Mahler: 5. Sinfonie ∙ hr-Sinfonieorchester ∙ Andrés Orozco-Estrada

[@lukahmad5683]

I think the camera man is a musician, love the camera play and angles.

[@xaitat]

As it should be, too often I see camera man having no clue what instrument they should be showing at that moment

[@Giraffe-Dealer]

Yes, that is correct. There is a video showing how this is done. A trained musician -located in the camera direction room- is reading the score as the orchestra plays. This is the way they know what instrument plays what and where to point the cameras at. The trained musician gives the order to switch between cameras at certain moments. It's great.

[@lukahmad5683]

@Giraffe-Dealer that's amazing!

[@michaelloew522]

@@Giraffe-Dealer I was wondering that. at least that is how i thought it should be

[@achintyarao7719]

look at that Mahler is the concertmaster! greatest performance ever

[@delicious9824]

One of the most impressive Mahler 5 intros.. He is sooooo great. He can play not only deep sounds but also sharp sounds in the high range.. Many players play this song's intro simply and neatly. But this player is wide, deep, and even play like pushing the tones that classical players hate. Very unique.

*symphony

[@mizofan]

good to have Buddha's take on it.

[@brucknerian9664]

You're right ... that's the difference between just playing the notes on the score or seeing into the mind of Mahler.

[@mwhite6522]

He's a serious cat -- watch him play the near impossible trumpet part in Stravinsky's violin concerto.

[@quonm1]

CSO/Solti is much better IMO

[@carlomazza731]

Mahler, Andrés, all musicians. Thank you to exist.

[@김옥라-j5y]

젊을때는 말러음악을 솔직히 이해하지 못했는데 40년50년이 지난 지금에 듣는 말러의 음악은 천재적입니다 그당시에는 말러의 음악이 미래에서 온 음악이였을것 같네요 인생의 산전수전 다격고 듣는 말러의 음악은 내 인생의 새로운 장르를 맞이하는것 같아요😊

[@KeysOnFire17]

Orozco-Estrada is such a talented and passionate conductor. So proud of him being Colombian and doing this beautiful job.

[@Paboll]

The attack of the strings at the very end is maybe, the best i've heard on Mahler's 5th. Bravo Orozco-Estrada!

[@jackburrows5850]

somehow this orchestra delivers all the fucking time

[@rogerroth9536]

My guess is bc what you're hearing is billions of hours of individual practice over decades and leadership that knows what to do with it when it comes together. These people have worked their asses off to get where they are.

[@clayel1]

@@rogerroth9536 not billions, assuming it takes about 10,000 hours to become a professional in anything, then that would be 100,000 people assuming 100 people, that gives a million hours, which is still impressive

[@rogerroth9536]

@@clayel1 Let's do a little exercise. Average age of these musicians is say 40. They started practicing when they were 5 years old, so 35 years practicing, say 4 hours/day which is probably low balling. 35 years x 365 x 4 = 51,000 hours x 100 = >5 million hours. You're right. Thanks.

[@GamerStars.]

​@@clayel1You must be fun at parties

[@louismastrangelo3781]

You couldn't use a better word than that??????

[@LavaMLG]

I: Trauermarsch 0:33 II: Stürmisch bewegt 13:02 III: Scherzo 28:36 IV: Adagietto. Sehr langsam 46:19 V: Rondo-Finale 56:53

[@andreseloygomez]

Danke!!!!

[@ElectronicHouseFlash]

Für 1 Stunde und 16 minuten können Menschen die kreativsten, besten, wohlklingendsten Geschöpfe dieses Universums sein. Wahnsinn. Was hätte ich getan um live dabei sein zu dürfen.

[@josephinelagerlow9324]

MVP of the comment section

[@unsignedint6089]

17:30 sadness

[@Dylonely_9274]

Thx

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

Da hat einer eine tolle Lösung gefunden wie man die Triolen "flüchtig" spielt, so wie Mahler das fordert. Spitze!

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

@中国的主人 Für was braucht es da Timestamp? Das Eröffnungssolo ist gemeint.

[@waynejones3870]

Wonderful. the French horn section sure had a great time! The genius that was Mahler on display.

[@matzek.9119]

Mahler hatte ein Gespür für die Blechbläser. Was für eine zauberhafte Sinfonie! Ein großartiges Orchester gibt einem großartigen Komponisten die gebührende Ehre. Ganz großartig!!! Bravo! Der einzige Dirigent, der noch mehr "Schmerz" in das Adagietto legen konnte, war der großartige Leonard Bernstein.

[@L1ghTx]

Wunderschön gesagt. Es ist wirklich dieser „Schmerz“ der das gesamte Adagietto durchzieht. Auch wenn er von Mahler mit solch einer Schönheit oder Reinheit präsentiert wird.

[@cassinihuygens1358]

When the orchestra, conductor and camera crew are perfect, plus Mahler, that's the best show I've ever seen❤

[@301250]

Phenomenal performance, from the first to the last bar! The best Mahler Fifth, past, present and future! Not even the Berlin Phil, Vienna Phil, New York Phil come close to this superb orchestra, helmed by a maestro with a great future!

[@gljamil]

This symphony is one of the greatest moments of our existence!

[@01Gezelle]

The orchestra goes all the way with the conductor. Craftsmanship and submission. Fantastic.

[@shin-i-chikozima]

The solemn comfort of this symphony is irreplaceable

[@scottmiller6495]

This performance was terrific and the audience should be giving a much deserving standing ovation !!!!!

[@rogerroth9536]

Maybe they've become numb to the phenomenal playing.

[@marcelortegaimarti6504]

Without doubt, the best Mahler reading in decades: clear, well guided and organized to climaxes, passionate and subtle, giving to every phrase the perfect sense and character... I would have loved to be there that day !

[@hedahedoh4488]

Mit dieser Fuenften Mahler hat Andres Orozco-Estrada meines Erachtens Solti und Tennstedt-Niveau erreicht, fuer mich die Benchmarks dieses Werkes. Der Spannungsbogen im ganzen Werk, glorioses Blech im 3. Satz und Verve der beiden genannten Altmeister im 5. Satz. Ueberhaupt erinnert mich AOE an den jungen Georg Solti. Ich sehe mit Spannung einer Sechsten entgegen...

[@johnwagner5527]

The best performance of the Mahler 5th I have ever heard. The camera work was outstanding. Showing the various musicians and their incredible talent. The applause was great but a SO was a must. What a fantastic symphony orchestra.

[@dan-us6nk]

I have a question for you now. Do you still think this is your favorite perfomance? A lot of people around me just side with Abaddo, and I understand that he makes it clear and balanced, but Orozco-Estrada has a very suitable style for Mahler, in my view. What do you say?

[@aumarifa]

@@dan-us6nk Agreed. Abaddo is great, but Orozco is just more suited for Mahler. To me Abaddo has a more fruity and punchy style while Estrada goes with an earthy and grim-grounded sort of take.

[@c.v.7950]

Mahler top, Dirigent top, Orchester top, Aufnahme-Menschen top ;-)

[@ernest_asa_iii]

Your comment top! 🏅

[@isaacbarreras2106]

I’m I’m I’m bout a @@ernest_asa_iii but right when I get I’m done I can can do do something it depends if you

[@josepmaria6959]

Ol..vvj😅😅

[@josepmaria6959]

😅😅u oghhhbo.b😅 CVV bjohgg🎉gob.g o😅😅k bohc🎉gch😂cbob G bv😅 😅bjh

[@G.v.5049]

Exzellent 👏

[@clintow]

Im dritten Satz ist Seidenberg, wie immer, ein Held der Hornisten.

[@musisavante6036]

Hello! I want to share with you my Miniature for string orquestra and piano, inspired by Mahler s Adagietto, I hope you will enjoy it! kzbin.info/www/bejne/o3OVYaicq7uGg6s

[@arteguey]

Very good interpretation. It is my particular opinion that the Adagietto is usually played TOO slow, bur this one comes out at the right tempo. Bravo for this Colombian conductor.

[@JorgeSalema]

Probably right. Since Bernstein. It give it a more somber beauty. I like it but one is not force to play it so slow just because Mahler wrote "very slow". As you khow, you can never guess the intended tempo without a recording.

[@remomazzetti8757]

Mahler's own timing was around 8 minutes. Dragging it out is a mistake. Both Hermann Scherchen and Bruno Maderna's live performances stretch it to a ridiculous 15 minutes. And Scherchen even makes cuts in the Scherzo and Finale!

[@ianrockdrigo]

What a genious, damn, Mahler, brilliant, ruthless, scenic, curious. Perfect.

[@johnvaughan7096]

Now just listened to the adagietto. Anne-Sophie Bertrand, what a sensitive harpist and look at the intensity of Sha Katsouris. Incredible!!!

[@brucknerian9664]

Best performance I've heard of Mahler's 5th. Everyone went all out!

[@vad1moSs]

First horn bravo!!!!👏👏👏👏

[@matzek.9119]

and Trumpet too

[@mackjay1777]

So much excellence from this orchestra and this conductor. World class music-making.

[@rogerroth9536]

This orchestra is absolutely thrilling. I've listened to this performance many times and it thrills me every time. Thanks, Orozco-Estrada and hr. I adore you people.

[@carloslaguensbermejo9812]

MAGISTRAL interpretación por esta prestigiosa orquesta dirigida por el colombiano Andrés Orozco-Estrada de la Quinta Sinfonía de Gustav Mahler que es el compositor más importante del Posromanticismo. Inusualmente consta de cinco movimientos. BRAVO !!! Saludos desde España

[@luzrodas519]

With this interpretation we can feel the solemnity of Mahler. Mr. Orozco is really One of a Kind!

[@kirksmith1534]

Such wonderful tolerant talented orchestral players. Much appreciated for their artistry. Give the PLAYERS a raise.

[@robertjschroff6307]

Beautiful performance, the best what I have ever heard. Amazing musicians, superb quality and musical approach. Greatest conductor and orchestra!

[@WilliamPhelpsIII]

Orozco-Estrada did this #5 the best ever.

[@Maranatha99]

i never get tired of listening the solo trumpet of the trauermarsch. can listen to it over and over.

[@davidkuder4356]

Another impassioned delivery of Mahler's musical *intention*, by people who really believe in what he meant to communicate. I'm new to the Fifth... Have loved and absorbed the First, Second (of course), Fourth and Sixth for years--decades now. Will listen to this one again and again till I really get it. Mahler GehLebt!!

[@animesuchti2476]

Kuchen zu backen während man sich diese Stücke anhört ist unerwartet amüsant

[@davidhawkins9818]

What an amazing brass section!

[@sergejvasiljevitsjrachmani2808]

Yes, they always amaze me

[@maxbaumann2451]

True

[@nerowolfe736]

This is the finest Mahler Fifth I have ever heard - surely the reference standard. Rich, musical, lyrical, and just plain LUSH, it's damn near the most perfectly realized Mahler ANYTHING I have ever heard (but the Klemperer/Wunderlich/Ludwig DLVDE still wears that laurel, at least for me).

[@alexb6139]

The question is, should it be lyrical, or lush? It is in many ways a deeply tragic Symphony. Hence the first movements marking - "Trauermarsch" - or "Funeral march". Of course, it´s an interpretation matter, although I feel I really should put that out there.

[@TRH2243]

It's good but Payare has it beat now

[@TrumpetBogeyMan]

​@@alexb6139 I do agree that mahler 5 explores deaths and grief in a bleak manners... But I do think this performance manage to get this feeling right across very effectively. Some of the passage are very musical and lyrical, but I don't think Orcozko conducted all the movement with the goal of making beautiful music One word that would describe this performance for me would be "grim" Even in the first movement, the opening is played, not lyrically but with a very deep sound almost with a lack of enthusiasm and life. As if it was a messenger delivering the news of death in a umphased and in bleak way I do think that this performance has many reasons to be the best performance of Mahler 5 accessible on KZbin

[@leestamm3187]

Outstanding M5 performance from Orozco-Estrada & orchestra. He is certainly among the best conductors of his generation.

[@thorstentopp3824]

Ganz hervorragend, was die Frankfurter da leisten! Fantastisches Dirigat! Würdige Fortsetzung der großen Frankfurter Musikhistorie.

[@lilalola33]

Großartiges Orchester spielt wunderbare Musik !!!!!!!

[@tinabirdshafer]

So exquisite. this orchestra is top notch and. Im a Cleveland Orchestra girl!! This piece makes me weep in third movement every time!!! WOW. !!! BRAVA

[@marcelouz1]

Amazing, impeccable and irresistible version of the 5th,, one of the best performance I ever heard, I love this young conductor, there are three conductors from Latin America which I respect and admire so much, Andres Orozco Estrada, Gustavo Dudamel and Alondra de la Parra . GREAT orchestra, recording, mixing and mastering absolutely genial, BBRAVISIMO,!

[@robinblankenship9234]

Maestro O-E is turning the FRS into something quite special and wonderful!!!

[@olivoribl]

Ein besonderes Bravo für die Künstler hinter den Kameras! Das bringt das Menschliche der Musiker wesentlich näher.

[@klassischekirchenlieder8909]

Tränen der Dankbarkeit ! Gottes Liebe und Weisheit vereint und stärkt ! AMEN !

[@FelixVW]

Wow. Einfach nur wow. Genauso. Herzlichen Dank für den Upload! Ich könnte mich hereinlegen. Und einfach nur in der Musik verschwinden.

[@zeona80]

one of MAHLER'S most powerful and emotional works

[@anandsamuel1978]

I would sum this symphony and performance in one single word BRILLIANT!!!

[@mrsphobostv58]

Barletta Francesco Roma. Non mi stancherò mai di dirlo questa orchestra è questo direttore sono formidabili, che esecuzione, meravigliosa sublime. Lo ripeterò all'infinito ottoni così bravi è difficile trovarne.Bravi veramente bravi!!!! Grazie grazie Estrada sei super!!! Grazie anche a Mahler.. 😊😊😊😊😊😊❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️Bravi a tutti.

[@mikeandvickyinshanghai]

I must give my thanks to this channel. Providing such high quality music and all for free. Thank you so much as I'm new to classical music, and it is an excellent source of inspiration especially for my writing. With no vocals or lyrics to distract the mind, the shifting narrative of the music informs what comes out in my writing.

[@JAPARADISIR]

DIOS TE BENDIGA ANDRÉS OROZCO Y A TU ORQUESTA, GENIAL!!!

[@edilsonarruda210]

The trumpet solo, the French horns attack and the whole of this massive instrumental at beginning of the first movement have made me very impressed and expectant about what will be from that part on. The performance of that orchestra to Mahler's Fifth will forever remain as one of the best I've ever heard. I'll be forever thankful to the one who shared it with us lovers of the great music. Greetings from Natal, Rio Grande do Norte.

[@ChanceyWigglesworth]

Fantastic! The Rondo-Finale, which in the wrong hands can make me impatient, was sparkling perfection right to the end!

[@robertapilipianist]

Was für ein Genuss! Eine einmalige Darbietung dieses exemplarischen Werkes. Danke!

[@cupido47]

Die Mahler Aufführungen dieses Orchesters hat schon gute Tradition. So liebe ich die Interpretationen unter Eliahu Inbal sehr. Diese Aufführung toppt aber alles was ich bisher gehört habe. Das gilt ebenfalls für die 3. von Mahler. Andrés Orozco-Estrada lässt mich diese Sinfonien völlig neu empfinden. Muchas gracias Maestro!

[@elpidatsakiridi5802]

Πολύ ωραία

[@jairvieyra6159]

Recently I sart to listen your concerts and I am very happy with your interpretation of each symphony! I really can tell you that I am your FAN!! Congratulations and greetings from Mexico!!

[@axeldognat410]

Los planos parecen grabados por el mismísimo Mahler...Vigor, profundidad, oscuridad, contraste y pálpitos en el corazón!!!

[@alvarogarciabarbosa3199]

Versión a la altura de la de Gergiev! Bravo por la Frankfurt Radio Symphony y Andrés Orozco-Estrada. Grande Mahler!!

[@rogeriocarvalho6944]

The best performance I've ever heard of this piece. Now when I think about hearing it will come in my mind this video.

[@oliviamassobrio6157]

Creo que mis oidos han sido insuficientes y se ha añadido mi alma.

[@bodhibhaktaleali8230]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rIDZiZuvocmIodE

[@AlphaLabOne]

@@bodhibhaktaleali8230 Bravo, wanted to reply the same ;-)

[@luzrodas519]

What a marvelous Orchestra!

[@andresriveros]

Andrés Orozco es un gran director, sin lugar a dudas. Bravo maestro!!!

[@luisdiazlopez3712]

El Director es de excelencia, ha dirigido grandes obras de una vasta diversidad y con muy buen éxito. La orquesta orquesta es extraordinaria. El adagietto, supongo que todos los que han escuchado esta sinfonía, lo esperan, es digno de las versiones de referencia.

[@mengincelep]

Majestic performace! Would love to watch this performance alive in Istanbul as well.

[@thomasbuve9551]

I'm speechless. Thank you, HR Symphony Orchestra. ❤

[@javiermozzo849]

Muchas felicitaciones a Andrés Orozco por haber dirigido tan monumental obra con tanta belleza y elegancia.

[@josefernandez3612]

La imaginación del Gran Gustaf Mahler no tiene límites.

[@juergenvoigt8931]

Eine unglaubliche Leistung! Selten habe ich derartig viele verstörende Details erlebt! Bin noch im 1. Satz - gesprnnt, was noch folgt, Und - das HR Orchester wächst über sich ninaus! Jürgen

[@ricardonascimento6020]

Não perca esse maestro de vista!!!! Ele vai dar o que falar. É jovem ainda. Vai escrever seu nome na história da música!!! Bravo!!!!

[@ricardonascimento6020]

Prezado Juergen Voigt, realmente esta gravação é fantástica, rica em detalhes, como poucas vezes se ouviu! Agora, toda essa profundidade musical veio da leitura de uma pessoa muito jovem como Andrés Orozco-Estrada. Tal fato, nos faz antever um futuro muito promissor para o jovem maestro. Acompanhemos a sua trajetória. Obrigado!

[@MaxwellKaye]

I'm going to comment in English, so now it's three languages :D

[@Scryware]

und jetzt sind es vier sprachen hehe

[@MaxwellKaye]

German was the original language here

[@brianjohnhorne3844]

Truly a brilliant performance, with a quiet audience.

[@notaire2]

Majestätische Aufführung dieses großartigen Meisterwerks! Der brillante Ton der Solotrompete am Anfang klingt echt eindrucksvoll. Die perfekt synchronisierten Töne anderer Metallbläser sind auch bemerkenswert. Ausgezeichnetes Orchester!

[@nakchauchau]

Incredible performance. One of the best performance I ever heard.

[@dasportsfan2122]

If you possible can, you must here this live in concert. It was so good, I’m going again in April with the Toronto Symphony Orchestra Edit: I’m back after the performance and it was amazing, the standing ovation would have probably gone until now if they dint have to clear the hall

[@davidhawkins2207]

What a great orchestra! All sections outstanding!

[@ВладимирУ-т3ц]

Благодарю Франкфуртский оркестр за концерт!

[@mranferr]

🎉Una scultura ad alto e basso rilievo. I toni sono spinti al massimo espressivo. Eccezionali interpreti con magistrale direzione.

[@juergenvoigt8931]

Ich wusste bis heute nicht, dass Mahlers 5. die Zerrissentse von allen ist!

[@Quotenwagnerianer]

Für mich ist das seine persönlichste. Ohne dass er sich selbst jemals dazu geäußert hätte ist das hier eine sinfonische Autobiographie. Erste Abteilung: Kindheit in Armut, Gewalt und unter dem Eindruck, dass der Tod ein ständiger Gast ist. Mahler hat zahlreiche Geschwister im Kindesalter verloren. Zweite Abteilung: Mahler erobert sich Wien. Dritte Abteilung: Mahler verliebt sich in Alma und gesteht ihr seine Liebe. Optimistischer Ausblick in die gemeinsame Zukunft.

[@beniveizagavalverde5501]

Bellísima música! Gracias por subir estas joyas musicales.

[@scottmiller6495]

Mahler was The Greatest Composer of Symphonies by Anyone of All Time and finally the world is recognizing it Now !!!!!

[@scottmiller6495]

Probably in this order but only in my opinion the 4 greatest symphony composers were : Mahler, Brahms, Beethoven and Tchaikovsky !!!!!

[@meropale]

I am surprised by the love for Mahler in recent years. It's all a matter of taste but I'd usually pick even a Bruckner symphony over a Mahler.

[@scottmiller6495]

@@meropale That's ok too

[@CENTEXRailProductions]

Beatiful sound from the French Horns!! And great conducting from my favorite conductor!!

[@philip2898]

As a teenager, I’m so glad I prefer these classical masterpieces over some of the less meaningful music found in todays culture. No one will be listening to Cardi B in 30 years, but I will live with composers like Mahler for the rest of my lifetime. ❤❤

[@Palazzomusic]

Every time I listen to the Adagietto I start to cry of both joy and pain.

[@nealhines4476]

You are a true Mahlerian!

[@robinsekanina8025]

I agree with superb evaluation of previous listeners, but I need to add something missing. Absolutely amazing perfect job of Masters of Sound. Very well done... you trasmitted all of this directly through our ears to our hearts... THANK YOU❤

[@theingabo212]

This performance is truly outstanding! Love this orchestra and conductor a lot.

[@fbpliegorrivero8869]

Fantástico, felicitaciones al Director y a toda la orquesta! 👍 👍 👍 👍 👍 Saludos 🌹 👈 🌸 desde México 🇲🇽

[@enchiladasqueretanas]

Por donde empezar? El conductor, la música.... donde ha estado esta música todo el medio siglo de vida que tengo? Hoy descubrí a este compositor en la estación de radio publica del estado de Georgia (USA) que belleza!!!

[@leonardoneckar850]

Simplemente, no hay palabras para clarificar y evaluar esta extraordinaria ejecución, ❤

[@arushi-kaushik-chandra7240]

Gonna try and see this live in concert 1 more time. I saw it with the Boston Symphony Orchestra this summer. Amazingggg

[@dasportsfan2122]

I’m seeing it in 2 weeks with the Toronto Symphony

[@johnvaughan7096]

Just read some of the comments below, not being sure why I was here. I am a big Mahler fan but this is not in my top 5 favourites. But, but, but, but, what genius from the FRS orchestra, each specialist instrument standing out and being outstanding!!! Bravo!

[@joseorlandocastelblancorey2725]

Se merece esa ovación. ¡Bravo!.

[@oliversuchy6288]

the playful flute at 1:09:06 is one of the greatest moments in my life. Absolutely transcendental

[@patricklaffin2172]

My favorite symphony of all time 😂

[@october65-h6e]

Just wonderful...great orchestra and great conductor!

[@JuanDavidCorreaToro]

Orgullo colombiano!!!

[@gessara]

WUNDERBARES ORCHESTER! EIN KLASSE DIRIGENT

[@nealhines4476]

Indeed thank you Andres & Frankfurt. We are hosting a student from Columbia & his name is Andres as well. And. A trumpet player so I am taking him to Seattle Sym. 12/2/23 to hear this intense music.

[@marcelocarcamo]

Que belleza en la ejecucion, un gran trabajo, pasion ,fuerza y exhuberancia sonora, para esta, una de mis obras favoritas de Gustav Mahler, obra imprescindible, gracias por tan bello trabajo interpretativo y de direccion !!

[@RobsMiscellania]

Everyone talks about Adagietto, but for me, the section of the second movement from around 17:17 to 18:15 is some of the most abruptly, superlatively profound beauty I've ever heard in my entire life. I mean sure, the 4th movement is great and all, and definitely part of the package. But like, where on Earth from Mahler's soul did that little part come from

[@SECONDBRASS]

Einmal mehr -genialer Jürgen - Gratulation. Gruss aus Siebnen