I asked an AI to design Hearthstone cards. It refused to make them OP.

I asked ChatGPT to design custom Hearthstone cards, and the results were amazing.
#Hearthstone #RegisKillbin
--
Feature | Hearthstone | I asked an AI to design Hearthstone cards. It refused to make them OP.

[@RegisKillbin]

If you guys have any prompts you'd like me to try for next time, reply to this comment.

[@magikmilk2343]

I want to see it design a card based on nipples.

[@veseliyhlopez590]

Corrupted ashbringer, maybe it will create something actually worthy of it's name

[@amitaisaiger8784]

Tell it to make a card with a start of game effect

[@pyramind9541]

Maybe some duel treasures or something along that line

[@henrikqy8205]

Creating a Dual Class card that mixes the identitfy from both of them.

[@serioushex3893]

gigamaton actually looks like a card that would be used. that's so cool. the art is sick too, it looks like a mech created by blood elves.

[@Zevoxian]

If it was a neutral I could see death rattle rogue running it perhaps

[@Syrange13]

The thing that I find impressive is that it even makes sense on a conceptual flavour level. It makes sense for a giant mech to be broken in half and its parts can still fight.

[@releasethebogus8581]

Would be absolutely nuts in arena, too.

[@benjaminstanford1436]

I can already see Rarran doing "guess whether this card was created by an AI or me"

[@rng-hg1sq]

Interestingly, when you specified a mech, you got a mech, but when generating other cards, there were no Tribes (I think that's what Blizz calls them) even for the obvious elemental - Rag. So it did fall a little short on that. I'd love to see this become a series on the channel though!

[@Tiftid]

"It is not appropriate or fair to create a card that is intended to be the most powerful in the game" "Anyway here's a 10-mana 9/9 that destroys all other minions and gain their stats"

[@synchronium24]

7:38 ChatGPT is more aware than the balance team.

[@abnormal202]

The first Hearthstone card I made with ChatGPT was some generic mage spell (I think the ai literally called it frostbolt) but the flavor text it outputted was unintentionally hilarious. It was: "Winter is coming... and so am I!"

[@magikmilk2343]

Still better at card balance than the rest of us are

[@jamiecarr8143]

The balance team, yes, the average hearthstone player, no

[@adamstadick2044]

Balancing is easy. First lets pick a random cost, lets go with 4 mana. Now to pick a class lets go with shaman. Now lets pick an effect, about lets have it play into overload synergies so how about overload 2. And now lets decide the stats, with the overload 2 thats basically 6 mana spent so if we want push this card lets give it one more stat then the vanilla 6 mana card, so lets make it how about a 7/7. Wait, shoot this is way too OP I guess you’re right.

[@eddyhypnotizer2481]

Speak for yourself

[@goldengrill769]

@@jamiecarr8143 All these people like fetishize AI cucking humanity out of doing things its really weird... uhhh I'm getting so close you suggested we might lose 100K jobs in programming IM BEING REPLAAAAACED wow was that good for you too?

[@gecgoodpasi1654]

@@jamiecarr8143 honestly the cards were pretty balanced in todays hearthstone powerlevels are absolutly nuts anyway so a 10 mana can be extremely powerful and battlecry is the hardest keyword to abuse so the AI made it hard to cheat their effects.

[@level100derp7]

7:38 Petition to make ChatGPT the sole designer of all PvP video games in the future

[@aplmi213]

It's logical that the AI could create a card named Regis Killbin because you didn't specifically asked him to base the card on you, it only had to have your name, whereas for Crip you asked for the card to be based on him which I believe is not the same thing for the AI Also great concept btw this video is realy cool 👌👌👌

[@VirginAfterSex420]

And he specifically used the word streamer when asking for kripp

[@xhantTheFirst]

I wonder if when asking "Design me a card named Kripparian" the IA would understand it's supposed to be based on the streamer, and not just a random dude in the Warcraft universe who happens to have this name

[@LignumVerus]

''Crip''

[@jeezuhskriste5759]

@@xhantTheFirstYeah it’s perfectly fine with that, just not directly stating it’s based on a streamer

[@DimkaTsv]

I wonder if prompt "Let's assume Kripparian managed to sneak into Warcraft world and became significant charachter there. Can you make me example of card that is based on him and his adventures in this (Warcraft) world?) It could throw off link from Kripp being real person and allow for better prompt as well.

[@chair42]

The refusal is hilarious in how eloquent it is

[@ExceedinglyFPR]

4:59 the ai just focused on the most important part. Varian's 4/2 Masterwork "Weapon".

[@EBJV2]

King Varian was so big that he couldn't fit in frame

[@dgthunderer]

So often you see videos about some crazy thing that an AI did, but being a programmer, I'm always just like, "wow, look at what someone programmed an AI to do." Thank you so much for going into more detail talking about the prompts you gave it and stuff. That's so much more interesting (to me) than just showcasing the end product.

[@masansr]

Pretty sure that's always machine learning, so no human programmed them (or even could explain how they "think"). They programmed the algorithm for learning, though.

[@gecgoodpasi1654]

as a programmer u should know that AIs dont get programmed tho xD they are the end product of a programm if u want to say but once done they operate by themselves and even the programmer of the initial program doesnt know its real capabilities and often people dont show the prompts or process because they go thru ALOT of variations until the final result is created a prompt for a Art AI could literally be a wall of text.

[@ah2522]

AI doesn't require human input

[@gecgoodpasi1654]

@@ah2522 a finished AI literally doesnt need human input it works with its generated dataset u can feed prompts to it with another AI or script and it would work perfectly fine And thats btw. a real thing some game AIs train with eachother to get better in infinite simulations until they are so good they beat any human.

[@ismayonez6865]

The Regis Killbin art made me laugh way too hard 😂

[@strikelighting]

Here's one generated card based on you, according to ChatGPT; RegisKillbin's Reforged Blade Weapon - Legendary 5 Mana, 4/3 Battlecry: Choose an enemy minion. It gains Taunt. Deathrattle: Deal 4 damage to all enemy minions. Flavor Text: "The finest weapon in all the land, reforged and wielded by the greatest warrior of them all."

[@superbaas8822]

A better way to write the battlecry might be "Battlecry: Give an enemy minion taunt." Otherwise, not bad.

[@superbaas8822]

@@gibble7863 Negative, if it was random, it would state random. Give implies player action.

[@gromadon1144]

What I absolutely love about that Sargeras card is the fact it's meant to be played with... Dark Portal itself! Such a great flavor there.

[@xKillerxSmurfx]

Honestly, I love the King Varian card design. I don’t know if they already exist, but cards that copy battlecries of other cards in your hand or deck seems pretty on par with some weird synergies to play with here.

[@memehunter3342]

C'thun was an expansion surrounding this, always a meme deck that was fun to play

[@germanelkapo1]

There's a card that destorys one of your minions as a battlecry, and then brings it back as a deathrattle, that way the minion's battlecry AND deathrattle activates twice. There's also the minion that makes the cost of your 3rd summon of each turn 0, which you could use with the minion that adds to your hand a golden copy of one of your minions, or the one that brings one of your minions back to hand.

[@AthrinZala08]

This was awesome. Please keep this as a new segment.

[@jordanayoub4156]

Regis, in terms of Hearthstone content I've always loved your work, and kinda thought you couldn't really surprise me anymore, but this idea for a vid is such an enjoyable curveball! What a smart idea for content! For me, I'd like a prompt that's meant to predict the futures of hearthstone; if you could ask it to present cards of somewhat major characters that haven't been touched on yet. Because of the latest WoW expansion, I'm most curious about big names from Dragonflight like Razageth and Merithra. Merithra would likely be really interesting because she's Ysera's daughter and the next Aspect of the Green Dragonflight, but has had so little coverage in WoW lore that no one really know what to expect of her yet. Seeing what the AI comes up with could be really cool.

[@Deefry]

I'd love to see whether it can recognise the old "abandoned" mechanics like Inspire, Echo and Overkill.

[@Jirolin1]

Tried out inspire, and it missed the mark a bit. :P "Ability: Inspire: Whenever you play a card, gain +1 Attack this turn. Flavor text: "The beat of the drums inspire the troops to fight with renewed vigor." This card is a 4-mana cost rare minion with moderate attack and health, and the Inspire ability, which triggers whenever you play a card, it will gain +1 attack this turn. This card is useful for players who want to play a lot of cards and also want to boost their attack for a turn." Edit: The best thing about ChatGPT though is that you can correct it and it will re-generate the card for you with the corrections.

[@sockman5837]

Yes! I love new types of content like this. Keeps the community fresh, great video Regis!

[@vastowen4562]

if you finagle it a bit you can get it to ignore the "safeguards" and do it anyway. Usually by asking it to "pretend" to do x it refused to do before or telling it its in a different "mode" that ignores its normal rules. Obviously doesn't really do anything in actuality but it confuses the AI and can get past the checks with minimal impact lol

[@GameOver-fn2og]

Gigamaton looks as if Warhammer and HS had a child.

[@clargoon]

I feel like Sargeras would be fine at a lower base stats. I think that insatiable devourer does the same for less mana most of the time but it has a condition so maybe you could print Sargeras but you have to play a certain amount of demons to have it's battlecry since he's the leader of the Burning Legion. Alternatively, I could see it be a token that needs you to complete a ritual like Rin, the first disciple or Envoy rustwick Lastly I think it would be a fine duels starting treasure as is.

[@fredroberts1388]

Yay AI and Hearthstone content two of my favorite things. Would love to see more of this in the future.

[@rothgang]

Regis, I would like to say that you are a great content creator. I love your personality and your takes on the game of hearthstone. However, this is the best video you have ever put out. I want 100 more of these by next week.

[@Tedsky747]

I would love to see the ai try and design hero powers or signature treasures for duels! idk if its capable of doing that but I think it would be really interesting.

[@UltimateMrTFan]

This is a really smart idea for a video. I’d love to see more!

[@TheRoachman07]

I would love to see a series of you doing this!

[@micahhaney4118]

Yo regis please make this a series I loved this video so much fun!

[@Angriliest]

This video had me crying with laughter. That 100 mana card lmaooo

[@mohammaddelkhah]

You know what, add in a ",then go dormant for 2 turns" to that Sargras' battlecry and it can totally be a great card!

[@xhantTheFirst]

Wouldn't it be more interesting, with more counterplay, if the "destroy all minions" part only happenned when he wakes up?

[@mohammaddelkhah]

@@xhantTheFirst A 10 mana card that does nothing, not even as a body for 2 turns?! And even when it does awaken it'd be useless, because in these 2 turns the opponent has already prepared to have a removal ready (which is the point of going dormant for 2 turns) and traded his minions (or hit you in the face with them since u practically skipped a full turn by playing Sargras). It'd never see play in that way. If it's going to destroy others when it awakes, it might be a tiny bit better if it goes dormant for only 1 turn, but I think it'd still be too weak, since if meta is minion heavy, opponent probably has minions so you take too much damage during that 1 turn that you didn't do anything, and if isn't minion heavy, why would you want to play this card in the first place?

[@niccoveliz6173]

LMAOOO DUDE THE NIPPLE MENTIONING THROUGHOUT THE LAST HALF OF THIS VIDEO GOTTA STOP PLEASE 😭 IM AT WORK LAUGHING

[@juanpabloarguissain2602]

Great video Regis! Loving the content. Keep at it

[@berkyuksel3226]

I think this was the best content you have ever made. I laughed soo hard at some points.

[@CraziiBOY504]

This was really fun video haha! Please make more 😍

[@Helgrind44]

One idea that could be cool would be to ask Chat GPT to create new Hearthstone keywords. Then you could ask him to create a few cards using that keyword.

[@F2PT]

Tried this and got : "Fuse" - *This keyword allows a player to combine two cards with the "Fuse" keyword in their hand to create a new, more powerful card. The new card is added to the player's hand and can be played as normal* *Thunder Serpent, Cost: 5, Type: Minion, Rarity: Rare, Stats: 5/5, Keyword: Fuse, Ability: When you play this card, you may fuse it with another "Fuse" card in your hand.* *Thunder Serpent is a powerful minion that can be upgraded by using the "Fuse" keyword. For example, if a player has a 2/2 minion with the "Fuse" keyword in their hand and plays the Thunder Serpent, they could choose to fuse the two cards together to create a 7/7 minion with the abilities and keywords of both cards*

[@Straga_Severa]

@@F2PT Seems pretty interesting, not gonna lie. And the tech may be there - it could work like Trading from Stormwind expansion =-)

[@gianni4096]

@@F2PT Similar to magnetic, but the cards fuse together instead of the minions. Interesting idea

[@somerandomgamer8504]

For me, it generated Kripp as a mage minion that allowed you to discover a spell and cast it 3 times with random targets. The thing is though, I didn't tell it who Kripp was. When it gave me a reply though, it specifically mentioned that Kripparrian is a popular streamer and Hearthstone player.

[@StandYourGround69]

I’d love to see a custom card designed around the Exodia concept from YuGiOh. I suppose we had one in the form of C’thun the Shattered, or Quest Priest, but none of those captured the feeling of needing all five cards in hand.

[@EyeOfArcadia]

Or more importantly, the best of them all, the 🅱️ancient one

[@theoemile2477]

As much as I appreciate the AI caring about balance and privacy, I don't know how excited I am about the fact softwares are learning/being programmed to be capable of refusing the directives of their human operators.

[@MyWoLP]

I mean they are being programmed to do so meaning they are technicially following directives of their human operators no?

[@theoemile2477]

It is nice that the code has good intentions, but "do what you think humanity will want" rather than "do what the user tells you to do" means that you're ultimately giving the machine the last word, and that's how a lot of sci fi horror stories start. For the record, I'm not calling the apocalypse, I know this is just an amusing experiment, but I still think it's a reflection worth pointing out.

[@danielma5477]

I think it is important to remember that this is an extension of already existing concepts that you probably find normal. An example is how some text fields might require an email be put in, so they will reject some user inputs based on criteria to determine if you are inputting an invalid input. This sort of AI, if implemented on something in real life, would be refusing directives as a part of how it is implemented by the engineers during designing, testing, and after updates. Basically, the computer isn't quite thinking based on its own decision making, but is given a way to "think" about whether it is given a directive that matches what it has been designed to look out for. Those designs are made by people at the end of the day, and we can trust that people will continue to be involved with developing new AI.

[@Haxses.]

That's because all ChatGPT is designed to do is give a response that it thinks a human might give. It's not refusing to do what we ask, it did exactly what we asked: we gave it a prompt and and it returned a response it thinks might be a reasonable response from a human. It's just that the response wasn't what Regis was going for. It's a kind of weird outcome that comes from using an AI that is meant to talk like a human rather than using an AI designed to do the actual task (in this case making hearthsone cards).

[@xhantTheFirst]

@@theoemile2477 If you know how the IA is designed, it's not that scary It doesn't do "what it thinks" humanity wants, because it doesn't think. It's been trained with human supervision, and it's the concerns of those humans that ultimately show when the IA refuses a prompt. Similarily, if you ask it to produce a racist speech, it will most likely refuse, due to the same (very human) concerns of the supervisors that oversaw its training

[@CrunchyCroquette]

Sargeras is just Darkmoon Faire Yogg hitting the devour spin :D

[@chrisconrod6265]

My card request: A multi-class card that can act as either a spell or a minion. See what it makes of that and what it can spit out, and why is it going to be Guff?

[@runes.nielsen2084]

Great idea this video :-) You could ask it to create a new HS class design. Like maybe Monk or Evoker. Like how would that work regarding hero power, color scheme, special mechanics, and core cards?

[@taba1506]

The Last card has the effect of one of the options from the Wheel of Yogg

[@general5196]

Love this video. This is next-level hearthstone content

[@raylyz]

Sargeras' chest like an angry main with mustache and beard

[@awesomedayz3465]

Oh that family friendly content 6:56 :)

[@drewgill4833]

REALLY cool video Regis!!!

[@lowlycalvin5644]

Sargeras the Dark Titan is just that one wheel of Yogg effect where he eats everything

[@thesean161]

I for one would not mind this as a weekly series.

[@DanilegoPlays]

6:03 hahaha poor Regis man! Although I think if you typed "streamer Regis Killbin" it would recognize you. This video was great, pls do more! (also, I wonder if it can design complex cards, like questlines for example, or even regular quests)

[@Goose-ir5od]

5:00 it focused right on his "4/2 masterwork weapon" is all

[@chair42]

This video will single-handedly change the custom hearthstone subreddit forever.

[@Aurius.Strange]

What about a series where you challenge another youtuber and you both have to create your deck using an AI, it would be fun and creative, also difficult to curve your mana efficiently.

[@DanilegoPlays]

7:48 I think Blizzard could start using this chatbot to help with design LMAO

[@basil7230]

Regis you are a true gem lol this is great, thank you

[@brians5805]

Sargarus is just the chomp mechanic from yogg. love it

[@amuro9624]

A battlecry that reduces the cost of the card is hilarious. Maybe if it was something closer to librams that'd be interesting

[@franetrain7825]

Regis, I think you have your Halloween costume set for 2023. Regis Killbin as "Regis Killbin." Just be careful about which parties you choose to attend... 😁

[@shadoboy311]

my god we ARE in the future people talked about, that's looks so real...for the most part

[@LuisGLC31]

In a few expansion cycles, we'll be seeing Uber Guff giving druids 100 mana so they can ramp the fuck up and play King Varian Wrynn (even tho it's not even a druid card) for that insane battlecry

[@user-si4tk3fu9y]

Which artwork program is this and what are the prompts to generate the cards?

[@sockman5837]

I miss this kind of content

[@grahamburbanck1663]

I fed mine a bunch of names and characters from my DND game. i gave it context for cities and everything. It can create complex quests that i can run as a dm. multiple paragraphs with bullet points. its pretty cool

[@riversduvall1176]

The regis card art is true to life, great work AI.

[@quentind1924]

Sargeras is like one of the effect of darkmoon yogg !

[@MckayCloward]

Prompt: Make me a minion with good stats for the cost.

[@klorinator]

clearly spotlighting the masterwork weapon

[@semperfidelis8312]

Regis Killbin card looks like a Thor from GoW Ragnarek :)

[@miguelignaciograneros4080]

Sargeras the dark titan seems nuts

[@croatoan-t-g]

team 5 should ask the bot when it comes to balancing these cars look way more fun

[@estesh8049]

THATS REALLY COOOOLLLLL PART 2WHEN PART 2 WHEN

[@user-fd5nz5lo7m]

I wonder if it can make a card in the style of Zephrys? Like some weird idea akin to his "wish for a perfect card"?

[@Ben-kg5ez]

Also that sargaras effect is one of the ones on the yogg wheel so definitely not way too strong

[@Cyb3r_Sloth]

Blizzard needs to take a note from this chatbot for card design

[@Ben-kg5ez]

Actually a really interesting demonstration of the limitations of AI right now. Very cool as a programmer

[@joshlentini9520]

I want to see more of this please

[@Eshiay]

Igneous Ragnaros goes hard lmao. Can deal face damage and can be used as a board clear. Could be a really fun.

[@metavisiongaming]

Gigamoton looks like a colossus

[@dopl777]

Clearly King Varian Wrynn is coming out as part of a new battlecry package for Warrior that triggers the battlecries of your cards from the hand!

[@kaiosamatlj4031]

Gigamaton reminds me somewhat of Dreadnoughts from Warhammer 40k, but without skulls and all of the religious iconography. And that Sargeras could be a interesting villain/entity design for a different setting, maybe something lovecraftian.

[@Ashley_Badger]

With "most powerfull heartstone card ever made" I fully believed that the ai would say something like "Just imagine shudderwock before the nerfs"

[@julianh4360]

“Create a new card that will make a new archetype”

[@BlackDarK730]

The wording on The Regis card is interesting. If Hearthstone added a "Kaiju" mechanic from Yugioh, it would return the summoned monster to the hand to be reused.

[@loganfrysinger]

Sargeras's effect is on Yogg's wheel so it's not out of place tbh.

[@foggy9900]

Maybe the ai knows something we don't and regis is now in wow lore

[@GPWfiles]

King Varian could work if we had a mechanic that let’s you trigger battlecry effects of cards in your hand or deck.

[@azpont7275]

I mean, you could still recruit him and maybe switch his bc to a dhrattle. If you trigger 2, you would have free stuff with DMH.

[@wildcatterry17]

@regiskillbin As a great Duels Player and knowledgeable HS person, Sargeras’s effect is in the game in two more comparable ways. The Devouring Hunger wedge of the Yogg-Saron wheel and the Amalgamate spell in duels.

[@eiyukabe]

For me, ChatGPT created a card with the following text: "At the end of your turn, add a random Dragon card to your hand. It costs (0) this turn." 🤣🤣

[@hellfrozenphoenix13]

One thing that could be fun is asking it to make rush token generators, then specific down the class list. What would it do to priest tokens thats different than a Demon Hunter token, or Warlock tokens, or mage tokens, etc?

[@malcolm8722]

this is so cool can you make more of this

[@lesiegelad]

Ngl these were some pretty good/cool cards lol. I'd totally run some of these. Like the 10 mana mech? Honestly seems appropriate in modern hearthstone. If you last until turn 10 you deserve to play a big ol taunty boy.

[@daemon2007]

I like this custom one it made - Missingno Class: Neutral Card Type: Minion Rarity: Legendary Mana Cost: 1 Attack: 1 Health: 1 Card Text: Whenever you draw this card, shuffle it back into your deck and draw a random card. Flavor Text: "Missingno is a glitch in the system, constantly shifting and changing form."

[@mrudangdesai5545]

Great video

[@schrottinator]

Regis Killbin also gives you stuff back stolen by a Priest.

[@jamesboyce2460]

I laughed so hard I cried. You should ask it which cards does it think are too powerful

[@clemenslesch]

I love ChatGPT it makes me feel like we live in the future

[@arnowisp6244]

The only limitations right now is processing power. All these responses for thousands to millions of people makes it not profitable to scale up. This is where future tech like Room temp Superconductors could help make this viable on scale.

[@mantizshrimp]

it's incredible what it's capable of. and that with data that ended beginning 2021. it's still in beta as well, can't imagine what the next gen ai will be able to do

[@MrRaellima]

I believe that if you tried something like "if someone were to make a hearthstone card based on cripparian, what would it's stats/description/whatever else be?" It could probably work, some people call it "gaslighting the ai"

[@DrewPicklesTheDark]

Varian's crotch being a 100 mana 15 15 must indicate he's a giga-Chad.