Ib Ending - Sacrifice [Redone]

Wow. Took a little over two years and recollection of the shortcut to turn Ib windowed, but I finally did this. The font isn't super blocky and there's actually sound this time.
That said, I did make this one a significant amount faster than the other video. If it's too fast, I'm sorry. I'd advise just pausing the recording to read what you missed, if it's not obvious.
As with the last video, you can find the link to the game right here - dl.dropboxuser...
Please note - I don't own Ib or the ending. This is entirely noncanon, and I'm afraid I've long since lost the one who originally made the modified game, or I would credit them. Naturally, Ib is the property of Kouri.

[@Bashuraptor]

This ending is a gut punch. Ib just died on her birthday

[@oonavuorio6247]

Just like C.C from Fnaf. Kids sure has the worse luck in horror games

[@kuparikuppi]

Okat but rewatching this years later, Ib, our nine-year old girl who's almost dying seriously pushed a girl and a 20-something years old guy. Respect to her.

[@cxlev01]

yet she cant push a mannequin lmao

[@kawaiidragongirl180]

​@@cxlev01the rose nerfed her fr😂

[@axl256gamesx7]

Caught them off guard

[@terramerc733]

2014-2015 were the glorified years for this kind genre of game... Witch's house, misao, ib, mad father, corpse party, the crooked man, mermaid swamp... good times, good times

[@bemiatto67]

I WANNA GO BAAAACK

[@nutanddash8552]

it huts

[@nutanddash8552]

hurts

[@interceptionbug4166]

mermaid swamp is not too great but...i don't dislike it

[@justnoel4088]

True, but memory serves me right it started much earlier, I rmb playing Ib and Witch's House back in '11 and '12 and can't forget the classics like Yume Nikki and Corpse Party (which amazingly became an entire franchise) that helped kick off the craze back in the last 2000s

[@jmadyoyo]

Want even more feels? Ya know when Mary says "I'm really, really sorry"? She is sorry. She's sorry for trying to hurt Ib and Garry, and only now can she say so. That, combined with the fact that Ib is gone, poor girl' gonna be very sad for a long time. At least she has Garry to cheer her up.

[@jmadyoyo]

Mary never wanted to hurt Ib or Garry. Even though she says she hates Garry, she doesn't. As siblings, they seem to be quite close, and in A Painting's Demise, she calls to him for help. She wants to be his friend, but would rather escape with Ib, who is her age and she immediately really really loved. She loves Ib, and is desperately trying not to get attatched to Garry because she wants to escape with Ib instead of being all alone forever and ever. She's just a little girl and doesn't know any better, and you scrap art all the time, right? But she is still sorry for causing them harm, and is really just a sad, insane, lost and lonely girl.

[@paraisosintetico6173]

Cinnamon Chan Exactly. And since she seems like the only one aware of everything that happened in the Fabricated World, now it seems like the whole real world is intending to take her into a massive guilt trip: Garry talking about the red rose statue that broke on the way to the gallery; Garry asking her about the candy that he gave Ib before; Ib's parentes talking about how they wanted a child, but never had one, and giving Mary what once was Ib's birthday gift handkerchief; and of course, the painting of a dead, self-sacrificed Ib. Well shit, Mary, I feel like the universe is out to make you regret ever coming to the real world. Also, I can't help but wonder what was the thing between her and Guertena (actually, I'd enjoy ANY info about Guertena), since in the ending "A Painting's Demise", after Mary finds out she's all alone at the gallery, she calls for Ib, then after some relutancy she calls for Garry, and only at the edge of despair, when she feels like all hope is lost she calls "father...", like she REALLY doesn't want to, and like Guertena is literally the last person she would call for help. I find that curious, at least.

[@jaxattax5560]

Reading that makes me feel like a dick for fucking with Mary. I purposely got all the endings where she gets fucked over. Like "A Painting's Demise" for an example.

[@Roman-fg4nf]

you mean to gloomy guy that literally represent sadness and remorse? i'm not sure dude

[@angelitastevenson834]

@@paraisosintetico6173 Well perhaps it's because Guertena is her father in a way being the person who painted the child named Mary and probably either being someone who never had kids and wanted kids pit all his spiritual feelings into her painting making her come to life, or she was once his real or adoptive daughter who died and after being painted her spirit went on to posess the painting, with the help of Guertena who died of heartache while making her piece in both theories through dying.

[@inplane9970]

This ending is probably the most satisfying. Ib gets to save both the people she cares for and they both live a normal life at the cost of herself. It also humanizes Mary, showing how she isn't just a selfish being with no regrets. She realizes that the one thing she wanted had too high of a price.

[@kawaiidragongirl180]

i dont think shell do well in the real world without ib tbh. Cause ib knows how unhinged she is and could probably fix her in the real world if it is even possible so she doesnt become a murderer psychopath. And the point of even being in the real world in the first place was so Mary has someone to play with , and i dont think she likes to play with garry who is an adult. plus living with "guilt" for killing ib , being that shed rather kill garry tbh, mary could become even crazier than before

[@even1ndeath]

@@kawaiidragongirl180 what the fuck are you smoking??? the only reason mary was so set on killing gary was because it was her only escape to the real world. its not like shed randomly get the desire to kill someone at the drop of a hat and why is guilt in parenthesis?? does everything need to be in black and white for you to understand it, mary isnt a fucking supervillain of course she regret killing ib dumbass

[@megurineziam5900]

Wow, I love this ending. Sad that it isn't canon. But I really love it.

[@thelivingliver6715]

Megurine Ziam i thought this ending was canon when i first discovered this game. mary canonically asked ib who she wanted to leave with, and her answer would decide who dies. and this ending is based off if she chose to sacrifice herself to save both her new friends

[@TCGRIVIERALEAGUE]

All the endings are canon bro, Even this one from the green version.

[@Bubblegumlyn05]

The Living Liver it isn’t solely determined by that, there’s a whole friendship system you have to keep up to determine who you’ll side with in the end

[@bernkastel7438]

Eh, I’m not a fan of the whole “selfless sacrifice” type endings unless it’s a character that’s built up well enough and you attach to. Ib is just the player character, she doesn’t have an established personality, you dictate what she says to the other characters, but even basing it off of dialogue options she still doesn’t really have a personality, not that that’s a bad thing since she’s a player character, but there’s nothing about her that would suggest her sacrificing herself so willingly like this for people she met not even that long ago. I like her somewhat still but Garry was a nice guy and seemed like he’d sacrifice himself for Ib if need be, which he does in one of the alone endings. If it wasn’t for him Ib would’ve died much, much earlier on in the story. Personally, I’d have wanted one where both Mary and Ib survive, but Gary dies sacrificing himself for Ib.

[@demonknight5617]

@@TCGRIVIERALEAGUE It's not canon. The creator of the game states that this ending isn't canon to the story.

[@i.2n.8]

I love it that after Ib pushes Mary and Garry out of the painting, Mary knows that Ib sacrificed herself. So many people have said this, and I agree that this should be canon. I cant believe how much effort was put into this

[@sparky111000]

The ending was based on a fans comic and then digitaltize to this

[@pralinealamode2713]

Worst thing: the author decided to delete all the copies for this ending. I love and hate kouri

[@adelaida5019]

@@pralinealamode2713 He didn't like it, sadly :/

[@user-ry4eg2mg2y]

@@pralinealamode2713 Omg, really? Dang, I'm conflicted dude-

[@thelivingliver6715]

Unoriginal Username i can see why he didnt like it. i dont know how, or why, but it just doesnt fit the canon game. its like trying to put a circle in an oval vessel. it almost fits, but it doesnt. its very well done though and im not hating on it. i love this fan ending!

[@Sierracat7807]

Holy- This is really well made. Dang. I kinda wish this was an actual ending.

[@theweirdlivesofcoleandmich8895]

I think i would like it more if they all survived

[@Sierracat7807]

+Makoto Ferlatte That too.

[@jackbright2377]

I like both of those ideas, I also think an ending where they found guertena in some way would be cool

[@yoontae4043]

This so sad hic hic

[@anomalocaris2593]

@@theweirdlivesofcoleandmich8895 It is not possible, in order for Mary have humanity someone must lose it

[@hunganh677]

1:43 You feel tired *Push a teenager and a child seem like as your age to other side of the paint at the same time*

[@patch141]

*YEET*

[@aruzyen4044]

*YEET*

[@angelitastevenson834]

Actually Garry is an adult

[@ripthelat2568]

Alongside Promise of Reunion, I like this non canon ending. Mary gets out, Gary doesn't die, I like it! You dont really get attached to Ib, but then again I see Ib as the player and sacrificing yourself is less sorrowful than getting bad endings for characters you grow to like

[@agirlthatsproudtobeafujosh1632]

Hey! We CAN get attached to Ib! After... All the good things she's done...

[@kardothys9151]

Noooo, how can you say that :( She is so cute ! She actually has a sweet personality and she is not as bland as other mcs in other games... I got really sad while watching this ending.

[@jackbright2377]

@@kardothys9151 same...this ending is so sad...yet so beautiful....I honestly feel kinda connected to the Ib in this ending.... I'd sacrifice myself for my friends if it came to it....

[@agathaplayziez4953]

this game is lowkey danganronpa

[@grifufu1306]

I think Ib is not dead but she will be suffering fron the pain until someone revived her rose. As a proof, Gary's rose had died because of the painting but after Ib revive his rose, he become alive again.

[@changvasejarik62]

Sad but all I can think of is damn for a dying 9 year old girl ib is strong.

[@melontimer7505]

Zettabeam62 Thats one of the reasons that makes Ib one of the greatest character.

[@imvolga1123]

Yes, she is. She can push Mary and Garry into the real world. But she can't move that fricking statue that obstructs the way. Lol

[@Mewkityy]

"You feel tired" *pushes a child and an adult man with one hand each*

[@BeanSprouts02]

@@Mewkityy I was feeling so sad but seeing your comment my tears evaporated 😂

[@changvasejarik62]

After Playing ai the somnium files I have to wonder if ib’s grandfather was also raised by dolphins. Edit: and now that ai: nirvana has been released and LP’d by nicob I’ve got nothing.

[@changroksuh6179]

Wow ib is really strong she push two people wow

[@galaxymilkyway6884]

She can push a 9 year old and a 20 year old in the painting but cant move a frickin statue

[@jackbright2377]

And you aren't even gonna acknowledge that she f***ing died. She died for her friends.

[@sugarkane1571]

r/wooooooosh

[@jackbright2377]

@@sugarkane1571 dude. It's called playing along.

[@sugarkane1571]

I don't see how that constitutes as playing along as you have clearly mentioned the ridiculousness of said statement but okay

[@axl256gamesx7]

The long red rose stained itself with it's thorn to not claw on the blue rose and yellow rose The yellow rose, distraught, cried tears of sadness, while the blue rose, still hadn't remembered the thorns of the red rose

[@forestdragon778]

I know its not a real ending but..i wish that all three could get out....ALL THE ENDINGS MAKE ME CRY BECAUSE ONE CHARACTER IS LEFT BEHIND. just the music and the pictures depiction and name really makes me feel like im Mary in that situation.

[@just-eo9ey]

BluePhoenixFire but dis time u ded!

[@elgatochurro]

but it fits since mary is tyring to harm others in order to get out

[@narees1748]

BluePhoenixFire I was just about to comment about that!!! it's so sad 😭😭😭😭 how is it possible that only 2 could get out? it doesn't make sense! wait.... first o need to know is Gary a relative to guertena? maybe like a son or a nephew? grandson maybe? Mary was said to be like a daughter guertena never had and wished he had. and only 2 souls could leave... does that mean two related souls (Gary and mary) + a different soul (Ib) can't leave? is that why only two could? it's like 3 choices, either Gary and ib leave as friends, Mary and ib leave as sisters or Mary and Gary leave as siblings.

[@nopenopenopesomuchnope4137]

You see, the thing is, Mary is not a real human. She's a work of art like the Lady in Red or the various enemies you see around the exhibit. In Mary's painting room, there's a piece of paper that says that she wants to get out soon, but for her to do that, she needs to replace someone in the real world and go with someone from the real world to guide her. We do see her try to go alone in 'A Painting's Demise' but she's locked inside the exhibit and left forever wandering in darkness because she doesn't have someone to guide her. She HAS to replace herself with either Ib or Gary, and go with Gary/Ib into the outside world. No matter how hard you try, only two people can truly exit.

[@dannycrandberryboo]

in short, one has to be there to replace mary as a painting of guertena (maybe that's how his painting is alive, tho i'm still not sure...)

[@androognoix1685]

Like I said, I love this ending the kit becuase it's an act of selflessness, to sacrifice yourself for the other 2. Yes, Mary is a bit crazy, but Garry is technically a bit crazy too. This, this should've been canon

[@thelivingliver6715]

Androo Gnoix how is garry a bit crazy? im not asking cuz im defending him, im genuinely curious. he seems sane. and mary isnt really crazy either, shes just lonely

[@katipunan4212]

Mary is a doll born and raised in an extremely hellish place not suitable for children, I'm more amazed she didn't kill Mary and Garry when they just met lmao

[@YesterdaysMinder]

The greatest of virtues.

[@reeemaximus2380]

@@thelivingliver6715 well gary's first instict is to always want to kick the fuq out of everything so yeah

[@ahagotcha]

@@reeemaximus2380 a haunted museum where everything is about to kill you according to that garry is pretty much right to kick anything come close to him

[@roselynflame]

I'm now choking on my tears. ;-;

[@nichitac5114]

who the fuck put an onion here?

[@learose989]

I actually am crying... You know why...

[@Incarnar]

Cameron MacDonald It’s painting’s name “Goodbye”

[@Noelciaaa]

HONESTLY THATS THE ONLY ENDING I CRIED AT.

[@lneybean4842]

Noelciaaa me too...

[@charlidrawz]

sAME HONESTLY ;-;

[@elemenopi9239]

Yeah... It fucked me up when I first saw it...

[@zhenee6729]

Same

[@supercorn5607]

Memory crannies made me cry tho

[@lazyartist1984]

I'll be dead honest, even though I don't know too much about Ib's personality I still get sad with this ending. Just the crushing pain in Garry's eyes when she tears her rose apart and Mary collapsing in front of Ib's painting just KILLS ME!!!!!!

[@maiseree1511]

Just imagine if a bunch of two new people come to the Fabricated World by accident again and Ib has gone crazy and has taken place Mary's role, trying to kill the guy so that he could take her place and escape with the girl

[@SweetieBelleCipher1359]

AND THEN THE MAN WILL TAKE THIS PLACE :')

[@quirkyusername1093]

Well... that'll be hard considering that she's dead

[@maverickdarkrath4780]

Buskman actually losing the rose makes it so your basically no longer able to leave

[@CtisGaming]

There's no real food in the painted world. Ib would starve like she does in the Guertina's World ending.

[@adelaida5019]

Ib is dead. She tore her rose apart.

[@ma.cristinamendoza1870]

If this was a ending, i would say how to get it : 1 ) You need to have garry alive and have the exact same relationship with you. 2 ) You need to have mary alive and have the exact same relationship with you. 3 ) Finish the game with 1 life ( Rose ) left, like it has to be 1 rose. This is probably a good idea, but sad it wasnt actually a real ending.

[@kuba878]

It's an ending in the hardcore edition of the game. Though the creator of the game told the creator of the hardcore edition to delete it. Now there are only a handful of people who still have this edition of the game.

[@SoLaurexia]

@@kuba878 Why did the creator tell them to delete the ending o.O or was it the whole game that was made to be deleted?

[@lilyhope432]

Sound of Lechaim It's from a fan-made version called Ib:Green Edition, and this ending is also in Ib:Hardcore Edition, both of which Kouri has asked to be taken down. I don't understand why - People have to care a lot about something to create for it, and it's not like he's losing any money, because Ib is a free game. I don't know if any links still exist

[@thelivingliver6715]

also u need to pick the answer “sacrifice myself” when mary asks you if you can only leave with one other person who would it be. she canonically asks that

[@koishikomeiji5527]

I actually tried doing that in my run until I noticed the ending wasn't really a real ending in ib107... I WAS CRYING I CAN'T DO THE ENDING OVER AND OVER!

[@thuyenvu8954]

Dude, i know that this is wrong for me to say it but when Ib pushed Mary and Garry, it looks like she punched them 😂

[@sparky111000]

Thuyên Vũ it sounded like she punched them *pow*

[@blazerheata6479]

You think that Mary has a stomach ache from being guilt driven and sad but nah bro Ib freaking sucker punched her guts

[@Eckef]

._. I'd pick this ending if it was in the cannon game

[@-.Cherry-]

........Me too. I would do that.

[@elemenopi9239]

Good night to everybody except these three individuals.

[@sparky111000]

Dean Chou I always choose surrender myself in cannon game question and then this game was beautiful, based a true comic.

[@saveevans327]

Same..

[@imthecoolestguyalive]

I know the creator isn't fond of this ending (for totally understandable reasons, it could feel rather OOC, and it does kinda trample over the intended story), but. My God, did Mary and Garry's "IB!!!" portraits tear my heart out. This is so mean. Why would someone do this. I need to lay down and cry after this. *_I adore it._*

[@ni-chol7427]

Come back to see this end and just realized that it a really sad ending Ib is gone. Mary have to feel guilty forever and might be even guilty because she try to kill Gary and now he really nice to her. Gary doesn't remember Ib well he might be the only happy one in this ending.

[@DamionFox2004]

So basically anyone who leaves with Mary will become a sibling to her. This is actually done really well and wish this was one of the endings you could get. I'm guessing to get this ending you need to have high friendship with both Mary and Garry and keep them both alive.

[@yuuyakizami2133]

"But it is not the end of this long road, as that the Red Rose faced the greatest of virtues - sacrifice. Pushing both the deranged yellow rose and the calm blue rose into the Fabricated World, sacrificing life herself for the best of the both of them."

[@learose989]

Wait, so if I replaced the hanged man painting, then who replaced Mary's painting?

[@jazzydrawz3792]

the hanged man

[@haileycasa3866]

@@jazzydrawz3792 wut

[@jazzydrawz3792]

@@haileycasa3866 What?

[@CtisGaming]

@@haileycasa3866 Their account's name was probably Ib when they posted that comment and they've changed it since.

[@ShadwSonic]

Or it was a typo... either or.

[@thelivingliver6715]

i thought this ending was canon when i first discovered this game. mary canonically asked ib who she wanted to leave with, and her answer would decide who dies. and this ending is based off if she chose to sacrifice herself to save both her new friends

[@jinclay4354]

Guys, guys, the modified versions aren't lost. I found both Green Edition and Hardcore Edition today. They're in a certain archive. I'm not linking it, though.

[@freckleflies]

Whoa really?? Thanks for the info, I'll have to look for it!

[@shininglunarz514]

Awww... At least Mary remembers

[@PuchimonExtreme]

Ah, the wonderful fan made ending that got permanently removed from the net. Though I kind of find it weird that we (the ones that prefer this ending the most) would "happily" send the 'best character' in this series to her death.

[@MrGameguyC]

Here it is. A little sad this wasn't canon in the remake but oh well. Good to see this video is still up!

[@andreaspeter8687]

good news this mod already posted in internet archive

[@MrGameguyC]

@@andreaspeter8687 Oh!? Where is it?

[@andreaspeter8687]

@@MrGameguyC ib green edition or ib hardcore edition u can search in google

[@diznutz5369]

I think it's clear why the creator disliked this, he made Mary as a fearful monster being human like the most scary thing about her, she can pretend to be at your side, pretend to be you, pretend to be others, seem like just another girl like ib, while really being just another paint monster. This regards Mary as a real human not an evil Pinocchio with different fantasy mechanics

[@diznutz5369]

Its also worth noting that she is the closest to a boss or an antagonist we have, it's really dumb to ever think of her as our third protagonist, this misunderstanding is only possible in this anime communities were we ship anything that barely looks alike, we root for anything that is bright and protagonist like, oh well, normies

[@sparky111000]

Cherry Nuckles Nah the creator was just mad that the person used their game without permission first.

[@nompuehuenu]

@@diznutz5369 tbh how sad to not let a character be multidimensional.

[@diznutz5369]

@@nompuehuenu I don't remember much after 10 months, the least I can say is that giving a character dimensions is not necessarily better and the one note ones are very convenient for short stories

[@nompuehuenu]

@@diznutz5369 playing ib again brought me here, sorry. but wasting such an amazing character as Mary who could've been much more is so sad tbh, none of your characters should be one-dimensional

[@user-he4zs9db7f]

I like this ending more than all of the others ending. This makes it feels like the friendship between the two of them and ib really exist an she sacrificed herself to make garry go back to his world and achieve mary’s dream to be exist in the real world

[@demyp7656]

this is the only ending that made me cry. damn I just wish all three of them would be saved :')

[@nursezatufek5716]

But that would kinda ruin the game, wouldn't it?

[@IreneTheBat]

@@nursezatufek5716 a bit, it could bé like a secret ending or something because, come on, wen we played ib game we all wanted all of them to survive

[@midnightmoonnn9033]

My chest hurts My tears are falling in floor I remembered my brother Who sacrifice me too From a car crash He was a great brother like ib :)

[@lucyg1073]

oh I so sorry for your brother ...

[@norin9940]

Oh poor thing...I hope your brother is safe now 😊😊😭

[@xaviermoonlove7886]

I"m sos orry,your brother is superhero

[@agathaplayziez4953]

I know I'm late but... sorry for your brother

[@aruzyen4044]

I feel sorry for your brother....he's really a good person.

[@jaxattax5560]

I actually cried a small bit. *sigh* I feel bad for Mary, despite her being an ass in every other ending.

[@thelivingliver6715]

shes very easy to empathize for actually. shes lonely, and that leads her to going insane, and the only way she is allowed to get out is if she replaces someone else. killing them is indeed a stretch, but like i said, she’d gone insane due to lonliness

[@darthestar8791]

Damn. This is a sad yet beautiful ending. Gary doesn't have to die, and Mary doesn't have to die(plus she gets to get out of the painting world). But it's at the cost of our own life. Because as much as I hate it, the fact of the matter is that only either two humans can escape, or a human and a painting can go(but at the cost of another human being left behind). And Mary can't leave by herself either( Ib's "a paintings demise" ending pretty much showed what happens)

[@gumikurenaino8048]

I just love this ending so much, i wish it was an actual ending from the game :(

[@user-ri2rr5gg6n]

Me to. I'm just going to lie to myself and say it's Canon. No one can copyright my brain

[@andreaspeter8687]

@@user-ri2rr5gg6n well this fan game already release in internet archive

[@sparky111000]

6:27 my favorite moment. The music is beautiful. I was hoping this would be another cannon ending to the game. Since it did give a question of who would you leave with: Gary, Mary or surrender yourself.

[@keshialinardo3540]

Where girls cry: Titanic Where boys cry: Tony Stark's death Where mans cry: Caesar's death Where legends cry: 1:34

[@HappyGoLucky149]

Ceasar's death still got me Crying :(((

[@sourlemon6484]

This game plays with your emotions like you can’t save them all

[@Timothy6195]

This has to be the saddest youtube video ever.

[@Autumn-Rain1122]

This should have been in the remake ngl

[@conficturaincarnatus1034]

Now that the remake spoiled me, i need a remake version of this headcanon ending of mine.

[@liamlional9433]

6 yrs-ish later and this still ages like fine wine. Love this game and love your work

[@KineticCosmetic]

This literally broke me down to tears. 😭🤧

[@JacobNintendoNerd99]

This ending is canon. Creator be damned.

[@smg3962]

nop m8

[@JacobNintendoNerd99]

Mary is nothing but a sociopathic bitch in quite literally every ending in the original game. This is the only ending that actually "paints" her as something other than a deranged monster that needs to be burned.

[@xuannguyenngo5519]

+Jacob Heward she is NOT A BITCH

[@Morgru]

And perhaps only Ib's selflessness could bring Mary back to her senses. Even though she is just a painting, but she somehow has a soul of her own. Plus, she likes Ib so much to the point that recognizing her as a friend the first time she met Ib. It makes me sad a great deal just watching this vid...Is sacrifice necessary in order to save someone? Both in terms of physically and mentality??

[@samjin4203]

You mean including the one where she doesnt want to ditch Ib and decides that she likes Garry? She seems pretty okay in that if you ask me. Shes like 9 btw. So...

[@zerumsiru5204]

I was hoping this ending would appear in the remake.

[@supermemoluigi]

even tho it isn't a canon ending this for sure it's my favorite. Forever Together and Promise of Reunion are really nice seeing the saved Characters all happy, but there was always one character who ends up trapped or death in the Painting World and we couldn't do Anything about it, just sacrifice it, but this ending, this give us the option to save them both and for IB, who was trapped in the Painting World, she's happy in her death knowing that both are alive and safe from this world.

[@melontimer7505]

I NEED TO SEE A SEQUEL. I think everyone else agrees. We need to see more of the gallery world and how it works. Beacuse we saw it change reality in the normal world in some of the endings. Is it just me or does it feel like the gallery feel alive. Like its a living being.

[@naomisisk4663]

It's an SCP confirmed. Also, I think a sequel would ruin it. The best things don't stay forever.

[@freckleflies]

No sequel but there's a remake announced for hopefully next year

[@Post_Stall_Maneuver]

​@@frecklefliesAnd as someone who got into Ib through the remake, I can say it is absolutey amazing (Mary's theme is completely different, copyright IIRC). Even the graphics have leaped in quality.

[@sparky111000]

Even if this was a fan made ending and got backlashed from the original creator. I still love this ending that wasn't in the original game. ❤ its just so beautiful and bitter sweet ❤

[@MQKWJXNDRBTVPL]

I cried the first three times i saw this, now my grief is basically gone and i do not cry for this anymore. This is bad, i like crying...

[@sakoz7650]

Damn, I kinda wished there was a "super-secret Ending" where all of them got out alive back in the real world.

[@midnight_matter8707]

Oh f&ck... ...This probably *should* be the true canon ending! it's damn amazing!!! F&cking Mary's reaction almost actually made me cry...

[@u_no8816]

This ending makes me cry, I hope Mary and Garry can life happily and remembering Ib

[@Lowpiss]

Mary is going regret everything at her life man

[@maryguertena5488]

I don't know why I can't change my profile picture to a happier me, but I think this video has something to do with it. . .Ib. . .

[@TheBillliantOne]

Mary...? :(

[@poyosuncut5854]

dooooooooooooooooont worry Mary, this ending does not exist in reality xd. So maybe your creator thinks that you are just a pure evil being with no chance of redemption xd. But look at the positive things !!!..... When you find something that is positive in this call me, because i find nothing positive in this sentence :D

[@hugo_the_waffle]

oh...

[@terung1392]

two years and you didn't change it

[@kitariauthor5943]

Garry and Mary crying at the same time when she pushed them out through the painting h u r t m e-

[@CannoliSlugYT]

In my past I believed that ending was canon... silly young me. T-T

[@edu2104]

I think we all need an ending that the 3 of the escape

[@hanawithouth]

This is my favourite ending, even if it ain't canon.

[@megasecptile3996]

After watching Pikasprey play through the remake and seeing all the ending from looking it up, then reading there was a fan made ending (which is this exact one). It's painful to see that. Not only does it connect dots and make references to the other endings. Here's what I got from it. Garry forgot everything since outsiders don't remember anything when being brought back from the painting world, like shown in Promise of Reunion and Memory's Crannies, but paintings exiting into the world preserve their memories from when they were in the painting world, like shown in A Painting's Demise. So when Mary says, "I'm very very sorry" it isn't towards Garry, but rather Ib. And maybe Garry but mostly Ib. The reason being is that Ib made the promise of exiting out with Mary but instead, forced Garry and Mary out to stay behind. Letting Mary hold onto that guilt and altering the memories of Ib's parents and Garry's, hence the apologies she makes. And since she preserved those memories of when Ib sacrificed herself and Garry mentioning the new portrait, of Ib, Mary couldn't hold it back any more and broke down. I love this fan made ending. It's just perfect in every way that I see it. And I just love communities who love the game they play, to make endings like these where it hits the hardest to those who know, maybe even outsiders. I know I'm years late on this but I was curious about it and I'm glad I found it.

[@ioriyume]

i love them so much theyre like a little family ugh

[@spxcewxlker462]

I almost cry every time I watch this ending. Especially when Mary see the picture of Ib

[@BeanSprouts02]

The “Goodbye” made my heart drop 😔

[@LeLe-2.0]

I noticed I am not getting long for me, I always feel I lost something since I was brim. I am more easily to feel tired and pain… I need to keep something change in the time… you have to remember, you get a pain childhood, it’s longer than you think…unluckily you end when you start to feel happier… this is where you like or love from you time…you must be control by your imagination…and that is pretty. Don’t think you are strange, that are the most happiest time you get…don’t care about are you the sister or brother you just need to know you want to love and be love…the only thing we trust is love…it’s the second strongest feeling we get in our brains . Human never know the closest and secret thing in the world is our brain…they lie by human and time, space…. I fail to end….you need to get into your brain or end yourself….otherwise you can survive…..this is you life…. We stilll can save if we work hard….but the chance is close to zero…. You need the most quiet, humanless peace…..hope you can succeed-lelesa

[@aoneko6813]

Phew~ I played IB at release (back then, i was 12, not too far from Ib's age.) I remember watching a pewdiepie let's play - but decided the game was so cool i would play it before i watched the following let's plays. I was scared shitless at every turn. After every session, I would get paranoid, not daring to leave my room at night, lol. I cried at the endings. Fast forward to current day, I just finished the remake! (Really happy this was made!) All-in-all, I was very satisfied and had several moments where my heart was pounding like crazy, dispite knowing a majority of the scares by heart. Now, I stumbled upon this video and holy shit, I cried so bad... ;_; This is such a good ending. God bless everyone involved in this. It fits right in with the other endings. Sad to see that kouri didn't like it. Welp, I think Japan has a different cultural mindset regarding intellectual property, (and consequently modding culture) so it makes sense, I suppose. It's confusing though, doujinshi culture in Japan is supposively pretty big, so it's strange that it isn't liked here?

[@nottoonoobgamer5867]

the ending in original game is actually unlikely, when Mary trades with Garry, she doesn`t hate ib but when she doesn`t trade, she hates them both, and want them to die. you can see how ib behaves when garry tells ib that shes not human based on the route, (or i dont remember if ib actually behave different) but i remember, for example , ib hugs or doesnt hug garry and, Mary tells them in her room; BOTH OF YOU ARE OKAY?! (i dont remember again)

[@kyulkyung4059]

I played this game like 5 years ago and I had no clue this wasn't canon 💀 I did all the different routes, i guess i downloaded the game with different non-canon endings without noticing damn.

[@kaktus5715]

Sometimes I really wish this ending was Canon.

[@itstrash_pigeon5304]

GOD DAM ONION NINJAS (;´༎ຶД༎ຶ`)

[@libertyblue159]

This made me laugh so much XD

[@analaids1687]

Ib can push 2 people outta of painting dimension but cant push a statue Seem legit

[@Buzzy913]

That was beautiful and heart-wrenching... My god... ;-;

[@zosiak3900]

damn. that ending hits hardest of them all imo especially when we see Ib's parents and Mary remember everything even tho she wanted to escape with her but that also shows how much she cared for her

[@alexanderjohnson5330]

Since the game released a few months ago remastered, I hope they update it sometime to add this as an ending, of course with Kouri's permission and the mod maker's as well.

[@andreaspeter8687]

is already release in internet archive

[@TheBillliantOne]

I'm so conflicted! This ending is happy and sad all at once! X(

[@MrGameguyC]

It did kind of bug me that there was no audio in the old video, but honestly it's nice to see this end in better lightening. Good job recording man & thank you for deciding to re upload this ending for anyone else still interested in it. Also, thanks for telling me about this. Now I'll go out & drag Josh to see this ending again.

[@Glimmericious]

+MrGameguycolor I'm sorry a bout the lack of audio in the last video, by the way. My craptop back when I recorded that was completely incapable of recording sound. It was a complete hassle. That's the primary reason this took so long.

[@MrGameguyC]

No worries man, it's done & dusted. Also if you're on of those people who care, for whatever reason that video received over 100,000 views. I guess most of those people didn't need the audio to enjoy & discuss the ending. But aside from that, do you plan on making another video after this?

[@Glimmericious]

It still absolutely boggles my mind that the video reached that number. I'd occasionally check in on it, and it was flabbergasting. In terms of future content... I'm just not sure. I'm too sure what I would try and get into. I've occasionally considered gaming, but my laptop, while better, is still pretty bad. As such, I'd rather not. If all else fails, I may try and do more stuff like this - Even though I only fleetingly managed to grab this. It could prove a fun project, finding out how this was made and doing it for other stuff.

[@MrGameguyC]

It was one of the 1st videos to show the ending, & a lot of people have started many conversions through the comment section. So it's a bit understandable to see why it took off so well in my opinion. (Maybe you should enable ads & make money off that video. :P) Ah yes gaming on the internet, it always seem like you need the higher dollar equipment in order to run any game at a decent rate that wasn't made through RPG Maker. I'm stuck in the same boat with my laptop & it really does limit what I can play on my channel. If you're going to stick with making more videos on games like this. Then by all means, go for. Play whatever you like, heck maybe experiment with other/maybe lesser know RPG maker games. Just a suggestion.

[@idkhi1837]

It definetly isnt one of my favourite endings but it was really well made(props to that) and also it really sad and made me tear up abit to an extent. I wish it was canon but i could see why the creator wouldnt want that

[@demomandemopan370]

heartaches by the numbers troubles by the score everyday I watch this vid, each day I cry some more

[@kyuuchat]

Seeing this makes me realize how much I wished there was another ending added in the remake. Not this one in particular, but just, something.

[@acerbusthedarkenvtuber5684]

Holy shit. That is an amazing ending.

[@user-jw7mc6hl7s]

I'M NOT CRYING, YOU'RE CRYING

[@normundsozolins2391]

Heres an idea for an ending i had. In the toybox part where Mary takes Ib's rose and trades it with Garry, i wonder what would happen if Mary would take Ib's rose and then Ib would go to the real world? I can imagine something like this: Garry understands that Mary likes Ib, and wouldn't hurt her. They would escape the abyss, and Mary would forgive Ib and Garry, because they gave one of their roses for memory. Mary would keep Ib's rose as her memory and make friends with the dolls. The happiest ending i can think of while not saving everyone exactly. Everyone is alive, but Mary gets left behind, with the memory of Ib, keeping her rose in a vase.

[@Wateey]

Oh! That actually sounds very nice! So much more pleasant than having to burn Mary's painting down T-T

[@khanhvan8011]

this ending is sad yet not official, but i personally believe it to be the canon

[@goldenfranny6012]

the instrument we hear at the start is old doll from the mad father games

[@cursed7992]

that heartbeat ending. Jesus, it made me cry so hard.

[@kokochydaios]

This is my favorite ending..... sad it's not in the game. It's really good.

[@Rainbow-lr9uy]

Well dang, didn’t think I was gonna cry today-

[@blake.1312]

Straight out of the deep emo section of Wattpad.

[@necrofixia1142]

It was the game that most marked my life. His horror is the most brilliant I've ever seen, I say without a doubt that this game is unique. I've never seen anything in the genre like it. Ib is a brilliant, dark, melancholic and poetic horror The feeling of this game is unforgettable, unparalleled The author had a choice of colors and music that perfectly match the environment and the story of the game, even though it is graphically limited, everything is detailed, everything is thought, everything is depressing, sad and with a background of hope that is almost dying. In IB the terror is in the environment, in the despair of never being able to get out of the chaotic and melancholy beautiful illusion. Everything is leaving, suffering, crying, asking for help in some way, entities are suffering due to their painter creator who is crumbling along Childhood drawings, past traumas, desires. Everything was gathered there in one place, brooding, wanting to disappear. Seeing this, we even feel sorry for these ''evil' entities, this is much clearer with the Mari Entity, we also have the Entity that accompanies the IB all the time, which I believe is a painting by the painter there too, he is the feeling of hope that exists in that world. Mari hates him so much, she doesn't want to be erased, because she knows that the author wants that, he wants to erase all that torment. Mari doesn't want to be alone, she doesn't want to die, she doesn't want to be forgotten, this desire is so strong that Mari acts violently not to be alone. Mari's entity has life, emotions, feelings, meaning. Like all the works of its creator. It's something totally interpretive and I think of IB that way, your story is beautiful, told in a simple way, but very meaningful to everyone who played it

[@thisonetoo4669]

ok but one of the things i love about this is that it says "you feel tired" and then ib turns around and throws a little girl and a grown man into a painting like fuck thats strength

[@lunastars6160]

Aw...WAIT THERE HAS TO BE A TWIST THE PARENTS SAID THEY MIGHT HAVE A KID!!! KID-IB SO SHE MIGHT BEABLE TO COME BACK RIGHT?!

[@supercorn5607]

Unless kouri makes a second game about this, we will never know. And that's what really saddens me. Promise of reunion but we never really knew if they actually reunited that's why a second game is needed. :(

[@sparky111000]

I really loved this ending, it was so beautiful 🥺

[@glitchydemonfairy3171]

This needs to be an ending in the game!!!

[@SamPings]

Back then, I watched this thinking its was a secret or new ending. Wish it was canon cause it feels canon:3 Everytime I come across this I ALWAYS rewatch it cuz' it's just THAT good💖💖🥺🥺 But, yeah.. I also watched a comic dub here somwhere with the same ending, Ib sacrificing herself only.. different dialogue.. and Garry remembers her. ugh.. inspiration knocked my braincell, imma be makin' a vocal cover and arrangement of Ib's theme with this ending if you don't mind.. Just finished the lyrics btw🙃🙃

[@actualdragonfly7657]

WOAH this is just a fan made but I got chills from this

[@angelitastevenson834]

Well at least Mary has a new friend and family and could leave but it would be great if this were canon and if there was another ending where all three could leave too...

[@skalbagge3131]

It's so sad... why can't everyone be together?

[@RamenLlama]

Ib's mom, can you give me a handkerchief? I think I'm about to cry