Huntahang Ligal: Papaano nga ba nag-umpisa ang matagal na isyu ng Pilipinas at Malaysia sa Sabah?

Kamakailan ay muling pinag-usapan ang isyu sa teritoryo ng Sabah sa pagitan ng Pilipinas at Malaysia.
Ano ang kasaysayan ng usaping ito at saang bansa ba talaga kabilang ang Sabah? Panoorin ang aming panayam kay Engr. Abraham Idjirani, ang spokesperson at secretary general ng Sulu Sultanate.
Subscribe to our official KZbin channel, / untvnewsandrescue .
Be the first to know about the latest updates on COVID-19 pandemic, lockdowns, community quarantine, new normal, and Serbisyong Bayanihan.
We Serve the People. We Give Glory To God!
#LagingHandaPH #UNTVNewsandRescue #COVID19PH
For news update, visit: www.untvweb.com/news/
Check out our official social media accounts:
/ untvnewsrescue
/ untvnewsrescue
/ untvnewsandrescue
Instagram account - @untvnewsrescue
Feel free to share but do not re-upload.

[@deborahrondez582]

Ang Sabah noong dekada 70 nakasaad yan sa mapa ng Pilipinas, napag-aralan pa namin yan. At ang pangalan nyan North Borneo.

[@dannybarcenas9701]

Actually 1960 Mapa ng Pinas kasama ang Sabah

[@emanyellazuli8828]

30 Years ago elementary p ako nakikita ko na ang Sabah sa Mapa ng Philipinas Ano pinag sasabi nya ...

[@kanortv739]

Nang umupo si cory. Geatai na daun ang tanan

[@sportsactiontv8353]

@@kanortv739 ma.o gyud😂

[@joeyleegamer8938]

@@kanortv739 sabi ni sec carlos pinatanggal daw ni cory yan s amapa ng pilipinas to honor the friendship with malaysia ,, wala talgng matinong utak

[@rebeccabook1773]

Cristal clear that Sabah belongs to the Philippines...

[@garry5oh]

The people living in Sabah have two options to choose from; 1. They can relocate to Sarawak or return to peninsular Malaysia and retain their Malaysian citizenship, 2. They can remain in Sabah and be affiliated with the Sultanate of Sulu and choose Philippine citizenship.

[@pacitaturanodano7920]

For your information Sarawak is including the claim of sulu sultanate.

[@klemarcorsino3422]

Kinnam... agtagalog ka no pilipino ka! wag Kang mag English Kong ka parehas mong Filipino ang kausap mo...

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

If they don't choose neither of the options you give but stay on in Sabah and be part of Malaysia, what are you going to do?

[@wilsonmiraflor2654]

Sana po mabawi na ng Pilipinas ang saba para po mapalaya ang mga pilipino na nakakulong doon.

[@nildanilda7226]

Atin ang sabah.kunin natin.rain.or shine

[@persia7262]

Philippines should give Sultanate Special Region ang sulu, so that they can govern their own. It may be good to sulu sultanate as Philippines Special Royal Province of Sulu...

[@hoemervaldellon4802]

...

[@maharlikanotv8849]

Sultanate of Sulu talaga ang nagmamay-ari nyan at hindi Malaysian .. pabor din ako na Sultanate of Sulu din ang mangasiwa sa SABAH dahil sila ang may karapatan dyan kasi nagbuwis ng buhay ang mga kamag anak ni Sultan Kiram sa lugar na yan ..

[@neliobello449]

@@maharlikanotv8849 Sultan Kiram is the legit owner of Sabah as per documents. We Filipinos should unite to help him( Sultan Kiram) Christians and Muslims are true brothers, it is in history in time of late Macapagal and Magsaysay. All Sultanate of Mindanao should unite in claiming Sabah .

[@TRL-lz7ed]

pederalismo.

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

@@neliobello449 , "...as per documents...". Which documents? The most vital document was the "the document of transfer" of eastern part of Sabah from Brunei Sultan to Sulu Sultan, signed by both Sultans. There was none.

[@naturesoidat1194]

ang sabah kasama din yan sa OCT 01-4 torence land title na isyon yata noong 1776 na pag mamay ari ng tagean tallano family kaya sa pinas yan

[@luckystrike1156]

Correction your honor. Ang titulong yan ay ini issue ng Royal Crown of England sa Royal Family ng Ragean Tallano clan noong January 17, 1764.

[@pacitaturanodano7920]

Tama

[@felipeorcasitas1973]

dapat wag tigilan yang pag ankin ng sabah.

[@jxbayer3372]

Parang awa nyo na. Ibalik nyo po ang dapat sa atin. Ubos na Yung mga gubat dito kaka loging nila. Alam Kasi nila na hndi sakanila kaya kinakalbo na nila ang ibang part Ng mga claim natin.

[@kyrieeleisoncabido5739]

Talaga po ba nasa sabah po ba kayo

[@jxbayer3372]

@@kyrieeleisoncabido5739 oo nandito ako ngayon.

[@lahingkayumanggi]

Kaya nga po malakas ang Labán ng pilipinas dahil sa dokomento at ancient map atin ang Sabah.

[@jxbayer3372]

@@lahingkayumanggi ᜆᜋ ᜃ ᜃᜉᜆᜒᜇ᜔

[@garizonmann1284]

Ang logging concessions dyan ay pinada dala sa bri tania

[@game.com_ebinggo713]

Ang dapat habulin dyan yong britesh comp. Para magkaalaman na. Yon dapat ang managot sa mga pilipino.sela ang dahilan kaya nagkaganyan ngayon .

[@yuekadere]

Grade4 po ako 1970 laging naka lagay sa mapa ng pilipinas ang North Borneo ... mga libro ng mga Diosdado Macapagal napirma.... mga Filipino po mga educators/ mentors sa lugar na yan supervisors/ etc....

[@pacitaturanodano7920]

Tama

[@jus4getLovv]

Sultan of Brunei gave Sabah to Sultan of Sulu as a gift. British Co. leased Sabah and mistakenly hand it over to Malaysia. So check all the documents and facts! Sabah belongs to the Philippine!

[@bluesky.believeitornot.1882]

One and more nonsense by illegal Filippinos..Sabah is in Malaysia.Not Philippines,Look up in any world map. The only thing Philippines has in Sabah are your illegal "Filippinos" loitering in Sabah.Looking for Malaysian citizenship. We Sabahan do not speak a word or your filippinos language. We speak our own native language which has nothing to do with filippinos.. If we speak and have our own native language for hundreds or probably thousands of years ago where could there be any filippinos influence and involvement in Sabah.period.

[@ApriFoat]

@@bluesky.believeitornot.1882 they why is your government paying for the lease lol 😂

[@ApriFoat]

@@bluesky.believeitornot.1882 honor the arbitration rule, without honor that's haram!

[@bluesky.believeitornot.1882]

@@ApriFoat I'm pretty sure you're unaware that Sultanate of Sulu was a pirate who kidnapped the people of Brunei,Sabahan and filippinos and sold the as slaves to Jolo Island. Yet you're willing to forget that and praise him as a victim. You forgot about those filippinos that became his victims that he kidnapped and sold as slaves and never every seen they're family after being kidnapped by the pirate that you call Sultanate of Sulu.

[@ApriFoat]

@@bluesky.believeitornot.1882 prove it to the court lol, honor the arbitrary rule 😂 you're just stating hearsay.

[@animelover-sx8hv]

Sa ating yang Sabah Wala silang karapatang angkinin oh kunin Yan.....

[@jjsv03]

Sabah belongs to the Sultanate of Sulu.

[@zahira0]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@zahira0]

@sky Flakes mak kau hijau🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jerrygodinez3294]

To make specific... Sabah belongs to the Sultanate of Sulu and not the Philippines or Malaysia after the Philippines successfully claimed Sabah, for sure the Sultanates of Sulu and Other Claimants will then ask the Philippine government to get back again Sabah as it owned by them and declared as an independent state.

[@zamiziz]

kahkahakahkahkahklah

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

Never.

[@tenangfokus6832]

For what ever reason Sabah joined Malaya and became Malaysia. That already happened Sabah joined Malaya . Sabah was not given to Malaya. Malaysian Government did not neglect Sabahan. Malaysian Government built University, Schools, Government Hospitals, government clinics, roads, Mosque, several airports In Sabah, libraries and several Government offices. All these are for the Sabahan. Malaysian Government lend textbook for the Primary and Secondary pupils and the pupils no need to buy textbook every year. The Malaysian Government gave money to the Primary and Secondary pupils when they started schooling in the beginning of the year. It's to help the parents to buy school uniform, bags, exercise books, stationery etc . The Malaysian Government also help the people with some money to ease their burden every year. The government clinics and hospitals only take RM1 from the patient who come for checkup and take their medicine. The school pupils don't pay their school fee . The fee is free. That's Malaysia

[@marcelobonifacio5232]

Dapat maghanda na tayong sakupin yan. Palakasin natin ang ating militar. Habang maaga pa at konti pa lang ang papulasyon nila. Kayang kaya natin sila. Sarap yan tayuan ng SM, Jollibee Mercury drug, Palawan Express you name it. Kailangan natin yang teritoryo na yan dahil lumalaki ang papulasyon natin wala masama dun dahil atin naman yan. Alam yun ng Malasiya na mapapasatin yan balang araw.

[@randypablo3062]

Forget it, di na makukuha yan. Mas moderno armas ng Nalaysia kaysa sa atin, noong pangulo si FM, nagpahayag ang Britain na tutulungan nila ang Malaysia

[@willycubelo6999]

magtatayo ng PHILHEALTH doon si General Morales ang head at mga abogadong aso hindi na bilyon-bilyon ang makurakot- doon trilyon na.

[@ErwinM888]

Mas maunlad Ang Sabah kaysa Mindanao. Ayaw din taga Sabah sa Pilipinas Kasi grabe Ang corruption sa Pilipinas. Masaya na sila sa ilalim ng Malaysia. Pagdating sa healthcare system, kung magpa check up ka sa public hospital, 1 ringgit ( 12 Pesos) lng Ang bayad mo, check up tsaka gamot na yan...

[@willycubelo6999]

@@ErwinM888 Noon nadestino ako sa Basilan isinama ako ng aking kaibigan na Yakan, a barter goods trader , I Have been jn Sandakan and Kota Kinabalu, the places are progressive. I had met many Filipinos Musliims and Christians gusto n[la doon na manirahan, they don't like Marcos dictatorship a corrupt government and many Martial Law victims , according to them they are enjoy to live there far from their own country. Nakita ko ang kanilang military well-equipped.

[@willycubelo6999]

@@ErwinM888 Noon nadestino ako sa Basilan isinama ako ng aking kaibigan na Yakan, a barter goods trader , I Have been jn Sandakan and Kota Kinabalu, the places are progressive. I had met many Filipinos Muslims and Christians gusto n[la doon na manirahan, they don't like Marcos dictatorship a corrupt government and many Martial Law victims , according to them they are enjoy to live there far from their own country. Nakita ko ang kanilang military well-equipped.

[@maximinasinsay1009]

Strike while the iron is hot...let us insist, be aggresive, steadfast and witty for the glory of the Philippines. We have royal blood, the Maharlikan people...

[@DThinkTalker]

Correct I agree..

[@jus4getLovv]

Maharlika is PHILIPPINES and it includes North Borneo now called Sabah!

[@maharlikanotv8849]

Tama !! Ipaglaban natin kung anong totoong pag-aari ng Pilipinas at Sultanate of Sulu .. wag tayong susuko

[@pacitaturanodano7920]

True we are a MAHARLIKAN not pilipino.

[@henzjosephgandiongco5342]

Dapat lng kunin Ang sabah ng pinas

[@joelguadalupe4334]

May sabah sa rizal park buong pilipinas yon

[@agapitouy4311]

How can Malaysia manipulate it's illegal claim on Sabah which belong to the Philippines.

[@Pexman-hu7zw]

Sana rin po bigyan ng katarungan ung mga Filipino Muslim Brothers na hinatulan ng Malaysian Government ng kamatayan noong 2013 noong nagkakainitan sa SABAH ,so walang basehan ang pag takda nilang kamatayan kasi SABAh is not part of Malaysia di po ba?

[@nikkilogan7726]

Sabah is, and always will be, Philippines 🇵🇭 Now it's time for Filipinos to claim whats truly is ours. Let's all be thankful for the Sultanate of Sulu for fighting our own rights & territory. Sabah, welcome to the Philippines!!! 🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🥰🥰

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

After 1 year, has Sabah become part of the Philippines?

[@mildredortega7210]

Nag elementary pa ako 1970s tawag yan north borneo at sa pilipinas ang may ari

[@RobertoSantos-bh3yd]

Sarap manood at pag-aralan ng old history..

[@cesariojacob4820]

Hi po mga Ser si Ang Pagka Intinde ko po sa Pagpapaliwanag po ay Sa Atin ang SABAH NANG DAHIL SA MGA SULTAN’s Ng N Br; & Sulu Phil;

[@m.e.p.b.]

So very informative. Any follow-up on this? 1 year ago na pala ang video na ito.

[@freddiepahilagao5360]

Sultan Bolkiah is the relatives of Late Sultan Mohammad Pulalon sultanate of sulu archepilago let's coordinate to Sultan Bolkiah and see the history at Phil museum

[@vennbagalso9216]

How Malaysia (Malaya) formed without the knowledge of the Philippines & Indonesia: On 31 August 1963, North Borneo attained self-government. The idea for the formation of a union of the former British colonies, namely, Malaya, Singapore, Sarawak (Indonesia) and North Borneo (Philippines) was mooted as early as the late 19th century, but it was Tunku Abdul Rahman who officially announced the proposal of wider federation in May 1961. It also seemed that this idea was supported by the British.[40] There was a call for complete independence on that date by it was denied by the British Governor who remained in power until Malaysia Day.[41] In 1962, the Cobbold Commission was set up to determine whether the people of Sabah and Sarawak favoured the proposed union. The commission had found that the union was generally favoured by the people but wanted certain terms and conditions incorporated to safeguard the interest of the people. The commission had also noted some opposition from the people but decided that such opposition was minor (especially without knowledge of the Philippines & Indonesia) what was going on). The Commission published its report on 1 August 1962 and had made several recommendations. Unlike in Singapore, however, no referendum was ever conducted in Sabah.[42] Most ethnic community leaders of Sabah, namely, Mustapha representing the Muslims, Donald Stephens representing the non-Muslim natives, and Khoo Siak Chew representing the Chinese, would eventually support the formation. An agreement was signed by Tunku Abdul Rahman, Harold Macmillan, the British Prime Minister, and William Goode, the last Governor of North Borneo, signed on behalf of the territory on 1 August 1962 putting to paper the agreement to form the union. The intention had been to form Malaysia on 31 August 1963 but due to objections from the Philippines and Indonesia, the formation had to be postponed to 16 September 1963. At that point North Borneo, as Sabah, was united with Malaya, Sarawak and Singapore, to form Malaysia.[43][44] To safeguard the interest of North Borneo in the new federation, a 20-point agreement was entered into between the federal and the state government. (How about the lease to the Philippines?).

[@philippinespremativeskills1337]

Dati sa lumang mapa yan sir kaso noong umopo si cory nawala na sa mapa. Dati mapa nati luzon visayas mindanao Sabah philippines piro noong huli nawala na.

[@danilobandong6901]

Nku po! Dun po k u tumingin s mapa s luneta nandun po ang sabah., ktunayan po n stin ang sabah☺️

[@ss9hagonoytaguigcps29]

SABAH(North Borneo) is not included in Malaysia it is part of Sultanate of Sulu (Philippines) ever since before they become independent from British. Like SINGAPORE is part of Malaysia and separated from Malaysia on 1965 while Sabah has distance of 1,011 miles from Kuala Lumpur but still they are claiming this part own by Sultanate of Sulu (Philippines). Meanwhile the distance of Sabah from Manila is only 683 miles.

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

The distance between a territory to the capital city of a country has nothing to do with it's sovereignty. There is an Indonesian island called Miangas which is 2,552 km from Jakarta and 1,177 km from Manila. That island is still part of Indonesia, not part of the Philippines.

[@kinofrias8616]

SABAH IS NOT IN MALAYSIA SABAH IS FILIPINAS MALAYSIA TENANT ONLY RENTING OUR HOMELAND MALAYSIA PLS LEAVE OUR HOMELAND!!!

[@zahira0]

😂😂😂😂

[@felixoliveros1317]

KAya dapat I pursue na natin ang paghahabol it's about time to asked UN to resolved this issue.

[@kinofrias8616]

@@felixoliveros1317 korek dami natin doon sa sabah..70'/, pinoy tausog bajau iranun visaya samal..starting lng kulang doon pagnasindihan un matik un liliyab un kc alam na nila di sila papabayaan ng governo at sinusoportahan sila.

[@leahchwa47]

But the Devil doesnt want to hear the truth and transparency!

[@williamjunior4924]

hello again everyone, i'm one of local natives live in sabah since my forefather thousands of years ago and is proven by historian expert and also proven by scientist they have proof about existence the earliest ETHNIC LIVES AT SABAH BEFORE YOUR SULU IS KADAZAN, DUSUN AND MURUT..!!! I want say is sabah belong to the true sabahan local natives lives here and sabah always belong to malaysia. The true landgrabber here is philipines and your sulu... if any of you people from philipines or your sulu try to invade my birthplace/homeland then i will say this and marks my words, I WILL GLADLY PUT MY LIFE THE ON LINE TO DEFENSE MY BIRTHPLACE/HOMELAND FROM YOU PEOPLE THE TRUE LANDGRABBER FROM PHILIPINES AND YOUR SULU.!!!! JUST BECAUSE SABAH CLOSE TO PHILIPINES, THAT DOESN'T MEAN SABAH BELONG TO PHILIPINES... i know you people will say we have document and paper.. bla bla bla bla bla... Your beloved secretary teodoro locsin jr already lose at UN, PBB and UK all denied teodoro claim.. even the very FIRST SULTANATE OF BRUNEI UNTIL NOW still denied your sulu claim... why you people are so stupid can't face the truth.. i only say this once, sabah always belong to MALAYSIA not PHILIPINES...!!!!

[@haberitomanalo9671]

for the information of all filipinos north borneo (sabah) is part & parcel of phil territory as mentioned in our present constitution, therefor our country has legal claim over this region !

[@willycubelo6999]

We won WPS by UNCLOS but China insist the so-called 9- line, we claim Sabah historically rights, nothing was happen.Diplomatic protest is still not valid most part of the world .Cao Bang and other territories occupied by China, But Vietnam attack swiftly leaving more than 200,000 dead and undetermined wounded number of Chinese casualty.

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

The Philippines claims Sabah on the basis that Sabah was once under Sulu. Sulu only claimed that Sabah was under Sulu because Brunei gave Sabah to Sulu as a gift for purportedly helping Brunei fight rebels. But Brunei refuted this claim and denied ever having given Sabah to Sulu. There was NO DOCUMENT regarding the transfer of ownership of Sabah from Brunei to Sulu signed by both Sultans. You can claim and put any island around Philippines like Guam and even Hawaii in your constitution. But you cannot enforce it to other countries.

[@kyrieeleisoncabido5739]

Malinaw na malinaw na ang ssultan of sulo at bahagi ng pilipinas ang sabah

[@christophermarmeto2920]

Sana kakausapin ang gobyerno ng Borneo at sila ang magoaliwanag na nuon panahun nayun nayan north Borneo binigay o niregalo ng Borneo

[@lahingkayumanggi]

Correct kaya Lang mahirap talaga na makialam ang Borneo dahil usapang ancient years yan.

[@arielenriquez3643]

Aalamin ko muna ang Concerns at Comments ng mga Genuine Natives O Tribals ng Sabah",,, Kung Gusto talaga nilang Mapabilang sa Pilipinas?? ",, O kung Kaninong Bansa ba Sa Palagay Nila' sila Kabilang",,

[@melodyromero2624]

nakita ko n comments nila mga sabahans, they dont like to be Filipino citizens, pro king ako sknila kung ayaw nila, pack up na sila at pumunta na sa KL. at mga kapatod na Tausug ang dapat tumira dun..

[@ranzrogelsumbillo9826]

gawing Parliament ang Pilipinas at iabolished ang Senado.with Federal State named State of Luzon Visayas, Mindanao, Sabah. gawing Ministry instead of Department ang katawagan maging ang Prime Minister. gawing Opisyal na Relihiyon ang Islam at Kristiyanismo sa Pilipinas!

[@maharlikanotv8849]

Mas legit kasi kung ISLAM na lang religion natin kasi Malaya pa Tayo noon .. at yan ang religion ni LAPU LAPU at kay Magellan mananakop naman ang Kristiyanismo ..

[@greenlantern2820]

Marami po tayung old map sa Skul at inabutan kopa 1980 na Ang north Boneo ay kasama sa map ng pinas paulit ulit pinapadrawing ng teacher namin noon Yan...

[@ronalyntapasao6098]

Malaysia only renting inly Sabah..There is agreement of British company,but they connt handle the Sabah so they sell to their leasse to other British company,,thats why they mention 5,300 mixican gold..the legal council of Sultanate has all the documents..

[@sinarmentari1443]

Other of the history ??? 😁

[@baderbader5943]

Meron sa mapa ng pilipinas ang sabah

[@markgarcellano1913]

Oo maalala ko until year1998 kung tama pa ang pagka alala ko mga local map noon kasama ang sabah doon sa local map ng pilipinas.....

[@ernestopobladormosquera6336]

Continues always watching again and again and again in 3 x a day all in 24 hours watching again and again in all watching again and again 11.7+ million numbers Pilipinos migrants working abroad international professional job watching again and again.....

[@code77141]

Ang Gustu namin malan Kung kailan ma i babablik Ang Sabah sa pilipinas ,,

[@PAGTATAGera]

Can we call it Borneo instead of Sabah?

[@anthonylim8865]

Very touchy issue 😓

[@hopelope1703]

Philippines claim on North Borneo based solely on historical and legal rights is very dubious without any evidence. First, Sultan Sulu claimed Sultan Brunei gave North Borneo to Sulu as a gift in assisting Brunei’s civil war is without any proof. Earliest historian like Sir Stamford Raffles (History of Java) in 1830 said it is only a claim. The agreement between Sultan Brunei and British North Borneo Company (BNBC) on 29 December 1877 which is 3 weeks earlier than the agreement between Sultan Sulu (22 January 1878) and BNBC show that North Borneo was still belongs to Brunei. The onus is on Philippines to proof it otherwise. Second, on 22nd July 1878, Sultan Sulu relinquished his sovereignty on Sulu Archipelago and its dependencies thereof to Spain (Bases of Peace and Capitulation agreement). On the same day, Sultan Sulu wrote to Governor General of Philippines and Governor of Sulu terminating the agreement (22 January 1878 agreement) between Sulu Sultanate and BNBC. The agreement between Sultan Sulu and BNBC on 22nd January 1878 is null and void. Thus, issues whether it is a rent or cession and translation either in English or Tausug is no more valid. On 24th July 1878, Governor of Sulu wrote to BNBC concerning the Spanish sovereignty on Sulu and its dependencies including North Borneo and the termination of the 1878 agreement. Governor General of Philippines wrote a letter on the same matter dated 20th August 1878 to the Spanish Government in Madrid. The issue was later raised by Spain with the British Government. Finally, the issue on the agreement between Sultan Sulu and BNBC and the status of North Borneo was settled through the Madrid Protocol (7th March 1885). North Borneo belongs to the British under this Protocol. Again, on the 25th November 1957, the latter Sultanate of Sulu declared termination of the lease between Sulu and BNBC effective on 22 January 1958. Thus, the agreement is null and void twice. Third, there is no such agreement between Malaysia with the Sultan Sulu nor Philippines on renting and payment on North Borneo. The 22nd January 1878 agreement is only between Sultan Sulu and BNBC. Any dispute between parties need to refer to the Majesty’s Consul General in Brunei as stated in the agreement but there is nothing in the record. Earlier the British (before formation of Malaysia) also do not have such an agreement. You pay when there is an agreement. It was only a gift from Malaysia after the Manila Accord meeting 1963 as requested by Philippines Government to cool down the situation. That is why the amount is ridiculously small in Malaysian dollar and not Mexican Gold Dollar used during that era (1878). Surprisingly, on 12 February 1989, Sultan Mohammad Jamalul Kiram III revoked the resolution of 1962 regarding the transfer of title and sovereignty to the Republic of the Philippines. Thus Philippines is no more a legit claimant to Sabah. There is a court case in ICJ record pertaining to the Philippines claims to North Borneo. A special 37 page report by ICJ was published in 2001 and easily accessible from the ICJ official website. It was a trial within a trial in the court case between Malaysia and Indonesia on the ownership of the islands of Sipadan and Ligitan. During the trial, Philippines which is not a party to the trial requested permission to intervene. To comply to Article 62 of the Statute of Court, Philippines stated 3 objects for the intervention namely to safeguard and preserve Philippines historical and legal rights over North Borneo, to inform the court the affect or effect of the court outcomes on its claim to the territories and on the procedural issues in the court. After deliberation, the court found the first 2 objectives are appropriate. Later Philippines lawyers explained their case and provide documentation especially the Sulu-Ovenbeck 1878 agreement and related information to the court. On 23 October 2001, by 14 to 1 vote, the court rejected the Philippines request on the ground that there is no interest of legal nature. Notwithstanding the recognition by UN on the formation of Malaysia in 1963 and this ICJ decision, Philippines still continue pursuing the claim. It is of no issue and need not be entertained.

[@hopelope1703]

British North Borneo Company (BNBC) signed 2 agreements with the Sultan of Brunei and Sultan of Sulu on 29 December 1877 and 22 January 1878 over the territory of North Borneo respectively. Thus, Sulu claims on North Borneo was given by Brunei as a gift is unfounded. On 22nd July 1878, Sultan Sulu relinquished his sovereignty on Sulu Archipelago and its dependencies thereof to Spain in Bases of Peace and Capitulation Agreement. The agreement by Sulu with BNBC on 22 January 1878 is null and void based on his majesty termination letters dated 22 July 1878 to the Governor of Sulu and Governor General of Philippines who later forwarded it to BNBC and Spanish government in Madrid respectively. Later this whole episode is override by the Madrid Protocol 1885. Regarding the rent, it is ludicrous to be considered as there is nonexistence of any agreement between Sulu/Philippines with Malaysia on the matter. Even when Malaysia stops giving money to Sulu since 2013, no legal process been taken until now. It is only a gift as the amount is ridiculously small. One dollar (Mexican gold dollar) has a weight of 1.7 grams of gold. For 5300 dollars has a weight of 9.01 kg of gold. Compare the value of 5300 Malaysia dollars to 9 kg of gold. Furthermore, rent you pay in full. The above documents are kept either in Public Record Office in London or General Archives in Madrid. It can also be accessible from the Philippines official website with Spanish to English translation.

[@amadeoelguira7015]

LEASE WAS BEING GIVEN TO SULTAN AS PAYMENT FOR RENT FROM OVERBECK THE ENGLISH CO. TO DEVELOP THE REGION. SO THE SULTAN AGREED.

[@edrianbobbycalabio]

Give Sabah back to the rightful owner, the Sultanate of Sulu.

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

Sulu only claimed that Sabah was given to Brunei to Sulu as a gift for purportedly helping Brunei fight rebels. But Brunei refuted this claim and denied ever having given Sabah to Sulu. There was NO DOCUMENT regarding the transfer of ownership of Sabah from Brunei to Sulu signed by both Sultans.

[@luburan1973]

Portugal returned Macau. United Kingdom returned Hong Kong. That is the precedent.

[@ronmcraig9157]

Philippine Maps before , showed borneo in our maps not as part but never disregarding its appearance to show the land...

[@fujiwarakatsumi2529]

British Government is to blame. International laws and arbitration must be respected of all government. Let Sabah declare merdeka with Sarawak they both deserve sovereignty over there lands.

[@Cyberoll]

Dapat may English version ng ganitong conversation

[@producebl1016]

meron nman yung Rappler, kaso baka mastress ka sa super bias nila hahahaha wag na

[@eunesanzano9040]

I love yo hear SABAH now

[@wesmids04lo41]

Mabuhay pi

[@tobeimisa6965]

meron po nasa luneta

[@aliciaortega481]

Noong 1970 High School Po ako mayroong mapa sa school Namin na Kasama Ang mapa ng Borneo sa mapa ng Pilipinas. Maghanap Po kayo , mayroong Po sa mga lumang libro ng Pilipinas sa panahon ni Apo Lakay. Salamat Po.

[@bebotestomo8594]

100billion budget para makoha ang sabah

[@arnelmanalo5934]

totoo? san mo nakuha yan?😂

[@twinkletoe02]

malaysia and indonesia settled their borders thru the courts. So should the Philippines and Malaysia because war does not change the facts.

[@minho1148]

In 1898, under the Treaty of Paris, Spain sold the Philippines to the United States. The treaty boundaries allegedly did not include Sabah...by that, sulu sultan lost his kingdom..no more sultan, only scamer sultan..any agrement no longger valid...

[@sanariosanario5028]

Dapat kasi yang tinutoro sa paaralan sa mga student para malaman ang history sa sabah dahil importanti malaman ng mga sambayanan pilipino

[@amorromero3618]

Kaso ang itinuturo bayani si Ninoy

[@apoloniopasajr5677]

Dapat nong ibinigay na ng araw na yun isinama sana sa mapa ng Pilipinas khit nirenta ng Malaysia, pra malaman nila na bahagi tlaga ng Pilipinas ang Sabah. Sa school dpat itinuturo na pra lahat ng babasa alam na sa Pilipinas yan. Nag rent lang cla, meaning sa Pilipinas pa rin at included dpat sa mapa. Sana no problem at madali lang ma-claim.

[@laurencegalit6566]

May pagsasamantala sa part ng Malaysia at Britain.

[@Gog_Magog179]

Malaysians dont know they are still colony.

[@christinebets2646]

What’s up with the background music is for?

[@herbertpayson]

Ancient maps support the Philippines' claim over Scarborough and Sabah (Ancient Spanish maps feature Panatoc (Panatag) or Bajo de Masinloc off the coast of Zambales). That includes SABAH FYI!

[@shaakir_tv]

Alhamdulillah 🤲🤲🤲... Sabah Philippines punyA.. lah

[@Cloud-er6yg]

Yes, yes ang North Borneo(/Sabah tday) ay nasa libro namin sa elementary.

[@taufikabdullah3666]

sa amin itong Sabah dahil nandito na kami kayo mag claim palang

[@wellsimple8375]

present that to malaysia as a proof that sabah belongs to philippines

[@leonardoamores2949]

Bogus na paguusap sila sila lang kaya may intention. Ang Malaysia.

[@amadeoelguira7015]

SABAH BELONG TO THE SULTANATE AS GIFT FROM BRUNIE IN HELPING THE SULTAN OF BRUNIE DRIVING OUT ENEMIES TOGETHER.

[@danielpalomares5418]

WE HAVE TO TAKE WHAT IS OURS . NO MATTER WHAT

[@patriciobechayda6296]

Kung titingnan Po ninyo Ang mapa Ng Pilipinas nong mga 1968 grade one lang Po Ako noon,Ang North Borneo na tinatawag na Ngayon na Sabah ay Kasama sa teretoryo Ng Pilipinas.

[@dilinglintasan652]

Ang sa agreement ng sabah ay Can not be transfer to other nation without the concern of sulu majesty pakatapos sabihin cession paano yon...?

[@gregoriolamayo9994]

Atty. Early 50's kasama yang N Borneo sa maps at SI JP Rizal galing dito sa Ponot Zamboanga gusto Nia pumunta sa Borneol. Noong 1956 natandaan ko pa sa poster ng league of 100 nation na may flag bawat nation at may maps kasama Ang N Borneo. And after several yrs ginawa itong United Nation at alam nio ba na may 10 k hec reservation sa league of 100 nation?

[@musangxplorer1290]

Malinaw na illegal ang pagkakalipat sa Malaysia, at talagang walang karapatan ang Malaysia sa North Borneo........

[@reginowaga2598]

mapapasa atin lang yang kapag nalimas na nila lahat ng oil or mineral resources jan, etc

[@ravenli3807]

Philippines flag 🇵🇭 soon to rise in sabah

[@tiffanyjanecantuba9565]

Nasa lumang mapa po kasama yan inabutan ko pa yon

[@markeller2787]

I think makasarili ang mga presedente noon at mooron p d sila nag iisip para sa future Ng bansa kundi sa future lng nila except Marcos...

[@mhadzzung8945]

Ang tanong jan ano naman ang agreement nang sultanate at pilipinas kong sakali maibalik ang sabah? Baka mg muka lang kawawa ang sultanate of sulu👋👋👋

[@lahingkayumanggi]

Di nmn lalaban ang sultanate of sulu if wala silang documents na kanila yan. Check of ancient map Sabah is part of the Philippines.

[@maharlikanotv8849]

Sultanate of Sulu ang legit na nagmamay-ari nyan at sa kanya dapat ang pagpapalakad dyan .. in-shaa-allah

[@joeyleegamer8938]

bakit ang ingay ng tunog nagsasalita si sir eh.

[@norodinlucman3358]

The 1964 UN-sponsored Referendum favored the Federation of Malaysia as Sabahan voted for inclusion into the new state. Pres. Sukarno denounced the UN Referendum and declared Ganjang Malaysia! (Crush Malaysia!) The war was short-lived. The borders between Kalimantan and North Borneo were settled. Did the Philippines go to war? No. It went on the diplomatic offensive through Maphilindo, SEATO, and the UN, despite losing two islands in Davao Gulf to the Indonesians, and Sipadan island to the Malaysians. In the event, the Malaysians and the United Kingdom were unfazed. They stood their ground. Aside from the popular vote of Sabahans rejecting Philippine sovereignty through Referendum, it referred to an article in the Philippine Constitution banning the Sultanates of Mindanao and Sulu, aside from multiple claimants to the throne.. The Philipines never made an effort to abrogate the 1935 article on Royal titles. (Art 6. Sec 31) The only solution is for the Philippines to go to war. But on what grounds?

[@luburan1973]

meron ba na bilihan na tuloy tuloy Ang bayad? Aba Renta/upa yon.

[@DThinkTalker]

Dalhin na uli sa korte. Or war can only be the last option

[@arsenioella917]

Sabah rightfully belongs to the Philippines!

[@dds4911]

“Wala sa drawing ?!?” … parang ang mga islets ng mga higanteng bansa wala din naman sa mainlands nila ?!?

[@gecko1131]

Nasa Mapa yan ng Pilipinas, makikita mo sa Old/Ancient Philippines Map. Kasama lagi ang North Borneo

[@sharemetv4967]

Noong pong elementary ako nasa mapa ng pilipnas ang sabah

[@charlespadamada5979]

Mababawi ba??

[@aldizchannel2820]

Ang tanong kong ang mga tausug magclaim ng sabah kasama ang pinas baka ang maninirahan dun puro naman taga luzon at visayas dapat pagusapan mona baka matulad din sa mindanao ponadahalan ng taga luzon visayas ang mindanao....

[@Simba_LJ917]

aldiz channel Oi marami rin po Muslim sa Manila, Luzon at Visayas. basta Filipino ka, anuman religion, Welcome ka saan man lupalop ng Pilipinas.

[@estoyvlog5163]

Ndi nman lahat nkatira sa mindanao ay muslim lng may mga ibang tribu rin na nativo sa bawat lugar

[@klimatbgt]

bitin ang video

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

The Philippines claims Sabah on the basis that Sabah was said to be once under Sulu Sultanate. Descendants of former Sultan of Sulu claim that Sabah belonged to Sulu Sultanate because Sabah was given by Brunei the original owner to Sulu as a gift for purportedly helping Brunei to fight rebels. But Brunei refuted this claim and denied ever having given Sabah to Sulu. There was NO DOCUMENT regarding the transfer of ownership of Sabah from Brunei to Sulu signed by both Sultans. In fact on 29 December 1877, the Sultan of Brunei ceded the whole of Sabah to BNBC/British and concurrently appointed Baron Von Overback, the co-owner of BNBC as Maharajah of Sabah and Rajah of Sandakan and Gaya. This cession agreement was documented. When BNBC went to Sabah to begin their business, Sulu claimed that Sabah belonged to Sulu. BNBC agreed to enter a "pajak" agreement with Sulu after they were advised by their fellow businessmen in Hong Kong who advised that Sulu would attack them if they didn't have a deal with Sulu. This "pajak'' agreement was signed on 22 January 1878. BNBC understood that this "pajak" was a "cession", so did early generation of Sulu Sultan accepted it as "cession". Only later generation of descendants of former Sultan of Sulu claimed that the "pajak" agreement was meant to be "rent" or "lease''. Still there was NO DOCUMENT regarding the transfer of ownership of Sabah from Brunei to Sulu signed by both Sultans. The two above events led to an overlapping issue on Sabah. What ever it was, the above agreement and overlapping issue were superceded by later event. On 22 July 1878, the then Sultan of Sulu had relinquished all his possession and sovereignty of Sulu and it's territories including Sabah to Spain. The Sultanate of Sulu only remained as hereditary cultural and traditional entity without any sovereign territory. In 1885, to resolve overlapping issue on Sabah and other issues involving other islands, Britain, Spain and Germany arrived to an agreement known as Madrid Protocol in which Spain surrendered Sabah to Britain. As new owner of Sabah Britain had full control and sovereignty over Sabah and they could do what ever they wanted. Sulu could not claim anything because they had already relinquished the sovereignty of Sabah to Spain and Spain surrendered Sabah to Britain. What ever happened to Sabah after that was under British jurisdiction. Even though British had full control and sovereignty of Sabah, they still honoured the annual "cession money" payment stipulated in the "pajak'' agreement as consolation for the Sulu Sultan. So did Malaysia when formed in 1963, still honoured the annual "cession money" payment as consolation for the Sulu Sultan. The term "cession money" was used because to use the term "consolation" was felt to be too degrading. Thus the term "cession money" was continually used as used before by the British. Even the argument about the word "pajak" and it's meaning in the "pajak" agreement still favoured the British. The "pajak" agreement was written in classical Malay, in jawi script (Arabic alphabet). Malay is the national language of Malaysia and Brunei, and mother tongue of majority Malaysians and Brunei. In those days, Malay was also used by people of Sulu because Malay was the "lingua franca" of this region including the present Philippines. That was why the agreement was written in Malay. But over the years Sulu people had lost their Malay language (standard Malay) because of several reasons like colonisation by different European. This made Sulu relied on translation of the agreement. Things got worse when they translated it to Sulu's local language, be it Tagalog or Tausug, which was rather translation of another translation, that they translated it to their favour. The word "pajak" carried several meanings depending on the contact used in the sentence or passage. It could mean "tax, rent, pawn, lease, or cession". In the agreement between BNBC/ British and Sulu, the word "pajak" was used together with the phrase "selama-lamanya" which meant "forever". When "pajak" was used together with the phrase"selama-lamanya", in this contact the word "pajak" meant "cession". Cession means "the formal giving up of rights, property or territory by a state". When Sulu "pajak" Sabah to BNBC it meant Sulu ceded Sabah and it meant Sabah no longer belonged to Sulu. This was further clarified. There was a second agreement which was a supplementary to the first agreement known as "Confirmation of Cession of Certain Islands Agreement". It was regarding certain islands between Sabah and Sulu which they were not sure whether they were included in the first agreement or not. In this second agreement, the word "pajak" was no longer used because they thought it might lead to misunderstanding by later generation. Instead the word "menyerahkan" which meant "surrender" was used, and the annual payment was increased from 5,000 dollars to 5,300 dollars due to certain islands included. Another example where the Philippines generally or Sulu in particular misunderstood due to wrong translation or translation to their favour, was about the clause that the territory could not be transfered to another party. Yes, there was a clause that Sabah could not be transfered to another party "... without the consent of 'Duli Queen'...". The British translated "Duli Queen" as "Her Britannic Majesty", even though it was not correct literally but it was correct in the meaning. The "... Queen" was referring to Queen Victoria, the ruler of England / Britain at that time. But Sulu translated "Duli Queen" (or rather translated from a translation) as "Their Majesties' Government". This led to an understanding that "Duli Queen" was the ruler of Sulu. The question was since when Sulu as a Muslim state had a female as their ruler (Sultanah or Queen)? The above showed that North Borneo (Sabah) had indeed been ceded to Britain, that was why it could not be transfered to another party without the consent of 'Duli Queen' (Queen Victoria), the ruler of England/ Britain at that time. And further it was stated that any dispute about the agreement had to be referred to the "Consul General" being the Queen's representative in Borneo to be resolved. It meant that outside Arbitrator had no jurisdiction over the agreement. This fact became the main reason of judgement by Paris Court of Appeal in setting aside and annulling the Paris Court (lower court) ruling awarding the heirs of the defunct Sulu Sultanate. On 31 August 1963 Britain gave independence to Sabah and before that on 22 July 1963 Sarawak was given independence. The people of Sabah and Sarawak had exercised self determination to form Malaysia together with Malaya and Singapore. The sovereignty of Sabah and Sarawak as component states of Malaysia is intact and recognized internationally and recognized by the UN. This was confirmed and clearly stated in the United Nations Malaysia Mission Report "Final Conclusion of the Secretary-General", 14 September 1963. The last sentence of the report says: "I fervently hope that the people of these territories will achieve progress and prosperity, and find their fulfillment as component states of Malaysia". Full text of the report can even be accessed from the Philippines Government Gazette website. About the arbitration award by Paris Court to Sulu of US$14.92B, it had since been set aside and annulled by Paris Court of Appeal. Here is the latest situation. Latest as in June 2023: 1. June 6th - Paris Court of Appeal had set aside and annulled the previous Paris Court (lower court) ruling awarding the heirs of the defunct Sulu Sultanate. 2. June 27th - Dutch Court of Appeal in The Haque had dismissed a bid by eight descendants of former Sultan of Sulu to enforce the arbitration award by Paris Court (lower court) ruling, and dismissed an attempt to seize Malaysian assets following the Paris Court of Appeal decision. 3. Paris Court of Appeal also imposed on Sulu €100,000.00 (Euro currency) to be paid to Malaysia as legal cost. 4. Mean while in Luxembourg, a second attempt to seize Malaysian Petronas assets had been filed in Luxembourg Court due for hearing in September 2023 after the first attempt was dismissed. This will likely be dismissed too following the Paris Court of Appeal decision. Now is already December 2023, no news about Sulu's claim proceeding in Luxembourg Court. It looked like they withdrew their case when they acknowledged the Paris Court of Appeal decision. Malaysia had spent around RM32m, equivalent to about US$6.6m to deal with these Sulu claim cases in various European courts, in Madrid, Paris, Luxembourg and Netherlands. Apart from the €100,000.00 Sulu has to pay to Malaysia as legal cost, Malaysia is planning to sue Sulu for compensation for the loss of RM32m (USD6.6m) spent.

[@jhaybryannorberte8402]

Mas maganda pa yan dugtungan naten ng lupang daanan naten papunta sa ating sabah Philippines at biyaya na saten yan?

[@hopelope1703]

Any pro Sulu or PH claims on North Borneo, their primal source of reference will be the Sulu and British North Borneo Company (BNBC) agreement dated 22 January 1878. In this agreement, Sulu “lease” North Borneo to BNBC (Tausug version) while the English version is “grant and cede”. This information will easily be cherry picked in any of their discussion or debate. But what they will not revealed are those that can refute their claim. The followings are few of the information that had been kept secret: Firstly, the agreement between Sultan Brunei and BNBC on 29 December 1877 over North Borneo which is 3 weeks earlier than the agreement between Sultan Sulu and BNBC (22 January 1878). This will deny that North Borneo was a gift to Sulu from Brunei. Secondly, on 22nd July 1878, Sultan Sulu relinquished his sovereignty on Sulu Archipelago and its dependencies thereof to Spain (Bases of Peace and Capitulation agreement). Thirdly, on the same day, 22 July 1878, Sultan Sulu wrote to Governor General of Philippines and Governor of Sulu terminating the 22/1/1878 agreement between Sulu Sultanate and BNBC. Thus, the agreement is null and void. Fourthly, on 24th July 1878, Governor of Sulu wrote to BNBC concerning the Spanish sovereignty on Sulu and its dependencies including North Borneo and the termination of the 1878 agreement. Fifthly, Governor General of Philippines wrote a letter on the same matter dated 20th August 1878 to the Spanish Government in Madrid. Sixthly, Finally, the issues on the agreement between Sultan Sulu and BNBC and the status of North Borneo was settled through the Madrid Protocol (7th March 1885). North Borneo belongs to the British under this Protocol. The above documents are kept either in Public Record Office in London or General Archives in Madrid. It can also be accessible from the Philippines official website with Spanish to English translation. In addition, during the US colonization of PH, 2 agreements (Carter 1899 and Carpenter 1915) were signed by the Sultanate of Sulu which relinquished its temporal sovereignty of Sulu and its dependencies. Later, the 1930 Anglo-US border agreement acknowledge the boundary delimitation between PH and North Borneo that belongs to the British.

[@jellybeluga8369]

SA AKLAT NAMIN NOONG AKOY GRDE 4 1964 KASAMA PA ANG SABAH SA MAPA NG PILIPINAS.

[@renatosuga4091]

Paano ka naging abogado kung di mo alam yan.

[@dromasoc]

so its 5300 mexican gold not mexican dollar. then later it converts to 5300 MR...

[@amadeoelguira7015]

SABAH BELONGS TO THE PHILS. THERE IS REALITY AND FACTS TO PRESENT IN INTERNATIONAL LAW IF THERE ARE ARBITRATION. FROM HOW THIS SABAH EXISTENCE.

[@joelaujero5896]

That is idiotic and self-serving statement on the part of malaysia to assert 'cession'. That is evidently stupid. No right thinking person who is in his sound mind would do it.

[@abdulwahidmdtahir3660]

The one who is stupid is YOU. The agreement between Sulu and NBCC was written in classical Malay (Malay is my mother tongue), in jawi script (Arabic alphabet). In the agreement the term "pajak" was used. The word " pajak" could mean "rent, tax, lease or cede" depending on the contact in the sentence. The word "pajak" was used together with the phrase "selama-lamanya" which meant "forever" and the phrase "selagi ada bulan dan bintang" which meant "as long as there are a moon and stars". So in this contact the term "pajak" meant "cede" or "cession". To clarify this further there was a supplementary agreement to the first agreement known as "confirmation of cession of certain islands" regarding the status of certain islands between Sabah and Sulu to be included in the "cession" agreement. In this supplementary agreement the term "pajak" was no longer used because it might lead to misunderstanding by later generation. Instead the term "menyerahkan" which meant "surrender" was used. And the annual payment was increased from 5000 dollars to 5300 dollars because of the additional islands were included.

[@romelcollins5247]

@@abdulwahidmdtahir3660 agree.

[@SurinaJabaliah]

May regulasyon ba ang pag papa upa ng isang bansa saang mng panig ng mundo?..kahit nga mag binta at mag bili ng lupa ay elegal...ganon din ang pag papa upa,..sana may responsabilidad kayong makatao mn lamng,...

[@armandolacaba3670]

May chance ba talaga na maibalik sa atin ang Sabah Sir?

[@ihoiha4063]

Ang tanong mababawi pa ba yan. Sinong presidente kaya makakabawi jan.