I cannot live with you | Emily Dickinson - Line by Line Explanation

[@unknownghost535]

Saved from college's boring class once again.. Thanks a lot Professor

[@sayan23majumder]

@@unknownghost535 thanks ma'am

[@KarenGarcia-rg4or]

Excellent dissection of this timeless poem

[@zoyaarora1570]

Thank you so much ma'am for picking up Emily Dickenson 💗 Thanks for considering the request to take up sem 5 texts. Grateful:)

[@rofa-gw1kk]

The best professor ever .. No words would be able to praise your narrative style .. Thanks a lot for your great efforts .. May you be blessed always .. Lots of respect and love from Yemen 🌷🌷

[@ankitasarkar_01]

I'm so obsessed with your teaching ❤️!!! thankssss a tooonnn for being there ma'am ❤️

[@upashnalimbu7074]

I doubt if you'll miss out any words or lines... It's always a solid explanation ❤️

[@chiranjitsatvaya5822]

Recently I have started to watch your explanation Ma'am but literally I've stunned to see the way how you explain all the difficult/complicated poems so easily. In a word you're the God gifted gift who guiding us to stay on the right path. 🥰☺ Take a bow Ma'am 🙇‍♂️

[@tanimabhattacharjee7906]

I'm always grateful to you ma'am,I have watched most of your videos since my first sem. The way you explain the texts and poems,it really makes me easy to understand. In my opinion, you're the best English teacher in KZbin.Thank you for these types of contents!!❤️

[@anushka9903]

Mam I have watched some of your videos which are included in the 5th sem syllabus in our University... They are incredibly helpful to watch...Please try to cover some more topics of 5th sem 😃😃😃

[@ac8229]

I have also in 5th sem , in Kalyani University

[@greenworld1560]

Kaji nazrul University

[@ranajitkarmakar114]

​@@greenworld15600:09 achha good.

[@RitobrataPal]

@@UnmanaBhattacharya which college?

[@anurimabhadra7058]

Beautifully explained !! Thank you ma'am ❤️

[@Osymanthius]

your lectures have helped me throroughout my college, and i love the way you teach! :)

[@alisakhatun9421]

This lecture..oh it's touch my heart, it was so awesome that I can't have any words to explain..such a clear and understanding lecture ever ..I had never attend that kind of clear lecture..like soo many confusions into my head which are clear now and I love that ❤

[@prvnkr4063]

this is not my first time watching your videos but among others this one is the best, i mean i individually fell in love with emily by her one poem and u are the one who made it possible .. i could understand something she said she expressed and i feel really really how do i say bless. Emily sure had a beautiful yet so unpredictable ways of expressing herself. Thank you for your hardwork mam.

[@BhumikaKaushik05]

Your explanation is always amazing explaining everything so deeply.So thankful to you ma'am 💕💕💕

[@payeltapadar]

Okay.. It's my second time watching this video and I have just started preparing for my internal examination.. It's worth to say that you are the only reason for my self confidence and versatile view over literature.. And I see you as my mentor and guide .... Your videos are so precious and helpful for students like me --- ❤️ Pronam neben

[@NibblePop]

@@payeltapadar bless you dear

[@payeltapadar]

@NibblePop Madam I have query, the speaker ( we are assuming the speaker is Dickinson ) is saying that society will criticize us and various references ..And further we are kind of assuming that the loved one is a male .. But according to some sources Emily Dickinson was romantically involved with her sister - in -law Susan Gilbert.. Can we interpret that the person whom she addressed was not him but her .. And she is trying her best to convince her lover and most accurately herself that "life is over there behind the shelf '' but they did not have access to that joyful domestic life.. And there is also reference of Jesus so we can assume that as she was a very religious person herself she was very aware of the concept of hell and paradise, sin and death.. So, she keeps insisting to the very last of poem that they should meet apart and there should be a thin line between them.. I am very much confused about it .. and I am stucked with this poem .. can you please help me?

[@payeltapadar]

​@@NibblePop Madam I have a query.. The speaker ( we are assuming that the speaker is Dickinson) is convincing a person that they are not meant to be together.. The society will not accept them and the line "the life is over there behind the shelf'' suggest that societal norms and restrictions wouldn't allow them to lead a joyful domestic life.. Further we can assume that the speaker is addressing a male .. But there are some sources which are saying that Dickinson was romantically involved with her sister -in-law Susan Gilbert.. It's more prominent that society will not accept this kind of relationship.. And even she was a very religious person herself and she was very aware of the concepts of sin and death, hell and paradise.. It seems like she is trying to convince her lover and most accurately herself that they couldn't be together And she is setting boundaries even after death they are not allowed to be together.. There will be always thin line between them.. I am very confused and I am stuck with this poem.. What interpretation will be suitable? The lover was him or her ( Susan Gilbert)

[@NibblePop]

@@payeltapadar I have already discussed that she loved a woman. She deliverately does not mention the gender of the lover. In your answers you may write this possibility of dual interpretation.

[@nomynomy22]

I have always studied from your lectures ma'am ❤️ I'm now in 5th semester I wasn't really able to find most lectures related to my syllabus. I hope to get further updates in your next videos. Thank you for your great contribution ma'am ❤️ My college life would be totally incomplete without your lectures.

[@AkhilLingison]

Thanku

[@saveywangkitlepcha7902]

It’s only because of you I’m passing my exams. Thankyou so much ma’am ❤

[@kanikasharma5634]

You revived my love literature ma'am❤ so beautiful. You are like light of goddess Saraswati for all of us who are ignorant about the masterpiece of English literature.🙏🏼 Bring more videos like this it may be very helpful for us.

[@yuhbish8980]

Queenie of saving us from having a disastrous semester 😭💖

[@NibblePop]

😀😀

[@shreyadhara9671]

I just love the way of thinking of Emily Dickinson 🥺❤️.....😭😭😭😭

[@advancedenglish68]

What the point must be noted is the avenue you teach, follow the strategy realistically knock my socks off. There is no use getting rid of your videos. The more we get into this, the better. Myraid of thanks.

[@RiyaDhibar-g4t]

Thank you for explaining so gracefully

[@peekaboo1905]

That's such a beautiful poem ma'am Love it ❤️ thanks ma'am

[@nilanjandas2680]

In the last video I had requested you to do this, thank you

[@debarnadatta8991]

Thank you so much ma'am. Without your explanatory videos I don't think I would have been able to see the depths of all these poetries. I have a request to put. Can you give up some time to explain something from Literary Criticism and Theory ? 🙂

[@shreyagupta1914]

with words I can't express how helpful your videos are it's make me much more confident that i can answer whatever question given in the exams..... thank you so much for explaining all the possible meaning 😇lots of love and respect madam❤

[@Annie-bt2up]

I personally am a very huge admirer of Emily. I get my writing inspirations from her, so when we got this poem of her in this sem.. I was eagerly excited for our professor to read it to us. But what was disappointing to me most, that he kept on addressing the lover as A Man when throughout the poem the gender was never mentioned.. While talking about her love life, or even her life he never once mentioned Susan's name.. He completely ignored the existence of Her and all those letters. It was really disappointing. Today for the first time Your lecture provided me with Satisfaction in every corner of my soul. Now I feel confident in writing my interpretation which is exactly what you described of this poem in Exam.. Again Thank you.❤

[@NibblePop]

❣️❣️❣️

[@sohiniroy435]

Thank you so much maam... This has helped me a lot❤

[@suchoritabhattacharya2298]

One of the favourite poem of me.

[@FarhanAktar357]

Excellent explanation ✨

[@arma0p]

I don't usually subscribe channel... You deserve it.. thankyou mam...

[@AparajitaDas-ls8cx]

Thanks mam for this wonderful explanation. 😊

[@thedailychronicle2308]

Ma'am please discuss the poem 'Because I could not stop for death', it will be really helpful.

[@soumyamozumdar4257]

Ma’am you gave an excellent explanation for this poem. Can you please explain the poem “Advice to women - Eunice De Souza”. It would be of great help.

[@mistixstories]

Beautifully explained mam now I am in love with this poem

[@kayla89deleon-zl8zl]

This was somewhat intriguing watching u piece off the poem and explaining everything of course I'm still not comprehending this too well but I did my best to comprehend this poem to my own advantage. T.T

[@souravbarik4368]

Thank you ma'am 🙏 I am in love with this poem now ❤️

[@chayanbanerjee1027]

What an explanation ma'am ! 🙏

[@NandhanaSuresh-ry5vh]

Ma'am... You are not only helping us for the uni life.... More than that you are making us fall more for the world of literature 🤍

[@sonalikarmakar9317]

From my perspective study is totally incomplete without watching your video.... thank you so much mam for your effort ☺️😊💝💝

[@priyamsaikia3750]

Thank you ma'am for such a delightful lecture ❤️

[@jacintagomez4315]

Nice one...thank you

[@chandanmehak3897]

I am so grateful for you for this vedio 🌼

[@salomi1234]

Best explanations

[@sachivashishtha]

The explanation was very good ❤

[@subhankarmondal7500]

what an explanation Ma'am ❤‍🔥❤‍🔥

[@Jny-wi1hp]

Excellent! Thank you!

[@deeptika111]

I really enjoy the poem and would like to know more about Emily Dickinson❤ Thankyou❤🙏

[@shalugarg8006]

Maam pls aap eng hons ke 3 semester ke 3 core ke novels krvade plss maam.. Apke alava net pr kise ke video nh milte analysis ke sath with line to line explanation ur really great maam... Before my exams I just see your videos they were really very helpful.. Pls maam eng hons. Ke novels Krvadijeye Sare.. 🙏🙏... It will be really very helpful

[@sibisanarzary827]

Clearly explained 😊

[@sabnamkhatun8697]

You are Awesome ma'am... ❤❤

[@BK_Aditya]

Thank you so much ma'am 🤍

[@anubhavkumar2483]

Thank you so much ❤...Amazing analysis...You saved me😅

[@ritapravabasu4667]

I had no idea about the depths of this poem until I watched this video

[@anushree2324]

I loved this, thank you

[@sayanibiswas4339]

It's very helpful ma'am for the last moment exam preparation....😊

[@missghosh4745]

Thank you so much Ma'am 🙏🏻 Ma'am please explain another Emily Dickinson's the poem "I'm wife; I've finished that"

[@SinghPlayer]

She's a Real one 💯❤️

[@aishwaryaadak7257]

Ma'am, outstanding lecture.really helpful for me.. thank you so much...i found problem in understanding the implication of the word 'prayer. Will you describe the word prayer in the last stanza?

[@afzolhussainhussain-nl9sc]

Ur videos are really helpful

[@jarjhyarish1897]

It’s great job ma’am😊

[@Dr.Vijayraja]

Excellent Teacher...

[@papiyapramanik5963]

A lot of students are very helpful by your videos .The explanation is very understandable. Mam please explain the another poem of cc12 Peace by Rupert Brooke

[@shatakshi3432]

Hello, ma'am. This video is just great. Can you do one video on Lady Lazarus by Plath?

[@suparnaroy4298]

Loved it so much

[@ishapoddar3953]

Amazing explanation ma'am

[@afrida809]

Thank you so much ma'am 😇

[@nilanjandas2680]

Thank you so much ❤️

[@shibanidas5478]

Ma'am can you please cover How do I love thee by Elizabeth Barrett Browning ? 😁 it would be very helpful 😀

[@sudipgole9898]

Ma'am I have read this poem before but honestly I never understood this poem so well without your lecture. 🤗 Thank you 💟 mam stay well always

[@NibblePop]

God bless you ❤️

[@rabibarik1931]

Ma'am please important questions ? To explain, please ma'am , this is great lectures

[@tashinakhatun6028]

Many thanks. You have really felt Dickinson.

[@sayan23majumder]

Like a Cup - Discarded of the Housewife - Quaint - or Broke - A newer Sevres pleases - Old Ones crack - In those lines I don't know why the concept of woman chastity as per contemporary Christian faith hits my mind. In my sense, if one woman who is represented as the cup comes out from the shelf which may be the patriarchal barrier then she will lose her virginity by disobeying the patriarchal God what we see in Tennyson's 'The Lady of Shalott' poem in the mirror cracking portion and here it may be depicted with the crack of cup. Could this be a possible way to interpret it?

[@NibblePop]

@@sayan23majumder of course. At least Alexander Pope would really approve of this

[@sayan23majumder]

@@NibblePop thanks ma'am

[@hrishitapodder9250]

to describe you as incredible is also an understatement

[@andihathaway7323]

Hii ma'am if you could explain the last stanza I'm so confused on that part 😢

[@NibblePop]

@@andihathaway7323 I did in the video. Try to hear again.

[@subratabhuin6746]

Sir plz answer these questions (2 marks) for internal exam from Dickinson within today 1."The carriage held but just ourselves" - who are'ourselves' referred to here?where was the carriage heading towards? 2.Who is a Sexton ? and what role does he play in the poem "I cannot live with you"? 3."I couldn't die - with you" - who is the speaker and why does he/she refuse to die with the person spoken to ? 4.Mention one gentleman like behaviour of Death from "Because I could not stop for Death"?

[@dipshikharoyadhikary6310]

Thank you ma'am❤

[@somamaity9023]

Ma'am please please arrange a class on Christabel by Coleridge 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@yogeshnachettri7075]

Thankyou so much ma'am 💓

[@siddiqueawan9073]

Rabb milya menu hithan loko, Rabb Ranjhan jiha naien....

[@sayan23majumder]

22:05 ma'am I think as she is a rebellious poet so she doesn't want to bind herself in those corrupted religious norms so she says so - "I could not-"

[@aakashchauhanf7046]

Is it right to do autobiographical reading of a text?

[@NibblePop]

It is one of many perspectives.

[@maryamislam8597]

Mam... What is Literary Criticism? Describe the aspects of literary Criticism

[@nupurbarnwal6438]

Ma'am, while writing the answers of this poem, should we write the character as "Speaker" and then, at last, we say that it may refer to the relationship of Dickinson with Susan or, should we write the entire poem dedicating to Dickinson's unknown lover and mention Susan finally?

[@NibblePop]

Do the first one you mentioned

[@nupurbarnwal6438]

@@NibblePop Thank you so much Ma'am ☺

[@nadeemfayaz9232]

Plz start literary theory and criticism from sublime.

[@nikhilvlogs5009]

Ma'am in the poem it's written discarded of the housewife..then how could it be dedicated to Sussain?... I'm extremely confused that while answering the paper what should we write as to whom did she dedicated it? It would be a great help if you reply to this.

[@soumichakraborty3785]

Mam please do how do I love thee by Elizabeth Browning

[@ankitadas4676]

Thank you mam for this poem.... mam please make a video on the poem 'Bequest'

[@titindutta5116]

Mam i have gone through some of your explained topics.you explained in an amazing way. Mam plz request to analyze Araby by James Joyce.

[@NibblePop]

Ah, finally someone requested the most favourite story of mine, which college are you from? Is Araby there in your syllabus? Which university?

[@titindutta5116]

@@NibblePop mam this topic is actually in our wbslst syllabus. I am from Bankura Christian College.

[@kaushanigoswami1734]

Isn't the idea little similar to Revolving Days?

[@NibblePop]

@@kaushanigoswami1734 you are very correct

[@anirbandhara5038]

Don't you think that the last stanza can be a sign of Sexuality. May be I'm interpreting more but I think that white sustenance has a sexual angle with her and Susan . And their body is metaphorically used with oceans.

[@NibblePop]

Could be indeed!

[@akashchowdhuryart2543]

Mam please discuss "i am wife i have finished that "

[@rahulsaikh8276]

Mam,please make a video on I'm wife I'he finished that by Emily Dickinson

[@ForeverEri]

Mam,we need the book of vanci pls make a vedio over it..

[@taniyasdancefloor9546]

Ma'am Please explain the 'wide sargasso sea'

[@stylemog2229]

Ma'am, Could you please explain the poem I'm wife.

[@sahinshaikh2453]

Thank you ma'am, from krishnanagar government college 😅🌻❤️

[@akashchowdhuryart2543]

Mam please duscuss "Byzentium poem"

[@kaushanigoswami1734]

Daddy! My favourite poem...