I think we already know who the Mystery Man Is...

Become a JoyFleet Executive Officer and enjoy special perks!
/ @joygirlyt
Join the JoyFleet Discord:
/ discord
Follow me on Twitter:
/ joygirl_yt
Follow me on Instagram:
/ joygirl_yt
Follow me on Facebook:
/ joygirl-1130. .
Become a Patron:
/ joygirl
JoyGirl avatar designed and created by Rid:
....

[@thebishna]

One of the metrics I use to think about how likely a theory will come to pass is to think about how much Luffy would enjoy if it were the case. Having to fight a Roger Seraphim before he claims the One Piece sounds like the thing Luffy would MOST enjoy. What a wild idea I love it so much.

[@Galkadrago]

Roger seraphim is a wild idea but i love it

[@yashivan566]

Inagine getting divine departure by a small roger with wings and flames

[@wmbtech]

The Holy Knights guard the final poneglyph. This is something the Gov likely established generations ago, so the Figarland family, or Figarlan D. Family, inherit the responsibility each generation. The Gov thinks they are guarding it, but Shanks is really gatekeeping and will turn on his family to help Luffy, possibly revealing his 'Figarlan D.' name. The new man will make this harder being related to Shanks but loyal to the Gov., giving us his and Shanks backstory and origin finally. Just my thoughts.

[@karthikeyans8610]

Interesting idea

[@HerculesOfHate]

I feel like Shanks might be the child of a Celestial Dragon and a slave. Thus the baby wasnt wanted even though he technically has Celestial Dragon blood. Perhaps the mother(slave) put Shanks in the chest because she knew they were doomed to die.

[@cecilfahie7152]

Naw he's a clone

[@kennethyoung1373]

Same, I even believe shanks is half celestial half will of d, his mother being an enslaved woman of the D clan. Possibly a sibling to Bonnie

[@blowc1612]

I've imagined that Shanks is like Bonnie.

[@cyndaquilist]

​@@cecilfahie7152no imagination

[@cecilfahie7152]

@cyndaquilist totally, because the reason given was soooooooo creative...totally has everything to do with the current focus.....maybe pull your imaginary head cannon out your...imagination.....Shanks is a knight clone put up for a prize at God valley sounds more lime oda.

[@sansexe6999]

The augmented roger theory is insane, never thought of it before, banger video!

[@Jus10sweat]

That’s crazy i hadn’t thought about Roger being cloned

[@theSUBVERSIVE]

Figarland Garling is like a commander, this character is probably the current captain of the Holy Knights and I don't think he is a twin, otherwise, it makes it really hard to understand whatever happened to Shanks as a baby. There are more chances that Shanks was like Bonney, he is related to Figarland Garling but his mom was a commoner like Ginny, so maybe this guy might be like a half-brother but his mom is also a celestial dragon.

[@pieceD399]

Underworld Boss , i think

[@mathieuleader8601]

I think its LV 5 inmate Roche Thomson who is actually Xebec himself either a clone of him or him under a new identity

[@errepeoficial]

Commenting on every Joygirl’s video until she reaches 100k subs part#-24 🎉

[@mokaljordan]

Based on the left side of the bottom 8 players we have a Revolutionary, Pirate, World Government/Celestial Dragon and Marine while the right side u have a Marine, Revolutionary,World Government/Celestial Dragon which only seems right that the Mystery man is a pirate which makes him unlikely to be a figarland imo, the Mystery man would be paralling kuzan which means he could of been a former member of a group on a hidden agenda that involves the one piece

[@whatupitzwinston]

Roger as a seraphim that the wg couldnt really make right would be cool, like it either doesnt listen or they had to stop the research of it. I like the idea of Rogers sword Ace being given to a gods knight like this is a sword from the pirate king and Garling might have been like yeah I want that to be given to one of the gods knight because he likely knows how stron pg Roger was if they crossed paths at god valley. Im hyped to see the holy knights, if Oda cooks on a design like Hanafuda he probably has something interesting for the gods knight.

[@blowc1612]

Horrible idea. Having some kind Roger or Rox copy cat is just terrible writing and takes away from their legends. The secret dude has to be Copper there's no way you're telling me that the left hand of Roger won't show up in the story is unimaginable. Without any hints that he has died, he has to be part of the story. With the legend that Oda has been saying should be coming soon, makes a lot of sense. Also having Ace the whole time. Also he would have the egg that's been shown every time we have seen Roger's ship. As he also makes a lot of sense to be the man who is marked by fire. If Shanks being a power house, Rayleigh a power house, no way Rogers left hand wouldn't be a power house when Zoro and Sanji as right and left hands of Luffy being power houses, there's no way Copper will be completely left out of the story and having this silhouette being copper having Ace and the final keep of the the road Ponoglyph makes a lot of sense to the overall of the story.

[@nagatouzumaki4628]

Who's copper its scopper 😭​@@blowc1612

[@ig56ruje]

i think hes wielding rogers sword ace

[@Axlplayz]

It’s bogard. I’m calling it

[@onbedoeldekut1515]

Do you think the Shanks pirate Rockstar could be related to Rocks D Xebec?

[@kennethyoung1373]

Curious about this as well

[@Afatdragon]

The rager clone idea was knew to me. I did have a thought of it being shanks twin with ragers sword. I could see the c dragons. Having a thing about twins being bad. Maybe emu was joy boys twin. Or they say there could never be two "gods"

[@poisonjam44]

2 shanks. shanks name has an S. shanks plural 2 shanks. Shanks = guildarts.

[@bloodofdepanta]

I audibly gasped at the end of this ngl. That sounds like a very oda move

[@jarvisfowlkes3200]

Yay, a JoyGirl video

[@StardustMonkey]

Shiryu already told us the answer… he said the government is most likely holding onto the last rode poneglyph! After Roger they realized the needed to be a gatekeeper of the final pneglyph. Meaning the strongest god night … shanks twin… is the man with the burn scars that he got from fighting shanks flaming sword… the world government has been very relaxed as pirates came up searching for the one piece because they know no one has the final most important key! That is why when he came to the revery the gorosei gave him a meeting but told him he should not be getting involved in politics! Because he is supposed to be hiding away protecting the poneglyph instead of being there at the revery where people can see him. He has to hide his face because people at the revery should not know about his existence

[@superman198224]

One point overlooked, the new mystery man is left handed and Roger is right handed.

[@3MrArtist3]

Oooh I hadn't considered a Roger seraphim....that would be absolutely sick. Luffy having to overcome a version of Roger that the world government controls? That's sick, wicked sick.

[@rashodmasters4299]

Yooooo

[@pieceD399]

Probably why world government wanted to take moria afther the war

[@darknightvenom734]

The man marked by burn scars is none other then Saul

[@xerlius]

I don’t think so, Saul has been preoccupied with elbaph and O’Hara libraries, you think he has time to also sail around guarding the ponegliph making whirlpools too?

[@Lill0fD]

My biggest problem with the theory isn't that it's not leading to a final boss Roger... but the fact that he's probably not a Seraphim. Seraphim are newer models that seem more a reaction to the Shichibukai system (With the DNA fusing I personally feel being a Vegapunk exclusive feature to try and bring back a dying race he knew was being killed by the government), but... a clone like Stussy I feel fits the mold a bit better with their age and timing. Stussy being a member of CP0 shows that the implementation of clones into government ranks and teachings was something that did happen. There were probably even more made, and we may start seeing some more familiar faces from that era of piracy soon. In fact, maybe Weevil was a legit attempt to clone Whitebeard, but they failed because Whitebeard was not simply a bigger human. Those that are closer to humans probably have better clones that were produced. Roger being one of these potential clones.

[@gabrieldjatienza6971]

Caterina Devon's infiltration plan can now be executed...with Saturn absent from Mary Geoise... her Saturn disguise now comes in handy.

[@SejiofAkatsuki]

Feels like burn scared man should at least be someone we've referenced before

[@SejiofAkatsuki]

A moniker is like a mask which we only should need if we want to hide their identity. I'd also like it if it was a world noble who was burned by King or a lunarian during their purge.

[@Ramonnnn]

A Rogee Seraphim would be awesome! I honestly didn't think of that before😂

[@timgersh6787]

I do speak and can read Japanese, Lotta Megaman games are Japan exclusive so its a skill but I figure its best not used when I know they will import One Piece. So reading early to theory craft just feels like a bad idea since I just need to wait for answers. My thought is that it may not be new but just somebody in a different way

[@SlimRootsOfficial]

Am i really the only one considering that the mystery character could be the pirate with the eyepatch that Oda once mentioned? I mean everyone is talking about the "final saga" and that One Piece is coming to an end in not too distant future tho Oda said, that we know we are near the end as soon as we've seen that pirate with the eyepatch. Maybe this character got teased on that page.

[@christianolson8543]

I will give JoyGirl a sub, a like, a comment, and Lord knows I wish I could give her more 😓

[@pivanov3321]

It may be Shiki "The Golden Lion". It's cannon he has a Plan and this plan comes to fruition about this time, so Shiki has to make appearance. He is a sword user and powerful one at that, he is an old sea dog, why not have the last ponoglyph? His ambition is yanko level, he clashed with Roger, try to recruit White Beard and cut his own legs, can't believe a character like that will stay idle and miss the One Piece race.

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

What I can say is maybe Shanks brother never had a good life because maybe his father always saw Shanks as his only true son and his brother as the black sheep, of the the family. See where I'm going with this? I'll fight between brother against brother and I'm betting everything on Shanks.

[@userrburnerr]

I’d say it might be the other way around considering Shanks was left in a chest on God Valley while the “brother” is still in Mariejois

[@christianedwards6364]

I don't want shanks to be evil but it is possible. I think it comes down to how he really feels about roger telling him he's not the one. He might accept it but he could also say screw u I'm taking it for me. Might explain him preparing a kid for the nika fruit, and him just chilling for 20 years, and no devil fruit users in his crew

[@an0mndr]

Ive been wondering about a roger seraphim ever since they revealed the seraphim. I do kind of doubt that it would be the roger seraphim in this panel tho, its just not the sort of character i think oda would tease (idk why, just the feeling i have)

[@pieceD399]

There are two groups that hasnt appeared Underworld people and Knights the knight is there , his reflexion should be underworld people

[@xerlius]

Roger would have given his sword to scopper for sure, he probably offered it to Raleigh who refused.

[@Scentsei_585]

She keeps talking about the god knights from the god valley incident like they gonna be having responsibilities today most of the people in that era are retired today. So all of the god knights of modern times have to ether be the offspring or new members in general

[@tylerhernandez-sida1825]

I came up with the idea of it being a shanks seraphim but damn Roger would be crazy

[@skitzowoods776]

What if shanks is a triplet..I seen him bein a twin ..not a triplet...brings a new idea to mind

[@pieceD399]

We cant assume Imu is evil , their devil fruit look like sumoning so Imu can be pocessed and be a good person , i could bet on this

[@peetsmcgoo5869]

Ty for representing all of Gryphon's vowells!!

[@djevans8737]

Just thought of this but what if sabo is the man marked by a burn scar scar on his eye wasn’t it a burn mark???

[@richcast66]

Oda has people pulling their hair out trying to figure out this silhouette.

[@SMRR17]

if the one piece community is john lennon this channel is yoko ono

[@BilliamJoyBoy]

Dragons brother obviously… look at the nose, or his clone

[@cesarthebruinboy]

What happened to blue banana podcast!????

[@clarissathedyan]

What is that red mushroom thing on you right?

[@darknesswithin0]

This girl is on fire 🔥 Very very well done!

[@bachenzo421]

Luffy x Nami at the end GGWP :)

[@obinator9065]

KONO DIO DA!

[@KeyAirAngelsTV]

It's always interesting listening to people who don't pronounce r's. Because everytime she said "guard", I kept hearing God. Lol

[@dakingotheworld]

Its clover

[@nathanielgingrich2365]

The saber of xebec?

[@RudeSnipe]

In defense of the evil brother theory, Oda used amesia before.

[@edvance1030]

Notification squad reporting for duty.

[@KyleDJones]

Blue banana!?!?!??!

[@no-rj5sn]

Could be Loki

[@lordpistonia]

Why cant you show any pictures/panels?

[@alejandrosolis5637]

Shonen jump has been taking down videos if they have panels in them, so joygirl is been cautious with her channel

[@muziyezorossa2499]

Rogers sword

[@angeluzerrare8170]

I wish Shanks was on that treasure because he was actually one of the prizes...

[@adaptking3170]

Every week is break week though :( Reaction Piece forever and ever

[@cecilfahie7152]

Just a thought, but what if Shanks wasn't abandoned, what if he is a clone that was put up as a prize in God Valley 🤔

[@kawaisoubaka1942]

"You are not the one roger is waiting for teach!" Gets a really different meaning when you think about roger is still im the game for pirat king

[@bledekdicky1202]

HERE WE GO AGAIN, SCOPPER GABAN APPEARS FOR 1000 TIMES 🤣😂🤣

[@1gnorantlizard733]

12:57 Contestants?!? Today on Who Wants to Be a Pirate King

[@shawnorjiakor]

The mystery person is Shanks' twin brother.

[@personablue7458]

Clearly the mystery person is shanks hot sister

[@ifantsaurells3014]

Its Figarland Thanks,, Brother of Red haired Shanks..

[@mathieuleader8601]

belated happy birthday Soph!

[@sadettinarslan5324]

Oda knows how to play us :D

[@ceptile226]

I HAD THE SAME THEORY

[@sascha2065]

Support

[@nickgates4259]

I don’t like the idea of there being more than the original 7 warlords as seraphim but if we have to add 1 more Roger is the best I’ve heard yet

[@Pinko-Diamond]

The seven warlords lords are not the original Warlords. The system had already been around when they came in place. Why would the government perceive them differently than any of the other warlords that came before them? It would be a matter of whose DNA they could obtain.

[@nickgates4259]

@@Pinko-Diamond dude I know but they’re the 7 original warlords to US the readers

[@blueb6815]

​@@Pinko-Diamondyeah I wonder if they ever got Hanafuda dna

[@DorkBr]

Rocks uses a saber.

[@thedude-nf1uf]

How do we know that?

[@DorkBr]

@@thedude-nf1uf I mean.. we don't KNOW it. But isn't he inspired by Roche Braziliano? All the art based on that real life pirate has him holdong a saber. And tlets be blunt here... every time Oda hold a character behind a silluete for this long, he turns out to appear eventually in the story as a villain. I doubt One Piece will end without Rocks being alive

[@posaune45]

Does it annoy anyone else she keeps saying “man marked by the burn scar” sounds way more lame like that

[@Doctor_Kroom]

Trying to push the theory that marked by flames automatically means mark by burned scars. Typical theorists and head cannon.

[@fifty6737]

Stop the clickbait, no we don't know who the mystery man is The man marked by flame is also a character that we don't know this one piece youtubers are pulling shit out of their asses

[@adaptking3170]

Who cares, she's hot

[@bloodofdepanta]

Chill out neck beard. This is why these KZbinrs are too scared to theorize anymore. Too many of you aggressive otakus go on the internet and cry.

[@adriancpm]

It is called a theory bro relax 😂

[@adaptking3170]

Who cares, she's hot.