I Played and Ranked EVERY Insomniac Spider-Man Game

I Played and Ranked EVERY Insomniac Spider-Man Game! Now that we played through the BIG New Game+ Update for Marvel's Spider-Man 2, I figured it was a good time to do a tier list of all the Insomniac Spider-Man Games!
👓 - Sponsored by GamerAdvantage! Use code "Caboose" at checkout for 10% off: gameradvantage.com/?ref=CABOOSE
💬 - Join my Discord! You can interact with me and The Cavalry here: / discord
🔴 - Official Elgato Partner: e.lga.to/Caboose
📱 - Follow me on Twitter: / cabooseek
📷:Follow me on Instagram: / cabooseek
Check out my other videos on the channel:
Marvel's Spider-Man 2 - Insomniac Secretly Updated THIS: • Marvel's Spider-Man 2 ...
Marvel's Spider-Man 2 - IT'S FINALLY HERE: • Marvel's Spider-Man 2 ...
He Just TEASED Marvel's Spider-Man 3: • He Just TEASED Marvel'...
Suicide Squad Game - They FINALLY Said Something: • Suicide Squad Game - T...
📣: Logo Created By: / pixelflaregfx www.pixelflarestudios.com/
Like, Favourite, Comment and Subscribe!
ABOUT MARVEL'S SPIDER-MAN 2:
Launching Fall 2023, Marvel’s Spider-Man 2 is the next game in PlayStation’s critically acclaimed Marvel’s Spider-Man franchise. Developed for the PlayStation®5 console in collaboration with PlayStation and Marvel Games.
There are many Marvel's Spider-Man 2 Videos on the Caboose KZbin channel. Including: Easter Eggs and Things YOU MISSED for Marvel's Spider-Man 2, Gameplay Trailer Reactions for Marvel's Spider-Man 2, The Story of Marvel's Spider-Man 2, Speculation and Theories for Marvel's Spider-Man 2, alternate suits in Marvel's Spider-Man 2, the Symbiote abilities for Peter Parker and the Blue Bioelectric abilities for Miles Morales in Spider-Man 2, Marvel's Spider-Man 2 DLC Teases and SO Much More!
#SpiderMan #SpiderMan2 #SpiderMan2PS5

[@Caboose]

Including the DLC from Spider-Man 1, how would you rank the Insomniac Spider-Man Games?

[@turkiyeBAell]

Caboose pls reply to this comment: whyd U put Spiderman 2 in the thumbnail in D tier

[@Yourgreatgrandma2]

@@turkiyeBAell for more people to view the video

[@fantapro23]

6. The Heist 5. Turf Wars 4. Silver Lining 3. Spider-Man 2 2. Spider-Man Miles Morales 1. Spider-Man 1

[@brockscape2355]

This guy is desperate for views

[@wumbowyatt2300]

@@turkiyeBAell Probably to make the haters mad when he puts it in the very top

[@tyleroutland435]

1. Marvel's spiderman 2. Marvel's spiderman 2 3. Marvel's spiderman miles Morales

[@tyleroutland435]

And I loved the story dlcs in Marvel's spiderman

[@thegreatacolyt1277]

I think the second game is the best

[@thegreatacolyt1277]

​@@tyleroutland435yeqh

[@Problemchild220]

Spider-Man 1 was a menace it’s og and all so I get that opinion but Spider-Man 2’s story was better than 1 and the gameplay was way better than both of the Spider-Man games but your opinion does fit it doesn’t really matter if you put 1 over 2 or 2 over 1

[@tyleroutland435]

@@Problemchild220 I agree

[@DanFarrell98]

I'll never understand how people can't like Spider-Man 2 I was constantly blown away by the gameplay and story throughout. It improves, or in on-par with, everything from the other games

[@macwelch8599]

Story wise, I think Spider-Man is still the best, but all the games are masterpieces

[@josemolina3858]

What makes it better is that the story was original, everything had a normal paste but spiderman 2 story is so generic like how many times have we seen games were symbiote try to take over the world? It's old and plane I'm tired of it that's why spiderman ps4 2018 is still better than spiderman 2 ps5

[@Shahriyararin63]

@@josemolina3858 Nah that was a good homage to Web of Shadows the only problem is that it could have been longer not because we have seen it before. Fans had asked for it and we got what we wanted. Symbiote doesn't take over the world for no reason. Harry wanted to heal the world but the symbiote gave him twisted version what we wants as the symbiote thinks turning people to symbiote is healing the world. Symbiote sees thing differently then their hosts.

[@josemolina3858]

@Shahriyararin63 the interpretation is different but it still the same dianamic that has been used like spiderman for the ps1 and web of shadows and spiderman friend or foe., spiderman ps4 was more thought out and very well executed

[@Shahriyararin63]

@@josemolina3858 that's what I'm saying it would have been more well executed if the third act was longer

[@LorenzoC2314]

No they aren’t all masterpieces.

[@grbhighlights9401]

Spider-Man PS4 is like Batman Arkham City. It’s the best game of the series, because of the story. But we will play Spider-Man 2 and Batman Arkham Knight more because the gameplay is phenomenal

[@Shahriyararin63]

Actually Spider Man PS4 is more like Arkham Asylum. Spider Man 2 is like a combination of Arkham City and Arkham Knight

[@james_8583]

@@Shahriyararin63sm2 is not that good storywise

[@DarkLord-hl1fi]

@@james_8583It is it’s got strong moments

[@TrickyTalon23]

@@james_8583I enjoyed 2’s story more than 1

[@Skibiditoilet9894]

Arkham city’s story is so mid. Arkham origins has the best story

[@NadeemShekh-uy9zn]

The lizard in Spider-Man 2 looks fantastic

[@-Anonymous-.]

Yea the lizard is one of the best parts honestly

[@Amirm_]

The mobility, fluidity, and combat in Spider-Man 2 have been amazing. I'm loving playing New Game Plus right now, and it's getting me excited for the future DLC.

[@anthonyplaysgames8954]

Yes your very very very right

[@GhostofNykr]

I believe the dlc will be a carnage dlc with goblin hints at the end for a background story

[@rajamohanareddygayam5309]

14:55 THAT'S THE ATTITUDE WE NEED. Some fans are literally turning into haters because they're seeing people hate on it like the hell. This game is a masterpiece.

[@awesomeredpandax2267]

Yeah i swear people will literally switch on a limb because they were told the story was bad. Despite them having fun with the game

[@philipblaise5166]

Omg fr 💯

[@Ghostyplays53]

W

[@fantapro23]

Fanboys when you criticize their favourite game: 😱😭🤬

[@Motherofdragons4780]

Exactly!!!!

[@imaheadout2639]

Spider Man 3, Venom, or Miles Morales 2 should definitely be set in the winter again. The vibes of Miles Morales were amazing

[@GregoThe3rd]

Venom game nah,i think it should be purely night no winter or anything,spiderman 3 for sure though.

[@onyxwolfreaper21]

Honestly I agree with almost everything you said about the Insomniac Marvel Spiderman franchise, however I disagree with Prowler's mix and Phin's character- When I first heard the mix, I was vibing to it. I was genuinely shocked to find out that people actually hated it for some reason?? Like c'mon it's good dammit- Phin, while I wouldn't say she's the best character.. she's far from the worst. I felt her pain when she lost her brother, ironic considering I'm an only child. But still I love Mile's friendship with her, it's genuinely wholesome-

[@GregoThe3rd]

I dont know how you think its good its actual cancer to my ears

[@onyxwolfreaper21]

@@GregoThe3rd Agree to disagree, I personally like it. I respect your opinion tho

[@Mikey_dykes31]

Rank all the suits in marvel Spider-Man 2 now that new NG+ is out

[@jackson4612]

I find your channel through Spiderman 2 and I still watch you

[@Namehere215]

Peter’s biggest mistake: not giving harry venom Miles biggest mistake: making the evolved suit

[@shaunavant532]

Venom biggest mistake: not using the inches

[@DBLEGENDSSpeedruns]

Evolved suit was a trashpiece😭

[@abhinavgandham4883]

I still think my favourite is Spider-Man 1 but Spider-Man 2 is the most replayable for me just because the enhancements to the traversal and aspects of the combat make it hard to go back to the original. However, story and character wise, Spider-Man 1's story is just too good.

[@antoniewest]

The hype around the first game was legendary

[@SNS156]

Thanks to you I managed to get the collectors edition for spider man 2

[@Skywalker10767]

I really hope before Marvel Spider man 3 we get a prequel game showing the first 8 years of Peter’s career as Spider Man

[@Motherofdragons4780]

I would love that! Then if Peter does retire or die, we can still play as him one more time.

[@goth.baby420]

It's depressing people are forgetting Cindy already. :((

[@DelayfrmFL]

I love this video

[@jamesconway7695]

the evolved suit has grown on me

[@dymoure]

I actually LOVE the DLCs for doing something that no main story really does: It keeps things pretty small-scale. It feels like a mundane story. No “end of the world” stuff. I actually prefer drama like “is Felicia pregnant…?” over “ALIEN INVASION!!!” ANY day. It makes you feel even more like Spider-Man in my opinion. It forces you to overthink your life drama like Peter. In Spider-Man 2, I know I’m playing a game. But with the small scale-missions, it doesn’t only make me feel like Spidey, it makes Spidey feel like us. It brings back the vibes from the first act of the original 2018 game, like the ESU Halloween Party. But the DLC makes a whole story out of it. I love the pacing of the small-scale stuff from all the games, but the DLC is all relatively small. Oh. And the OG Peter face. I’m honestly never gonna be over the change. It isn’t “just an aesthetic choice,” it actually takes me out of the story. I don’t believe this is the same guy from the 2018 game.

[@grbhighlights9401]

1. Spider-Man PS4 2. Spider-Man 2 3. Spider-Man Miles Morales Spider-Man PS4 just had such better story, and writing. DLCs: 1. Turf Wars 2. The Heist 3. Silver Lining But the DLCs are very interchangeable

[@darksonicthehedgehog721]

I feel like all of these games are Masterpieces! The Spider - Man DLC’s for the First Game are kinda a hit or a miss honestly. But ya”ll cannot be sleeping on Miles man How DARE YOU ALL SAY THAT GAME IS A DLC YOUR ALL LIES! That game is NO DLC it is its own game and it’s Almost a Masterpiece! if the story was longer and if they could’ve changed Phin’s Character writing heck even had some DLC‘s in there then Miles Would’ve Easily been S Tier!! And before they move on to making a third game the very least that they have to do is make a sequel to Miles’s Spinoff game because I believe that game deserves a Sequel especially after the ending we saw in Spider - Man 2!

[@dj.elitez7591]

Perfect ranking

[@leyrxplays371]

I agree though Spider-Man 2 didn't have the best writing towards the end of the game it started strong but ended with me being kinda disapointed.

[@pinhe4d321]

Dawg why do people prefer video games nowadays for stories...

[@NadeemShekh-uy9zn]

Bring on Spider-Man 3 with green goblin, doc ock, carnage and silk

[@Nether_Child19]

3:51 Are you sure about that? 😂

[@Deadlierquill96]

I actually really like the whole robot hammerhead thing I don’t know why though I just thought it was cool I didn’t even know who Silvermain was before I saw people comparing them together

[@anoldweirdo7084]

spider man does the story really well, and the emotional bits really hurt, that fell short was spider man 2 tho, but the gameplay was amazingly done

[@tiffanyclark734]

Story for two was good

[@lumbago8]

Completely agree with you here. Only thing I would do personally is put the heist DLC in B tier. Just don't think it's on the same level as Miles Morales

[@wolfsaints]

Hey, maybe that’s why he was a robot cyborg thing cause there’s was some damage done when he “died” was brought back

[@spiderslayer2248]

man i do love all the games and insomniac are going some bad hacking but they still cook up amazing and great storytelling games . 10 out of 10.

[@ironwill48]

I agree Caboose!! Marvels Spider-Man 2 is a masterpiece!!

[@navya0412]

A freaking masterpiece 🔥

[@lavamason2863]

W vid and tbh all insomniac Spider-Man games are A tier or S tier

[@CRISPYPOP]

This feels like the end of an era

[@LOMAZKO7]

The best handled game in the series is no doubt Spider-Man 1 and its not really Debatable at all. My fav is Spider-Man 2 but sometimes just becuase of SM1's incredible story it makes it hard to choose.

[@technicalgamero9701]

SM2 is so so good.. i couldn't believe when some people online told SM2 didn't meet the expectation.. what else they wanted Spiderman to become Batman? Only 1 complaint i have in SM2 was combat was slightly slow (air yank, air throw felt bit slow) and creativity of gadgets during combat was missing like Sm2018.

[@rajamohanareddygayam5309]

fr man. Those dudes don’t know what they talking about

[@whereyomomat9366]

I love Spider-Man 2 idc to it a masterpiece fr

[@360smooth6]

All 3 games is my favorite I can't pick one over the other lol

[@elijahdrake9113]

how did u make this into 16 min haha

[@patrikdanheimer1504]

Spider Man 2 is the beat game I've played since The Last of Us part 2.

[@deadpool5928]

Honestly, Spider-Man 2 was the one I replayed the most out of all of them. I a hundred percent completed it every time I replayed it too, even though the more forgettable side missions, I love the game so much and I hope Spider-Man 3 lives up to some sort of hype, because there isn't much else they could do to really better this, but I trust insomniac to at least try making something that fans will love.

[@Marvel-Multiverse-xq3hs]

Miles fighting peter felt like a finale but then theres moree

[@liamn.7664]

without a doubt Spider-Man 2 is the best game out of the whole franchise even though there are still some little issues wit the storyline and overall gameplay, it is still a masterpiece 👌

[@dredre2684]

Spider Man 2 is the first game I got all trophies for

[@NadeemShekh-uy9zn]

Do a video on Spider-Man the great web

[@dariusjones6413]

I admit, they were out of their minds when they made hammerhead into a full body robot

[@SoulsInTheMINES]

The thumbnail really said spiderman 2 is the worst at d tier when its ✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓✓

[@CoffeePotGames]

1. Spider-Man 2 2. Spider-Man 1 3. Spider-Man Miles Morales Spider-Man 2 has the best gameplay no question. I already have well over 100 hours into it and I cannot wait for the dlc. There are issues, but the swinging and combat is god damn PERFECT

[@rajamohanareddygayam5309]

YES!

[@Jeoul]

Bro why does Peter’s mask in the Hellfire Gala suit have weird white outlining from a distance? It’s really off putting to me, to the point where I can’t wear the suit.

[@mistermatthewgamingpreside4186]

I do agree it is the best spider man game I ever played

[@Ray_9832]

The dlcs for spiderman took me at least 3 hours to complete

[@1243578690]

1. Marvel's Spider-man 2 2. Marvel's Spider-man miles morales 3. Marvel's Spider-man

[@mccm48]

i liked that teir list

[@tonyslife255]

I just want a venom insomniac game 🙏

[@Buzz852]

4:47 bro they are lightwork

[@AnthonySmith-bj9mo]

hi Caboose

[@DerrickAliyas]

Alright I've got this wheres UNCLE BEN where's the DAMN RICE

[@vancedenton3764]

I whole heatedly believe the people that are hating on Spider-Man 2 are people that speedran it in a day or two and didn't actually take the time to savor the dialogue and character interactions within this game.

[@fantapro23]

Well, you're wrong.

[@vivaraulito]

Nah from a gameplay perspective it’s the best one but from a storyline perspective the first one is better and they do more justice to Peter’s character

[@vancedenton3764]

@@vivaraulito hard disagree, but to each their own

[@fantapro23]

@@vancedenton3764 I agree with him

[@sillysebastianstudios]

@@vivaraulito it doesnt have suit powers so the gameplay is worse

[@Amir-mu5wl]

07:08 idk guys but i felt like the raimy suit is more like The New Animated series in 2003 to raimy verse

[@SlxmeLxss]

Marvels Spider-Man 2, Spider-Man PS4, Spider-Man Miles Morales

[@khodekhoda89]

Please rank bossfights too

[@1DAR26]

1. Spider-Man 2018 [Remaster] 2. Spider-Men 2 3. Spider-Man: Miles Morales What set Spider-Man 2018 remaster a part from the rest is the unique gadgets Peter could utilize. All of those crazy gadgets become useful in combat or stealth once you truly master them. Those who are fans of youtuber SoniSymbiotic would remember his crazy combo videos utilize those same gadgets. It's not just the gadgets, the abilities you can unlock for Peter as well in his skill tree. Like the gadgets and even the variety of Surges, they don't all make a return for Spider-Man 2. Getting into SM2, they shouldn't have made Peter and Miles play the same. Their Web-Abilities layouts shouldn't have been the same at all. Miles Morales video game first introduced this and it was a fine improvement... For Miles that is. Peter should've stuck with the gadget wheel he had from 2018. This would've made both characters feel unique and different rather than the same. That's why I liked their original games where they both had their own unique game mechanics to utilize rather than disregarding how Peter plays from 2018 and force him to play like Miles was originally created to be. Peter is just a Miles Morales 3.0 in Spider-Man 2.

[@travelledchain1316]

Still don’t get why people say Spider-Man 2 is copy and paste. A sequel to a game usually plays the same as the first because they are the same genre that’s how games work. What happened to people just casually saying “it’s not really my thing” rather than making up bs to crap on the game

[@thunderbolte711]

I do wonder how they will explain how the Carnage symbiote survives after you destroy the meteorite. Maybe there's more than one or he was simply out of the blast radius.

[@wumbowyatt2300]

The carnage symbiote i think was apart of the bigger venom symbiote in the tube harry was in so since the venom symbiote was not going to die when the meteorite was destoryed the same would apply to the carnage one.

[@thunderbolte711]

@@wumbowyatt2300 I guess that makes Sense considering Peter's anti venom suit survived

[@Blvdkova]

I feel like Spider-Man 3 is going to be their magnum opus they are about to put everything into that game it’ll feel completely different!

[@Matt-ek6bf]

16 minutes to rank 3 games is wild.

[@hasanqalib9530]

I literally finished spider man 2 new game plus in 2 whole days because I started on Friday

[@SaneU_c]

The best part of sm2 is the traversal

[@TheFlash_2014]

I think that from the 2018 game that started it all, it just got better each time. Marvels Spider-Man 2 is the beat out of all (in my opinion)

[@Nickiacampo59]

Spider man 3 about to be bananas

[@infinityguy16]

Or Miles Morales 2/Venom

[@Ray_9832]

The heist should have been a chapter in the base game

[@stadic5311]

I wish the black suit story line was longer and I wish miles lost the fight between them.

[@bio9104]

I had to skip all of it until the end cuz i still cant play the game cuz i cant get a ps5 but my hands are itching to play it🔥🔥

[@whosDaBun]

“EVERY” as in all 3 of them lmfao

[@dylanvandergriend04]

Insomniac could still add some skills like for peter having symbiote change like web of shadows and for miles i have no idea 😅

[@TrickyTalon23]

I liked Spiderman 2 the most too

[@hamzajamil3543]

Agree with this, spiderman 2 is a masterpiece and the story was really really good

[@daquariuschism5655]

I agree

[@isaacbeeks4637]

When black cat opens the door before the explosion she uses a smoke bomb. I just saw that.

[@GregoThe3rd]

I still dont get how she was fast enough a smoke bomb dosent give you the ability to teleport.

[@WrldhatesMEE]

Marvels spider-man is my favourite of the 3 but I can’t go back to it because im so used to the fast swinging and loading Of MSM2 that MSM feels slow 💀

[@tsuvariable2331]

I finshed spider man 2 in new game plus but i still need suit tech and golden gadgets but ive 100% is it a glitch?

[@Damienkpruitt]

am I the only one who doesn’t dislike uncle aaron’s beat? like bro it kinda hits lol

[@purson8]

I was playing miles morales while waiting for my copy of spider-man 2 to get delivered and I had one trophy left before it arrived but it was a pretty annoying one I think it was knockout x amount of players with remote mine, so I just deleted it and downloaded spider-man 2 and I still have not gotten the platinum trophy to this day.

[@Ray_9832]

Someone once said either save one or save everyone

[@ceejaydawkins7306]

I do understand what you mean. But, the quote was actually "when you help someone, you help everyone"

[@Ray_9832]

No it wasn't it was from across the spider verse

[@ceejaydawkins7306]

@@Ray_9832 Oh okay. Yeah, someone did say that in Spider Verse

[@JV_inthemix]

Mister Negative partly carried the first Spider-Man game for me. I hope he’s comes into the MCU since the F.E.A.S.T. Organization is in those movies. He’s such a cool villain and I’d like his story to be expanded, a terrorist crime lord would be great in the MCU.

[@anthonyplaysgames8954]

Then somehow Peter would have the anti venom suit in the next game

[@DanFarrell98]

They're all top tier games.

[@user-gt8rp3mg3t]

Are you sure that they are going to do a spiderman 3 next? I think since Peter is taking some time off that they might make a short miles morales 2. This is just a theory

[@ringo60643ify]

They should have added more swing mechanics

[@DarkLord-hl1fi]

It feels different that’s all that matters

[@lancelotanderson9813]

The symbiote arc is rushed tbh. Idk why they chose the WOS path and did it bad. WOS is an amazing game. SM2 couldn't do the symbiote part better than WOS. A 30-to-35-hour story overall wouldn't have been a problem. But nope they had to rush it to reach the deadline. I'm telling ya if Peter wasn't nerfed, story wasn't rushed, and Miles didn't get the trash suit then it's a masterpiece. Insomniac put a lot of bad stuff in the game. So, I can't say it's a great game. But the gameplay is really good. And as an experience it's a 10/10. But yeah, it got it's flaws. The first game's story is far better.

[@That_Dude1511]

I have a PS4 and I do wish I can play Spider-Man 2 but the first Spider-Man is just 👌👌👌 perfect 🤩 Miles Morales is a good game but I still think the OG game is superior

[@OdinLarsen738]

We need a Carnage DLC

[@francescogiordano5475]

Not ashamed to say they are all S tier for me top to bottom. SM2 may get even better if there are DLC plans.

[@anthonyplaysgames8954]

The symbiote is completely fine but at the end of the game Peter should have gave the symbiote back to harry then somewhere in the game the symbiote would have came out of harry like in the venom movie the you play as miles to defeat him again and maybe get harry and new spider man suit too before the final battle then you play as harry and miles to defeat peter

[@mohdsalmand1385]

I might be the only guy who loved Spider-Man 2's story better than other two games. MSM2's story felt more personal and never felt it was rushed. There are a few things that could've been better but still with those flaws it doesn't make it bad.

[@tylerlussier1896]

I definitely agree with you and I don’t care what anyone says Spider Man 2 is the best game they have made… is the story better than the first? I would say they are both tied I wouldn’t give 1 or 2 the edge… You can definitely have the argument about it being game of the year and in my opinion it was not the game of the year, But when compared to its predecessors it’s definitely better… This game will definitely be better looked at once all the DLC is released, It was the same with Spider Man 1. DLC was released and people rated it higher than it was before… If insomniac introduces Carnage in the DLC ITS GAME OVER! And I believe they will.. they teased Black Cat and she was in the DLC I believe all the characters teased in the second game will make an appearance in the DLC…

[@NadeemShekh-uy9zn]

I wish Kraven was a playable character in Spider-Man 2 as you hunt down and kill the sinister six characters like electro, vulture, scorpion and shocker and maybe rhino

[@edgarpuente1985]

Holy shi imagine

[@-Anonymous-.]

That’s what I said. Kraven hunting them. Mj chasing symbiote Spidey & then the Venom mission. Those should’ve been the ONLY alternate playable segments.

[@Ghostyplays53]

That would be a great dlc idea

[@dj.elitez7591]

Nah. There should've been missions where you play as Spider-Man racing to save your rogues gallery from Kraven.

[@-Anonymous-.]

@@dj.elitez7591 😂

[@samletsplaygames]

Peter being able to use his symbiote abilties before actually getting the black suit in the story in NG Plus is just dumb.

[@SadraG2008]

I agree with you 100% but the only problem I have with spider man 2 is that they nerfed peter so bad he stood up against sinister six on his own with 14 broken bones but in spider man 2 he gets stunned by a fridge and in most scenes he's spider sense doesn't work at all but overall the spider man 2 was a masterpiece

[@MartinMmm-ju1vj]

Rank the boss fights