I Paid 3 Designers On Fiverr To Design The SAME Website... 🥸 | Saptarshi Prakash

[@jamiuaderinkola5963]

Thank you so much for featuring my design! My work is Submission 3, and I really appreciate the valuable feedback you’ve shared. It’s great to see it highlighted on your channel! :)

[@ffvlog369]

good design

[@Ayush54407]

Presentation was good

[@MuhammadQasim-bu8lc]

Good. Keep it up your work.

[@priyankamahto1964]

BRO GOT NO CHILL JUST ENJOYED THE PROCESS AND LEARN FROM IT . NICE BRO KEEP IT UP

[@hit_bheda7]

bro honestly you did damn good work! it just work it look good and really nice

[@karthik_tbh]

After watching this video, I realized that I had underestimated myself all these days.

[@Ux.utsavv]

trueeeeee

[@MadhavanMaddy-n3e]

😂

[@IamShashi98]

So True 😂

[@RonithBurman]

Feeling same 😂

[@lyricalkb]

Indeed, I can relate. can I have your Instagram handle?

[@niwashlarc4599]

I still can't believe that the 1st Submission was a paid work.

[@adarshss516]

True 18 to 20 k dude, i was working on the project and the client was not ready to pay after the 5 iterations, amout was just 4 k

[@gazitalks]

He is a developer and entered the design world to earn extra money. Thats why the design was like this

[@Ux.utsavv]

true why these peoples doing this rofl

[@GlorytotheGod-i3i]

@@gazitalks bhai.. wo designer aap hi hona? :D waise not bad compared to the rest 2 designers

[@gazitalks]

appko kaise pata chala?

[@asadmehmood6173]

After watching this video and seeing the final design, I realize that discussing design is easy but actually doing it yourself is a whole different challenge.

[@md_sathik]

💯💥

[@designerdude07]

very true

[@iintore]

Thought i would see something different at the end too 😂lol

[@sakshamshrivastava4599]

These type of designers get money meanwhile talented designer are working for 10k per month

[@adarshss516]

True

[@Shirokokun]

10k ? Bruh I worked for 3k for two months :)

[@souvikdey9425]

Interned unpaid for 6 months

[@KitchenPlatform]

Sorry if it hurts... yours is not really that good either lol...

[@VishalPawarR]

I agree his design feels basic and not vibrant with color

[@talhasaeed]

As a product designer, you should show the full page of your own entry too. After seeing yours, I don't really prefer it either, except for the color you chose, which suits Gen Z, but UX-wise, not so much.

[@ranjithgaddhe9818]

Hi how did you comment like searchable GenZ

[@shubham_M7777]

Sir, how to choose between 3-4 skills? I'm confused and dropout because of health issues 😓 lot of confusion coding (web developer, app developer, data analyst) vs designer ( graphics designer,ui/ux designer, product designer, logo, thumbnail, book cover designer etc) vs writing-copywriter, content writer, blogging etc which is better? Which can be better for freelancing? Because I'm dropout and for jobs you need required qualifications, degree etc Can I get job without these? It is possible, or i need to do freelancing for lifetime? How to make career in freelancing, how convert it into a full time business? Please reply, guide 🙏🏻

[@yesh2817]

​@@shubham_M7777 bhai apko kya skill pasand aya he vho choose karo. Sab skills me paise he app skilled he tho . Koi bolega ea skill choose kiya tho vho apko pasand na aaya tho dikkat ho sakta he

[@vinusharannavar]

Please please we need more and more of such review sessions, not necessarily paid freelancers designs, but these sessions are so insightful to learn how to think like a designer. and yes we need your version of design in detail.

[@adibalam706]

yes, this is what a designer needed the most

[@marufurrahmanabir9642]

After watching this video, I realized that I had underestimated myself all these days. I've been working with coaches and photographers who have been featured in VOGUE and they really liked my work and thanked me for the effort. I should start charging more.. (I charged around $1000 to 1500 per website and took around 1 to 2 months)

[@MuhammadQasim-bu8lc]

That designer after watching the vedio = 🤬🤬🤬🫨🫨🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮☹️

[@yas_art]

Love how you reviewed them very detailed and constructive with rich feedbacks! It's a let down that designers of such low quality and morality are getting orders while we're sitting ducks as fiverr's algorithms are ruthless for new designers. WOULD LOVE TO BE ALL IN, IF YOU DECIDE TO DO PART 2 CHALLENGE!

[@TheUniqueJ]

The design you made does not have a prominent CTA button that grabs the attention.

[@prashantDMM]

🤣

[@aabidfaiyaz]

Sapta Bro, I would encourage you, to have the brief of the landing page, made available to all. That way. No matter what sort of a designer, someone is, they can learn to do something from themselves… I feel, you should add the brief in the pin comments.

[@philipwilliam477]

Irony is your not a genZ and looking us from a 3rd person view and commenting. As a GenZ we dont need various pop up colours layouts animation and cool vibes like you described. Clean sophisticated simple and one highlight to attract is enough

[@madhavkhandal3353]

In my opinion, many developers are shifting into UI design as a way to earn extra money. Most of the designers selected weren't fully dedicated to UI/UX design; they were either graphic designers with basic Figma skills or developers. This trend is increasing competition in the market, and as a result, skilled and dedicated UI/UX designers are being overshadowed by them.

[@Tanish.Agrawal]

Fr many of my colleague are developers but they are also doing designing as it is most needed skill in industry now and the worst thing is they don't even use any design software not even figma they just start developing and make design in their mind

[@madhavkhandal3353]

@@Tanish.Agrawal most of the startups do the same. In my last company, I designed something, the changes are made directly in the code and the result is shit.

[@SrishT]

Can't agree more. The result is pretty evident on every recruitment place online where there used to be some 10's of applicants previously but now the count has rosen to 100's soon after a role has been posted. God knows how many of them are really deserved for the position

[@opsnax1468]

Now we need the next part where you designed this ❤❤

[@Ucreator1519]

Amezing video sir I am a junior UI UX DESIGNER . This video inspired me to understand colour and typography. Once Again Amezing video ❤😍❤

[@ajeshvshari3445]

Heyy🙋‍♀️ i am also an UI UX DESIGNER. How is your design journey going? Happy to see an junior ui ux designer as me😊.. why not get connected through maybe linkedin , behance or may be instagram?

[@SuccessSeedss]

im actually very insecure about my work, may be my employees made me belive that, mostly because i learned uiuxby my self, never taken any paid class because what i wanted always in the internet. so i was saying that this video made me belive that my designs are not that bad. i always use variables , responsive , all the elements in figma. for me this this actually an inspirational video . thank you for that. ❤❤❤

[@ffvlog369]

i need full video of you designed new landing page from those 3 design

[@asphaltgamingchannel1325]

In your second design, there’s no sticky CTA, which you had mentioned would be included. Additionally, from my experience, not everyone has a developer’s eye to spot details like sticker cuts. In the first design, you used a sticker cut for the food image but not for the others, which feels inconsistent. It's one thing to evaluate a design, but another to judge the work itself-there's a fine line. Honestly, I learned something valuable today. Giving constructive feedback is helpful, but judgment isn’t always the best approach.

[@Sindhu3004]

I’m stunned at the cost. Have I been underselling myself

[@riteshbumbak133]

Sapta we want to see more data heavy stuff, UX Saas or data heavy products. What's the mindset should be while designing those products. How should we even approach them.

[@funindia6666]

I would like to suggest you few things 1. I think you should made the teaser much smaller my be 20 sec 2. You would have given more information about the project you gave to the designers 3. Slightly improve your audio quality (the higher tone of your voice feels little louder) I think it would help you :)

[@isanskari]

I would love it if we could see your design for longer. Maybe you can put the Figma file link in the description so we can check it out for ourselves.

[@harinijagadeesan6066]

I absolutely loved this video! I have an idea: why not open a challenge for your followers to create some simple and fast designs for a homepage or something similar? You could review the designs, which would help us improve and learn more through an actual project.

[@surjeet-f8v]

wtf how this guy dont have million subscriber

[@gauravrayakwar1993]

Personally I'd encounter roadblocks designing UI for a brand that does NOT have a logo or identity defined already. UX is another matter and probably would be possible although this process isn't optimal. Love these Audit like breakdowns in UI/UX.

[@AnisQureshi-s3j]

Great work, Saptarshi! Your insights on UI/UX are super helpful, and your content keeps getting better. Looking forward to more awesome videos from you!

[@Mathan.design]

even i accepted your all point, but final your version color also i don't like think its match with this theme. but visuals are good

[@aijazbir2010]

After watching this, I stopped doubting my designs 💀

[@Gdeepanshu_]

It’s concerning to see subpar design quality being offered at such high rates. Many freelance designers seem to lack a deep understanding of visual design principles, UX/UI best practices, and important design decisions. It raises questions about how they receive such favourable reviews and compensation when the work often feels like the bare minimum.

[@adityasshukla]

I wonder the same too! I was eager to see how would they tackle conversions and convey the value prop but I was really disheartened when I saw that their fundamentals itself are broken. They are gaming the system and pushing pixels for low-value, unaware clients. Sadly, the industry is now filled with such designers.

[@EXAML]

I think they do paid reviews for that

[@neji-hyuga-]

It's more about exposure. If u r more popular and highly rated, u can sell high. Great design is important but there are other factors that come to play as well

[@jeeldungarani5156]

My observation from this video is that nowadays, designers are becoming considered by how much resource of design and ui elements they represent and not the basic ux and ui principles.

[@akash007patel5]

Yes we want your version of design❤

[@saajidjiffrey7914]

And these guys are level 2, here I am that nobody even clicked my gig😢

[@ashrafultamim9166]

This insightful and highly informative video is perfect for beginners looking to start their journey as a UI/UX freelancer on Fiverr.

[@yashranpara6887]

You’re spot on with everything you’ve reviewed. I would also like to add that the 3rd designer has copied few things from his previous designs or from community designs because of the colour differences and also the form has yellow colour in the Icon for agreeing terms and also the foodie logo in the mobile responsive design.

[@AmanKumar-ji1cv]

Please make your version ❤ I am waiting for it 😊👍🏻

[@SunlitGaze]

Bro, i don't know what stereotype you have of genz but i actually like simple websites better rather than flashy websites which are harder to watch and interpret.

[@shine7835]

May be he thought genz watches nickelodeon

[@adibalam706]

really worth it video this is my first experience in this channel and guess what Now I am going to be a regular viewer of this channel because this channel will me to improve my skill

[@soul_l]

Okay, first one gave me some confidence and faith in myself, lol. I am trying to design my first ever website design and after seeing this I believe I'd do better than the first one.

[@anurajdwivedi]

Hi Sapta, I watched the entire video, and I found it very informative. However, I have one request: I would like to give it a shot myself. I will design the landing page for the influencer foodie meetup in Mumbai and share the design file with you for your review. I believe I can create something even better than the submissions you showcased in the video. Note for the audience: Design is subjective, and all the designs presented are commendable. Each design also has room for continuous improvement.

[@MohaMmedMQ]

Website without a branding 💀

[@heeynotok]

Do more video of this type so can learn what's type they should look like ..

[@theycallmequirky]

Yes we want the redesign part of final design

[@aviralkaushik9425]

Hi sir please make a full video for new landing page and also explain how can we choose colors based on requirement.

[@Ayush54407]

I like the second design but love the presentation or representation of third one ..

[@vasnthhere]

Now I am confident I can do better than this 😂..

[@ayaniegain]

me too

[@parthkabra8880]

4:25 we can easily see it's Smita in the sidebar dude

[@Createsphere-n4p]

Make a dedicated video on your version of landing page

[@Ux.utsavv]

damnn i learned alot you have a sharp eye for detail!

[@Mr_kiki0]

great and very informative video as beginner UI ux freelancer on fiver

[@Devisingh-wb9tw]

very Informative video thank you for making this video

[@chayankanungo2125]

Vary good thing, its very helpful for us 🎉🎉

[@adityasshukla]

You are too kind Sapta! None of the work here deserves to be paid imo. It seems that their fundamentals are wobbly.

[@artistad8109]

Since we are seeing the whole site at first glance rather than the 'first fold " I liked the submission 2 - the figma style and those strips of register now. But yeah, as you said, maybe they were calling too much attention on everything around. @

[@Tanvird555]

If you are having a color problem you should have told them the color you like to use.

[@saikatchatterjee5355]

Your design was really good, but i think I can add a bit more spark to it. Btw big fan of your content, you helped me learn Figma.

[@padmav7268]

Please post a detailed breakdown of your version.

[@dhairrya]

Drastic use of Figma layers naming like - Rectangle, rectangle, rectangle :'(

[@OrgRonakmh36]

I charge only 4000 for this design and better than all 3 fiverr designer

[@aghatechia]

Make a dedicated video on your design✨

[@prateekhota5759]

Again with such an in-depth critique of the designs. Absolutely loved this type of video Sapta and I hope we get to see these videos once in a while. Thanks for enlightening us with the color and typography knowledge and for the efforts you put into making this 🙌🔥

[@tarandeepsingh566]

Hey, I just wanted to say that everything in the videos was great, and I really liked all the points you mentioned! However, I'm a bit puzzled about the register button in the header and the hero banner. I’ve noticed that some big companies, like Headspace, do the same thing. I understand you’re enhancing user interaction in the UI, but I’m curious why they follow this trend. Would love to hear your thoughts!

[@trshani1110]

May be he designed this image in photoshop or in illustrator. what you think?

[@hemantchauhan6437]

Need tutorial on how you designed your own version

[@Str953]

I feel really good about my designs now

[@ishantyadav7630]

Every thing was perfect but your designs not too good compared to first one.

[@Saissh7]

What you learnt from this video? > No one is perfect in this world.

[@Afsharocksss]

Wow so impressive ❤

[@umarfarooque88]

How much time they took for submission???

[@arpanConYT]

bruh these are something i did 7 year ago and I'm not getting clients for 20k today -- now I am thinking why don't I put mydesigns on fiverr ... what the hell am I doing with my career!! if anyone DONT want to waste your money hiring AI image copy pasta wala designer, then I am here to work on your PROFESSIONAL project as a professional lol

[@vixy236]

you showed us a version of your website for 2 seconds

[@TomRiddle-pe2ho]

I have been learning figma for few months but consider me as user If i talk about thier design i would go for number 2 his rest of others things was all most good except he hero section and If i talk about rest of 2 design so number 3 is very simple design okk but i can also design like him 😵‍💫 he is very passionate person i think relly good thing. Number1 he was in a rush i think🤣 and he add so many stylish font in heading whic i feel not attractive By the way i am not pro like you but thats my opinion Bless for me

[@SharksNetworks]

@29:47 He is 🎉

[@Sarah-r4d7e]

I like the idea not sure abt the execution

[@Autolayout]

oh my god! I am so much better than those damn. I am underestimating myself for years now. TIme to dive into freelance

[@akadarshkumar6]

Getting paid to give your work for review is nice 😉😉😉

[@phantomberzerk9486]

I just started ux but i can tell what your going to tell beforehand does that mean this maybe the career for me?

[@shubhadipbhowmik]

None of the design is created by those freelancers but by him.

[@sriharshakoduru]

Will the society accept me if I say I liked the 3rd submission

[@KitchenPlatform]

Not at all, I really liked the 3rd one. It was the best design with no nonsense.

[@RahulJoshi-k5m]

Discussions and reviews on design were good. But the final design, I don't really liked it

[@Stoic1197]

Sapta this was a very Informative video! Will you please review my Design?

[@yashkalra6518]

i thought only my designs were bad but damn these are much badder 😂😂

[@Hemxnth_434]

Informative

[@AsianHousedecor]

🔥🔥

[@Sindhu3004]

How in Figma do we do the register button that appears on scrolling only

[@MadMonkeyWeb]

One possible approach could be to change the header when the user scrolls.

[@rockyrocz-q6w]

After so much of self judgement this youtuber himself forgot to put Register button down below for quick access on his own design, what a waste😅😅😂

[@KitchenPlatform]

I didn't like his design at all.

[@Metroroid]

The highlights looks clustered as hell

[@alifemranemon9785]

fiverr has some criteria for all the lavels. to get a lavel a seller must full fill all the criteria. there is no switch on/off 😅

[@Shanmu_s4]

First designer, Smita 87. So sad

[@princesalman5231]

it does not even look like a paid work

[@ayanshproplayer5559]

Worst thing i ge wants his personal Not Users you like this type Many Area have deferent deferent UI/ UX people like Zen Z Food Only fast food Why not other types of food i don't like Which Website don't give Choice and Don't don't get Details Bad and Good thing

[@classicaf]

I am a web developer and not a designer and I design better than Entry no 1 and 2, they should be ashamed for charging 20k for this bs

[@googlesai1]

I want to work with swiggy as a designer ❤

[@vixy236]

you paid 20k for first work? seriously? wow

[@ffvlog369]

very helpfull

[@Tomodachi-f5l]

2nd one is good i liked it

[@geminimanvfx]

Please get a pop filter, my ears exploded with my headphones on

[@anjumayoub9077]

fiverr is crap promoting sellers with mostly bad designs Please don't take my comment as rude but that's what I think about this platform. they should promote sellers based on the final approved designs from the clients and voting should be done by the designers.

[@TJ-jf1cq]

r/therewasanattempt - hiding the name of the designer