Historical Accuracy of Clothing in Red Dead Online

[@ianjohnson3840]

Historical accuracy of the dialect/way of speaking

[@koniczka2000]

Thats actually a really good idea!

[@josemariaalipio449]

Always found it interesting how characters use “was” instead of “were.” “While we was robbing” or “They was talking.”

[@koniczka2000]

@@josemariaalipio449 Yeah! Me too!

[@josemariaalipio449]

Roger Dodger Thanks for that partner. I’m not from the US, so that’s cool to know.

[@TheRoboticDream]

The accent for Arthur is slightly inaccurate and is a mixture of dialects, but Roger Clark said he wanted to focus more on being consistent and that since that Arthur was constantly traveling that he would probably had picked up bits and pieces from the regions he stayed at.

[@RocketDragons]

"If there's an article of clothing you'd like added to the game, let me know down in the comments" because this guy puts more effort into RDO than Rockstar does, these days.

[@ManvsHistory]

Ha! That's pretty good, Mark.

[@TheWazzoGames]

well, they were quick to shut down there servers "To honor George Floyd" so that's something 🤷

[@kedrshr1mp6]

@@TheWazzoGames Seriously?

[@acanuck4life]

@@kedrshr1mp6 yes

[@riotrecker8978]

Gabe02 yeah because that does anything

[@kosmickosm771]

Rockstar: *adds historically accurate clothing* Also Rockstar: "I require gold for that I'm afraid do you have some?"

[@gatorkid3653]

“Man killed another person for their hat” Me: I WOULDN’T **HAVE** TO IF THEY SOLD THE HATS WE WANT

[@jimmykearney214]

I do that in story mode all the time to try to get all the stolen hats.

[@buckleuphun]

Yup. In online mode I don't even think about paying for the overly inflated prices and just steal someones hat. Works just fine, and I usually just knock them out, put them back on their horse, and let them on their way

[@aggressor6609]

The trapper in Valentine has been through a lot of "Gimme your hat" fights

[@nicobones9608]

@@aggressor6609 I've gotten into a number of fights with that guy and taken his hat, but it's not usually BECAUSE I wanted the hat, it was because he was mouthing off. One time, I just stared at him until he got really mad, then the second I turned my back he sucker punched me and the fight began. Another time, I walked up to him and took a photograph, and this pissed him off enough for him to attack me. Every time I take his raccoon hat.

[@gravitymk]

There one guy who always spawns in valentine and I always knock him out or kill him for his hat.

[@hvgk3565]

*The Fat Men's Special* ... could be a nice Netflix show

[@ArielYoursTruly]

@Cumbria Strong ^

[@jimmykearney214]

@Cumbria Strong oof

[@george-o2514]

Arthur's hat is from his dad and when Arthur was young they immagrated from Wales

[@Log-On-Line]

wait arthurs from wales

[@george-o2514]

@@Log-On-Line yes his parents moved to America when he was VERY young not old enough to remember much

[@LonesomePrarie]

Logan Ainsworth I’d like it to be true, he says in game he doesn’t remember. His last name is very common in Wales. Henry Morgan the Pirate was from Wales.

[@Big-BossX]

Arthur was born in america his father was from wales no?

[@george-o2514]

@@Big-BossX he was born in Wales but the immigrated when he was a bay so the only things he knows are from what his parents told him. His parents are originally from Wales so yes Arthur grew up in America hence the southern accent

[@mariobrother4882]

You should do how historically accurate are the food and goods in red dead online

[@koniczka2000]

Pretty nice idea!

[@ricefarmer4738]

Yes

[@eliegbert8121]

like how a can of beans is worth three gold wedding rings?

[@spex5575]

Ẁe need Arthur's blue winter coat from single player in online (The buttoned up version). Having chains and pocket watches on vests like Dutch would be cool as well.

[@user-zg5ey5xo9i]

I want to wear my gun holsters like dutch.

[@iemantswout]

Or like hosea

[@alextorres4667]

It's in the game but unbuttoned just like everything, I wish we could choose to button up clothes

[@mariajudith1895]

It’s practically inside Red Dead Online as a “Limited-Stock” item; you can buy it but the only downside is only opened button. It will be a nice addition if Rockstar give us an option on our option menu to have it open and closed just like on GTA online.

[@glorifiedmastodon1353]

@Lucas Johnson your goddamn right

[@Steff_kjns]

By the way, Arthurs leather hat was a keepsake from his father,. Which is why he always kept it on him, despite it not being comfortable.

[@ed-id4ek]

Its like rockstar forgot about inflation while making the prices and remembered it when making rewards

[@tarheelpro87]

Made everything you can purchase more expensive than your existence but pay you as much as a McDonald’s worker.

[@pvrpleheart4093]

I've been dying for anyone to make a video on this! This is great!

[@ManvsHistory]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@andypalmer7600]

Just wanted to say how much I love these videos. I'm a History teacher in the UK (kind of High School equivalent). The American West is a personal fascination of mine (particulalry earlier era - massive fanboy of the Mountain men, disguising it as academic interest). I also teach the topic at exam level. Aaaaand I love Red Dead; frequently using bits of it to illustrate what I'm teaching, particulalry inviting students to identify inaccuracies or anacronisms. Anyway - thanks for the videos, mate. Definately enjoying them!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Andy, really appreciate the kind words! I'm with you on the American West. Just an amazing period of history. I just finished 'Blood & Thunder' (massive book on Kit Carson) that you'd likely love. I recommend it. I think many of us yearn for the adventure, danger, and freedom of that time in the American West. I can't watch Jeremiah Johnson wishing I could do the same thing. Where in the UK are you from? My wife and I were over there last summer.

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

Well this brave R.U.C. man came marchin' up our street 600 British soldiers he had lined up at his feet

[@alexalaniz5176]

Roger Dodger Frontier Australia had its own little wild west didn’t it?

[@demarcus6493]

Man i wish the world could be as simple as it was back then.

[@ElPayasoMalo]

Things get more complicated if you're anything else but white, and even then it can be iffy if you're of Italian or Irish decent.

[@lucasmorris7540]

@@ElPayasoMalo What

[@vacuumcleaner9895]

⁠@@lucasmorris7540everyone was a lot more racist back then

[@Gbag34]

These videos are really interesting and fun, even though a lot of the time they make me sad that Rockstar has to go all goofy and overkill on their Online modes. Super underrated channel man. Cheers!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks man, really appreciate it.

[@UncleBen205]

nice vid, btw there are already 2 variants of the leather wrist cuffs in the game that you get from outlaw pass 1 and 2

[@ManvsHistory]

Good to know! I missed them!

[@markfromaustralia1594]

Outlaw pass 3 available in stores on Mars!

[@guarded_sheriff1934]

But they made the players roll up their sleeves which is wrong they go over

[@Log-On-Line]

you cant buy them though and the good leather gauntlets were in outlaw pass 1 and fucking rockstar wont let pc have that outlaw pass

[@krackedupkrabers5372]

Yeah but you have to pay thru ur asshole for the outlaw passes

[@markfromaustralia1594]

I play as a Native American and would love to see head dresses and the beaded chest plates that they also wore I think not having Native American gear is a huge mistake by rockstar

[@BasedGod66]

And im a Taino

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

Im still waiting for a highlander skirt jajaja

[@TruBluMonkey]

I know they have cholla boots, as well as brindle shoes as well as the leather pants. Run the button up John marathon style vest, tan version, you’ll have a Native American set up.

[@mysticmike9778]

Same I agree

[@ezrael6795]

I don't want head dresses as much as I want native beaded jewelry

[@Devin_Stromgren]

Fun fact about the bib front shirt. It was originally designed as firefighter gear in the 1850s. The purpose of the bib was to cover the buttons so that it was socially acceptable to go vest-less while fighting fires for more freedom of motion.

[@ShootistFN]

I asked and I was given, thank you so much man vs history. never fail to make your viewers entertained

[@ManvsHistory]

Happy to oblige! Thanks buddy.

[@noahsherwood2445]

I can't stand that Rockstar made everything so expensive in RDO it's so stupid.

[@thatbuckmulligan]

What crest is that?

[@iemantswout]

Its not that expensive

[@Hirovard]

money isn't hard to earn and its not like you have taxes, day to day living costs to cover. you can just eat a can of beans if you need to top up your health and your basically good to go for weeks in game. try that in reality and you will be dead, and even then a can of beans isn't a meal.

[@noahsherwood2445]

@@thatbuckmulligan The crest of my Irish ancestors, Clan O'Byrne

[@Tigershark-oy5ci]

Hirovard just hunt for food. And pick shit around the map to craft cures. And your all set.

[@Hamstersandw1ch]

The big coats can be bought at a trapper in rdo. Edit: Realised this video was probably made before the coat was added.

[@Danny_V272]

Arthur’s hat belonged to his dad, who came over to the country from wales when Arthur was very young. Both “Arthur” and “Morgan” we’re both very common welsh names

[@Llama_Of_Rivia]

According to the red dead wiki Arthur was born in the northern US, please check your sources before commenting

[@Danny_V272]

@@Llama_Of_Rivia my bad, that was copy and pasted from a wiki so thanks for correcting me

[@juan_valdez117]

@@Llama_Of_Rivia do you even have a second brain cell?

[@noahferguson3460]

The people who disliked probably was killed by their hats

[@Cydia942]

Virgin Arthur’s hat Vs. Chad Viking helmet

[@HarryTheEustreptospondylus]

Bro, that one Bounty Hunter outfit 💀

[@Atlas.Calamitous]

Another fantastic video! I am very interested to hear how accurate was the geography of the setting of RDR2, specifically the cities and townships compared to similar communities from the time period in regions that inspired the game.

[@koniczka2000]

Very good idea!

[@kris_the_unhip4963]

I’d like to see more holster types. I’m pretty sure that not all cowboys/gunslingers wore their holsters the same way.

[@mojaverootz6049]

I’d like to see more mountain man outfits in rdr2 online. Be cool to have a trapper

[@brandedsw0rdsman1]

Maybe in the next update? People have been speculating that a trapper role could be next.

[@ManvsHistory]

This is my dream.

[@Slowpoke514]

Even if it is not a new role, I hope they bring in the trapper from the story line. All of his trapper stands are already in the online game. I want to get some of the items that he makes for my online character. I'm hoping he is added along with the legendary animals that R* has confirmed are coming.

[@fullbeans983]

Well, we have the trapper. All I can say is I hope it is expanded on and actual clothing can be bought. Not these animal costumes.

[@xavierpravednikov8012]

I want to see more ponchos especially in story mode

[@ricefarmer4738]

U could get some from del lobos and some u can keep.

[@malcolmong5488]

@@ricefarmer4738 no you can keep their clothes you can only save their hats like the bolero hat.

[@davidolvera1031]

@@malcolmong5488 You could open a chest in one of their hideouts and the poncho would be added to your wardrobe.

[@Johnnysmithy24]

@@davidolvera1031 Wait what?? Is that true??

[@davidolvera1031]

@@Johnnysmithy24 No. That was a hypothetical.

[@scottn322]

There technically are leather wrist cuffs in the game. They were a limited item available when they did the Outlaw Pass, but as far as I know there are only two of them, one for the first pass and one for the second, and that was the only way to get them. Whether or not they will come back around, or another type of wrist cuff will be on offer in the future, I don't know.

[@sinux8438]

It's 2 AM and I just watched a video on how historically accurate clothes are in RDR2... I need to go to bed... great video though!

[@willhoops695]

This is my fav rdr KZbinr this man is a genius and puts real work into his pls don’t stop posting

[@ManvsHistory]

Ha! Thanks, Kid! I appreciate the kind words!

[@kropotkinnie]

Holy cow, you were at like 300 subs last time I checked in! So excited for this growth. Can't wait to see you get into those double digit thousands!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Ash, very cool of you to say. Really appreciate the support! Thanks for being a subscriber!

[@VickiVampiressYT]

Just started playing Red Dead 2 the other night. I've been having a blast, and being a history nerd I guess I've found a great new channel to follow! You just gained a subscriber, boah'!

[@ManvsHistory]

Awesome, thank you, Marcy!

[@brotherbrace2303]

Great content man I made my guy a native that's based on the lakota people I literally jumped for joy when they added those beaded moccasins to the game all I need for them to do now is add some variant of buckskin pants that's beaded like you see the Wapiti occasionally wear and maybe a bandana that's tied around the head like a headband and maybe I'm asking too much but a buffalo headdress would be really cool too it's all already in the game just not for the online portion yet

[@ManvsHistory]

Agreed, would love to see some more Native attire. Thanks Brace!

[@timothywhite5453]

Imagine finding out from a friend that one of your two favorite profs has a youtube channel, log on, see he has 8k subscribers and pretty polished content and then all you can think about is how he said class would be cancelled the week RDR2 came out. Cheers to the success of your channel and looking forward to binging all your content. Hopefully when the apocalypse is over I can scrounge up more money for a few unnecessary for my major history classes. Haven't been beheaded in a while.

[@ManvsHistory]

Good to hear from you, Tim! Hope you're well, buddy!

[@K-Han-sd]

Been loving your videos! I love knowing the historical context when playing, definitely makes it more fun. Keep up the good work!! Looking forward to your next video.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Kevin!

[@jagcf]

Great video! 👏🏾👏🏾Now I would like a more in depth video on women's clothing accuracy, as I'm a female player with a female character, often using skirts and blouses for her. I love historical facts videos😍

[@sirsporty6556]

Great video with lots of very interesting info, however I really would like to have seen you talk about gloves, which is the only item of clothing in RDR2 that you missed as far as I’m aware. Most of the gloves in the game seem to be fairly realistic, but I would’ve found it interesting to hear you talk about why certain gloves were worn among certain types of people. And yes, I realise this video is nearly a year old now, but I just thought I’d mention it anyway haha. And again, really enjoyed the vid, nice work. 👍

[@doggodiggin]

those huge coats you were talking about can be seen in trappers clothing jacket section now

[@zacthecrusader9759]

This video is a year old but still amazing you make History awesome

[@Ltngstrike]

Another great video! I've found so much of the clothing in the game to be too "gangsta pimp" for my taste. To each their own. My ex-Mountain man/Trapper toon wears worn ropers, buckskin breaches, work shirt with a duster, Liberty hat and chaps. That's as close to cowboy attire as I can seem to put together from the offerings in game. Of course I have other combos for cold weather, i.e. Sobel hat and wooly chaps, etc... I'd sure like to see an historically correct Capote offered. Keep up the great work my friend!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Ltngstrike! Appreciate the support!

[@TheHeavyshadow]

Arthur's hat could be tailor-made. But I'm not sure that's a good idea for someone constantly on the run. I always find it fascinating to see these old prices. Like 85 cents for a vest on average seems so unreal. And thinking about that: I think an interesting video(series?) could be "How much would/did living in X cost for a day/week/month?" X here being either a real city/town or a RDR2-city/town for which the math is done with a comparable IRL-city/town. Then looking at some everyday-items and -services and how much they cost for what could have been considered "lower class", "middle class", and "upper class", and maybe what professions would have payed enough on average to allow that level of living. Those everyday-items being the bare minimum like "bread" for the "lower class", and more "luxurios" items like sugar, honey, or soap for the "middle class" and "upper class".

[@MOONSUN4Life]

Fascinating! The part about hat customization was particularly interesting. I had never even given a thought as to why hats looked the way they did, just assumed that was how people wore their hats back then, not unlike some people today wear baseball caps the wrong way for no particular reason. I would not have imagined that there was actually a practical reason why some wore their hats the way they did. I was completely unsurprised by how outrageously inaccurate the prices in Red Dead Online are, but I was still shocked to see just how overpriced they are. I mean, a markup of over twenty-five THOUSAND percent (yet we get four percent of the historically accurate payout for bounties)... Really??? Dang, Rockstar, that's what I call cutthroat! I love Red Dead Redemption and I love this channel, keep up the great work!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Moonsun! I'm with you. I love the game, but have to call things out as I see them. I get the economy, I just think it could be better balanced is all. Thanks for the support, man, really appreciate it!

[@goonggoongginga9954]

I love these videos it's just really cool to learn how accurate the game is to history and weird stories you find and share also I love the background and how informative you are with the videos.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Ginga. Glad to see you took the red pill.

[@goonggoongginga9954]

Man vs. History You betcha 😉😂

[@Silly_little_snakes]

I'm a costume design student and I absolutely love rdr2, so I've always been curious as to the accuracy of the clothing in rdr2, as I know that movies and such often make mistakes, exaggerate, or just simply make design choices favouring their own personal preference over the historical accuracy of the garments, so this video was really interesting! I am also currently working on a project in which we redesign characters from existing materials but put our own twist on it, and I chose to focus on the American West and need to research historically accurate clothing for the time, so much of the information here will be very useful! Great video! :)

[@ManvsHistory]

Glad it came in handy! If you're looking for clothing for specific people/occupations, see my "How to create a historical...." vids.

[@MrMOd3RnW4rF4R3]

I'd be really interested to see you make maybe a 3 or 5 list compilation of accurate outfits where you dress your character up as something from that era. For me I have 2 that I have created. General Robert E Lee and the El Paso Sheriff Dallas Stoudenmire which is who I use primarily. I find the game a bit more fun knowing the background of my character.

[@ManvsHistory]

I like that idea. Thanks HW!

[@GLJ94]

I'd like to see the historical accuracy and a price comparison for the saddles. Read an article a long time ago that said for a cattle drive you could expect about $50 and that was about as much as a new saddle. So I'd like to that

[@ManvsHistory]

The most expensive saddle in the 1898 Sears & Roebucks Catalog was $32. Most were around $15. That said, the days of the cowboy would have been a bit before RDR2 begins, and it seems like many things were a little more expensive then (c.1870 vs 1898).

[@just_justin7]

The wrist cuffs are in the game but they were limited time and now are gone.

[@sadare765]

Thanks! This was a very interesting watch! Have you thought on checking out the points of interest in rdr2's main story and their real life counterparts?

[@ManvsHistory]

There's a guy on KZbin named Real Pixels that tackled the story mode. He put a great deal of work into it, and it's fantastic. So instead of reinventing the wheel on that one, I'd direct you to him. Superb video.

[@sadare765]

@@ManvsHistory oh yes I've watched that video, but I mean the little points of interest, like the settlers/viking rock carvings or the mammoth/whale bones Arthur can come across free roaming. Either way, if anyone sees this comment, go to Pixel's video, it's a must

[@AllThatJuice-]

im designing a cowboy character, helpful to know which clothing is accurate to the time period and where R* took creative liberties. Also appreciate you explaining the function of each clothing item for the cowboy

[@ManvsHistory]

Happy to help, Yoda.

[@davidtennantllewelyn1367]

Wrist cuffs are in the game as a purchase item for the collector role. Great video as are the rest. Keep em coming.

[@Rox-in5pu]

This was fabulous thank you!

[@alextorres4667]

My request has been fulfilled!

[@ManvsHistory]

You got it, buddy.

[@zsoltcserep9104]

I don't know if i can give next video request, but i will, historical accuracy of hunting, the animals, killing them (there is the lasso killing, i wanna know if its accurate or not) the skinning techinque, how a pelt looked like and if it fits in a scatchel or only a horse, do they really store pelts and carcasses on horse, the value a butcher would pay for a pelt/ carcass? These are the question that came up in my mind

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks buddy. Yeah, I have some components of this on my list. Have to look into a bit of it further. Appreciate the suggestion!

[@zsoltcserep9104]

Alright, thank you for answering

[@roberthuffmann8204]

Although I know that they didn’t exist at the time, I’d like bolo ties to be added to the game. I also want to mention that leather cuffs were added at some point a few months back.

[@mariajudith1895]

Your channel is awesome and your descriptive narration it’s delightful; I’m impressed how much Rockstar give us the pleasure on living this kind of era with this open world game... I’m laughing especially on the ladies clothing because in online I’m playing as a female gunslinger but like you said - the women’s clothing choices were more aesthetic than practical. Have a nice year, greetings from Puerto Rico 🇵🇷: Manvs.History. 🥰👩🏽‍🦱

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Maria, glad to hear you enjoyed it! Stay well in PR!

[@mr.mimmler2151]

I love this channel, I'm surprised its not more popular

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Walker. Really appreciate you subscribing!

[@raypaquettejr]

Funny you mentioned the bison fur coat cuz they went on to add one, well it’s made from bear pelt but its the exact same look and even colors. Maybe they listened to you lol. Love the content

[@StacieMMeier]

3:15 Is a Gamblers hat and was not as common. These hats though were not that hot nor heavy and were considered great for travelling. It is hard to find one today because they were...well...leather and left untreated tend to not last long. That being said, it is a true hat and very true to that era. Many used them for rain and snowy areas, because of the resistance of never getting soaked--unlike felt and fur. The reason you don't see them in pics is that they shine and this caused issues with pictures of the time. These hats, if original, because of the rarety are highly collectable. You need to find a catalogue during that era, 1880 to say 1890. After that, they seem to be less common. And a true version of this hat exactly how he has it, not fur nor felt. Saint-Denis would have carried this hat though I doubt other towns around Red Dead would have. I doubt Sears would have sold it, however, department stores like Goldwater's or even Macy's (Which did exist at the time) would have had it. These are the type of stores that would have carried it not a Sears. People assume Sears was the majour store at the time, it wasn't. It was founded in 1892 and while Sears did own a store before this and a catalogue it never amounted to much. Sear's store started out as a Watch/Jeweler seller until it incorporated in 1892. By this time, Sear's had left and sold it, he then joined A. C. Roebuck and the current Sears was born. Using it for Red Dead though isn't correct historically, the gang probably never even heard of Sears. MY point, you looking for something that Sears couldn't have carried because it didn't exist at the time of that hat (Which was more like the 1870s to early 1880s.) By the time of Red Dead 2, that hat was out of style though people still wore them.

[@OneofInfinity.]

One of my favorites is the worn cavalry hat, looks good on Arthur.

[@flowerpower003]

I believe the cavalier hat is more of a “macaroni” hat... which is putting a feather in your hat to look fancy perhaps a rich person educated explorer would wear it? the tillman hat may not be period accurate but my copy of “the aventures of huckleberry finn” on the cover huckleberry looks to be wearing a similar hat if my eyes aren’t mistaken. In the end of the day I am keep repeating this but thank you, I will use this info to inprove my rancher character from valentine.

[@miscito8334]

Nice to see the part about fur coats knowing that they were recently added, nice video!

[@ManvsHistory]

Yep, I'm pleased they were able to add them in.

[@YoursTruIy_]

They sort of do have wrist cuffs in the game, they were available to unlock with the outlaw pass season one and two, both of which featured wrist cuffs

[@Nytellem]

This is exactly the type of research R* should do more of.

[@thatguydude419]

I truly enjoy your videos, thank you for your consistent content

[@ManvsHistory]

Glad you like them!

[@ElPayasoMalo]

I decided my character was a former Dartmouth professor, so he looks fancy-as-hell. Black stovepipe top hat, black formal coat, expensive red vest, bright gold necktie, black opera pants, embellished black boots, studded red spurs, custom black gunbelt, and a golden pince-nez. I wanted to make him unique, so he's rather portly, has shoulder length hair, and has a fancy mustache. To really hammer home his current life as a badass gunslinging hero, he often also wears a black bandolier and black rifleman gloves.

[@milannikolic8731]

Another great one! Man the 19th century US was one strange place.. you'd get killed by the weirdest things. On the side note.. I believe there are 1 cuffs in rdro. I believe I got it from outlaw pass 2. Not sure

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks man. Yeah, somebody else mentioned the cuffs! I missed it, but glad to hear they added it!

[@milannikolic8731]

@@ManvsHistory They look a lil bit different than the ones in the vid. They have like fluffy wool ends

[@chinind.5611]

currently making a story bout a outlaw so this channel really helps me with making the right consistency. spelled that wrong

[@ManvsHistory]

Glad I can help out then, Emory!

[@mehdigouader]

Impressive effort and Great job done on fact checking historical accuracy of RDR !!! +1 Subscriber !

[@ManvsHistory]

Welcome aboard, Mehdi! Appreciate the support!

[@spookysioux1224]

Hey dude! They added a bear coat that is very simillar to the big fur coats you mention and show. It looks very nice, find it at gus.

[@einarfagge1931]

This series is gold👍 keep it going

[@onlythemoon3273]

You should do a historical accuracy of tonic prices and if they even had a effect on your person.

[@Cricreone]

Hats like the "Tillman hat" are historically accurate for poor farmhands on latin-america, from early 1800 all the way to late 1900's.

[@solidsnakeshugecake]

Wow. So its actually historically Accurate that i kill people for their hats in story mode 😂

[@k3vman089]

0:31 *sweats nervously knowing I damn well did this before in story*

[@jacobmarshall6163]

Great video as usual you legend!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Jacob! Appreciate the support, man.

[@InspireDogworks]

You are absolutely fascinating to watch. Please keep up this awesome content!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks for the kind words, Ashley. Much obliged.

[@SemperPearce]

Thank you for more quarantine content! I'm wondering if you've ever heard of the firearms company Uberti. They seem to specialize in manufacturing working models of some of the firearms that would be featured in RDR2. I'm not sure if videos relating to firearms are problematic or not when talking about history with some of KZbins newer policies, but I think it might be interesting to see how their products compare to the weapons featured in RDR2.

[@ManvsHistory]

Yeah that would be interesting. Solid idea.

[@gormlesshoboproductions]

“Man killed for their hat” yup that sounds about right for RDO

[@herredward9277]

I never saw that 152$ coat jesus christ! I could buy a whole state with that! I never thought those prices were overkill until I saw your videos! (At least not that much because that's pretty obvious they were cranked up.)

[@tomcat909]

I have two pair of wrist cuffs... (gauntlets) were rewards from Outlaw Pass participation.

[@Dalt1n999]

you can buy leather wristcuffs from madam Nazar, but not from stores though

[@blaze_unleashed7286]

Would love to see them add an option to button up jackets. Or at least add more options for set closed coats

[@rjohnson1690]

Many of the coats in the game appear to be frock coats or palatots of earlier patters.

[@GhostRider-on6bz]

There is one pair of wrist braces in the game, they came with the second outlaw pass so not available now sadly but they should make more of them and make them purchasable... for cash. I think they should add more cool cowboy hats so that people can have a bit more individuality and less ridiculous things like the cavalier hat etc which are only really there to appeal to the GTA mindset players. Great video mate!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Ghost Rider! Appreciate the support, my friend!

[@patmurphy7266]

river junction trade co has amazing reproduction of clothing. i had an 80% beaver, Beaver Brand hat, AMAZING

[@n0t_spark]

He's back!

[@ManvsHistory]

Good to see you again, Spark!

[@michaelkores6860]

beware minor spoiler! Very interesting video as alway. I highly appreciate your series on RDR2 and hope for many more videos to come. Just one thought on the leather hat: I know, that they are not very common and most likely would be considered kind of exotic in the games region and time but I do like that, because Arthur's hat in the single player game is his "lucky hat" that he has worn for many years and eventually it is passed on to John Marston. In that context I do not mind that they chose this kind of hat considering that is meant to be outstanding. One word on the leather hat beeing very hot. I have worn a heavy bull-leather hat multiple times while on safari in africa and I wore it when I went hiking in the Namibian desert on an extremely hot day with temperatures rising to 113 and I will admit, that a heavy leather hat is hot compared to one made out of linen, but it is perfectly fine even under the most extreme conditions.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Michael. Yeah, I like the look of it, and it is plausible, just unlikely.

[@GregIsWong]

John Marstons Rancher outfit from the first red dead has leather wrist cuffs I believe

[@alibehrami8573]

I would like to see breeches added in the catalog

[@kato2395]

the most historically accurate is the skull mask in one of the outlaw pass before the latest one. thank you rockstar

[@OGBOOP]

I want cavalry gun holster added to the game (the one's Hosea and Micah are using). They have the animations from story mode for it and they look dope so why not just give em to us

[@tracingsb643]

Gus actually sells the bear pelt coat you are talking about if you take him a perfect bear pelt it's called the mauberry coat

[@kurunzi8614]

Unfortunately some of the best looking fur coats in the game are locked in story mode, my favorite one being the shotgun coat. Technically there is a version in online but with no fur on the outside, just I the collar and cuffs, you can make them at the trader. As for the Gauntlets you actually have two versions of it, one for each Outlaw Pass. 🤠👍🏼 Great video and great hat stories! 😂 please keep them coming.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Kurunzi! Supportive as always, you're a good man!

[@kurunzi8614]

Roger Dodger I was talking about coats you (the player) can actually wear. If they release Flaco’s jacket it would be great no doubt.

[@ManvsHistory]

@@kurunzi8614 Would love to see them added!

[@bigblue6917]

There is a story of a man taken to court in England and convicted for the hat he wore. He was wearing the Stovepipe Hat, which was the latest fashion at the time, when the police arrested him, took him to court were he was convicted because the hat was said to frighten the horses. I am not sure if this is a true story or not but the stovepipe hat became so popular even the police wore them.

[@johnnyguitar007]

Great Video.

[@NakedHillbilly]

One of my OLD relatives Wyatt Earp was in the video yay

[@cesarh0767]

What i have waited on this one. Ps. Your videos is so great

[@Crooked-60]

The fur coat and leather gauntlet got added a little while back maybe a rockstar employee watches some of these videos.

[@toddhoward234]

Congrats on 10k!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks, Todd! You're the first!