How to solve Depth of Field edge problems in Nuke

[@HugosDesk]

Hugo's Desk will be live on Twitch tomorrow Sunday, 17th March from 15.00 GMT. This will part Two of a CG compositing Nuke workshop using a real production shot. Hope to see you there. www.twitch.tv/hugosdesk

[@liorweisspi]

I really like the 5 min tutorial concept. it becomes very practical and useful during busy work day with artists, producers and clients. whatever the topic is. Per the Colouredge and Anti-aliasing it's the first time someone is addressing this issue in a tutorial So many thanks. I never miss any of your tutorials.

[@HugosDesk]

+Lior Weiss Thanks so much fro the Kind words. Yes this started because people complained about my 90 min long FXPHD classes, lol. So I am promising always 5 min, but will try at least to be less then 7-8. Thanks again

[@HenrikDoark]

Hugo, how amazing was that your mini class! Several years that I watch videos of DT, FXPHD, YT and never explained to me how to normalize the depth and / or fix the artifacts! Thank you very much! :D

[@HugosDesk]

+Henrik D'park Thanks so much for the kind words. This technique will not work if the Objects cross over too much. For that I use this and some Edge Blurs with Object ID's and sometimes a few stroke of paint. But that is another video for another time.

[@Michael-yf6pj]

Thank you very much! It is a question that I have been puzzled for a long time!

[@HugosDesk]

No problem, glad I could help.

[@yankostoyanov6702]

Thanks, you're doing a fantastic job with all NUKE videos! Keep them coming.

[@HugosDesk]

No problem. Wish I had more time

[@Cimpy101]

You rock. Thank you so much for this. I was trying to tweak the depth values in maya. This is just what I needed.

[@HugosDesk]

Glad to help. Thanks for watching

[@pioniercg]

Love it, cant wait for more. No crap, long, boring tutorials anymore

[@HugosDesk]

I try making it as short as possible and to the point. It is hard but I will keep trying.

[@haaake]

Great information. You can also just use the raw depth data in the zDefocus node setting the math to "depth". You don't have to normalize the depth unless you need it for some other purpose. You can also use the Filter Erode to expand the depth channel to fix the rough edges that don't properly overlap the anti-aliased alpha.

[@HugosDesk]

The only reason I normalize is so I can have a visual representation of where the Z-depth is. This way I can adjust Edge Extensions, Edge Blurs, Filters using IDS, etc. I just prefer to see it so I can locate where the problems are. Having said that, this video is now almost 4 years old. These days I just use Deep information to solve some of these issues, to be honest.

[@AFaria8]

Thanks for the video Hugo, really nice and helpful. and thanks for providing the source files too. looking forward to the next ones :)

[@HugosDesk]

+Anabela Faria Not a problem, glad you liked the video. Cheers

[@ToonHimself]

Thanks! just discovered you channel, really cool! Gonna watch all the video's!

[@HugosDesk]

+ToonHimself Thanks mate, more to come soon. So glad you find my channel. Hope not to disappoint

[@AronDurkin]

these are the best videos about NUKE on the whole web.

[@HugosDesk]

+Aron Durkin Thanks so much mate, making me blush. 😊

[@PinkMarz]

I was just running into the normalizing issue yesterday, thanks!

[@lukex975]

this helped me today. thanks Hugo

[@HugosDesk]

Thanks so much for watching. Glad I could help

[@rr_10102]

Short and sweet. Thanks for the very useful tip!

[@fotuoh]

Great tutorial, quick and easy! Obrigado Hugo! I'm loving your videos

[@HugosDesk]

No problem, thanks for watching

[@RebelPhoton]

This was great! Thank you Hugo!

[@HugosDesk]

+RebelPhoton Thanks so much

[@Pinionistus]

Awesome and to the point! Hate those long and dragging tutorials.

[@HugosDesk]

+Pavle Milićević Thanks so much mate, Hope you are well.

[@Pinionistus]

Hugo's Desk all is good, gonna be actually teaching nuke to few friends soon. Will keep eye on you how pros do it hah 😊

[@HugosDesk]

+Pavle Milićević Come man, you are more Pro then me mate. Good luck.

[@Pinionistus]

Haha you gotta be joking Hugo 😂 maybe in 10yrs

[@usernoice]

Really love this series. Useful and very easy to digest.

[@HugosDesk]

I try making them as short as possible but sometimes it is hard.

[@soheilasghary]

short, clear, helpful. Thanks.

[@HugosDesk]

Thanks so much for watching.

[@r2detta]

Great explanation!

[@HugosDesk]

Thanks so much for watching

[@mdesnoyelles]

Great ! I like this new format ! 5 minutes tuto is clever idea and a great challenge XD Cheers

[@HugosDesk]

Thanks so much. Yes it is a challenge specially since I pretty busy and this is a side hobby of mine to make content for You Tube. But hopefully I can keep it weekly. Thanks

[@nutellaj1778]

Hugo is the best

[@GHDSchrank]

Parabéns pela iniciativa Hugo !! vou acompanhar seus trabalhos por aqui ... Muito Obrigado !!!

[@HugosDesk]

Obrigado, ainda bem que gostas.

[@NervalFilho]

Fantástico! :) Obrigado por compartilhar seu conhecimento, Hugo!

[@HugosDesk]

+Nerval Filho Obrigado por veres

[@OlafBlomerus]

A huge help. Thank you, Hugo.

[@ramakrishna284]

Just coming to the point everytime........💙

[@guillaumedelescazes512]

HUGO !!!!! I have been struggling with this for ageeeeeessss ! Wow ! So happy to see someone treat and solve this issue ! And all that in 5 minutes.... What else...... ;) You da man Hugo ! Keep it up ! Oh by the way, do you know how you could get this to work in After Effects by any chance ? I know you don't really use it anymore but sometimes we just don't have the luxury to be Nukin' around soooooo ;) Would be greatly appreciated ! Till soon ! Take care ! THANKS A MILLLLLLLL !

[@MiyuOzz]

Simple, very effective thank you very much!

[@justKolia]

Thank you very much Hugo! It is really cool! I like it! And i think it is not so important to get in 5 minutes range. Because sometimes is difficult to explain something in a 5 minutes. And it will get more then 5 but less then 7 or even 10. It is a quick format too! I wont be upset if your quick tut get 10 minutes. ))) Thank you sharing your knowledge and your huge experience! I really appreciate it and i think im not only one. Keep going! Looking forward your new tuts!

[@HugosDesk]

+justKolia Thanks so much of the kind words mate. And yes sometimes it will be 5, 6 or 7 min. I just want to make sure it is short and one topic or node only. Easier to share and to watch. Thanks again.

[@danielefrontini6204]

Thanks Hugo!

[@HugosDesk]

No Problem

[@SupunLankage]

Super cool job!

[@John_Anderson_P]

desde o inicio você sempre fazendo incríveis trabalhos! 🏆🏆🇧🇷🇧🇷

[@9177852573]

Good one! thanks

[@brod515]

thank you this looks like it will be fun.

[@HugosDesk]

+MrBrN197 Thanks so much. I hope so. Cheers

[@naveenprabhu_Vlogs]

Hugo you make my life easy thanks

[@lazyartist5163]

We need an updated version of this tutorial. If it's possible. Thank you!

[@HugosDesk]

It's on my list but I do show this on my latest stream! I will publish a edited version soon but the full stream is up.

[@lazyartist5163]

@@HugosDesk okay, I will watch. You are a great teacher. Thanks for sharing ur knowledge!

[@zsmithcreative9519]

ColorEdge & EdgeExtend remove from nukepedia any any suggestion how to find out this 2 gizmos...?

[@HugosDesk]

You can do the same with Nuke 12's new Edge extend node! The new node is GPU accelerated. But if you the old ones want here you go: www.dropbox.com/s/qs8fhzp594w7u25/Archive.zip?dl=0

[@zsmithcreative9519]

@@HugosDesk really appreciate it man..thanks a lot..

[@HugosDesk]

@@zsmithcreative9519 NP

[@mariozorzi]

@@HugosDesk Thanks Hugo!

[@PixelCommando]

Wow so cool ;) i owe you a beer ! as we could fix our Z-Defocus in our last project.. Thanks for your great work on helping people with your tutorials.

[@HugosDesk]

+PixelCommando Thanks so much mate.

[@ryanjstever]

Really appreciate your tutorials! Have you composited with passes from Unreal Engine? Im trying to follow what you are doing here but the passes from UE look a little different.

[@HugosDesk]

Unfortunately not yet, but I will soon!

[@RajuMon2016]

Great video

[@sachindhillon4099]

Very nice

[@miltongiordano]

really interesting video

[@HugosDesk]

Thanks mate. Glad you like it.

[@backendninja8333]

Wow, that's great tip.

[@HugosDesk]

+Cyan Tarek Thanks so much

[@Emm_R_Guitar]

This is a great idea. The edge thing has always thrown me with zdepth. (student) What is the difference between the Nukepedia node, and copying the alpha and eroding it or dilating a few pixels? Just wondering.

[@HugosDesk]

Thanks for the kind words. Yes you can do it manually without gizmos but I just find it easier to use the pre-made nodes. But there are many ways of getting the same result. Cheers and thanks for watching.

[@monocore]

Awesome

[@HugosDesk]

Thanks. Need to make a new version, this is like 4 years old already.

[@monocore]

Hugo's Desk that would be great. I just moved from AE to Nuke and I found your videos super helpful. The logic is exactly the same I just need to work my way through the right nodes. And the edges problem in depth is old as time itself. I used to render the depth pass 4x times the resolution but that is no longer suitable. I’m having trouble with overlapping foreground de focused objects, but I guess that’s just a limitation of the technique perhaps? Anyway, big thanks and keep it up!

[@jkartz92]

is coloredge node removed in recent versions of nuke?

[@pioniercg]

Does ColourEdge node has different name on nukepedia, cant find if there?

[@HugosDesk]

Try this link, these are some of the gizmos I use: www.dropbox.com/s/nqjzmiiba38w8zt/Edges.zip?dl=0

[@dysnXO]

Any idea how to fix this in After Effects?

[@HugosDesk]

I am sorry but not sure how!

[@mindsteamers]

Great tutorial! Could you show us something about using deep composite?

[@HugosDesk]

+mindsteamers Yes maybe another time, sure. I will added to the list. Thanks so much for watching.

[@Pinionistus]

+Hugo's Desk yeah hardcore deep compositing is my next stop on my learning curve 😊

[@GHOSTPIXEL95]

Hey man great tutorial! I was wondering where can I find the Edge Colour gizmo it seems to be deleted from everywhere, I dont know why L( plz help!

[@haaake]

You can also just use the Filter Erode to expand the depth channel by +1 or so to expand it to properly cover the alpha. Put the FilterErode into your depth channel stream, set channels to "depth.Z" and +1 or so should work fine.

[@Alexandremetalhead]

Hugo, obrigado por compartilhar conhecimento. E quanto aos tutoriais em português, você ainda pretende faze-los? Grande abraço e sucesso para você.

[@HugosDesk]

+Alexandre Rufino Obrigado. Achas que existe muito gente que gostaria de ver em Português? Achas que sim? Eu posso fazer Dub a este e ver se tem muitos "views"

[@Alexandremetalhead]

+Hugo, eu acho que sim. Existe um canal chamado Borgo TV, do Magno Borgo. Todos os seus vídeos são em português, e acho que tem uma comunidade grande e muito carente de tutoriais em nossa língua. Seria ótimo se você fizesse tutoriais em português, já que você é um dos grande nomes da composição digital :)

[@AndreiBoscoBR]

+Hugo's Desk Também acho que seria bem interessante vídeos sobre composição e nuke em português.

[@apmanti12]

hey hugo, can you explain on how to use curve tool to find depth?

[@HugosDesk]

I guess that’s a video right there. Thanks

[@annasorgon8878]

thanks... where is it possible to find the colour edge node? on nukepedia I´m not able to find it!!!

[@HugosDesk]

Here you go: www.dropbox.com/s/54o65exulbir0ca/ColourEdge.gizmo.zip?dl=0

[@annasorgon8878]

Thanks a lot Hugo, I really need it!

[@rikinpatelvfs]

Hi Hugo. Once again, great tutorial. Very helpful to a lot of us. But I have a question for you. I was working on something similar and getting the same artifacts, but in my case the 3d geo was overlapping and the edge of the foreground object was off by a few pixel (with depth pass). As objects were overlapping, I couldn't do edge extend. Hope it makes sense. How would you approach to this problem? Thanks in advance!

[@madballdesign]

+1

[@madballdesign]

have you found the solution?

[@talesbyfirelight3728]

Hey Hugo! great vid. The values in your Depth pass are in the thousands. 3108 for black point and 1873 for white point. The Depth pass I'm testing out here from my client is 1.09000 at it highest and .55000 at its lowest. And its backwards. The closest part is darker and farthest point is brighter. Any thoughts?

[@HugosDesk]

Not sure about those values. Are you clamping or limiting the values in 3D? The values should match 3D coordinates and distances camera so if your 3D is made to corrects scales it should be a lot higher.

[@mixjix]

I'm having the same problem, did you manage to resolve this?

[@HugosDesk]

You need to make sure you have correct values in the Zdepth settings in 3D. Also you need a proper scale in your 3D scene. Maybe that could be the problem?

[@mixjix]

@@HugosDesk I'm new to Nuke, but turns out your workflow works for me, I for some reason have to use decimal values from 0-1 (0.XXXX) instead. Will look into your suggestion though, thanks.

[@ACES-BRAZIL]

NOBODY SPENDS NOTHING IN THE NET ... I KNOW WHY YOU ARE RELEASING THESE MIGALS

[@HugosDesk]

+VFX Sorry what?

[@WiseHoax_ArijitDatta]

I have a render but which has no alpha channel because its a ground shot .then what to do??

[@radhanathdutta7312]

what the mask pipe do? why that goes into that character?

[@MaDiViL696]

Really cool video ! I just have a question, i have an animate and i would like to have my focus first on the FG and then defocus to the BG, and i some issues doing it. even if i animate the focus place. Is there anything to be carefull about ?

[@bassamkasper]

Great ,, thank you

[@HugosDesk]

Thank you for watching

[@Nighscreach]

I can't find those nodes in nuke

[@blackswann]

Hey Hugo! Is there a way to fix the edges of this character if she was rendered out as part of the background and not a foreground element? I’m running into edge problems on a scene with lots of leaves and grass - when trying to apply depth of field on the whole scene in Nuke I get edge artifacts in between leaves - any way around this in Nuke or would you need to render DoF in camera in 3D?

[@HugosDesk]

Only way to go around this is to use Deep compositing and PGBokeh. Everything else will have edge issues. Last resort would be DOF in 3D

[@blackswann]

Hugo's Desk thank you for quick reply! Loved your deep compositing process video - will have to try this out.

[@MrThirumal]

Thanks hugo.....

[@Advection357]

Is there a way to get a "Y depth" from a renderer? As in points close to camera's height are black and farthest upwards are white... so just an axis change. Maybe something can be done with the position pass? It's for an atmospheric effect I'm trying to build in post & want to avoid rendering large scalar field volumes :3 Search brings up nothing...

[@morrisabramian2276]

this can be created while rendering, a falloff map based on camera Y axis

[@Screensam]

Hey Hugo! Do you know if there is a way to link the focal point attribute to a tracker? It seems that Nuke won't let me do it...

[@ACES-BRAZIL]

NINGUEM PASSA NADA NA NET... EU SEI PORQUE VOCES ESTAO LIBERANDO ESTAS MIGALHAS

[@entertainmentchannel8952]

please make a video which describe it more in depth and detailed

[@ghamay2011]

Dropbox link is dead

[@HugosDesk]

Fixed now. Cheers

[@ghamay2011]

+Hugo's Desk Thanks hugo for a quick reply and it works now.

[@jszewczyk]

Dropbox link is dead :)

[@HugosDesk]

Do you like this tutorial? Want to see more? Support my channel in Patreon for $1 and have exclusive timed access before everyone else. Don't miss out: www.patreon.com/hugosdesk