How to Create a Historically Accurate Gunfighter in Red Dead Online

[@InspireDogworks]

"I didn't want to send a man to hell on an empty stomach." What a gentleman.

[@joaquinfraziermusic6094]

that's a freaking legendary line

[@Pending0]

“Kept on eating like nothing happened” wow

[@AlexKS1992]

Said by infamous shootist Clay Allison. A man who was so crazy he was kicked out of the Confederate Army for “paroxysms of a mixed effect, partly insane and partly maniacal”.

[@uptheworker]

@@Pending0 "so whaddya think of the steak?" *looks up at corpse*

[@litmus7325]

God DAMN that's badass

[@eeeeegy]

“-You can never miss fast enough to win a gunfight.” Wise words.

[@ManvsHistory]

Slow is smooth, smooth is fast!

[@eeeeegy]

@@ManvsHistory Ever since this video I've played by that quote

[@ohcaptainmycaptain3478]

@@ManvsHistory The exact words of my martial arts coaches

[@BastiatC]

John Moses Browning: haha, hold my beer.

[@NODnuke45]

@@BastiatC You've never played a milsim... have you?

[@davidnoahperkins]

Two dislikes? Must have been some fellas that fire from the hip

[@ManvsHistory]

Ha!

[@smrtt92]

They tried to like from the hip, but missed

[@brandonmann9952]

Maybe they were fellers who didnt wear square toe stovepipes

[@zh2266]

Maybe they were *damn O'drsiscools*

[@thepkchannel2269]

Great now I have hip to be square in my head THANKS

[@atomicdreamz6035]

I think you just tricked me into actually learning history and stuff. Sneaky.

[@elijahtxt2334]

I only came here for the history

[@NBGambit]

fallout does that too

[@yohanreview6721]

I think the same , honestly I was looking for a guide to create my online character hahaha

[@joshuajim65]

School just make shit boring.

[@MulletMutent]

If school did it like this, school wouldn’t be horrible

[@SpecterNeverSpectator]

About how cowboys only carried guns to show and were actually bad about it i would say there is a reference to it in the game, in a random encounter in practically any town except Saint Denis you could find a person showing his friend his new revolver and playing with it while his friend tells him to be careful, then two things can happen, he either accidentally shoots his friend dead or he shoots his own leg and walk away like it doesn't hurt because of embarrassment

[@ManvsHistory]

That's right! I remember seeing this. Awesome touch by R*. Kudos to them.

[@xaninuax]

I had this one today (on my first playthrough in 2022,,,)

[@jasoncarswell7458]

The most popular pistol in the old west was the Colt S.A.A, which had no "safety" position of any kind except the hammer down on an empty chamber. Since this meant a reduction of your immediate ammo capacity by 20%, many "especially confident" pistol owners loaded the 6th round anyway and left the hammer down on it. This converts the hammer into a gigantic exposed firing pin, waiting for something to bang on it. If the newspaper reports are any indication, the most common result of loading 6 rounds was a drunken pistolero sitting down to take a crap without remembering to take his pistol belt off first, thus causing his gun to fall backwards out of the holster, land on the hammer and fire a round into the ceiling of the privy.

[@billcarson4187]

@@jasoncarswell7458 The most popular pistol in the Old West was not the Colt SAA. It was all the .38 S&W Top Break revolvers. By far.

[@gabrielboi3465]

if he shoots his friend you can hogtie him and bring him to the sheriff. I did this in Rhodes

[@nicobones9608]

I'm still a little surprised that Red Dead Redemption II Online doesn't have actual cowboy work that you could do. Imagine doing a mission that's a stock drive with potential rustlers, predators, and the threat of stampedes.

[@josh6550]

All I wanted to do in online is run a ranch. They still could've run with the outlaw angle by having other players try to rustle your herd or burn your fields.

[@stpbasss3773]

RDR1 had way more cowboy type work

[@shoeby9273]

Imagine if it wasn't just GTA online reskinned.

[@lullaby.for.arsonists7329]

@@shoeby9273 if it was that, it would have more content

[@andrewnewman8907]

@@josh6550thought that myself. Same way players can rob other traders. Would be cool if other ranchers could rustle others cattle. But rdo is in more or less the same state as it was 2 years ago when you suggested that so I doubt it’s ever gonna happen. Imagine a western game where you can’t be a cowboy.

[@hawksiver]

There's like three videos worth of research in this 23 mins of pure gold....epic quality sir.

[@theinnocents4002]

He's ok...

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks, Siver! Yeah, I could have divided it up (would actually be more profitable that way), but that's just a pain for you folks to have to watch a series, when you could just do it all at once. At least that's my thinking!

[@DevyKins]

@@ManvsHistory We all appreciate the hard work. Makes my day much more interesting!

[@charlesboots6508]

@@ManvsHistory Remember this and act accordingly, folks...

[@hayespipes]

@@ManvsHistory If only every KZbinr was like that. We really appreciate your display of altruism.

[@wanderinghobo4917]

11:20 "Remember, switching to your pistol is always faster than reloading."

[@Digletdiggy]

MW2 memories ❤

[@starwolfcyberlight4546]

What about if your pistol ran out of ammo would you still reload or switch to fistfight

[@mollyracca237]

@@starwolfcyberlight4546 switch to your second pistol

[@tommytaylor2084]

Knife the watermelon

[@starwolfcyberlight4546]

@@mollyracca237 so what if the second pistol ran out

[@vaughanb1963]

That quote from Allison is displayed over my dad's mantle, no joke.

[@ManvsHistory]

That's great! You're dad sounds pretty awesome.

[@MrJakedog104]

I used to work with a guy who was related to Clay Allison

[@Unknown-pj6dm]

@@MrJakedog104 no way

[@MrJakedog104]

@@Unknown-pj6dm He said there was a photo of him in his Aunt's family albums with the name Clay Allison. And when he saw that photo in a wild west documentary he was blown away.

[@icedog3636]

@@MrJakedog104 lol "blown away"

[@carlitos5061]

Could you make historically accurate mexican outlaws, like pancho villa and zapata

[@francis7310]

I second this

[@yusseftheelusive4357]

Up

[@klownnuke6553]

Yes please! I need this.

[@adren-a-line1473]

And José chavez if possible

[@javyassassin13]

This one

[@Najaboa]

Man vs. History is more consistent than Rockstar is.

[@peanutbutter6720]

Is that a joke about updates or game releases?

[@quanahriddle3065]

@@peanutbutter6720 yes

[@clawzx1195]

@@quanahriddle3065 not hardly near the work though, least i hope they work on things...

[@USMC_brue]

Whats sad about that is thats not really a high bar to start with

[@SomerandomShmuck]

swear to god, 3 years later after 2021, "HEY GUYS FIDGET SPINNERS AND PRANK CHALLENGES!"

[@frink7184]

Came for red dead tips, stayed and subbed for Wild West history

[@ManvsHistory]

Welcome aboard, my friend!

[@bungersinyourarea]

Same here

[@hunterrivera2142]

7:37 “If you’re a gamer you recognize this as no scoping.” 😂 I’m dying right about now

[@Blue-mr7fe]

I call this the Spray N Pray

[@Nugcon]

gamer moment

[@carlholleman2702]

"Fast is fine, but accuracy is final. You've gotta take your time in a hurry. "

[@Scottendo]

Congrats man, you actually got a huge shoutout from Rockstar. Here's hoping they actually listen to your suggestions as well!

[@ManvsHistory]

Ha! I just heard that! News to me! Yeah, very cool!

[@MrJamiez]

Where did Rockstar shout him out?

[@David-bg9od]

Damn it sounds like cowboys were 1800s Chads.🤣

[@Zack_410]

​@@David-bg9odRomanization.

[@sonofokes]

I would like to thank you MVH for including me and my friend for the part at 6:19. I showed my mom and she laughed at my role. It was fun working with you, and you we really appreciate it. Sincerely, Stone Wolf.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thank YOU, StoneWolf for your help on this. You and your buddy were awesome to work with. Thanks again, gentlemen!

[@silkroad1201]

Nice work! That was dope

[@XSaintsXTroopsX]

Based history lesson I wasn’t exactly expecting. Always been a Wyatt Earp fan (obv) but didn’t know his quote which is pretty much the progenitor of “Slow is smooth, smooth is fast.” One of my favorite lessons in combat.

[@ManvsHistory]

I thought the exact same thing when I heard it. Chuckled to myself.

[@garmrmagu6524]

My football coach says that all the time

[@DannyMorrs]

In case you weren't sure if your recreation of Holliday is great, Rockstar put out an official Holliday outfit thats almost identical to yours. Good work!!

[@kingman-fm4dq]

What's it called?

[@snapulous5165]

YES he's back, Thank you for saving us from the dryness of red dead online and provide us with some content :))

[@roninwaveman]

I'm truly shocked there weren't any gunfighters that wore a black and purple Baron Samedi outfit. Love the channel man.

[@Year_of_the_Dell]

Superstition would curtail that often.

[@cameronbuckner254]

The amount of research and fantastic information that you cram into these videos are insane! I just want you to know I appreciate the effort akd hard work these videos must take, and me and the rest of your subwcribers will lift you aloft on our shoulders until you dersevedly take over the internets! Its a new manifest destiny that doesnt involve wars or reservations!

[@ManvsHistory]

Ha! It's a revolution of love! Thanks, Cameron.

[@hansolo2829]

You just tricked me into learning history because I wanted to look cool, this guys a marketing genius

[@mullemeck5015]

Thought i’d just get some outfit tutorial but ended up learning more about history than I did the whole 9th grade

[@outlaw615]

Relatable

[@JosephJamesScott]

Most cowboys wore bowlers rather than the wide brimmed hats we see in the movies or artwork. The narrow brim didn't get caught in trees or blow off in the wind.

[@alexjonathanwhite606]

Theses videos are are actually incredible, it’s amazing to watch because it’s an interesting subject and you make it just a little bit more entertaining, great job mate

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks, Bruh! Much obliged!

[@anthonybatuello6153]

You should definitely do a "how to recreate a historically accurate Texas Ranger". Another good one would be creating a historically accurate pioneer

[@elsantanito]

i genuinely think you are the best red dead redemption content creator out there, i love the mix of historical facts and game ideas like these outfit videos! i recently moved my moonshine shack to hennigan's stead and was wondering what type of outfits people living in hot climates used to wear! keep up the good work man!

[@connorperrett9559]

9:20 Oh man! A friend and I were at the leather shop in Dollywood once and they have these toy revolvers in leather holsters with gunbelts. We each put them on and had a duel and mine got stuck! I guess it figures that that actually happened to someone in real life, too.

[@Rabon12]

For my gunfighter I use the brown military scout hat, worsted coat in black, crafting shirt in gray, padded saddle work pants in worn black type look, and the stovepipe square toe boots in light brown, and a black nekerchief.

[@afreestate8466]

Completely forgot this was about red dead. Such a good history video

[@ManvsHistory]

Ha! I sometimes forget that myself.

[@danielcompton9318]

I’ve always wondered about the historical validity of the poncho in Red Dead Online, as you’ve never (to my knowledge) mentioned them. Were they simply never adopted by the white cowboy, or were they never really used at all? I’m asking because I love the kind of look TMWNN had towards the end of The Good, The Bad and The Ugly and I was wondering if it’s pure Hollywood fantasy to wear a poncho or if there’s some historical backing to it. Side note: the day after I finished my own gunfighter outfit based on your lawman, outlaw and cowboy videos I saw the community announcement for this! But as always, great work and thanks for making our experiences in the game more accurate and more interesting, really appreciate the amount of research and effort that goes into these.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks, Daniel! I've looked at thousands of photos of cowboys in the West, but haven't seen one wearing one of these ponchos. That doesn't mean it didn't happen- in fact, I think it's highly likely that some did so. I just haven't seen evidence of it. But knowing how much interaction/exchange took place across the southern border in both directions, I'm sure it did. It certainly was functional, and it looked cool as well. My understanding is that this style was originally brought to Mexico from Chile- migrating north over time.

[@joaqu7002]

@@ManvsHistory The iconic ponchos came first from Chile, but there they still have a lot of cowboys and criminals are robbing trains, while these are rare in the rest of the world.

[@genghiskhan6809]

@@ManvsHistory From the lore I heard, it was mainly (if ever) a thing among people from border states (the Mexican border). So if you RPing a cowboy from Texas, New Mexico, Nevada, Arizona or California, it wouldn’t be too out of place or historically implausible.

[@amazonamazon4872]

Tmwnn, had name, it was blondie lol

[@michaelhunter2631]

@@amazonamazon4872 TMWNN was called Joe by the undertaker at the end of "For A Fistful Of Dollars," Manco by the sheriff with Lee Van Cleef near the beginning of "For A Few Dollars More," & then was nicknamed Blondie by Tuco throughout "The Good, The Bad & The Ugly"

[@legacyofoutlawshd4972]

Hey man! By any chance could you do a video on Mexican gunslingers and outlaws? I would really love that since my country is Mexico!

[@andrewwitham8493]

The vaquero!

[@EMlIlANO]

I'd love a video on them too

[@thecumbucketofficial]

@Craig the Brute why did you just type gears of war?

[@thecumbucketofficial]

@Craig the Brute explain yourself

[@KC.45]

Hello Legacy, I want to see Pistoleros too.

[@spartan5271]

Hey, I want to thank you personally, you have taught me a lot about the old west and I really like your videos, thanks man!

[@ManvsHistory]

You're welcome, Ranger. Thanks for watching!

[@sukhoisu-24fencer3]

I think that guy in the thumbnail is a young Wyatt Earp, my dad has that same photo sitting on a shelf. He showed it to some supposed experts who were big on the history of Wyatt Earp and tombstone. They said that they couldn't deny that it was him.

[@DUMMY_4]

I love these videos. It’s like I’m taking a history class but it’s actually interesting because the teacher relates it to one of my favorite games

[@El_Presidente_5337]

As someone who doesn't really know anything about the Wild West I really enjoyed this video, very informative and great visuals. I didn't even knew belive that there were so many gunslingers in the west.

[@Dingo_Doom]

glad to see R* give you a shout out in RDO this week. love your vids, keep up the great work!

[@Freyafanboy90]

It's amazing seeing these old photos and news articles and knowing that these people once existed. It's like a section of history that seems like it never happened.

[@ManvsHistory]

Yeah, we often forget these are real people.

[@sharko3211]

I used to come here to see the outfits but now I find the analysis the more interesting parts of the videos. Very rarely do you learn about interesting history in school, most of what we’re taught is ancient history or the founding of America/Native American history(which can be interesting but what we’re traditionally taught rarely is).

[@ManvsHistory]

Very cool. Thanks, Sharko. I consider myself much more of a history guy than a Red Dead guy. Just glad I can use the game as an avenue to teach about the past.

[@thesenate7963]

I'm ruining out of outfit slots with all these historically accurate outfits you have blessed us with keep up the good work and hopefully rockstar will give us more outfit slots

[@stevenandbobthedog]

Right on man, thanks for making a series like this. I see so many people posting their character builds and still using the wrong guns, or guns that are modified in unrealistic ways.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks man, glad you enjoyed it!

[@SerSerington]

When you started talking, at first I was like “OMG it’s the dude from the thumbnail!” Haha. Excellent video, brother. Really awesome info

[@ManvsHistory]

I appreciate that!

[@ded2thaworld963]

I hip fire a lot. I don’t dual sidearms like 99.47363% of players because some reason i love the idea of being some kinda damn gunslinger pistoleer or whatever some reason. Also i hate how we can’t have our vests and coats opened or buttoned up

[@oceancactusrequiem6232]

Not having the off hand holster on you kind of feels like declaring to the enemy that you don't need two sidearms to destroy them.

[@zab6124]

I personally would dual wield because larping, but I usually just keep a second gun handy

[@HaloFTW55]

I just use it for practical purposes. The Colt Navy has a long reload, so I would have my character use the second revolver when I run out for my first revolver. I’ve always seen dual wielding as a stupid waste of ammo anyway.

[@bravo6959]

I use dual revolvers for the style

[@ded2thaworld963]

@@bravo6959 most people do, plus cheesing paint it black with them for easy kills is too much for most folks to resist. Most the time all i use is a single navy. I use slippery so if i have to i can use it to get close enough to hip fire most of the time.

[@56Werdan]

I honestly have my character dressed more in a Hollywood style, but I'm glad people are being interested in more historical accuracy. I like my Revolver Ocelot style bounty hunting outfit though.

[@gboymachine9762]

I like how it's a history lesson AND custom Outfits guide. I love the old west

[@johnmcdonough887]

Thank you so much!! These outfit suggestions as well as many from your other videos have seriously enhanced my in game experience. Very interesting videos as well, thanks again.

[@ManvsHistory]

Happy to help, John! Glad you’ve enjoyed them!

[@c41tl6]

I Really enjoy these videos. Please don't stop making them!

[@Arjenbakker1988]

Yet another masterpieces. Well researched and excellently translated into understandable information for us less-informed. Keep up the good work and thank you for your effort.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks, Arjen!

[@Puppy_Puppington]

Man I cannot get enough of these videos I really love just you going to the history of stuff related to the old west and then also throwing in red dead in. This is really fun. Spaghetti westerns are the best.

[@ManvsHistory]

Glad you enjoy them!

[@The_Mikler-29]

I live near Tombstone Arizona, and it blew my mind to know that my character in RDO had a prettyyy similar look to Doc Holliday. Also, the shooting at the O.K Corral is said to not actually have taken place at the bar, but at a lot near the same location. However the bullets in the wall are very real, so someone else was shot there lol

[@larryblack5963]

My favorite gunfighter, while not exactly historically accurate, is Paladin from “Have Gun will Travel”. He’s a badass, and rarely uses his rifle, and prefers his custom Colt.

[@theinnocents4002]

Schofield all the way!! If not for S&W being stubborn and only chambering for their own rounds there would have been no Colt SAA!

[@charlesboots6508]

I wished the game had made the Schofield's reload faster and the Cattleman more powerful, but that's quibbling.

[@spookysioux1224]

The schofield looks awesome but I use the navy. Best revolver in the game hands down.

[@theinnocents4002]

@@spookysioux1224 It is, but I can't bring myself to use it anymore. Won't use the semi auto shotgun either.

[@thecowboy9698]

@@charlesboots6508 - I think the Scholfields reloaded just fine, but I do hear you 100% on the Cattleman. One thing I wished is that we didn't have to always shoot an enemy twice before bringing him down. Even with Express Ammo, I have had this issue several times, and that's the most powerful ammo you can buy.

[@deancarr4507]

@@spookysioux1224 I'm a LeMat guy myself

[@SawRunner]

You're one of the only people on this platform I actually enjoy watching and get excited when you upload. Keep up the great work, man! This is pure quality content

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks, SawRunner! Mighty kind of you!

[@Livan-yuruikami]

Its crazy how the two revolvers you talked about are literally the two best in my opinion The double action for hipfire and the navy for general use (The lemat is cool because of the shotgun mode but excepet for that its a low cost navy)

[@sleufffff]

1:57 bro feed your horse lmao

[@stefano1895]

Man, one thing is definitely missing in your catalogue: historically accurate saddles!

[@krakenonesixgaming6061]

I'm a fan of interesting history, but this is something else. I'd watch this like a history channel documentary. The rdr2 piece is just a bonus. Also, your podcast episode with OnlyPvPCat was really nice. Great work!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thank you, Kraken! I appreciate that!

[@zion9802]

DUDE. i came for red dead, stayed for the history lesson. i wish i had found this channel sooner

[@ManvsHistory]

Welcome aboard, Brandon!

[@ShellShock11C]

Great video. I was surprised to hear Wild Bills preference was a Colt 1851 Navy (cap/ball/powder) revolver which was a bit dated at that point, since cartridge's were showing up. I was also very surprised because when that point came up in the video, I was sitting here playing with my Colt 1851 Navy. Love BP shooting.

[@flippydippy6587]

“I didn’t want to send a man to Hell on an empty stomach” that’s the most badass thing I’ve ever heard

[@ankujo8924]

Just wanted to say thanks for these vids, this one in particular. I'm enjoying RDO more then ever looking historically accurate as possible, and you've sparked an interest in the real history of the american west for me with all the info you share.

[@ManvsHistory]

Very happy to hear that!

[@Stonehead420]

“Because I didn’t want to send him to hell on a empty stomach” such a cold response 🥶

[@Texo_McKevo]

I made mostly inspired off of Wyatt Earp, John Wesley Harden, and the John Wayne/ Clint Eastwood inspired winter outfits.

[@Casedilla73]

This video is awesome; so inspiring. I love the fantastical and seemingly impossible stories of gunmen in this video. I didn’t expect to hear all these stories when I clicked on this video, but I’m glad I did. This makes me wanna become my own legendary gunman in this game. Thank you.

[@ManvsHistory]

Glad you enjoyed it, Nova!

[@dEnNiS_0175]

Pls Do a historically accurate cavalry scout outfit video

[@SecretlyATrout]

This one too, they're all great suggestions

[@bigjill6906]

I think that the reason I love red dead 2 is the same reason I love Robert Frost's poetry, both embody a sort of romance that appeals to me as a man, a sense of our relationship with the wild, and a feeling of isolation. When playing, the missions and combat, while fun, was never what felt the most real to me, what felt real, and maybe even what I enjoyed most, was riding through the woods quietly, having not encountered another person for several in-game days, and I, even if only having played for 10 minutes i also began to feel alone in nature.

[@misterdonlon]

Late 1800's cowboys prioritizing avoiding chafing over carrying a gun as such an awesome and hilarious historical nugget. Another awesome video my guy!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks, Donlon! Good to see you drop in again, my friend! How's your channel coming along?

[@misterdonlon]

@@ManvsHistory The channel is still surviving! Haha Took a quick detour to make some introduction videos for some projects I do with my students (*the Renaissance got a March Madness themed twist this year, and the Paris Peace Conferences were the location of the new season of Survivor) Not too much of an audience for those videos lol but the students were into it! Hopefully I'll be back in the databases looking into accuracy and authenticity soon!

[@ManvsHistory]

@@misterdonlon Glad to hear that. Best of luck, partner!

[@KealohaHarrison]

Stumbled upon this channel last week and I absolutely love your videos! It would be really cool to see a historically accurate gambler character video where you go into the various games Rockstar left out like Faro or dice before showing how professional gamblers would’ve dressed. Keep up the great work, love the channel!

[@therebellion96]

This is a very interesting educational experience! Kind of reminds me of when FrankieOnPC used to tell these WW1/WW2 stories while he would play Battlefield games. Initially, you would come for gameplay and commentary and you would click off the video knowing you learned something. This is my first time watching your videos by the way. I definitely gonna check out some more!

[@ManvsHistory]

Much obliged!

[@Maximus-bd4ef]

It's so awesome seeing a fight between 2 groups in a town, or really anywhere

[@atlasthewolf1508]

You folks online got Navy Revolvers? Y’all are lucky.

[@tillercaesar-kq4ou]

I’m a McCoy and I got excited when I heard the McCoy shot gunn lol

[@X_DXFFY_X]

This man isn’t the history teacher we wanted but the one we needed 😔

[@pygmy.]

0:07 I'm your huckleberry

[@ahhhaah]

"guns aren't for threats, their for actions." top 10 favorite quotes i've ever heard.

[@deovindice2625]

Another great video! Thank you for the effort, I hope you had as much fun making it as I did watching it.

[@nicholibre]

To be honest, I feel like the hat you get with the Londonderry outfit is the coolest one for making a gunfighter outfit

[@dejavu3547]

1:32 i wonder… if… he had a big iron on his hip?

[@underdweller5327]

I'd love to see you do a video on the historical accuracy of the haircuts in RDR2/RDO!

[@excollector9963]

I vaguely remember a story about Clay Allison and another man digging a grave to have a knife fight in where the winner would bury the loser.

[@Person-uz5lw]

Not only am I inspired to make a period accurate character but I'm more so inspired to start reading gunfighter history

[@shadowagent6051]

So the lesson to be learn here is,Cowboys and Gunfighters are in a whole different level when it comes to pull that trigger.

[@ibefullofme]

I named my character Bummin Pete and he runs around with no clothes because his horse ran away.

[@jacoblanning]

i really enjoy this stuff i like the history abt stuff like that i’m glad you educate us on the history of it while also showing us what we wanted to see so we have a better idea on what to look for in the outfits

[@jessecromwell3669]

Your fantastic I absolutely love your videos !!! Your research and knowledge shows you have a passion !!

[@ManvsHistory]

Much obliged, Jesse!

[@willtaylor754]

I really enjoyed this video. I came here expecting a voiceless video of several outfits and left with a greater appreciation of history. Thank you!

[@gcates1147]

This is gold....I cold watch for hours.

[@jak_379]

If only school was as informative as your videos! I’ve watched this one many times so far and I don’t get tired of it

[@ManvsHistory]

Appreciate that! I used to teach my classes the same way, actually!

[@casualcaveman18]

Please do a historically accurate US soldier please

[@alexandermiller5910]

Ive had the same realistic outfit for almost two years with minor additions. Buddy said it looked like my character was one in the game already. Its very similar to Brendan Fraser in The Mummy.

[@DarthWall275]

I thought this was just going to be a 23 minute shitpost, but I was pleasantly surprised by actual historical knowledge.

[@theredheadedredneck8089]

What about a historical accurate horse like commonly found hair styles hair colors saddles spurs to go with it

[@theredheadedredneck8089]

Or a historical accurate preacher

[@real4426]

@@theredheadedredneck8089 if there was a historically accurate preacher I'd make ENRICHO PUCCI

[@real4426]

@PigzWithAZee cowboys are a jojo reference so this is fair game buckaroo

[@real4426]

@PigzWithAZee sex pistols moment 😎

[@kindadim]

@@real4426 you're so boring

[@alexalvarado5753]

If you want your doc to have the gun the real doc Holliday had, use the high roller revolver. It can be found at the fence

[@collin5598]

Idea for next one: historically accurate trapper? Because these vids are amazing! My mountain man outfit had a lot of inspiration from these videos, and a trapper outfit would seem cool to me :) pls keep uploading these vids 'cause I’m enjoying them and they are all masterpieces!

[@Iceman-cq2po]

Try the Video he made for “How To Make a Historically Accurate Mountain Man.

[@collin5598]

Already seen that, but mountain men looked pretty different from real trappers

[@Iceman-cq2po]

Ohhh ok well good luck

[@calicojack7029]

Another fantastic video. I love all the artwork that you use, I keep sending these videos to the group I play Deadlands with because they've got such great info.

[@ManvsHistory]

Awesome to hear that, man! Glad you're enjoying them!

[@Bovium]

Just found this channel and wow, your videos are of absurd quality! Informative and fun to watch.

[@ManvsHistory]

Ha! Thanks, JokeBo. Mighty kind of you!

[@thelightpost6056]

Dual wielding pistols is for a special type of situation in rdr2 which is “uh oh I’ve been thrown off my horse right in front of a gator and I could not grab a semi auto, time to unload 16 bullets into the face of this creature in the shortest amount of time possible.”

[@MetalheadQ]

I love the background music.

[@megapancake1876]

What is it?

[@MetalheadQ]

@@megapancake1876 I have no idea sorry

[@Just_Zurc]

I love how you give a history lesson before you show the outfit. I learned more about the old west from this channel than history class could ever teach me

[@enby_kensei]

I love how that distinction between gunfighters and cowboys is actually suggested in the gameplay of the story mode. If you look at the way Arthur and John use the Dead Eye mechanic, Arthur's aim is way more steady and the soundscape is far more relaxed, with a ticking clock. John's aim is a bit more wobbly, and you can hear his heartbeat. It's like Arthur is a more natural and trained gunslinger, whereas John is a cowboy who can handle himself in a fight.