I'm On Jury Duty For A Very Strange Case, The Evidence Is Disturbing

[@irena4545]

"I'm the kind of person that will do everything I can to justify something before beginning to look for answers in the paranormal" Yeah? So why didn't he call the police the moment the black stuff first appeared in his flat, because that has a clear connection to the case and the logical non-paranormal conclusion is that some kind of psychopathic murderer is apparently messing with him.

[@FlatEarthOracle]

The same reason the juror remained on the case even though they literally would be kicked off of it the very moment they posted anything on Reddit/social media that garnered enough attention for people to start notifying courts across the country…….because the writer is horrific at their “occupation” and doesn’t know how to close logic loopholes or even properly research jury rules/etiquette once selected. Furthermore the case itself was so laughably stupid and would be one of the easiest “not guilty “ verdicts in the history of court room trials even if the attorney for the defense acted as ridiculously inept as the story made him out to be. The thing is all of that isn’t even the dumbest part of the story, the ending where the “entity” apparently was related to Wile E. Coyote made my skin crawl with such douch€ chills that I legit gave the video a thumbs down even though it’s not fair to Mr. Creeps(although he does need to learn how to pick better and more logically sound stories).

[@irena4545]

@@FlatEarthOracle Well... I didn't even finish. The internet is full of competently written stories, no need to waste my time on a stupid one. Thanks for confirming that it was the right choice ;-)

[@AnonymousStrangeness]

Jury tampering

[@Infamous41]

​@@irena4545check out I sold my soul for a dishwasher" great story funny, creepy

[@simplify3621]

It was reported later on but the judge ruled it a”flimsy connection at best” even if all jurors experienced the same thing.

[@mrsw2923]

I burned my dinner I was so wrapped up in this story. Totally worth it.

[@dankone3]

God damn you are fuckin gorgeous. 🙄

[@Pinoccappuccino]

Bruh, I got my first jury duty summons yesterday man.

[@yomogami4561]

lol creepy coincidence. good luck

[@emilyritter5590]

Don’t worry, I got one like a year ago and filled out the form and everything but never heard back from them so maybe you’ll get lucky.. or I’ll get unlucky… we shall see

[@AnonymousStrangeness]

@@yomogami4561 This was not a coincidence 🤔🧐

[@ryanbashor7371]

I would be so mad if some entity came into my house and kept spreading black dust all over my house.😅

[@shitneyb5562]

Mhm c'mere ghost, I'm haunting you now

[@rdbuckels]

I may have that gut in my house now. Ever since we moved into our 118 year old house, there is a constant layer of black and gray dust. We live in SE WV and until I heard this story I thought it was coal dust, but the mines are rarely in operation these days. 😱

[@leparfumdugrosboss4216]

I had it one time. I was victim of a burglary, the cops came to my house and in order to gather fingerprints they spread black dust all over my house. And as in the best ghost stories, it was all because I had contacted them in their realm and invited them to come in. 😅

[@arlesthegreat]

I’d be like ‘I am a resident and you will respect my authoritah!

[@shitneyb5562]

@@arlesthegreat 😂

[@jonseon5952]

"He was a small man 5ft 8" That stings

[@EatAssandDriveFast]

You can be tall emotionally :)

[@Mary-Anne0]

😭😭

[@labased2539]

He meant his weight. 130lbs. 5'8" is average.

[@Dr_Bille]

5ft 8, 130 lbs is small for a fully grown man. Sorry bro

[@primesspct2]

That's the perfect height for a gal my size. 5'4'. I also think 5'8'' is average my dads and both brothers are that size one of my tons too.

[@wyattcommander2655]

This easily became my favorite story I’ve ever heard so far. Amazing writing paired with a beautiful narration, this couldn’t have been executed more perfectly. I want to see this as a movie.

[@FlatEarthOracle]

You either didn’t listen to the story or are severely handicapped because the writing in this story along with complete misunderstanding of how courts operate made this story completely unlistenable. But I’m sure the fake internet clout your comment got will make you feel much better once you find out how completely ignorant you are.

[@bigblackchris5263]

The most unbelievable part of this story is any court letting the Jury go home during a murder trial. You get no phones, no TV, you stay at a hotel and you get limited access to your own family for the integrity of the case.

[@sophritoh]

Depends what trial… you think they do that for every single trial?? Only for high profile ones … even then it’s not always… When my mom served on a jury for murder, she came home as usual, she was under instructions not to watch news or read news or talk about the trial and she followed instructions, it’s pretty easy

[@nellietwo]

Not every jury is sequestered like that. Really depends on the trial and the judge. Some juries are just instructed to not discuss the case or look into it on their own.

[@nickbotic]

Not true. Well, not always true.

[@pharnum5956]

Great story. Stellar narration! Weird ending. Blah blah blah the end be well it was like they hit a hard word limit

[@erabearm2565]

Haven't listened yet but if this is about the stormy daniels hush money trial im going to be very disappointed

[@einienj3281]

Oh man.. that trial has some disturbing testimonials.. "you remind me of my daughter"...

[@idk_what_im_doing_please_]

You disappointed yet

[@fatrhino]

Great comment!

[@susieturk1]

Can you explain to me why he's in trouble for giving her hush money, but she's not in trouble for taking it? I've wondered this for way too long. I'm not a lawyer type minded political person so I really don't know.

[@erabearm2565]

@@susieturk1 simply put, because it's bullshit and it's not about wrong doings but about a 2024 election

[@maxdoles5806]

"They'd been suffocated, which meant that they were alive while being broken and impaled." Or he suffocated them and did those things afterwards.....

[@sirrmobreadings6978]

You could probably tell from the amount of blood, if she died before the impaling thered be less blood as there wouldn't be any blood flow when the heart is stopped If there are signs of anemia on the body it'd probably mean she was alive and the murderer only suffocated her when she was about to bleed out anyway

[@yomogami4561]

enjoyed the story but was rather dissatisfied with the ending it just seemed lacking compared to the rest thanks for the narration

[@savvynyx7156]

Hey Mr. Creeps, great narration as always! Shoutout to NickBotic for another great story! ❤

[@king81992]

Thumbnail Image- The police officer would later recount the bizarre things he witnessed at trial. This is the second court themed creepypasta I heard today. It seems like supernatural forces of the evil kind have a vested interest in the outcome of this trial. I wasn't expecting that fate for the defendant and his lawyer.

[@kimberlyshepherd270]

Thank you Mr. Creeps!

[@kentworch]

Thank you Mr Creeps for another awesome pasta. Excellent story and narration as always. Definitely made my night. 🖤🖤🖤🖤

[@arlesthegreat]

Come back next week for ‘I paid an adult star to keep quiet, now she thinks I’m an alien. She’s right.’

[@DocBree13]

😂

[@normfredriksen1381]

Come back tomorrow for a class on turning an old sundowner into the perfect puppet. I heard the recipe is massive amounts of Alzheimer's drugs and a teleprompter with extra large letters.

[@joshuahumphries7743]

I just got summoned to jury duty yesterday

[@blaircrocker9845]

Me too just opened the summons.

[@Aburame9595]

Act overly religious and they won’t pick you.

[@FlatEarthOracle]

Just ask this question to the attorneys and they will let you go immediately, “is the defendant rich and/or famous? “ and when they ask why just state “I’m trying to figure out what set of rules we are going by here”

[@joshuahumphries7743]

@@FlatEarthOracle I will take that into consideration

[@joshuahumphries7743]

@@Aburame9595 well in that note I just gotta turn my dial from devote to cult like devotion and delusional

[@shakycameratheater]

Juries are kept under secure locations for unique cases. No Internet during the trial . The trial would be tossed out once either legal team found this on the internet.

[@FlatEarthOracle]

So let me get this straight, this entire story is one big gaslighting session to make listeners afraid of accepting that the paranormal is real? At least the protagonist wasn’t portrayed as mindbendingly stupid as the court system and cops were however that stated it still is beyond exhausting listening to all these stories where the writer has LITERALLY NO UNDERSTANDING of how the judicial system works on any level let alone court and jury rules/etiquette. The very second this juror posted ANYTHING about the case, even that she was a juror in a case without naming where or what the case was the judge would remove her and she’d be lucky if she wasn’t severely punished. Just once I’d like the people who write these stories to do a smidge of research into the nonsense they pretend to know.

[@staruchx]

Yea it's annoying

[@savvynyx7156]

Dude, it's a story. And NickBotic is actually a very popular Creepypasta writer. Lay off or go read something else.

[@alexandrosh6277]

Yo it’s uhh like not that deep just chill🙏

[@lapetitemorte6307]

It's.... fiction. Pretend? Not real? Are you OK? Do you need to talk? You seem stressed.

[@savvynyx7156]

@lapetitemorte6307 I woke up my husband this made me laugh so loud!

[@jackdurden466]

Well! My prediction may or may not have been correct, but either way that doesn’t take away from the story. I liked the explanation, I enjoyed the entire story from the beginning to the end and even though it’s sad that both the defendant and his attorney had to go out that way, id bet it could have been far far worse had they not known the one ritual that Anthony M. Wouldn’t have given to John no matter what. So he would have at best had to have gotten it from one of the jurors, who if he’d been found guilty couldn’t have been able to reach him or supply him with what he needed to do it. Sure it’s a bit convoluted, but it was a good story! Well done to all of those involved! Thanks for the entertainment:) 👏👏👏👏👏

[@caseybee1.2.3]

This was an amazing story.

[@kimxanders7004]

I thoroughly enjoyed the story & narration, as always ❤

[@StarBrained]

This attic crap is giving me Grudge vibes

[@MrsCaranAmy]

This was an excellent story. Great narration. Thank you ❤️ 🤗 🌟

[@poodoom9856]

The author needs a thesaurus. It Is black dust... we get it. I like how all the affected jurors go to the guy responsible and their only reaction is, "Thanks for the herbs and advice bro." Finally put some of those herbs in a Dustbuster and boom problem solved.

[@rebeccaharris3374]

Love your voice and content

[@JohnnyInferno1]

I need pictures of John, because either he is pure of heart....or unbelievable handsome 😂

[@liamfoxy]

Ghostie never haunted a clean freak. I know people that woulda beat his ass back to the underworld for getting that dust on everything after they just cleaned 😂

[@joshuaprimeaux610]

When i had jury duty i got hit by a car outside the court house and i still had to go

[@h1ckjam3s]

MR CREEPS FTW!!!

[@JustinGray-ti2vo]

Bad ass story !!!! 👍👍👍👍

[@alexanderp.goddard5722]

I think the first part of the title is scary enough as it is, it didn't need more.

[@riptantorn5337]

I like turtles

[@abeminslow4085]

That did NOT go the way I thought it would

[@AngelofDarkness1978]

Awesome content Creeps thank you for sharing much love and respect 😊❤

[@LadyNikitaShark]

Always have salt stones at home ❤

[@gracielahernandez4978]

Great story and love your voice for narrating.

[@jackdurden466]

32:46 I’m predicting that it’s a demon who has all over it, what would be ashes from something burned in hell..

[@aprilmcpherson-vanraalte5590]

Love you Mr. ❤

[@samueltaylor3909]

This was a good one. Very original and thoroughly enjoyed ❤

[@notchocolatemilk2483]

LOL 10: 28 is my birthday o’clock, that gave me a shock! 😂

[@unknownmachinax2748]

Do you guys think the reason the other jururs died was because the entity knew what they were trying to do after the first 3?

[@majortiergamerelite294]

%1000 what I thought. Went looking in the comment for thus specific comment

[@alniahjohnson8494]

I think they just messed up the ritual somehow... if they all had to do it all 10:28, that means it was all happening at the same time... they probably said the words wrong or didn't spread the salt correctly or went in first.

[@katherinezuber544]

Amazing!

[@darkangel6742]

Hey, M.C!!!

[@andrewcolona8523]

LOOK MA I FUCKING MADE IT TOP MA FUCKING 20 WE FUCKING DID IT RICK FLAIR WOOOOOOOOOO

[@shitneyb5562]

Andrew this is your mother. What did I tell you about wooing? Go the fk to bed, now.

[@donnadunlop7853]

Thankyou 🖤 🖤

[@juanpineiro4507]

After listening to this I suddenly want to watch drag me to hell again

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

Double D: That's Disturbing

[@kcarano7858]

1 million coming soon i feel it!👏🏽🤙🏽

[@jbear3478]

Oh dang you took some Benadryl before this recording

[@TattooedPink]

Cheers 😊

[@paulaleonard936]

Good story, just shows you be careful what you believe in, and there probably is some truth in voodoo, we just never know......Peace & Love from Scotland 🤍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿💙

[@roamingfree6968]

The monotone voice puts my to 😴 sleep.

[@roberttanguay8532]

Well told 👏👏👏

[@no.1.2.u]

I would like to thank you for this story especially the part where you mentioned my ex girlfriend's name (holy cow like 1st and last blew my mind for a second lol but I'm not telling online) motherly known as my baby mama lol and how you unknowingly, literally innocently made this story way more uneasy than it really would have been if her name wasn't used in this story. Not to say it's a bad story tho. Not at all. 😅

[@einienj3281]

Thank You 🩵🩷💜🖤

[@strgazerlilly]

🍷 Why did I have a little bit of Déjà vu with this story, Mr. Creeps? Congratulations to the author 👏 👏Bravo $or still being here Mr. C I started getting notifications for your channel again I was very happy too🍷

[@pattou2175]

It is kind of cute that they're trying to convince us the story is a real thing. Other than you gave us plenty of evidence to find who you are and what case this is

[@michelepruitt3145]

Hey Creeps looks like you'll make it to 1 M subscribers by early Autumn! 🤔🤗 So Excited!!! 🥰😁

[@indiaaycox5330]

I hate voodoo misrepresentation

[@dazdilinger1151]

Wife breaks vows cheats on husband is killed because of her ap and caused her sister in laws death husband charged with murder Hear me out maybe just maybe oh didn’t do it😂

[@oversizedspeedbump9375]

paranormal activity: crack addict

[@LeeroyPorkins]

Tune in next week for "Run When You Hear The Bell Belch."

[@src6339]

Is that tacho reference 🤔

[@SirSmorbie]

The singsong AI voice doesn't keep my attention. It's annoying. And if you aren't AI, I'm sorry I called you boring.

[@christinedigregorio1449]

You all should watch the movie narfariouse there are 2 movies with the same name you want the one with the man in jail awaiting execution but first must be considered sane knowingly committing these crimes on his own knowingly knowing what he was doing bit in the end seems a demon was at play nafariouse is the name

[@ddbob1]

You knowbthis was going sobqell up until the explanation was just voodoo nonsense. I thought we moves passed that as a horror trope.

[@aWitness33]

#slenderman ... #belief #bondage

[@shitneyb5562]

Well that escalated

[@tr4sh248]

sup chads

[@designationc6042]

I felt bad for his wife until I heard cheating

[@blacksuite1]

2/5. The guy in the story does to many dumb things for it to be enjoyable to me. Great job reading it.

[@cadillacdeville5828]

Yippee 😁😊

[@meTj2]

The average male height on the planet of earth is 5’ 5”

[@aaronweaver9751]

Another reason why I avoid jury duty. Where's the Winchester Brothers? Kudos to the narrator and author.🎉🎉

[@anastasijajelic3298]

Discuss the case or shut up. Why did you came here then 😅

[@andylipsco9783]

Way way way to slow pass dislike

[@kathymcguire8287]

❤😮😮😮❤

[@arstotzkanplaguedoctor]

🎠

[@happymonkey420]

✌🏼🐵✌🏼

[@AliasReads]

Hello! New Narrator Need FeedBack!! This is a greedy self promo which brings many shames upon my cows! I'm a new narrator, editor, sfx, music, and ambience maker. I would love more feedback on my material!

[@dazdilinger1151]

I’ll give you a shot if I like I’ll sub

[@pajserlatacchini9400]

Bro I love these storys that begin where they say names and blah blah will be fake cuz its ilegal to say them for what ever reason, and they tell you the country the date the situation the rank the branch where they work sometimes even the city 😂 if this was real life you could figure out where the story happend and who is telling it or who is in the story or whats it about 😂 its funny and cringe when a story starts like that.