I strongly recommend... A Brighter Summer Day (1991)

If you haven’t seen it yet, I strongly recommend A BRIGHTER SUMMER DAY, directed by Edward Yang. It is my favorite Criterion release.
*****
Opening credits music:
Mario Bava Sleeps In a Little Later Than He Expected To by Chris Zabriskie is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: chriszabriskie....
Artist: chriszabriskie....
Closing credits music:
Divider by Chris Zabriskie is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: chriszabriskie....
Artist: chriszabriskie....
*****

[@Helena081107]

For quite some time in my life (approx. 15 years), I watched around 20 films per month. Any genre, apart from maybe romantic comedy (except when it was from the golden era of the 50's) or science fiction (apart from the great Alien series or Kubrick or...well, the "better" exceptions), because I never cared for those genres. But the films were from anywhere between 1914 and nowadays. So I guess I've seen a LOT of films, from all over the world. Pretty much ALL of these films... I rented them from a tiny video-shop, now gone obsolete sadly. The owner is, purely by accident, a couple of years later, a customer of me nowadays, so I see him at least 2x a week. Both of us were a HUGE fan of "Yi Yi" (I even play the track at the end of the film (made by his wife btw) on piano regularly, and have the sheet music if anyone is interested, just send me a PM). Again, purely by accident, I hear from another film lover that FINALLY this film has been made available by Criterion, but as a blu-ray. The ONLY reason I got a blu-ray player, was because I have been haunting down this film for years... So I finally ordered it, post-poning my "holy grail of films" for months, and waited for the right day. What can I say? Almost every shot is pure film magic. 4 hours and yet the time flies by. And the best thing for me? I was able to give it as a present for the video-shop owner who hadn't seen it either. :) Some times all the stars in the universe just allign. Doesn't happen very often, but when they do, it's pure magic !!

[@Idonotsa49]

The best thing about quarantine is that I’ve had time to watch this film twice already, and plan on watching it at least a few more times.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Yes, this film is worth watching many times!

[@joannneusner5040]

I just watched it twice in 24 hours

[@jasonleetaiwan]

This film was popular in Taiwan, but I think the general population is unaware of the fact that it has been so well received on the Criterion Collection. When I tell them, they seem surprised and proud that something from Taiwan has made such an impact on world cinema.

[@juandong-ic]

I remember in March 1986, I was in a small cafe near Taiwan University. Edward Yang was there too, he was sitting on next table of mine and discussing the script with other people. After decades I still could remember his voice and appearance clearly. Greeting from Taiwan.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

OH MY GOODNESS. That is amazing. Absolutely amazing. I am so honored that you would share this story with us!!! Wow.

[@juandong-ic]

@@DaisukeBeppu Thank you very much for recommending this movie. The Chinese name of this movie contains the name of a street in Taipei (Guling Street), which is also the route that I drive through to work every day, and it reminds me of this movie every time. 😊

[@YuenXii]

Edward Yang left us too soon.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Oh I agree. It is so sad. He had so many tales to tell.

[@genesis_requiem8600]

Just finished this absolute masterpiece. It crawled its way up to my top 3 favorites of all time.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I am so very thrilled to hear this. Thank you so much for your very kind comment.

[@bigsky1970]

I stumbled upon this film ironically enough through the Criterion Collection's KZbin channel in a video about the film restoration of A BRIGHTER SUMMER DAY, showing the difference between the degraded film quality to the restored version with it's rich color. Not going to give any of the plot away, but for me seeing it for the first time, it seemed like it was actually 2 films in one, as there is a plot change almost half way through the 237-minute film. Many thanks for your review, and many thanks to Criterion Collection for restoring this film to it's original beauty. Without their work, this film would still remain in relative obscurity and difficult to find.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much!! Yes... the difference is really amazing. It is such a miracle of restoration in many aspects. I hope you are well and cheers and warmest regards.

[@chrisjohnson8033]

I rewatched A Brighter Summer Day & Yi Yi a few weeks back. Both masterpieces. I think A Brighter Summer Day might just be the best film of the 90s. Incredible.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much for this, and this comment has made me very happy.

[@UnsnappedFilmsProductions]

Over the last week or so now I have been paying attention to this channel. I haven't bought a physical media disc in close to six years. Over the last year though I have been watching movies like Eraserhead, Onibaba, and the works of Wong Kar Wai on streaming. I've became ingulfed by these works of art to the point that I would go on HBO just to check to make sure these movies have still been on the streamer. But now, I'm trying the Criterion Collection because of you and this channel. Thank you. My first buys were The World of Wong Kar Wai box set, Drive My Car, and A Brighter Summer Day as a sample to see if i like Criterion. I chose these films because the way you talk about A Brighter Summer Day reminds me of how much I love not just that movie but passion i feel for the art cinema. Wong Kar Wai's films, Drive My Car and A Brighter Summer Day.

[@TylerKingNuReview]

A film that works on so many levels and creates a world that I never wanted to leave. The Criterion Collection should be lauded for what they did in terms of restoring this film and finally bringing it to more people

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much for this. Yes it is hopefully being seen by as many people as possible my friend.

[@NoirFan84]

Love this masterpiece. I got one of the '1001 Movies To Watch Before You Die' books for Xmas when I was in my teens & held onto it for years, it was like my bible for a long time & there were certain movies in it that caught my eye & I was desperate to see but they were very hard to come by for a long time, well this was one of them. Before Criterion brought out the BluRay in the UK a few years back there was no other means of seeing it over here so I was ecstatic to finally get my hands on a copy & get the chance to see it. Needless to say that it didn't disappoint.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

What a great comment. Yes, there was such a long time when it was not available or it was in a poor quality release. So, the Criterion release was like a kind of miracle.

[@tyrusquiroz8810]

Carl Rees Who’s the author? I’m very much interested in getting this book now since it includes ABSD. Does it by chance include Ran?

[@NoirFan84]

@@tyrusquiroz8810 There's no real set author, it's a book made up of writings from a whole host of film scholars & critics. It's a very thick book & they release a new edition every year for around £20, however I never felt the need to upgrade on the one I had from years ago because all the new ones do each year is add a few new write-ups on the best movies from the past year but most of us will have already seen & known of them anyway. You can get an older edition on Ebay for as cheap as 3 or 4 pound, it's a great place to start your education & act as a guide on the history of world film. Just type '1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die' into EBay & you'll get plenty of results. And yes Ran is certainly included, a number of Kurosawa's films are included.

[@tyrusquiroz8810]

Carl Rees what year’s edition do you have?

[@NoirFan84]

@@tyrusquiroz8810 Mine's the one with Heather Ledger's Joker on the cover.

[@Befera18FERA]

Thank you so much for this video Daisuke! Just watched the film yesterday and what an astonishing experience. Tender yet mysterious, magical but realistic, beautiful yet profoundly terrifying. I always knew Edward Yang was a master but wasn't expecting something to this level. Anyways, thanks again!

[@Evan-cp9of]

Edward Yang is my favorite director, great video!

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Oh yes. I think for me, the series of videos I did on all of his feature films here on this channel is perhaps one of the things I am proudest of. I hope I don't sound like I am bragging, but, really, I have such a great respect and admiration for his films, from IN OUR TIME and THAT DAY, ON THE BEACH and TAIPEI STORY, to TERRORIZERS... and then there is A CONFUCIAN CONFUSION and MAHJOHG and YI YI, as well as this film of course. Such a great director. It would be great if A CONFUCIAN CONFUSION and MAHJONG could get proper blu ray releases one day, hopefully by Criterion.

[@Evan-cp9of]

Yes that would be great, there are still a few Edward Yang films I haven’t seen and I’m looking forward to seeing them, thanks for the reply.

[@Peter32tjrksor]

This film blew me away. I now own it. The play that's an extra feature is actually really good as well. It was so engrossing even though there were no props.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Oh yes, Likely Consequence!

[@BlackHoleBrew42]

Make Way For Tomorrow.

[@gourmetpez775]

This is my all time favorite film. The part when Sir tells the director what he thinks life is about took me away. Fastest 4 hours in my viewing of any film. I would love to do a livestream with you someday.. Been collecting for over 15 years.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I am so happy and thrilled to hear that this is your all time favorite film. Yes... this is so powerful. I rewatch it regularly, and every time I am stunned by its brilliance. Cheers and warmest regards. I hope you are well.

[@davidgriffin9667]

I watched A Brighter Summer Day for the first time today but as yet I can only see the film in powerful fragments. I'm feeding sections of the film into it's riveting, seemless flow. I liked the film very much and look forward to watching it again tomorrow.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much. When you finish the film, please let me know what you think! I would love to know my friend. Cheers and please be well.

[@Lukas-sv5rk]

I just saw it for the first time last night! What a film.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

That makes me so happy to hear my friend. Thank you so much!

[@JMPerona]

This film is on its way to me right now. After your video I want to see it more than ever. Thanks for your recommendation and keep the good work!

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Wonderful my friend. I would love to hear your comments on the film when you see it!

[@MatthewGhirardi]

I saw the film a while back, and I enjoyed it a lot, despite the runtime, it’s such an incredible film

[@DaisukeBeppu]

WONDERFUL!!!! I am so happy to read this comment. It has put a smile on my face.

[@huubkuyvenhoven1294]

I watched your top 10 criterion tips video and watched a brighter summer day last night, i am speechless. Fastest 4 hours of my life, i am probably going to watch it sometime soon cause for like the first 90 minutes i had no idea who anyone was

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Wow! Thank you! I am so thrilled to hear that you reacted in such a way to A Brighter Summer Day!!! Brilliant!!

[@thisgenius]

Quite possibly my favourite film of all time! Looking forward to checking out your previous videos on this..

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you very much! Yes, I had the great chance to talk about this film and all the other feature film releases by Yang. And if this is your favorite film of all time, that is such a great choice.

[@henrycheung4327]

A year ago, I discovered your channel by somehow and base on your recomment, I purcahsed this film in last summer time, after I spent more than 4 hours to watch that film, I was totally stocking for that moment of time, and I leave you a comment at the first time in your video channel, thanks again Daisuke you introduced me such a epic masterful film for me, and lucky for me I can understand their language, beacuse I am Chinese, and I think if you don't understand the language well, it will be more difficult for you to understand that film, but because this is a really really deep meaning inside this film, so you have to pay attention on each sence as well, anyway thanks for sharing A BRIGHTER SUMMER DAY again, and I know this is one of your favorite CRITERION COLLECTION

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you very much for your lovely message. That is so great. And you say your views with great energy and feeling. I really appreciate this my friend. Yes, this is one of my absolute favorites.

[@neonpop80]

So nice to hear this about this masterpiece! I watched it in theaters in the mid 2000s and have been begging Criterion to release it for years after, and that's after I downloaded an AWFUL copy online and custom made a cover. I'm so glad it is now in my grips in a clean package and restored doing it justice. This film was in awful shape before this copy. Thank you, Criterion! Side note, though this is an epic, I may like YiYi a tad more, just because it's a tighter package and a simpler watch yet reaches so much depths with its simplicity. Either way, E Yang is a beautiful filmmaker

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Oh yes, the Criterion release... WOW. And excellent point about Yi Yi. Another wonderful masterpiece. Cheers and it is always so nice to meet another fan of Edward Yang cinema.

[@HelloBlossomStudios]

One of my favorite criterion releases. People ask, “how could you ever watch such a long movie, what is the point?” Being in the world of the film for so long really makes it feel... tangible. Real. I would say the 4 hour length of the movie is absolutely necessary. Just want to say I’m very happy to have found your channel, and someone who appreciates film!!!!

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you and not at all. I can see if people might not be into the film due to its running time. But I always try to say "the film goes by so quickly when you are watching it". And indeed I think it does. It is amazing just how fast time flies. Your comment is really great. Thank you so much for your enthusiasm for this film and for cinema in general. Please be well my friend.

[@JimTheMovieGeek]

long movies really intrigue me and I love going on the cinematic journey. To me, Once Upon A Time In America needs to be 5 hours, as does Fanny and Alexander, as i am m sure does a Brighter Summer Day, which I need to see. When the credits finally go up and it all comes together you realise you've seen a spectacle, and the length is a huge part of that.

[@folksurvival]

Novels are sometimes 60+ hours to read, so a 4 hour film isn't very long really.

[@992turbos]

I don’t understand this sentiment either. People binge watch streaming shows which have 10 1-hr episodes back to back in one or two days like its no big deal.

[@fabianm9378]

Hi, I recently discovered your channel and after watching this video, you inspired me to purchase the Criterion release of A Brighter Summer Day. It arrived today and so I'm now very much looking forward to watching it for my first time on Saturday.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Hello and thank you so much for your comment! I hope that you enjoy the film. When you see it, please let me know what you think. I would love to hear your thoughts on it.

[@fabianm9378]

@@DaisukeBeppu I finally got around to watching Brighter Summer Day last weekend and I'm finding it difficult to articulate and put into words what I thought about it. To say I loved it would be a disservice as it was so much more than just that. It was an experience. I already feel the need to watch it again. I'm so pleased to have listened to your recommendation and to have added it to my collection. Thank you.

[@joeljacobsson47]

Thank you for bringing this film to my attention, I probably never would have watched it if it were not for you! It is more of an experience then just a normal movie watch. I have only seen it once so I definitely must watch it more but I can say that I will never forget it.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much for this kind comment my friend.

[@Martinmd12-zt7vu]

I just got this film because of you. I had no idea what to expect. The runtime was intimidating. I just watched it like 20 minutes ago and it really impressed me. I was really engaged. Although I was a little confused at some parts, I was surprised that this film felt faster than it actually was. It was beautifully shot. I can’t really articulate my thoughts in full right now, but I thought it was great. Also that ending made my jaw drop. Thank you

[@ElliotCoen]

Thank you for this video, Daisuke. It's one of the greatest films of all time. So moving, as you say. We are be messed to be able to watch this film thanks to the Criterion Blu-ray, as the film was so hard to find for the longest time. Stay well, my friend.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Yes, you are absolutely correct as it is a very moving and oftentimes tough and challenging work of art.

[@latenightdoublefeaturepict2048]

Can not agree more - it is a wonder of a film - I’ve seen it only recently for the first time a few months ago ( based on your discussion of it) and I adore it already - must watch it again soon!

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you my dear dear friend. Thank you so much. This really means a lot.

[@gavinramsden6571]

Came to this video after returning to this film this morning. On a second watch it's still overwhelming in it's scope but in all the right ways. There's so much here and I'm so glad Criterion restored and brought this film to a wider audience. I loved watching this video and seeing your passion for this film. Have a good one Daisuke :)

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much Gavin. I love your description especially about how the film is "overwhelming in its scope but in all the right ways". Yes!! And so it makes one want to watch it again and again.

[@jerrycan4775]

Just woke up from a nap, so glad to discover this! Always excited to see a new video had been uploaded 👍

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you very much my friend.

[@elijahsbday]

absolutely love this movie

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much. I agree with you!

[@tyrusquiroz8810]

So powerful to see you tear up over this film! I can’t wait for my first watch this coming Monday!! 🥺😁😁

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much my friend.

[@noahplunkard7590]

New to both your channel and collecting Criterion. Thanks for providing awesome content during such a strange time.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much and welcome. It is nice to be able to get to know you. Please stay well during these times and stay safe.

[@pandanamin7104]

Hey Daisuke, I must say thank you. For the fact that you promote one of my favourite movies of all time. It reminds me a lot of my childhood in the early 94-99 era. Kid gangs, music, families all that package...finding your voice in the world that you thought was huge but it was just your town hehe ☺️. Edward Yang was exceptional when it came to this and YiYi. Definitely both some of my favourite movies of all time. I can't remember how many times I watched the scenes, with the dad and his radio, his cigarette 🚬, and his clean white shirt and cool specs. With all the lovely old furniture (rattan etc). Ahhh

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I am so happy and thrilled with this comment!! Yes, such a brilliant work.... one of my absolute favorites in the Criterion Collection!

[@pandanamin7104]

@@DaisukeBeppu I'm sure we share similar memories watching it. You growing up in Japan and me in France. Two different countries but the same in its style.

[@HylianCuber]

I've had this film sitting in my Unobstructed View cart for weeks now, maybe this video will be what pushes me over the edge to finally make the purchase

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much and yes, if you get the chance to see it, I would love to hear your thoughts on it. Anytime my friend.

[@marcl4000]

Discovered «Yi Yi» many years ago on tv, was very happy to get a print with Criterion. What a great film. Unfortunately I didn’t followed Edward Yang career... I’m sorry to realise that this was his last film, looking at his filmography (he passed away in 2007 i just learned tonight). Thank you Daisuke for this «A Brighter Summer Day» suggestion. (I see it’s available for rent online)

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Oh thank you. Yes, Edward Yang left this world way too soon, as he had many more stories to tell. And when you get a chance to see this film, I would love to hear your thoughts on it my friend.

[@marcl4000]

@@DaisukeBeppu Yes will let you know after viewing.

[@user-gg6sh7wr6d]

Hello Daisuke, I don't know if you will read this but I felt I had to comment after seeing this film for the second time yesterday. While I had enjoyed it immensely the first time, I struggled to follow the plot and keep track of all the characters. I don't think I have ever been as deeply moved by a film as my viewing of A Brighter Summer Day yesterday. It was my second time watching it. The ending shattered me completely, and I have not been able to think about anything else today. I am deeply indebted to you because without your recommendation of this film, I don't know if I would have plunged into it on my own, given its 4 hour run time. I hope you're having a wonderful day.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much for this, M!! I am so happy to hear that you saw the film a second time. Yes, I totally understand what you say about how the film can seem quite overwhelming and confusing upon a first watch. I feel the same way. But with subsequent viewings, the characters become clearer and I think the Criterion release does a brilliant job (including the commentary track) to provide further guidance and examination into the plot, the characters, and the historical context. Thank you so much again for sharing this with me. I am so deeply deeply moved.

[@user-gg6sh7wr6d]

@@DaisukeBeppu wow you replied!! Yes I was contemplating watching the Tony rayns commentary but decided it be better to watch it without, just so I can experience the film, this time being able to follow the plot. However next time I watch A Brighter Sunmer day I intend to watch it with the commentary. But yes, I think a brighter summer day will be one of those films I’ll continue to revisit throughout the years, and will always hold a special place in my heart.

[@myfasmarine]

I went back and found the video you spoke of. I ordered the movie from the Criterion website. 😁

[@DaisukeBeppu]

THANK YOU!!! And please let me know what you think of the film when it arrives! Cheers my friend. Your comment has made me very happy!

[@myfasmarine]

Daisuke Beppu will do friend! What’s the best way to let you know? Come back to this comment and add another reply? Or a new comment to a new video or something like that?

[@MrSwisha18]

I discovered Edward Yang's work through your channel, and I'm so glad that I did! A Brighter Summer Day is one of the greatest films I've ever seen, and the same can be said about YiYi and Taipei Story. Thank you so much for recommending it! Your channel has made this shelter in place a bit easier, and I deeply appreciate it!

[@DaisukeBeppu]

This comment makes me very very happy. I am so glad about those past videos I did about Yang's works. I am very very proud of those, as Yang's works are so important to me. Thank you so much for this. Your comment has made my day my friend.

[@alanpav]

I have to say, Daisuke spends 10 minutes telling us how great it is, but not one word about why! I did see it some years ago and certainly liked it.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I have spoken about this film in detail in a four part series: kzbin.info/www/bejne/ipCaaaKQe8p_naM And while I don’t quite agree with you when you say “but not one word about why!”, still I appreciate it very much that you took the time to comment. And perhaps if you are looking for spoiler and details, I can recommend the 4part series to you. Best regards and cheers.

[@Jared_Wignall]

Never seen this film, them again I’ve never seen an Edward Yang film period. Until you’ve talked about his movies, I never even heard of him. Don’t know when I’d get around to watching this, as I have a lot of movies I want to watch and rewatch. Sort of have to make a cut off of sorts regarding new films to put on a watchlist as I don’t know when I’m get to all of them while it continues to grow, even in the midst of what’s going on as I’m doing whatever I can to stay busy, while I try to watch a movie at the end of the day to help unwind and I noticed watching films that are new to me don’t always help me unwind at night as I sometimes think about what I just watch and don’t fall asleep as quickly as I’d hope. But thank you for recommending this film Daisuke, I’ll try to get to it whenever I can. Just don’t know when that would be. Hope you’ll have a good day. Take care.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much. I would love to hear your thoughts on it one day my friend. It is long, and so perhaps one needs to be in the right mood to watch it. I think therefore there is no hurry and it is ok to wait for the right time to watch it, but believe me, it is SO WORTH IT!

[@Jared_Wignall]

I’ll defiantly keep it in mind Daisuke. Have a great day.

[@WolfGratz]

I liked it and although I don't at the moment love it as much as others do would suggest giving it a go. I also suspect it will grow on me after a subsequent view. But it is in my favourite 900 odd.

[@intogrey2038]

What a brilliant film I will be doing a second viewing in couple of months.It was shocking and left a imprint on me for sure.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much my dear dear friend!!

[@bc5327]

Just watched YiYi. I like how it evokes many emotions but the many great shots might be my favorite aspect. Planning on watching A Brighter Summer Day soon.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much! And yes, if you can, please check out A Brighter Summer Day! I hope you enjoy it my friend, and cheers.

[@chandanrawal4137]

Hi daisuke...greetings from India...i hope you are having a great time watching films around the world. I watched it on 18th April after your recommendation...it is made up of 237 minutes deliberately, depicting a simple story into a strenched array of time just to make the viewer dwell into the time of 1960s Taiwan... I guess this is the main strength of this film. This film is tough/challenge to watch if someone is new in the amazing and spiritual world of foreign language cinema.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

An excellent, excellent write-up and review of the film my friend.

[@tyrusquiroz8810]

Hey Daisuke! This is perfect timing for this video!! As you know, I frequently ask you questions regarding this film, before I’ve even seen it. As you would remember last year I said I would be watching it in April which is now! 😃 I will be watching it on Monday, and my first ever watch of A Brighter Summer Day!!!! You have persuaded me to buy the Blu Ray and to hold it of such regard even before I’ve even seen it! That’s power!!!!!

[@DaisukeBeppu]

OH yes, my friend, yes I recall our past discussions about this. With great fondness for you and your wonderful enthusiasm.

[@JWSportsNetwork]

I haven’t seen this movie in a couple of years, but I have the criterion collection edition and you’re making me want to watch it again lol

[@cinearts1173]

Hi my friend. As i think i mentioned before, i own the criterion blu-ray. It's still sealed as i am waiting for the perfect conditions haha. I really can't wait though. I will try and see all of Yang's films eventually. And the Epic length gets me even more excited. Thanks for this video Daisuke and it clearly means so much to you! Take care.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I know you would have so many great things to say about it. Please make a video about it on your channel when you see it!

[@cinearts1173]

@@DaisukeBeppu Thanks Daisuke. Yes i will hopefully review the film on my channel. Although sometimes i prefer to review once i have seen a film at least 2 times. But it might be another few months before i watch the film anyway. Will let you know my thoughts whatever the case. Take care my friend.

[@johnadair4693]

I will order now thank you Daisuke, I'm not eating this week, spent a fortune this three weeks, and still waiting for delivery's can't wait!

[@DaisukeBeppu]

My dear friend, thank you, and please continue to take good care of yourself.

[@hydr0genjukebox]

Lovely movie. Lovely message, Daisuke. Stay safe yourself, mate.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much for your kind words. Likewise, stay safe my friend.

[@EastAsianCinemaHistory]

Everyone should see this film.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I AGREE 100%

[@2011Antidote]

I have seen YiYi which I borrowed from the library but they unfortunately do not have A Brighter Summer Day. I guess I would have to buy it! :)

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I hope you enjoy it my friend!

[@bc5327]

This one was epic in it’s subtleties and not without the flash of intensities. The whole time I was thinking “how is this thing going to finish off?” Just think it’s pretty interesting a pick for your favorite :) only 4 hour film I’ve ever seen

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Dear B C, yes! I love the way you say it. The subtleties... you are right... though of course there are instances of flashes of emotion and intensity that emerge, which make the build up and emotional background all the more profound, and the other way around of course. Brilliant comment, and thank you so much.

[@BarryVCU]

Just ordered this Blu-ray as a blind buy, based solely on your recommendation.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Wonderful. I hope you enjoy it my friend.

[@CSJR]

Like others, I've taken the time to watch A Brighter Summer Day while in quarantine. The timing of this is additionally interesting because I've started a journey in film with the intention to step way out of my comfort zone. With regards to Criterion specifically, I started with Do The Right Thing and Jackie Chan's Police Story, both superb in their own way. I followed those up with Picnic at Hanging Rock (via Criterion Channel) and, as of yesterday, A Brighter Summer Day. I think I've watched all of your videos about the movie and I want to thank you for sharing your thoughts. I felt there were so many threads throughout the film that I find hard to understand and articulate, but you've given me the words for a few elements of the film. I'll share those after a couple more viewings but the movie is really good. I'm excited to watch more of Yang's work.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Wow... you are so kind. I am so so happy that you saw this film and that you responded to it the way that you did. I hope you enjoy your film journey my friend. And at any time, if there are any other films along the way in your journey that you particularly enjoy, please let me know anytime. You are always welcome here.

[@JimTheMovieGeek]

Heard about this movie for so many years, maybe its time to finally take a look since we are in lockdown. I picked up Kobayashi's The Human Condition which is a huge undertaking of a watch so thats taking my attention at the moment, but Edward Yang is a filmmaker I really need to make a priority. The movie sounds like one of those mind blowing works, some movies really do leave you speechless and numb, and I think it is not a problem with you as a reviewer, quite the opposite, i think it takes an amazing reviewer to admit when the film has penetrated almost an area that is transcendent. Almost describing it would be trivial. I've felt that way before. Wonderful review Daisuke.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you very much. If you do get the chance, please see the film. It is really one of the absolute greats. It is long, but the time goes by so quickly. Cheers my dear friend and please be well.

[@TommyBoy249r]

Thanks to constant refreshing of Barnes & Noble’s webpage: I was finally able to purchase a Criterion copy of “A Brighter Summer Day.” I’m so excited to take in all 4 hours of it!

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I am so happy to hear that!!

[@MarlinAmada]

This and a lot of the special features along with the commentary is available on the criterion channel, so I’ll have to check this out! Thanks for the recommendation!

[@DaisukeBeppu]

The commentary is very very helpful. Strongly recommended.

[@MarlinAmada]

Daisuke Beppu I feel like I should take notes like I’m back in college! 😉

[@samuelstephens6163]

So, I did watch this film after seeing your strong recommendation. I did like it quite a lot. It's a film of quiet but real experience where the little things add up, and they might have been different, but one series of decisions outweighed another. It's not quite a fatalistic view, but it certainly puts the weight of evidence on life circumstances. Little cultural shocks here and there (Elvis night), but was continually reminded how under every culture we are all worried about the same things. The major thing I wish I had known beforehand was the real-life story this is based on. It really helped anchor my perception of the film and why that crime was such a shock in Taiwan. There's a terrifying scene in there I'll leave unsaid, but which hit very close to home. I'm undecided, ultimately, if a film like this is even worth assigning a rating. It doesn't exactly have the Aristotelian feel and structure of "what art is," but neither is it merely like a documentary or anything quite so pedestrian. I'm in an odd place with it. But I did like it and it did move me, even if I did have to watch it in three sittings.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

WOW! Thank you so much for sharing your reactions to one of my favorite films!! This is really excellent.

[@premiumblurays1785]

I just managed to get hold of the Novamedia One Click edition of this film - never seen the film but the edition looked so beautiful and it was a great deal - and of course the film sounds like it’s gonna be good 😀

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much for this. I hope you enjoy the film!

[@marcl4000]

Hello Daisuke. I wrote I would get back to you after viewing the film, sorry it took so long. After my commentary I rented the film of Yang on itunes and I had 30 days to see it. Today was the last day to view it and I just finished it. I have to say it was a pain to watch… I thought these 4 hours would never end. And I say this with all respect to you and the others that love the film and that commented here. It’s one of the situation were you find yourself, as a viewer, not going with the majority, but that’s ok. I’ll try to explain what didn’t work for me. First the print on itunes was the Criterion one. Strangely some shots of the film were really sharp and sometimes shots would be really grainy. For me this version of almost 4 hours was too long. If you watch a movie this long and you don’t have interest in any characters you’re in trouble! :-) So I was, but I read that there were 3 versions of the film; a 237 minute version, a three-hour version and a shorter 127 minute version. (Maybe the short version would have better suited me). I’m going to quote movie director John McTierman (Die Hard) who used to say that you should have plenty of time to tell a story in 90 minutes! :-) As for the characters I found that the principal role of Si’r was plain and you don’t really care what happen to him. Is it because of a lack of charisma by the actor (or the fact that a lot of them were amateurs), something doesn’t work. There’s no evolution of Si’r through all the film, except the end where you question the crime as if the director didn’t knew how to end is film. And you see it (crime) coming! (Not only Ming is killed but her mother commits suicide, this is too much). The rivalry between the gangs is rather light for most part of the film. When the massacre happen you don’t believe it a second. There was no build up for so much violence. And although there are many victims the police doesn’t seems to care or some characters are not concern about was they did (like Si’r). Close to the end the lady cleaning the floor says « cops come all the time » but we never see them doing an investigation. The scenes with the movie crew and Si’r father arrest has no impact on the story… Although filmed with a nice cinematography too many long shots keeps you out of the storyline, it’s my feeling. Maybe the director wanted to tell to much stories at the same time, everything gets diluted. Too many family members, too many stories with Ming, etc...

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Hello and not a problem at all my friend. You present your criticisms of the film very well and perhaps there is a kind of elliptical quality to the narrative presentation that could prevent a viewer from being fully engaged. That is a great point. This could be a reason why multiple viewings are so rewarding but at the same time its length could prevent that from happening. Anyway that is OK and thank you so much for sharing this viewpoint! Cheers my dear friend.

[@marcl4000]

@@DaisukeBeppu I must say it a bit disturbing to not appreciate this film like you all do here. I really regret how it turned out for me. Maybe I need a second screening, some other time. (And it doesn’t mean I won’t try to see other films of E.Yang). I used to argue with a good friend of mine; he loved « Last year at Marienbad » from Alain Renais… and I hated this film. We used to make jokes about our oppositions. I think it ok not to be always agree on films, as long as there is respect in the exchange. To balance what I said about the E. Yang film and show my appreciation of asian cinema I can say that I had no trouble seeing «The Human Condition » of Masaki Kobayashi (part I, II and III are 9.5 hours long, so length is no problem). And I have a better opinion on actor Chen Chang (playing Si’r); i just found out that he continued acting after E.Yang film. He was playing a role in «Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon» (2000, Ang Lee) which I loved. (I read after my comments that this ABS Day was based on a true story. At the end you have details about how the murder case was handle. I almost didn’t saw this, I thought it was the end credits). Cheers my friend.

[@marvelfan4518]

I’m now buying this movie even though I don’t usually buy Criterion’s with Yi Yi so I can experience this. Daisku thank you once again my friend I was debating watching this but now I know I should. I’ll be reviewing it on my channel as soon as I get it but that’ll be a little bit. But know I will hopefully get to experience this.

[@marvelfan4518]

Also I’m sorry I’m adding on more my friend but is there any other long foreign cinema masterpieces you would recommend?

[@marvelfan4518]

*long foreign cinema masterpieces or near masterpieces

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you and I agree with J T!

[@marvelfan4518]

Daisuke Beppu Thank you!

[@marvelfan4518]

Thanks to you guys I’m up to buying three Criterion’s to add to my one that I already own. So great thanks to you both!

[@84paratize]

I watched a new Taiwanese-American film called Tigertail on Netflix the other day. I feel like it was inspired in part by the films of Edward Yang. It doesn't quite reach those heights but it is a touching film, in my opinion. If you have a chance to watch it sometime, I would recommend it.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you so much for this recommendation my friend.

[@akajkyt]

You’ve finally broken me Daisuke, I have gotten this particular Criterion. My family were asking what I’d like for my birthday, this film was amongst those things, so the order for this criterion has been placed. I have a sealed copy of Yi Yi on Criterion and have been wanting to rewatch the film so I may watch them 2 nights in a row or something. I’m beyond excited to watch this film, I don’t think there’s another film I’d like to see more that I haven’t seen. I’m curious about the contents of the second disc...

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Thank you!! This is such a powerful film. One of my favorites.

[@Julio_Liu]

Ah the perfect video to follow-up on a comment I made a few days ago.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

My friend, your timing is perfect as always.

[@jnagarya519]

I picked this up because it's Chang Chen, and his first. Only watched part way so far.

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I hope you enjoy the film.

[@jnagarya519]

@@DaisukeBeppu I will. I only just noticed that I have several films -- "Three Times," with Chang Chen and Shu Qi (I first encountered him as the "bandit" in "Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon," by Taiwanese director Ang Lee), and "The Assassin," with Shu Qi, by director Hou Hsiao -Hsien.

[@SceneOnFilm]

I love this movie. I have only seen Yi Yi and this one. This is one I believe everyone should watch at least once! Do you have a letterboxd by any chance?

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Hello and thank you as I agree! And yes, I have letterboxd (under my name) but I admit to not using it too much (only very very occasionally).

[@xx_kordelia_xx6392]

Check out Taipei Story, and Terrorizers by Yang too, they are left in his other films shadows and don't get enough credit.

[@davidheard2674]

I've seen Yi Yi and absolutely loved it. Not seen this but have the Criterion edition and can't wait to dive into it. Just need to find the time. How do you find the time to watch it?

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I strongly recommend it. I mentioned this in the last set of videos I did here on this channel on Yang and on this film. But, if the running time is an issue (and I totally get it if it is), then I think it is OK to watch it in sittings. So, maybe in 2 or more sittings, though, of course, if possible, it would be great to see it in one sitting.

[@SX1995able]

Check out The Terrorizers also by Edward Yang if you haven't It was on Amazon Prime last I saw

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Oh yes I agree. I also had the great chance to talk about Terrorizers on this channel. I strongly strongly recommend it too.

[@cwvideo6552]

Will you do more of these "I strongly recommend..." videos as a series? I think it's a great concept - these shorter videos that quickly capture your strong impressions of a film shortly after seeing it

[@DaisukeBeppu]

I will do my best my friend.

[@MrLugoku]

I bought it like a month ago, but due to the quarantine it is collecting dust in a storage

[@DaisukeBeppu]

My dear friend, I hope when this world situation gets better and you are able to get the film out of storage, I hope you get to see it, and anytime, I would love to hear your thoughts on it. Anytime at all my friend.

[@MrLugoku]

Daisuke Beppu I had the opportunity to watch it like 2 years ago. I can not say too much until i watch it again but something that i always says to my collegues about, A Brighter Summer Day it’s one of the most beatiful films ever made.

[@samjira6206]

I just learned from my Taiwanese friend that the original title of the film is something like "Street Teen murder case "

[@DaisukeBeppu]

Yes that is right… I think the title can be translated into English something like “the incident of a youth killing on Guling Street”.