851]

According to Phoenix's logic, it would have infinite holes

[@internetuser9667]

a straw is two holes and one tunnel 😎

[@FrostDeino]

VIDEO ON DOOFENSHMIRTZ's INNOCENCE: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZyvZ3akqNGgjNk Like the video? Join the discord: discord.gg/fkKjm9xa7 You can debate there!

[@croassung3721]

5:51 *phoenix having a mental breakdown*

[@ballbellows]

1:36 Edgeworth I will literally "Frankfurt am Main, Germany"

[@cyborgbob1017]

The reason why when you cut a straw in half it makes 2 seperate holes, is because now they have 2 seperate entry and exit points. Before, they shared the same entry and exit point, making them a solid “hole”. However, if you take this new half of the straw and line it up perfectly with the other one, now you have one hole with a gap in the middle. And if you cut up the straw into infinite slices and place them next to each other, you have yourselves infinite holes, because they have infinite unique entry and exit points

[@Nello_angelo]

"I'm her and I'm confused" Yeah that's me in every video of this kind

[@strangecolouredbird]

One that goes through the whole straw.

[@BenStudios167]

i have a idea it depends Paper straws are made as a coil, so it could be Nan or Inf holes Plastic (Made with a mold): Are made originally with 2 holes as the mold But with plastic (By cutting the plastic whilst its hot) would make it one long continous hole

[@goovindnarula6470]

a straw has one hole with two ends while a bullet through the head is two holes because if you lay the materials out on a flat plane the straw will cease to exist, it will be without holes because the straw itself was making the hole. but a flat version of a shot skull will yeild two holes.

[@ShadowyKatana]

The I want what wright’s smoking killed me😂

[@Wah934]

Since depth is required, but a bottom isn't, a straw has (or more accurately is) one hole with two openings.”

[@Mrwiggles37]

they're might be 2 openings but there is one hole in a straw. because that one hole is filling the entire straw, but there is 2 openings.

[@UnknownGamer40464]

false, a hole has to have a bottom, otherwise it's a tunnel

[@psgamer-il2pt]

​@@UnknownGamer40464 And a tunnel is a hole

[@UnknownGamer40464]

@@psgamer-il2pt nope

[@BIackhole]

Nope. In topology straw has only 1 hole. So in science we accept that straw has only 1 hole​@@UnknownGamer40464

[@JuliaTDI23]

OBJECTION! A straw does NOT have holes. It has two openings. For a straw to have a hole, it would have to have a solid end. But it ends with an opening.

[@FrostDeino]

So if I punch a hole in a wall and it goes all the way through That's not a hole?

[@BlueT1ger]

Bruh the cyborg wanted what he was smoking then said “actually maybe I don’t wanna lose all my brain cells”

[@jonathanh.2483]

After my calculus class, in which we evaluated solids of a certain cross section along a path, I think Phoenix is right…it’s integration, so “infinite” cross-sections (infinitely small, actually), which translates to infinite holes. I don’t really like it but I think it’s true.

[@Ethan13371]

I'm pretty sure that would only be the case if he actually cut the straw, the same way that something's state is defined as what it now, rather than what it could be if you cut it into infinite pieces. Otherwise, you could cut infinite holes from any object that exists, and thus any object taking up any space would have infinite holes, even if it were, say, a sphere.

[@youraveragerobloxkid]

I'd say two. Think about it like this, one of them takes in fluid, the other puts out fluid. They are distinct enough to say there are 2.

[@src6339]

This answers the question "What does legal council do between cases" in ace attorney

[@BonBon15159]

One hole since for example you dig down in one way if you make the hole from 2 different sides then probably yeah 2 holes

[@myau9912]

I view things through practical real-life purposes only, not mathematical or philosophical. If there is ever a point where you can tell someone "No, don't put it through that hole, put it through the other hole." then it has two holes. So straws have two holes. The hole is the opening/exit and everything past the opening is a tube or tunnel until it reaches either an exit, such as another hole, or a deadend. I dont know of any situation of why it would it ever matter which hole you use for a straw, but that isnt the point. The fact that that's even a question at all means it has two.

[@FrostDeino]

That's a good way to approach this

[@theincarnateofkurro]

a straw has three holes, one from the south, one from the north and the one thats in the poor person i stabbed with a straw.

[@forresterlewis3197]

Phoenix made me concerned by the end

[@Ace_of_the_Chaos_Element]

straws are hollowed cylinders, nuff said

[@entitypolyhedron]

Aha, but there is only 1 hole if each opening is connected. There is one hole in the shirt :troll:

[@GabrielParedesOrtiz-c4i]

2:27 Using Edgeworth's and Godot's logic, there is actually 4 holes in the shirt.

[@Jar.Headed]

Here's my take: A doughnut has 1 hole, and so does a coffee mug, because we can start with a doughnut, and sculpt it into the shape of a mug, without introducing new holes. Likewise, a straw is just a long doughnut; like a doughnut, it can be sculpted to become a coffee mug. This assumes the definition of a Hole in topology, which states that a hole in a mathematical object (like a doughnut, more formally known as a torus) is a topological structure that prevents the object from being continuously shrunk to a point. With this definition, a Mug has a *pit*, which I define as a significantly large, concave depression in an object, like the ones used in cups and mugs to hold a liquid. By the definition in topology, a mug, straw, and doughnut have 1 hole, and so do all the cases, except for the shirt which has 1 for the neck and torso, 1 for each arm, and 2 extra, making 4 holes, and as for the initially proposed question, Vsauce made a video about that, but to resume, at the scale of 60 microns, the human body has 7 holes, each being the tear ducts (2 in total), the GI tract, Nostrils, and both Eyesockets (2 in total). What Phoenix presented was the simple observation that a circumference, with a radius equal to that of the cylindrical surface it exists on, can be drawn an infinite number of times, but since a circumference i a 1D line curved in a higher dimension, and since those circumferences are stacked in a cylinder, forming a 2D manifold, or 2D surface, the straw doesn't have an infinite number of holes, but only 1.

[@BNe0]

One hole. One tunnel.

[@TemplarLux]

Can’t believe Von Karma just doxxed Edgeworth like that 😭

[@Saidokatje]

Godot switched sides eventually lol Anyways I enjoyed this one, we need more objection.lols

[@klaus.sfc01official30]

Karma especially has one extra hole.

[@seer665]

Holes. We all have em. 50% of us love em.

[@TheLeviathanYT]

They have one, it goes through the entire straw

[@boxboi286]

if you dig a hole to escape prison the you dug a hole (singular) to escape

[@UnknownGamer40464]

but there will be 2 holes, one inside the prison, and one outside the prison. what you dug was called a tunnel, and it connects the two holes.

[@DeltaSilver88]

Personally, I view a straw as having two holes - one at the top, one at the bottom. Since if a straw had only one hole, there is a possibility for it to have a closed end. With two holes, the closed end argument would be moot.

[@bipinnambiar]

But if you put a hole is a piece of paper, or dug a tunnel through a mountain, those would be one hole

[@bipinnambiar]

And if you dug a pit in the ground, it would be different than punching a hole in the earth

[@boredombandit647]

*OBJECTION!* You are correct about paper as it is a single layer, unlike a shirt that has a front and a back HOWEVER, the mountain point does not go well with definition of hole. “a hollow place in a solid body or surface”. When you play golf, there is a hole in the ground but you can easily get it because there is only one hole. If a straw had the bottom entrance or surface entrance blocked would not make a TUNNEL but a hole…

[@bipinnambiar]

@@boredombandit647 then it is one hole unless blocked. If you put a thin layer through a hole in a paper, somehow thinner than the paper, it would be two holes

[@boredombandit647]

@@bipinnambiar *Evidence* *Cylinder* *TAKE THAT* Were not talking about a thin square, we are talking about cylinder. A good example would be a coffee mug. How would the coffee not leave the cup, because it has a hole to enter but not to exit. So is it 1/2 a hole? Imagine if you had 2 doors, an entrance and a exit. If they were facing each other, is it just one loooooooong door?

[@Falmosta]

A Straw has no holes as it's only the flat part that makes it up, it is then rolled and bound, making the number of holes a straw has undefined. Poor phoenix Needs calculus to prove this!

[@BIackhole]

Straw has 1 hole according to topology, a scientific math field

[@Falmosta]

@@BIackhole Never Studied topology.

[@meemdic8682]

An yes the good old argument between topology and everyday definitions

[@FrostDeino]

Calculus actually…

[@meemdic8682]

@@FrostDeino and that, too, apparently more so towards the end with wright, really

[@kaligath6616]

The answer is both depending on perception a hole naturally has 2 points of entry and or exit but as a constant its 1.

[@pitapockets5481]

This hurts my brain and I’m all for it

[@UnknownGamer40464]

A straw has 3 holes, and no I will not elaborate.

[@helpful_sus]

Fun fact: if you look at a normal clothes 👕 you will see 4 holes, so technically if i close the 2 holes where you put your arms in it will be technically have 2 holes because 4 - 2 = 2

[@dawkosussybaka8190]

Nilered said it himself, there is only one hole.

[@robloxtime595]

Humans contain billions of holes, as there is space between every single atom.

[@GiovanniH-vw8zn]

The amount of holes in a straw depends on the number of atoms long the straw is.

[@nsei7828]

Them every hole existent maked would come with inumerous holes overlaping itself

[@AbileneWCUE]

Straws have one hole, and no one can tell me otherwise.

[@Axels100]

I bet theyve had a hard time surviving handicrafts in school..

[@Nova-Star-01]

it depends on how the straw was made if they just punched a hole into the straw from one side, its one hole if they did that form both sides, its 2 holes

[@deadheat1635]

Topologically speaking, a straw is the same as a donut, so it has one hole.

[@SonicEXEProductions]

The last couple seconds is me for no reason

[@CodesTheOtaku]

To answer Manfred’s initial question, we have about 5,000,007 holes. 5,000,010 if you count eye sockets and belly button.

[@Snake_4750]

Objection!... A straw is just a rolled piece of paper... HOW THEN CAN IT HAVE HOLES? A straw has NO HOLES!

[@FakeCultist]

bro i got 4 minutes in and starting thinking "wheres the judge"

[@Spamtonne-t8x]

Godot was neutral ground till like halfway and then made up his mind

[@cadaeib65]

6:10 Technically it could have between 3 (the two in the front and the neck one) and infinite, but if its not messed up its 6 or 7

[@AccelerateHedge]

"Holed it!"