I Tried EVERY Poptart Flavor | Tier List

MERCH - www.shoptylertu...
Watch Me LIVE On Twitch! - / tyler_tube
Chat In The Discord! - / discord

[@DoglegMediaMatt]

*Tyler eating the chocolate chip* “You can’t beat that” *puts it A tier*

[@caitlynbowers1701]

When Tyler says "if you don't heat this up, you're insane" Me that never heats any of my poptarts up ever 👀

[@nerfco2330]

I came out fine too

[@Carpenter1]

Psycho

[@shawnduffy1988]

i always ate not toasted too

[@Fetidaf]

I dont think I’ve ever had a toasted pop tart…. And I eat them fairly often.

[@tunasubbackwards420]

I only toast them once in a while.

[@dillon4903]

Tyler: I don't like raspberry flavor Also Tyler: I'm going to rate this one low because it doesn't taste like raspberry

[@Thelawnmower278]

😂

[@prestonwhite6423]

Look. He's trying to grade on accuracy of flavor, 😆 let him do him

[@dngleberry]

A fair and accurate assessment by Tyler

[@MrNobody91]

@@dngleberry but tbh, it should be does it taste good and would you eat it again, not how accurate are the flavors cause that's a totally different thing and not how he ranked all of them lol. He ranked some off of how much he likes and some it's like he found a reason to not rank high. I also was confused as to why he was acting like he could only put so many in each tier/S tier tbh. It made no sense to me lol.

[@deshawniskeng-mixedmediatv]

When you said red 40 it reminded me that pop tarts are banned in several other countries

[@straingedays]

A friend sent us a box of Peeps, we were shocked at the ingredients but laughed at seeing Yellow Dye #5 (we'd only heard of it from Die Hard)

[@Matts44444]

I think, for the sake of comparison, you should rank stuff based solely on how it tastes. Because at the end of the day, you’re ranking how the flavors ate between eachother, not their accuracy to the labeled flavor. Love the videos mang

[@MikeS-el6vd]

Would love to see a tier list of Tyler eating pickle varieties. 😄

[@shaggy7927]

that would be so funny

[@fishnpitstaknnames4699]

He has

[@mariestarlight]

Would be just like Charlie's smoking review, everything is F.

[@owenleonard-v7y]

he already did that btw

[@joekni2002]

What about different pickled foods?

[@theadmjg]

You should do a separate video where you eat all of these desserts you've never eaten before, and compare them to the pop tarts.

[@Thelawnmower278]

Yes 🎉

[@David_Stevens]

Get real ones and not the cheap store dessert ones.

[@jerrysberrys3415]

no. no he shouldnt

[@brennansander6165]

And why not?​@@jerrysberrys3415

[@Elusivecamel31]

The worry on my face when he took a bite of the banana bread tart.... I absolutely NEEDED that to be good.

[@dustinschaefer1]

I'm not a fan of the banana bread one. It tasted too fake and I love me some banana bread

[@Masquaradethewriter]

It's ok, I found the icing to be too much but I'm not a big icing person

[@shadowpartition]

Whenever my mom would get the hot fudge sundae ones back in the day, I’d always throw 1 or 2 in the freezer. They’re amazing frozen.

[@drifterdragon]

😮

[@FayeBush381]

Do the same with the strawberry shake ones too. So yummy 😋

[@DadBodFitness1]

Buddy that s’mores is S tier! That’s the best one my guy

[@TheBeebop420]

Agreed!

[@absolutelyblasted]

Tyler should definitely do Oreos next!

[@NoName-zz8nl]

How hard is it for you to grab a camera and record yourself eating a variety of Oreos and then uploading it to youtube

[@Patrickmiker57]

first video I've ever been this quick to find and I'm so happy that it was a Tyler tube video!!! definitely in my top 5 fav youtubers!! comedic timing is perfect!

[@sstarrlind]

Tyler and his mutant tastebuds. Blueberry and strawberry are literally the most popular flavors. Brown Sugar you can add in too. But those 3 are the only ones you can find in singles, which it makes sense they would put only their top sellers in.

[@eternalv0id_]

Paul Harrell would love this vid, Rest in Peace Paul.

[@bwc1976]

Oh man, something happened to Paul?

[@dustinschaefer1]

I was thinking the same thing the whole time.

[@Zorro9129]

@@bwc1976 Unfortunately cancer got him.

[@MrNobody91]

15:10 the two really don't taste the same at all tho. Idk if his taste buds are off or what, but they both taste distinctly different tbh, except for the fact that ofc they both have the same icing on the outside.

[@EpaphroditusBeltishazzar]

You're 100% correct

[@MrNobody91]

@@EpaphroditusBeltishazzar I'm glad I'm not alone in this cause when he said they tasted the same I was like "I've had them both and they're both very distinctly different to each other" lol. Glad I'm not going crazy and my taste buds aren't off lol

[@tinyt1.236]

I completely agree with you. They don't taste the same at all

[@MrNobody91]

@@tinyt1.236 exactly what I thought lol. I knew I wasn't tripping lol.

[@MrNobody91]

@@tinyt1.236 he also confused me talking about some of the filling being "sticky feeling". Like no shii lol, almost all of them are that way to me tbh. He seemed to be tripping a bit here and seemed to only say that about those he didn't like it seemed. I like Tyler, but sometimes he says some weird stuff lol.

[@farmwife99]

They no longer make the best ever flavor……. Chocolate Vanilla Cream. They need to bring it back.

[@patthompson1761]

Next Poptart flavour Tyler tries is insulin Poptarts

[@chrismayer3919]

🤣 there’s a SUCROSE born every minute…

[@bradasstv]

Untoasted? Doesn't he mean raw??

[@browncoatsunite5794]

I totally thought he was going to saw raw as well!!

[@jesser_p]

Moving out of the garage has changed him in not good ways lol

[@dougbrown7150]

@@jesser_p he's a lot more cautious

[@markfireinthehole7003]

The landlord saw his videos and said nope not in my house ​@@jesser_p

[@Khanxay]

To be fair, most people use the toaster to cook the poptarts and the whole thing is cooked before packaging. Saying its raw is kind of like saying "raw bread".

[@dexter1981]

Tylers garage is now full with half-eaten poptarts

[@Michaelstew]

I stood in the sun and pretended to be an electrician while watching a grown man eat pop tarts for 40 minutes today, what’d you guys do?

[@theatheistcowboy4227]

S’mores pop tarts are the best frozen in my opinion. They get chewy and it’s awesome.

[@kyrennb9018]

Algorithm: he’ll watch anything at this point, even Tyler ranking Pop-Tarts 😂

[@zeeantoinette]

Warm or hot Pop-Tarts taste different but better for certain flavors

[@GraceToo_]

C'mon Pop Tart, make a special pickle flavour just for Tyler 😄

[@Patrickmiker57]

the cinnamon poptart is enhanced so much by toasting it and spreading butter on it, TRUST ME!

[@Jamie-vw8bj]

Yes, butter

[@-tzadakim-7805]

Cherry is probably in my top 3 but only because my dad used to eat them in the morning when he was working in the living room, and I would eat them too so they have a place in my heart, they remind me of my dad. So it’s a nostalgic reason.

[@fun_sized]

Pls do more! Would love to see an Oreo one or every type of pepperoni pizza, etc etc!

[@jadedjackel655]

Let's make it interesting. Tyler ranks whiskey brands.

[@marradax]

"Hmm let me try that one again... no i think i need a side by side analysis..."

[@presley913]

Let's be honest... his palate is far below whiskey tasting capabilities.

[@JohnPryer-f8d]

Me too Tyler, I've had the Strawberry Pop Tarts, and the Brown sugar & Cinnamon Pop Tarts when i was growing up, and still like them, and i can't believe Tyler dosen't like or has never had the Chocolate Fudge Pop tarts before this video because there very delicous.🤤

[@stevenhitchcock4278]

Strawberry milkshake pink because strawberries are red. And white for the milkshake. Mix together. And you get pink

[@chonkyhonky1887]

My absolute favorite pop tart is unfrosted blueberry, but I can never find them anymore. because what I do is I take peanut butter and spread it on top

[@CBRboy1717]

I’m blown away by the things you’ve never eaten before in life as an American. No peach cobbler? No snickerdoodle cookies? How? We did a PopTart taste off a few years ago when PopTart was coming out with all kinds of crazy flavors. I miss the Eggo branded Poptarts. Those were my favorite non-permanent flavor.

[@patrickjoseph9158]

Next video “alright guys, I got some rulers on Amazon. How straight can I make this chart now?”

[@KylezGotGame]

16:04 When something’s so good you gotta read the box 😂

[@AppRemb]

You have redeemed yourself with the brown sugar cinnamon poptarts speech. Hits hard

[@P121_BEN]

Time for Tyler to go down an new rabbit hole, at least that’s videos sorted for the next year or so 😂

[@sidneyshipp3632]

Brown sugar cinnamon, toasted, with butter? Basically a cinnamon roll. My dad and I will be eating them for dessert for the rest of forever

[@sidneyshipp3632]

Blueberry and cherry are also good with butter but they’re nowhere near as good as the OG

[@dougbrown7150]

Didya ever put butter on a pop tart it's so freaking good😅😅

[@wheresmyfinger]

For me, if it's chocolate based pop tart, it gets toasted. If its fruit, untoasted.

[@ecuz3]

This 1000%

[@m2pt5]

Tier list snack cakes - Little Debbie's, Hostess, Entenmann's, whatever else you can get your hands on. Maybe one brand at a time then compare the best of each in another video, so you don't overload yourself.

[@get_some2083]

I started to watch this and realized that I can never take Tyler serious as any kind of food reviewer

[@jonrubio2993]

One of my favs is the Eggo Waffle one I’ve found at an AAFES store on base. They’re always low to none in stock as all the soldiers snatch em up soon as they’re stocked.

[@KeC04]

Strawberry milkshake poptarts thrown in the fridge for a few hours are the best off all time

[@montanahalesbass]

Am I the only one thinking Tyler should do more of these videos??😅

[@MangoTangoFox]

This was randomly in my feed and it made me really want to try the top rated Pumpkin ones. I remembered a few days earlier I'd seen a big display of at least 100+ of em all stacked up. When I went back to the store they had sold every single one of em! So disappointed, hopefully they restock, it isn't even near thanksgiving yet they have to!

[@NormireX]

For un-frosted you need to toast them and then while hot melt some butter on them. Or put a scoop of ice cream on top while they are hot for a pie and ice cream type dessert.. I like Un-Frosted Strawberry better than Frosted Strawberry as there is more filling in the un-frosted it seems.

[@dewflower7298]

Same

[@SS-dm5iy]

TLDR: Everything chocolate is top 3 tiers. Everything fruit is bottom 3 tiers.

[@EpicAllie]

I was about to say the same thing. Just a preference, for me I like the berry ones better than chocolate 🤷‍♀️

[@KP-ei2vb]

..... The 4 flavors of pop tarts i have in my house are all on the same row of your pyramids. I have the brown sugar, cherry, apple jacks, and banana nut bread right now lmaooo

[@OmniSoundAI]

What a weird world we live in that someone can eat and talk about Poptarts and make money, childhood dream lol

[@cognaccam]

I’m exactly 5 minutes in and I’m telling you right now, Strawberry Milkshake is absolutely better untoasted and because I’m expecting you to not like it and give it a bad grade, you have to put that one in the freezer for a short amount of time and eat it cold. Thanks for coming to my ted talk.

[@BeckyA59]

I haven't had a pop tart in more years than I can remember, but brown sugar cinnamon was, I agree, the best, followed by strawberry

[@Goose-Man]

My goat chocolate fudge is S tier as always, keep up the great work bro

[@TheOriginalJGuns]

anyone suggesting freezing poptarts is a psychopath.

[@Dylan52meow]

Awesome video Tyler! I love the format! I see you created another tier list and I'm off to watch that next!

[@RUDY3098]

Tyler is all sugared up and will not sleep for days.

[@jacobgamble3302]

He really made a video to justify buying a ton of pop tarts. Love it🤣

[@ImigrentfromMars]

Doctor put me on a Rabbit Food diet and the last 2 weeks have been killer and now im watching this lol

[@nomadiavan6560]

Carnivore is the proper human diet.

[@ImigrentfromMars]

@@nomadiavan6560 I grew up Meat and potatoes man but doctor says Cholesterol is way to high. So I will do the rabbit food for a few weeks,

[@TheGrossMeta]

Please do a toaster streudel tier list next 🙏🏾

[@jayeff7900]

Every single PopTart, huh? ... heh, this hits a little close to home! Please continue the bachelor diet vibe and rate every single Hamburger Helper.

[@dethkl0k]

You know what really grinds my gears? They don't frost the ENTIRE Pop Tart........the worst part is the plain edges with no filling........C'MON POP TARTS!!!!!!

[@mcfrisby]

I've been watching you from the start. I got to watch you grow your channel's from 2000 to where you're at now. It's been an awesome journey. Thank you for your content ❤❤❤❤

[@CMcSchwifty]

Love this video! Agree with the placement with most of these. I was so excited when I saw the peach cobbler in stores…but was GREATLY disappointed!

[@granoculus7430]

My favorite is S'More PopTarts. They are good toasted and untoasted.

[@NickMiller-w2n]

Am I the only one that eats Poptarts cut up into bite-sized pieces and smothered in melted butter? It's sooooo good

[@nicholasrutherford2871]

Great Tier list. I wish they would start making the 2 peanut butter flavors again. The best no competition.

[@berlyn3014]

I've been on the fence about trying the banana bread pop tart. Definitely going to try it now.

[@mysinging748]

Did you try it?

[@berlyn3014]

​@@mysinging748 I did and I really like it.

[@Ovum_]

Amazing video, I love watching Tyler eat for almost 40 minutes. Make a tier list of Cheeto flavors

[@SpaceNazi62]

Use to tell the grandkids they’d get worms eating “raw” pop tarts 🤣

[@mikebramlett445]

You gotta put butter on there man! Great channel. Great beard. Skew

[@derekkinsella2343]

Great idea brv 💯👌

[@ppowerproductions2953]

Well next video idea testing out all the pumpkin pies from all the different places see which one's the best

[@Dorkasaurus234]

Please do more tier lists you're the first person i could watch the video fully through!!! Bravo!

[@satenhimself9918]

I really enjoyed this 😊 tbh you should do your fav pizza or ice cream haha yum love your videos

[@motoadventures4132]

I was literally eating a brown sugar one while watching this with glass of milk at 1 am 😂

[@thathemiguy9191]

Ive noticed for how much tyler proclaims he hates cherry flavor things he always finds a way to put it in atleast b tier

[@jakejones3361]

You ought to do a blind taste test between pop tart and off brand pop tarts (Meijer, wallmart). I henestly think the off brand is significantly better

[@dylanmason6598]

Chocolate chip cookie dough and the peanut butter limited time one was so elite 😢

[@ThatTruckerCarGuy]

Im a frosted confetti cupcake and brown sugar cinnamon consumer myself. First time i tried the cupcake one that was my exact thought was that they absolute nailed the flavor 😅

[@superpaul79]

The milkshake strawberry is pink because the red color has been blended with the white of a milkshake.

[@williamharris8367]

Sadly, here in Canada, we can only get Chocolate, Strawberry, Blueberry, and like one other flavour -- whenever I go cross-border grocery shopping I always look for different types. I am disappointed that Apple has been discontinued. There used to be limied-edition flavours, but I have not seen any examples in a few years.

[@shoreamaze177]

Damn… I wish Poptarts would bring back the Jolly Rancher flavors, those were top tier

[@ecuz3]

How have you never had apple jacks cereal, a Boston creme donut, or a snickerdoodle cookie?

[@tessajohnson3377]

Love your videos Tyler! I’d love to see you do a tier list of Oreos!!

[@anthonyguidas2012]

That’s a great idea

[@rwmullis79]

Wrong wrong wrong. Unfrosted strawberry with melted parkay on top is the only way to eat a pop tart.

[@3DJapan]

My favorite was apple and cinnamon with no frosting. I had them for breakfast every day in college. Then they dropped it. The closest now is Apple Jacks, with frosting.

[@carrioncrow8191]

Seeing the joy in Tyler’s eyes just before taking a bite of the brown sugar poptart was kinda heartwarming. I do want to say, I don’t like the chocolate flavor pop tarts. It is such a fake flavor that makes me feel a bit ill. It’s gross. What’s not gross, is a frozen pizza tier list!

[@xcross08x]

I thought the strawberry milkshake reminded me of the strawberry milks I would get in school 😅

[@coolstuff6768]

Funfact actually about the orange pop flavor you mentioned. Pop tart in 2016 released a Rootbeer flavor. And an orange crush flavor. So maybe they "reimagined" the recipe.

[@LaniaMaliceLove]

Make a tier list of pudding or jello flavors!!! Id watch that!!!! ❤❤❤

[@robertj2]

Chocolate Peppermint needs to make a comeback, and of course Chocolate Vanilla Crème.

[@DullVivid]

I think hands down, the best flavors were those peanut butter/pb+chocolate ones in the gold packets. Criminal behavior that they haven't sold them in what feels like 8 years.

[@Alpha-zulu-009]

Everybody knows Cherry is the best flavor. Side note: Tyler was scared for life because of a hair in his food - grows up and grows a full head of hair on his mouth.

[@Treighjustice]

Cherry tastes to fake

[@DavidKulasiewicz]

Cherry is only good broken up and eaten with vanilla ice cream

[@Alpha-zulu-009]

@@Treighjustice *too

[@Treighjustice]

@@Alpha-zulu-009 same damn thing

[@BeardedStigg]

Nah dog they used to have a chocolate penubutter one, that was the best imo😂

[@StonerSmurfin]

There were a few flavors i have never seen before that I want to try but sadly the store in my area only carries like 5 flavors and we never get the special edition flavors.

[@AB78]

🤯🤯 I'm 45 and I've actually never had a Pop Tart toasted 😂😂 what have I been missing all these years. Next time I buy some I will definitely have to try them warm. Huh 🤔 who would have guessed

[@Varnage]

I love a toasted/warm unfrosted brown sugar with a little salted butter.

[@Sh0ckw4ve575]

Gotta try freezing them. Especially the hot fudge sundae and strawberry milkshake

[@jamesreece9502]

My granny used to make homemade peach cobbler and blackberry cobbler. Best dessert I ever had. Yes, you put a dollop of ice cream on it.

[@joshuawilson6900]

I love that people hang on to someone’s opinion of something they don’t like.

[@JohnPryer-f8d]

Tyler, I just tried the Boston cream donut poptarts and they are pretty rich, But pretty good 🤤

[@jordanclarkson7284]

Tyler east chocolate chip pop tart “You can’t beat this” And then places it in the A tier below 2 that are already in the S tier hahaha 😊

[@zoosky]

jolly rancher poptarts were the bomb idk if they still have them

[@wandlbaker]

You got something right without knowing. The "fruit" based ARE all APPLE with artificial flavors.