டி.எம்.கிருஷ்ணா அதை செய்வாரா? - கேட்கிறார் சுதா ரகுநாதன்

டி.எம்.கிருஷ்ணா அதை செய்வாரா? - கேட்கிறார் சுதா ரகுநாதன் | Sudha Ragunathan Interview - Part 2

Рет қаралды 131,882

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 288

@MuthuKumaran-hb6ku 2 ай бұрын

Wow...that last rendition was pure bliss....all i could do was close my eyes and absorb the divine vibrations of air coming out of the mouth of the divine manifesting in Sudha m'am....

@venkattrinity 2 жыл бұрын

Excellent. She is a fighter. A winner. A role model. An exemplary artist and a person.

@saikalasaikala2711 7 ай бұрын

May be she is fighter. but definitely not winner..can't winner... She do changes n her culture in her marriage.. Like that automatically this situations also will be changed. Let wait and see...😊😂

@ravib7420 7 ай бұрын

Intelligently answering every question without hurting anyone

@TheSubrama 2 жыл бұрын

Salute ma’am for your bold stance and response. Personal questions about your family was so well addressed. Beautiful!!

@journeyintocarnaticmusic7009 2 жыл бұрын

Beautiful interview, so Frank and lucid. Sudha is a champion in every way.

@uauu9099 2 жыл бұрын

I don’t understand why no-one explains or understands that Carnatic music was never excluding anyone but rather it is an exclusive performing art form. Why is it a big deal that it should be available to everyone when it is already? In fact my grandma being a Brahmin herself could not learn music but every day at noon she never failed to listen to the AllIndia Radio broadcasting Carnatic music and she learn to understand ragas etc. I think it is truly an absurd concept that music should be available to everyone when it has been since time immemorial.

@sriBsai 2 жыл бұрын

Great observation. But have you thought how your Grandma was able to listen to it in the first place? How did she cultivate that interest? Even though she couldn’t learn music, she had the interest to listen. Where did that come from and how come people of our generation don’t have the patience or interest to CM even though most of the kutcheris are free and there are so many CM concerts online? Film songs get 1 Million views in one day, while CM hardly gets viewed in tens and hundreds. Why is it the case? I think the answer is: the inclusivity is not about who can listen or not, but the inclusivity is about who is given the opportunity to cultivate an interest to listen to this. Film songs do not require any training on the listener’s part. You can just tune in and start listening and feel good. But CM is an art form that requires the listener to cultivate a taste towards it. How are we going to create that? I hope this answers you question on why it should be available to everyone when it’s already available. It’s already available but not many know to enjoy how to appreciate it.

@raghunathansrinivasaraghav6455 2 жыл бұрын

You are correct. No. One is excluded. But the art form is exclusive demanding 1. Hard and sustained practice 2. Proper diction 3. Understanding the sahitya bhava 4. A lot of patience and preservarance. 5. Working knowledge in multiple languages with correct pronunciation. 6. Basic knowledge of Sanskrit script. ( It will help in mastering sahityaas in Telugu, kannada, Hindi etc. There are lot of vidwans of repute. To mention few Kancheepuram Nainaa Pillai Chittor Subramanya pillai Madurai Soma Sundaram Ramnad C S Sankara Sivan M M Dandapaani Desikar Sundara Murthy Rajananickam Pillai. All the great Nadaswaram Vidwans, starting from Rajarathinam Pillai onwards. Top class percussion vidwans like Pudukkottai Maamundia Pillai, Pazhani Subramanya Pillai, Dakshinaamurti Pillai. Who can forget T Viswanathan Brother of great Balasaraswathi. Veenai Dhanammaal, jayammaal Brindha Mukta sisters. In composing, the great Tanjore quartret. Tamil Trinity Marimutha Pillai, Arunachala Kaviraayar etc. Once I had an interaction with a great vidwan, a musician's musician. He told me that he does not take students just for fun. He said he will ask the student " என்னப்பா கற்றுக் கொள்ள வேண்டும்." If the answer is "பாட்டு கற்றுக் கொள்ளவேண்டும்". I tick the student out. Then I will ask how many swaraas are there. If the answer is 7. That is the end of it. If the student says that he wants to learn " சம்பிரதாய சங்கீதம் மொத்தம் 12 ஸ்வரங்கள் என்றால், then i ask the student to sing for a few minutes. He also said there is no crash course in class. But now we are in " அவசர உலகம்". He said that he will advise the prospective student to attend Bhajans to understand the nuances. Because of these hurdles people find it difficult to take up music and general public think it is elitist art.

@raghunathansrinivasaraghav6455 2 жыл бұрын

My list is only illustrative and not exaustive. I forgot to mention T M Namasivayam T M Thiagarajan Legend K J Jesudas. K P Sivanandam Chitti Babu.

@sriBsai 2 жыл бұрын

@@raghunathansrinivasaraghav6455 Nicely put! Yes, it is not just an art form. It is a way of life. The music practice requires patience, discipline, sensitivity and dedication. It’s everything but அவசரம்! But today we are in the world where we want instant gratification for everything. We, as a society and as each individual, have to recalibrate what is important to us and where we are heading. And to do this, the education system and mindset has to change. We need an education system which is not focused on external material gains, but an education system which can help elevate our souls through இயல், இசை & இலக்கியம். Bharathiyar called our nation- ஞானத்திலே, பர மோனத்திலே, யோகத்திலே, கானத்திலே, கவிதையிலே உயர் நாடு!!.. Is it still true?

@freshmaniac8450 Жыл бұрын

Well said.

@starsflow9 7 ай бұрын

அவாளுக்கு மத்தவா பிரச்சனைகள் தேவையில்லை. எங்கே அவாளுக்கு பொழப்பு இருக்கிறதோ அங்கே மட்டும் தான் அவர்கள் கவனம் செலுத்துவார்கள். இசை அனைவராலும் உணர்வுகளை கொண்டாட பட வேண்டிய கலை. ஆர்வம் மட்டும் இருக்கும் அனைத்து மக்களாலும் கற்றுக்கொண்டு சிகரம் செல்ல முடியும். எந்த ஒரு குறிப்பிட்ட சமுதாயத்திற்கு மட்டுமே படைக்க பட்டதல்ல....

@saikalasaikala2711 7 ай бұрын

சரியாக சொல்கறீர்கள்.

@ஊர்நாடுஅப்பளக்குடுமிதொப்புளான் 6 ай бұрын

நீ நூல் ஆரிய வெள்ளை அழகு ப்ராமணன் பீயை தின்று பூளை உருவி உருவி ஊம்பி சூத்துக் கொடுத்து தானேடா ஆரிய வர்ணாசிரம பார்ப்பனீய சனாதன ஹிந்து தர்மத்தின் எஸ் ஸி சர்டிஃபிகேட் பிச்சை எடுக்கிறே . நீ உன் கருப்பச்சி லோலாயி அம்மா பெண்டாட்டி பெண்கள் பேத்திகள் மருமகள்கள் எல்லார் கருங்கூதிகளையும் ஆரிய நூல் வெள்ளை அழகு ப்ராமணனுக்கு கூட்டிக் கொடுத்து தானே டா ஆரிய வர்ணாசிரம பார்ப்பனீய சனாதன ஹிந்து தர்மத்தின் ஜாதி ரிசர்வேஷன் பீ 69 % துன்றே . உன்னிடம் நூல் ஆரிய வர்ணாசிரம பார்ப்பனீய சனாதன ஹிந்து தர்மத்தின் எஸ் ஸி சர்டிஃபிகேட் பிச்சை மட்டும் இல்லாட்டி நீ உன் கருப்பச்சி லோலாயி அம்மா பெண்டாட்டி பெண்கள் பேத்திகள் மருமகள்கள் எல்லார் கருங்கூதிகளையும் மும்பை ரெட் லைட் ஏரியாவில் வைத்து ப்ராதெல் அதாண்டா லவ்டேகேபால் தாயோளி தேவடியாப்பயலே கூதியானே சூத் காட்டி விபசார விடுதி நடத்தி டாபர் பாடூஸ் மாமா தொழில் தான் செய்திருப்பே . உன்னை திருட்டு திராவிடம் காப்பாற்ற லே . ஆரிய வர்ணாசிரம பார்ப்பனீய சனாதன ஹிந்து தர்மத்தின் எஸ் ஸி சர்டிஃபிகேட் பிச்சை மட்டுமே காப்பாற்றுது . நீ ஆரிய நூல் வெள்ளை அழகு ப்ராமணன் பீயை தின்று பூளை உருவி உருவி ஊம்பி சூத்துக் கொடுத்து தானேடா ஆரிய வர்ணாசிரம பார்ப்பனீய சனாதன ஹிந்து தர்மத்தின் எஸ் ஸி சர்டிஃபிகேட் பிச்சை எடுக்கிறே . ந் ஆரிய வர்ணாசிரம பார்ப்பனீய சனாதன ஹிந்து தர்மத்தின் எஸ் ஸி சர்டிஃபிகேட் பிச்சைக்காரன் தானே டா லவ்டேகேபால் தாயோளி தேவடியாப்பயலே கூதியானே சூத் காட்டி அப்போ நீ தின்பது சோறு இல்லே . ஆரிய நூல் வெள்ளை அழகு ப்ராமணன் பீ தான் . உனக்கு ஏண்டா இப்படி திருட்டு திராவிடச் சூத் கொளுப்பு . அப்போ உன் ப்ரெக் ஃபாஸ்ட் நூல் வெள்ளை அழகு ப்ராமணன் பீ தானே . உன் லஞ்ச் நூல் வெள்ளை அழகு ப்ராமணன் தானே . உன் டின்னர் ஆரிய நூல் வெள்ளை அழகு ப்ராமணன் பீ தானே டா லவ்டேகேபால் தாயோளி தேவடியாப்பயலே கூதியானே சூத் காட்டி

@ஊர்நாடுஅப்பளக்குடுமிதொப்புளான் 6 ай бұрын

நீ சம்பளம் வாங்காமல் சூத்தைக் கொடுத்து இலவசமாக வேலை செய்றியா

@ஊர்நாடுஅப்பளக்குடுமிதொப்புளான் 6 ай бұрын

டாஸ்மாக் சரக்கு அடித்து எத்தனை பாவாடை கர்நாடக வித்வான்கள் . சூத்தால் ப்ரெயிஸ் தி லார்ட் என்று ஊளை விடுங்க

@wolfsr9259 6 ай бұрын

சரியா சொன்னீங்க

@enoren21 2 жыл бұрын

Carnatic or classical music and light music are like reading literature and a novel.each will have its own circle of admirers and their numbers will always be different.but we can enjoy both and the individual has to develop a taste for each.

@geetasridhar5511 2 жыл бұрын

Honest, bold , talented . Sudha Ji has given us a new perspective on herself

@vidhyasankaran3094 6 ай бұрын

Enjoyed the interview. Nice queries & Sudha ji was very sincere in her reply. Hats off chandruji. 💐

@Chennaivasi80 Жыл бұрын

Excellent interview...Sudha JI answered a lot of personal mischievous qsns about his son in law without getting defensive and honestly...What a voice..

@mnarayanaswami3262 2 жыл бұрын

Kudos to Ms. Ragunathan!!! A wonderful interview; we didn’t listen, we floated through the interview. Well done; credit to Wow Tamizha channel as well.

@shankarnatarajan6230 2 жыл бұрын

கர்நாடக சங்கீத உலகில் புரட்சி , சீர்திருத்தம் தேவையில்லை. கால ஓட்டத்தில் அதுவே தன்னை மாற்றி அமைத்து கொள்ளும். தமிழில் பாபநாசம் சிவன், கோபாலகிருஷ்ண பாரதி, ஊத்துக்காடு, அம்புஜம் கிருஷ்ணா போன்ற பல மேதைகள் பாடல்கள் இயற்றி அவை இன்று பல மேடைகளில் அதிகம் பாடப்படுவதை கேட்க முடிகிறது.

@kunnakkudy 7 ай бұрын

exactly

@SusiFernando-e5p 6 ай бұрын

Azhakaaka soneerkal

@ஊர்நாடுஅப்பளக்குடுமிதொப்புளான் 6 ай бұрын

உண்மை . கிருஷ்ணா பயல் பேசுவது வடி கட்டிய அயோக்கியத்தனம் . ஒரு நூல் இப்படிப் பேசுவதால் பாவாடை திருட்டு திராவிடப் பயல்கள் குல்லாய்கள் ஆதரிக்கின்றன . கதழுதைகளுக்குத் தெரியுமா கற்பூர வாசனை😂

@rsathyanarayana6047 6 ай бұрын

Don't give stupid Comme nts it is not a profession can you sing one line what they sing

@arkay2838 2 жыл бұрын

We need an Artist Like you who is Bold & Outspoken ... KUDOS to you MAM !!!

@srinivasankumar9766 Жыл бұрын

Most Respected Sudha Ragunathan Madam Thanks for your open minded approach with control. You are absolutely correct that we should not fail to do what appears to be right without affecting others. Your style of singing makes me belive that our MLV amma is still alive ! I pray to God for your long long journey in the field of Carnatic music in the years to come.

@rajesh5279 2 жыл бұрын

Music should expand minds. It cannot be kept only to small sector. If TVG didnt reach Ilayaraja and ARR, we would have lost legends.

@nammanur Жыл бұрын

The listener should be with open mind. Otherwise it won't work.

@ganesanr736 Жыл бұрын

இளையராஜாவால்தான் TVG க்கு பேர். ரெஹ்மானாலதான் உன்னிக்ருஷ்ணனுக்கு பேர்.

@rakeshchand9189 7 ай бұрын

No arr not learnt from tvg

@anonymozanonymouz9323 2 жыл бұрын

Very nice interview. Mrs.Sudha Raghunathan 's replies are thoughtful and wonderful.

@laxmikrishnapuri9806 2 жыл бұрын

Interview with open hearted Sudha Ragunathan has replied. I am astonished the way Sudha has spoken. For personal matters beatifully replied. It is justified. Highly talented Sudha Ragunathan. My best wishes.

@krishnaswamysampathkumar1162 6 ай бұрын

Sudha talks very sensible Informations. Tm. Krishna should change himself. It is need of the hour totally for his respect knowledge and reputation. Otherwise TMK will be nowhere soon

@msamarshal 6 ай бұрын

Music is an art can mastered by anyone. Don't underestimate TMK because he doesn't compromise with you.

@raghavgopal4363 2 жыл бұрын

Very genuine heart felt answers. Sudha is a very liberal yet a conservative person.

@sugunakapali1 2 жыл бұрын

Sudhaji giving a fitting reply to the question “ why the music fraternity is not getting involved in sociology political issues “ - There are specific groups only for in getting involved in such issues and so no necessity for the Carnatic music fraternity to get involved in such issues. Carnatic music fraternity is fully involved to in giving soulful, mind soothing and elevating music to the music listeners caught in the tussles of day to day mundane life

@padmanabhanra4728 2 жыл бұрын

Why cant you enjoy Music, it can be in any language, Tamil, Hindi, Telugu, Kannadam etc.,. There are many old Hindi movie songs very popular in Tamilnadu, because of its melody , singer talent etc., still you can enjoy the music. With today's technology, language is not at all a barrier,if one has sincere interest in music. Always quality Music has no language. It can succeed any where and can suceed for generations,

@arkay2838 2 жыл бұрын

Fantastic Mrs Sudha Raghunathan .. Fitting reply to the Question raised on TMK Views

@gomathir7341 2 жыл бұрын

Namastey Sudha Raghunathan ji. அற்புதம்

@mahalakshmivijayan9201 2 жыл бұрын

Yes. Exactly Mam! It is known to everybody that You are a well known renowned classical exponent! But the way you faced the interview and replied show how determined ,logical thinking with high degree of Generosity,Humility etc . These virtues make you really a very good human.!!! Mam my Namaskaarams to you for your talent and virtues!!!🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 Really a very blessed personality by all means!!!!;

@moutainlover 2 жыл бұрын

Like how she managed to get Padmabhoosan, she knows how to tackled the interviewing person

@saranathantg Жыл бұрын

Carnatic music is at a high position. Only those who have interest in that can appreciate. Unfortunately this is restricted to a group only.

@RajaBalan-z2r 10 күн бұрын

We have to adopt to succeed. That's is the only formula.

@vimalaraju5370 7 ай бұрын

Neelamayildhanai naangalum marakkavillai.❤❤❤❤❤ u mam.

@mathiselvi4067 2 жыл бұрын

தர்ம செய்யும் நல்லெண்ணம் கொண்ட இசைமேதை மரியாதைக்குரிய சுதா அம்மையார் அவர்களுக்கு வணக்கமும் வாழ்த்துக்களும் தாங்களும் தங்கள் எண்ணங்களும் நீடோடி வாழ ஆண்டவனை பிரார்த்தனை செய்கின்றோம்

@krishnamurthyvenkataramani3736 6 ай бұрын

Madam u are correct. It should from come within. Afterwards they can learn. Without having the knowledge of music from poorva janma, it cannot be learned in this Janna from zero.

@trgtrg7776 7 ай бұрын

You real mother we should not live for society. Every body eating for their own hungry. Great Heart Sudha Amma. Sweet voice Ram Ram

@umamaheswari604 7 ай бұрын

Nice interview. My favourite song thankyou

@gomathir7341 2 жыл бұрын

அம்மா. சுதாரகுநாதன் அம்மா. உங்களை உங்கள்குரலை. கண்டு. கேட்ட. நாள் முதலாய்உங்கள் மேல். அன்பு பெருகுதம்மா. வணக்கம். Wow. Tamiizha. Thank you 🙏

@MotilalJ 6 ай бұрын

My mom, a non brahmin was an expert Carnatic Musician & used to perform in All India Radio, Trichy frequently during late 60s & early 70s.

@nathanvms7419 Жыл бұрын

மக்களுக்கு புரிந்த மொழியில் பாட வேண்டும்

@reaspondto 7 ай бұрын

மக்களுக்கு புரியக்கூடாது என்பதற்காகத்தான் அந்த மொழியில் பாடுவது.

@ஊர்நாடுஅப்பளக்குடுமிதொப்புளான் 6 ай бұрын

திருட் திராவிடம் போல . திருட்டு திராவிடம் திருட்டு திராவிடன் பீ சூத்திலா இருக்கு

@subburamveluchamy9747 3 күн бұрын

அது எந்த மொழி? சென்னை மொழியா? தொண்டை மண்டலம் மொழியா? கோவை ... பாண்டிய... சோழ மண்டலம்... Etc

@rajiKrishnan52 8 ай бұрын

Smart Sudha, versatile and an achiever. Enjoyed, her experience is shown in her talk. A great inspiration to me. ❤😊

@ramabharath5707 2 жыл бұрын

Wow sudha u ended with my fav song..if u remember I always ask u to sing this song in every concert

@kv7689 2 жыл бұрын

Bombay jayasri Aruna sairam Raga sisters Gayathri venkatragavan Amrita murali Are focussing music only They are very simple and not giving interviews in sensitive matters I like their music only especially Raga and bombay jayasri

@ljrs12 2 жыл бұрын

I agree

@utbe2002 Жыл бұрын

TMK talks…. Talking is just that - talking. Real experience is how Sudha and husband Raghunathan handled their daughter’s marriage. It showed us their true character. Conservative, liberal etc., is all badges we give people. Means nothing… When it hits close to home, how people behave is what defines them. God bless you Sudha ma’am and your entire family.

@ramaswamymuruganandam3112 6 ай бұрын

In this Globe for every human being to survive need a profession. Or for self survival an individual depending with any profession. The same thing for music also. The Music is making very big money. Music is a tool of survival. Nobody will present a Music with free of cost. But one thing is prooved that the Music is depends on individual talent not with perticular group.

@vijaya6459 2 жыл бұрын

Sudhama. Goodmorning. I am your Rasika. A normal Rasika without knowing much about raagam thaalam. Your interview was very nice. I always have a feeling that I did not have the opportunity to learn music. Which is very unfortunate. But my daughter learns music. I used to talk to your daughter malavika when she comes for dance class as my daughter was learning dance from the same guru. ( Smt.Meenakshi chittaranjan).

@kannansethuraman3301 2 жыл бұрын

Mam, you have fantastic knowledge base. Also you are a good human. May God bless you.

@lakshmirajagopalan7699 2 жыл бұрын

Wonderful interview mam. God bless u n your family with all good things

@sugunakapali1 2 жыл бұрын

Our neighbor used to say “ I am fed up of reading daily news paper headlines of dirty political tussles and abuses and get mental relief by only listening to devout Carnatic music”

@rajurukmani9724 2 жыл бұрын

Superb..

@premasekaran8479 2 жыл бұрын

Super👌👏.Brilliant Answer from My Favourite Sudha mam👏💐Vazhga Valamudan PallanduMam💐👍

@krmziaudeen8854 Жыл бұрын

பர்சனல் பற்றிய தேவையற்ற கேள்விக்கு தெளிவான துணிச்சலான பதில் தந்தார் சுதா அவர்கள்.

@veenai.s.thirumalvasagan7653 2 жыл бұрын

Thanks I am very happy madam

@ganesansambasivam6701 2 жыл бұрын

Madam Shrimathi Sudha, I fully viewed your discussion with Wow Tamzhla.Had you become a doctor,India would have lost popular carnatic musician with a vast variety of songs.I hope it is ordained by Sai Baba and Lord of fine arts Goddess Saraswati that we have daughter only for Music in India.I being a senior citizen pray the Lord and Goddesses to shower the best in your life and a long healthy and most prosperous life.My best wishes to you all in your family.S.Ganesan Kannampalayam Sulur kovai

@malaraghvan 2 жыл бұрын

WONDERFUL WONDERFUL. I am very great fan of Sudha

@TheKakamuka Жыл бұрын

20:55 ahahahaaaaaaa🙇‍♀️🙇‍♀️🙇‍♀️🙇‍♀️ this interview - pure gold!

@gurugurumurti7846 2 жыл бұрын

Concluding the interview with Sudha's signature piece in Maduvanthi made my day. Thank you

@mahanarasimhan1867 2 жыл бұрын

Great Sudhaji. Your answers were on point

@latharamakrishnan4677 2 жыл бұрын

Wow wow sudha. Very Outspoken. Superb interview. Final touch kanda naal awesome.

@parvathyhariharan2151 6 ай бұрын

வாழ்க வளத்துடன்

@b22krishna 7 ай бұрын

Ragunathan asks if TM Krishna does anything to the issues he claims about carnatic music? There is an awkward pause, she smiles and then says 'no' - TMK does practice what he preaches - with his music festivals for oppressed groups, sings with Jogappas, writes a research book about carnatic music and then writes a book about the oppressed groups who make instruments

@krithikakarthikeyan6235 2 жыл бұрын

Very truthful! Amazing woman!

@twins85392 Жыл бұрын

Amazing. Hats off for her. Regarding language e.g. enforcement of Hindi. Always For Musicians, language is not a bar. So like an activist need not fight. Music and language go together.

@vasanthvasu6993 2 жыл бұрын

It's good to hear thoughts & views of Sudha. Nice interview. 👍

@dhanalakshmi-dg4qq 6 ай бұрын

I request all the Carnatic musicians to go to any ambal Sannithi and pray to save our extremely. pure. Culture from the. evil notions of miscreants RAgaswaroopini. Will de.finitelyanswer genuine prayers

@joyoflife1754 2 жыл бұрын

Awesome Sudha ji 🎉🎉 Diwali fireworks in advance

@Madh1953 Жыл бұрын

She is a wholesome vidhwan. Asking her questions out of focus, is just unpleasant.

@thenmozhi9425 2 жыл бұрын

இந்தப பாடகியை நினைத்து நான் வருத்தப் படுகிறேன் . என் தாத்தா அடிக்கடிசொல்லக்கேட்டிருக்கிறேன் . பல பிறவிகளுக்குப் பின் கிடைப்பது பிராமண ஜன்மம் நான் ப்ராமினாகப் பிறக்கவில்லை என சக ப்ராமண அலுவலர்களைப் பார்த்து ஏங்கி இருக்கிறேன். எனக்கு ப்ராமினஸ அவர்கள் பழக்க வழக்கம் ரொம்ப பிடிக்கும் . என்னிடம் பிரியமாகப் பழகுவார்கள் . இவர் எத்தனை சுலபமாக இவரது மகளின் காதலை அங்கீகரித்து ஊரறிய மணம் முடித்து வைத்து விட்டார. கூடுதலாக ஆப்பிரிக்க மாப்பிள்ளை வத்தலகுழம்பு உருளைக்கிழங்கு சாப்பிடும் அழகை பெருமையுடன் வியக்கிறார் . ஜாதி பார்பது நடுத்தர பிரபலம் இல்லாதவரகள் தான் . பிரபலமானவர்கள் பணக்கார்ர்கள இது பற்றி கவலைப்படுவதே இல்லை. என் ப்ராமின் தோழியின் மகள் படிப்பில் சுட்டி. பேரழகி. அமெரிக்காவில. மேல் படிப்பு படிக்கப் போய் சென்னையைச் சேர்ந்த Non Brahmin பையனை விரும்பி அவனைத் திருமணம் செய்து வைக்கும்படி பெற்றோரைக் கேட்டாள் என் தோழி என்ன சொன்னாள் தெரியுமா? நீ அங்கேயே இருந்து விடு. இந்நியா வராதே என்ன வேண்டுமானாலும் பண்ணிக் கொள் என்றாள். நாங்கள் சொன்னோம் அவனும் இந்து தானே. நீங்கள் வணங்கும் கடவுளைத்தானே வணங்குகிறான் என்று சொல்லிப் பார்த்தோம். என் தோழி நாங்கள வெங்காயம் பூண்டு முட்டை தொடமாட்டோம். காஞ்சி பெரியவர் பக்தர்கள். ஒருநாள் விடாமல் NV சாப்பிடுபவர்களுடன் சம்பந்தம் வைத்துக் கொள்வார்களா? எங்கள் ஆசார அனுஷ்டானம் இதற்கு இடமளிக்காது என்றாள் எங்களுக்கு மகள் பிறக்கவில்லை என நினைத்துக் கொள்கிறோம் என்று சொல்லி மகளிடம் எங்கள் அந்திம காரியங்களுக்கு நீ வரக்கூடாது. வந்தால் எங்களுக்கு செய்யப்படுகிற சடங்குகளால் பயனில்லை . எனவே இப்பொழுதே எங்களைத்தலைமுழுகிவிடு என்றாள். ஒரு வாரம் கழித்து அந்தப் பெண் நீங்கள் சொன்னால் சரியாக இருக்கும் என்று பணிந்து வந்தாள். இதுதான் வளர்ப்பு I informed him. He stayed away decently என்றும. சொன்னாள் . நாங்கள் கூட வேறு பிரிவில் குழந்தைகளுக்கு மணம் செய்ய எளிதில் சம்மதிக்க மாட்டொம் இப்போது தோழியின்மகள் அவர்கள் குலத்தில் அரவிந்தசாமி மாதிரி ஒரு டாக்டர் வரன் கிடைத்து லண்டனில் செட்டிலாகி விட்டாள் . அழகான ஆண்குழந்தையும் பிறந்துவிட்டது. வங்கியில் பெரிய அநிகாரியாக இருக்கிறாள் . குழந்தைகள் சொல்லும் வித்த்தில் சொன்னால் கேட்பார்கள் . பண்புடன் சேர்ந்து படிப்பு . IIT DIRRCTOR ஶ்ரீ காமகோடியை அவர் தாத்தா பெற்றோர் எப்படி உருவாக்கியுள்ளனர் . அவரவர் விதிப்பயன் என்ன செய்வது? . பாடகியின் மகள் எல்லா வளமும் பெற்று வாழ பாபா நிச்சயம் அருள் புரிவார்

@MotilalJ 6 ай бұрын

I think you were born in the unusual place, ie head😂😂😂

@hamsahari3980 2 жыл бұрын

My humble pranams to sudha amma 🙏🙏🙏🙏

@akbarhussainjabrudeen8250 6 ай бұрын

உண்மைதான், ஆனால் இசையில் தலைசிறந்திருப்பவர்கள் அனைவரும் வரும் இசையை complex யிலிருந்து மீட்டு அனைவரும் விரும்பும் வகையில் தருகிறார்கள், அதனால் தான் மொழிதெரியாவிட்டாலும் ஓசை நயத்தை ரசிக்கிறோம்

@natesanvishwanathan7656 2 жыл бұрын

Brilliant. Radhekrishna Bhaghavather Stay Blessed

@bhuvanasiddharth5402 2 жыл бұрын

Very open minded talk. Hatsoff to Sudhaji.

@gomathir7341 2 жыл бұрын

First we heard your voice such a wonderful pleasingly to see in our minds. That’s true. MLV AMMA’s. Best trues student you are Ji. Namastey Maa

@rangarajanl320 2 жыл бұрын

Plain and cryptic response.carnatic music is not totally an exclusive preserve of any community.we can name many legends outside the so called ' dominated community'.But music needs to reach out to next generation to preserve its glory and guard it against the onslaught of other forms of music.While preserving the sanctity of sanctum,musicians should find ways and means for a inclusive growth.

@lalithaasubbu8824 2 жыл бұрын

Absolutely true

@b.shyamalab.shyamala9644 2 жыл бұрын

Carnatic music is divine music so it should reach every one.

@DrPurvajasNatyaMandira 2 жыл бұрын

She answered very well

@a.samsudeen3195 Жыл бұрын

Sudha Mam always great

@rajisai42523 Жыл бұрын

Hi Mam, you are so honest and open, Sri Gurubhyo Namaha 🙏🙏

@vembubhuvaneswari6213 Ай бұрын

Music is open to all. It is a complicated mathematical art. Those who have the capacity can enter into that area. Many are (as you said carnatic controlled by a sect of people) good listeners but not a singer.

@ramabharath5707 Жыл бұрын

Wow sudha, u sang my fav song...everytime I ask u to sing in all concerts

@arulappanfrancis9909 2 жыл бұрын

Excellent! Well done !!!

@bimasu 2 жыл бұрын

Carnatic music, like other forms of classical music, including western classical, is totally different from pop music and by nature, complex and difficult to appreciate. If I want to appreciate it, I should make a sincere attempt and persist with it for some time,even if I don’t understand it initially. The onus is on me. Thousands of Westerners have attempted and succeeded. In a general situation where one rapidly changes the channel, “ என்னவோ மொக்கய போட்டுட்டிருக்கான்”, the moment one hears Carnatic music, the musicians can only cater to those who have a ear for it. A society cannot berate and make fun of an art form and at the same time, blame the artists and their connoisseurs for keeping them out of it.

@sharadakrishna774 2 жыл бұрын

Just as everyone cannot be an actor or actress, painter,. Dancer, Sportsperson etc. Only those who are interested can be taught. You cannot force it on anyone. Every parent has to strive hard to push his or her child into a particular art. Best example is actress hemamalini's mother. She spent half her life in giving her daughter good training in dance then gradually entering cinema. Parents' full support should be there. Amrit Raj brothers could shine in tennis only because of their mother Maggie amritraj. she used to take the children early in the morning for practice.First of all as a family parents should push and help their children in the activity which they are interested. No use in blaming one சமுதாயம். If a person is interested and talented nobody can stop them from coming up in life whether carnatic music or any field

@lakshmimani7275 10 ай бұрын

Excellent super

@pvraghavan3825 2 жыл бұрын

The more I hear her the more I like her

@srinivasansundarum6326 Жыл бұрын

Carnatic is a difficult concept to appreciate and become an exponent in. Just like most people have difficulty with jazz or western classical or opera. There is a select audience and select group that performs. It isn’t based on caste at least in the current generation. Even among Brahmins only a a small percentage take to Carnatic. Think of it like blues or blue grass or country. Only people who are brought in that mileu take to it. They musical forms do not have universal appeal. So accept it and don’t keep harping on caste as limiting it. There are enough teachers in Carnatic who are open to accepting students from all backgrounds. But without a keen widespread interest in that genre it is bound to remain in select circles. Just accept it. ™ krishna has many avenues to attack casteism without specifically targeting One community.

@shantielangovan3802 2 жыл бұрын

Isn't it responsibility of veterans to simplify the complexity of saastriya sangeetham and expand the reach of carnatic music. Chembai swamy had trained shri.K.J.Yesudass cutting across all barriers. We need such courageous singers willing to groom singers from all sects to expand the reach.

@bimasu 2 жыл бұрын

Carnatic music, like other forms of classical music, including western classical, is totally different from pop music and by nature, complex and difficult to appreciate. One has to have an inclination towards it to be able to appreciate it. In a general situation where one rapidly changes the channel, “ என்னவோ மொக்கய போட்டுட்டிருக்கான்”, the moment one hears Carnatic music, the musicians can only cater to those who have a ear for it. A society cannot berate and make fun of an art form and at the same time, blame the artists and their connoisseurs for keeping them out of it.

@kumarsubra1 7 ай бұрын

No it is not. Their responsibility is not any more and not any less than the responsibility of any expert in any field to transmit their knowledge to a suitable recipient. A lot of effort needs to be made by an aspirant to come get the knowledge. KJY met that level and he received the knowledge from appropriate Guru. Same like Physics, chemistry, sciences, engineering, PhDs. No shortcuts. One Develops the passion, come half way and then the guru will show up and take you rest of the way. Don’t fall into the misleading narrative of TMK. The man who makes to 50 RS coconut shell violin and plays it beautifully in the train and sells it to others. For an extra 100 bucks ask him to teach you how to play it like him, he just can’t make it happen overnight. It is a lot of rigor and practice.

@eshwarswaminathan3031 Жыл бұрын

Madras Sanskrit College Kala kshetra bharatha natyam school is there open to all.

@gomathir7341 2 жыл бұрын

Good comments. Madam ji

@Canada_Immigration_Bible Жыл бұрын

நீல மயில் தனை நெஞ்சமும் மறக்கவில்லை நீல மயில் தனை நெஞ்சமும் மறக்கவில்லை நேசம் உடன் கலந்த பாசமும் மறையவில்லை நீல மயில் தனை நெஞ்சமும் மறக்கவில்லை நேசம் உடன் கலந்த பாசமும் மறையவில்லை கோல குமரன் மன கோயிலில் இருந்து விட்டான் ஆ ஆஅ ஆஆ.. ஆ ஆஅ ஆஆ.. கோலகுமரன் மன கோயிலில் இருந்து விட்டான் குறு நகை தனை காட்டி நறு மலர் சூட்டி விட்டான் கண்ட நாள் முதலாய் கா.தல் பெருகுதடி கையினில் வேல் பிடித்த கருணை சிவ பாலனை கண்ட நாள் முதலாய் காதல் பெருகுதடி (Carnatic song, written and composed by N. S. Chidambaram)

@sriBsai 2 жыл бұрын

The biggest problem concerning inclusivity in Carnatic music directly relates to privileges and biases involved in music teaching and learning. It is an art form that is scientific in nature and this requires some serious contemplation, patience and hard work on the part of a learner as well as a teacher. It is anything but instant gratification of senses. We all learn languages and mathematics in schools, but do all of us end up becoming poets and mathematicians? But, we need an education in math and languages to be literate and numerate to appreciate and make sense of the world around us. Similarly, we all music education to appreciate good music so it can be useful in our lives, make us more sensitive to beauty and help us find ourselves. So, more than anything else, we need to focus on making music education more equitable so we all are given equal opportunity to learn this art form. How we choose to use it- whether we want to be Carnatic listeners or use to understand other genres of music, is our choice. Carnatic music is a language to understand and appreciate music in depth. And we need great teachers to teach and share this language with others. While learning of a language can be made equitable and possible, whether one becomes a poet, an artist or not is only in the hands of God. But at the least, music equity will open the doors to all to appreciate beauty in music. And I believe, this is at the core of TMK’s work, in him trying to help people understand this language of Carnatic music better. I am surprised and shocked that SR’s insights were not in depth, given she is such a senior artist. When the interviewer asked about her thoughts on ARR, I wish she shared some musical insights instead of just saying how he liked her musical bouquet. Come on, we deserve more depth than this SR!

@arkay2838 2 жыл бұрын

I think you totally misunderstood .. Firstly you need to understand things more in detail before commenting on a Senior Artist Like Smt Sudha Raghunathan.. Go back to Histroy of Carnatic Music ..There were Legendary Singers /Instruments Players Like ( Veena Dhanammal // Kanchipuram Naina Pillai/ Dhanakoti Ammal // Muktha & Brinda / Karikurichi Arunachalam and many more to List ) who are not from the So Called Brahmin Community but were Glittering in the field Carnatic Music ... TMK 's comment was ,As if Someone in the Community had build a Great Wall of China and that C-music is not letting it out is mere Stupidity and Politicizing for some cheap benefits ... Smt Sudha Raghunathan was Point Precise and gave very Fitting Reply Spontaneously .. Kudos to her

@TheSriGudi 2 жыл бұрын

@@arkay2838 Perfectly put !!!

@sriBsai 2 жыл бұрын

@@arkay2838 Thank you for your response and refreshing my memory. I’m well aware of the history. I’m also aware of the fact there was a time when singing and dancing was looked down upon by people belonging to upper castes. Why were there no women singers from the Brahmin community before Smt. D.K.Pattamal who sang publicly? Prior to the 1900s, or before abolishment of the Devadasi system, music and arts was much more spread out among different kinds of communities and as far as I know, Brahmin women didn’t sing publicly. They thought it was a bad thing. So how come suddenly the Carnatic music world is dominated by mostly Brahmin women and men? Have you thought more about this? I’m interested in knowing your response. I’m not a subject matter expert, but I can’t accept things blindly without analyzing just because they are a senior artist. They are also humans and can be fallible. According to me, this interview was neither insightful nor had any depth. You may choose to disagree with me and I respect that. Thank you!

@rbhanumathi8348 2 жыл бұрын

Tamil songs in carnatic music reached ordinary tamilians reached well Ilayaraja and AR.Rehman examples for this,

@krishnakumar2390 2 жыл бұрын

Amma great neenga

@lakshminarayanan6543 7 ай бұрын

Very very super

@karthikiyengar6141 Жыл бұрын

Whether it's music or dance the Fondation should be strong but senior teachers don't do this one who learned 10 years only they teach so teaching work is less many teachers do very good and sincere after learned they got the named people poor thing all the concert s people come to see their dress and armaments that's there in all the performance

@mahalaskhmisridhar6755 Жыл бұрын

Excellent.

@Arulvarathan-notes 2 жыл бұрын

Well said . Well done MATHA Ji 🌹💧🙏🏻🙏🏽

@mahadevanhari261 7 ай бұрын

Super madam

@eshwarswaminathan3031 Жыл бұрын

Best wishes for interview

@senthilkumar-xi1hw Жыл бұрын

சமுதாய அறக்கட்டளை மூலம் நீங்கள் இன்னும் சிறப்பாக செய்ய வேண்டும். நீங்களும் உங்கள்👨👦👧👩👴👵 உறுபினர்களும் நீடூழி வாழ எல்லாம் வல்ல இறைவனை🙏💕 வழிபட்டு கொள்கிறேன்

@lakshminarayanan6543 2 жыл бұрын

very excellent programme

@natarajanbaradwaj3560 7 ай бұрын

Its a fact that, as a % of the South Indian population (let alone whole of India), only a minuscule number have the interest and ability to appreciate Carnatic music. This is largely due to the rigid nature of Carnatic music and the high level of discipline required (which the majority of us Indians are not known for) to attain a level of proficiency be it as a performer or even as an appreciative listener who understands the nuances of this part of Indian art & culture. It is also a fact that the brahmin community, again as a % within the community, cares much for discipline and has the willingness to do the hard grind with sincerity to learn this form of the art. Given this scenario, it is perceived as though the brahmins are not inclusive and not welcoming of other communities into this form of the art. One question that begs an answer is, what prevents the other communities which collectively form 97% of Tamil Nadu's population to go head on and learn this art and beat the brahmins at it? Why do 97% expect to be "allowed" to participate as equals in this field when they have the numbers and the clout to do it themselves? The 97% can't beat the 3%? This is ridiculous! Its sheer laziness to do the hard grind but with a desire to be at the top and conveniently blame others for their own deficiencies when they don't reach the top. There are exceptions within the 97% but they really are exceptions. This is the truth and truth is bitter unfortunately. Whilst brahmins like T.M. Krishna and the like have the full freedom to share their knowledge and skills in this field to the 97%, the willingness and desire to learn the tough art and reach high levels should be with the 97%.