Ibn Hajar on the Mawlid

وذكر عن الحافظ ابن حجر أن "أصل عمل المولد بدعة لم تنقل عن أحد من السلف الصالح من القرون الثلاثة، ولكنها مع ذلك اشتملت على محاسن وضدها.. فمن تحرى في عمله المحاسن وتجنب ضدها كانت بدعة حسنة ومن لا فلا".
يقول ابن حجر: "وقد ظهر لي تخريجها علي أصل ثابت وهو ما ثبت في الصحيحين أن رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم قدم المدينة، فوجد اليهود يصومون عاشوراء، فسألهم، فقالوا هذا يوم أغرق الله فيه فرعون وأنجي فيه موسي فنحن نصومه شكرًا لله، فقال: إنا أحق بموسى منكم فصامه وأمر بصيامه .
فيستفاد من فعل ذلك شكرًا لله تعالي على ما من به الله في يوم معين من إسداء نعمة أو دفع نقمة، ويعاد ذلك في نظير ذلك اليوم من كل سنة ، والشكر لله يحصل بأنواع العبادات والسجود والصيام والصدقة والتلاوة، وأي نعمة أعظم من النعمة ببروز هذا النبي الكريم ،نبي الرحمة في ذلك اليوم؟
وعلى هذا، فينبغي أن يتحرى اليوم بعينه حتى يطابق قصة موسى صلى الله عليه وسلم في يوم عاشوراء، ومن لم يلاحظ ذلك لا يبالي بعمل المولد في أي يوم من الشهر، بل توسع قوم حتى نقلوه إلى أي يوم من السنة، وفيه ما فيه، فهذا ما يتعلق بأصل عمل المولد.
وأما ما يعمل فيه، فينبغي أن يقتصر فيه على ما يفهم الشكر لله تعالى من نحو ما تقدم ذكره من التلاوة والإطعام والصدقة وإنشاد شيء من المدائح النبوية، والزهدية المحركة للقلوب إلى فعل الخيرات والعمل للآخرة.
وأما ما يتبع ذلك من السماع واللهو وغير ذلك فينبغي أن يقال ما كان من ذلك مباحًا، بحيث يتعين السرور بذلك اليوم لا بأس بإلحاقه به، ومهما كان حرامًا أو مكروها فيمنع وكذا ما كان خلافًا للأولى.

[@wajahatgilani]

We all need to focus more and more on loving the Prophet (S)

[@AlphaMaverick1111]

ﷺ

[@MW_3]

@@wajahatgilani yes but it doesn’t have to be in Mawlid necessarily akhi. Love, learn and follow his teachings every day, week, month and year

[@ismailmiah1446]

By implementing deen in life

[@wajahatgilani]

@@MW_3 Alhamdulilah

[@aqsa005]

The MAWLID of ibn Hajar's time was not like Todays MAWLID. and Ibn Hajar was wrong here what was not part of Our religion At the time of Sahaba can not be part of our religion Now.

[@jaywalker6464]

Sorry i don't do syiah tradition

[@Memic86]

All analogy in ibaadah, qiyaas in ibaadah is not permissible according to consesus of ‘ulamaa. Ibn hajar makes mistakes like every scholar. Fast on monday if you want reward and stop this nonsense, stop spreading bid’ah may Allah guide you ameen.

[@SafinaSociety]

It's not an analogy in ibada. It's an analogy in celebration. Celebrating things is halal if the matter being celebrated is halal, as well as the means of celebrating it.

[@Memic86]

@@SafinaSociety fasting on monday is an ibaadah, are you saying the way the soofies celebrate the mawlid is not considered ibaadah? Isn’t celebrating loving the prophet peace be upon him an ibaadah? The prophet himself said “none of you will truly believe until he loves ne more than his mother, his father…” Isn’t anything we do that Allah loves us for an ibaadah? What is the point of celebrating this innovation if it is not ibaadah?

[@SafinaSociety]

@@Memic86 No being happy is not an act of ibada. Hence the only ruling is on the subject of why you are happy, and how you express it.

[@bilbo23baggins]

Hey amir, we do Mawlid because we want to, if you don't like it - go somewhere else.

[@Memic86]

@@bilbo23baggins hey bilbo Abu Sa'id al-Khudri reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying: You would tread the same path as was trodden by those before you inch by inch and step by step so much so that if they had entered into the hole of the lizard, you would follow them in this also. We said: Allah's Messenger, do you mean Jews and Christians (by your words)" those before you"? He said: Who else (than those two religious groups)? حَدَّثَنِي سُوَيْدُ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ، حَدَّثَنَا حَفْصُ بْنُ مَيْسَرَةَ، حَدَّثَنِي زَيْدُ بْنُ أَسْلَمَ، عَنْ عَطَاءِ، بْنِ يَسَارٍ عَنْ أَبِي سَعِيدٍ الْخُدْرِيِّ، قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم ‏"‏ لَتَتَّبِعُنَّ سَنَنَ الَّذِينَ مِنْ قَبْلِكُمْ شِبْرًا بِشِبْرٍ وَذِرَاعًا بِذِرَاعٍ حَتَّى لَوْ دَخَلُوا فِي جُحْرِ ضَبٍّ لاَتَّبَعْتُمُوهُمْ ‏"‏ ‏.‏ قُلْنَا يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ آلْيَهُودَ وَالنَّصَارَى قَالَ ‏"‏ فَمَنْ ‏"‏ ‏.‏ Reference : Sahih Muslim 2669a In-book reference : Book 47, Hadith 7 USC-MSA web (English) reference : Book 34, Hadith 6448

[@mahmoodiqbal6666]

Criteria is quran and sunnah not the aimma or ullama . Juhaal qullu biddatin zalaala wa qullu zalaalatu finnaar .doesn't matter what ibne hajar or any one else says . It's what the prophet pbuh said that is deen . Stop corrupting the deen and fear Allah.

[@brawlnator]

I'd rather follow the sahaba than any scholar. They loved the prophet عليه صلاة و السلام more than any of us ever will. They understood the Deen better than any of us ever will. Did they celebrate the mawlid? Nope. I'll just play it safe and follow their foot steps since the prophet عليه سلام himself gave them the seal of approval. Saying that they're the BEST generation. 🤷‍♂️

[@EesaChance]

Exactly. And it is well known that the mawlid was introduced by the shia raafidah, so to celebrate it is to follow their sunnah instead of the companions.

[@carfreaknazz]

Technically you still follow the scholars because all the hadith and commentaries come from the scholars, so you're not directly following the sahabah at all.. The scholars know the sahabah better than the lay muslim who can't even read the Arabic matan of the hadith..

[@DeitritusFillamore]

The sahaba did everything that happens during a mawlid. They did salawat, they recited poetry praising the prophet, they read Quran, they gave lectures on the seerah, and they did dhikr. The only difference is that these days, people like to schedule a day to come together and do these things and we have picked the day of the birth of the prophet. It really isn’t that complicated

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@brawlnator The idea of thanking Allah for the birth of the Prophet SAW by going good deeds on it, and being happy on it didn't come to the sahabah. But later on the idea did come to our minds, and now it's a good thing to do. Same goes for marked prayer rows. Is it not an innovation? Did the sahabah do it? But its a very good innovation!

[@bozhaque5754]

Celebrating itself isn't haram. As Allah says to rejoice in the Quran. Celebrating his birth is not a innovation, as it's ruling can be derived from the hadith about fasting on monday and other hadith. Celebrating once a year is an innovation but Hajar Asqalani has given its ruling. Doing it once a year, the ruling can be derived from the hadith about salatul tasbih. If the sufis or whoever is dancing and does an act of haraam, that specific becomes haraam not the entire thing. Islam is about moderation the middle path. Those that believe Allah will punish you for it showing gratitude once a year, have really dumbed down the region and Allah's wisdom and mercy.

[@uj9700]

Beautifully said brother ♥️

[@justaky]

Well said 👍

[@tazboy1934]

What about those who cuts cake on mawlid like some in subcontinent?

[@bozchowdhury6286]

Then learn to condemn the action and not the practice itself. Only a fool generalises particulars.

[@AbdulRehman-j6q9h]

Can u give the reference from quran and hadeeth or any sahaba celebrated Happy Birthday to you 😃 Abu Baker Umar uthman Ali (ra) know this religion islam more than any one can u give any one reference from any books by them celebrating happy birthday to you 🎉

[@Lucario6804]

I'd like to think that the sahaba and the early salaf would've celebrated the mawlid if it was correct, because surely they loved the prophet more than people 600 years after did?

[@ottersarecutest]

exactly We love the prophet ﷺ but celebrating the mawlid is a biddah may Allah guide us

[@DeitritusFillamore]

The sahaba did everything that happens during a mawlid. They did salawat, they recited poetry praising the prophet, they read Quran, they gave lectures on the seerah, and they did dhikr. The only difference is that these days, people like to schedule a day to come together and do these things and we have picked the day of the birth of the prophet. It really isn’t that complicated

[@TheSlaveofAllah7]

Why don't these same people tell us the book that Ibn Hajar said it and the page number?

[@DrWoofOfficial]

I could only find it in Al-Hāwī-lil-Fatāwī by As-Suyooti (Part 1, Page 229) but I don't know where Ibn Hajr said it in his own works

[@thestraightpath8236]

الْحَمْدُ للَّهِ رَبِّ الْعَـلَمِينَ FOR ISLAM الْحَمْدُ للَّهِ رَبِّ الْعَـلَمِينَ FOR MAKING US FROM THE BLESSED UMMAH OF THE BEST OF CREATION, AL-SADIQ, AL-AMEEN, RAHMAT-UL-LIL-'AALAMEEN, JADDAL HUSSAIN, RASOOL-ALLAH ﷺ

[@ottersarecutest]

We love the prophet ﷺ but celebrating the mawlid is a biddah may Allah guide us

[@OhYeaTheBest]

We love Mawlid in Nabi Sallalhu Alihe Walihi Wassalam

[@ottersarecutest]

@@OhYeaTheBest We love the prophet ﷺ but celebrating the mawlid is a biddah may Allah guide us

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@ottersarecutest It's a bid'ah hasnah if you celebrate it with good deeds (which includes giving feasts and reciting naats) and avoid evil ones.

[@ottersarecutest]

@@BLACKPANTHER-m1h no such thing as biddah hasanah, all biddahs are misguidance and all misguidances are in fire. Don’t innovate in Allah’s religion, it’s not worth not drinking from the Kawthar in heaven

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@ottersarecutest Nope there is such a thing as bid'ah hasanah, and all 4 khulaafa Ar Rasshideen (and other sahabah) have engaged in it e.g. Uthman RA did bid'ah hasnah by adding the 2nd adhan of Jumuah. Even the Prophet SAW has encouraged us to innovate good things in the religion e.g. Nabi SAW said "He who introduced in Islam a good practice which got practiced after him; the reward would be written for him (even) of those who practiced it after him..." Muislim 1017e

[@arshadmohammed5534]

You can keep on making videos with the titles “ibn hajar on Mawlid “, “ibn Arabi on Mawlid” ibn falan, sheikh falan etc but can never make any video that says “Rasool Allah on Mawlid “ “abu bakr on mawlid “ “ Umer on Mawlid” radiallahu anhum.

[@mohammedhamedsajid8349]

Beautiful reply

[@DeitritusFillamore]

No it’s a stupid reply

[@arshadmohammed5534]

@@DeitritusFillamore yes that’s what green goblins always say when they are cornered 😁

[@MotorWorld-v8y]

⁠@@DeitritusFillamorewhen Allah says if you love me then follow him it’s all in the Quran and sunnah follow the messenger your saying it’s a stupid reply akhi may Allah guide us

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@mohammedhamedsajid8349 Yes it is a stupid reply, because the Prophet SAW didn't prohibit it so it counts as a bid'ah hasnah. The Prophet SAW and the sahabah don't need to do something for it to be permissible. If that were the case, why do you have marked prayer rows in Masajid? Why do women have separate sections in the masjid?

[@wordswords5926]

Ustadh don’t forget according to salafis Ibn Hajar ra repented on his death bed just like every other Muslim authority 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@yojan9238]

Please don't bluff same as the Neo-Pseudo-Salafi-Wahhabi. Off course, he do repented everyday of his life. Ibn Hajar Asqalani, As-Suyuthi and Ibn Hajar Al-Haitami. Everyone of them were the Ashab of Shafie'iyyah. They're the Imams (A'immah) of the Shafi'e mazhab and they're Ash'arites. The Traditionalist Students know their teachers, the sanad (chain of transmission) of their teachers, their ulemas, more than the Neo-Pseudo-Salafi-Wahhabi. Neo-Pseudo-Salafi-Wahhabis are the outsiders, not from us, the Shafie'iyyah, but they declared they knew better than us the Shafie'iyyah.

[@khairt1731]

Their spiritual guide and Master Ibn Wahab is infallible, remember? Same with Shaykh Baz. Wahabis didnt find 1 "mistake" in their speech yet. Amazing isnt it? Nah, its just their gang mentality.

[@AbdulRehman-j6q9h]

​@@yojan9238mawlid is celebrated only by the grave worshipers.learn islam e Deen from the people of madina.not from the grave worshipers and bidahathis.

[@thepeacefulislaam8667]

​@@yojan9238yeah

[@faris6755]

Lol

[@raihantayeb]

To start the video by saying Ibn Hajr, whatever he said, is acceptable unconditionally is in itself a red flag.

[@annabhai8733]

Is Celebriting Allah's Ramah on Mankind is Bidda? I thought Allah send our beloved Prophet Mohammad S.W.S as Ramah to mankind and whole reactions of Allah..

[@calmskies1299]

Muslims need to accept this difference There are bigger issues that unite us Calling each other names or insulting them or even questioning their belief is a clear sin On another note, it's not about personalities, look at the arguments.. And agree to disagree if you wish but don't defame each other...

[@abuaisha715]

Prophet sallalah alayhi wassallam, Abubakar, umar , and all companions radhiyallah anhum not accept .❤

[@abdullahmahmud1298]

Ibn hazar and suyuti are not prophet.....they have mistakes....this just their opinion which was wrong..... Prophet, companions and the three best generation didn’t ever celebrate the mawlid which today the sufi invent and celebrate it..... Sufism is not Islam.... Its a deviant sect..... follow the Akida and Manhaj of righteous Salaf.....

[@MotorWorld-v8y]

Did Abu bakr ra do mawlid please clarif The prophet saw said follow me and my companions

[@aneeskemal4431]

Remember Rasulullah SallAllahu Alayhi Wasallam asked us to follow the Sahabah RadhiAllahu Anhum, the Tabieen and Tab Tabieen Alayhi Rahma. The Hadith ends with 'after these three generations falsehood will prevail. Ibn Hajar came after the three generations so his Fatwa doesn't form Shariah. Try again.

[@saadsalman4518]

Who is ibn hajar? Mawlid is biddah the end, just search how birthdays are started so if you claim is that its a good biddah then its not, as just search how birthdays started. Also who is ibn hajar? Why didnt abu bakr, ali, umar uthman or anyone else celebrate it? Bafoonic argument

[@ahlussuffiya4225]

So if anyone really want to know the brief ruling and complete guidance on this topic(Mawlid un nabi(saw)) then the best book ever written is Mawlid un Nabi(PBUH) by Dr Tahirul qadri. So better read it, I am sure all your doubts regarding this would be cleared in sha allah

[@IzzoferRuste]

He has just merged imam suyutis and imam nahwis book on mawlid.this is what i heard from a scholar

[@tazboy1934]

Also mufti taqi usmani

[@AbdulRehman-j6q9h]

Only Barelvi grave worshipers believe in tahirul Qadri can u quote any books by imam Abu hanifa shafi Malik or Ahmed bin hambal (ra) about celebrating happy birthdays.

[@mohammedhamedsajid8349]

He is a big liar... deen of dreams

[@ottersarecutest]

We love the prophet ﷺ but celebrating the mawlid is a biddah may Allah guide us

[@mohammedhamedsajid8349]

So stupid of you to compare ashura with mawlid... At that time sallallahualaihiwasallam was ALIVE to make it ibadah.... now how you make it halal 600 years after the death of sallallahualaihiwasallam?

[@amirullah19]

Mawlid is part of faith , celebration of the day of arrival is a part of faith , if he had not come , u would have not known anything and would have been pagans. Allah says in Quran to send blessing on prophet . Why should he say that and that too in Quran . So take your ego aside and celebrate and recite durood.😊

[@princephilipisback]

Sallallahu alaihi wasSallam

[@yojan9238]

Alhamdulillah shaikh, as a country that upholds the Shafi'e Madzhab and the madzhab of the Ashhab Shafie'iyyah (our beloved Imam Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani included), we celebrated Maulid every year, nation wide. Neo-Pseudo-Salafi-Wahhabi thoughts and Shi'ah thoughts, are considered deviant sects here, many Fatwas have been issued regarding their twisted teachings.

[@affanansari5450]

Assalamu Alaikum Akhi, what country u live in?

[@dortoka]

@@affanansari5450He’s Indonesian I think

[@AbdulRehman-j6q9h]

He's day dreaming.

[@syedzainulabideen3564]

I just don't get it !! how stupid one can be...It's completely fine to reject a certain ideology and accept another as everyone has their own opinion. But, you cannot call a certain group deviant and then religiously follow their innovation (bid'ah) !!! Please do some research and learn about the guy who started Mawlid ?? The first Mawlid was started by a Shia ruler in Egypt.

[@yojan9238]

@@affanansari5450 wa'alaikumussalam warahmatullah. Can't mention it here.

[@Human_boy_91]

Imam Jalaluddin suyuti rahmatullah alaih was approved mawlid

[@MotorWorld-v8y]

It is reported on the Imaam Maalik, that he said: "Whosoever introduces into Islaam an innovation, which he deems is good, then he has claimed that Muhammad (saws) has betrayed (the trust of conveying) the Message. Read the saying of Allaah, the Mighty and Majestic: 'This day I have completed your Religion for you, and I have perfected My favor upon you, and I am pleased with Islaam as a Religion for you.' [Surat-ul-Maa’idah:3] So whatever was not (part of) the Religion on that day, is not (part of) the Religion on this day.

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@MotorWorld-v8y So all the bid'ah Hasanahs of the sahabah are also prohibited? Was Uthman RA naudhu billah a bid'ati because he introduced a 2nd Adhan for Jumu'ah? Was Umar RA a bid'ati because he restarted Taraweeh in a single jama'ah after the Prophet SAW stopped it? Was Abu Bakr RA a bid'ati for compiling the Quran? Was Ali RA a bid'ati for continuing the bid'ah hasanat of his predecessors. Was Umar RA a bid'ati because he started counting 3 talaqs (with the intention of 1) as 3? Was Ibn Umar RA a bid'ati because he added new words to the thalbiyah? Was Umar bin Abdal Aziz RA a bid'ati for increasing taraweeh to 36? Was Mu'adh bin Jabal RA a bid'ati bid'ati because he started the practice of completing the missed raka'ahs of Jama'ah after salam before the Prophet SAW commanded to do so?

[@MM-mc8hs]

إنا لله وإنا إليه راجعون Respectfully, forget about the mawlid. If this speaker and his followers invoke to other than Allah عز و جل, then the deeds will not be accepted, and the punishment is eternal hellfire

[@focus497]

صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم

[@muslimspeakmy]

Needs in depth thought. The basis of the fatwa was Ashura, that you could celebrate something if it for syukur to Allah. But Ashura was made known to the prophet and his actions are sunnah. Celebrating his birthday, he told us how to do it, we should fast. The fact that his birthday is a mystery, as all birthdays of all prophets before him, is designed, I feel, so that we do not commemorate them. Due to the large part of celebrating a birthday of a prophet that would require a lot of creativity, so that's why there is no specific guidance on it, and that is not by chance, it seems deliberately left out to ensure it doesn't happen. If it was a particularly good thing, it would have been very clear from the sunnah. Coming back to the prophet's (s.a.w) initiative on Ashura, that can be seen as part of the Sunnah, but interpret his actions and apply that to Mawlid is quite baseless and not proper methodology. Allah knows best, may we be forgiven for our striving.

[@abdidesign3255]

No one has put any date on the prophet’s birthday, the whole month is celebrated.

[@tyt2841]

He refuted Deobandis so bad right now 😂

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@tyt2841 Alhamdulillah whole ummah celebrates mawlid except Deobandis and Wahhabis/pseudosalafis (may Allah guide them Ameen)

[@AhlulAthar123]

So not 1 sahaba did it, not 1 from the salaf, yeah sure not a bidah😂

[@mwm2927]

It is bidha but a good bidha

[@AhlulAthar123]

@@mwm2927 كل بدعة ضلالة

[@eerievon2208]

@@AhlulAthar123as the late ahmed deedat once said to a salafi brother when the salafi called out to ahmed deedat calling him doing bid’ah by celebrating mawlid..the late ahmed deedat said “let Allah judge during Judgment Day”

[@islamictreasuresacrosstime5529]

Point taken. But really, I still don't understand why some Muslims zealously promote Mawlud as if it's an obligation when we can (to remember n praise Allah's most beloved servant ) encourage people to fast every Monday and do abundant Salawat on the Prophet (peace be upon him) every Friday. This is far superior to a one day show in a year. Meanwhile, I am curious to know if Imam Ghazaali and Abdul Qadr Jilani celebrated Mawlud in their time. This is an honest curiosity, if you know the answer please respond.

[@guccibase]

💯

[@toxic-2197]

No one says its obligation, you guys make it out to be that we do. It's recommended. If you want to do it. Do it. If you dont then don't. However you cannot make claims that its haram or evil bidah

[@dmmeforscript4729]

why salaf dont need to celebrate the mawlid ? because they know the prophet very well since they live near the sahabah that know prophet , but us we dont know unless we are studying it , and the purpose of mawlid is to let people know about the prophet life and shalawat upon him , its cultural thing that has ibadah inside it.

[@yojan9238]

The issue of Celebrating the Maulid already resolved a long time ago. It only arised again during the Neo-Pseudo-Salafi-Wahhabi era in Arabia. And sadly to say, many Westerners Muslims and the people who loves to study online without proper way of studying Islamic Knowledge plunges themselves into the fitan (fitnah) of Wahhabism.

[@squidguard1]

@@toxic-2197I know sufis personally who don’t pray, have house on riba, never share Islamic reminder of naseeha but are so persistent on celebrating mawlid

[@irfanalikurrimbux5515]

Why do you take Islam from the pagan's descendants and not from its source ? وَسَلَامٌ عَلَيْهِ يَوْمَ وُلِدَ وَيَوْمَ يَمُوتُ وَيَوْمَ يُبْعَثُ حَيًّا.

[@ubaidu11ah]

This aayat talks about Yahya AS

[@sehroz100]

The prophet peace be upon him and his companions showed us : 1. Explain the seerah of the prophet pbuh as he is our perfect example 2. Read quran 3. Give charity 4. Praise the prophet pbuh etc... Which we do on the day prophet was born. It can be any day during the year but rabi ul awwal is more special. Even the prophet commemorate this special day through fasting. It is just that the way we are commemorating is different which is a good innovation. Sunan al-Nasā’ī 1578 - The hadith kullu means majority not all innovation Sahih Muslim 1017 - The hadith emphasises on promoting good innovation in deen If any one wants to perform exactly of what sahaba done in the past. So guys start reciting quran like in 1400 years ago without harakat which has been newly added Stop using your mobile to read quran etcc.. Use camels or walk to masjid etc....... Finally its just a matter oh hidayah ! Will you be like satan who cries and shows his dislike when the prophet was born

[@flossyb.9532]

أشهد أن لا اله الا الله و أشهد أن محمدا عبده و رسوله

[@MkA-p9g]

Who is here 2024 ❤❤

[@NurSa3id]

When the Prophet s.a.w was asked why he fasted on Monday, he said *"Because I was born on a Monday."* From this, Ulamah concluded that celebrating our Beloved's s.a.w Birthday with worship is allowed. Only the ignorant compare our celebration of the Beloved's Birthday with a kafir's way of celebrating a birthday. We perform prayers and perform Salawaat upon our Prophet s.a.w, whereas kafirs get drunk and party. The difference is like day and night.

[@mycollections4068]

Fasting is not allowed on Eid days

[@NurSa3id]

@@mycollections4068 May Allah give us patience towards utter ignorant "brothers" like you... He is CELEBRATING his birthday by fasting, what are you talking about Eid days? Shameless people of today will even have the audacity to preach to the Prophet himself s.a.w if they had the chance... Just shut your mouth and listen to people who know what they're talking about without mixing your illogical thoughts in subjects you know nothing about.

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@mycollections4068 Buddy there's a difference between shar'i eid and lughawi (linguisic) eid. For example, here in Saudi Arabia; they celebrate EID ulwatni (national eid) on 23rd September. Why don't you call that bid'ah? Eid just linguistically mean a day of happiness and Mawlid is a day off happiness.

[@mycollections4068]

@@BLACKPANTHER-m1h there is no Eid linguistically also in shari matters

[@mycollections4068]

@@BLACKPANTHER-m1h many scholars have already advised against celebrating national day as well...... I don't support that as well ..... The only difference between national day and Eid milad is that national day is not celebrated thinking it's virtuous or it will give you good deeds

[@Dawah-Quest]

So should we celebrate our own birthdays? Should we also celebrate the birthday of other prophets peace be upon them? Should we also not be so judgmental on the Christians for their celebration of Christmas? Or are these questions not valid? My understanding is the shaytan gets us over time the same way the people of Noah (pbuh) started worshipping the righteous people! Personally for me a muslim is supposed to be living by sunnah everyday! We may all fall short on this but that should be the goal and by Allahs swt mercy we are the successful.

[@Shiyam-eh3dj]

Revelations stopped with the death of Our beloved prophet(s.a). Ateed (a.s.) doesn’t take anyone’s opinion when recording sins. He checks with teaching of the Prophet & Quran. If it is not listed then it will match with the sahih hadith (wahee) of bid’ah. And Mawlid was first celebrated by Fatimid shia dynasty in the world. Sorry for bothering your sect but it is my responsibility as ambassador of Allah

[@mohammedabdirrahmanrubblei9141]

Why don't you bring up the Imam Abul Walid Al-Baggs take on Mawlid

[@MukemalMohammed-mb1dm]

why don't our beloved Ummah do not stopped to OUR SALAF GENERATION ,why we do things they don't do by saying bida'a hasana

[@afrozzz5634]

JazakAllah khayr dr!

[@ahamedzeidh5614]

Masha Allah ❤

[@kazimnidiaye527]

Why you are just choosing ibn hajar?

[@miladmiah]

Masha Allah

[@extremeTruth23]

*Imam Suyuti clearly said that the essence of celebrating Mawlid is Sunnah, by quoting a Hadees in which Prophet (saw) itself celebrated his birth by slaughtering an animal and distributing it., but the way in which people celebrating it is Bid'ah Hasana which have came in all fields like Mus'haf, Bukhari, Madrasas etc..* *Even Ibn Taymiyya was forced to say celebrating Mawlid is better in some of his work...!*

[@abdulkarimhagedorn1520]

He didn't though, he said that perhaps because people are celebrating it due to their love of the Messenger صلى الله عليه وسلم they may be rewarded because of THAT, not for the celebration in and of itself. و الله تعالى أعلم

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

​@ياسين-ب5ح You mean the relied upon opinion of Taymiyyi/Wahhabi/Salafi school 😂

[@MotorWorld-v8y]

@@BLACKPANTHER-m1hthe name wahabi came later after ibn tammiyas the name is from al wahab which is the name of Allah azwajal fear Allah

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@MotorWorld-v8y When we say Wahhabi, we mean followers of Ibn Abdil Wahhab; not followers of Al Wahhab. Allah knows my intentions so he won't count it as a disrespect.

[@qanciye969]

Masha allah

[@shawnmohammed7987]

This is what people of bidah do, they go all around in circles.

[@kredziigaming981]

read what imams wrote not what mr wahab wrote Mr Muqalid Of wahab 😂 u cant bear it even ur imam ibn tammiyah wrote a whole chapter on Kashaf o Ilham And approved it yet u call him anti sufi 😂 Hypocrites !

[@AbdulRehman-j6q9h]

These people are only interested in celebrating happy birthday graveworship they will not understand Qur'an and sunnah arguing with them is waste of time.

[@Kl45458vfw]

Seems you are more knowledgeable and logical than Sheikh ul Islam imam hajar al asqalani r.a. is it? Really? 😂 For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.

[@lukashradecky5492]

​@@AbdulRehman-j6q9h Accussing a Muslim of shirk without apparent evidence is fisq, fear Allah

[@muhammadsamiullah6962]

Mashaallah subhanallah alhamdulillah

[@AlphaMaverick1111]

ﷺ

[@BCfortheWin]

Nobody says ibn Hajar is a mubtadi, but he is wrong on this mawlid issue

[@GharibBFulan]

I hadn't realized that ibn Hajar رحمه الله رحمة واسعة was incapable of error. Start the presses. Spread the word. Ibn hajar was معصوم and has become an evidence in Islam. Its a miracle that the muslims and scholars prior to him were able to function. Forget { فَإِن تَنَـٰزَعۡتُمۡ فِی شَیۡءࣲ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَٱلرَّسُولِ إِن كُنتُمۡ تُؤۡمِنُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلۡیَوۡمِ ٱلۡـَٔاخِرِۚ ذَ ٰ⁠لِكَ خَیۡرࣱ وَأَحۡسَنُ تَأۡوِیلًا } [Surah An-Nisāʾ: 59]

[@khairt1731]

Yet you act like your spiritual guide and Master Ibn Wahab is infallible. Same with Shaykh Baz. You wahabis didnt find 1 "mistake" in their speech yet. Amazing isnt it? Nah, its just your gang mentality

[@TheMercifulAndJust]

He is for sure an authority to correctly judge whether a matter is within Shariah legal or goes against it. Your rude exaggeration to justify this Martin Lutheran Protestantic rampage on Islam the Shariah and how new matters are judged which is in accordance with UsulelFiqh and Muslims through the hands and works of Mohammed bin AbdilWahhab and the House of Saud and the Ikhwani and Qutbi

[@TheMercifulAndJust]

فردوه إلى الله والرسول ... Did those Sahabas qualified or unqualified as in authorized bs nonauthorized to issue religious public opinion fight Ubayy bin Kaab , Umar and our Master AbuBakr for coming to the conclusion after being persuaded by Sayidna Umar to implement innovating the collection of the Quran after running it back to Allah and The Messenger to come back empty handed from them on this matter decided by The Khalifa AbuBakr رضي الله عنهم?? How about educating yourself on how new matters are judged in Islam and the Shariah Law and way of legislation ?!

[@TheMercifulAndJust]

He was not the only authority figure to come to this conclusion ! He is one of thousands Authorized Authentic Scholars from all the 4 mathhabs that see this celebrating not just not a bid3a rather a hasana and great means to come closer or grow higher in spiritual growth

[@Kl45458vfw]

Seems you are more knowledgeable and logical than Sheikh ul Islam imam hajar al asqalani r.a. is it? Really? read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.

[@SwizzyConsequence]

Ok i always had doubt about this brother, now im certain to stop following him, Mawlids are biddah, its clear cut... Mawlid comes 400 years after the prophet s.a.w, in egypt practiced by sufis and shias, the birthday of jesus and its confusion is evidence enough this is from shaytaan, the prophet andhis companions didnt do it, what makes us better then them to celebrate mawlid? Alghamdulilah allah has made it clear to me that doubtfull matters i should stay away from but with mawlid inhave no doubt its misguidance, this brother didnt even give the prophets s.a.w tKe on innovation, hashtaged unfollow this fool

[@mijanurrahman5640]

I know you're confused, but this is how the topic of the mawlid stands. The scholars of Ahlus Sunnah with reference to the Quran and Sunnah have 2 main views on this matter, which are either it's permissible or it's not. Both views are classed as reliable, and are classed as issued regarding fiqh...rather than aqeedah. Therefore it is not a major issue to dispute amongst, and either side should respect each other, and should not cast each side out of Ahlus Sunnah. There are way too many scholars of the Ahlus Sunnah whom your respected imams follow that permit the mawlid based on Quran and Sunnah. You have to ask, if they were misguided.. How is it that that the great scholars of Islam that we all respect got everything right in thr Islamic sciences, and failed together in this regard?

[@SwizzyConsequence]

@@mijanurrahman5640 what did our nabi s.a.w do on his birthday?

[@SwizzyConsequence]

@@mijanurrahman5640 every innovation is a misguidance and misguidance leads to hell fire, muslims have 2 eids to celebrate..... Mawlids in many parts of the world have woman and men dancing side by side, you need to strip away culture and deen, anyway its all good if you want to practice it go ahead, allah knows best

[@mijanurrahman5640]

@SwizzyConsequence whose interpretation of that hadith are you following? Like I said..the Mujtahidoon differ in the interpretation of the hadith, it's classification of Bidah, and the fiqh ruling that come from this. These difference are not from anybody, but your respected scholars. So before you cast people as ahlul bidah, you need to figure out why so many of the scholars your teachers respect (or from from the teachers who gave you this viewpoint) are all misguided? Imam Ibn Rajab al Hanbali Imam as Subki Imam Al Qastallani Imam Al Hathaymi Imam as Sakhawi Imam Hajar Al Asqalani Imam Abu Shama (Al Nawawi's teacher) Imam as Suyuti These were amongst the scholars who ensured that the understanding of the Quran and Sunnah according to the 3 first generations were preserved and passed onto now the 21st century. Everytime you open a commentary on Sahih Bukhair, you're likely reading from that of Imam Hajar Al Asqalani. Don't just blindly follow your teachers. The list of scholars I've given you have a stamp of approval from the entire ummah without any controversy. The question you should put is, if the viewpoint is misguided, how is it they all made this mistake? Secondly, the permissibility of the mawlid is the majority opinion of the ahlus sunnah. Worldwide every muslim country (except saudi and maybe 1 or 2 more Salafi state countries) all follow the Mawlid according to the fatwas of their countries biggest imams. Therefore you need to be calculated and understand whether celebrating it casts them outside the Ahlus sunnah or not...else you're saying the majority of the Ummah are people of innovation. Therefore it's okay to think it's bidah and take your viewpoint, but do not cast them outside the Ahlus Sunnah. It is a "fiqh" difference, and it is okay to tolerate this according to the scholars. The scholars of the past differed on this but understood that this was not enough to divide. Division should only be done with those that differ in AQEEDAH, such as the views of the Shia or Ahmedeeyah etc. The Mawlid is not an aqeedah issue, but an issue of fiqh, and so differences (so long as they are within the paradigm of the scholars of Ahlus Sunnah) are acceptable, and both sides may follow. Both sides have their evidences from Quran and Sunnah. Just because the Prophet SAW didn't do something doesn't make it Bidah. The Sahabi's added to the prayer, and the Prophet SAW praised them. Ashura was a celebration that was initially done by the Jews, and the Prophet asked about it and saw what they were doing and then told us to similarly fast as well. Are we now imitating the Jews? So the Mawlid started with the Shia? Did fasting on Ashura start with the Jews? And by origin is it Jewish? Then? Therefore there are 2 views of Bidah. One school that doesn't not permit good bidah, and another school that permits good bidah, so long as it doesn't contradict the Quran and Sunnah. There are so many things that are done today but weren't don't at the time of the Prophet SAW which your teachers do: 1. THE FORMING OF A CONGREGATION TO PERFORM TAHAJJUD SALAAH BEHIND AN IMAAM. 2. THE RECITATION OF DU’A AFTER THE QURAN HAS BEEN COMPLETED AT THE END OF RAMADAAN IN TARAWEEH PRAYER. 3. THE GATHERING OF PEOPLE ON THE 27TH OF RAMADAAN AT TAHAJJUD WHERE THE IMAAM DELIVERS A SERMON. 4. THE CALL OF THE MUEZZIN BY SAYING “SALAATUL QIYAAM ATHABAKUMULLAH.” 1. THE ISSUE OF COMPILING THE QUR’AN IN ONE BOOK 2. PROPHET IBRAHIM’S STATION (FOOTPRINT). Changed by Umar RA. 3. INTEODUCTION OF SECOND AZAAN AT JUMMAH PRAYER. Introduced by Uthmaan RA during his rule. 4. SENDING PRAISE AND SALAAMS UPON THE PROPHET (SALLAL LAAHU ALAIHI WASALLAM). Started with Ali RA 5. THE ADDITION MADE BY IBN MASOUD TO TASHA’HUD. Addition made by Sahabi Ibn Masood. 6. THE INTRODUCTION OF READING “BISMILLAH AL-RAHMAN AL-RAHIM” BEFORE COMMENCING TASHA’HUD. Bukhari and Muslim both narrated that Ibn Umar use to read “Bimillah Al-Rahman Al-Rahim” before Tasha’hud. Imam Ibn Kathir has actually said in the same book “Al-Bi’dayah” Vol.13, p. 136: “Sultan Muzaffar used to arrange the celebration of the Meelad Shareef with honour, glory, dignity and grandeur. In this connection he used to organise a magnificent festival”. Then he said in praise of that man: “He was a pure-hearted, brave and wise Aalim (Scholar) and a just ruler, may Allah shower His Mercy upon him and grant him an exalted status.” Imam Shafi’i (radi Allahu anhu) said: “Anything which enjoys the backing of Shari’ah cannot be an innovation even if the Companions did not practice it, because their abstention from doing something may have been due to a particular reason which was there at that time, or they have left it to something which happens to be better, or perhaps news about a particular them did not reach them all”.

[@SwizzyConsequence]

@@mijanurrahman5640 did our prophet s.a.w celebrate his birthday??

[@taqikabeer2773]

The fact that we have hadees of fasting on Mondays automatically nullifies any sort of celebration. Eids and fasting can never be on the same day, think about it

[@huzefaxqureshi]

Do you know the way to celebrate Ashura is by fasting ?

[@j2shoes288]

Not really a strong argument, since one is general, and the other ruling is specific, like fasting on a Friday, unless specific

[@taqikabeer2773]

@@huzefaxqureshi lol The way milad is termed as Eid, and it is called Jashn, Ashura is in no way similar to Milad. And why not fast each Monday , thereby "celebrating" Eid 52 days a year and not limited to just one day.

[@taqikabeer2773]

@@j2shoes288 what ruling? Fasting on Mondays is established. Leave alone any ruling, Milad date is not even agreed upon, yet y'all get over enthusiastic on an unapproved, unauthorized, unauthentic way of commemorating this day.

[@AereForst]

Greetings, brothers. So he literally said it was an innovation not practiced by Companions ‏رضي الله عنهم and the Righteous earliest generations رضوان الله عليهم. Isn’t that enough to avoid it? Did the Companions ‏‏رضي الله عنهم and those earliest two generations that followed not love the Messenger ﷺ? So whether Ibn Hajar thinks there’s possibly some good in it does it matter, since he does not reach the level of the aforementioned of higher rank? And please don’t reflexively throw the “Salafi” or “Wahhab” label at me, because that’s exactly what I’m seeing in the comments section.

[@szlyar]

End of question/debate here.

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@AereForst The Companions also didn't have marked Salah rows? So why do you put such carpets in your mosques?

[@AereForst]

@@BLACKPANTHER-m1h If you can’t see the difference between the matter and the example you gave, you need to study modal logic, logical fallacies and epistemic hierarchy. Can’t educate you here, brother. Next you’ll ask about cars, air conditioners and a plethora of other logical red herrings. Peace.

[@BLACKPANTHER-m1h]

@@AereForst There isn't really a fallacy here. The Companions never had marked rows because the idea may have never come to them. Same goes for Milad unNABI SAW, we celebrate ot by thanking Allah for his greatest blessing to mankind by doing good deeds; but this idea never came to the companions. If you claim that the companions didn't have marked rows because they didn't need them but we do; I respond by saying that that the companions didn't need to celebrate mawlid because they were doing these good deeds (like reciting naats) all the time but we do need to have such a specific day so that even the lazier brothers among us can participate in such activities.

[@trillionpacks3815]

He clearly said that it wasn’t celebrated by the Sahaba or the first 3 generations of the salaf. Based on what Ibn Hajar said, the Mawlid celebrations which people do nowadays is Biddah according to Ibn Hajar.

[@Awliyah786]

Again you and twisted things and teachings that’s not what they said watch the video again

[@Raheem.rasool]

Book name and page ??

[@syedasadullah7462]

Hawi lil fatawi of Imam suyuti r.a

[@syedasadullah7462]

Al Husan ul maqsid Fi amalil mawlid of Imam suyuti r.a

[@AbdulRehman-j6q9h]

So we can also celebrate Christmas because isa alai salaam is also a messenger of allah.

[@bozchowdhury6286]

No, because Christmas is a made up date, we don't know the exact date. Also we don't celebrate the same way Christian do

[@AbdulRehman-j6q9h]

@@bozchowdhury6286 same way Nabi alai salam birth date also 2 dates.

[@imraanedwin3252]

But Nabi Isa a'layhi salaam was not born on christmas...so we can't celebrate it...

[@AbdulRehman-j6q9h]

@@imraanedwin3252 yes isa alai salaam was not born on Christmas day. Allah sent 124000 nabi alai salaam to this world if we know the date of birth of all the nabi according to you we can celebrate all of their birthdays. There will be birthday celebrations every day.one thing you have to learn in Islam our prophet Muhammad (pbuh) taught us every thing example how to sleep how to eat how to pass urine.......he has not left anything everything is mentioned in the hadees. Can you show the hadees.where he has taught us to celebrate his birthday. You will not find any sahaba or 4 imams abu hanifa shafi Malik or Ahmed bin hambal celebrating the birthday of our prophet. It's the people of bidhath started all these circus.if you want guidence follow Qur'an hadees and follow the four great imams.

[@eerievon2208]

@@AbdulRehman-j6q9hwe r not the ummah of isa a.s… why on earth shd we celebrate his birth date…. isa a.s himself will b the ummah of nabi muhammad s.a.w…. n remember.. among the nabis n rasuls… nabi muhammad s.a.w is the highest ranked among them.. n he is the only one that will give shafa’at to all during qiyamah…. we shd be glad to b born as the ummah of prophet muhammad s.a.w… i don’t celebrate maw lid as per say attending its celebration in masjids.. bt if happens it is celebrated there.. i don’t mind joining it.. as there’s zikr remembrance of Allah also.. there’s charity being done via giving out food n drinks.. n remember the angels will report to Allah whenever His servants attend a majlis of zikr n ilm… the angels will dua to Allah for ur forgiveness n Allah will answer the angels’ dua n grant it..

[@GarethBryant15]

I respect the Honesty & Holistic-Objectivity of This-Video. At the Same-Time though, as per what was presented: then by default it means that Muslims are more justified to celebrate Christmas, because Jesus-Christ (Peace be upon them) is a Muslim & a Nabī/Prophetic-Individual. But, I can humanly guarantee that it'll be a Hard-Sale to pontificate/promote Christmas amongst Muslims when ironically Christmas & Mawlid are literally the Same-Type/Kind of Holiday.

[@Mixedblood82]

Very good point. However Jesus birth date my Iggy be several months different to what it is claimed to be today. Secondly Muslims don't celebrate Christmas but many use it as an opportunity to talk about the life of Jesus during the holidays from an Islamic perspective. And this is fine. Problem is Muslims imitate the society by having Xmas trees, decor, lights and that's all stuff that should be avoided

[@SafinaSociety]

Christmas has an aspect which the Mawlid does not, namely it is a practice of another religion, which is the legal basis for not doing it.

[@SafinaSociety]

The better analogy would be a celebration commemorating the day he descended onto the earth to lead the umma of Muhammad ﷺ

[@GarethBryant15]

@@Mixedblood82 Ironically, what you've mentioned (as per Christmas) is precisely how Muslims celebrate Mawlid.

[@GarethBryant15]

@@SafinaSociety False...Proof: Fasting via the Day of `Ashūrah (the Day Allah rescued the Children-Of-Israel from the Armies-Of-Fir`awn/Pharaoh)... ...this is derived directly from Judaism. And, the Details of `Ashūrah mentioned directly via This-Video speak for themselves.

[@GhulamMustafa11111]

Muslims have already been taught how to celebrate the Mawlid by Rasul saw, i.e to fast on Mondays. Everyone accepts what is done today is a biddah, and every biddah into this deen of ours is a misguidance, and every misguidance is in Hell fire, as per the hadith.

[@hiddenguy9116]

Jahil people shouldn't speak without Ilm. Imam Shafi'i defined Bid'ah as: الْبِدْعَةُ بِدْعَتَانِ: بِدْعَةُ مَحْمُودَةٌ وَبِدْعَةُ مَذْمُومَةٍ، فَمَا وَافَقَ السُّنَّةَ فَهُوَ مَحْمُودٌ وَمَا خَالَفَ السُّنَّةَ فَهُوَ مَذْمُومٌ. Bid'ah is two bid'ahs: praiseworthy bid'ah and blameworthy bid'ah. Thus, whatever agrees with the Sunnah, it is praiseworthy and whatever conflicts with the Sunnah, it is blameworthy. (Ibn Hajar, Fath al-Bari, Vol. 4, p. 257)

[@Mixedblood82]

The talk explains this statement. 2.50 he states it's a bidda but then explains why it's ok. (At 2.50 he explains the hadith you've mentioned)

[@GhulamMustafa11111]

@@hiddenguy9116 Who gives you or anyone the right to make these bifurcations when the words of Rasul saw are clear. Please fear Allah akhi.

[@GhulamMustafa11111]

@@Mixedblood82 Please listen to the justification given. The fasts of gratitude were instructed and encouraged by Rasul saw himself, hence CANNOT be a bidah. It does not hold, I'm sorry.

[@bilbo23baggins]

Hey Ghulam, if you don't like it - get lost.