I Made Minecraft Genuinely Horrifying

[@Rodelicc]

subscribe if u swag

[@XrCreateMC]

its already invalid 😐

[@thatperson8126]

@@Rodelicc were you gonna add the modpack? i was gonna play it but i dont see it

[@NebulaticXD]

@@Rodelicc invalid again :( man i love this content bro

[@Demodog90]

Nah 800k btw I’m not begging by making more comments

[@Marduk-np5gq]

@@thatperson8126 same i still dont see it

[@neologicalgamer3437]

"I'm just gonna take him on a house tour" "Not right now man" I love how Rod and Herobrine are just buds throughout this lmao

[@thekingpotato346]

I only have herobrine BECAUSE im buds with him XD

[@sr.brigadeiro7718]

i think horror mods should try to build up an uneasy atmosphere that would be interesting

[@fil-_-]

That's why From The Fog is peak

[@thegunkiestofgunks]

Thats something a horror mod cant acomplish, because their HORROR mods not scary mods. From the fog for example isn't a Horror mod because it isn't an threat at the start. It is something that makes you feel uneasy and paranoid. Thats a SCARY mod.

[@Redley-jones]

Manbear mod is very good at that

[@mellowecho]

facts, just like the herobrine mod from the fog he takes a few minecraft days to start showing up and gets progressively worst as time continues

[@dhadasbfgabfu]

Gets boring quick@@fil-_-

[@thebluesavior]

What minecraft needs is something vaguely similar to Phasmophobia. You literally SEE what the monster is in the pictures before you even download most of these dweller clones, they don't build tension and aren't scary, and ruin any kind of imagination. After all, the scariest monster is the one you make up in your own mind. Modders should make a HAUNTING instead of a singular mob. Add invisible mobs that can rarely do shit or rarely eyes in the dark, freezing breath, etc. Give the impression of an evil presence instead of a normal physical enemy that can be fought with normal means.

[@mclovin2408]

I want an entity that is smarter, an entity that is almost afraid to be seen and that actively tries to avoid being spotted and that attacks only when it thinks you’re unaware of it, and it only ever does so very rarely but very effectively.

[@Birde_Draws]

If I remember correctly there is a mod that kinda has that feel, I forgot the name but it has insanity etc with invisible mobs

[@TiernanHousman]

​@@Birde_Drawsyeah dude. You go insane when doing certain actions and once you get insane enough you start seeing them, and the more insane you get they'll start becoming aggressive. Assuming I'm thinking of the same mod as you.

[@Birde_Draws]

@@TiernanHousman yea we're definitely talking about the same mod, do you remember the name of it?

[@emergencia9669]

@@Birde_Draws The one who watches? It resent update has like phantoms or smth like that

[@daderowley4514]

As Alfred Hitchcock once said “Fear is like a gun, there’s no tension when the shot is fired, but when the finger is on the trigger.”

[@DrUnfunny]

"I made Minecraft genuinely horrifying!!!" Zoom out to see 5000 clones of this exact video.

[@Tridentofmemes]

Reaal

[@menaatefadly]

He has become what he sought to destroy

[@Clancyyyy]

Cries

[@jdcleif8490]

The thing that really stuck out to me in this Modpack was the world itself. It genuinely felt unnerving, like you've entered a place not for you. It feels vaguely sinister, while somehow also feeling alive, but it almost feels like the world itself has given up on life. Basically, 10/10 world generation and shaders, 6/10 creatures.

[@gookietae8611]

bro tbh faxs

[@keekorsomthin]

"WaO a NeW dWeLlEr!!!111!!!1!!!!111" literally just the cave dweller but red, or with goat horns, or with green skin, or it crawls, or it's santa, furred, black, pruple... They're all the same, tbh. Exexpt maybe the ones that actually have something new/unique to them, then that's taken and now it's boring again. We need something new that has some true love put into it.

[@Rodelicc]

genuinely yeah

[@brguii]

you're forgetting the fact t hey make it spawn way too much

[@gabusdeux]

id suggest looking up the manbear from idk someguy. it looks pretty scary

[@qphobos]

​@@gabusdeux the way it imitates voices is truly terrifying af

[@thermochemist]

I think a good horror modpack would make the world seem empty mostly, with creatures like the Warden that only appear when you finally try exploring or going underground to find something. A mix of subnautica and how minecraft was in alpha days.

[@Sh0rt_F0x1]

Ah yes. Cave dwellers we need a different monster.

[@Rodelicc]

fr

[@DUMPSTERFIREEE]

@@RodeliccWheres your pfp?

[@Sh0rt_F0x1]

@@DUMPSTERFIREEE uhh do you mean where from. And if so just look up human alastor and this will be one of the top things that come up.

[@Electronic_one678]

@@Sh0rt_F0x1he wasn’t talking to you

[@Sh0rt_F0x1]

@@Electronic_one678 ?

[@redpanda7789]

Bruh really just gave herobrine a tour of his house like he's looking to sell

[@IVThesimple3436]

something that replicates the sort of lonely foggy beta atmosphere, just like a "Everything looks fine but something is kind of off here" vibe mixed with monsters that will rarely if ever do enough damage to kill you, a monster that fucks with you so rarely that you aren't sure when it's that or if it will be there is scarier than something you know when will be there, know what it looks like, know what it acts like, something you don't know see or understand is spookier than something you can identify.

[@FlyingBaco]

R/ihadastroke

[@BigHatLoganGaming]

If anyone needs a reference of the worst Minecraft horror experience look no farther than The Silence - annoying gimmick where playing the game gets you targeted nonstop - generic spooky-guy-chases-you focused mod - jpeg jumpscares that take up your entire screen every few seconds

[@thebluesavior]

That mod perfectly sums up what terrible "horror" is. Because it isn't horror. At best it's trying to startle you. Jumpscares are a cheap way to force a natural physical reaction instead of attempting actual horror. But I think it's worse than that, the mod throws everything at you immediately, anyone could see it's just not suited for real gameplay, but perfect for "THE SCARIEST MINECRAFT MOD EVER MADE" youtuber shorts and videos. I wouldn't be surprised if it was created specifically for views.

[@baphomutt]

it feels like a lot of mod creators are drawing from the YT era of Slender, Amnesia and FNAF (but missing FNAF's atmosphere, buildup, and use of jumpscares as an _actual_ game mechanic). Maybe seeing the big monster is scary for some people, but letting your imagination do the work is much more tense

[@FlyingBaco]

The silence is updated and way better than the one who watches or from the fog

[@BigHatLoganGaming]

@@FlyingBaco can you direct me to a video of the new silence? Preferably that doesn't involve a 30 year old white guy screeching full volume for ten seconds every time he gets startled

[@FlyingBaco]

@@BigHatLoganGaming there is a guy who did it and he has a 5 hour video. He is very calm and the mod is showcased really well (it’s a series he has) his name is Robert 45 I think

[@SmokeyMarshmallows]

I wish we had more stalker enemies, theyll watch and watch for long periods of time, you'll hear them before you see them, and you can't have a confrontation because thats a death wish. Run like hell because you can't fight and you can't hide. Id also love something that feels home invasive escque. Mainly though, just being stalked and having an atmosphere building up, no junpscares or random PNGs popping up on screen

[@soup3499]

I had an idea for one, that i've been trying (unsuccessfully) to prototype A horror mod based on the Pale Crawlers of various american descriptions. They have an actual state machine based around four variables: Hunger, Anger, Curiosity and Fear. When hungry, like if you killed/caged all the animals, they'll break in to try steal your shit to eat or kill your farm animals while you're not there. When curious they might break windows, doors, hit you while you're not looking and/or sneak up on you to observe. When angry, like if you chop all their trees, they attack and try to wipe you out, including ripping up your carpets and beds. When scared, like you fight back, they retreat and stare at you from a distance. I want to make something that reacts to you, and also messes with your head, breaks your shit and makes your life a real hassle instead of just- instakilling you

[@SD-ni9jh]

That's a really cool idea

[@turquoisephoenix6548]

The thing is with every mod like this is the fact you know exactly what's after you there's no suspense, they focus on the entity being "scary" instead of focusing on what actually makes horror scary, its exactly like cheap jump scares, there's no suspense or fear of being prey, that's what makes predator's in the real world scary too, you have no clue what is stalking you and they try to stay hidden, they arent just up in your face instantly the second they see you, the intelligence behind them makes them scary too, they strategize and how the world around them effects an attack and how they can use that to an advantage, no mods really have that essence of primal fear or unease of being hunted.

[@3SCAPER00M13]

I really would think that'd be the scariest horror mod for any game, to be honest. Being alone, stalked from afar by something you didn't even know was there, and it just... follows you. Keeps an eye on you from a distance, waiting for you to make a bad move. Then it gets you. Like an actual predator. I've always found survival / near-death stories with real animals scarier than monsters. It's scary because it's a real fear that has happened to people everyday since the dawn of time.

[@anonymousman34]

fun fact if you think yourself a warrior sent to fight the daemons it turns the game from scary to slapstick real fast

[@haunted_pixel]

15:40 Alright, THAT was COOL. If that's part of the Herobrine mod then that's genuinely one of the creepiest and coolest things I've ever seen from Minecraft horror.

[@pixelcoder]

First of all, the editing was really well done, especially in the intro. I need to learn how to do that lol. I watched the whole video, and you probably did the best job of making Minecraft actually scary from what I've seen. Having less mods is definitely scarier because you don't get jumped every couple seconds. I am glad to see TOWW included in the video. I am also happy to see you not actually get jumped by the real one, the hallucinations definitely were too frequent though. You actually were able to avoid him which is the entire point of the mod so thank you for that. I am curious which version of the mod you were playing. The video was really good man. Hope you get to 10k soon. If I think of any other good mods to include, I will let you know. But still make sure to keep the horror mods down. You don't want too many.

[@Rodelicc]

I can teach u some editing afterall i gotta know what software u use

[@pixelcoder]

@@Rodelicc I use davinci resolve

[@CamesGorner_YT]

@@Rodeliccwhat’s that song at the beginning lil bro 😭🙏

[@choutaro4567]

You found it?​@@CamesGorner_YT

[@thestoryteller1807]

I think the best type of horror for MC would be psychological/cosmic horror. Sadly, no one has done this yet.

[@blindedjourneyman]

I mean, cthulu fishing helps, and thaumacraft used to do cosmic horror well, but it aint gettin updates to newer versions, distsnt friends adds some good creep factor, if the mobs werent do fucking loud and high spawning subnsutica artic mod is great for the agressive fish that can eff you up if boating/swimming and not paying attention

[@skyhawkslcb18]

the old abyssalcraft mod from like 1.11/1.12 was cosmic horror i loved that mod

[@blindedjourneyman]

@@skyhawkslcb18 aye its an amazing mod, and the best part is theyll eff you up even if ya dont directly interact, with the mod. Demonic mobs catching me off gaurd and getting free hits cause they dont immediately shapeshift and do the screeching modern horror mods do.

[@thestoryteller1807]

@@skyhawkslcb18 Hey I've heard of that one, I'll have to check it out

[@drakewarrior1013]

The only problem with these shaders is they kill the lighting system. Torches don't look like they do anything.

[@tntluoi9115]

Bro, the only thing that creep me out is the shaders and the very bright light thingy suddenly appear and FLASH BANG me then disappear💀

[@imnotcreat1ve588]

A way to make something scary is that it needs to be subtle, quiet, there when you least expect it, not a direct threat and only a threat when you have something to lose. The warden for me becomes a bit more scary when i have about 30 diamonds and other stuff in my inventory

[@Beef_Cooker]

Ever since the first dweller came out, I haven’t seen a single normal Minecraft video

[@baphomutt]

With its recent behavior update, the brown stickman is STILL scarier than every other Xerox of a Xerox dweller

[@Ad4msonek]

​@@baphomutt if only it wasn't on the worst version, That's why cave dweller evolved (the one made by siverdx) is best

[@Xofol]

Hey I made a modpack with my friend that was litteraly horrific, and it just used some basics horror mods, but what really sold it was that I added two mods (or one i dont remember): A mod that made it so it is very dark outside and another mod that made the moon give different light levels depending on its phase.

[@DominicMixes]

Lately I have wanted a Minecraft horror experience similar to the horror game silent breath. I like how the game has a lot of abandoned structures and graveyards and most of the creatures from what I've seen come at you but don't attack unless you are too loud because of the microphone utilization. We need silent breath mods and data packs. the data packs will put in the games structures and the mods will put in the game's creatures, flashlight mod, and a new simple voice chat microphone utilization mod. One key part is that the monsters run at you but despawn when they hit you to emulate the game mechanics of silent breath and they should only attack when you are being too loud ergo forcing you to be silent. Also, you would want to have a new world generation mod that emulates the game's never-ending forest feel and have it be adjustable with the world type settings when you go to create your world. Now if my computer could handle silent breath, I would just play the game instead of trying to recreate it in Minecraft.

[@Putridwizard5464]

What may make Mc scary is like if the dweller makes a appearance without a sound like man bear

[@tftc97]

"I made Minecraft genuinely terrifying" *cut to that one buzz light-year meme with 500 copies of the same character*

[@JacobWassup]

3:10 nah bro I think you got stuck in the berserk eclipse :skull:

[@ackreikthecouncils.6449]

GRIIIFFIIIIITH

[@bottleofcat]

Nah did you actually type :skull: bro just use the emoji 💀

[@keztannis6848]

​​​@@bottleofcat_💀_

[@dark-oc5ln]

**💀**

[@Sk-mo4qu]

Why is bros emoji drunk😭​@@keztannis6848

[@Plutoniumisconsumeable]

We need a silent monster that stalks at a perfect distance so you don't know whether you saw it or not leading to more panic

[@unknownraven9574]

My opinion on this is that horror mods genially don't change anything about the game, they're just extras. I mean sure the first dweller mod tampered with the ambience inside the games, but honestly Minecraft itself isn't about just caves. They need to catch you off guard and when you just do somewhere or wait for the night for them to actually "work" is like being forced. They need to change Minecraft like it's biomes or make new ones, there needs to be a variety of creatures that work differently depending on the biome with you having to find out yourself how they work. More than anything, they need a purpose. Simply scaring you isn't a good purpose so there also needs to be an objective, whether that is sealing a specific creature from the biome you're in or just unlocking gear to fight it off. Those I think are some good examples to put into practice for a mod to actually be scary

[@Qszavier]

those 10yo on your comment section were the real dwellers

[@captainmorganiv1034]

The psychological horror angle that you stated was effective in your last video... That's exactly correct This modpack, is scary. I can tell it's scary, because you can get scared when a monster ISN'T there.

[@casualsleepingdragon8501]

"Imma make minecraft scary" *permanent blindness debuff*

[@SprayInk-Kreatïv-Nouveau]

I have always been afraid mobs staring at me, so the scariest mod that someone could make for me is one in which every mob stares at you from a distance.

[@oryshit8405]

Istg friends just make horror games look like a comedy show

[@thomasseamenacetoysgamesan155]

We need a dweller that uses psychological horror, messing with your mind, something truly horrifying, like a child playing with it’s food, it would practically never attack, just toying with you, building tension, and when you think “oh it’s not gonna attack I’m safe” it attacks and you have a panic attack.

[@ThamyRose19]

Well to me you described the Manbear.

[@pado7526]

Im pretty sure what you described happens in this video many times

[@SamHahaBob]

Herobrine being friendly, how cute 14:51

[@nemesisalex9424]

Just a mob or two isn't enough to make a game scary imo.the sanity mod is actually pretty good at delivering some spooks with the audio hallucinations, but the sanity ghosts are more annoying than scary (too much HP always aggro on you when really low on sanity). The from the fog mod is also neat for spooks and scares, but once you realize briney isn't really a threat it loses a lot of impact. Dwellers can be scary, when the thing doesn't just spawn out of nowhere with loud music just to kill you because they add tension, but rarely work to build said tension over time and just fnaf jumpscare you.

[@BearBearYT]

4:27 “ZEUS!!!” Ahh light

[@flames.5711]

Herobrine always makes me nostalgic lol. By the way, great video!! :)

[@theoneandonlymr.d]

minecraft needs a proper psychological horror that builds on its existing psy-horror elements (isolation, cave sounds, weird glitches, etc.)

[@xnukdctecz7199]

17:20 **not now dude** this got me lmao

[@lowchlna]

watching ds on my deathbed buh

[@derp_128]

Let me grab the lotion and tissues

[@Wimpykid2345]

Yes

[@oskarnowicki56789]

?

[@zaney8469]

🧐🧐🧐🧐

[@PoF0200]

never in a million years did i think we'd take herobrine on a house tour

[@Jamsteo]

Ayyyy a new video from the Legend himself

[@Rodelicc]

much love❤

[@imnotcreat1ve588]

The most scary things is villagers in realistic texture packs. Those things need to be exiled to the center of the sun.

[@Rencer_1217]

You know we have been doing alot of Dwellers we need the Hunters like The Night Hunter, the Cave Hunter and the Goatscared idk some names I came up I'm just imagining the hunters

[@Biggi19]

15:43 I think from a KZbin I saw that’s part of the Insanity Shaders where trees will get stripped from all leaves every once in a while

[@Heavvyrain]

I feel like more "horror" mods need to do more to unease and put fear into the player rather than just getting a little bit of a jump out of them. For example, The Manbear, it gives a sense of paranoia because you never know when its just watching you, but it is

[@xenoscout9319]

when everything goes silent, you know something is really wrong.

[@Entropic_Deity]

TOWW is probably the best horror monster mod out there right now.

[@Entropic_Deity]

Guess what? You're one of my favorite Minecraft KZbinrs now because of TOWW. That's crazy low standards for Minecraft, because of how vast the numbers are, and how massive some are. You have good horror taste to be honest

[@insertthing684]

Consider unbinding the zoom key, perhaps? I'd imagine it'd make distant entities *far* more unsettling if you couldn't see them properly. Alternatively to using a zoom key, maybe try obtaining a spyglass as a progression milestone.

[@awesomestgamer4075]

"Simp we put it it's becoming evident that Minecraft Pokemon no longer..."

[@catergamer1]

your personality is very suitable for these types of videos, the perfectly cut screams are what get me

[@Rodelicc]

ty

[@deadlydelusion.]

deep blood is genuinely a horrifying mod you should add it

[@lor1den627]

chicken, corn and pineapple sounds fire not gonna lie

[@kou3803]

idk why people immediately assume you're "hating" when you critic something. modders do work hard, but that doesn't make them immune to criticism and you have valid points in that regard.

[@daderowley4514]

Also btw, if you want a good example of horror that takes its time to get under your skin, break your spirit, and keeps you scared every time you play… then I recommend play the Mortuary Assistant. Genuinely one of the most disturbing games I’ve ever played and actually chickened out on. It’s basically takes the unsettling profession of working a mortician’s assistant and combines it with the lingering threat of demonic possession. The game is very unpredictable and its paranormal events are randomized which keeps it scary as you can’t just simply “get used to it”

[@WizardMan420]

Horror mods are either only scary in theory like with the cave dweller, fast running and loud and it will just kill you or its a pathetic little creature thats easy to kill

[@kyceessadki2501]

the leaves dissapearing is a feature of spooklimentary, it's not a bug, it's intended and it is really cool, especially if you don't know about it

[@Rikseli]

18:33 that achievement is funny for some reason, you wouldn't expect it from a horror mod pack.

[@NecromanzerGaming]

Nahhh this channel is mad underrated, Also this modpack looks very good for a series.

[@zqkery6017]

i swear i heard “music” this could POSSIBLY be carti 😭😭🙏🙏

[@Rodelicc]

[@frankthetank6298]

bro did NOT link the mod pack in the description

[@isaiahbar9324]

I like how it fits the Minecraft style yet still being horrifyingly

[@bremalerage5935]

For me, at least Minecraft gets scary when you think you’re not alone in a single player survival and that’s what I think they should do with mods that indicate horror in Minecraft

[@Ezkex]

im literally craning my neck to watch this masterpiece cuz my glasses are air drying so everything isnt a fawking smudge

[@okbutwhatif9905]

The problem I have with spooklementary is the game becomes impossible in caves.

[@TheSinisterMachine]

Wow, the shaders do change everything, bbbbuuuuuttttt, WE CHILL

[@DanzTheGB]

I didnt know herobrine was chill like that

[@sam8687]

Intro was fire

[@paehlovesyou3694]

The distorted Minecraft music ties it all together.

[@양승원-n4k]

"i should call kevin" is such an obscure reference lmao

[@Gana_cz]

I think that the shaders are little bit too much dark

[@OG-ZirfyGaming]

The *WALTUH* jumpscare was hilarious

[@InvTest3022]

i think it would be better if there was a modpack that focused less on cheap jumpscares, and more on setting the mood along with suspense and other things. not that it'd matter to me, i'd be painting my chair brown eitherway

[@blademasterzero]

This was just one of those regular horror content farm video’s but with less jump scare spam? And a slightly better shader I suppose

[@Rodelicc]

best believe it

[@TheOldCheese]

Im too wimpy to even go to the area where the horror mods will do anything

[@rainix7817]

i find it annoying when people overreact and act so slow to actually try to make it scary. I played with similar mods and it was rarely scary.

[@xtonev]

-Me wondering how you play when its so dark -Meanwhile my phone screen on 20% brightness

[@trinityadams2733]

One thing you never do with something inhuman or supernatural... You never taunt it, I've seen enough Sam and Colby to know not go taunt something supernatural or inhuman, especially one that's stronger and faster

[@hesliterallyme.]

By the way I recommend with the "from the fog" mod with herobrine to set him to spawn extremely rarely because that way its more scary and less annoying (and for him to appear for a split second)

[@TheOriginalXPTV]

that renault soundboard got me fucked up 👨‍🦯

[@masterofbloopers]

Finally, someone put their money where their mouth is! I'm not saying I disagree with the criticism of Minecraft horror mods, but I like when people offer a solution to the problem they're critiquing. Even if it's just a mere suggestion, it helps.

[@Phethrao]

Dweller survival 101: 1. Keep blocks on you at all times 2. Never stay out past dawn 3. Don’t go far from home goofy 💀

[@Brute_Studios]

Neat mod! It'd be nice if I could SEE it.

[@waterfox1210]

I think a mod with ONE entity that fallows you doesnt get up all in your face, it should drive you mentaly insiane

[@NameTaken-l10]

10:52 nobody gonna talk about the knocker is just standing there staring

[@Talkination1]

minecraft mods have the potential to be genuinley horrifying but most mod creator just dont know how to make it

[@uneditedcontent4864]

you should try the silence its an intresting mod that relys on how much noise the player makes

[@forever-dreaming4062]

Idk how much of this is the shader or the mobs actually being terrifying lol, cuz I played vanilla minecraft with insanity shaders on and that was pretty scary. It's really good at making the game feel unsettling

[@Joshua-di8po]

W song choice for outro man

[@anubiscerberus4348]

If HP was real, my eyes would have lost 2% of their total health just trying to see half of the video when it was night, I SWEAR, MY EYES HURT. And, oh well, I can't take "Minecraft horror" videos seriously anymore, BUT, you installed the right mods and created an agitated atmosphere, kudos for that. The day I see a horror mod with no monsters, or a minimal amount of them, giving more protagonism to the ambiance, I will applaud it.

[@danem2215]

Hearing Europeans trying to adopt a hood accent is so funny to me

[@projectincomperablesloth3324]

15:43 >Has supernatural event happen in front of his eyes >Confused >Event stops >Goes back to building Maybe the most nonchalant person ever?

[@unusual_sandwich]

The nonchalant dreadhead

[@Logical.Psychopath]

I will not play a modpack that does not have distant horizons in it. Once you play or even see distant horizons with shaders, you will never go back.

[@boogie2]

The most horrifying thing in this mod pack, is what they did to the sheep 💀

[@p3ngu1n24]

I like ur video style, kinda entertaining aint goin lie

[@WesleyDekoningZzZ]

I love you're videos bro keep it up