why didn't Allah protect ALL previous scriptures like He did with Quran Dr Zakir Naik

[@AyZeeMusicc]

Although I respect his answer here, I believe the true answer will never be known. Allah is knowing of all things- he could have from the very beginning preserved the message. God himself in the Quran tells us there are unknown things that he is only knowing of. Maybe we will never know- but we must trust his plan.

[@Kazuki729]

​@abdulsattarali8220 ok?

[@flint8173]

​@abdulsattarali8220OK, but nobody asked 😂

[@MuammarQadaffi]

@abdulsattarali8220 Jews bring corruption to this world 👃🏻👃🏻🎩🎩✡✡💰💰💰💰💰💰

[@khushminakhan]

@abdulsattarali8220 The Torah u r referring here is Corrupted by humans and is not in it's original form of revelation.. if u get the Original One, Original Scripture of Torah u will Find that Allah in Torah and Allah in Quran is Same.. And if u r Muslim as ur name suggests u r.. you shouldn't write "are" for Allah.. Allah is WAHID.. Qul Hu Wallahu Ahad..

[@rahiahad5312]

I'm student not a scholar but I want to say something When you're really looking for the truth you should be unbiased and give it a shot (the Qur'an) In the Qur'an human beings are called as INSAN. Which means The one who forgets The reason behind conveying the same massage during a long period starts with ADAM A.S and ends with MUHAMMAD S.A.W is whenever a messenger came with the message that - indeed your lord is one. worship him and follow the guidelines indeed to him everyone will return People followed the messenger through long period of time people used to forget the massage it’s a true fact till now that we people are not every time be accurately practicing with the time the essence of the massage used to fade people used to forget then to remind them God sent another prophet for guidance the chain of prophet goes on like this When the last messenger came with the message God fulfilled the guidance with all solutions humankind need to survive a lifetime and God preserved the message and made it easy for the people to memorise the whole Quran even if every Quran is erased or corrupt then the people who memorised the full Quran will correct last scripture God made it easy for people to memorise it to word to word The question comes now is why didn’t he do this at the first place at the time of Adam A.S Why didn’t he preserve those scriptures before ? God made us gave use mind intelligence emotions free will and ability to think What we can think now how we think now how we perceive thing how we can relate back then people couldn’t do so each one God made with different intellect That youth years back would convinced by the solutions that had been provided in the old scriptures Because God had a plan to send messengers time to time who will convince people of their time and those scriptures would be enough Maybe because the updated world needed to know more and more what we’ve now in the Quran it’s like all in one 1400 years back people were amazed by that convinced by that related issues were there solutions were then it’s the same book now people are getting convinced by finding the solutions from this solving mystery from this and dealing each affairs of life with it even the scientists couldn’t are trying to solve the matters but with the Quran they find science so relatable When God had a plan to turn off the chain of prophets he revealed something miraculous magical A book like Quran from what each being will be benefited will feel related will solve things with till the end of time

[@firozabuksh5187]

Jazak Allah ho Khair may Allah reward you

[@firelord1202]

All those previous scripture meant to be updated no need protection

[@user-ey6xv3gz1w]

WHY ALLAH DOESN'T PROTECTED PALESTINIANS PEOPLES? IF SOMEONE IS AGAINST GOD AND JESUS , YOU CAN'T BE GOOD.

[@nicbentulan]

Lol amen

[@yeasirarafat7395]

Great answer..

[@ahmadabdulquddus102]

Ya Samad (All praise is due to Him) send prayers upon Muhammad and upon the family of Muhammad just as You sent prayers upon Abraham and upon the family of Abraham, verily You are the Praiseworthy, the Glorious. Ya Samad bless Muhammad and the family of Muhammad just as You have blessed Abraham and the family of Abraham, verily You are the Praiseworthy, the Glorious.

[@RK19936]

Wouldn't it be better to protect those books too (the Bible and other sky books), even if the message was for a specific time?

[@zarriebarki2001]

You think anyone can do better than what Allah plans? World is a test for a reason.

[@klickklack3949]

​​@@zarriebarki2001well allah should have known about all problems of not protecting those scriptures, like for example Christians and jews rejecting quran and thinking mohammed to be a false prophet. So his plan seems like a mess. And he should have known the outcome of each failed test, caused through his prior scriptures - so that also sounds like a mess of a plan

[@Inanotherworld.]

​@@klickklack3949you think it's a mess. If Allah had preserved the old scripture then there would be no fighting then where is the test??

[@klickklack3949]

@@Inanotherworld. how exactly is it a test when he should have known every single Christian who'd reject quran because of his mess of a plan? Its not like someone could do anything allah does not know.

[@burakkyi]

You just proved your point, he knew Christians were going to disbelieve in the Quran, that's the test. If Allah didn't make this test then there wouldn't be any diversity in mankind such as Muslims Christians jews etc.

[@Umer-r3y]

The Quran is the confirmation of the Psalms, Torah and Bible. We must read all these books with the Quran as the leading authority and the go-to source for the verification of all matters written within the previous scriptures. This is what is meant by the Quran being a confirmation for what was revealed before it

[@nicbentulan]

Lol no that's not what quran 5:48 means. 1- The Serpent told Eve that God's revelation was corrupted (by Adam?). How's this different from Islam? Both Jesus & Paul never said previous revelation was corrupted. 2- Why didn't Allah provide Torah/Gospel in uncorrupted forms? Dear terrorist, I dare you to PM me to debate me. --- More info: - Ha6uVGB-Mtw

[@furkanahmad4226]

In this Islamic channel, why such ads. are being showed🤔🤔😡?

[@servantofallahthelordofthe8740]

It's not channel ad brother. It's for you based on your channel preferences

[@furkanahmad4226]

@@servantofallahthelordofthe8740 Hmm.. it may be and thanks for clearing my misunderstanding👍 Actually I got surprised at watching such ads on this Islamic channel.

[@servantofallahthelordofthe8740]

@@furkanahmad4226 sometimes yt just messes up. Another day an Indian song app ad popped up where a man and a women was literally.... I hate yt ads sometimes

[@mn-sz7kf]

Ads sometimes are random. So each & every country has them different

[@VinodkumarBhandari-vq9vt]

its all business in the name of God

[@MAYONNAISEMOOSE]

I dont like the sheikh's analogy tbh. IN Islam, humans have free will from compulsion, but not free will from causation. We have ultimate free will in that we can choose evil or good. but we cannot have free will of seeing the causes of what we choose. Similarly, behind the unlimited wisdom of Allah subhanihu wa taala, is that he gave the people of the book to choose. Most chose to follow desires and corrupt the messages. that was their free will. The causes that stem from this, is the revelation of Muhammad s.a.a.w.s, khatam al anbiya (seal of the prophets. the last messenger) in which he preached the uncorrupted truth that Allah has promised to safe guard/perserve (which, is true to this very day) Now, the previous revelation's corruptedness caused Islam. And the Causes of Islam, is the test. And we start again: To choose Islam or not. And the Causes of our decisions is the akhira (the hereafter; when you die) and those choices will be looked at in yom al qiyama (day of judgement). This is just a miniscule example out of the unlimited bounty and wisdom of Allah, our creator.

[@Tabethy]

So whats the conclusion?

[@delaware12pwner]

Imagine a Chemistry teacher (Allah) giving 3 test paper to his students (Humans) except 2/3 of his questions have been changed from Chemistry to Physics without his will and inability to protect it… How do you expect a student to be successful when teacher has allowed so much confusions and ideologies in this world… Its a clutter world with even Allah have 3 different religious text ideologies for the “people” to pick and follow the right one… Infact, how do you consider the “one” all powerful when he cant protect his own words via The way Quran did. If so he couldnt, atleast write it in the quran that “as of today, Quran is the updated version since the words of gods have been corrupted in the scriptures before.” But its nowwhere in Quran as an unequivocal statement (unless I am wrong). Heres even a better analogy, lol: The teacher presents his student with 3 exams on paper. 2/3 of them are false and 1/3 is the truth… except all looks very close to be true.. how do we determine which is the right one when others are very confusing and LITERALLY CAME FROM HIM.. And if you say that well quran is the last text as its written but the other two dont say that. The first 2 say that they are the true text and you have spokepersons (prophets sent to specific times) convincing you which book to read at different time of millennia. WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK!! And oh btw, those are only 3 religious ideologies that we are assuming came from “god”. What about the other million religions that date really far back… what kind of sadistic test is this given by a teacher who isnt clear with you… ofcourse its going to cause chaos and good people being distracted… Its mad confusing broski… I am a muslim too but struggle with this thing. If I wad god and Adam (PBUH) was the first human being and prophet sent to earth, then my only first and last revelation would be given to Adam PBUH as a human manual to live your life. Those who stray away from it and create their own manuals contradicting that god sent manual will be punished in the hereafter.

[@Tabethy]

Brother, humans have been given FREE WILL. I can go up to a quran right now and willingly change the words. But it will still be perserved, execept because the population was small back then, you could easily change the words, like what the children of israel did with moses, they hid a part while revealing another. You saying that how can the teacher (allah) has allowed such a thing?(changing questions)wrong. A better example is Allah giving the answers to the questions, but the students changing the questions in their own way, to make the answers look like it answers whatever the person that changed it, to make it answer whatever he desires. With his free will.

[@VinodkumarBhandari-vq9vt]

He meant to say God made mistakes while making previous revelations and hence, he updated it again and again

[@y_r_u_geh]

How intelligent.. wow

[@japibobo5829]

He literately said in the video that people had a capacity of how much knowledge they could absorb. That is why all the revelations were divided in different time periods. Nothing was ever said about God making a mistake. Next time listen to what you’re all listening!

[@VinodkumarBhandari-vq9vt]

@@japibobo5829 he said it's ok but, where is this statement written in Qur'an, please explain.

[@polite.cat.has.playlists]

@@japibobo5829 assalamualykum brother. Can I ask you some questions?

[@mrimperfect5214]

@@VinodkumarBhandari-vq9vt in surah hijr abt final revelation.but not abt bible,its different from torah and injeel(gospel)2:30 didnt u hear the video.

[@Sirat-ul-Islam]

thats not even a answer 😅, allah knows the best

[@hamzarasheed1232]

According to your logic there must be revelations after muhammad SAW. Why would there be no revelations after Quran? Why Allah didnt made the first life manual when Adam AS was sent down the earth that this was the right way of living your life? But then after, he stopped the process of revelations suddenly and told this one quran is ultimate.

[@japibobo5829]

Because there was nothing to add to it anymore. We know what we need to know and now we need to guide ourselves to the right path. We don’t need every 1000 years a new prophet because else life wouldn’t be a test anymore. That is reason why Adam(AS) was kept on earth, to be tested even tho he asked for forgiveness.

[@tilluabdy3270]

And i also want this answer

[@tilluabdy3270]

@@japibobo5829 i also want this answer

[@hamzarasheed1232]

@@japibobo5829 please look at my argument again. Its not about the guidelines which were completed by Muhammad SAW 1400 years ago. Why was it not completed in the first place?

[@hisham1774]

@@hamzarasheed1232 At that time, the people wouldn't have understood directly the Holy Quran

[@creativity2598]

Why this why that Just watch youtube sleep and fight This is the state of ummah

[@glenbritto]

But Allah says go back to previous book

[@jinaurora2469]

Source

[@Hristusist]

@@jinaurora2469 quran 10: 94 also quran 4:136

[@jinaurora2469]

@@Hristusist pevious books are not the torah and bible of today quran talk about the gospel of jesus pbuh which we dont have dear

[@Hristusist]

@@jinaurora2469 Quran 6:115 allah protects his revelations . Also if you really think that previous scriptures were corrupted , does that mean that all ayets that allah revealed about the torah , indjil and zabur are now abrogated ? Meaning that the quran is not eternal? Also , when did this corruption of injil happen , because muhhamed says that the one in his time was good quran 5:43 ?

[@jinaurora2469]

@@Hristusist people failed to protect their holy scriptures till this day the bible gets changed i dont know what you are talking about

[@masudfahim4531]

Almighty Allah sent last Revealtion of Holy Quran to send prophet Muhammad SAW but you will read Quran u will see maximum Surah indicate prophet ISA , prophet Moses so strange 🤔🤲

[@cancercancellous2206]

Wgat do u mean

[@Religioustobe-888]

Allah s.w.t is telling the stories of previous prophets and what happened to them in the Quran to prophet muhammed s.a.w....

[@Tabethy]

Because allah is giving the stories of those before him as a sign from allah (for disbelievers) and as knowledge for the prophet, and to know your enemies (like our sworn enemy satan)

[@mikemental8285]

If Allah did not protect all Scripture, the are few possible reasons: 1 Allah contradicts himself 2 Muhammed did not get quran from Allah, but made it up 3 Allah is not truth, but lie.

[@Tabethy]

Lil bro did NOT watch the video 😭🙏🙏

[@mikemental8285]

@@Tabethy Facts i presented, wont change

[@Tabethy]

@@mikemental8285 first let me ask you what your religion is before debunking this entire statement that just because allah didnt protect all past scriptures to be available to this day, that means allah is a lie, or made up by muhammad or that allah contradicts itself.

[@mikemental8285]

@@Tabethy I am a follower of Jesus Christ.

[@Tabethy]

@@mikemental8285 bro, you dont make any sense, why do you follow the bible if its corrupted after all what you said? You literally said god doesnt exist if he couldnt protect his books your book is corrupted atleast the quran isnt like itd make more sense to follow quran

[@HiErOx21]

it is the same as saying that God failed to protect previous scriptures.

[@Inanotherworld.]

It's whole different meaning you idiot.Failed means you have tried but failed.Rejecting means you have rejected it

[@thomasshelby5686]

How to ask questions to Dr۔ zakir naik sahab ?

[@Guest-vz1dj]

Because he has no power to protect previous scripture

[@Tabethy]

Wrong, because of this (a comment i made before you, read carefully) Brother, “the book” youre talking about, was “the word” with some prophets (just like with the quran, allah spoke the word to our prophet, and later the prophet illiterated the word, for it made it easier for people) so, to prophets were sent commandments, why would allah perserve one single word or book containing commandments given to one specific prophet? Would every human from adam to today need to know what those commandments were? Thats why allah sends new prophets with new commandments (words or books). Not to mention the rules of Islam, for example, haram and halal, used to be different, prophet isa used to be able to drink wine for a specific amount. Would that fit the world of today? 2B humans today lost in entertainment would certainly have trouble keeping themselves for the allowed amount, causing yet other problems.

[@elvisuchman7309]

What did he think he was saying concerning protection of God's word? 🤣🤣 This Muslim joke will kill me one day with his comedy shows 🤣 I will die laughing....

[@sajsultan1839]

The people are the devils the keeped the truth to themself and took out parts to suit others

[@servantofallahthelordofthe8740]

Sadly many Muslims nowadays are doing something similar called fatwa shopping

[@servantofallahthelordofthe8740]

In shA Allah we must have save us and our family from it

[@akgknowledgehouse702]

I don't agree with Zakir sir. If Allah subanawtala would have preserved previous scriptures then there would have not been trinity or misconception of Jesus in Islam. There would have been no other mal practices in different religions

[@mehrinrahman4444]

Life is a test. That's why Allah let it go. If you think our creator did mistake then people couldn't live in the perfect world. That's why he gave people hard choice because he knows people will ask about scrift and few other things after final prophet.

[@akgknowledgehouse702]

@@mehrinrahman4444 brother I think you did not understand what my point is

[@MohammadAariz252]

Allah SWT already replaced all scriptures with The Holy Qur'an...hence god's word has not been actually changed...he sent revelation in every age for but for a limited time...now we have to follow The Holy Qur'an till the day of judgement...and we know Qur'an can't be changed

[@akgknowledgehouse702]

@@MohammadAariz252 Allah azzawajal has replaced I agree but my question is why did he not preserve the previous scriptures

[@MohammadAariz252]

@@akgknowledgehouse702 Ofcourse those scriptures were not changed until their period was over,but even if we have the final revelation the Holy Qur'an people still follow the old revelations which aren't necessary (for eg. christians and jews) and while we having the unchanged Holy Qur'an why do we need the old revelations ?

[@joelsiboro5090]

In 1:56 said that Allah has made a mistake. how allah can made mistake? zakir naik said that the previous scriptures has a mistake....so allah gave a new one....so if the first one has a mistake, i think the quran also has a mistake.... it is simple...

[@elvisuchman7309]

Don't mind him, he is a joker

[@sahiba9951]

He said that he disagrees with people whoever says allah made a mistake

[@Newmindseton]

Do better then that , quaran Checked over and over again , zero contradictions ( All false claims from non Muslims ) …

[@aarifeena2745]

He didnt say Allah did mistake. He says Allah gave revelations.. People made it corrupted. Allah didnt want to preserve them as he did for final revelation Quran.. Allah never makes mistake.. Preserving a revelation or not is upto his right

[@joelsiboro5090]

I challenge the Muslims, "if the quran is perfect, why should there be so many hadiths?"

[@beyzaatasoy9821]

Because even there is a clear message, people try to twist the message and justify what they want to justify by extracting false meanings, as they did before. So Hadith doesn't mean that the Quran isn't perfect, but they are to support and protect its meaning being twisted.

[@jamesotis6493]

@Mai Khaar That means the Quran is not perfected

[@jamesotis6493]

@@dra.aqureshi6528 Then how do you know how to pray? Even the 5 prayer times are in the Quran

[@saniyashoukat3936]

Hadiths and life of Prophet Muhammad is the practical illustration and demonstration of Quran. But for people like you who think Quran as an ordinary book like anyother book then it's unbelievable for you to think Quran is a way of life not only a simple book..... Also the previous revelations were demonstrated by their Prophets like Musa, Jesus...

[@osamabinladen4613]

think of the quran as like a syllablus and hadiths are like the teacher of that syllabus

[@VinodkumarBhandari-vq9vt]

Shiv Shankar Mahadev is the only God. you all are in darkness.

[@y_r_u_geh]

What about Vishnu? And that 4 or 3 faced old man with white beard?

[@VinodkumarBhandari-vq9vt]

@@y_r_u_geh they are also Shiva

[@y_r_u_geh]

@@VinodkumarBhandari-vq9vt ok

[@shieldgamingyt8490]

😂🤣

[@shieldgamingyt8490]

You will get to know after day of judgement who were in darkness