Mahler: 3. Sinfonie ∙ hr-Sinfonieorchester ∙ Andrés Orozco-Estrada

[@dfdhgtrss212]

This symphony changed my life.

[@thomasley4006]

Tell us more!

[@sergiocabeza2146]

That's sad

[@crichardson1893]

makes two of us

[@karlheinzkirchmann6469]

I say, to listen to Mahler you are living in an adventure. You dont know where it ends and where you all of a sudden find yourself back. 😂

[@fukpoeslaw3613]

​@@karlheinzkirchmann6469yes, and I'm on some truly interesting powder, it's called ketamine (don't do drugs children!) ...... Anyways, . what you wrote is pretty exactly what I'm experiencing right now. and then in some more dimensions or something... Man, I'm telling ya, Mahler and ketamine go together like a horse and carriage!! Really! it's just, my nose feels a bit -I dunno- je ne sais quoi a bit..... Erhm oh whatever... I'm already coming down now.... The 6th of Mahler also mixes quite good with this needly looking Cristal powder.... (I mean it looks like little needles) Ok, I can't really describe what happened when I took this phantastical stuff at 20:33 and started this symphony... Ok, good luck and an interesting but happy life to y'all!

[@elenaGruzdeva-g1m]

An Mahler muss sich herangestet werden, aber wenn es getan ist, wartet eine Welt der Wunder.

[@Insulanerin-y6t]

Ich habe bei diesem Konzert im Publikum gesessen und erinnere mich noch daran, dass ich die ganze letzte Viertelstunde geweint habe - einfach weil die Musik so unglaublich schön klang! Ich hatte Mahlers 3. schon mehrmals im Konzertsaal gehört (und sogar auch mal im Chor mitgesungen), aber nie zuvor hatte sie mich so ergriffen wie an diesem Abend. Danke dem hr-Sinfonieorchester und Andrés Orozco Estrada für dieses unvergessliche Konzert!

[@dst0212]

Du glücklicher, ich wäre auch gerne dabei gewesen und hätte mit geweint. Wunderschön

[@steveegallo3384]

@@dst0212 -- Yes.....BRAVI TUTTI from Acapulco!

[@hugogarciadelavega503]

Te entiendo, a mí se me han saltado las lágrimas en los últimos 15 minutos, sólo de ver el vídeo. Increíble el ambiente y climax que ha sido capaz de construir este inmenso director con esta extraordinaria orquesta, una de las mejores del mundo en la actualizad

[@jarodvmusic]

I have listened to the Mahler Symphonies many times and I am blown away every single time by the time it ends.

[@EminAnimE1]

One of the best symphonies of all time.

[@swinger9374]

You deserve that compliment sir

[@my.heart.in.the.highlands]

Real talk, bro😘😘😘😘

[@guilhermesobrinho1329]

lol

[@gunterkastenfrosch698]

Ach sie sind auch hier?

[@Gabriel-_-245]

if you say so...

[@mswdesign9164]

Wow- let's be clear that the quality of what we can see here for free is just incredible. All the hr-Sinfonieorchester videos have fantastic sound and the orchestra often sounds like they have no equal on the planet (and I live in Chicago!). Thank you to all involved.

[@MaxPower-grrl]

Agreed!

[@wotan9630]

The silence at the end is heartbreaking!! It must be an awful strain on Andres to “come back” to the real world after such heavenly music-making! I know it does me!!!

[@brucemiller5356]

he looked first up, as if to heaven, then slowly brings his arms down, and his hands come together in prayer. then the audience reacts.

[@liseclement7722]

@@brucemiller5356 z

[@katerinaparizova5550]

V

[@정준영-o8r]

​@@brucemiller5356청취의 기회를 주셔서 감사합니다

[@3ggshe11s]

I'm working my way through Mahler's symphonies one by one. The sixth movement is one of the most sublime pieces of music I've ever heard. I'm awestruck.

[@nerowolfe736]

I've worked through everything Mahler ever wote, over the course of nearly 50 years. Man, do I envy you! (And you'll never find a better Third than this one).

[@rdkamath]

I have started doing the same....1 symphony per day. Today is 3rd..... 8 more to go.

[@leestamm3187]

​@@nerowolfe736 Me, too, for over 50 years. Those just entering the Mahler universe have so much discovery ahead of them. Happily, it's a never ending journey.

[@nerowolfe736]

Here is what I have to say. Mahler is my favorite composer by a huge margin. This is one of my top four favorite Mahler symphonies, the other three being 2, 6, and 9. Over 45 years spent with it, I've listened to everybody perform it, hundreds of times: Bernstein, Horenstein, Levine, Barbirolli, Boulez, Haitink, Abbado, Adler, Abravanel...you get the picture. Hundreds of times. I've never heard this symphony before in my life. Touched by the hand of Mahler. I am NOT KIDDING.

[@annakimborahpa]

From out of the depths, have you commented.

[@nerowolfe736]

@@annakimborahpa - M...M...Master Yoda? Is that you?

[@annakimborahpa]

@@nerowolfe736 Could be, Luke Skywalker ...?

[@johnvaughan7096]

Have you heard every letter of the alphabet??? Try, Abbbado, Bernstein, Celibidache, Dudamel, Eschenbach ..... ???

[@danilovelasquez2539]

Do you have the first commercial recording conducted by Charles Adler in 1951? It was my first encounter with the Third in 1975.

[@polymn]

Said to be the longest symphony ever, but I have never been bored of this. Beautiful, just beautiful

[@bomcabedal]

Also, not quite the longest. That's probably Jean-Louis Nicodé's Gloria at well over two hours. And yes, far more boring.

[@LisaKTownsend]

It is SO long. But meaningful.

[@crichardson1893]

@@bomcabedal Longest in standard repertoire

[@jgesselberty]

@@crichardson1893 Exactly. Havergal Brian's Gothic symphony is longer but rarely performed. And, few lengthy works pack the beauty and power of this symphony by Mahler.

[@sergiocontreras3447]

This is perhaps the slowest version I have heard of this symphony and perhaps the most dramatic. As usual this orchestra and its conductor are excellent! Kudos for everyone!

[@nerowolfe736]

If you like a slower Mahler Third, you might want to check out the performance by Adler/Vienna (on KZbin). It's an old mono, but you won't care, because the most recent remastering is jaw-droppingly excellent.

[@sergiocontreras3447]

@@nerowolfe736 Thank you so much for your input!

[@progfan9917]

​@@nerowolfe736do you have a link?

[@Discovery_and_Change]

0:14 Begins | 10:10 friendly flutes begin | 14:07 marching | 14:27 winning awe | 24:50 repeat of beginning | 1:05:53 singing begins | 1:19:37 beginning of end | 1:40:02 (short version of beginning of end)

[@LadyArt123]

Andrés Orozco-Estrada ...dass der wundervolle, charismatische Dirigent am Schluss alle beteiligten Musiker und Sänger ganz besonders würdigt, das ist doch außergewöhnlich und großartig. Ich hatte bei dieser Aufführung mehrmals Gänsehaut und es traten mir Tränen in die Augen ... das gebe ich gerne zu. Wie wundervoll ist diese Aufführung von Mahlers 3. Sinfonie ... sie ist einzigartig. Ein großartiges Orchester, ein großartiger Kinderchor, Frauenchor, die Sängerin, Nathalie Stutzmann, tief empfunden, jedes Wort, jeden Ton ... Ich danke Ihnen allen, es waren wundervolle Stunden! Stunden? Ja! Ich konnte mich nicht lösen, ich habe mir Ihre Aufführung zweimal angeschaut/hört ... ich bin gefesselt und verzaubert. DANKE!

[@steveegallo3384]

EXACTLY! BRAVI TUTTI from Acapulco!

[@jff3060]

Nathalie Stutzmann alto voice is so deep, appropriate and adjusted to the key 4th movement of the symphony. Thank you, Mr Estrada for your choice and conducting this master piece of music with so much conviction.

[@ingorichter649]

She is someone who can be called "musician overall": She is senior conductor and singer in one person. There are existing recordings of baroque music, where she sings and conducts simultanously, absolutely unique and fantastic. A real artist. Listen also to her Eroica interpretation here at YT for example. 🙏🎵

[@quickfoxxes]

Of all the symphonic repertoire, this is the most glorious of them all!! Mahler was miraculously gifted in penning these enchanting, majestic, rhythms and harmonies. What a magnificent performance Maestro Andres Orozco-Estrada and the Frankfurt Radio Symphony have given us as an inspiring gift. Thank you immensely for posting this most memorable performance. When the soul leaves the body for the life everlasting, this would be the BEST music to transport it to Heaven. God bless each participant.

[@tadpoleeeee]

This is the best performance of Mahler 3 I've ever heard. Those horns!!! So confident, they're breathtaking

[@johnboyce1833]

Fabulous timpani at the end of the last movement. Those two guys really punched out their last few notes. Don't think I've ever seen a timpanist hit it so hard, and yet sound so clean and perfectly in tune. Bravo you guys!!

[@alexandergrigoriev6946]

I've attended the performance at LA Phil, and the final timpani were played each with two hands throughout. A sight to behold.

[@MahlerHolic1860]

Yes I'm in complete agreement with you. Fabulous timps in the finale.

[@mihohobaba]

Yes, those guys were totally in sync with each other. There's also a great version of this symphony here on KZbin with Claudio Abbado and the Lucerne Festival orchestra. The timpani playing at the end is just as stunning.

[@ingorichter649]

Yes, this is one of the solo details in this work. Mahler did not wrote jazz-music, but especially in this symphony the instrumentalists are also intended to engage in relevant solo passages. For me is this one important fact, which makes Mahler's music so fantastic and entertaining.

[@hugogarciadelavega503]

Extraordinario Andrés Orozco-Estrada, al frente de esta magnífica orquesta, que han conseguido una de las mejores versiones de esta maravillosa obra, que contiene algunos de los momentos más emotivos de toda la producción sinfónica de Mahler. A destacar, sobre todo este último movimiento, de una belleza y pasión casi sin parangón en la música; estas frases eternas que ascienden y ascienden y se encadenan hasta la resolución. Pocas veces la música es capaz de elevarnos en semejante medida. Y la aportación de Estrada, como en todo lo que le he visto, fuera de lo común, con una capacidad de mover el tiempo descomunal, y de extraer de la densa maraña orquestal aquellos sonidos por descubrir que nunca habíamos oído. Por ejemplo, es el primer director al que veo destacar el precioso juego de arpegios que hacen las cuerdas al final del primer movimiento, en el que los metales llevan, sin duda el protagonismo. El director colombiano se queda sólo por detrás del inmenso Bernstein, el auténtico arquitecto mahleriano del SXX. Grande, maestro! UN abrazo desde españa, hermano

[@LatinoChap]

Thanks to Maestro Gustav Mahler for composing this symphony. Special thanks to Conductor Andres Orosco-Estrada for this performance and al always thanks to KZbin for posting.:)

[@johnmcgowan6413]

One of my favorite symphonies, and by far one of the most emotional. Wonderful, heartfelt rendition.

[@andreaskindermann11]

Just incredible, that it could be played 100 years ago. I wished Mahler could have heard his symphony in this perfection

[@brucemiller5356]

i was word processing through much of the symphony; when i sensed the last movement was going to end, i changed to watch the orchestra, full page. i wanted to hear those tympani beats, which i think make the ending of this symphony one of the greatest endings. then the conductor ended the symphony, looking up, as if transigured, which he surely was. then he bowed his head and put his hands together in prayer. that is when i burst into tears, as the audience had remained silent until that point, before roaring to life. i love the way this orchestra's conductors call out each section for applause, as well as the whole orchestra. the first time i listened to the symphony, without watching it, i was sort of unimpressed. unimpressed no more. absolutely splendid!

[@mackindle12345]

That pianissimo brass chorale at the end is probably the best I've ever heard; genuinely heavenly - absolutely exemplary principal trumpet and trombone

[@mauricerivermusic9110]

Ahhl The memories. The first time I heard this live - American Symphony in Carnegie Hall, Catherine Comet, conducting - our son was a "Bim Bam Boy" as a member of the American Boychoir (RIP). I can still see and hear it in my head after all these years. It was his first Mahler 3rd of many, including the CD by Ozawa and the BSO with Jessye Norman. How many years ago! That little boy is now 38 with children of his own. And he still knows and loves all the symphonies of Mahler. This performance is one of the best I've ever heard, and I heard the Mahler 3rd several times in my decade as a classical music reviewer for a large metropolitan daily in the '80s and '90s.

[@garyshelton3014]

If you could, ask your son for us: as a child performing this work, did you sense how monumental it is? And did you feel old enough for it? I ask because the emotional swirl Mahler creates in No. 3 has always seemed almost too much to take, and it occurs to me that it should be rated PG-13 for (intense adult content or something).

[@MaxPower-grrl]

Glorious! Thank you HR for all you do to promote civilization!

[@PhilipFClark]

This orchestra never fails to thrill me with its works. Absolutely one of the finest performances of this deeply haunting, beautiful symphony. Nathalie Stutzmann's entry is completely engaged so deeply in the music she is singing. It is all in her face. I wonder if she, as a conductor, has also performed this work. I have not been able to find a recording.

[@decone4839]

agreed

[@josuepereyra3473]

0:13 I. Kräftig, Entschieden 35:47 II. Tempi di Menuetto. Sehr mäßig 45:52 III. Comodo. Scherzando. Ohne Hast 1:05:12 IV. Sehr langsam. Misterioso. 1:15:19 V. Lustig im Tempo und keck im Ausdruck 1:19:35 VI. Langsam. Ruhevoll. Empfunden

[@РадиИванов-ц9э]

Thank you!!!

[@1924Puccini]

THANKS FOR THIS

[@arkazoo4769]

the end is at 1:46:37

[@KuangyuChen]

THIS IS WHAT THE AUDIENCE NEED WHILE LISTENING TO THE GREATEST SYMPHONY COMPOSED BY MAHLER. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.

[@michaelmacneil8552]

@@1924Puccini q

[@mevje8249]

Nothing short of an absolutely stunning performance. As a classically-trained pianist and media producer/engineer, dissolves rather than almost any cuts in the final movement would be my preference to truly accompany what is being heard. Many thanks to all who produced, funded, performed, engineered and posted this production and wherever you are, Gustav, a very special 'thank you.'

[@alvarogarciabarbosa3199]

Mahler uses the same melody in his 4th "Wir geniessen die himlischen Freuden". Always fantastic music.

[@LisaKTownsend]

Unbelievable level of passion! Truly remarkable.

[@jgesselberty]

Perhaps the most amazing ending in all of symphonic literature.

[@frankstein9982]

it's really just a big held chord. however that doesn't make it any less effective.

[@TheDemonicPenguin]

@@frankstein9982 It's because it's the climax of what it's come before it. Not the chord itself.

[@nicolaspalermo3980]

@@TheDemonicPenguin l . V0

[@GoOKuSj33]

I prefer the 2nd symphony ending.

[@remomazzetti8757]

He had a hard time with it and rewrote it more than once. Originally the song that now ends the Fourth Symphony was supposed to be the seventh movement of this already overlong symphony. When Mahler decided that the Adagio finale was sufficient, he added the loud bombastic ending heard hear. He was much more successful with the beautiful quite endings of the 9th and especially the 5th movement of the 10th Symphony.

[@carstenboning8071]

Der Schluss gibt mir in diesen schrecklichen Tagen Hoffnung !

[@magnoliacosta7703]

.

[@magnoliacosta7703]

Е

[@magnoliacosta7703]

л ваш цхыраара Ә

[@서용춘-e5x]

: 文, 그

[@bogdan98ify]

The most amazing thing in this symphony is probably the attention to detail, especially in the wind section. SO many little details, little musical decorations and ornaments, like a medieval book page. Not long and boring ambiguous phrases.

[@IrvingWaldorf]

Mahler's greatest symphony in a splendid performance. Thank you for sharing.

[@alvarogarciabarbosa3199]

Since I have listened this wonderful orchestra with many conductors I have fallen in love with its amazing performances and exceptional great sound. Congratulations for all the musicians. Under this maestro conductor all the interpretation are really sublime! Bravo Andrés!!!

[@miltongajardo9800]

Bravo Andres! si Sr. Garcia, es un placer escuchar como un musico de la categoria hace sonar una orquesta, la magnificencia de esta solo depende de su director mas que de la calidad musical de sus componentes.

[@joannabose7299]

@@miltongajardo9800 You may also like to listen to Sergiu Celibidache. Also excellent!

[@miltongajardo9800]

@@joannabose7299 You was absolutely right, it was magnificent, thanks so much for the tip

[@kiqw]

This most moving of performances brought tears and goose bumps to me. Congratulations on a tremendous performance. Thank ou for sharing.

[@birricforcella5459]

This is truly one of the best orchestras in the world with sound engineering second to none !

[@lj291261]

Das hr-SO kann mit den grossen Orchestern der Welt mithalten. Dieser Mahler klingt wunderbar und elektrisierend. A++

[@RoseMarieRaccioppi]

The BREATH in its sounding grace, the HAND in heart's command, the SOUL in its lilting flight... and touched be our BEING... the music ... the music ... the music...

[@ingehermanrydland9106]

An absolute fantastic performance - more than anything did the conductor and the orchestra unveil Mahler’s ability to speak to the heart. Thanks!

[@lisa1212ification]

i always tear up during the 6th movement because my grandmother liked him. and also its very beautiful. 😭

[@notaire2]

Farbenprächtige und majestätische Aufführung dieser außergewöhnlich großartigen Sinfonie mit angemessenen Tempi und perfekt kontrollierter Dynamik. Der Dirigent ist echt genial!

[@elfriedewolfer]

Was für eine ausdrucksvolle und tief empfundene Wiedergabe von G.Mahlers 3.Sinfonie! Das hr- Symphonieorchester,Nathalie Stutzmann sowie beide Chöre und Orozco-Estrada verstehen es, den Zuhörer in tiefer Ergriffenheit zu sensibilisieren.Elfriede Wölfer

[@infirmuxx]

Absolutely stunning performance. This conductor is a genius.

[@astridarraut9502]

Garbage? That's not the way to talk about this orquestra and Orozco Estrada. You garbage.

[@slubert]

@Sam Stone viola! >:(

[@jackhousman6637]

Absolutely the most glorious performance of this magnificent work I have ever, ever heard!!! (and I've heard a few.)

[@RoseMarieRaccioppi]

Feelings in accord!

[@ljiljanastanic9076]

I agree...absolutely fantastic version!!!

[@ljiljanastanic9076]

I agree with your opinion absolutely!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@michaelmyers2757]

Try Horenstein- London SO; Bernstein New York ,than which there is no other( with apologies to Anselm); Dudamel - Los Angeles( heard live).

[@cmw9876]

Andrés - your masterpiece. Many people deserve credit, sure, but one person had to lead the team.

[@wcolburn1]

In October 2018 I attended a wonderful performance of this piece by the Chicago Symphony Orchestra with this conductor! I love peacefulness of the final movement.

[@jgesselberty]

The Mahler 3rd is a religious experience and Orozco-Estrada treats it that way, with a personal "Amen" at the end. Thanks for posting.

[@ljiljanastanic9076]

Mahler 3 ,the best!!!I believe that this phenomenal performance(in the right sense phenomenal becouse it is so special)will remain to be remembered as unique and enchantingly beautiful💗💕💙💗💕💙💗💕💙Braaaaaavo for conductor and magnificent orchestra!!!💕💕💕💗💗💗❤❤❤

[@walterroberts2861]

This Is Truly; A Graduation; Into The Realm Of Upper Class-men; I Believe This To Be Grade: A; Quality Work!!!!

[@santianaya2000]

Espectacular ver esta pieza maestra! Y dirigida por un compatriota. El maestro Andrés Orozco. Un ejemplo para todos los músicos de mi país.

[@jvaughan3904]

for a hundred years I have loved the 4th and the 1st and only got to know the 2nd some years ago. But this is serenity at its most touching and why shouldn't the guy be passionate about such beautiful music???

[@dxsz7836]

Bravo Samuel Seidenberg and the rest of the horn section!

[@walterroberts2861]

This Is Definitely; One Of My Favo(u)rite; Frankfurt Symphony Orchestra Performances!!!!

[@macinafrancesco3516]

Grande interpretazione di una delle piu' belle sinfonie di Gustav Mahler

[@Octopop2010]

VI is just the most beautiful, sad, warm feeling. Absolutely breathtaking

[@rkentburke]

The lengthy silence after the final chord is overwhelming.

[@jgesselberty]

Like he was ending a prayer.

[@muslit]

that silence is not written in the score.

[@richardjohns8617]

Life recollected in tranquility in one's last hours in remembrance of its positives as well as the unavoidable crosses born. Deo gratias

[@ingorichter649]

Je mehr ich mich mit Musikhören beschäftige, desto mehr merke ich, wie Beethovens Geist auf Mahler übergesprungen ist. Er hat einfach da weitergemacht, wo Beethoven aufhören musste. Genial 🙏🎵

[@Billy-dj8zw]

The final movement says this to me: "Humans are destined to greatness"

[@RoseMarieRaccioppi]

As with Nature itself, the instruments of the orchestra in expression of diversity and in unity of purpose... and so we are touched by its sounding messages of BEING.

[@tonatiuhorduna6479]

Magnífica idea la del director!! Hacer una pausa en el primer movimiento 35minutos es lo que dura la quinta o séptima sinfonía de Beethoven; y cuando escuchas esa poderosa marcha del verano: KRAAAFTIIIGGG!!!!! 😃😃 Siempre quieres aplaudir en el concierto,; aún que la costumbre dicta que hasta que termine la sinfonía!!👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍 Bravooo!! maestros; Todos excelentes!!

[@michaelletellier218]

Magical music moments happen sometimes. On this occasion the hr-Sinfonieorchester deliver a superb performance of the Mahler 3. Nathalie Stutzmann, and Jürgen Ellensohn deserve especial mention, but the whole orchestra respond unequivocally to the music, and to the direction of Andrés Orozco-Estrada. I'm so pleased to have subscribed to this channel. Look out for the live performances via KZbin on Friday evening. Thank you all for sharing this music with us.

[@barryguerrero7652]

I wish this performance would get issued on DVD or CD. With Jessye Norman gone, Stutzman sings the fourth movement better than anyone. Orozco-Estrada knows what he's doing too.

[@louisbrown8060]

Magnificent performance...the finale raises goosebumps!

[@paulusaurelius6563]

A magnificent performance! My congratulations to Maestro Andres Orozco-Estrada and to the entire Orchestra!!!

[@AnxiousSeeker]

Fantastic timpani playing at the end. :O

[@Vi-on8cv]

Brett Butler Agree!!

[@lilje372]

Not one day in my life passes without listening to (or at least thinking of) Mahler's music

[@crichardson1893]

real

[@garyblais8602]

Superbia In The Ultimate- with Leibe So Gott - from War to Love and remembrance to the Caritas which we look to in Such uncertain times .its like Moses facing God on the Mount " what shall I say " I am who I am " only Mahler . Bravo to all who gave us this great Gift .

[@katrinat.3032]

This my first time listening to Mahler, I like it.

[@olivierdemones]

C'est vraiment une version de référence, Nathalie Stutzmann est sublime et bouleversante, le posthorn nous transporte dans un monde de mélancolie rêveuse, cette troisième Symphonie porte tout l'espoir de la Terre vers un monde meilleur, et le chef particulièrement inspiré par cette magistrale Symphonie nous emporte avec son orchestre au firmament de la musique symphonique. Bravo aussi au travail très professionnel des caméras.

[@julieandrews730]

Just awesome (perfect use of the word)! The adagio ending made the hairs on my neck stand up. Thank you Frankfurt Radio Symphony and A O-E, one of my favorite conductors!

[@jandirdonascimentocorrea926]

Maravilhoso! Que maestro fantástico! E esse final...nossa celestial!!! Belo Horizonte

[@olivierdemones]

C'est un hymne à la Musique, un chef d'oeuvre absolu de la littérature symphonique , cet Orchestre et son chef nous donnent une émotion qui nous transportent 'un bout à l'autre de cette 3ème symphonie jusqu'à cette finale qui nous transporte au firmament,. Le silence que porte le Chef sur lui est l'apothéose de cette admirable réussite musicale Merci à KZbin sans qui nous n'aurions jamais écouté ce concert.

[@jairoestupinan9924]

Andrés Orozco es de una sencibilidad inusitada, hace de su cuerpo y de su rostro todo un vehículo de comunicación para dirigir su Orquesta. Ha llegado muy merecidamente a posicionarse entre los mejores del mundo. Junto a Gustavo Dudamel han dejado muy en alto a Latinoamerica. Abrazos

[@miltongajardo9800]

Compartp absolutamente su opinion respecto del maestro Orozco-Estrada, es sin duda un gran conductor. Al mismo tiempo estoy en total desacuerdo respecto del Sr. Dudamel pues mas que un musico es un tecnico y es solamente un producto de los medios y de las influencias de su Sra. Madre, jams estara a la altura de los grandes como Kyril Petrenko,Berlin Filarmonica, eso si es un musico.

[@Tungusqa]

Antes que ellos la dejaron muy alta, musicalmente hablando, Daniel Barenboim, Martha Argerich y Claudio Arrau.

[@leogonz629]

Bellissima sinfonia e grande esecuzione. Bravo orchestra y bravissimo al direttore.

[@Stepherner]

Uplifting. A true masterpiece both by composer and orchestra. BRAVO!

[@AnguieCortes]

Se nota que es Colombiano el director por lo expresivo, orgullo colombiano a la vista.

[@EduardoGonzalez-vf7sm]

Me encanta tu comentario.

[@shupingwang3392]

Great orchestra and wonderful conducting. Andrés Orozco-Estrada touches eternity.

[@frogmouth]

I loved this. I have not heard the whole work before in one performance from go to whoa. I was very moved. Some fascinating bits of orchestration. Loved Stutzmanns solo and the choirs. The conductors enthusiasm was wholly engaging and the acknowledgement at the end heartwarming. Thankyou For posting

[@johnvaughan7096]

Just listened for the nth time - such a shame Seb (Sebastien Seidenberg, principal horn) has left. The part where he and Natalie complement each other, virtually the whole of the 4th movement, is simply stunning with amazing help from concertmaster Alejandro and Nicolas on oboe.

[@johnvaughan7096]

Samuel Seidenberg!

[@johnvaughan7096]

Samuel Seidenberg, John! Wake up!!!

[@Tokkemon]

What a fantastic ending. That D major chord just blossoms in that space!

[@th3seus]

Posthorn starts at 51:40

[@Dylonely_9274]

Masterpiece. One of the greatest symphonies of all time !

[@Powerspectrum1]

This conductor is born to conduct Mahler.

[@mateusdearaujo3317]

You have to see Bernstein.

[@rossini9mozart10]

@@mateusdearaujo3317 Who doesn't hearded Bernstein in Mahler ? Of course he know

[@tuirfghfhg1787]

"This conductor is born to conduct", Mahler.

[@benjaminfraser2535]

What about Gustavo Dudamel?

[@sebastiaoaparecidocarvalho8978]

Impressionante a riqueza sonora e a versatilidade. Maravilhosa!

[@thetygerpulpitwithpastorglenn]

There are only levels of magnificence when it comes to Mahler symphonies.

[@carluy7351]

I would go as far as to say there are only two levels of conducting Mahler symphonies: sublime, or utter garbage. Andres' conducting definitely belongs to the former

[@thetygerpulpitwithpastorglenn]

@@carluy7351 Fortunately, I have yet to experience the latter.

[@robert72744]

Bravissimo. Beautiful deep Langsam. Wonderful conductor.

[@stephenmessick865]

An extraordinary piece and an extraordinary performance. I am sorry that it had to end.

[@MahlerHolic1860]

Maestro Andrés Orozco-Estrada conducts Mahler supremely well. This is a wonderful third from the Master Composer.

[@juergenvoigt8931]

Bemerkenswert, dass man Mahler's Musik - die ich immer schon geliebt und geschätzt habe - im Jahre 2017 noch einmal neu hören darf!!!! Orozco-Estrada ist kompromisslos, selbstverständlich aggressiv, super klar in Denken und Handeln. Und siese Orchester des HR wächst ständig über sich hinaus und geht mit ihm. Großartig! Jürgen, alter deutscher Musiker

[@muammererboy4889]

Ganz meine Meinung!!! Alte Oper Frankfurt als Konzertsaal und das Orchester kenne ich schon seit meiner Studentenzeit in Darmstadt in den Achtzigern. Sie waren unter Eliahu Imbal immer sehr gut. Mit Estrada-Orozco sind sie grandios geworden.

[@rkentburke]

To those who might refer to this performance as inferior, as a staunch lover of this work for four decades, this ranks right up with ones I witnessed in person by Mehta, Tilson Thomas, Sir Simon Rattle, Erich Leinsdorf, et. al. It is quite spectacular.

[@Dan474834]

+rkentburke Mehta sucks for Mahler.

[@MrMax967]

I agree with you. Just attended a Mahler 3 with Mehta and the Israel PO at Teatro Colón. Rather square at times (especially the scherzo). The first movement was just short of being dislodged, so slow was the tempo. Wonderful, however the alto solo (Lioba Braun) and the choruses, as well as the sublime finale.

[@janouglaeser8049]

​@Steven Moore I love both Mehta's 5th (prefer the newer, 2013 version with Los Angeles Philharmonic) and his 6th. In my humble opinion, they're probably the best renditions of those two symphonies out there (Orozco Estrada's are also fine by the way, but not as tidy). But it's true that his conduction is mediocre for the rest of Mahler's symphonies.

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

Rattle could have been one of the best interpreters of the 3rd. Sadly he insists on doubling the tempo during the apotheosis in the finale, when the timpani come in. Robbing the entire movement of it's climax.

[@heavyclassics7243]

@@Quotenwagnerianer Also Gergiev do this. It's disturbing and without sense...

[@johannesbrahms7414]

I'm going to be attacked because of what I'm going to say: I have always secretly felt The Third to be Mahler's greatest symphony. It is so truly sincerely personal---- heart--felt. He was able to take the bits from his childhood, youth and adulthood and make the most powerful, existential, statement of them all! It is astonishingly sincere, no pretense. Although most would say that it is "emotiona", "sentimental", even, "cheesy", that's, insultingly wrong! Mahler is cosmically---- accurate---- in his personal utterance! As to the performance itself, I would be impossible to convince otherwise: Leonard Bernstein's old recording from around 1960 brings to truly painful "real life" the truly powerful philosophical of this, creation. Bernstein believes in it. It is obviously most personal to him, and he has the impressive skill to make the audience, feel, it, be moved by it and be entranced by it! However, this performance does offer something, SUPERB: the Contralto! She is so, movingly, expressive---- the most expressive that I have ever heard, either, live, or on recordings, both, on my many recordings of The Third, as well as, on Radio! If she has not donevso already, she would make a "top-rate" Lieder singer. She should avoid Opera in order to conserve her voice for a long time. It's too bad that the video didn't give her credit---- or at least I didn't see it. One more thing , I have a duty to say: Although I expressed my high regard for Leonard Bernstein's early recording, the Conductor's, and the Ochestra's work in this performance is truly---- fine. Among the may recordings of this work, it is top-rate. It's just that Leonard Bernstein and Bruno Walter, whom I believe didn't live to make a recording of The Third, were "genetically conceived" to be of the most intimate, spiritual, communion with the hurt-by-life Gustav Mahler! P.S.: I want to buy the Contralto's recordings. What is her name?

[@Metamario68]

I cannot agree more with your statements about the contralto's voice. I just wish she were the only one to ever sing this symphony because no one else has ever come close to what she has done. Absolutely marvelous and almost too good to be true, but thank God it is!

[@miltongajardo9800]

Totally agree.

[@sergiovicente7618]

Hard to choose among all Mahler symphonies, without adjectives to classify them, which one is the best.

[@MegaVicar]

She is Nathalie Stutzmann, and has recorded many Lieder including Schubert’s 3 cycles. She is also the new music director of the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra. I won’t attack you, but IMHO this is only his 3rd best behind the 4th and’Das Lied...’.

[@dasportsfan2122]

@@MegaVicar interesting, me personally I would say this is 2nd behind his 2nd symphony

[@ljiljanastanic9076]

Brilliant..The start of this my favorite symphony thrilled me always...phenomenal interpretation

[@drtlbntr]

best part is the lengthy silence at the conclusion

[@mauricerivermusic9110]

Yes! The silence was "louder" than the subsequent applause. Orosco-Estrada conducted the audience silence so effectively.

[@frankstein9982]

indeed, by raising his arms that high he kept people from clapping right away.

[@davidbjornstad7759]

Very effective. Reminded me of my first concert in our high school orchestra; we played the 4th movement of Tschaikovsky's 6th, and our director held a similar silence at the end -- stunning. On KZbin there is a video of this same orchestra / conductor playing the 6th, and he holds the silence for 50 seconds. I would have loved to be in that audience.

[@cmw9876]

It's as if in silence, he's saying "This mighty work!" Indeed, it is. A superb rendition!

[@WritingontheWallIL]

watch the end of Abbado's version of the 9th

[@johnfromvirginia5794]

This wonderful performance is so emotional and heart-wrenching. I have no idea how the players keep their composure to create such a performance.

[@paulviren6599]

Amazing introduced of the last movement after the chair. Expression of heavenly peace. Golda here

[@astridarraut9502]

What a magnificent orchestra and conductor.

[@pega17pl]

Bei Mahler habe ich immer das Gefühl, zum Schluß öffnen sich riesige Flügeltüren und lassen einen Blick auf die Unendlichkeit erhaschen. - Heinz

[@most_sane_piano_enthusiast]

Schönes Zitat

[@dst0212]

Sehr schön gesagt, Danke

[@johnmueter378]

Fabulous performance, a deeply moving experience.

[@IrvingWaldorf]

My favorite, Moller Symphony! Thank you for an excellent performance

[@nikollmerdhoci2018]

Wanderful orchestra... great Mahler

[@TahseenNakavi]

Magnificent. I stood up and applauded when the symphony concluded.

[@xavierbordes1373]

Je réécoute cette version merveilleuse et profonde sans me lasser. Un vrai tour de magie musical !