How to Safely Replace Garage Door Springs & Save Hundreds

This is a complete walk through of how to identify your broken or underpowered garage door spring (torsion spring), determine which one to replace it with, safely remove the old ones, safely install new ones and maintain them afterward. This is a safety first video that will save you hundreds of dollars! #diy #garage #homeownership
🎬 CHECK OUT THESE RELATED VIDEOS! 🎬
• Which Garage Door Insulation Works Best?: • Which Garage Door Insu...
• Garage Door Opener and Track Replacement - Step by Step Guide: • Garage Door Opener and...
• The Easiest & Most Effective DIY Garage Door Insulation: • The Easiest & Most Eff...
📦 PRODUCTS & LINKS FROM THIS VIDEO 📦
You can use the product button in the video or check out these links below.
• DDM Website - Diameter Charts & Guide: geni.us/E6MwcYS
• DDM Garage Door Torsion Spring Calculator (this site is pretty great - please support them!): geni.us/XHuu8Q
• Complete Springs & Winding Bar Kits (Amazon): geni.us/U6r1B4
• Winding Bars with Handles: geni.us/ZF5a
• Garage Door Lubricant: geni.us/GMBq
• Flat File: geni.us/6gLUsB
• Vice Grips: geni.us/As1iwc
• Analog Scales: geni.us/UVXRCv
• 7/16 (1/2" drive) 12 Point Socket - fits set screws perfectly: geni.us/LAa2Zr3
• 3/8" Open Ended Wrench: geni.us/a2ywt
• Milwaukee 12v Fuel Surge Impact Driver: geni.us/rbKN
• Milwaukee Fastback 6 in 1 Flip Knife (Amazon - Check out the "New From" section on the right for the best deals): geni.us/HgUx
• Milwaukee Fastback 6 in 1 Flip Knife (Home Depot): homedepot.sjv.io/e4ydK
Any link here may be an affiliate link, which means you pay the same price as always but we make a small commission, which helps out our channel - so thanks!
👍 WANT TO HELP SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL? 👍
Become a channel member! Hit the "Join" button or head to / @lrn2diy
Support us on Patreon: / lrn2diy
👕 LRN2DIY SHIRTS, HOODIES & MORE 👚
lrn2diy-shop.fourthwall.com/
📸 MY FILMING GEAR 📸
Here’s everything I use to film my videos, including cameras, lights, microphones and more: kit.co/nilsynils/my-filming-gear
🕶 SOCIAL MEDIA 🕶
Facebook: / lrn2diy
Instagram: / lrn2diy
Twitter: / lrn2diy
TikTok: / lrn2diy
📲 MORE DIY GOODNESS 📲
Check out our many projects and plans at
lrn2diy.com
📲 WANT TO LEARN MORE ABOUT 3D PRINTING? 📲
All things 3D Printing at The 3D Printing Zone
/ the3dprintingzone
📚 TWO FREE AUDIOBOOKS! 📚
To get two free audiobooks from Audible, just follow this link: goo.gl/QGFC4Q

[@BustedSills]

I did it safely. I called the overhead door company & they fixed it safely for me!

[@MichaelChance-sm9cx]

Thank you 🙏 this video was exactly what I needed. Following you advice/instruction save me one thousand dollars. My springs broke on double and single car garage. I successfully replace both cost @250 for springs, lubricant, and tension bars… Thank you

[@icecat8]

You Sir, are like the little pin holding the steel cable at the bottom: In spite of so much weight and tension, you've succeeded in lifting us all up! Super video in content and construction. Thank you for all your careful work. I finally got my heavy off track wood double door working. YAY! And I'm a 5'4", 72 yo gal. We used to have to walk to the library to read manuals to fix stuff. Now the world is in the palm of our hands. Fantastic!

[@brenthood3399]

Well done, mostly. I have more than 20 years of Garage door installation, removals and repairs. You really should have a taller ladder for a 8 ft tall door. When you wind the springs you may need to brace against the ladder to counter the toque of the spring. I would want a 6 ft ladder. When you are marking the torsion tube at the drum the cable is off the drum. The marking will be slightly off. As a pro I would lock the torsion tube with 2 vice grips with curve jaws in both directions against the wall above the door. I saw that you had 2 pairs of vice grips in the video. I use 2 to secure the torsion tube. Not every one does this. For a 8 ft tall door you will normally put on 8 1/2 to 8 3/4 full turns. The springs will break in and lose some strength during the fir week of use. A 7 ft tall door gets 7 1/2 to 7 3/4 full turns. The door should balance from your knee to your shoulder. The springs will be a little hot at first . That is normal. They will break in soon. Your door will be heavy in a week or two. Then you will need to add tension. Open your door manually after about one week after spring installation to see how much tension may have been lost to break in. If the springs are too light the opener could cause a lose cable to come off the drum. This creates a dangerous problem. If your door has just one spring when it breaks always replace it with 2 smaller springs. They will last twice as long and the door runs better with 2 springs.

[@LRN2DIY]

This is all excellent information, my friend,. Thank you so much for this!

[@jao8084]

Towards the end, of above response, when you said if the springs are too light, do you mean light as in tension?...not putting enough turns?

[@I3loodcrazy]

@jao8084 Yes, when the door opens, the springs unwind. So if you have too little tension on the springs, this will cause the cables to slack and potentially come off the drum. That creates a lot of issues. When you replace your springs, it's good practice to open the door all the way manually and ensure both cables are taunt.

[@Esterovball]

What do you think will happen if I don’t do this after adding insulation like this video?

[@I3loodcrazy]

@Esterovball the door will be too heavy. If you have an operator, it might still lift the door but will eventually "burn" out.

[@michaelcook-pt8bt]

Awesome. I was hesitant to replace a broken garage door cable on a torsion bar door, but your how-to video gave me confidence to do the job....SAFELY! Thank you!

[@etsahidu]

Great video....NOTHING IS TO BE FEARED, BUT TO BE UNDERSTOOD!!!

[@jonesgang]

I have had the enjoyment of replacing a lot of those garage door springs and garage door openers. The tension springs are extremely dangerous and you should always use an abundance of caution when working on them. If you heard one snap you would understand, most people think something hit their house when they break under tension. There is a great deal of kinetic energy in those springs. Your tutorial was spot on with the procedure to replace the springs. As far as staying in the safety zone it is not just you but anyone else in the garage with you. I cringed watching your daughter get in that danger zone with the scales. But it all turned out safely. Just remember that in the future if you have to do this again.

[@LRN2DIY]

Good points. I'm glad I was holding the winding cone with the winding bar while she was there but I understand what you mean - I could have had her go around me to stay clear of that path since something certainly could have gone wrong. A good warning to other DIYers.

[@troubleshooter1975]

I had the exact same concern the minute I saw him set up 2 scales, and said his daughter was going to set them...

[@jonesgang]

@@troubleshooter1975You really have to treat garage door springs like they are explosive devices, because they can literally explode. Many homeowners will say when one of the springs break that they thought something hit their house, because it is that violent. Now under the proper precautions they are relatively safe to replace, but you must use and abundance of caution for you and those that might be around you.

[@CJM_v1]

If I may: I am not a handy man at all! Just a young first time home owner in his 20s, a “kid pretending to be an adult” if you will. This video is perfect and walked me through replacing both of my springs. But pay attention to which ones go on the left and right. I had to do everything twice because I messed that part up. But thank you for the tutorial 🤙🏼

[@NativeSwan]

You probably narrowly escaped an insane injury

[@edfelicetti8076]

Always said i would never replace these springs, but i did. Safty safety respect for what your doing. Great presentation great emphasis on safety. Proceed with caution. Relax take your time.

[@robertfleming5829]

Great Video ! FYI , the Drums / Cable pulleys are 1 foot circumference , so an 8 foot door = 8 winds + a 1/4 to a 1/2/winds and that is what you came up with. plus No need to crush the pipe when tightening the 3/8 set screws, that just makes it harder to remove or install the next time. Always go for the higher cycle rated springs , its worth the money.

[@LRN2DIY]

Great input, Robert. Thanks!

[@ronyerke9250]

The last time I had garage door springs to replace, I just took the broken one to a brick and mortar shop, and they fixed me up with the correct set of springs. That was over 25 years ago.

[@smetzger1972]

Great video ! Watched a couple times, went out and bought torsion springs. Completed the job successfully in under an hour. Took my time & was over cautious. No problems & door works great. Thanks !

[@raguripper]

Dude! Thanks so much for mentioning the danger zone. I was trying to loosen a set screw and the winding bar fell out and sure enough the spring unwound. by design my body and face was out of the way. Thanks for the steps and warnings. Just watching again to make sure I'm following the right steps and getting my mind sorted on what occured. You saved me a hospital trip. Also saving with DIY. Great video. Money saved for my family...

[@rickm.6839]

Thank you 🙏🙏🙏 Your well articulated video helped me save a lot of money. Doing this myself was important as these are very hard times for me and my family. I went through the video step by step, pausing the video and performing each task. The safety tips are very much appreciated. I bought my torsion springs kit from Amazon and they were delivered the next day. Unfortunately, I found only one torsion spring made in the USA (Dura-Lift), but delivery was 1 week minimum.

[@craftymomcreations]

I just want to say this video was very detailed. My torsion spring was broken on both sides. I ordered the replacement part on Amazon and alone I was able to replace the spring. Thank you so much for sharing this video ❤

[@mpoulin]

Great video! I am a DYI-er, but this is one project I've always paid someone else to do. I'm confident I can take this on safely now. Thank you.

[@LRN2DIY]

That's totally reasonable. If in doubt at all on something like this, calling a pro is the way to go but it really is DIY-able if you take it slow and safe.

[@ScrappyXGC]

Stay on the outside of the spring. If the good one pops, there may be a projectile. I worked at Wayne Dalton for a bit. Seen one of those tubed twisted by the spring as well, that was a hard fix, that's why I ask how old always. Cause you may have to change out the bar/tube/pipe as well. There is a methodology to that also. You can get yourself killed/mangled. Be careful.

[@ScrappyXGC]

@@LRN2DIY "it really is DIY-able if you take it slow and safe." You weren't safe. It's always from the outside of the spring that you unwind and rewind. I made a long comment, you should find it and read it.

[@denrayr]

Following this repair will result in a better repair than you're likely to get by hiring a pro. Helping friends and family lubricate their doors, I've noticed most doors aren't properly balanced. If you count the number of turns, they're tightened properly, but the wrong weight/length spring was installed in most cases. I believe that the garage door guys either replace like for like spring size without verifying they are correct, or they use what they have on the truck that's "close enough". Certainly only tackle this job if you're the OCD type as safety and attention to detail are paramount, and it's not worth risking your safety. With all that said, as a DIY guy, replacing my springs and door hardware was one of the most satisfying DIY repairs. The door is perfectly balanced, and it's nice and quiet. It's going to last years with minimum maintenance. I wish this video had existed back when I worked on my door.

[@LRN2DIY]

While I suspect most garage door repair techs are doing a great job, I have definitely heard cases of them using a spring that isn't optimal for the door because they had it in stock and paid for already so it would save a few bucks. Mismatched springs are sometimes used in order to accommodate what the tech had on hand. Like you said, this is a very satisfying repair, so long as you're willing to take your time and be uber safe.

[@denrayr]

@@LRN2DIY having an undersized spring guarantees future work haha. A heavy door shortens the life of the worm gear and sprocket bushing on automatic openers. My parents have lived in their house for forty years, and have had multiple spring replacements and drive failures. They seem to only get 5 years out of a repair. I finally ordered the proper spring and got the door balanced, and they're in good shape now. I had a similar issue at my house and proactively changed the spring for the right size in order to prevent future problems. Short lifespan aside, having a heavy door means your family could be stranded in the case of a power outage. Neither my wife or my mom could manually lift the door on either of our houses before I got the doors balanced.

[@michaelmmofo]

Bravo ......being a body&fender dynamo, you've made my 1st attempt an easier one. Thanks for taking the time. You've got my gratitude.............

[@polim4877]

Awesome video and instructions. Just replace my springs and garage work even better. I put a longer spring so it should last longer than previous.. never change springs before and thank you again for saving me $360. The local repairman wanted $480.

[@chanteljoshplummer8745]

Thanks for the help, I just took care of my door. Easy and safe

[@spaknives]

I just finished replacing both garage door springs. Thanks for this Awesome video/guide. It really helped a ton! I am a pretty handy guy, I think, I build and fix a lot of things. This was not a super difficult job, but I can see how it could be very dangerous! Just be cautious, and watch this video! I followed all your guidelines on ordering spring and purchased them from DDM as well. Everything seems to be working perfectly. Thanks again!

[@ajdrew252]

Thank you sir! You saved me hundreds. Only lost one tooth but dental work is still a little cheaper than hiring someone to do these springs.

[@mccslawg]

What a awesome video!! You did a fantastic job of explaining how to preform this job. Thank you.

[@jefff1224]

Brother you helped me tremendously. I had to remove about a full turn to get the correct tension for going down but otherwise you were spot on. My old one was a 37 1/2 and the new spring was 35 1/2, when done, I measured to make sure i was 2 inches off. The only difference I did from what you taught was on the center mount, I didnt trust to measure and it hold in place, so I took a sharpie and drew a line around the base showing exactly where it needed to go back. Regardless, you took a project that was completely foreign to me and made it possible. Thank you.

[@woodlandburl6648]

Thanks! I found that this video of garage door spring install is the best one that I have found. The instruction is spot on.

[@ScrappyXGC]

Stay on the outside of the spring. No sleaves.

[@putt72]

Excellent step by step video. Made doing the job myself very easy and saved me a couple hundred bucks. Look forward to checking out more of your videos!

[@denisealston6312]

Okay that did it I'm calling a professional.

[@josephpeters8916]

I was able to complete this thanks to this video, excellent walkthrough!

[@matthewbrown6078]

Thanks for providing such thorough and safety conscious information.

[@BrentTech]

Not something I have to do currently, but have paid to have done in the past... I'll definitely handle it myself next time! Thanks. Great job teaching too.

[@LRN2DIY]

Thanks so much and hoepfully your next replacement is a long ways out :)

[@joeljean273]

The garage door service spring replacement prices is ridiculous. I appreciate the detail explanation, very thorough. It helped me greatly, thank you.

[@24kachina]

Good video. I have done this twice now at my house, two 24" wide springs on a 7' door, most recently yesterday. As of April 2024, I got a quote from a reputable door service guy my neighbor has used and liked - $250 per spring, plus $75 service call = $575. On Amazon I got two Vevo brand springs, with winding bars and included new drum cables, for $65. The door lost multiple rollers and got badly off kilter when springs broke and door fell hard. It took me and my hand brother about 80 minutes to replace, more time spent getting rollers replaced and the door aligned to move in its tracks. The spring part is easy if you just take your time. And measure twice if you're not sure of your spring size, it's not hard, just tedious counting spring coils and doing a tad of basic math. I saved $500. You can too. And the Vevo springs and winding bar seem very good quality, even cam e with a decent pair of cotton gloves with the little blue rubber stipply grippy bumps. I did it alone the first time when the door was not out of its rollers. One person can do it that way as in this video; if the door is jacked up and out of alignment, buy a 12 pack of beer and grab a buddy.

[@Disco42]

Thanks for that! Just replaced both springs---gotta love Amazon 135.00 bucks, here next day- 2 hrs done!

[@TripleBRanch]

Great video! Very well done and very well explained about how to be safe etc, without going all OSHA overboard. I’ve don’t this several times and know I can always learn, so I always watch a good video or two before tackling DIY stuff. THIS is a very well done How To. 😎👍🏻

[@karthiksc47]

Thanks! A coffee for you, Brother

[@BiggMo]

14:44 it does make perfect sense… in new construction, take-offs are taken from plan elevations so it’s looked at from the exterior. Same with windows when determining which side of a slider is the vent. Always from exterior.

[@LRN2DIY]

Great point! I hand't thought about it that way.

[@MannyG32968]

Well done! Understanding this process is complex and appreciate the details.

[@Miguelhernandez-lw9wv]

Followed step by step came out perfect👌🏻thank you god bless.

[@Mixwell1983]

Just replaced my springs about 6 months ago after hearing a loud pop. Sounded like someone ran into the side of the house, purchased the springs and winding rods and it was a pretty simple job if you're careful. I didn't use scales or anything like that, just measured 20 coils and a few other things and got exactly what I needed from a chart i found. The windings for mine was like 27-30 give or take.. I feel the video was very detailed but I think a lot of the extra info can be intimidating. There were a few other videos i went on that were much shorter and to the point that gave me all the info.

[@LRN2DIY]

I appreciate the feedback. I can see how the video can be overwhelming. I chose to go this direction (extra detail, all of the ways to identify the new springs you'll need, etc.) after seeing that most other videos out there seemed to be lacking details and info, at least for the way I would want to learn this. I totally get that it's not for everyone though. Thanks for watching and for the feedback!

[@thickwristmcfist3399]

Great video! I always hear about guys getting their head chopped off by garage door springs... Glad you made it out alive, man!! Bravo!

[@LRN2DIY]

Haha - me too. I haven't heard of any decapitations but I managed to get out with my head still attached ;)

[@ChristianGuynn]

Great video. I don't think there's any part of this job you didn't cover. So I just got an estimate of $650 to replace both of the springs on my garage door. This seemed a bit high to me, but I really had no point of reference. Now, I'm a DIY guy by nature, but I wasn't sold on the idea of replacing these springs myself only because I know the tension on these springs can cause some serious injuries if not handled properly. After watching this video, I'm not worried about tackling this myself and I'll be saving probably $400 bucks in the process.

[@BlueCollarHauler]

I did a direct replacement on my springs. Ended up only going 24 turns to have it balanced. Guess they were wrong from the start. Guess I'll replace them with the correct springs when they break again lol. This video was super helpful though.

[@mikepettengill2706]

Thank you. Mine needs to be tightened, I think it is showing it's age, and it was terrifying me. I think now that I will just 'spring' for all the new hardware.

[@richharover495]

You’re a great teacher. I’ll probably never do this, but fantastic tutorial

[@Wires747]

Honestly bro ur so underrated, this a great tutorial and reference. Ana use it for sure 👍

[@geniferteal4178]

Don't underestimate the value of a lifetime of experience. We had something installed at our company. The owner of the small company that installed it came to explain to us how it works. Our maintenance people were asking him questions. One of them said, "What if it did this xyz?" He said in 30 years we've installed thousands of these. I've only seen it happen three times. You're not gonna have to worry about that. That's the experience of knowing what really goes wrong or can go wrong and how to manage those situations so they don't continue to happen. It's the shame he sold the company and retired. I would definitely recommend them to anyone. It was heating equipment.

[@troubleshooter1975]

It is important to point out that the shaft is hollow, and if you over-tighten the keys, they will just keep going deeper until they flatten the tube shaft; as some others here have commented.

[@MacNifty]

I'm the type of guy that doesn't read manuals and I like to go through trial and error physically and mentally in the real world and the first time I ever took a Bay door that was 40 feet high with a huge Spring while I'm on a 30 foot lift that was exciting when the son of a b**** went crazy on me. lol. I learned real quick.😅

[@cachamp203]

Very nice video. Great job explaining everything in detail.

[@LRN2DIY]

Thanks so much!

[@HoangDiep4ever]

Great instruction! Thanks for posting this up.

[@shawnm2597]

Ah! If I only found your channel 2 weeks earlier. I already spent $280 to have a tech do this. Great company, but it would have saved me over $100 from labor charges, and possibly a little more for spring cost. Keep these vids coming. I DIY everything I can so your efforts are greatly appreciated.

[@seitenryu6844]

$100 more to spare yourself any physical risk, knowing the right parts are used, and saving yourself the time? Sounds like a good deal. Most places guarantee the parts and work too. I think you're looking at it wrong. I do agree that it's not too complex an operation, but my time is worth money too. Last thing I want is injuring my hands, maybe permanently.

[@frogmandave1]

Excellent video sir. Great work.

[@scenictravels4664]

Awesome video. Just saved me at least $300 bucks. Thank you sir

[@Muhabbatik]

Wow super detailed even the idea about sharpy marks and chalk line omg im glad i visited this video learned many tips as im planning to try to do it myself. Thanks! Vid liked!

[@BiggMo]

Springs are considered a wear component that need replacement periodically. I’m in my forever home… and I hired it done, because they came with a lifetime warranty. Next time they require replacement, I assume I’ll be too old to tackle it.

[@DavidRog-qm6qp]

Great video followed step by step. If ur even 20% mechanically inclined u can do this.

[@jrupinsk]

Well done! Thank you!

[@RichardDorward]

Thanks for the info Rick

[@rbs427]

Outstanding video!! Thank you!

[@shane3978]

Thanks for the video. I'm getting ready to replace the springs for the first time on my garage door due to a broken spring like in your video. I had one question. At the end of your video you said you you had to back off a 1/4 turn and no more than half a turn. Can you clarify what exactly you are looking at to determine that you need to back off and just how much? I didn't quite understand that part, but maybe I need to go watch the video again.

[@richardchen7248]

Very helpful. Thank You.

[@01AudioVideo01]

Mission complete! I followed your instructions and demonstrations and completed it in about two hours. Watched your video a couple times and as I was performing it, watched and paused and watched. Doing almost every step as you. I did see that you measured from the wall to the pole near the pullies to verify your center distance. - Could you have marked the center bracket where the springs are bolted to before removing the two bolts? - I was not able to move my springs the 1/4 inch to stretch them out so hopefully they are still spaced enough. - I have a 7 ft, 200 lb door so I torqued the springs 30 cranks but it was too much lift, worked against my opener when closing causing it to think my door was touching something going down and it would open back up. So I removed one crank from each spring (29) and it works normally.

[@LRN2DIY]

That’s awesome that you did this! Great feedback as well. To answer your questions, yes - marking the center would work well, the 1/4” stretch isn’t always feasible as it depends on the spring and you should be fine, and I had a similar experience with the number of cranks. That’s very specific to your situation so you did what works for your door, which is perfect. Thanks again for following up and nice job!👍

[@garyroxene]

Might want to add a section showing how to deal with a garage door where the partitions (walls) on either end are too close (to the drums on both ends to add springs - meaning the axel with drums needs to be removed from the middle bracket to allow room for the springs to be applied .. also? automatic focus and larger depth of field (smaller aperture) helps a lot..

[@finedandy447]

I had already replaced the springs on my garage door before seeing this video. It is 99.5% correct. If you don't own a ladder, you shouldn't be doing any DIY projects. Also most are not lucky enough to have that much space on each side to remove and install the springs without taking the bar down to remove and replace everything. In that case, you will need two ladders. Everything else is spot on.

[@antibrevity]

The DDM site linked in the description will give you free winding bars with a purchase of springs, so add the bars to your cart first. Also, the site explains how to convert some inside diameters to more common 2" springs in order to save money in some cases.

[@MinhNguyen-bw7et]

Thank you. It works for me.

[@davekenyon9582]

This is the best video well done

[@carlas8905]

I had a guy come out and his first quote was $750. I walked him out. I asked my husband if he could do it (even though he works 14 hour days…he said he would.) He watched this video and read the comments. He said somewhere in these comments someone said something crucial that saved him. Anyway, thanks for doing the vid. He did it for $120 for two springs.

[@Risingsunn1]

Love the video, this was my go to guide on getting this done myself and saving $300-$400. You MAY want to work on camera focus as it seemed to focus on other things besides you while working. It did not detract too much from the quality of the info but is just a slight bit distracting. Thank you kindly sir!

[@LJimenez0185]

Quick question, so when you measure the length of the spring you measure the new one and you said 36” but the label that you showed before was 18.5 did you upgrade the spring for the extra weight of the insulation? So if I have a 16x7 that weights about 154 pounds and has a .0875x2x16 should I upgrade if I’m putting insulation in the future? And how do I find the right spring for the future weight? Thanks great video!

[@willmallory9085]

Thank you SO much. 😊

[@davegeorge7094]

important to stretch spring out ward holding hub like 2" then screw hub to rod otherwise spring wire get squeezed and rub. There should be a tool that clamps rod with lever handle to hub and pulls on spring, locks it from turning so screwing the hub down is simpler.

[@gonsteadaz1]

Hey man, really helpful video. Going to attempt to do my own spring repair. I'm a retired physician and I just wanted to advise you on one thing. Start using gloves when touching any of these petroleum based chemicals. They get absorbed through your skin and go straight to your liver. It's a major toxicity and carcinogenic concern that bites you later in life. Gave you a like and a subscribe - was really well done!

[@JediNate1974]

Great video! Thanks a ton. Also in Utah👍

[@troubleshooter1975]

They do make 8-point sockets that are a better fit for a square-head bolt. That is my preference. [3/8 8-point socket]

[@geoffg659]

Informative video great tips example of which way the strings are wound \. I would not of though of losing at my fist!

[@ert-7112]

Awesome video. The spring on my garage door are .243 28, I made a mistake and bought .243 33, does that matter. Thanks

[@abdullahhotaki2128]

Great job.

[@CGAZ66]

Lost the spring tension to my door. ( My own fault ) Not sure what tension should be on it so I equally adjusted both springs. Ended up being 24 ...one quartes turns. Lifted door half way and it stayed in place. Did I miss anything. Seems to work fine.

[@kwd57]

What I have done on mine was to wind the spring with the door open, which takes very few winds and much less winding pressure to deal with.

[@LRN2DIY]

I've heard of people doing that and there are definitely different schools of thought on whether that's a good idea but I can see the advantages.

[@ImportedFromSerbia]

How did you get access to the springs when door is open? Unless, you push door all way back! So, what determine how many winds you do?

[@kwd57]

I do push it past the normal stopping point and it takes very little effort to give it a few turns. Not all doors will need the same, but I have 3 of them, so I give them the same winds as the others in the up position. It may take a little trial and error to get it to where you want. I just think that it is saver and easier to let the door going down to do the hard and dangerous part. All of the springs I have came with a straight line that runs from on end to the other in the unloaded position that makes it easy to count the turns.@@ImportedFromSerbia

[@captainstress]

Great video. I wish this came out before I paid over 700 for my new springs. Question: Why did you leave the ends of the springs unlubricated? I'm pretty sure my installer lubricated the whole spring.

[@LRN2DIY]

The idea is to prevent lubrication from effecting the set screws, so they don't slip out.

[@Z28Bama]

Can I just use 220 for the door weight in calculations, even if my door is lighter?

[@lolajoker]

I understand the “don’t do it, leave it to a professional” message but I think the price is what leads many to try to do it themselves. I understand the inflation but I had to have a single spring (on a 1 car door) replaced 7 years ago and it cost $120. Now the spring broke on my other single door and it cost almost $500. Quite a jump it price in 7 years!

[@vincentvawter2785]

Thanks!

[@JCWren]

Excellent video. One thing I'm curious about though -- If you're going to loosen the set screws when you're getting ready to unwind the old springs, why not remove them completely? If the spring does get away from you, at least the hazard of ripping open your hand is reduced.

[@LRN2DIY]

That's a great point - I don't see why you wouldn't want to do that.

[@The_El_Guapo]

I unwind and wind my torsion springs by hand 💪

[@arrow_door]

Spring change in SLC UT: $375 (Arrow Door) Winding bars can be fatal. DIY floors or paint, not seatbelts or springs.

[@antibrevity]

Thanks for the helpful video. You discussed this in the video, but I'd like to make the point as well. You're saying hundreds of dollars by doing this yourself, so there's really little point in savings tens of dollars by choosing cheaper springs. The absolute minimum in the table shown at 17:35 should be the 34,000-count springs and even the 77,000-count springs are only $30 more for more than twice the expected lifetime; they should last the life of your garage door and, in fact, that might be the only overruling consideration if you don't expect the garage or house to survive that long. There is a point of diminishing returns, of course, but it's generally a better investment to get the most durable option and in this case the better springs might be conserving the resources it would take to manufacture, transport, purchase, and install replacement springs in the future. This also saves either yourself or a future owner of your home the hassle and potential injury of a spring failure and replacement that might not even occur if you install better springs today. From the table shown at 17:35, we see that: 13,000 cycles at 4 cycles per day is 9 years for $47 + shipping + tax 77,000 cycles at 4 cycles per day is 53 years for $97 + shipping + tax The budget springs may need to replaced 5 times by the time the expensive ones fail, though these are all *expected* lifetimes, of course. Shipping is likely the same, regardless, further reducing the relative difference. Considering the parts cost versus the labor and risk involved, just get the best or second-best springs in the table and be done with it. Cheaper is usually more expensive.

[@rob8823]

A steering wheel and gas pedal are far more dangerous. Thanks for all the time spent breaking this down. I wonder why they dont just use counterweights.

[@G_Weezy]

We have to make sure tension is released from both sides before moving to the center bolts? I know yours is broken but it wasn’t mentioned to unwind the other side if needed to.

[@LRN2DIY]

Yes, that’s correct. All tension has to be relieved before removing the center hardware for sure.

[@ReggeditCh04]

Hi! Can you review the mobile drill stand that you ever used in one of your videos?

[@LRN2DIY]

I'm not sure what you're talking about here - what mobile drill stand?

[@mortimersnead5821]

The left-wind spring spirals in the same direction as the threads of a left hand screw.

[@LRN2DIY]

Good point!

[@Kana7782]

I followed your instructions, every step. Still got my fingers, teeth and eyes. And the garage door is now fixed. $150 later (two springs and spray) How often do you recommend spraying everything?

[@davidbennett4340]

I was noticing that the springs are connected in center through the open mouth bracket. One of yours was broken so you could unmount the first one after the tension was relived from it. That said, for someone who is just replacing them for any other reason other than having one that was broken wouldn't they need to make sure they remove the tension from both springs before unmounting either spring from that center bracket? I know you mentioned this scenario at the beginning of your video but for someone who may not have done this before they may not have put that together. Unless i am just completely wrong about this which is possible but this is just my two cents for safety concerns.

[@LRN2DIY]

You're absolutely correct. I could have been more clear on this but yes - if you're replacing two tensioned (non-broken) springs, you have to ensure that the tension is removed from both springs before removing any center or end hardware. Great point.

[@troubleshooter1975]

@@LRN2DIYpin this!

[@robertginsburg8113]

Most people take their cars to a mechanic but there are a lot of DIY's that enjoy doing the work themselves and find it very rewarding. I'm the latter and working on cars is much more dangerous. You can literally die if you do something stupid while working on cars. Point being, you have to access the risk for your capabilities.

[@joat_dad4090]

My new Cloplay door came with only one LW Spring. Should I buy a RW spring?

[@ImportedFromSerbia]

1 car garage door comes with only one spring, torsion.

[@Brian-Burke]

How much weight did the insulation add to the door? Very thorough video. Well done.

[@LRN2DIY]

Thanks so much. Each sheet of 1.5" Formular NGX weighs 4.41 lbs (2 kg) and this used around 3.5 sheets, so about 15.5 lbs (7kg). It's enough that new springs would be required.

[@Brian-Burke]

@@LRN2DIY Thank you!

[@engrpiman]

When this happened to my parents door I just lifted the door from the ground to get in /out. It was heavy

[@LRN2DIY]

It really is heavy. On mine it was really tough to open by myself even with one spring still engaged.

[@bobg8997]

So the addition of 15ish lbs. of insulation weight will require replacing the springs unless you verify that weight with the insulation falls within the springs' limits? Given that my springs are almost 20 years old, replacement seems likely if I want to insulate my door.

[@LRN2DIY]

That's correct. Basically anything that requires more than 2 quarter turns of increased tension (which is often anything over 7-10 lbs but this will vary) should result in spring replacement to the proper springs.

[@AbernathyPJ]

Thank you. Saved me a couple hundred dollars by not having to hire a repair company.