Human Rights lawyer: Exploding electronic devices are legal weapons only under special circumstances

[@chrishenschke8627]

Bad audio. Poor preparation by DW.

[@dopeboi13yearsago9]

What r u talking about it's fine

[@FrickingLunatic]

that lawyer should have a better communication system//

[@philg4116]

​@@dopeboi13yearsago9 sure it is, Fido

[@jibril2950]

The most useless program I've seen on DW so far

[@p.m.of4299]

Human rights of Hezbolah- what a clown.

[@Elo-hv3fw]

The human rights lawyer is definitely attacking.

[@sharokha.h.6774]

Khuman Rights for Ben Gwir, Smotrich and Netanyakhu is fine and not for Khezbollah.

[@peabase]

Are you advocating that Israel should stoop all the way to Hezbollah's level?

[@david-bd6td]

This is clearly act of terrorist, of course US does not bother when the culprit is his half brother ...😏

[@imlvee8909]

Wtf is this???? Is this serious?

[@mikicerise6250]

As serious as "we export regulations". This is Europe's parallel reality these days.

[@theloniousm4337]

About as serious as saying Israel was illegally parked.

[@arlenreinstein9907]

Military communication systems .....no problem at all!

[@beatlesleo]

Dog.

[@elmo430o]

How cute. Nobody ever questioned the legality of october seventh.

[@DEonaraR]

We were bombarded with Oct.7 and in this video only, was mentioned at least twice, and ICC requested 2 arrest warrants for 2 hamas leaders??? How much more can one take?

[@RRR-vi3hs]

75 years of octobers caused the seventh. And 143 nations voted to stop illegal occupation.

[@IceQueenaliasIQ]

Because people are not braindead. Why would that be discussed? It's obviously illegal.

[@nuqwestr]

ICC has, and issued warrant applications over Oct 7.

[@jackbleiham8475]

October 7th ? all you trolls sound like a bitter ex-girlfriend

[@diazvirdani1059]

*Israel🇮🇱 must respect UN~ soveregnity territorial integrity of Lebanon (south), Palestine (East Jerusalem, West Bank, Gaza Strip) & Syria (Golan).*

[@muhammadnaftalibennett7887]

*DW channel please.. continue report situation in Gaza Strip, West Bank, Golan. god bless DW 🤲*

[@adne1819]

*Israel🇮🇱 need new Prime Minister. Benjamin Netanyahu 16years Prime Minister' Israel.*

[@LARPBeard]

So only half way through the interview you disclose this person is in a conflict of interest as he took part in legal action against Israel. Classic lawfare. "You can defend yourself, but only once the attackers have invaded your home, once you push him back, you aren't allowed to continue." Thi king of thought leaves no option for self defense, only continued victemhood.

[@joexavier4070]

This kind of incidents shows international rule based order only applicable for certain countries Recent Hypocrisy and double standards exposed "weakeness" in the rule based order

[@sharingfamspace3156]

Germany is on the dustbin of history again 😂

[@SeniorPanda79]

You never discussed legality of the rockets that Hezbollah is firing on Israeli civilians every day since month! But now you discuss an attack on this terrorists?! What's wrong with you DW?

[@DEonaraR]

Yeap what's wrong with DW? They been paid and bought by the Israeli lobby and now this 😅

[@darrylsugg7230]

You seem to forget is royal is an illegal occupying force.

[@LeafyNerd]

Also no one ever discusses the right of any other country to exist. It's only Israel that has to justify its existance.

[@DEonaraR]

​@@LeafyNerd. If Israel had treated the natives in more humane way, maybe nobody would noticed😅.... but Israeli cruelty is on a different level

[@david-bd6td]

Israel brutality and torture of Palestinians are the root cause and made possible by US support ... Imagine 75 years .😢

[@adriennefried5368]

How much money is he getting from the Arabs similar to S Africa.

[@beatlesleo]

Maybe ur momma gets all the money

[@creeperFIN123]

Man geography isn't your strong suit... Arabs similar to South Africa? fr interesting.

[@kakkik3756]

@@creeperFIN123they always have dumb justification 😂😂

[@Hugoleewx]

Everything is legal as long it has US backing.

[@happymelon7129]

if this is doing the right thing, then Putin must be doing too little to defend his country.

[@adriennefried5368]

What about the rockets targeting civilian population in Israel?

[@DEonaraR]

What civilians? If you force your whole population to serve in the army, who are the civilians?

[@IceQueenaliasIQ]

What about them? They are acts of war and Hezbollah is a terrorist organization in most people's opinion. So what about the rockets, in fact?

[@zen1647]

Two wrongs don't make a right. Even when Hezbolla is making illegal attacks, as a recipients of western military support, we expect Israel to follow the international rules of law. Otherwise military support should be withdrawn.

[@IceQueenaliasIQ]

@@zen1647 Precisely.

[@Zockopa]

Well,even kids were killed. So it was terrorism. The same kind of terrorism that accepts multiple civilian deaths to eliminate one military target.

[@dljad5582]

DW is new BBC

[@shazibrabha9366]

Why dont expert question Hezbollah daily rockets attacks? Such a so-called biased expert

[@DEonaraR]

Its been 11 months of the same discussions, how much more can we take?

[@arlenreinstein9907]

ICC and ICJ. ....,the height of double standards

[@amritpalsingh3293]

Only Africans or non Western allied countries can be booked under international law

[@PrinceOfTheCity1]

Can’t hear a thing sounds like he has marbles in his mouth

[@IceQueenaliasIQ]

Subtitles worked for me.

[@andreaspedersen8136]

The only thing worse than this guys mic quality is his credibility.

[@patrickstar686]

Omegalul

[@sgn4899]

The audio from your guest was very distorted so I had to watch subtitles. Germany should not supply weapons now.

[@josepha.r5839]

The 'legality'? War in its totality is not 'legal'. As well, do they discuss the legality of Hamas on Oct. 7 last year?

[@DEonaraR]

Trillion of times, in every MSM, and you again!!!

[@josepha.r5839]

@@DEonaraR Yep! Me!!

[@RRR-vi3hs]

But first of all do you condemn the Genocide?

[@IceQueenaliasIQ]

Dude, why would anyone discuss this. It's clear as day that this was illegal, terrorism, an act of war, you name it. So why would anyone discuss this? There is no doubt about anything.

[@josepha.r5839]

@@IceQueenaliasIQ Don't deny that for any second.

[@damham5689]

Does it matter if its legal or not when the US and others blindly protect lsrael no matter what?

[@jonlenihan4798]

Allah is telling you something. Take the hint.

[@happymelon7129]

relatively, Putin is kind

[@happymelon7129]

if this is doing the right thing, then Putin must be doing too little to defend his country.

[@johannamacrae3067]

This terrorist attack is "self defense" in your opinion? Wow.

[@ardeneberly4450]

GEneva Convention IV, Article 51, section 7: 7. The presence or movements of the civilian population or individual civilians shall not be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations, in particular in attempts to shield military objectives from attacks or to shield, favour or impede military operations.

[@SincerelyYoursAK74]

Another deflection like every other "Unbiased" comment here, still doesn't change the fact Israel joined the terrorist club.

[@HomeFromFarAway]

this is a very valid comment

[@SincerelyYoursAK74]

​@@HomeFromFarAway Is that why the headquarters for most of your military operations and branches are buried in civilian populations?

[@HomeFromFarAway]

@@SincerelyYoursAK74 my previous reply went missing. I am not American or Israeli. I think ziomism is a cu|t. but the leadership on any side of any war is accountable for their actions and the law matters.

[@Ghost-Dna]

3:06 would you use this excuse to excuse Russian crimes?

[@Muhammad-muskim]

When your own mobile device goes Allah akbar..

[@valkyreve]

🤣😶‍🌫

[@RPSartre01]

It's indiscriminate murder - of course it's illegal.

[@AldrianCG]

Let me guess, if Israel does it.

[@MendeMaria-ej8bf]

It shouldn't be questionable but regarded as terrorist acts in the row of daily war crimes. If it weren't Israel with their extraordinary rights to self-defense it wouldn't even be discussed.

[@imakedookie]

right, if any other country or group were to commit an identical crime, there would be a riot. but israel does it and they are above criticism and question

[@MendeMaria-ej8bf]

@@imakedookie We are in sync. Thank you for consent. ❤

[@TheCaniblcat]

Because the CIA, MI5 or KGB never blew up an electronic device before.

[@daviddzebisashvili]

What a liar 😡

[@mtherlihy]

Isn't this a form of terrorism?

[@theklienfour]

no

[@SeniorPanda79]

Attacking terrorists is terrorism? But when terrorists attacking civilians you be silent? You never use your brain?

[@mtherlihy]

​@@theklienfour setting off thousands of small explosives in civilian areas? If someone walked into a grocery store and detonated their pager themselves what would you call it?

[@SeniorPanda79]

@@mtherlihy Hezbollah are not civilians 🙄

[@derwolfpack3599]

@@mtherlihy Chance. I know the same guys who hold hostages, and regularly hide behind woman and children, are not crying now. O, yes you are.

[@samjaytv5674]

Western media always defend what pls them

[@ZePovinhofilosofo]

Legality? Who supposed to enforce the law? UN? 😅😅😅😅😅

[@derwolfpack3599]

Legality? The same people who hold hostages and hide behind woman and children dare to speak of legality?

[@RRR-vi3hs]

The Justice league ofc.

[@jackbleiham8475]

WE enforce it because WE can, but nobody can enforce it on us or on our friends

[@ryuuguu01]

The member state of the UN and signatories of the international treaties are supposed to enforce the law nad the treaties.

[@derwolfpack3599]

@@ryuuguu01 Right. Law. You can not have a strait face.

[@happymelon7129]

Pandora's box open by the west. This mean they should be happy, if they received the same "gifttttt ". These gifttt may flow to open market and on airplane, let that sink in.

[@SincerelyYoursAK74]

This is 100% a breach of International Humanitarian Law.

[@tomhenry897]

What about when the Palestinians murdered Israeli children

[@HomeFromFarAway]

@@tomhenry897 both sides have evil leaders. both sides are allowing this

[@nuqwestr]

Urban warfare with enemy hiding among civilians does not have the same "proportionality" standard as a battlefield with both sides in uniform.

[@IreneOldakowski-x6c]

Is this Israel's warning to the World ?

[@zen1647]

Audio was absolutely terrible. Was any check done before this segment was filmed? Very amateur.

[@mauriciokreisler2868]

It is an WAR !!! IT IS NOT AN CANDY PARTY !!!!!!!

[@albertoserrano67]

Funny it wasnt said when Oct 7th happened 😂

[@albertoserrano67]

Wasn't said when o c t 7 happened 😂

[@Lynette.usa.]

Since when does Israel care about International Law or People?

[@Elo-hv3fw]

1933 !!!!

[@Elo-hv3fw]

1945 ?

[@Lynette.usa.]

@@Elo-hv3fw SS Liberty 1967 ring a bell? You should Google it.

[@user-unfound33]

Pagers are a no-go but drones are fine?

[@robertmusil5831]

Well I'm no lawyer but who among us does not recall with breathless admiration that "stunning display of intelligence and technical ingenuity" shown during the IRA's audacious letter-bombing campaign in London in the 1970s. The precise targeting and sophisticated tradecraft of this strategy involved literally addressing the explosive ordnance to the intended target and co-opting the Royal Mail as a trojan horse to deliver the device through the target's front door. Yes, regrettably British noncombatants were also drawn into the fray as unavoidable collateral damage. But hey. You know what they say about the fine art of omelette-making...

[@RRR-vi3hs]

Excactly 😂

[@IceQueenaliasIQ]

Golden comment right here.

[@rchas1023]

Causing unnecessary mutilation or maiming ....

[@rockbutcher]

'unnecessary'? Is there such a thing as 'necessary' in war? War sucks. This was the most precisely targeted attack we've seen since this whole round kicked off.

[@rchas1023]

@@rockbutcher Research the definition of war crimes.

[@blitzrumble2956]

What is the poster on the wall behind the guest speaker?

[@Sherluck93]

The whole vocal line is amazing! Performace wise, JK is the center, syncing them. Jin is damn stable and dependable. Jimin give the special touch. V is a natural with depth. They are all equally amazing and compliment each other perfectly!

[@sharokha.h.6774]

After a year an unbiased interview in DW.

[@johannamacrae3067]

Look at the man smirking. No. How many times must the Dr Schwarz attempt to explain to you that it is not legal because there was no control of who was killed or grievously injured around the exploding pager. Two children were killed. Where is your humanity?

[@blitzrumble2956]

So called 'international law's is not realistic and impossible to be recognized. This expert is a dreamer.

[@JanBruunAndersen]

There is no such thing as international law. At best, there are mutual agreements.

[@DEonaraR]

I am not buying a new phone, because obviously there is no warranty! (Google don't ban my comment).

[@FreddyKrueger007]

Venezuela 🇻🇪 support Palestine 🇵🇸 USA 🇺🇸 support Israel 🇮🇱 Venezuela🗿 USA🤡

[@rockbutcher]

Venezuela 🤣

[@mikicerise6250]

Thanks for that Mr Krueger. You should know, though, you stopped being scary after the second film.🤣

[@labandonaldhock80]

Most people in Lebanon do not know much about nor did they join Hezbollah. You kill an Ambassador???!!!! Germany has lost its marbles.

[@nuqwestr]

Hezbollah is a political party in Lebanon, they directly control parts of the country, including the Beirut-Rafic Hariri International Airport. They "do know".

[@Chaos-94]

I don't think Germany ever had their marbles in the furst place.

[@FreddyKrueger007]

This is just wrong

[@despicable_bit]

If they were experts, they would know already the Israeli actions are illegal; no question.

[@derwolfpack3599]

So is hostage taking.

[@DEonaraR]

​@@derwolfpack3599. By definition israeli are prisioners of war, since all serve in the army.

[@nuqwestr]

@@derwolfpack3599 so is R@pe and T@rture, charged by the ICC against Sinwar.

[@Annonymm]

Why always asking the lawyers that support the own opinion? Most lawyers support Israel’s actions in being rightful.

[@kevinjenner9502]

“Rise to Kill First:The Secret History of Israel’s Targeted Assassinations”. By Ronen Bergman

[@adriennefried5368]

R Bergman is another 5th Columnist...not a legitimate voice of Israels majority.

[@JyR-v4ozxcvbnm]

So now the human rights are interested because Israel is involved. How about the hostages did human rights and Red cross even bother to Gaza to investigate and see into their conditions and their rights.

[@Elo-hv3fw]

The sound was recorded in Dachau.

[@suwirwong]

So hisnoballah sending missiles blindly into populated areas and killing innocents sounds ok to you? Speaking of war crime

[@dwirajesh]

Experts should discuss the legality of channels like dw

[@worldupdatechannelinfocus110]

You will never see animals right when it's the opposite 😮😮

[@HomeFromFarAway]

PLEASE run a sound check for non-frontline interviews? this was so garbled even on a good speaker. I pity anyone trying to listen on an average or phone speaker

[@happymelon7129]

if this is doing the right thing, then Putin must be doing too little to defend his country.

[@FreddyKrueger007]

🇨🇳🇵🇸🇨🇳🇵🇸🇨🇳🇵🇸

[@kimsoon6927]

Was this recorded on a Gameboy?

[@guilhermereis9520]

2024 and this guy has the worse microfone possible....

[@tomhenry897]

Have him explain October 7 when the Palestinians murdered Israeli children And the thousands of rockets fired at Israel by the Palestinians

[@ryuuguu01]

Are you going to explain the thousands of children killed by Israel and the tens of thousands of munitions fired into Gaza? Will you explain the 700,000 Israeli war criminals in East Jerusalem and the West Bank?

[@mikicerise6250]

Looks like it's that time again. Roll your eyes at Europe everybody. 🙄🙄

[@JosephHoggang-bk4bk]

Everything is fair in love and war. This saying is true.

[@nuqwestr]

"Science is the belief in the ignorance of experts" - Richard Feynman Feynman famously challenged the experts regarding the Challenger "o-ring" disaster.

[@Ratryggva1090]

Has Israel ever claimed responsibility? Whatever happened to das land der denker?

[@ResolverResolver]

The cause and foundation of the problem is italy and France Paris,Rome,Napolitano,Napoli,America,Rome,Taranto,Torino,Sardegna?'';;

[@nuqwestr]

why the constant incoherent posting, cut and paste?

[@abigailkannai484]

You've got to be nuts

[@arlenreinstein9907]

Nicaragua.....a model regime😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@DEonaraR]

Not commited Geno twice, at least 😅

[@azizsakr5565]

Extremely silly discussion.. every Israeli attack brings casualities between civilians.. every attack of them is an act of terror. Has the moderator heard of Gaza??

[@guilhermereis9520]

Israel going full circle into biblical age tribe behaviour.

[@ResolverResolver]

GOD bless Lebanon,Glory to Lebanon in jesus mighty name Amen """""

[@jpi28602]

Lebanon was great in the early 1970s…spent several summers in that Mediterranean paradise.

[@MD-bu3xc]

Terrible audio from guest.

[@niteexplorer9934]

Can’t understand him

[@MR-op3mo]

Experts make me yawn. 😂

[@SincerelyYoursAK74]

All the comments and defenders of this terrorist attack have something in common. Like they all have the same credibility at stake. 🤔🤔🤔

[@ЮлианГуруев]

So if you are not terrorist you, your family and those who around you are fine. Just don’t be terrorist, clear massage from Israel. 100% support to Israel.

[@SorbusAucubaria]

Israel seems to define every gazan as terrorist, I am pretty sure they are quite fluid in their definition of terrorist. they seem to think anyone who they dont like as terrorist.

[@jan_darysh]

Why is Germany suspected?😅

[@Elo-hv3fw]

Oct. 7th are exactly those very special circumstances that justify the use of any electronic devices. By the way, are not almost all weapons equipped with some electronic device.

[@j-k-j]

💪 🇮🇱

[@Roonasaur]

This literally has to be the most precise, accurate military strike in history. This guy needs to eat a pager.

[@rowredround7206]

Here you go DW, presenting Russian talking points again.

[@jackbleiham8475]

Does DW not like Ru$$ia ?

[@nycgweed]

Was what they did on October 7 humane? So now u talk legality? Dw a joke

[@beatlesleo]

Líbano october 7 ? @NIMAL

[@ryuuguu01]

Were the 700,000 Israeli war criminals in east Jerusalem and the West Bank before Oct 7th legal?

[@kamleshkushwah4895]

So called experts 😂😂😂😂😂😂