I Turned Mario Odyssey into a Horror Game

[@Fir]

People keep asking for my POV so I spent like an hour on stream talking about it and sharing some footage - kzbin.info/www/bejne/iHi7coOsqNGYm7M

[@hunterdalehite813]

YESSSS

[@HexagonCircle341]

Every video in the background, fir has more and more swablus and altaria. Fluffy Pokemon addiction?

[@EmerARold]

For some reason I was expecting to see Dampé in the grave yard

[@frostyclouded]

cj knowing fir was luigi before he even saw luigi vs poo not figuring it out until fir says it at the very end is peak comedy

[@homerman76]

Poo had more trust in Fir, CJ knew Fir too well and hated being nabbed for a horror game so he also just wanted something to blame Fir on xD

[@hopeburnett8313]

That was my favorite part, lol!

[@thegamersclub9326]

@@frostyclouded And Smant just never figuring it out, too?

[@Axe-fs9eb]

I didn’t realize until poo said it either lol

[@frostyclouded]

@@thegamersclub9326 i really couldn't tell if smant knew or not lol hence why i didn't mention him, i figured it clicked for him at some point but he didn't say anything

[@soaringsoaps6135]

I find it hilarious how CJ rejects the immersion and yells at Fir whenever he sees luigi

[@Tulinx]

1.5k likes and no replys wtf?

[@knottedupnonsense]

@@Tulinx what are we supposed to say dawg

[@AryaPlus]

@@knottedupnonsense "Haha, so true"

[@chloehm2976]

I'm unsure if you've seen the vod yet that Fir put up in his comment, but CJ knew from the start that Luigi was Fir because he had to get into the multiplayer to do this video

[@Katedfate]

I love how odyssey moding started out with, oh you teleport every 30 seconds, to oh we now have multiplayer, to, I create a first person horror game using a custom map, to troll my friends, IN A MARIO GAME

[@anoniem9285]

*odyssey

[@bigz205]

​@@anoniem9285 *odessy

[@orangeluigi137]

@@bigz205*ought i see

[@wreck_out211]

I had a stroke while reading this

[@KatsuTG]

​​​@@bigz205 *odussy

[@char1194]

Love how poo spent most of his playthrough trying to AI manipulate a living player

[@thegamersclub9326]

The moment of realization when Fir apologized was golden though.

[@SueNorman-ww9mx]

Oh my god. I’m the 1K like anyways why am I replying?

[@reynnberri]

I didn't even realize it was Fir until poo realized too 😅

[@raphaelchan7574]

@@reynnberri bruh he literally said he was controlling Luigi fym you didn’t realize

[@anna-gt2mu]

Q

[@TrevorCarrell-m6c]

Cj saying get out of here constantly is so great, and then Smant is purposely singing Luigi's mansion when Luigi is after him is also great

[@bernard832]

From the thumbnail, I thought it was going to be Fir playing a horror level, but inflicting it on these guys is so much better.

[@paigeofthebook]

yeah that's why I hadn't watched it yet, but I ran out of videos and it popped up on my recommended again

[@StrawhatTrev]

7:20 “Doesn’t seem like there’s anything left to do here…” Cappy, you’re not helping.

[@lonely_demon6040]

Desperately need a Fir pov of this video

[@yukikitsune7366]

That's just a 44 minute long video of Fir smiling like The Joker and laughing at the terror he's inflicting on his friends.

[@tehgaminstar3062]

@@yukikitsune7366that’s perfect exactly what we need lol

[@tweebox5572]

I also really need to see that

[@MercuryA2000]

That would be so great.

[@ender4384]

on his vods channel there is a stream where he shows it

[@OGSoup]

2 kinds of gamers: fir: “are you lost right now?” smant: I would never get lost cj: i’m so lost

[@spresso]

The "poo references old games" was the funniest part about this😂

[@firimousse3676]

Smallant guessing the room was a decoy so fast is honestly pretty impressive

[@Raineditz220]

Tbf fir has made rooms full of red herrings multiple times

[@Infindox]

I love that CJ immidently figured out that you were controlling L but the other two didn't XD (well until near the end for Poo lol)

[@TheNomad94]

The word is "immediately".

[@uberlord983]

I mean, we all know CJ has a sixth sense for Fir's bullshit. Now, whether that's of legitimate spite or not, I don't think that's the case, otherwise they wouldn't have been recording videos for literal years together.

[@alvinip9128]

I'm certain smart knew and was just playing into it. Sometimes you don't reveal stuff for content

[@uxieorsomething]

between this and the magic the noah style hide and seek video for april fools i think you’ve solidified yourself as the youtuber with the best holiday videos

[@Lscala]

Don't forget the straightest line for june

[@Atle-ez7ir]

Let's not forget the Pride Month video about setting up a gay frog wedding on the straightest TotK line

[@Medium4343]

Strongly agree

[@Jekvkwnv]

It makes sense considering how I think he commits the most to bits in h&s/among us

[@finnsharma6331]

@Atle-ez7ir That was probably the best concept out of all of them

[@IanCannonPiano]

4:15 not even 5 minutes into the vid and Smant is already pulling shenanigans...

[@Feyntheviewer]

Underrated comment

[@FluffyCurry]

Lol

[@adriangrayver3854]

Always

[@TheUnkGamer]

smant cheating the system will never not be funny

[@paraquietusghosty6407]

To think GPB might’ve beaten cjya if “L” didn’t throw him back in the well. This was pretty fun to watch, and everyone’s reactions were about what you’d expect, which is great.

[@frostbite5607]

I think it’s funny how every time CJ politely asks Fir to go away, he does.

[@ZekromAndYugiAndDrago123]

9:54 Smant: What's over here? It's kinda shining.. Firigi:

[@coffee_beanie87]

"Firigi" 😂

[@InexplicableInside]

That was great, and genuinely spooky. I see Fir made one crucial mistake, though, that SPOILERS One crucial mistake that let Smallant take the win. Specifically, as soon as Fir knew the layout of the mazes, that knowledge was mirrored into Smant's subconscious through their shared brainstem, allowing him to guess his way through them much faster. CJ and Poo never stood a chance.

[@Necroblaze]

Smant 100% saved a good 2 minutes breaking that moon shard part. And about the same in the second cave. But God knows how he was that fast everywhere else. Might be the first maze.

[@mlien7377]

I mean, you kinda just notice it pretty early when there are way less clips of his gameplay. He seems to just do everything more efficiently. Probably less wandering around and deaths from mistakes.

[@israelwoodard770]

I think it would have been sxarier if fir just stopped talking to them when they entered the first person zone

[@heyitsmeagain6897]

I think CJ would have gotten a heartattack😂

[@jakobtime]

Yeah but they would probably be more confused than scared, id be like hello? you there? and assume they went to go to the bathroom or sum

[@exac9949]

I was thinking the same thing. Also woulda been cool if he didn’t tell us what was going on right at the beginning of the video so we could be surprised along with the players. I guess it was necessary for the title/thumbnail to get more holiday traction, so ah well. Still a great video.

[@MercuryA2000]

He'd have had to say/do juuuust enough so they know he's there, but not so much they get to curse him.

[@erinslemko5429]

@@exac9949it’s also nice as a viewer to know that it’s horror, I’m not good with horror so I was able to prepare myself, other people maybe wouldn’t watch it at all because of that

[@kyx5631]

Concept: 10/10 Guests: 10/10 Modders: 10/10 Editing: 10/10 Final result: 10/10 What an amazing video.

[@BadgerByNature]

Brilliant, Fir! The stalking Luigi was genius. Loved how you tried to encourage Poo to go the right way to no avail.

[@tysonfontanez]

It honestly felt like Poo was winning the whole time but maybe that was just an editing trick. Also I love how CJ knew Fir was there before Fir showed up but Poo didn't know Luigi was Fir until the very last possible moment

[@Celestia282]

I get the feeling that he was probably doing well at first, but then he wasted a lot of time on that last maze.

[@PriffyViole]

To be fair, he was doing fine until he got respawned at the wrong spot.

[@Mc_clorinde888.8]

and smant never knew

[@Draenen]

Yeah I like the way that these videos get edited because it's usually all three people at similar places at the same time of the video, but because this was a more open-ended "escape room" with little visual markers it was even harder to tell

[@nicerhabara]

Crafty (and ofc also Sanae and Cupcake) is such an incredible modder, this guy definitely has a bright future ahead of him as a game developer if he wants to

[@ArmundJay]

24:57 *whistling* "Marioooo.." "..he says his own name, to.. comfort himself." i'm fucking rolling lmao

[@TheMarinaDiamandis]

that bowser jumpscare got me 😂 you and the modders are doing some really impressive and creative stuff with SMO, really fun to watch

[@AngelofGrace96]

love how CJ was the most scared, but also figured out fir was luigi before even seeing him

[@Gfletch09]

There were issues with the online multiplayer server when fir and cj were trying to do their run, and fir couldn't disguise it since it took hours to fix. Also cj had to put in the online multiplayer server ip. So cj had so much more information to work with. Smant also had to put in the online multi-player ip, but Fir disguised the reasoning pretty well. Smant probably figured it out fast enough, but didn't say anything. Poo already had the online multi-player IP put in from a previous HnS, so he didn't receive any information that could have spoilt the plottwist.

[@stone5against1]

11:54 great idea Poo! It would be sooo spooky, especially if everyone's in first person, hiders could be even sneakier than normal

[@seizan88]

I love the contrast between CJ and Poo 😂😂😂 one is having a blast. The other hates every second of it 😂❤

[@stress1300]

14:55 What an excellent way to transition the backround music, bravo to the editor I must say!

[@jorgesteingruber661]

Loving the Fir_st person horror!

[@unski7051]

This is exactly what it felt like to go to the Deep Woods for the first time

[@skylarjekyll8878]

I desperately want to see Fir's POV

[@Fir]

It would have been fun but it had a lot of Dev stuff that didn’t make for a good POV in the vid

[@skylarjekyll8878]

@ fair enough!! Glad you had fun though!

[@velvetbutterfly]

@@Firit would still be a good POV for a second video if you wanted to explain the dev stuff and what all you could do as you did it

[@Fir]

Yeah, might do a quick upload on the VOD channel showing some of the stuff from my POV

[@ababrr6]

this is exactly what i was thinking lol

[@dizu_5]

Smant: Singing Luigis Mansion Theme and not scared at all CJ: Scared AF and knows Fir is up to something Poo: Refrencing games similar to this and is probably creeped out I love this group of friends they are all a core part of my day whenever any of them upload Edit* Smant seems really good at puzzles, make him play we were here together with you, would love to see it

[@Goragle]

the amount of work that must have gone into this is insane. oh my god.

[@Aniittiali]

Ohhhh whistling Luigi's mansion, love that. Poo collecting all the coins just in case-- the individual reactions... This is so good Fir, delightful content, 10/10!

[@RiKSh4w]

It's a deep cut to have a "Poo references old ass games cause he's an old ass guy" counter on the screen.

[@dhampir_days]

the textures used in this game were VERY effective in all honesty, particularly with the eel. just goes to show that even just changing the look of the game and making it darker can create a creepier atmosphere

[@theoneandonlyever]

this is genuinely such an impressive modding feat 😮 really fun video, i was cracking up over CJ being scared while poo and smant just vibed. the eel maze taking up a good chunk of time was hilarious 😂

[@frostboi77]

11:20 tbf i think only cj was at the correct angle to be scared cos i only jumped frm his perspective HAHAHAHA

[@Marcus-jt2ff]

These are by far my favorite type of videos. Thanks for all the hard work Fir and friends!

[@DraconisLeonidas]

lmao this is diabolical. My anxiety is sky high just from watching. That said, the eels in the maze are a little bit much, they definitely seem like they cross the line into frustrating territory.

[@DepravedCoTApologist]

I appreciate that this horror levels weren't reliant on cheep jumpscares, and instead went on spooky vibes

[@brohnor_6342]

next time you should make it so their character models are seen as different to other players, drop them in a spooky map and have them do different objectives and whenever they see each other they will scare themselfs

[@uberlord983]

33:14 Fir, you have my respect. Unironically, 99.99% of Nintendo gamers have no idea of Big Boo from Mario Party 4's existence, but I'm so glad you both know it exists AND know how terrifying its OST is.

[@cassieo376]

This video was SO much fun! Also Poo mentioning Manic Mansion!! You don't hear people talk about that game very often!

[@MelodiCat753]

I know that CJ said L was Fir early in the video, but I didn't realize L was actually Fir until Poo figured it out, lmaoooo---I forgot you said you were controlling the ghost at the start. The effort on this is insane!!!!

[@ricardoediza2690]

All i want to say is that the time, money, and hard work put into this was not in vain. All the talent and passion is felt in every moment, and Im glad it got everyone spooked, especially CJ

[@GameJam230]

You know, I didn’t even think about it until just now, but I’m severely disappointed that they didn’t have something like a Haunted Kingdom. The Boo Mario power up from Galaxy was such an interesting mechanic that had a lot of use potential, but there literally wasn’t a single Boo in this entire game, the game about literally CAPTURING enemies and using their powers.

[@AbruptAvalanche]

Loved this! It was cool watching your POV after, but you made the right decision to not including your perspective. I think it would have pulled the viewer out of the horror of it. Good call on not showing “L” right away either. It might have been better to let the players know you’ll be going minimal contact after they got to the horror section, only chiming in if something is broken or if they get really stuck. Would have enhanced the spookiness for sure! Did Smant never figure out that you were controlling L? It might’ve been fun to include his reaction when you told him that.

[@Garathon]

35:24 I love how fir just gives up here

[@zeldaindisguise]

Nothing says "Happy Halloween" like a Mario Odyssey horror game! Made all the more fun by watching this at 3AM. Seriously, thanks for the great video -- it really was a lot of fun to watch!

[@marsmaxxing]

13:01 "why is there a bullet sound? 💥💥" 😭

[@Jordanlukemarks]

So you turned Mario odyssey into the deep woods?

[@juanpetersburgo6467]

It would have been incredible if fir changed models of the skin to look like the tall skinny mario from mario maker 1, it would have been much scarier

[@idonnu7624]

9:30 ~ love the background music

[@RixtvdVelde]

This is so good I love how innovative your content is

[@crizthit1249]

Hey great vid! Would've clicked on it sooner if I knew it was an escape room-esque video! Keep up the great work!

[@Carlhero-ce2xq]

I love that whenever he does this kind of videos CJ acts personally insulted by firs trolls

[@TheLemonyOne]

You and valefisk should never be allowed to meet

[@semisemicoloncolon]

Imagine how awesome this would be with jumpscares on deaths

[@Rubbly]

41:29 is so great, Poo finally realizing!! lmao

[@daisythegoddes3483]

OH IT'S BOWSER!! BUT IT'S EVIL!! Soooo... Bowser?

[@ArcticCN]

this is what deep woods felt like when smo first came out

[@sebastianizcue2135]

11:56 yooooo that’s a great idea. Imagine playing hide in seek in SMO first person. Fir please make this dream real

[@Flipdew]

I feel like it would've been a greater horror experience if Fir simply cut off all communications with his friends for the remainder of the experiment.

[@BringerofGoats]

Utterly brilliant Fir, thank you ❤ This is a joy to watch 💯

[@delilahdahlia247]

I loved the old game reference counter throughout the video!

[@Sonicpro5]

Next thing you know he’s going to turn SMO into a multiplayer escape room

[@Bupboy]

Kinda reminds me a certain blue bird on youtube

[@Drawoon]

I'd love to see how this looked from Firs perspective.

[@maggielasher8320]

I loved when Poo called the goombas "goombies". I don't know why. I just loved it

[@Aaden-m9z]

love how smallant was less scared of this than subnautica 😭😭

[@VincentiusTheSecond]

31:11 Best Fir video ever

[@nineteen5941]

I love how for Poo, he runs Luigi away at first, but for CJ, he runs Luigi straight at him

[@thejacobian]

Honestly, I’ve seen videos with you in it but never actually seen your videos or been particularly interested in watching them (no offence intended) but just wanted to say that the thumbnail, video concept, title, and video content are really damn cool!!

[@lorettabes4553]

11:48 I really like seeing people be scared, though fir still was a comforting voice. I wonder how scared they've been if Fir had muted?

[@MiiHAYE]

I love this video and was even creeped out by L even though you said it was you. Amazing job to everyone who worked on it! Thanks for also including a POV link

[@brendenstaab1131]

I've watched this a few times now and every time it just puts a huge smile on my face for the whole video. Awesome job to everyone involved!

[@mattshnoop]

This is the most inventive thing I've ever seen done by a mod. Incredible, your guys' work really paid off!!

[@TheOhioNews]

When are we getting the captures video Fir 😮 Editing that must be exhausting so I get it but I'm excited for it 😊

[@sbyamibakura]

GPB: Woah what's that? Smant: What is that?!?! CJ: *having an existential crisis*

[@Chris-zs6fd]

FIR!!!!!! This is absolute best SMO content on the platform right now, thank you so much to you and your team for putting it out there!!!!!

[@kraterkop]

Man I was smiling through the whole video. Well done❤

[@sammarso8178]

No matter how long i try to stay away from mario oddyssey, fir always brings me back

[@FredrikKarlsson-oi5kd]

You know when fir uploads its gonna be good day 😊

[@Lequartzv5]

22:58 Smant : I know exactly where I am Also smant, 1 second later : where am I ?

[@borz0inks]

i almost can't believe that this is even mario odyssey, amazing job to all of the people that worked on this mod!!!!

[@iferpe]

That was so cool lmao I kinda wanna see what Luigi's point of view was

[@HoshiArt]

Poo taking until the very end to finally realize what the heck Fir was doing as luigi was so funny

[@meltingrocket89yt]

The idea of a slenderman type of game with Mario is so cool like i could just imagine an actual game that took place in this exact forest you made, this is honestly really cool

[@royalfizzbin2131]

I know you said this project probably won't make money back but I'm glad you do big ambitious projects like the escape rooms. They're really enjoyable high quality content.

[@Kerthyi]

Imagine a perfectly cut screams from this video. It would be legendary.

[@jordanleighton6893]

I love Poo arguing with the horror movie villain about where they should be

[@jordanleighton6893]

This was only made better by Poo not realizing Fir was Luigi

[@onebear6504]

This reminds me of that one modded mario 64 game where the game slowly breaks the more you play it as some kind of existential horror theme of some sort and I'm all for it!! XD

[@zappy2000]

"This worls is better off without you"?

[@ez9566]

4 altaria plushes? Thats like 4 times the cuddles!

[@That_Ifrit_Guy]

This was amazing, Great job fir and the team!

[@sa64ds]

Love the fact that the SNES filter was used to add an extra layer of spooky

[@cubidog1]

Anytime Fir makes a new custom level I know I'm in for a treat!

[@sgtmaggi]

This seems hella well made. Props to everyone involved